ML19291C442
| ML19291C442 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Seabrook  |
| Issue date: | 10/18/2019 |
| From: | C-10 Research & Education Foundation, Harmon, Curran, Harmon, Curran, Spielberg & Eisenberg, LLP, NRC/OGC, NextEra Energy Seabrook |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| SECY RAS | |
| References | |
| 50-443-LA-2, ASLBP 17-953-02-LA-BD01, RAS 55373 | |
| Download: ML19291C442 (41) | |
Text
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 217 19 docketed as, by docketed by Judge Spritzer 218 4 would to thank would like to thank Judge Spritzer 220 15 Information Education Curran 220 24 Byrce Bryce Wachutka 220 25 Phillip Philip Wachutka 229 3 ERA-005-R3 NER-005-R3 Lighty 232 8 Glen Glenn Bessette 236 20 notes, The notes, the Curran 240 2 control controlled Lighty 241 1 is complete is a complete Lighty 242 16 relative relevant Lighty 243 12 engineers, the engineers, and the Lighty 243 23 meeting meetings Lighty 246 2 power reactor Lighty 247 25 two-scale to-scale Lighty 252 20 specimens program Wachutka 255 16 a license amendment the license amendment Wachutka 256 10 along, alone, Wachutka 262 17 in country in this country Judge Mtingwa 263 7 research on research projects on Saouma 264 8 help them through help them solve Saouma 264 11 So I have I have Saouma 264 18 not a PE and not a PE, but Saouma 264 18 student to pass students to pass Saouma 266 3 Its expertise I dont claim expertise Saouma 267 17 to what extent to they have to what extent do they have Judge Mtingwa 268 13 MS. BUFORD: JUDGE MTINGWA:
268 17 structural integrity associates Structural Integrity Associates Simons 276 8 wouldnt call it wouldnt call Saouma 276 14 ensure a ensure Saouma 276 15 characteristic characteristics Saouma 276 17 query quarry Saouma 276 21 that, when you that, you Saouma 276 22 represent represent: Saouma 276 25 So this axial This axial Saouma Page 1 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 277 3 concern concerns Saouma 279 4 observed with informs but concrete observed which informs what concrete Bayrak 280 18 no true no through- Bayrak 281 11 ACI 318-7 ACI 318-71 Bayrak 283 6 not only conservative side not only on the conservative side Bayrak 283 15 There is There are Saouma 283 22 shear crack shear cracks Saouma 284 3 crack. cracks. Saouma 284 10 the so-called a so-called Saouma 284 15 almost every almost everything Judge Trikouros 286 8 comes as a clause comes as cause Saouma 286 9 T-bar rebar Saouma 286 12 AAR ASR Saouma 286 15 is a lot are a lot Saouma 286 15 of members members Saouma 286 16 with enforced with reinforced Saouma 286 17 adequate reasonable adequate or reasonable Saouma 286 17 good adequate good, adequate Saouma 287 13 aggregate of aggregate or Saouma 287 16 of course, also of course, Saouma 287 22 chemical. chemicals. Saouma 290 16 in the core solution in the pore solution Bayrak 292 2 identified along identified in Saouma 292 4 However, a nuclear However, in a nuclear Saouma 292 20 strengths. strength. Saouma 293 1 analysis, and a analysis, in a Saouma 293 1 used as used in Saouma 293 10 type types Saouma 293 10 type of concrete types of concrete Saouma 294 3 pretension concrete beams pretensioned concrete beams Bayrak 294 6 pretension concrete beams pretensioned concrete beams Bayrak 294 9 pretension concrete beams pretensioned concrete beams Bayrak 294 19 NextEra NextEra's Bayrak 294 20 colleagues and colleagues Bayrak 294 23 there is there are Saouma Page 2 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 294 23 unintentioned unintended Saouma 295 4 two through Bayrak 296 16 REI RAI Carley 297 4 0.00207 0.207 Bayrak 300 25 get gets Saouma 301 10 from beginning from the beginning Saouma 302 1 temperature temperature and Saouma 302 7 is true factor is a true factor Saouma 303 5 A The Bell 304 6 the code's (delete these words) Bell 306 16 ACI code. the ACI code. Saouma 306 17 ACI 1971 code -- 40 years ago the ACI 1971 code -- 40 years old Saouma 307 11 still model still models Saouma 307 12 all direction, all directions, Saouma 308 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 310 8 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 310 10 Yeah. Yes. Saouma 310 12 Design code Design codes Saouma 310 13 Design code, Design codes, Saouma 310 15 design code, design codes, Saouma 310 19 there are hired Saouma 310 25 solution solutions Saouma 311 15 hand of hands of Saouma 312 4 in is Bayrak 313 15 matters metrics Saouma 313 18 analogies analysis Saouma 313 19 ASR then ASR, then Saouma 314 9 parentheses parenthesis Saouma 314 13 assumption assumptions Saouma 314 17 conducted that conducted - that Saouma 314 20 quantify insecure in quantify and secure Saouma 315 2 property properties Saouma 315 8 Lego Legos Saouma 315 11 with a so-called with so-called Saouma 315 12 property properties Saouma Page 3 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 315 15 strengths strength Saouma 315 16 increasing evidence increasing the evidence Saouma 315 17 so compressive that compressive Saouma 315 18 strengths strength Saouma 315 19 perform perform an Saouma 316 4 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 316 13 hey , try they tried Bolourchi 317 16 perform performed Saouma 317 18 So and I So I Saouma 318 20 were are Carley 319 24 guides guidelines Simons 320 11 primarily primary Simons 320 13 due to or compared due to ASR for comparison Simons 321 25 MPR 40-153 MPR 4153 Judge Trikouros 323 20 NPR MPR Bayrak 324 18 ISC ISE Bayrak 325 3 We are to We have to Saouma 325 6 structure. structures. Saouma 325 9 structure. structures. Saouma 325 22 We are to We have to Saouma 326 16 are not quotes at all are not codes at all Bayrak 326 24 ISC ISE Bayrak 328 18 ones once Saouma 328 22 sabbatic sabbatical Saouma 329 4 reaches of concern. reaches concern. Saouma 329 5 Empa EMPA Saouma 329 15 MS. SHERMAN: MR. SHERMAN:
329 19 materials' materials Sherman 329 24 documents document Sherman 330 21 Everything from For example Sherman 332 18 MS. SHERMAN: MR. SHERMAN:
332 22 sensing sensitive Sherman 333 4 one on Sherman 335 3 and details and details an Saouma 336 15 justification that that could continue to be used. justification that it could continue to be used. Thomas Page 4 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 337 2 So, the next step licensing So, the next step licensee Thomas 337 4 it could continue to be developed. it could continue to be enveloped. Thomas 337 21 It is. These are applicable. It is not. These are not applicable. Saouma 337 25 Applicable Not applicable Saouma 338 24 lenient linear Saouma 339 4 there was this There was Saouma 340 6 fractural fracture Saouma 340 10 sheer shear Saouma 340 12 MSE NRC Saouma 343 10 remember his remember her Saouma 343 20 the shear strengths and its impact shear strengths and their impact Saouma 343 24 specimen. specimens. Saouma 344 2 strengths on strengths in Saouma 345 17 in closed enclosed Carley 346 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 346 18 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 346 21 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 346 24 true thickness through thickness Bolourchi 346 25 enforcement reinforcement Bolourchi 347 10 true thickness through thickness Bolourchi 347 21 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 347 24 three directions the third direction Bolourchi 348 24 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 349 1 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 349 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 349 20 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 349 23 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 349 25 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 350 2 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 351 1 affects the critical in the direction where theres effect is critical in the direction where theres Thomas 351 2 the strength to expansion. the restraint to expansion. Thomas 351 3 what kind of a strength exists in this structure. what kind of a restraint exists in this structure. Thomas 351 8 unisotropic anisotropic Saouma 351 19 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 