ML19276H265

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Transcript of Affirmation Session 79-23 on 790809 in Washington,Dc
ML19276H265
Person / Time
Issue date: 08/09/1979
From: Hendrie J
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:
References
REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 7910160435
Download: ML19276H265 (6)


Text

O s

1.

c,: s,,

.,._.,.-,e..

wa w

a

.. g a a., g n:

  • qa

==., 4 a A :: s

m. u..a $

.e.e g..

,..m.: _:. n, a.2. _'

_,.,.c, 6

. v i

4. '

--; v e _.

-.n.

.. -..i s.n O.. s.,;..

  • n.. e,... ^ m...... 4 a.e, i,,..

%..,e _* 4

. n3,a %A 3,,

9 A,,CUSu 7g, y m*

r,.

<m.. e r.,

4aa.w4..

n a

1,_-.

u...o _ _. _
v. 4 J

4 4::

u u,

, _,.. 4 S,, s a-v--,oa a

mw4

-,S,,.,..,.4 v

Sc.-

.2.4O..

-k

-.2

,u

-p,

, -,. w 1 4 -

a 3 _ _4 m C e nC e,.

2, fu a<

s

- 4a#,

'.'..',_'_'~"'.~'.'aA,

's_"

  • A 4 ~.= A,
    • d

_4 _-

..a v ".'..'."4..

'. a.c.

..v**

~

a a e

.e.3,

,,_3C4 a.

2 1

s, n a _a n. n e.

n g n.e__v..e..'.

_z. ~. n.n.....e.- o u = -.

. ~

m.%, e.

- 2,. 3,n. _ a., _.-

.e... s.... A. a ;

-y-s n.:.

u. a

_g.....,.*.

9 - e,- -.7 4 43A h_..

_n SQ C,.1 n,. },

_4 &.

4. a-r.,,

4

_, n.. 4.

w 3,, g.e a_ a.

.n a f.s a

y -- y

-~4,.

--4d_

m., _:

.u. a

..g a., e.

.e. w g.e a, -.

-- g.,-aao

.e.

.-.,= a

,.,...-- - =

-A

. _: a=...-:

e

._v.

y-

-u

..n...a n a S 2.. i.'.. va:~an-1 4.. = ~-

e...
u., =

_, n...z.

v. _e - - An n, y :

a n

a

., p

4. s a.
v. 0

'y' '_ 6 ". # _'.". ';'*

v'~

0",".".'.~.

" a,C a.". ~..."'j* N,

- - _' c '#

e

=, _ m... 4

..-s..o r o.

y

-,., C a e;- ;.,,.,, d s u. e.,,. a :2 u -

p.:.:. a n c ;.-

..'u e.,...., a a :

=..

s

.. e

., a n

y-a -...... -

a ".V, s '.." " a "..e..

v

    • ~"'...a7'-

O.". *..= _#.".a d.

".. e " a.d.".,

A,..v. ~a c "y -

.A S

  1. ~. a

~

^

z

%',',s, 4.-.. _ a a.4.,., I,.

.=.,. n t,

d,b..* h A, =* 4 ar a *

. j 4.

w

/

il

!i 2

i i

1 I

1l UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

..,Ro 3 5 0 2l NUCLEAR REGULATORY CO.T12SSION 3'

l PUBLIC MEETING 4I i

AFFIRMATION SESSION 79-23 i

5' t

i 6'

Room 1130 1717 H Street, N.

W.

t 7

Washington, D.

C.

8 Thursday, 9 August 1979 9

The Co=ission met, pursuant to notice, at 11:50 a.m.

10

337093, II '

DR. JOSEPH M.

HENDRIE, Chairman I2 VICTOR GILINSKY, Comissioner 13 J RICHARD T.

KENNEDY, Commissioner

., :1

:1 PETER A.

BRADFORD, Comissioner

. e,a JOHN F. AHEARNE, Comissioner i

16 i /_LSO PRESENT :

,1 e

  • 7

,1 Messrs. Biokwit, Ostrach, Snyder, and Chilk.

.I lb i

19,

I 20 -

21 ! lij

'l 22 U l

,,t'

= =' !

