ML19275B589
| ML19275B589 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 12/05/1979 |
| From: | Smith I Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | Sholly S AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7912180082 | |
| Download: ML19275B589 (6) | |
Text
p nauq fw
-t UNITED STATES
- '~
'j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION i
5 ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD PANEL
?, * *
,8 WASHIN GTON, D.C. 20555 December 5, 1979
'\\
<P$h
.#y cc Mr. Steven C. Sholly 9
Y cTe *[$
'8 304 South Market Street g
Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania 17055 Re:
Metropolitan Edison Company (Three Mile Isiand Nuclear Station, Unit No. 1)
Docket No. 50-289 (Restart)
Dear Mr. Sholly:
Please submit a retyped version of your Contention 6 pursuant to the discussion at Tr. 563-567.
Very truly yours, W
Ivan W. Smith Board Chairman cc:
Docketing & Service /
Section (for service) 791218o OT>1 Cr
)-c..')
.I
.B J...
2.
n,
. :I
- e-
- r.-l,..;. c.,.,.. _:...... s..;..- -,., 4... 2 4. g,
- 4., - - 4 r,a w...
9 iI
<.. i..*,...
, :.... s.1 4.
e s.-. e w -
.fc.4.
C _/:
p.2
, a,,.
6 E
_n
- c. c,..,g e..
- g.. p.4.. s..
i
.a.
- ...s
.....~
N..
e.
'7 [
, f i. _.,..,
.2
- s.., -. 4 *_. D.>
-- _- c.
_i +
.; u.
.A_
-. 4 n..,.t.'
' 3 ' V *_ ~3 6
- _- I.'6 '. '-
,n. r..-. a... e, s
s 3
c
.a.,...,...h.,..
c,3._.,s.4. r. c y...
- h. m-.:.
_4.e. +.w e.. ~_%_ u s _ c _4 e 'v. _
_.s e
i i.
e., 1
.e.,,..- yc.,
c,, e.
. _,.., ;.,,. 3 6,
(..,
,..,4
_u_ e u.
t l
.4..,..
f
- a.. 3....
.. wy
~
I 10 '
...,:.. 4 '.,,, r...... <... i.. u41
.4v C'13.i.a..m..'..a'.
C4.."
e
-4 I.
i e..
n.
.., w.. e....... ;. l.
t
....a. s.
.*(
,,. a.. _.. t :
a a
~
- b. %.,..3.
- c.. G i_. O
_4 3,
3,if 3..
.Js A
0 -. -.
w n,..
.,.,s.
4.
w f.n 6
g a, d
w.s... 7 J. p 6....*
-.. y s.
w..
jw w
.e
. { =6..'. m_.
.3..,2...wc..p*
.'.',,J..
f..;.,,. b.4.
..s.
w
- l. o I8.-
....3..
,...-.'}
g f,,.
s.. 4. _s.,
..O
... ).Q.. 4.
a A 1.J.4.C s,. C.{. s.,
- i.
u
=
9.
g*
,..-.e..
s
,i ll
- 3.,
e.s
.s.
, a. _..,
3.. v 4.i, n Cra 3
c._:O.4 Ua 4.4.
,J.i 3. _-
s y.2.
i.,f 1.e.
c-us s.3 4.
- . i.- -.-
e, o.1 a.
.a n
C.
1 n...,,,., 3. s.,_ a, c.4.
.,c_ S _.c,_ n.
w.
s s.
w.:r_. v.
s.e.a....- -
e s./.v...:....
e-
- *a n_
},C.a a u 4. e
.s.w.at f.s. A. :.: C3. 4.
- t. -
4 g,f g
,v
-s
\\@
D
,.., s.:
_ayw n_,
_ o.g
_44 i.w o en >.. Ca,,u.-$1 #c..
't'
- 3..,..,...
s N,,
. ~ _
m
~
S M" [s, //. ll 4
13,., and E,
'.2 =hrid.go and cec 11 it can be subnitted i:
.y
~ -
2 an agret e,c
~
, pq
'o ngs :,., g,,. :
- n.,
g s
h ((n 9,
- -: >.. T5M..2 :
I can : un it '..hrough right nov.