351 21 biometrical parametrical Bolourchi Page 5 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 351 22 closure enclosure Bolourchi 351 22 under the other Bolourchi 351 23 wall walls Bolourchi 353 9 true through Bolourchi 354 2 we do some make we do make some Saouma 354 20 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 354 23 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 355 1 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 355 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 355 9 a, (delete these words) Bolourchi 355 9 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 355 10 it's talking (delete these words) Bolourchi 356 1 code quotes Bolourchi 356 7 formation deformation Bolourchi 356 12 using is using Bolourchi 357 3 formation deformation Saouma 357 16 pictures of pictures of a Saouma 357 17 retaining the wall retaining wall Saouma 357 20 was very was a very Saouma 357 25 part impact Saouma 358 1 Ive I Saouma 358 5 whether internal whether an internal Saouma 358 14 before testing, before testing Saouma 358 16 expansion was expansion - was Saouma 359 12 off of Bayrak 361 5 really major really a major Saouma 361 11 strengths strength Saouma 361 22 too to Saouma 362 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 362 8 shearest stiffness shear stiffness Bolourchi 362 13 shearest stiffness shear stiffness Bolourchi 362 19 whole, it total change Bolourchi 363 11 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 363 13 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 363 16 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI Page 6 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 363 24 that that that Bolourchi 365 14 admitted method Saouma 365 20 which existing ASR. with existing ASR, Saouma 365 21 And you want and you want Saouma 369 4 MR. BAYRAK DR. BAYRAK 369 7 MR. BAYRAK DR. BAYRAK 370 2 Popovic Orbovic Saouma 370 10 because of nonlinear due to the nonlinear Saouma 370 11 that than Saouma 373 13 universally universally, Saouma 373 15 as the kinetics at the kinetics Saouma 375 8 out of door outdoors Saouma 375 22 expansion because expansion (because Sherman 375 23 its idea is you the idea if you Sherman 375 24 look at see look and see Sherman 375 25 future. We future), we Sherman 376 1 had add Sherman 376 3 times, not times not, Sherman 376 4&5 Baruba (phonetic). Berube. Sherman 377 25 provided to it? provided to it. Sherman 381 9 all wall Carley 383 17 that was that it was Simons 385 5 cross-aggregate crush coarse aggregates Saouma 385 5 multiple tests for tests Saouma 386 1 applicable application Saouma 386 2 values test various tests Saouma 386 4 over time over the time Saouma 386 13 all the way all the way to Saouma 388 9 ISC ISE Sherman 389 3 of agree of us agree Sherman 389 13 ISC ISE Sherman 390 22 curve? curve. Sherman 391 21 through-all through-wall Collins 392 17 So method The method Saouma 392 19 relate - so relate the Saouma Page 7 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 392 20 that is degradation of elastic models that is, degradation of elastic modulus, Saouma 393 2 implemented discussed Saouma 393 3 resection introduction Saouma 393 10 perform. perform it. Saouma 394 2 nearly, not all nearly if not Saouma 394 13 two reactants. One two reactants, one Saouma 394 15 build, then it build, build. Then it builds, Saouma 394 19 by quote. by all. Saouma 396 20 3493R in ACI 349.3R Carley 397 1 three-wall through-wall Carley 400 11 today ASR. todays standards. Saouma 400 13 qualifier quantification Saouma 400 17 So slow Slow Saouma 404 4 concrete when concrete Saouma 404 6 come. were mixed. Saouma 404 11 interesting one, an interesting one, Saouma 404 13 location, a certain location, location here, a certain location there, Saouma 404 14 a certain location, how Saouma 404 21 hid had Saouma 406 6 bar box Sherman 408 16 has qualitative has a qualitative Saouma 409 9 structure. structures. Saouma 410 2 cut specimen cast a specimen Saouma 410 3 was inhibit was an inhibitor Saouma 410 7 specimen, specimens, Saouma 410 9 0.5 percent special 0.5 percent Saouma 415 20 two or three Tier Three Simons 418 22 There has There have Saouma 419 7 out of plane, out-of-plane, Saouma 419 23 out of plane out-of-plane Saouma 423 20 pour solution pore solution Bayrak 425 6 So cracking So the cracking Saouma 426 3 smaller crack. smaller cracks. Saouma 426 3 surface appear Saouma 426 4 It might They might Saouma Page 8 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 426 12 far as far as to say Saouma 427 14 probability laboratory Saouma 427 16 we had to we have to Saouma 428 18 quota code Bayrak 428 19 quota code Bayrak 431 9 directly to directly related to Saouma 434 11 AK11-EI (phonetic) Equivalent "EI" Bayrak 435 24 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 436 4 make need Bolourchi 436 6 expressed stress Bolourchi 436 14 defined refined Bolourchi 436 19 full 99 analysis full nonlinear analysis Bolourchi 437 10 for the dam dam Saouma 437 17 1TE Gentilly Saouma 437 18 (phonetic) [delete] Saouma 437 19 , the F, the Seminoe Saouma 437 25 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI Lets not mention what the Bureau of Reclamation Lets mention that the Bureau of Reclamation did 437 12-13 Saouma in terms of linear perform nonlinear analysis also for ASR 438 2 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 438 5 1TE (phonetic) Gentilly Saouma 438 15 lining leaking Bolourchi 439 9 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 439 14 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 439 18 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 440 10 Is it due It is due Saouma 440 11 theres degradation? there is a degradation. Saouma 440 25 everything flow everything flows Saouma 441 4 father of a lot of the fathers of the LRFD Saouma 442 7 alluded alluded to Saouma 442 17 SD&H SG&H Simons 443 23 a genesis the genesis Saouma 443 25 competing opinion, competing opinions, Saouma 443 25 There was There were Saouma 444 12 This is again, some general consideration. These are again, some general considerations. Saouma Page 9 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 447 14 implication. implications. Saouma 447 20-21 NRCs safety values. NRCs safety evaluation values. Thomas 448 7 So The Saouma 450 10 in certain in a certain Saouma 451 7 there is papers there are papers Saouma 453 14 referred to my referred to his Curran 454 18 Empa EMPA Saouma 457 16 ignoring ignore Saouma 460 24 on sides inside Saouma 467 4 CC CI Simons 468 12 53 5-3 Simons 468 18 imbedded embedded Simons 469 14 artificial actual Simons 473 20 loop loupe Bagley 475 22 -- term Saouma 475 23 to mention previously mentioned Saouma 476 5 on site onsite -- Saouma 476 6 the data, the data -- Saouma 476 18 but just and Saouma 476 20 likelihood; not stronger, likelihood -- not stronger -- Saouma 476 25 MR. SIMON MR. SIMONS 478 10 MR. SIMON MR. SIMONS 478 16 MR. SIMON MR. SIMONS 478 25 MR. SIMON MR. SIMONS 479 13 MR. SIMON MR. SIMONS 481 3 which is which shows the Saouma 483 7 Institutional Institution of Bayrak 484 22 screen strain Bayrak 485 1 build bill Bayrak 489 1 time times Saouma 489 8 substantial substantially Saouma 489 10 cases where cases where the Saouma 489 12 By Stark classical paper where In Starks classical paper, Saouma 490 1 paper Stark paper, Stark Saouma 490 3 observation in observation for Saouma Page 10 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 490 5 again result again the result Saouma 490 17 dried drying Saouma 490 21 engineer. engineers. Saouma 490 23 where which are Saouma 491 16 no conducive not conducive Saouma 491 21 So average So the average Saouma 491 23 in other word, in other words, Saouma 491 23 me Seabrook, Saouma 492 2 crack cracks Saouma 492 9 direction. directions. Saouma 492 11 show showed Saouma 492 17 ASR want to expand. ASR want to expand ASR wants to expand ASR wants to expand Saouma 492 18 humidity which humidity - which Saouma 493 1 crack cracks Saouma 493 2 crack, and crack. And Saouma 493 7 called fracture called a fracture Saouma 493 10 it plastic it the plastic Saouma 493 11 it fracture it the