ML19289A014
| ML19289A014 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 10/16/2019 |
| From: | Ed Miller Special Projects and Process Branch |
| To: | Mihaela Biro Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| Download: ML19289A014 (16) | |
Text
1 NRR-DRMAPEm Resource From:
Miller, Ed Sent:
Wednesday, October 16, 2019 7:36 AM To:
Biro, Mihaela; Pascarelli, Robert
Subject:
NEI slides for passive component categorization Attachments:
Oct 16_Enhanced PB Methodolgy_10-11-2019_rb.pdf Slides for todays meeting. Please forward to whomever else you think may want to see these. Thx.
ed
Hearing Identifier:
NRR_DRMA Email Number:
268 Mail Envelope Properties (BN7PR09MB27551D535D7FECEB46E72113E9920)
Subject:
NEI slides for passive component categorization Sent Date:
10/16/2019 7:36:07 AM Received Date:
10/16/2019 7:36:00 AM From:
Miller, Ed Created By:
Ed.Miller@nrc.gov Recipients:
"Biro, Mihaela" <Mihaela.Biro@nrc.gov>
Tracking Status: None "Pascarelli, Robert" <Robert.Pascarelli@nrc.gov>
Tracking Status: None Post Office:
BN7PR09MB2755.namprd09.prod.outlook.com Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 114 10/16/2019 7:36:00 AM Oct 16_Enhanced PB Methodolgy_10-11-2019_rb.pdf 904923 Options Priority:
Standard Return Notification:
No Reply Requested:
No Sensitivity:
Normal Expiration Date:
Recipients Received:
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m KŽ
t&E
Enhanced Categorization Methodology for Pressure Boundary Components
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Problem Statement
>&Z
/ŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
/ŽŽŽ
EZŽ
ZŽ^
Ž
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Process for Streamlining the Categorization Methodology
^Ž&ZŽ W
Ž
ŽŽ
WŽ
ZŽ&ZŽŽ
ŽŽ
d
ŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Existing Process (OHPHQW
&DWHJRUL]DWLRQ6WHS
1(,6HFWLRQ
(YDOXDWLRQ/HYHO
,'3&KDQJH
+66WR/66
'ULYHV
$VVRFLDWHG
)XQFWLRQV
5LVN 35$
0RGHOHG
,QWHUQDO(YHQWV%DVH
&DVH+/-6HFWLRQ
&RPSRQHQW
1RW$OORZHG
<HV
)LUH6HLVPLFDQG2WKHU
([WHUQDO(YHQWV%DVH
&DVH
$OORZDEOH
1R
35$6HQVLWLYLW\\6WXGLHV
$OORZDEOH
1R
,QWHJUDO35$
$VVHVVPHQW+/-6HFWLRQ
1RW$OORZHG
<HV
5LVN 1RQ
PRGHOHG
)LUH6HLVPLFDQG2WKHU
([WHUQDO+D]DUGV+/-
&RPSRQHQW
1RW$OORZHG
1R
6KXWGRZQ+/-6HFWLRQ
)XQFWLRQ&RPSRQHQW
1RW$OORZHG
1R
'HIHQVHLQ
'HSWK
&RUH'DPDJH+/-6HFWLRQ
)XQFWLRQ&RPSRQHQW
1RW$OORZHG
<HV
&RQWDLQPHQW+/-6HFWLRQ
&RPSRQHQW
1RW$OORZHG
<HV
4XDOLWDWLYH
&ULWHULD
&RQVLGHUDWLRQV+/-
6HFWLRQ
)XQFWLRQ
$OORZDEOH
1$
3DVVLYH
3DVVLYH+/-6HFWLRQ
6HJPHQW&RPSRQHQW
1RW$OORZHG
1R
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Existing Process Review - Results EŽŽŽ
^Ž
