ML19303A296

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comments on NUREG-0813,DES for Facility.Section 5.9.4.2, Accident Experience & Observed Impacts Is Misleading
ML19303A296
Person / Time
Site: Callaway Ameren icon.png
Issue date: 11/24/1981
From: Sandler A
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
To:
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
References
RTR-NUREG-0813, RTR-NUREG-813 NUDOCS 8112020669
Download: ML19303A296 (2)


Text

.

Eh7 Col::bia riaca Y~,

u,,

l'ninrsity City, ".

ov..ga, 1og1

n.,

e d,N:

P0" d

',,o O.

3^

s

.v....,

u 4. 4..,

c.. w.4

..... e,

44-e.

v'

.g aa

.w,.c.

a.

v......-

(.

.. o......, e.. :e p.,.. c : C

4.,.,4..

y

,4..vo.., 3.e

m...:.

V.

1 s b 3>.a..a..-... D>a,,. e..,..

e t.-

~

.i...ci..a, 4,... e.. e., on, ev e ra.,..e.. e e.

4...s..e c.~.. e..v4. e.,

-o....

v.

.re., "..e "al'.a. -....' e ar

.'..e..+. (Do +..et 7e..e0-L3,2, "Li.' a - C,4.1,9 d

..s.

. e e.

,4 4.

.n _g e.,f..

..u.

w 4,,

....ec.

I... e.e.. e e4.,,.,.

av.... e.a.

,7

.e e c+.4 y

.m-

,.:...ce, n C..a........ r.Xp e.4. ~,
s..-"..= e.mte d.S.r =.C '... "

s..

i g

,...,,e

,;,Q,

. m e

.c. Q, _

C..,

.s

. '.2 ' e". e ".'..# s *..a* #.e *' *..*.C.*.'".* ' *@ f'# ~.~..' ' ir. *. ~*.* e #

..g

~.

-c.

....e....

n a... a..a s..., s..c..... C... e A

.e eye., e*

s.g.e e.' " ' ' '..#.e "a. "

C*.'

.y..s.

3' Ak

.~

s.

c

4. -

yeg. --c,,

.,ec.4c..:.;.L'

.4.,

4

..,..a a

....-. e q-s. ae 44.... - e..,4g.e

,. to p

n ccenr. '"hese clai-s, base'd en selected acc*.:de5ts in references 36 and 37, are s.......ae,.

..e e....

Ch e.*,,

..,47 oc

~..........

a,.

,.4 g.ta.ce,e

.ae.,o c.e.

p.I licensee Event RepErts., cr the *:1-veekly. Power Reacter Reperts h.ich are

...p.=

read.ily available in d.e x* cite:-r libraries shr,rs tk.at there have been "accidcts" u

.e.

a.e,

s...., oc.,...rre.

e.,

a+.,,e,e.,

y..

u

,.,a, o 4. e.,,.

.~

ein 'e :-e..In 193_0 alene,there trere.cre than 37% :.ncider.s, :.ary relbasing u

a

.ve,.

..e... t '..

d..'.w
  • .k..e s_..v '.-. e...+..

"...+.s. a.=

.. '.~.-Ja.= *.

c.'.' W.,.

,v* - ' a7 9 th*t "the exterie.ce base ~is not large energh to pe: :it a reliable cuantitative 7

.. q. 4.

e.egl 4.

e,

.,e en 4.e.e, %.,, -. en w.

aC.a

, a3.,

.. w

...e C.e 4 # u,...,

r,'a_a

  • 4..e
  • a

. *.. s... e?"'

p... s.,... e e

+..m w.Ve a.

4..a...

. a a,.

..s.

- e eCO >

,s,.,E...

n.,.

a,4

.. e...,4 a t.A., +., -w,.e e ' * ~ ' ' '..".d..., $

s. A.. E + e

. _. s.y f.

y 0 : ;

..y..

...4 4 4. e

4.,.

,e, E a 6..,.

.a.#.

  • w

".".*.e.#4 . '.'. $.'.