fracture Saouma 493 14 test. tests. Saouma 493 20 There is There are Saouma 493 21 of Hillerborg by Hillerborg Saouma 493 23 exhibit. exhibits. Saouma 493 25 There is There are Saouma 493 8-9 cementitious nature of the material for concrete cementitious nature of the concrete Saouma 494 1 ASR crack ASR cracks Saouma 494 4 Surface The surface Saouma 494 21 there is much there is a much Saouma 494 22 petrographic, petrographic examination, Saouma 494 25 pattern; pattern -- Saouma 495 1 map cracking, map cracking -- Saouma 495 2 reinforcement the crack aligns reinforcement, the cracks align Saouma 495 4 dispute; you dispute; as you Saouma 495 5 universally accepted it is universally accepted Saouma 495 7 coming next, under comes next, and under Saouma 495 12 written was was written Saouma Page 11 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 495 14 Swiss report the Swiss report Saouma 495 16 technician technicians Saouma 499 1 weren't were Sherman 501 13 managements, measurements Carley 502 23 shear strength, BWD shear strength, (bw)(d) Bayrak 504 2 is document describing in the document describes an Saouma 504 5 mentioned mentioned: Saouma 505 11 FHWA. FHWA report. Saouma 505 20 reach reached Saouma 505 21 expansion rate. expansion. Saouma 506 16 Through the wall, Through-wall, Saouma 506 18 through the wall through-wall Saouma 507 9 opinion accurately opinion, accurately Saouma 508 12 high-level crack on the surface high-level crack that surfaced Saouma 511 8 installed all installed, all Saouma 511 9 It doesnt It does Saouma 511 12 putting an putting in an Saouma 511 13 as bad as as bad as a Saouma 512 3 advance advances Saouma 512 7 petrographer petrographers Saouma 512 10 shows show Saouma 512 12 make estimate make an estimate Saouma 512 15 track, so cracks, Saouma 512 20 petrographer petrographers Saouma 512 21 weight. weights. Saouma 513 13 install installing Saouma 514 10 called called the Saouma 514 12 have has Saouma 514 13 calibration calibrations Saouma 514 15 elastic modulus the elastic modulus Saouma 518 11 CCI and MCI. CCI and CI. Buford 521 1 need to need the Bagley 521 11 were miss were to miss Bagley 522 8 margin margins Saouma 522 8 needs need Saouma Page 12 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 522 10 normalize normalized Saouma 522 12 showing using Saouma 522 14 resulting results Saouma 522 15 and to and -- to Saouma 522 16 extent possible extent possible -- Saouma 524 6 production reduction Bagley 525 5 the element the finite element Saouma 525 9 code mode Saouma 525 10 apply uniformly apply it uniformly Saouma 526 15 law wall Carley 526 21 final finite Saouma 526 22 analogies analysis Saouma 527 4 final finite Saouma 527 5 analogies analysis Saouma 527 14 understanding understanding, Saouma 527 18 readings they readings do they Saouma 527 19 water transition code. transition zones. Saouma 531 2 crackage cracking Saouma 531 7 is the the Saouma 531 9 provocation propagation Saouma 531 22 insulation installation Judge Trikouros 532 6 midplane cracking Carley 534 13 crack fold. crack. Saouma 534 2-3 flow rate distributor through-wall distribution Saouma 535 1 occurs so far because occurs because Saouma 535 9 and too or two Saouma 536 16 modules modulus Bagley 537 2 well it well, it Saouma 538 24 cycling, cyclic Saouma 539 7 F prime C f prime C Saouma 539 9 error bars error bar Saouma 539 11 competence confidence Saouma 539 18 is date which has are data which have Saouma 539 24 field field, Saouma 540 6 values, which values which Saouma Page 13 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 540 7 account, account Saouma 540 9 so model no model Saouma 540 13 without error without an error Saouma 550 23 query. quarry. Saouma 550 25 query. And quarry. And the Saouma 551 1 -- quarry -- Saouma 551 7 container containment Carley 551 8 containment. and containment. Carley 554 4 arranged on the range of Saouma 556 16 demic (phonetic) DEMEC Saouma 556 17 direct. direct measurement. Saouma 556 19 on the - models of the modulus Saouma 557 13 explain explains Saouma 557 14 German side German, Saouma 558 17 MR. BOLOURCHI MR. BAGLEY 559 16 at specific at the specific Saouma 559 20 much as the location as are indicated much of the location as indicated Saouma 561 14 direction that is directions, that is the Saouma 561 15 direction. directions. Saouma 561 19 into in Saouma 562 1 And has And it has Saouma 562 9 as saying by saying Saouma 562 11 depths. depth. Saouma 562 7-8 Walt (phonetic) Wald Saouma 563 4 and how and in how Saouma 563 9 irrespective, and at irrespective of Saouma 563 15 form shape deformed shape Saouma 566 3 alkali-reaching alkali leaching Bayrak 567 16 extending to. extending to the surface. Bayrak 569 16 analogies, we use highly deformed shape. analysis, we use highly deformed shapes Saouma 569 19 measurement measurements Saouma 570 25 fractured energy fracture energy Saouma 571 8 on the naked with the naked Saouma 571 11 There is a There are a Saouma 571 13 well well, Saouma Page 14 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 571 16 crack because a crack -- is crack, because a crack is Saouma 571 19 not -- not Saouma 572 21 perditious pernicious Saouma 573 3 indication because indication - because Saouma 573 15 3493R. 349.3R. Carley 574 3 requires to requires us to Saouma 574 7 mind minds Saouma 574 8 program problem Saouma 574 9 and doing best doing our best Saouma 574 2-3 extra identity extraordinarily complex Saouma 575 4 judgement judgment Judge Trikouros 575 15 ASI ACI Buford 577 18 or not all the codes and other codes do not Bell 578 15 0.75, 1.4D.L. 0.75(1.4D+1.7L) Bell 578 18 to like Bell 579 24 adjust material adjust the material Saouma 580 2 not all, not all -- Saouma 580 3 but many but many -- Saouma 580 4 318.71 were written 318.71 Code was written Saouma 580 5 element were in its element analysis were in their Saouma 580 7 later version a later version Saouma 580 21 approximate equation or the approximate equation Saouma 580 22 code is code - is Saouma the 1.9 or 2.0 terms in the equation that gives the 580 23 1.9 or 2.0 equation, we give as the shear Saouma shear 583 25 properly properly, Saouma 584 1 discussed it discussed Saouma 584 7 structures, which structures which Saouma 584 16 there have there has Saouma 584 19 stress stresses Saouma 586 15 have linear have a linear Saouma 586 16 linear, linear response, Saouma 586 17 displacement. displacements. Saouma 586 18 displacement plays displacements play Saouma 588 6 strengths. strength. Saouma Page 15 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 588 6 surface ability serviceability Saouma 588 11 exceed demand exceeds demand Saouma 589 23 next or NextEra Judge Spritzer 592 15 staff at Staff and Judge Spritzer 594 21 complete concrete Saouma 595 1 on this angle through this angle Saouma 595 20 that the lack of of the lack of Saouma 595 23 match, matches, Saouma 595 24 which is in in Saouma 596 4 reflection rejection Saouma 596 10 F prime C f prime C Saouma 597 9 MR. BAYRAK: DR. BAYRAK:
