ML19263D206

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Responds to Telcon Questions Re Economic Consequences of NRC Facility Shutdown Order.Util Has Completed Required Shock 2 Reanalysis & with Exception of One Hanger Which May Need Reinforcing,Finds Sys Adequate
ML19263D206
Person / Time
Site: Maine Yankee
Issue date: 03/22/1979
From: Randazza J
Maine Yankee
To: Fine P
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 7903260282
Download: ML19263D206 (4)


Text

.'7_"%:CG;p.O.r.wq._,.W.qv.s.ygOyg35pt_.,r P usem w - ~ m~-.m 1

.~r

....-s....

.s 4,.

'* It i p

,h l..i

.. '. t,,, g i l ',.j " '

, (,,,c -

u.

s -

. = w...

....o

..w.h

.Jb.

E

't

g. M e M J*

rp.

M M\\

p'd***mosa.' #-

I

[Jg* ;f *]d3fE-N s9ZE27PETBi h wa, suas oci

.GED 5m=

gM A

! a' March 22,2.S E a

Dn 00

,l a

..s_

U {i J

l

2 m

l Mr. Paul Fime-Divisica of Site Safety auad Envia -

= =1 An=1p is office of sucleme %-*w Regn1=Maa_t i

U.S. W. clear Regular Comunission. d,,

~

Va a h i agcco, D.. C.

20"

Dearittr. Fime:

~ Ibe:

Resymme to Teleph'==d Quem'== Peremiai=*

to"Eca u= i e ConsequenAes.qf NBC Sf= red -

ordee on Maine Y= nee

=.

1.

What would have been the car =n-icy racing and Sqp=eiey hene for M=ine Y

== q t2ne al=*ri

, period?

la.

itaine Y=* -: bas a net cap =eity racing <af ;830 EGi.

Itsesu=e it gener=cem low cost er.ergy, Maf e Ym=&==

norsumily operates at the hi* heat ate =4==hle cap =efey pperating practicea.

,T h e har caessi=te with load reductions for==adatasy. testing.<g ca 11ne =x :;rA capacity F=eenr would course 'be =YY=-*==4.bv a c

=mi e -

n= ace.

We wan1d - - e the month),y e=----f ey F= rear,tn be appraw h ee3,y'951.

W<,

.. y..

- ** l This repremenen a power picduction.af q--saast'be zwp1=e-a. ~y g-568 million M per =aaehYf=ne Replace--ae will 'bewe to come frama che ' farmed +;- a t==

=O= =

of older Issa efff daae nti-fired.@= and hag.Mim Aselag same periods by time operation.of. peak and saa turbinea:"7% more *g = 'iwe.graden.afiall.

lat au ptverage af 600 m/ bbl.cf. oil,. thia M'ito 2 a..,

" "'.7 3 000,000 bbim,N.per===wr( 1.:y~j j(

' n j '--

, n.. ;rp.

.i

' Petrolessa, ennts 'in'1E*=, Eng'Tund.m nM :- _,_ ^ -= 413290

'y

==4 ~$19,20 per 'harr='t '.~d(W aqpesa ; Mead==the g...

,t.v.R,...

cancene mad ottaer F=a* ave yn..+.

,l"'Or..

}_g@,.

}'.**

...L.,

Q..

~

..s.l... ),q.

ll:' ;

. 0

~

+

\\

9I I i

7903260281

I g

a MA=ut Ya m'en" ATDeeC POWrER ooMPANY 2

'T k Ptr. Ben 1 Fizza D)2 1

d I

D"dj8

,fg j

maren 22., Iwe 2:.. son, - is mf.e Ts.m*. s 1b

  • n.1e 1. swt do.or E Thswe are no enmM savisags to.Msine Yazicee shile shut h

In fimee. ita the currenst abutdamm mode Mnfno T:asikse usast - __ - N=e betta poseer sad petrolenes for unam* mad & m purposes.

Ed gesseral,. all &rf n===f

==f eemnee expenses will er=r-Th== as they wouldtat fh11 N 1. oyestion m ept that fzsel would: not be berrned so the bmmy portion of funi cost will not be expensed'(The indirect costs associated with the irrvestament in fuel will e-im ta=be a cost to Maine Tankee even W ther r=-f r is shut doun}.

This L,.mm portices of fuel cost is daTT=r v=y =rrm-- i-tely 3.28 = itis /KIE, therefore the errrrentl T==

of the nuclear fuel not burned will be about $1,860,000 per -*h.

3L. Elast is the difference in "c-p--eden and "hten=nce" cost of Naine Ymennes e vs. the oil-fired pT=es that repInce it?