^ŽŽŽŽ
ŽZ//^/Ž EŽ
^Ž
Z//^/
/&ŽŽ^
DŽŽŽ/
DŽŽŽŽŽ/
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Existing Process Review - Results
'ŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ ZŽ Ž
3/4
3/4^
3/4^Ž dŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽZ//^/
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Safety Improvements (1 of 2) h
/
Ž
/>K
DŽ
/>K
DŽ
&ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ ^ Ž
ZŽŽ
WŽŽŽŽ
&ŽŽW&
ŽŽŽ
KWŽŽŽ
Ž, W
&ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ ^ Ž
ZŽŽ
WŽŽŽŽ
&ŽŽW&
ŽŽŽ
KWŽŽ, W
&ŽŽ
^ŽŽŽŽŽ
hd
&ŽŽ
^ŽŽŽŽŽ
hd
W> Z&Ž DŽ
^tsŽŽ
&ŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
EE
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Safety Improvements (2 of 2) h
/
Ž
ŽŽ
EE
&ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽ
^t^ZŽŽ ŽŽ
EE
^t^ZŽŽ ŽŽ
EE
^t
hŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
^tŽŽ
hŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
&ŽŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ ^t'ZŽŽ^Z
,ŽŽŽŽŽ
dŽŽŽŽŽ
Žd'dŽŽ
DŽ
,W&
EE ŽŽŽ
ZŽŽt
EE ŽŽŽ
&ŽŽŽŽŽ ^t'ZŽŽ
,E
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Explored Possible Alternatives
ŽŽŽ
/ŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽWZŽ
ŽWŽŽŽ
ZŽŽŽ tW E
E
EKZ/ZZ
dŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Brainstorming Results (1 of 7) d
Ž
^
>Ž
/
^Ž
dŽ
^
ŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽ
Ž
Ž
x
ŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
Ž
x
ŽŽŽŽ x
ŽŽEZ
Ž x
^Ž
x
^Ž
Ž
ŽŽ
WZŽŽŽ x
Ž
ŽŽ
Ž DŽŽ
ŽŽ
ZŽŽŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽ
Ž
Ž
x DŽŽŽ
ŽEZŽ x
^Ž
ŽŽŽ
Ž>^^Ž
,^^
x
Ž
ŽŽ
Ž DŽŽ
ŽŽ
DŽŽ
ŽŽ DŽŽ
ŽŽ
x DŽŽ&Ž
ŽŽ
Ž>^^Ž,^^
x
ŽEZŽ x
Ž
ŽŽ
Ž DŽŽ
ŽŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Brainstorming Results (2 of 7) d
Ž
^
>Ž
/
Ž
Ž
Ž
Ž
Ž>^^Ž,^^
ŽŽŽ x
DŽŽ
ŽŽ
x
ŽŽEZ
Ž x
Ž
ŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽ
ŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽŽ
Ž^^
ŽŽZ/^
Z/^
x DŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
Ž
Ž
Ž
x
ŽEZŽ
ŽŽ
ŽZ/
ŽZ//^/
ŽdZ
/ŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
Ž
D
ŽZZŽ,^^
x DŽ
Ž
Z/ZZŽ
Ž
x
^Ž
x
^Ž
Ž
x EŽŽŽ
DŽŽ
ŽŽ
x DŽŽ
ŽŽ
E /
x EZŽ
x
ŽŽ
Ž
Ž
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Brainstorming Results (3 of 7) d
Ž
^
>Ž
/
hŽŽŽ/&WZ
h
ŽŽ/&WZ
ŽŽŽ hZ'Ž/&
WZ&Z
>Z
ŽŽŽŽ
E /
x
x
&Ž
&> Z&
ŽŽ x
ŽŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽ
x
E /
Ž^^
,^^Zt
EZŽ
ZŽŽŽ
Ž
tŽŽŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽ
ŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽŽ
Žt
Ž
&> Z&ŽŽ
ZtŽ
,^^tW
ŽŽ
h/&WZ
Ž
ŽŽ h/&WZ
ŽŽ
Ž
W> Z&
x
Ž
ŽŽ
WZ
Ž
x
ŽŽEZ