597 17 pace paste Bayrak 598 17 by standard 40 by the standards of Saouma 598 17 higher that higher than Saouma 599 16 ACI318, 71 ACI 318-71 Bayrak 599 23 RIs our eyes Bayrak 600 10 the tests are the tests have Saouma 600 11 F primes of C f primes of C Saouma 600 18 because the lack of accounting because of the lack of accounting, Saouma 601 6 me man Bayrak 601 15 hydroxide has on hydroxide on Saouma 601 15 which extent the the extent of Saouma 601 17 Its accelerated Its an accelerated Saouma 601 19 Whether there has Whether there have Saouma 603 21 Yes, cracking Yes, the cracking Saouma 604 5 cracking is at cracking are at Saouma 604 6 route root Saouma 604 20 there is there is a Saouma 605 7 accelerated tests. accelerated the tests. Saouma 605 9 the same come the same came Saouma 605 10 the source as aggregate the same source as the aggregate Saouma 605 16 sand - or by the prime aggregate. sand. Saouma 606 17 damaging casting Saouma 606 22 entire being entire building Saouma Page 16 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 606 25 Salt River Crystal River Saouma 607 2 goes in delamination caused delamination Saouma 607 12 analysis were analysis where Saouma 607 14 Thats dangerous Its dangerous Saouma 607 17 there is there is a Saouma 607 18 Thats a call for That causes a Saouma 608 23 not referring the not referring to the Saouma 610 8 posted posited Bayrak 610 12 palier failure Bayrak 612 23 happened happens Saouma 613 11 It is a shear It is the shear Saouma 613 10-11 to allow the to some Saouma 618 13 through T&D throughout Saouma 618 21 statement which was statements which were Saouma 618 2-3 this it is safe if it is safe Saouma a couple of dams and all of them showed that 619 9 a couple of times and so that if humidity Saouma humidity 620 18 still not Saouma 620 21 some issues are one issue not Saouma 620 23 up to the right the right size Saouma 620 24 wall have different wall has a different Saouma 621 3 consider sufficient consider representativeness sufficient Saouma 621 5 4,800 4,800 psi Saouma 621 6 6,000 6,000 psi Saouma 621 7 low displacement curve which is load displacement curve which are Saouma 621 8 occur. occurs. Saouma 622 2 something wrong that something is wrong Saouma 622 13 account accounts Saouma 622 24 were 36-inch. were on 36-inch specimens. Saouma 622 35 specimen. specimens. Saouma 623 3 36-inch 36 inches Saouma 623 1-2 24-inch 24 inches Saouma 624 7-8 apparent element and damages finite element analysis Saouma 625 3 In 1971, version In the 1971 version Bayrak 627 16 years, When years, assumed that when Saouma Page 17 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 627 20 CEB outside for the CEB for the Saouma 627 23 again, is a panacea and absolve again, it is a panacea and absolves Saouma 629 4 sometime sometimes Saouma 629 5 for additional of additional Saouma 629 13 Thats why in Thats why Saouma 629 14 is that the is the Saouma 629 15 condition condition: Saouma 630 9 number member Bayrak 634 5 behavior. So we behavior so we Simons 634 7 model, we were model. We were Simons 636 18 produce produces Saouma 636 22 is alkaline is the alkaline Saouma 636 30 specifications and specifications. And Saouma 637 4 importantly important Saouma 637 7 curve curves Saouma 637 23 controlled control Bayrak 638 14 agg mixtures admixtures Simons 639 22 conclusion conclusions Saouma 640 2 what is what is the Saouma 640 14 continuously a continuously Saouma 640 18 there was not there were not Saouma 640 19 ingredient ingredients Saouma 640 21 number numbers Saouma 640 24 consistently a high temperature a consistently high temperature. Saouma 644 10 Just clarification Just a clarification Saouma 644 14 fine, fine sand, Saouma 645 18 kinetic kinetics Saouma 645 19 which is which are Saouma 645 21 kinetic kinetics Saouma 645 23 temperature. temperatures. Saouma 646 5 humidity or not. humidity. Saouma 646 15 all what it is. all it is. Saouma 646 17 model of Larive model - of Larive Saouma 648 22 extractions are extractions that are Saouma 648 22 its very its the very Saouma Page 18 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 648 23 elastic models elastic modulus Saouma 648 25 other context? the other context? Saouma 649 1 core cores Saouma 649 2 well established well-established Saouma 649 5 extracted and extracted. And Saouma 649 8 with different with a different Saouma 649 10 with aggregate with an aggregate Saouma 649 14 modules modulus Bagley 650 24 property properties Saouma 651 3 surrounding surroundings Saouma 651 7 Jacob Philips Jacob Philip Saouma 651 8 prediction predictions Saouma 651 18 linear non-linear Saouma 651 25 into in Saouma 652 1 any, any code, Saouma 652 4 from different from a different Saouma 652 5 property properties Saouma 652 16 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 653 13 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 653 22 there is there are Saouma 653 24 very simplified a very simplified Saouma 654 1 to more to a more Saouma 654 4 Even simple Even a simple Saouma 654 7 prediction. predictions. Saouma 654 10 has has a Saouma 654 18 have very have a very Saouma 654 23 do your use their Saouma 655 4 Moniere (phonetic) McGill Saouma 655 9 posts pores Saouma 655 12 force or forcing NextEra Saouma 655 15 colleague and friend colleagues and friends Saouma 658 19 program program, Saouma 658 21 where there was a result the with the results of Saouma 658 23 is analysis if the analysis Saouma 658 25 in your benchmark study. in our benchmark study, Saouma Page 19 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 658 25 So stiffening effect is due the stiffening effect due Saouma 659 1 to SR to ASR Saouma 659 2 that predicted they predicted Saouma 660 1 lines goes lines. It goes Saouma 660 7 degradation gradation Saouma 660 8 design to design - to Saouma 660 9 degradation gradation Saouma 660 11 what the degradation what gradation was Saouma 660 16 study what study. What Saouma 660 17 comparing to comparing it to Saouma 660 20 that standard. that is standard. Saouma 672 20 whole hole Simons 675 3 But I I Saouma 675 6 current project, current project, that Saouma 675 6 of DOT mixed of the DOT mix Saouma 675 8 the reasons, have the reason. have their reasons, they have their reasons. Saouma 675 19 Oguz Ozzie Simons 681 8 on that my attention my attention on that Saouma 682 3 within within the Saouma 685 22 used use Simons 687 15 at high at a high Saouma 687 20 books on books I am Saouma 688 19 conditions, conditions vary, Bayrak 691 3 at exact at the exact Saouma 691 4 location based location, based Saouma 692 10 frequencies well frequencies will Buford 693 1 and CTI, and CCI, Buford 694 5 volumetric accepted limits, volumetric acceptance limits, Buford 694 17 jump into, jump in too, Buford 694 20 widely understand. widely understood. Buford 696 17 crack which have not manifested themselves cracks which have not manifested themselves Saouma 696 20 2018 2018 RIC Saouma 697 6 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
698 2 being progressed being processed Philip 698 6 And NCR staff And NRC staff Philip Page 20 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 698 16 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
698 19 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
698 24-25 in the professionalized sort of analysis profession now, nor in the analysis Philip 699 16 and people can come out to it. and people can come out with. Philip 699 21 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
701 9 MR. PHILLIP: MR. SHERMAN:
701 13 MR. PHILLIP: MR. SHERMAN:
701 24 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 702 1 No. 11 or six inches No. 11 at six inches Bolourchi 702 7 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 702 24 refrain restrain Saouma 702 25 Defines Even in Saouma 703 1 volumetric. It is confined in volumetric even if it is confined in Saouma 703 2 B for instance, in the two directions. in two directions. Saouma 703 7 concrete. Theres Theres Saouma 703 8 Its wont expand. It will expand. Saouma 703 14 details detail Saouma 704 4 have reinforcement have the reinforcement Saouma 705 25 phases faces Sherman 707 13 track crack Saouma 707 16 either said Saouma 707 23 divisible visible Saouma 708 6 certain it will certain - it will Saouma 708 8 expand, it is expand, but if it is Saouma 709 5 data than data more than Saouma 709 10 year-and-a-half a year-and-a-half Saouma 709 14 it edge effect it an edge effect Saouma 711 2 full course pull cores Carley 712 16 discussed? discussed. Simons 713 15 MS. COLLINS: MR. COLLINS:
717 16 ageing aging Buford 717 17 mechanism. mechanisms. Buford 717 24 here, what here, Saouma 717 25 concern is at concern is that at Saouma 718 19 system, people a system for people Saouma Page 21 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 720 24 dams which is dams, which are Saouma 721 7 indication indications Saouma 725 19 one have one we have Saouma 725 20 with that. with. Saouma 725 22 element and element analysis and Saouma 726 14 in and Carley 726 16 did have did not have Carley 727 23 three years three years ago, Saouma 728 1 linear non-linear Saouma 728 3 linear non-linear Saouma 728 5 funding from funding from the Saouma 728 5 with one search research Saouma 728 6 classical unit classical report Saouma 728 10 linear non-linear Saouma 728 12 EPRI EPRI, Saouma 728 15 Seabrook would suffer Seabrook suffering Saouma 728 16 analysis. To analysis - to Saouma 728 17 just used is just used - is Saouma 728 18 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 729 16 surface stress Bolourchi 729 17 seam stress Bolourchi 729 24 record code Bolourchi 731 6 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 732 4 true thickness through thickness Bolourchi 732 14 non-linear are applicable. non-linear analyses are inapplicable. Saouma 732 20 analysis analyses Saouma 732 21 analysis analyses Saouma 732 24 Chantilly Gentilly Saouma 732 25 Bureau The Bureau Saouma 733 2 than nuclear reactors. than a nuclear reactor. Saouma 733 3 need because need non-linear analysis because Saouma 733 8 the regime the linear regime Saouma 733 9 such high factor such a high factor Saouma 733 10 reactor from my point of view reactor, from my point of view, Saouma 737 19 attempt intent Simons Page 22 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 743 13 paper fabrication papers, publications Saouma 743 15 is a type is the type Saouma 744 25 probably he is probably it is Saouma 745 1 bad brittle reinforcement also had brittle reinforcement. Also Saouma 745 20 proper hopper Simons 748 24 lab because lab, because Saouma 750 11 28 day strengths 28-day strength Saouma 750 11 the deterioration the deterioration, Saouma 750 13 28 day 28-day Saouma 751 13 to a database to the database Saouma 751 15 28 day strengths 28-day strength Saouma 752 4 and to get it back again. and get it back to us again. Saouma 752 19 true thickness through-thickness Bayrak 753 16 F prime C? f prime C? Saouma 760 6 Court Board Bessette 760 6 Glen Glenn Bessette 766 9 rod raw Lighty 766 23 for the license and memory request for the license amendment request Wachutka 769 1 I went here I went Saouma 769 5 So, very The very Saouma 769 6 repetitive of free force representativeness of reinforced Saouma 769 16 what the degradation, which what is the gradation. Saouma 769 18 Degradation Gradation Saouma representative of reinforced concrete at Seabrook "representative of reinforced concrete at 769 22-23 Saouma Station Seabrook Station" 770 1 still not still do not Saouma 770 3 discussed prior discussed Saouma 770 4 a gradation, what is a the gradation, what is the Saouma 770 6 I mentioned I mention Saouma 770 10 ratio ratios Saouma 770 12 condition. conditions. Saouma 770 14 structure structural Saouma 770 20 crack, cracks, Saouma 770 23 again in again is in Saouma 770 17-18 inspect course for mid-plane, mid-plane cracks. inspect cores for mid-plane cracks." Saouma Page 23 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 771 5 complete concrete Saouma 771 6 the day, would the day, Saouma 771 9 also have, also Saouma 771 12 bottom of the page bottom of the page: Saouma 771 13 through-thickness inspection and, through-thickness expansion and, Saouma 771 14 inspection relies expansion relies Saouma 771 15 reservation with that method which reservations with that method which, Saouma 771 22 modulus cannot modulus that cannot Saouma 771 25 routine monitoring [r]outine monitoring Saouma 771 25 there are determined they determine Saouma 772 2 program limits. program limits. Saouma 772 16 forward looking forward-looking Saouma 772 16 which is very which is a very Saouma 772 18 what is a what is the Saouma 772 19 expansion and, expansion, and Saouma overlapping contingency plan for extending the develop contingency plans for extending the 772 22 Saouma expansion limit. expansion limit."
773 1 dont have dont meet Saouma 773 8 Volumetric expansion, there is, what does At Volumetric Expansion, it says, "test data Saouma 773 9 it shows that show that Saouma 773 10 direction, does not direction does not Saouma 773 11 in other strain direction. in unrestrained directions. Saouma 773 14 Milton Multon Saouma 773 16 free dependent Saouma 773 23 maximum volumetric expansion maximum volumetric expansion Saouma 773 24 analysis analyses Saouma 774 1 yes, CEB, yes, the CEB, Saouma 774 7 section 6, it is said that for, Section 6, it says, Saouma that after the FSEL test specimen exhibits a Thereafter, the FSEL test specimens exhibited 774 8 Saouma measure much greater 774 9 of expansion and the through-thickness expansion in the through-thickness, Saouma 774 16 last past Saouma 774 17 last past Saouma 775 22 write meant Judge Mtingwa 776 10 dwelt delved Saouma Page 24 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 776 14 reviewer reviewers Saouma 776 19 such an observation will [s]uch an observation would Saouma 776 21 location with the CCI locations with a CCI Saouma 776 22 per meter. per meter. Saouma 777 1 extensometer extensometers Saouma 777 5 the expected plant [t]he expected trend Saouma that in-plane and through-thickness expansion 777 6 at in-plane and through-thickness value would be Saouma values will be 777 7 expansion level expansion levels Saouma 777 10 we had we have Saouma 777 13 had have Saouma 777 14 monitoring monitoring program Saouma 778 22 owns own Bayrak 780 21 us use Bayrak 782 19 band bent Bayrak 782 22 spent death rations span to depth ratios Bayrak 783 19 co-IT co-PI Bayrak 785 6 degrading grading Simons 785 17 4273? 4273. Simons 786 8 in-plain in-plane Simons 786 15 plan's plans Simons 786 19 box plot Simons 786 20 plain plane Simons 786 25 in-plain in-plane Simons 787 5 in-plain in-plane Simons 793 22 separate from with Saouma 793 25 Modele Modeer Saouma 795 2 MR. SIMONS DR. BAYRAK 795 6 coded code Bayrak 795 6 MR. SIMONS DR. BAYRAK 797 7 LSAP LSTP Saouma 797 12 not only with issue strengths. concerned not only with the issue of strengths. Saouma 797 19 which the result in the error bar without error bars Saouma 797 25 caught, cut all this caught all these Saouma 798 4 had has Saouma Page 25 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 798 17 myself, my myself. My Saouma 799 2 background. backgrounds. Saouma 799 3 having put having been put Saouma 799 14 My name is Jacob Phillip My name is Jacob Philip Philip 799 14 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
799 22 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
799 23 the long large scale test the large scale test Philip 800 4 Mr. Phillip, Mr. Philip, Judge Trikouros 800 6 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
800 10 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
800 13 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
800 15 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
800 18 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
801 9 the membership of the NR the membership of the SAITT Thomas 803 13 president publishing Saouma 803 17 two years two years and Saouma 803 23 NIST, Kiara NIST. Chiarra Saouma 803 24 Sarathi (phonetic) Ferraris Saouma 803 25 work works Saouma 804 3 NIST. NIST, in Saouma 804 16 engineer, researcher engineers, researchers Saouma 805 1 analysis. analysis of ASR. Saouma 805 4 his art ASR -- Saouma 805 5 okay, okay -- Saouma 805 6 with ASR. of ASR. Saouma 805 8 prevail itself from avail itself of Saouma 805 9 someone someone, Saouma 806 1 Phillip? Philip? Judge Mtingwa 806 2 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
807 10 We have extremely well or instrumented We have extremely well instrumented Philip 807 18 like NUREG C, NUREG documents like NUREG documents Philip 808 9 for its the Saouma 810 7 Under C-3411, question was Under C.3.4.1.1, question was Judge Trikouros 811 4 engineer as engineers, Saouma 811 5 limitation about the limitations about our Saouma Page 26 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 811 23 to the - to obtain to obtain Saouma 812 4 the user capacity reduce the capacity Saouma 812 8 there is so much unknown so much is unknown -- Saouma 813 21 this conformed risk informed Thomas 814 2 the regulatory guidance and Reg Guide 174 the regulatory guidance and Reg Guide 1.174 Thomas 814 21 regulatory guidance, and regulatory guidance were met, and Thomas and core damage frequency within the NRCs and core damage frequency, they are within the 814 4-5 Thomas acceptance criteria. NRCs acceptance criteria.
