ML19276B292
| ML19276B292 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 04/12/1984 |
| From: | Feldman C NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REGULATORY RESEARCH (RES) |
| To: | Schwink W NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO) |
| References | |
| TASK-CE-902-1, TASK-RE NUDOCS 8405160084 | |
| Download: ML19276B292 (3) | |
Text
.
R-2516 RES Task No.: CE-902-1 Return to: 1130 SS APR 121984
!Tt CP/WJH FCE: Ualter S. Schwint, Pepienal Onoraticos enc Generic Recuirerents Staff, GEDO TFRU:
reith 0. Steyer, Chief, Cl er ical Ergineerit;p l'rench Division of Encineering Technology, DES FI'CH:
Carl Felcr.an, Chemical Encineerirm trench Division of Engineering Technolegy, FES Scr' JECT :
CI.G FEVIEF 0F PP0 POSED PULE CU.CEh!IEG DECl M ISSlH lfG CRITERIL FOR MICLEAP FACILITIES This is in response to cortents en the preposed rule subreitted to you by CIC in a t'erch 16,19N r-erorandor).
This docurent vcs reviewed by EES anc resolution of corvert s concerning the reoplatory analysis war discussed in deteil by staf f of PES and CtC (Cerl Feldrnan ene Sid Feld) and resulted in tbe follcwing agreenent.
(1) CBG corrent P. 2, Fnd line: CAG states that "f ecilities licensed order Parts 50 and 72 (Type 1 Licenses) will recuire significant co-cnrrnissionino of forts and thts, the new tecorarissioning requircnents vill be f elt rest heavily by these licensecs."
PES corrent: t>e are unccrtain what is irplied here.
FES agrees that deccroissioning ef f orts f cr Type 1 licensees (particularly ter rentr reacter licensees) will be more significant than those for lype 2 licensees.
- bowever, we do not acree that new cecorrissioning rule recuirernents will be f elt vnst heavily by lyre I licensees. Feneral decSwissioning rule receirerents arc aircedy in place.
The new rule rskes these reouirerents rsere explicit and of ficient in terrs of irplercntation bot h for the licensee end f*C staf f and would ten! to recuce overell decerrissionino irrect.
(2) C/G corrent P. 2, Sth line: CAC indicates flat the cost analysis for lyne 1 licenses ignores ccsts to 55 knove applicants (50 power rcactor enes ane 5 Part L cres).
PES corrent:
Part 72 already has all requirements in it.
The amended rule sipply retes Part 72 rscre consistent in forcat with arendrents to other Perts. Therefore, no aeditional ccst analysis is reovired fcr Part 72 applicants.
There are currently L? (and 7 edditional CP's) power reactor applicants whict. were 8405160084 840412 RES SUBJ R2516
,,c,,
CF sunwaner k
..a..
w.>
une rom m no m nacu ouc OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
.b APR 1219S4 Fr. Sctoirt p
left cut of tie cost enalysis brceuse, based on larea carcelleticts of rou+ r re ct ors, it res orcert ain hew reny ecule rerain arrlicent s.
Lt 5 anre es, boi+ver ther noe accress in this crea is reasonable ere vill essore that bl4 cr 20 erplicents rroain ar.c will ir:clude cost eralysts f tr these e;plicent s in the recelatory arelysis and accorparyino rule pattepe es applicatlo.
(3) C/r cervert P. 4, i t er-1:
Tie cost of cevelrpine end r etlistir o reculatory cuides Felpful for roic irplerontaticn is not intloded in the ccst e stiratc.
Df S cornot : Peoeletery caides shoule be de velcced recorcless of >*et ter rtilr erendrerts Oere ortresee t rcbuse recre t yplicit cuidance to Lcth license (s arc LTC stat t is rreced in the areas of finercial assorer.cr ard f acilitetion and in the particulars of ubet shev1d be included in cecorrissioning plennirp.
(c) rt0 cos.rrnt, P.
4, iter ?: Ser e corr ent as nt. Ler (P).
PT S corrent: Sue corrent as ror her (2).
(t) rtr ccrr ent, P.
4, iten-3:
The cost of ordetir9 f?SS licensee f uroirio r,lans i es ret bern prorr rly ecccuoted f or ir. fiC cost irpact.
Pf 5 corrent:
It is r,ot cypected tlat fuadinc rien creatt reviews t'y f PC tmuld be very sicnificent 200 would prirerily te besed on censideretir ns of inflation, lhe rajor rt view of the forcire plan woulc have tun done initielly wit hin t he first five years (e.o., licensee renewal).
It tuture renewals (every five years) a fondino plar would recuire tepdatirg.
Feu ver, et tt is tiro ef ficier>cv of tfC staf f t cold be optir al sirce review of all esrects of liter. sire woulc t e recoirea.
PES reccenizes ttat r entico et i4f irrects at licensee rert wal t'einc irsionificent d as cr itt ed end will be inclun d errrrrrietcly.
(fi) Ctr corr cot. P. C, 3rd rereerc[ h:
Eer0 ceFr er ts as f cr it er.s (2) cnd (E), but for licensee.
PL5 corrert :
Sere as ccrr-ents for ite rs (2) ar!c (5) bt:t f or licensee.
(7) Ctf cor rgent, P. 7, f irst rAraoreph:
The C/0 acrees that trie ircrerental cost to rever react er licensees cf rrovidion f ondino essorance is 7ero (assertino f unds rarn the real crpcmcity cost of rorey) l'ut since the coller recoirercot is so leroe, it steule be explicitly developed are expleirec in t Fe reculetcry erel3 sis.
PES corrent; in corres to cyplein in the regulatory analysis oby ti+
revel reert er f undine essorence ret r anise. is not considerec sicnificar;t, even t hc,uch tet el dellers it volved are larte, omcq sura ^=r)
DATE k unc ronu m. m eo unc" "
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY
APF< 121984 Pr. 5ctvir k (U) ( / 0 cor rtr.t, P. 7, l est re recr at h:
fereer(rt Statt litersirr cests I a ve not t+rn account ed fcr.
H.S ccre ent : (n P. 23. Scttien 4.1.F.P, it is incicetec whet ccst irpects are ryrerted f or / r ret rert States.
Ibis vill 6150 it sere rcre explic1t in ctier apprcpriete places, esr ecially in 16 tile ? deelir.9 wit h f10 costs.
(9) C/4 corrrrt, P. 8:
1re reculatory analysis does not explicitly ederess ccsts to tre puHic ard the ir. cit'slen cf costs to the poblic in the renulatory eralysis would constitute a dothie cruntinc.
Pt S coerent : i?f 5 ccrees with these cou+nts and u111 clerify this in t he sertien en Costs to the P0blic.
It will alsc explicitly J cir,t cet t he rejor rott orial cest to ite FLblic that crres f ree a lack et fir.ancial itst rar ct resultir4 in 6 litersee's inet ility tc recorrissicr. er,c resulting In a public t ur cer'.
Carl Feldman Chemical Engineering Branch Division of cngineering Technology Office of Nuclear Regulatory Research Distribution:
RES RDG/ ALPHA CEBR RDG/SUBJ bec:
G. A. Arlotto L. C. Shao K. G. Steyer C. Feldman
.R(S;h,C[Bp.,,
= t>
.RE_S:,EBR,
d
$"""*"'>.fe.l.dm[ bh..
KGSt,'__,_,,,
can ) 4/11/.84 4/..///.84.....
une roaa aio no oo, unc"
OFFICIAL RECORD COPY