I i
b 4
tt i
nj
- 1cvc e ve:.f ge:S idea cf what I 1 Ent it te be and in fact, i; i
I 4,<.
2,. 4. s-
- c.., t y--', -'. "
.e.'_.'_
'. v, _4 t.
g[
.~
f 9
%,,,.2:
. m..._c :
v.cc wen-.: ::c c.e :..: m ;?
4 n
a...,
v_..
v, 2
"tl' d.
i 1.I
a 4
i
->i 564
~i['
,..- -y. s.. ua.
.e.. C.c.
I g
2
.'e.. SDCLL ':
I h:.r e n : 2 *. d : cannes to ;c' ' ' '--
3 vriting and gat it sent out.
4 m7tLGH SE"H:
Give i'. a g
d if it doesn' t 5
work, meyba you can do it during an i=*-'hsics.
S
.G. SECLLY :
Very well.
7 Cantantics G, the last partgraph er the last sen-8}
tenec ss it stands right =cw says:
i Gl'
'It is furths: centended that -Lhe shcrt-10
+r'-~' c=t! 01s itzutified i
- n A sicu*z orde:
If and notics of hearing datsd 9 Aug$st 1979 ara 12 issufficien: to previde the reccisite reascrabia 12 !
assurasse of c;s:stien without tads =gering public
}
l 11 [
h'ialt. anc Ca:St"f. "
}
]
15l I onld replace that with the fc11cving :
i 16 i "It is ft:ther conMrd*4 W-t.he short-17 ta_:n acti:nc identified in the '"* sion's c dar
- e_
!a,
and notice of hearing ds==d 9 August.1979 are t
,\\
m
- ' f2 i ins fficiant to orovida the recuisite r - ~ =h'-
..t D,
4 dsEEM O hoe 7I On Yee
.me % [
} =% l g?
^
4.I i}
- n.. z[3 -
^
...... _.p..
g
. ' 21 health and safety bac=nne
- Lase eb -M av 'm g y.,..m, g
. -. <. r --
3 7, _ wg., g
~3
. u g. _,4. = 9. g.g=., ' gg.,,
3T%
.7 '.
do not ino'-6e 'Sa Ech.=g it=nr m.:
~ - : *f, '.
n 1
3._
m-~
.e.
.f. t..g [
~..
=,...
f%.
...n.
CHKOCGN SMI'23:
~dmit a ci=nts Eculd you alcw n
-s
-g(
}
g,
' d.=a. '1.)
m Q f *.. *
- -: v.-.
t
- 6
~,.5 C
,. _y
1; 5.? S 1 '.;;
...... !i..... m.. :
C.
y,
.Jc11. -;-h.3 e z.: a dir2 0t'. i i:ca e - !.,
q,
/.
a
~
~"
~ 1,-
.v.*
bac17. c:. : cp c 3.c n e :..:.Iv. n 1 a.: L...-
-.........a....
. u.a
'i
.3 'j befy of the cc:. ten:. c.
A CHAIRMAN SF.ITH:
Se then ycu're going to start 5
back up with A, B, C, and D?
6 MR. SHOGT : Yes, sir.
7 CHAIRTJ SMIT!!:
So I draw an arrow frem "becaune' l
S up to A.
I 9
MR. SEOGY:
I discus. cad--
Well, here I'll go 10 through them ned then we'll talk ahcut the.m.
11 CHAIRICd! SMITH:
Okay.
12 MR. SEOI.LY:
"A" is a requirc=cnt fcr a failure 12 meds and effects analysis of the integrated c00trcl systc.
1.;
i to be nuhr.itted to the ti?.C Staff fc: revic.3 er.d 6.pproval.
15 C H A I P E di U.".Z T H :
Well, wait a minu.2.
I grass I t-j$
d1Can O uncer3 tant.1.
17 MR. SEOEY:
That's the only one which is not in 15 that listing in the basis.
It's desc-ihed immediately 19 beforn'that listing.
2 2D GAIRMAN SMITH:
All right.