816 9 a CEB a CEB, Saouma 816 12 come comes Saouma 816 14 Design, four Design, and there were four Saouma 816 15 time, reviewer time, making a reviewer was making Saouma 816 16 clarification. clarifications. Saouma 816 17 There is There was Saouma 816 19 maybe there was maybe there were Saouma 817 3 some datas, some data, Saouma 818 2 STM ASTM Saouma 819 6 analyst appear analyst Saouma 819 9 already then Saouma 819 10 parameter. parameters. Saouma 819 14 O'Neil nonlinear Saouma 819 24 engineer engineers Saouma 819 25 with on the with the Saouma 819 25 earthquake. earthquakes. Saouma 820 8 80% 80% risk Saouma 821 18 Cervinka (phonetic) Cervenka Saouma 821 19 Czech the Czech Saouma 822 2 is one is none Saouma 822 13 engineer engineers Saouma 823 4 just qualitative suspended risk just qualitatively informed risk Thomas 823 9 probability of probabilisitic Bell periodically by connecting integrated leak rate periodically by conducting integrated leak rate 824 1 Thomas tests. tests.
824 14 D of the D the Saouma Page 27 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker Galambos. And those people were on a 824 17 Galambos and those were pioneering Saouma pioneering 824 18 NIST, has to NIST. The code has to Saouma 824 19 things a Gaussian things as a Gaussian Saouma 824 20 to once infinity from minus infinity Saouma 825 1 limit load resistant load resistance Saouma 825 7 accept to accept and to Saouma 825 8 codes beyond codes. Beyond Saouma 825 9 analysis, my analysis, in my Saouma 825 10 starts with really for starts really with Saouma 825 11 structure structures Saouma 825 12 Kennedy Kemeney Saouma 825 17 competent components Saouma 826 11 who was who Saouma 826 20 if there is a certain if a certain Saouma 826 21 happen. happens. Saouma 828 2 concern concerns Saouma 829 19 effect affect Saouma 829 20 produce reduce Saouma 830 2 pre-stress pre-stressed Bayrak 831 17 BWD (bw)(d) Bayrak 833 12 Hognestan (phonetic) Hognestad Bayrak 833 21 Asheville code (phonetic) AASHTO Code Bayrak 837 22 the implant expansion the in-plant expansion Bagley 838 8 because for because Saouma 838 23 monitor, but monitoring bounds Bolourchi 839 22 prediction to what it is predictions as to what it is by Saouma 840 1 pretend pretends Saouma 840 4 if you are if you have Saouma 840 6 So dependents It depends Saouma 840 7 pretend pretends Saouma 840 10 heat larger lead to larger Saouma 840 13 elastic modulus elastic modulus, Saouma 840 14 shear strengths and fracture energy shear strengths, and fracture energy -- Saouma 840 16 also investigation also the investigation Saouma Page 28 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 842 4 don't it dont do it Saouma 842 9 particle particular Saouma 842 19 stipises (phonetic) stiffnesses Bell 843 2 demand. That is demand - that is, Bell 843 4 structure, and capacity. The structure - and capacity - the Bell 845 5 command, comment, Saouma 845 6 find all its finds its Saouma 845 10 which says it is which says [i]t is Saouma 845 11 when known well known Saouma 845 13 on its own therefore, on its own, therefore, Saouma 845 14 not sufficient. not sufficient. Saouma 845 16 a curve, that a curve, but that Saouma 845 17 infinite way infinite number of ways Saouma 845 18 matched and as matched. And as Saouma 846 15 page 16 page 76 Saouma 846 20 engineer when known engineers well know. Saouma 846 20 We do feet We do take Saouma 846 21 and, we and we Saouma 846 25 fast 48 transfer fast fourrier transform Saouma 847 3 garbage in between garbage in, garbage out Saouma 847 15 some engineer some engineers Saouma 847 18 by a mere by mere Saouma 847 19 analysis correct. analysis is correct. Saouma 849 20 ACI 318.71 ACI 318-71 Bayrak 849 22 our built our buildings and Bayrak 856 1 criteria choices constitute of criteria, choices on constituitive Bayrak 856 2 ASR how ASR, how Bayrak 856 25 blind prediction an example so one a blind prediction. An example is one Saouma 857 3 shear was shear that was Saouma 857 3 ASR about ASR. About Saouma 857 4 results and results. In Saouma 857 5 recent a decent Saouma 859 1 building, when building. When Bell 859 2 release. The release, the Bell 859 5 annuals annulus Bell Page 29 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 859 9 boil boiler Bell 859 9 ASME the ASME Bell 860 5 Seabook, is Seabrook is, Bell 866 3 unlimited limited Bell 869 8 maintained within the elastic rate. maintained within the elastic range. Thomas 869 16 defamation deformation Buford 875 18 Mr. Phillip Mr. Philip Judge Mtingwa 875 22 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
877 14 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
877 17 we and research, we in research, Philip 878 8 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
879 16 defamation measurements. deformation measurements. Buford 885 20 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
888 25 PARTICIPANT: MR. LAMB:
893 11 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 893 15 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 897 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 897 5 INT22 INT022 Bolourchi 897 19 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 898 2 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 898 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 898 11 consistently consistent with Bolourchi 898 15 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 899 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 900 8 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 900 11 RAI-B10 RAI-D10 Bolourchi 900 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 900 25 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 901 4 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 901 9 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 901 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 901 12 a bit of it as Bolourchi 901 17 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 901 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 902 3 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI Page 30 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 902 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 902 21 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 902 24 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 903 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 903 16 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 903 19 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 903 25 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 904 19 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 904 23 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 905 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 905 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 906 1 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 906 4 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 906 19 under the structural Bolourchi 907 1 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 910 1 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 910 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 915 6 ISC ISE Bayrak 915 23 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 917 1 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 917 5 moving frame moment frame Bolourchi 917 12 moving frame moment frame Bolourchi 918 6 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 919 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 919 6 principal distress principal stress Bolourchi 919 7 restraint strain Bolourchi 920 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 921 25 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 922 4 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 923 4 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 924 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 926 22 minute meter Bell 928 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 928 7 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 928 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI Page 31 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 928 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 933 23 expanding expansion Sherman 934 8 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 934 18 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 934 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 934 25 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 935 10 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 935 18 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 936 13 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 937 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 938 3 ASR code ASR growth Bolourchi 940 23 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 942 9 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 943 9 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 943 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 947 16 5059 50.59 Judge Trikouros 949 7 5059 50.59 Buford 949 8 via CFR 50.9 via 10 CFR 50.90. Buford 950 9 Task Force on tests were on Sherman 951 16 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 951 19 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 954 4 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 961 3 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 961 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 961 8 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 961 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 961 19 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 961 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 962 5 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 962 13 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 962 20 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 964 10 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 964 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 964 14 enforcement reinforcements Bolourchi 965 3 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI Page 32 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 966 7 JA03 talking JA03 is talking Bell 966 15 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 966 16 balance distance Bolourchi 966 18 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 972 14 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 983 16 elastic modulus, elastic modulus -- Bagley 987 2 FHAWA FHWA Saouma 993 8 within the 3757 within -3757 Bagley 1002 5 PARTICIPANT: JUDGE TRIKOUROS:
1002 14 ISC ISE Bayrak 1003 19 different difference Bayrak 1004 4 ACI 31871 ACI 318-71 Bayrak 1004 5 ACI 31871 ACI 318-71 Bayrak 1006 16 B sub c (phonetic) V sub c Bayrak 1016 1 captured in Appendix E of MPR 4273. captured in Appendix C of MPR 4273. Lehman 1016 14-15 Mr. Lehman, can we start at nine Mr. Lamb, can we start at nine Judge Spritzer 1017 5 opening statements, closing statements, Judge Spritzer 1017 6 opening statements closing statements Judge Spritzer 1019 11 At that is, And that is, Buford 1019 18 MR. LEHMAN: MR. WACHUTKA:
1020 22 MR. LEHMAN: MR. WACHUTKA:
1020 23 SC SE Wachutka 1021 14 Jacob Phillip, Jacob Philip, Judge Trikouros 1021 15 Jacob Phillip Jacob Philip Judge Trikouros 1021 18 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
1021 24 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
1023 15 Fuel walk-downs field walk-downs Judge Trikouros 1026 12 and ASR expansion monitoring program. an ASR expansion monitoring program. Judge Trikouros 1027 9 needed to come into needed to come to Buford 1028 4 really leads in the next paragraph. really leads in to the next paragraph. Wachutka 1029 1 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
1029 3 approach or our review, approach for our review, Philip 1029 6 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
1029 8 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
1036 10 and getting into a and getting it to a Buford Page 33 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker the load test failures that conducted at different the load tests to failure were conducted at 1038 4-5 Thomas levels of ASR expansion. different levels of ASR expansion.
