ML19289E704
| ML19289E704 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 05/02/1979 |
| From: | Gilinsky V, Hendrie J, Kennedy R NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 7905290008 | |
| Download: ML19289E704 (4) | |
Text
q_
y 6
f
=
(
.. =
~
~,
C?4546
,. =.
,j
'l D**
- D Y
~'
1
. @. W G
"J
=
1
/.
r.
D'.e. ct>.m... e.o..
This is an unofficial transcrict of a caeting of the United States Nuclear Reculatory Ccamission held on We&ess., 2 mv 1979 in the Ccmission s offices at 1717 H Straet, ii. W., ~Wasnir.gtsa, O. C.
The i
meeting was cpen to public attendance and observatic:2.
Th'i s t-anscript has not taen reviewed, correctad, er edited, and it =ay contain inaccurac-les.
. The transcript is inter.ded sciely for ceneral informa'ticnal curposes.
As provided by 10 C. R 9.103, it is not part of the formal or informal e
record cf decision cf the matters discussed.
Excressicns of cpinien in this transcript do not necessarily reflec: final detarminatiens or beliefs.
- <o pleading er other paper may be filed with the Ccamission in any preceeding'as the result of or addressed to any statement or argument contained herein, except as the 'Cc=issica may auther-ize.
htys$6'.
M 790529000g
f i
1 I
CR4 546 1 :
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 2
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION i
3i i
4, PUBLIC MEETING I
5 i
AFFIRMATION SESSION 79-10 l
6i l
7j i
4 8'
Room 1130 9q 1717 H Street, N.
W.
Washincton, D.
C.
10 h
Wednesdav, May 2, 1979 11 i
The Commission met, pursuant to notice, at 11:30 a.m.
I 12 l
BEFORE :
13 !,
i DR. JOSEPH M. HENDRIE, Chairman 14 l VICTOR GILINSKY, Commissioner 15,
RICHART T. KENNEDY, Commissioner 16,,
li PETER A. BRADFORD, Commissioner 17 j l
JOHN F. AHEARNE, Cc=missioner 18 l l ALSO PRESENT:
19 Messrs. Chilk, Grimes, Scinto, Eisenhut, Gossick, Snyder, 20 1 l,
Moe, Bickwit, and Murray.
21 d i
\\\\
22 ll n
91 24 'i
.2045 147 l
- -:erai n eooruri, inc. '
25 <
L
2
- CR4546 WEL/wel
_P R O_ C _E _E D_ _I N_ G_ _S 1
2 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Are there affirmations that are available to be made?
3 4
MR. CHILK:
Yes, there are two.
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Okay, Sam, go ahead.
S MR. CHILK:
The first one is SECY-A-79-20, which 6
is the Shearon Harris proceeding, and it's a draft order 7
disposing of a motion to reopen the Harris proceeding on 8
J 9
the need-for-power issue.
i
~
A memorandum and order was distributed to all 10 of you yesterday, and my understanding is that all of you ji have concurred in that draft order.
I would ask you to 12 affirm it.
33 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Those in favor?
34 1
15 i (Chorus of " ayes. ")
So ordered.
16 MR. CHILK:
The second item deals with 79-16A, g
I is '
which is the Kranish FOIA Appeal.
Six documents involved i
i on B5.
The Staff recommended that it be released in part, ig t
and by unanimous vote you agreed to release it in part.
20 On 36, the Staff recommended the appeal be
,t l
e l!
denied and unanimously you decided to deny the appeal.
,,2 4
I On 37, the Staff recommended denial of the 23
!l appeal, and you unanimousiv decided to release the documents '
n
,J 1
On 38, the Staff reccamended denial of the l
r
}
sascica acnacu. sa 2045 148 444 NCRTH CAPTTOL STREET W A S MIN GTON. D.C.
20001
'202; 347 3700
.i
- l i-l appeal, and you have denied the appeal by a 3 to 2 vote.
1 2
In the draft summary, the Staff recommended I
3 I denial of the appeal, and you denied the appeal unanimously.
l 1
I ask that you affirm those.
4 i
5 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Those in favor?
6 (Chorus of " ayes. ")
7 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
What do I have to vote 8
in order to continue to vote to release B8?
I'll vote 6
9 l'whatever way -- as long as it's clear that I would release i
10 l it.
COMMISSIONER AHEAR'iE:
You would vote that Sam's 11 12 description is accurate.
COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
I will vote that Sam's 13 description is accurate.
MR. CHILK:
All right.
You voted to release B8.
15 That was a 3 to 2.
The Chairman, Mr. Kennedy and Mr.
16 17 i Ahearne voted to deny the appeal as recommended by the 1
staff.
ig l
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
All right.
We have agreed to ig l
take the vote as it cuts, and we af firm that we have voted 20
,3 3 that way.
.,s f
so rdered.
22
!i M ereupon, at 11:30 a.m.,
the affirmation 23 2 ~.,; session was concluded.)
2si 2045 149-l l
t c0:e 9ede:aI c.Repc:teu, Dnc l
/,
444 N C RTw C A PtTot. STREtt 3
]
W A S MINGTC N. D.C.
20001 l
'202? 347.J 700