2A f

..=,w, a..m r.ert. me. i

s

vi

,; 3 s v.

. 1 :'

.s

.~s :. w :. i n:M6 is.r.eonaTo7 3, Q *:6 nee 2 L,:~.:~.. w..

af

?

.. m, e.n... 2..: ;

3 C.,. ' ii 5S I ON E: 35IECM:

I believe so,.fr. Cnairman.

e C.-i A I R..;AN H::iD R I E :

Sam, am I c.oina. to have an 5

affirT.ation session er cisCussion?

~.

r-Arr,rmation.

u. t.. 7.,-. ( m.,., eni_A:

o ie:1

c., u i

c.m,, :.. - l e. a....... 3..1:.u. : ::

t.;c w e n e e d n, = _:

s..

i ka n )....:.: s.p. )..,.:;

.. D v..-

.d. =..e.c s a n.u.w. ". o ".

."i.>. n ' =. s s

.s y

-e.on.4on.

u...,.

4 -

s...

u_

7 u.

.2.

--m.

s.

.'t.

...i

. c.n. :. i c :

., 1 1 rignt.

If we can come to O rc e r asin.

,; e nava noc. an affirmation se ssion in nand.

c.,

s. 2,.

u.,, o u v.9

.c v

s..

c..

.o o-.

e

, o-u..,.. a c, t ua :.4 u n 1.,.r. :

2n., s i s an a:.. irma tion or. the I-

_ tem one order cistriouted to "ou by the general counsel on

.....,.. =.cu nesoe-ad - = v ' a-4.'. a.

4.,,

.. _.,.,, e.

...,3.

. m.

..,m. r.
.,,'u.'.."

. ~ ^.,, v' 's

^"

.C

-,,..i.~.

.O.'" a u". 4 v' '." v"' on t.."

.c a..t = H = V,.

'-'s "o

1-l 'i On= 03 sic orOer that /cC,re be.ng as.KeC. t o B T! i r~ii.

z i.ce_ 979 the gSnerG., Coun sel Cay haVe Wnat a Unce rs tanc

-I are sCOe Cinor Changes WhiCh he Will relate to oU.

u;:y.,t:v-(nlea-s' t L-.w.

t nave had a chance to c

.u...

it a

2i relate to sorte of :n3 corni ssioners the changes.

I could 22 run through, hem culckly, if that is what you would lika or 23 you coul: take y narc c:1at they are minor, with one 2-exception.

.'.n d I ns t

.s Ccmmissioner Bractoro's croocsed

.- -.i.3 o.

o u n n,/ o.

s eo. c.._.,,,,, _,

=

a

,.n., 2.,

2.,,.

.a.

D D

r D' Q] g 9

o wu 3..

,um

s

~

.C p your gcing af f firmetion on cne as trer.

--: nere a.7 so i s a comma here and v.m n, I.,., o s

...,t=

r. = u u.,.
v...

3 a cetrer worc tnere at tne last minute.

I can't neec to see those.

~

uJ. &,I 5c ita,.r n,

x m,lELf:

I nave alreacy chec<ec. them a

and f ounc them satisf acto ry, and I agree with the sentence WJ1C n LorGi sslOne r drad?o rO N1snes to aC.

i 00.'l.tI 5S IGNER CHII_a:

All of the commissioners have t he n egree; witn the casic order, and t..e c hange s i

!O r ecommencec oy..ir.

Sradf o rd, you qualified your a cceptance 11 oy no ting his enange wi thout objection.

I would ask you to n +. +..; r. m..

13 CHAIPMAh HENDRIE:

Thos e in f a :ror ?

i,

( A c horu s of ayes.)

15 00;.. 4 I 55 IO.!ER.<5:::!EDY :

In coing so, let me note, 16 however, I went to note a particularly egregious article in 17 the Wasnington Post Inis morning which wa s unf ortuna tely Ie inaccurate.

I would like to read the sentence to which the 1v article was addressed, the sentence in -he order being 20 diametrically opposec to that view given in the Washington 21 Pcst.