comparison and capacities are made to a comparison of capacities are made to a 1045 24 Thomas controlled controlled 1048 25 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1049 3 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1050 11 MR. PHILLIP: MR. PHILIP:
1055 7 it does into it goes into Thomas 1055 22 which is by using crack section which is by using cracked section Thomas 1057 11 at a certain point. up to a certain point. Thomas 1057 18 way SCI318 is based on is way ACI 318 is based on is Thomas 1057 21 rather than concrete failing and compression. rather than concrete failing in compression. Thomas 1058 6 MR. THOMAS: DR. SAOUMA:
1059 9 flexion flexure Bayrak 1059 21 ACI 31871 ACI 318-71 Bayrak 1059 22 ACI 31819 ACI 318-19 Bayrak 1060 3 ACI 31871 ACI 318-71 Bayrak 1060 16 Soft weight Self weight Bayrak 1062 2 the formation deformation Bayrak 1064 18 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1064 20 low-grade below grade Bolourchi 1066 7 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1066 10 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1066 14 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1066 17 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1067 1 ACI creating code ACI building code Bolourchi 1067 9 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1067 12 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1067 17 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1067 19 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1067 22 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1067 25 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1068 2 MR. BOLOURCHI DR. BOLOURCHI 1073 11 had have Saouma 1074 3 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS Page 34 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 1075 4 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1075 12 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1076 4 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1077 15 PARTICIPANT MR. SIMONS 1078 9 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1078 25 PARTICIPANT MR. SHERMAN 1079 2 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1079 6 Dr. Derek Kong Dr. Derek Cong Simons 1079 14 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1079 17 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1080 6 regional original Bessette 1081 15 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1082 4 here shear Simons 1083 14 composite strength. compressive strength. Thomas 1084 1 about above Thomas 1084 12 anchorage test program, our flexure tests. anchorage test program, or the flexure tests. Thomas 1085 10 it begs us all the time. it exists all the time. Thomas 1085 18 ACI 3.8, ACI 318, Thomas the rebar is not affected, only beyond that the the rebar is not effective, only beyond that the 1085 3-4 Thomas rebar becomes affected. rebar becomes effective.
1088 25 Microcrack Microcracking Saouma 1089 19 access axis Bayrak 1091 14 safe shutdown. safe shutdown earthquake. Thomas 1092 14 The bottom portion of the member The top portion of the member Thomas 1092 25 use of crack section properties. use of cracked section properties. Thomas A member is subject to bending a flexure. The When a member is subject to bending or flexure, 1092 10-11 Thomas bottom portion is subject the bottom portion is subject 1093 6 The code addresses using equal and linear The code addresses this using equivalent linear Thomas 1093 10 problem muddying problem being muddied in Saouma 1093 12 hear we hear Saouma 1093 13 is no are no Saouma 1093 18 of structure of a structure Saouma 1094 4 them because them is because Saouma 1094 7 and more and and more. And Saouma Page 35 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 1094 9 under sustained load, under a sustained load. Saouma 1094 9 with time, With time, Saouma 1094 10 It is well established There is a well-established Saouma 1094 21 beam beams Saouma 1094 21 HTT time t Saouma 1094 23 response, responses, Saouma 1096 25 ISC ISE Bayrak 1097 1 ISC ISE Bayrak 1099 8 PARTICIPANT DR. BAYRAK 1099 10 PARTICIPANT DR. BAYRAK 1100 7 fee factors phi factors Bayrak 1103 6 use used Saouma 1104 10 brittlement (phonetic) brittle Bolourchi 1104 14 2 prime C 2 square root of f prime c Bolourchi 1106 9 compressive strength, compressive strength, Saouma 1106 9 plastic strain, and plastic strain at Saouma 1106 11 factors affecting the response factors influencing the response. Saouma 1106 12 Compressive strengths Compressive strength Saouma 1106 13 compressive strengths compressive strength Saouma the wall and lateral colum exhibit non-linear the wall and lateral column exhibit non-linear 1106 1 to 2 Saouma behavior. behavior."