21 MR. SHOGY : The rc:2nining four are on that list.
22 B is a cc pletion of instrumentation installatics 23 for detection of inadequate core cooling.
C, ccmpletion of installation of hydrogen ga:
3 j [d centrol penetraticas of the contain=snt,
' l I
\\s
.e
..b O
e.
f
?
- .c :
1 j
C. r.w-4 aw of tre basis fer race-ssiner tisa.
., g 3
a
?-
- .nf. I. co. ne&. ion of i r.allshion of a high-range
)
j I
3l rMi x.cti; *: s.fflu It monitor sys- =.
l i
4 hu u e the five issu+s which I raised in my j
I 5'
basis discussion.
l 5
ME. i'ccw;grar;3:
yr, ch.'mL I t.*cu.lf. he. satisfied 7
sith the record as it now s4 %, showing that *M =
b==
been 8
.W. Shc11y's in*-nt by the last aantence to refer enly to '.he 9
itans that he just ref2. W. to.
10 (The Beard confarr4ng.:.
n SIa. SHC'J,7:
Mr. Nhm, I Lve this typed cut 12 if that sculd help to clarify it.
1 MR. EC22DG-b I Jculd he very happy to have it 14 c= pied into *he r.scord.
15 NN MM-W er-cr is I depended upon 1
. s.
Id.mnses's stats =ent of the Petitiens 's cento rcion and in i
17
- " : inst:sca h t.as a mist h.
I gg ;
MR. TRGWM Tf:G2:
- 4r. ^ ^4 m n, we repeat caly the 3
.. __._ 19_ '
cont 2ntion and not c e W is.
M 4
- ti.5; gg CZAIRSlt SMITH
Scirstiass -
5..
MR. TC ~W71Yi"I'3: ' M ("wi nazi,~% !!!ey be%x2n f
} lgM m
"4
.3
- 1.. '.+ 34 Lic:nns.:.:;is. srdsni-esI von w.~.e-52
"_.le.e.:haveT h
~
i w
tst. tion 3 a.!id 'tNeit-tSGy haJtse through E.
.do not hr.va -
- i. 5.N. %. 24-I C:=tention 5 in thera.
T
.h ~-
l m
l A-
? 5, g,
- "R. O COEIDGE:
We do not have C.;>nic _ ion 6 in 1
-- x,...
1 4
7 i
567 i.
eb10 1ll ou l'
a 1
C~IAIR.T47 O!!Tih
!!o, it'c there.
3 L HR. TROWBisIDG* :
At the botten of paga 5 r.d on d
4 to pcgs 6.
t.
5 MR. Twx;r1J.OTS:
Oh, I'za scrry.
6 DR. LITTLE:
License:s's versicn hegina en the 7
Mi.s of page 5 and continces on to the top of page 6.
The 8
por on that Mr. Sholly is raferring to is in his statament e
s of his contentions, afts: -hic:., for each contention, he has to stated the basis for that centention and has them listed.
11 Correct?
12 '
MR. SHOLLY:
Yes.
The five items which I propose 12 to include in the bcdy of the contentien are now in the I
14 basis discussion.
15 [
MR. h" 7CI""E:
With that explanation, the 16 Staff has no objection, Mr. Chairman, c2 37 MR. SFOLLT:
Are we prepared to nove on?
l ggl CHAIRMAH SMI'"H:
Yes, sir.
4 i
t
}
~
19 t MR. SHOLI2:
As I understand it there is no 1 *+T[.,
. 20r
.i
- [
objection to r"--'
on 7.
x-
-s m
.A.. _
8-and 9 were objected totin part br,
.Idcensee
- b. A'))2t
..w w -
%- n a n d
ds is.with respect to revised' plan $ for emergencTM%
8
-C+2 &.
~-
~~ggi':.
4-p""N and radiation monitoring. _i-. qu..e '. der.;. y :_
_.a. f'$.
_423 q-- : :
4....
24, I;ECCOpI tb8 biCEEEOO ' E '.h*
'IO.
tbOEO 8
.x
{. q gj.[ u g centnations later, with a proviso that I woula have a so-day b
i "; 4 R
%W::
M