Ž x
dŽ
Ž
Ž^
dZ
x
>Ž
Ž
ŽŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Brainstorming Results (4 of 7) d
Ž
^
>Ž
/
h/&WZ
Ž
ŽŽ
E /
h/&WZŽ
Ž
E /
ZtŽ
x
ŽŽ
Ž
WZŽ x
dŽ
Ž
Ž^dZ
x
>ŽŽ
EZŽ
x Z
Ž
ŽŽ
h/&WZŽ
ŽŽ
h/&Ž
Ž
x
ŽŽ
Ž
WZŽ x
dŽ
Ž
Ž^dZ
x
>ŽŽ
EZŽ
x Z
Ž
x ZŽŽ
Ž
ZŽ
h/&WZŽ
ŽŽ
Ž
h/&Ž
Ž
Ž
&> Z&y
>^^
x
ŽŽ
Ž
WZŽ x
dŽ
Ž
Ž^dZ
x
>ŽŽ
EZŽ
x Z
Ž ZŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Brainstorming Results (5 of 7) d
Ž
^
>Ž
/
h/&WZŽ
ŽŽ
Ž
h/&Ž
Ž
Ž&
> Z&y>^^/
W> ZW x
Ž
ŽŽ
WZ
Ž
Y
x dŽ
ŽŽ
^dZ
x
>ŽŽ
EZŽ
x Z
Ž ZŽ
Ž
Ž
ŽŽ
'ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
&
, >ŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽ
x Z
Ž
ŽŽ
x
ŽŽ
Ž
^
ŽŽ
Ž
Ž
W
'WŽŽ
&, >W
WdWŽŽ
x Z
Ž
ŽŽ
x
^Ž
x
^Ž
ŽŽ
ŽWZ
ŽŽŽ
x ZEZŽ
x
ŽŽ
Ž
^
ŽŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Brainstorming Results (6 of 7) d
Ž
^
>Ž
/
Ž,ŽŽ
hZ/
/^/Ž^D
ŽE hEŽ
Ž x
^
x
Ž x
EŽŽŽ
x EŽŽŽŽ
x
ŽŽ/^/
YZZ
x WŽŽŽ
&/'^tZ>
x ZEZŽ
x ZŽŽ
^Ž
DŽŽŽ
^D Ž
EŽ
ŽŽ
hE
ŽŽ
Ž
<
&> Z&
Ž x
^
x
Ž
x DŽŽ
h^
Ž x
EŽŽŽ
EŽŽ
W^ŽEŽ
x EŽŽ&Ž > Z&
Ž ŽŽŽŽ
x DŽŽŽ
x EEZŽ
^Ž
DŽŽŽ
EŽ
ŽŽ
W> ZW
Ž hE
ŽŽ
Ž
W> ZWŽ
/Ž
&> Z&Ž x
^
x
Ž
x DŽŽ
h^
Ž x
dŽ
x
^
Ž
x
,ŽŽ
x
ŽŽ
x DŽŽŽ
x EEZŽ
^Ž
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Brainstorming Results (7 of 7) d
Ž
^
>Ž
/
hZ//^/Ž
^D ŽEŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽ
hEŽ
ŽŽ
Ž
Ž
x
^
x
Ž
x DŽŽh^
Ž x
ZEZ
Ž
x DŽŽ
Ž
^Ž
hZ//^/Ž
^D ŽE
ŽŽŽ
Ž
ŽŽ
ŽŽ
hEŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽ
Ž
x
^
x
Ž
x DŽŽh^
Ž x
ZEZ
Ž
x DŽŽ
Ž
^^
0DQ\\RIWKHEUDLQVWRUPLQJLGHDVZHUHIXUWKHUH[SORUHGEXWLWZDV
GHWHUPLQHGWKDWGHYHORSLQJDKROLVWLFDSSURDFKWRUHIOHFWWKHVFRSHRI
ZDVWKHPRVWHIIHFWLYHSDWKIRUZDUG
0DQ\\RIWKHEUDLQVWRUPLQJLGHDVZHUHIXUWKHUH[SORUHGEXWLWZDV
GHWHUPLQHGWKDWGHYHORSLQJDKROLVWLFDSSURDFKWRUHIOHFWWKHVFRSHRI
ZDVWKHPRVWHIIHFWLYHSDWKIRUZDUG
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Overview dŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
3/4 ^ŽW &
3/4 ^ŽW,^^^^
3/4 ŽŽŽŽ
,^^
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Prerequisites dŽŽŽ
ŽŽWŽ ZŽWŽZŽŽ ZŽWŽŽŽŽŽ ZŽWŽŽŽŽŽ
ZŽWŽŽŽ WŽDŽŽŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Pre-determined set of HSS systems/subsystems consisting of:
ZŽŽŽW
Ž WŽŽŽŽ
Ž
^'& Ž
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
Ž
<ŽŽZt^d
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽWtZ
Ž
WtZŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
,/^>KŽŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Pre-determined set of HSS systems/subsystems consisting of:
EŽ
,^^
W
ŽŽŽ
ZŽŽŽWŽ
Ž>ZŽŽ
^Ž
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽZ/^
ŽŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽZWŽŽZWsŽ
ŽŽŽŽZWsŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽŽZWsŽŽ
ŽŽŽZWsŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
&ZZ//^/Z/ZZ
^ŽŽŽWtZ
,^^Ž
>^^ŽŽE /ŽŽ
,^^Ž,^^
ŽŽŽŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Pre-determined set of HSS systems/subsystems consisting of:
EŽ
,^^
W
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽEW^EŽ
ŽWtZŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽZ/
ZŽ
Z/ZZ
,
^ŽŽŽ,^^
ŽŽŽ
Ž>^^ŽWZ
ŽŽEW^EŽ
ŽŽK
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
&ZZ/
,
dŽ
Ž Y
^ŽŽŽ,^^
Ž>^^ŽWZ
WŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽh,^ŽEŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽŽ,^^
Ž
ŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
dŽŽ
ŽŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Pre-determined set of HSS systems/subsystems consisting of:
EŽ
,^^
W
ŽŽŽ
dŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽZt^dŽWtZŽŽŽŽ
tZ
Ž
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
EŽ
Ž^Žd^dŽ&t &tWtZ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ&t &tŽ
Ž
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
EŽ
&ŽWtZŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
Ž&ŽŽŽŽŽ
ZŽ
t
>^^
ŽŽŽ DŽŽ
WZ
ŽŽŽt
ŽŽWtZ
,Ž
ŽŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽ
Ž
ŽWZŽ
ŽŽŽ
DŽŽ>
Ž
ŽŽ
ŽŽŽ/&
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Pre-determined set of HSS systems/subsystems consisting of:
EŽ
,^^
W
ŽŽŽ
K, /ŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
/ŽŽŽŽ
Ž,^^>^^
ŽŽ
Ž^tŽŽ
ŽŽ
Ž^tŽŽ
ŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽŽ
& ŽŽŽŽŽ
> Z&
ŽŽWZŽ
Ž
ŽŽd
ŽEŽŽŽ
ŽEZŽ
E^Ž
ŽZ/Ž
ŽŽ
^Ž EŽŽŽ^Z
Ž
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Pre-determined set of HSS systems/subsystems consisting of:
EŽ
,^^
W
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽ&
ŽŽ&ŽŽ
ŽWŽŽŽŽ
ŽWZŽ
Ž
ŽŽ
ŽZ/Ž
ŽŽ
^Ž
/ŽŽ
ZŽŽ
ŽŽ&
W
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽ> Z&
ŽŽ> Z&ŽŽŽ> ZW
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽWZŽ
Ž
ŽŽ
ŽZ/Ž
ŽŽ
^Ž
/ŽŽ
ZŽŽ
ŽŽ&
W
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Plant-Specific Outlier Evaluation 7KLVZLOOHQVXUHSODQWVSHFLILF+66RXWOLHUVDUHFDSWXUHGLQWKH
(QKDQFHG&DWHJRUL]DWLRQ3URFHVV
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Additional Confirmatory Evaluations ZŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽŽŽŽ
tZ^
WtZ E
/
ŽŽ
WZ/ZŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
Enhanced Methodology Summary W,^^
ŽZŽ^
ŽŽŽŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
ŽŽŽ
Ž&Ž Ž
/Z/^ŽŽ^
ŽŽ
Ž WZ/ZŽ
dŽ
WŽZ//
w w w. e p r i. c o m
TogetherShaping the Future of Electricity