1107 2 200 day, 200 days, Saouma 1107 4 1,000 day, 1,000 days, Saouma 1107 12 steel, the stress to it is stressed to Saouma 1108 21 failure in the institutional structural engineers failure by the Institute of Structural Engineers Saouma the staff makes is on operating experience 1114 25 the staff makes on operating experience related to Thomas related to 1115 22 structural failures; structural failure; Saouma 1117 15 PARTICIPANT MR. PHILLIP 1119 11 Mr. Phillip Mr. Philip Saouma 1119 12 method, he said method. He said, Saouma 1119 20 mortar bar a mortar bar Saouma 1119 22 PARTICIPANT MR. PHILLIP 1119 24 below one-quarter for inch. below three-quarter inch. Philip 1120 16 PARTICIPANT MR. PHILLIP Page 36 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 1120 23 PARTICIPANT MR. PHILLIP 1121 7 mortar bar a mortar bar Saouma 1121 8 mortar bar a mortar bar Saouma 1121 9 story so I story. So I Saouma 1122 3 monitoring the program, monitoring program, Buford 1123 10 statement a statement Saouma 1123 11 often enough; often enough; Saouma 1123 12 often enough "often enough Saouma 1123 13 short enough; short enough; Saouma 1123 13 what short enough what short enough Saouma 1123 14 statement like how to predict a statement like "how to predict" Saouma 1123 15 next inspection on next inspection. On Saouma 1123 16 we predict. we predict? Saouma 1123 14-15 we know how to predict we know how to predict Saouma 1124 25 institutional Institution of Thomas 1125 1 structural engineer's Structural Engineers Thomas monitoring a structure in the UK and monitoring of structures in the UK and 1125 2 Thomas internationally internationally 1125 8 where there is long-term monitoring, the rigorous long-term monitoring, Thomas 1125 9 of gas blocks of cast blocks Thomas 1125 14 The expansion sites are where concrete The exposure sites are where concrete Thomas research establishments AAR exposure site Research Establishments AAR exposure site 1125 11-12 program, as confirmed with linear expansion with program, has confirmed this linear expansion Thomas time, with time, 1127 20 mirror if mirror to see Saouma 1127 22 box of box. The Saouma 1127 23 value which value Saouma 1128 1 by having by having an Saouma 1128 3 ISE talk ISE talks Saouma 1128 4 which is which Saouma 1128 5 FWA (phonetic) FHWA Saouma 1128 5 talk talks Saouma 1128 10 on closer on looking Saouma 1128 11 bird view birds eye view Saouma 1128 17 That's, in my opinion, That, in my opinion, is Saouma Page 37 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 1130 8 accepted limits acceptance limits Buford 1130 21 There is There are Saouma 1130 24 FSWA FHWA Saouma 1131 2 Scandanavian, Scandanavians, Saouma 1131 2 Canadian. Canadians. Saouma 1131 5 asking to asking NextEra to Saouma 1131 11 the number of a number of Saouma 1131 13 is end is the end Saouma 1131 16 Remind me Reminds me Saouma 1131 21 not what you not what we Saouma 1133 5 that proceeded the LAR, that preceded the LAR, Buford 1134 11 densometer extensometer Saouma 1134 13 that, that that, Saouma 1134 18 investigation. investigations. Saouma 1134 24 to be not to be Saouma edges of the large-scale test specimens, at the edges of the large-scale test specimens, at the 1138 24-25 Buford very top and bottom, were restrained. very top and bottom, were unrestrained.
1139 25 apparent delamination is "apparent delamination," a Saouma 1140 2 something it something that it Saouma 1140 5 precisely we precisely why we Saouma 1140 20 -- it's as Saouma 1140 23 is explanation? is the explanation? Saouma 1140 25 want to wants to Saouma 1141 1 Just it Just so it Saouma 1144 16 MPR-4152 MPR-4153 Saouma 1144 17 there is there are Saouma 1144 18 building has building has a Saouma or if I divide the mean by the standard deviation, I 1144 21-22 or if I take the standard use by the mean by Saouma get 1145 2 point points Saouma 1145 5 there is that is Saouma 1145 7 ACI code that is ACI Code: that is, Saouma 1145 8 57,000 - of 57,000 square root of Saouma 1145 8 F prime sub C f prime sub c Saouma 1145 16 estimated estimate Saouma Page 38 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 1145 20 is very high is very low Saouma 1145 24 enclosure building the containment enclosure building Saouma 1146 4 electric tunnel the electric tunnel Saouma 1146 15 is Achilles heel in is not Achilles' heel Saouma 1146 19 need needs Saouma 1147 15 factors factor Bagley 1148 5 exensometer? extensometers? Saouma 1148 12 measurement measurements Saouma 1148 13 extensometer extensometers Saouma 1149 10 The large The purpose of the large Saouma 1150 1 renders render Saouma 1150 12 try to remain tend to remain Saouma 1150 16 relies depends Saouma 1151 1 inspection. inspections. Saouma 1152 8 concrete concretes Saouma 1152 13 linear classic analysis or we linear classic analysis we Saouma 1152 16 parameter. parameters. Saouma 1152 21 aggregation aggregates Saouma 1153 14 shown by the showed, the Saouma 1154 4 Having multi- Having a multi- Saouma 1154 7 hand hands Saouma 1154 7 engineer engineers Saouma 1154 25 passage passages Saouma 1155 2 on very locations, on a very few locations, Saouma 1155 3 addressed that addressed: that Saouma 1155 4 is that has this Saouma 1155 5 compression. compression? Saouma 1155 8 under service under the service Saouma 1155 8 under ultimate under the ultimate Saouma 1155 12 God knows God knows, Saouma 1155 13 strength strain Saouma 1155 15 details which the details of which Saouma 1155 22 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1156 6 cover them cover it Saouma 1156 9 We don't cover If we dont cover Saouma Page 39 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 1156 11 structure, structures, Saouma 1156 17 well established well-established Saouma 1156 22 as pointed yesterday, as I pointed out yesterday, Saouma 1156 23 take over takes over Saouma 1156 23 say crack, you stop. Says, Crack, you stop. Saouma 1157 1 stop you. stop you. Saouma 1157 2 Okay, "Okay, Saouma 1157 5 delaminate. delaminate. Saouma 1157 10 the crack cracks Saouma 1157 11 Part which The part which Saouma 1157 15 Part underground The part underground Saouma 1157 17 earthquake come; earthquake comes; Saouma 1158 15 been similar been a similar Saouma 1158 16 Chad Wood Charlwood Saouma 1158 20 expansion less expansion with less Saouma 1158 20 percent. percent humidity. Saouma 1160 9 metals measured Saouma 1161 2 extensometer, extensometers, Saouma 1161 2 which is a which is the Saouma 1161 6 flow flaw Saouma 1162 7 microcrack microcracks Saouma 1162 10 determine that determine the Saouma 1162 11 approach, approach; Saouma 1162 18 CCI is capture CCI has captured Saouma 1162 29 can be location can be a location Saouma 1163 1 extension expansion Saouma 1163 22 defamation deformation Judge Mtingwa 1163 22 defamation deformation Saouma 1164 4 is impact is the impact Saouma 1164 8 type types Saouma 1164 24 last in the last Saouma 1164 25 What a petrographer What petrographers Saouma 1165 5 crack. cracks. Saouma 1165 14 them up and giving them up, giving Saouma 1165 14 different weight is a crack in this different weights to cracks and Saouma Page 40 of 41
ATTACHMENT 1 - HEARING TRANSCRIPT NON-PROPRIETARY ERRATA SHEET In the Matter of NextEra Energy Seabrook, LLC (Seabrook Station, Unit 1)
Docket No. 50-443-LA-2 September 24-27, 2019 Evidentiary Hearing Page Line Now Reads Should Read Speaker 1165 15 type of aggregate types of aggregate Saouma 1165 18 protocol, what are the weight, protocols for what are the weights, Saouma 1165 20 petrographer petrographers Saouma 1165 20 same. same results. Saouma 1165 21 petrographer petrographers Saouma 1165 23 petrographer, petrographers, Saouma 1165 24 Wiss, Wiss Saouma 1166 1 Kong Cong Saouma 1166 11 back six back in Saouma 1166 13 slice and slice. And Saouma 1166 25 rapid rapidly Saouma 1167 13 MR. SYMONS MR. SIMONS 1167 18 Derek Kong Derek Cong Simons 1168 20 one core on one core Sherman 1169 10 engineer engineers Saouma 1169 18 engineer engineers Saouma 1169 21 limitation limitations Saouma 1169 21 assumption assumptions Saouma 1169 22 in details. in detail. Saouma 1170 5 yes, yes -- Saouma 1170 6 petrographic examination "Petrographic examinations Saouma 1170 6 to I to the DRI Saouma 1170 7 minimum effort. minimal equipment. Saouma 1170 11 drawn extent drawn regarding the extent Saouma 1170 16 including my including Saouma 1173 14 God knows if God knows, Saouma 1173 17 know if know of Saouma 1173 18 terminal thermal Saouma 1173 22 principle principal Saouma 1174 1 AAR. ASR. Saouma 1174 9 careful shell careful with shell Saouma 1174 10 the two direction for the two directions, Saouma 1174 11 plane. plane? Saouma 1191 21 records record Lighty 1197 9 two-scale to-scale Lighty Page 41 of 41