22 I reac, n.'hile real and suostantial concern attaches to 23 issues such as psychclogical distre ss and others arising 2-from the continuing impact of the Three Mile Island accident 25 cr.related to expc sure to radiation to One cititens living

./

..: i

,,,,3 o.., R.< n e,,

.d n,. ww..s

.e..

..a 2 y.i.= n.,

..,,.,o s, w

...e.e... i.

S ow

<=-e s,,,,

v.

.w

.....e. r

.e..e...-

,s n.

1 e..,. a..'.'s,.

m.1,s y e n s o,."..'.<., C '" O C o. a. '.'.'..'.'1 v.c.. "

.e.,....

a i.2

.,. i.,,i 9,..,

As.-3.

.-.. m,3 4,..,, a S.e. 4,, n

t..w.a w

.-.,3

,2-. -. D c. v e a

w.n 2.. y.

GE6 Oden dec.ae' in E.'.e dr.2-.ac<Ve.

I '.liSh Sim, ole to note 5

.nat it has not 1.: e c n

.f s e i ce c.

I would t ope that our me.T.oers

..., 1 d n.s. e rio w.i Ce.

cc.

2-

- i. s,

-.2.e. s c. *.:.

v.-

w.6-a,.

. o...... t I

CD

".'I 5510; d.-

J a..d:~J R; :

I agrs-9 Wi th taa t TeaCinQ.

~.sia l.y. s a

.1.:..., :.,. _. g y a../

g,., a.

s -

r-4 y

.~

,.e s

.. a i 2.,3

.m_,-

2

,i... ;..

n.e....a

. avl.

es-v.

o v... o.

v.

v u

i

-,...<.s.

w.a. g. 7 2..:.~~.,, c.,.

c.! s g.

T a u,.s,.- s,., -...;, h..

_e, - ;

a.,.

] -.

.r.n..

a t

_. i s

' >... '.1 0 v i b, v. --::

.s c e. 6

.J f 1 T. e O g a'.a d b e c a U S e i ~. 4 s

,.,.s,

...q.

.i

!Z

.': i a i n E n.;;1. s h.

~' h e tord n o t " has only one meaning to

'e,

4aan,

. i

c..o.

e a n.4. n S vr a

3., c_.,

.w.C....s E v,

.e., 0-. :......i,.,.

. s/ a.

.J g

< i w

u y. -

.. c.,,a. J

-. 2, -. :. 44. 4,. y a e i,

-. 4 -... '.

.2 i-

  • J**O J."...'l*

V. c. ; i 1 m..e. m.

-.. n o.-

.h.e, e..,.

L.

m..ae m..u......l..'.c i-u e

.s.

2 4.

.m.- =..

..a

,,,,,..t.a a: I u..,...:.,

.,a cu t' :

I aiways :ut :nea bacn

.,y..., - n u

.y-.

., e,;.

Iy Co..i.dI SS IONE? OI LINSKY :

Of Cot:rse, in c ao.i. e s the y 23 put not, repeat not.

2!

CO?.PUSSIONER AH?ARNE:

You understand w."y.

22 COlC.iI SS IONER KENNEDY :

It may be that in the 23 ratura we're going to have to do that.

2-CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:

Okay.

C T.tm".- c. e.r o.s.

a-m...ir '

.'.h a

~.v.. = s e s

."..o Df" D

P D "U TU h, ((

L d

o o

i

a es a~

o a ! f i r!.~.a t i o n 0 9 d r i n g.

I 4

LT. A l tt.o.a nn.. ) t I :

-.Anat co"ip., e te s tne S,!1rCa tion n.

3 session.

I </cuic as4 :ne co.7missioners if they could please stay for ancther snort s e ssion.

I had scheculedcontinuation o

of :ne cudge t markup se ssions ' oth at this time f or ano ther c

o apcroximately 45 ninute s and also f or this af terncon.

It 7

seems to me that we eti 1 no t n eed tnis af terncon's mee ting, c

snd I can'; propose to need anytning more than a fet m inu te s

..4 2 _c

,4.,,.

7 1

( Jine re u pen, :ne

. ear ing ela s con cluced at !I: 57 Ii a.. '.., Au:;us; v,

I979.)

0 E I3 a

f/

$0 I:

l.-

V i 7 i c 17 20 2i 4m 23 u

25