  • E.,.'.'*.-

e.

e 4..a.a e.

2.+

...s...,

a

  • e.

.. e. e

._. e.,. ' e. *,.

.,. 0

  • e, a....."?...:.

f.....

.2 a.,....a.,.

.. s..e

. A..s.. e..e.e...,.e.: e... a....

4

.. u. 5....

n m

...... '. e... a. '. *. *..* e d s...

.e s.... w a... : e..... e *.7 T.e. w 4.e

. a.C.,.e.k,.? e e,..'.', e e,-.

4.%..<.

e.,..c...,...

.a.*..,

s.

e.

e w

4 4.

4g.e # * " e. *.,

  • 'I o.

....y m.

~

...e *4oe.,ee g..

.#e e', '...* 1EY e..".,.*4e -

~ ~*e.

~..

s

-w

.'.c.. * '* e s *w*.*. e"...*. *.*.

d.'.

.4

.na4

. e..

e.e C 4

.c.

  • w a.g ?..

. ~.5 5"

(. -v.=> / C,t, m. -v ) 4 a..e.-

m '

r c......,

..+e.**.*.**.a*.*.#'.~"..*.,

3,,

f, c.

n'."..e,~<~s~.*

.'"e'... #.' *.'.'. *'.*..*2...,','.k.*..'"'a..

i

~

r

......_.9.

,....*..*e

      • '.*.s*.,e,.','.~.~*..*.*a.'3****~.~*.***"..r.'.".L3 ww C'..-*'. u.=.

'~*

3..a.., ;

2 4., 4.3 g e.g4 y m

.s, 6..+

+wg. 4.;..,

J 4,

4.w.e

.M.4.C. s... e..

.n.

7......y a

.ao.

,.4

. a..e.ge

4. n.

w

....a 7g. e...,.e...a.. w. g <.....,, +

y..-

.a 5.....

.e e_... -.4 0,

. %..g g w.A.V e ' *. *. *. 7. 0.**..* *. E

  • e ' * #

...,.. 44.g 9.a "a d..d.Cc*. s*,. *..* V 8

'.*..#d '

  • t *.'

-s*., e.,.'.' *.e

.....*.e.,

.r

.g..,.*.

.,.,e.a.,..

ms..

s...

2.e+,. ~, e / 4..

s..

- *:.., c., }..,. e,3e....e.-

t..

..a..r.

., e., p.,

e. 2.t e. s.

, C,. a..a... e OC...

eA.t.

s.

3 3

..a

. s.

on.

s.

a.. s.g g e

,.e e.e.. a. ta. 72s.a C. * *.'.'. s e ".# '.'.'.*..*e p.,.s.~r.e.

.c..

..,...2, a _.s. g., +.

e. p..g,,. e,.' a '.., ".. 's '

.c

.E*.*

        • F.".'.*..e'*.*.**.*.

.N...'.'*.*'.

  • *F.. e *..
  1. . 2

,...e.

.s 'y e..e.,g..

.1

.c s f.,..

e.,s

.c 4.4.. e '.'.*.. .ea.*.'.,**.*'-*#

. s,.

3

..g e.

e... s a.g.g..gA a 4

4

6. ".*'V*..* 1.*..

. a.. w 0* *

.4.

..e"..,.**.'**.*E.'".'e

.e

...e

z.. A.

4.

.+

,+4..

,e

.~. 44.

.v,. e.4.e.

J. e..rE ee.n e.e.w

.. a...

,,4...,..

., ~.l e i...d 2 +.

a

..v;

.5

e..e'..s e 4 J. 3 m.

. 2 4.. g.. e.........

e.,.c.,e 7,.,

9 a..

....a 9.C,.M.z,

p....

.e D e 4.e. w.

1 w

. e c...,,

s.u.. g ~.<. a.a, e., "4 '. '..a * *. s.* '.' O '..'.. t.e +4 Lc' -

,n..o e...

.a

=. _

.c......

~., n.....n n..a.

.u..e.~,.. -...