3E..

n=aer the electrical intercr===ction pool rules in Eiew R=-1=nd " operation and unintenance" costs are borne by-the r====rs of the facilities so are irrelevant for the of deter-fnine repimeemment power cost.

Darereg shutdossa Main = YmM ceaners amase Maine Yank=='s O'& M cost pins the fuel cost of rep cement poseer mund soune A charges associated with the re-p1= - - - i poseer such as tren==f =sion charges.

4.

What is the dif%..sce in fuel cost of Maine Yanhee versus the oil-fired. costs timmt replac e it?

Express in xxills/Krs.

4&.

As stated earlier, Maine TanWs current fuel cost is es-- :==tely 3.3 nuills/KEE.

Rep 1=-:-

rt poseer costs will vary dependant upco the rher==1 effici*aey of the repiccwi units and the cost of fuel for each of those units.

Dayrf== repimee=ent poseer will cost s g.wthtely 32 snills per Kwa.

Ar night and ont =*e3renda it meay be about 25 mills per r.ra.

On average, osse could use about 27 scills per K3E.

Arturhed is a copy of a letter we received from the New England Pouer F-T-- ge og1 March 14 regE

  • ding the effect of tbl2 M2ina Yankee stustdaun.

De appreciate the N :C's interest in the econcuric isr,mact of the Y=fn* Ya h shui. dome upon New England.

Since the N: sine utilities can about 507. af the r=14r, the in=ressental iv_et upco naine coa-u ta vill be greatest.

r L

nm v - Anm*c rown 3

p M

Ifr. MT Fi=:a r

'l Nm-cli 22,.1979 D"*D FDVl@

V 50$ dY' n o

a D

O L: M---w, t2 e fed' dimwedown of Naine Y=ra=e has weakened

(

  • rs14mbility of the states power supply.

tesina's <nly other i

1==ce 2.1-e 1 carit iis otsst dbum for mieen=nce end operation of its czW 1=rgest fw11 p1==*- im soi.ricted becanoe of afi j

Aal'he=y pre!blems.

"J* - - 4 6.

upcn tro no.for hasion tin =tM state is b=vily dependant t

W t o E'a ur cies can a - right-of-way, R

of snRM=-*%ddre and one north to Gew Bruncwick.

The lack local ~generatibg-capacity coupled with a Inrge fU

&=#m cca transerission iniemurw= action is analogous to the i

c!T ti.cn =%feb precipitated the noost recent b1mekout in New York l

City on July 13 and Ih,1977

=%== a 14@t nfre storm caused short i

circrrfra on several ermnmerission lines.

Main, too, has storms.

Rw Mai:c Ym-*=e has co=mleted the required suu 2 reenalysis and i

p M the F-m gion of possibly one hanger that anay need reinforcing, b

Inns fu the systemt aiwte.

We are preparirq the remnalysis work L

fer I2X: St:aff review and look foi-rd to expeditious action leading E

to the =rliest possible ayymov=1 for restart.

h Very truly yours, g%

]

l'E e

it W

6

. B. Emndar=a h

Vice President

.6%

lttach.

y q

hbe r2 h

l w

~..

a Ti, t-5 F

[5s

.9 gI/

E_2..

w/

i.

MEPCX

'a - =~.. z a Ekw Erg 1=rA Pcwer F-h=nce 174 Brush Hill Avenue l 02 i

~~

West Sg rf rwfield[419) 785-5871 Massachnnetts 01089 Te1@

4 r

i Ju 3

Ezrch 14, 1979' nr. chor1.s z. v-ty i

Senior Vice F.4Aa*

F d n em.Dag arui Freduction

~ Central Maine Fc Cosspany a

j M -a=

brive I

A=-nsta, Mstine 04336 naar Mr. ',w'.a.y:

{

TMim letter will serve as ennF4rnation of our discussion thi= - uing.

EEPEI has anade a pre 1T-f==ry estinuate af the near-terna 6

effe_t of the Maine YanE=e =hmedown.

It is our estimszte that i

it will een=e the burning of shu Inntely 40,000 additional i

barrels of oil per day, inc1=if as operation of both internal i

consbustion units and fossil-fired units.

t The estimated cost l

of eMa anLYfrional oil-fired operation is approrimmately

$ 500,000 per day.

The err" t over the full t'u c =- th period may be smore extensive as t9=eme eart===tes are s- !mt on the conservative side.

Very truly y - s,

/S/ Dawid E. Stuart David E. Stuart Ascisenne DirectorM4::'

THIS LE.Aw CO?IED FG2 r rAnrz.