=..

e

-f.a.,,,-

..., -,- : ^

a. '..* e

..-*r..* '"**.d.e.*.*...<"'e..".,

e '. a re ' e. - =. e. u-.. '.e d.. * -

.v, s

, e.,3og. s.e.'.'xi

...e

,iw..,.

e.a.

e

.s.,..

. a

._.,,...,,.4,.

8112O2066E B11124'

~

PDR ADoch 0S0004g3 O

PDR

c-t,.

}4 Cn sce T-33, section ".9.L.2, 'recident Fxpe-ience and Ger'e: ted I cocts,"

.a

.m 4.. a. s.. +

.g(

...... e. _a a.a,.+

n.,

.o...

m,

.;e eu,. eg g..

,. 4 4, + 4..,. 2. 2..

e7

.e 6

  • a 4 f a

A.,o.,- e

.%. g,.

t..P A.s. e-

c. _.

.c3 e,{.r{.

A s

.w

,4

a4.a.,.,n.x.,.
..., c

.r

%..t.4

{p.,q.t 4 4wa't... c p o p.64.,a.

4.e,c.., e a 4. 4 o f +.s..e.. 4....er.

n

(..

iceert r.; te,the ILeegee Event 2eperts, *.here can ce no d enht ' hat ex or::n

1. ' '.ake.i :. lace.

.s.

~-

'. e.+..S *..*. P. i..d.4. '..,3

.3'.4- "/ C.

.'.$....'.d.'.~.g.", **.

"e. e 9.1 'C.~... *.'.* '.

d 4

.L.4

,,,,,e.s cer crA : enetic ch=.S.er :,ne.'utr te d velop. (.c. 3-37) v On pas;te 5-37, the pection esiled 'Healt'.-E'fects Avci.d.ance" suggests thr.t

......e..e.,

.e y: ' d'.'.cp d. '.~,. e'i e. e ac a.d d.e..~..,s

. d. can b,e.-ved d '_ by. s e.'. ' *." >

+%..,.,.. e.,4, c..+ g a, + ga,. y 6.

p,

. rag.

...r.

A 3s.*g,

.y.4.a.ga s.

4..s.e.s.7.g.*,

+%..g

,g7 pe.,

...,y f

e n..,.,.

J.

44...,

t.,.* *,.C,..rre A 4

.-.a

.s....

,w e..e A,,.k.c.

. eve e. c a.e..,

a'.h.J 3

4. 4 a 4.c,. S -

4

~.. e.,

,1. 4 n.. 4.

.e.n.... CL..,4 ne e.4..n.i.c S.

Sc e ac a a.e..,,!1,..,..,e.,.,.s. 4,.

c.

..u v....

.. e eV'..*e,. m-- * ". *, be ea.e*

a. 0.==e *.*. e d.

a' '.,

.C.'.".".,.

i, a..

c r. ".e.v..'.', '. 'Tu, a. =.'. e.". e

..c

,,,,..c.

A.k.e

--.a%.#.~.. p**.-*."S.ee.'a..'.'e'.'.*..".'.'..*.'.'a's.*

y

. a.' *^ '*

........ e 3.r. >

na'.,

r,, c..

c.

e.3 e as e.ye ' ' e......e S'e..e *.2." e.,.

l'.,****>*

7m w

o 4, c. 4....... w u,..,.,

4

.fs Zi tr ar the rer lt "cf. c ecidenT, at 'Os19d.rs he~ easv rculd.he d'aved d

,s.

e.s c.c.). g

.b.e. g i. s..

ance

i... a,. n 4.*g..,

=,,

a e t.,e,..Jagc,

s.,L.

. s.

L.

,4 4 e

,4.,.,. c.e e,,.+.,Aa g t

c+

...g

.t.y 4.*

a,a r*

m.

e...

9 w..

e

/

t '..

.o.n

.a s-----

.i Arle:b Emnd',er

.2 s.

r=

5'"-

o

- - * - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~-

~ ~ ~ '~

.