ML19262A534

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards Hydrologic Engineering Concerns Re Inadequacy of Flood Protection Design Bases for Potential Large Pump Storage Project Upstream from TMI
ML19262A534
Person / Time
Site: Crane  
Issue date: 08/25/1972
From: Harold Denton
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
To: Deyoung R
US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
References
NUDOCS 7911130542
Download: ML19262A534 (4)


Text

-

AUG 2 5 ET R.

C. DeYoung, Assistant Director for PWR's, L POTENTIAL LARGE PUMP STORAGE PROJECT L'PSTREAM OF THREE MILE ISLAND PLANT NAME:

Three Mile Island LICENSING STAGE:

OL DOCKET NUMBERS:

50-289 & 50-320 RESPONSIBLE B RAN CH :

PWR fl APPLICANTS RESPONSE DATE NECESSART FOR NEIT ACTION PLANNED ON PROJECT:

As soon as possible REVIEW STATUS:

Awaiting information Comments from EPA dated August 16 on the draft environmental stacament for Three Mile Island indicate that a large pump storage proj ec t is to be constructed on Stony Creek upstream of the site.

The applicant has nowhere, to our knowledge, described this project in his application although it potentially could have significant implications on the adequacy of his design bases for flood protection.

As we have discussed the applicant of our concern,about should be promptly notified the potential safety implications, the deficiency of his application in this important area, and the probable extension of review schedules.

The type of information we will need to evaluate the safety implications are given in the enclosure.

Onginal signett by H. R. Denton Harold R.

Denton, Assistant Director for Site Safety Directorate of Licensing

Enclosure:

Hydrologic Engineering Concern ect See attached page.

221 099 v

D**D

  • D'

{

W d.

W

.u.t 2

AUG g 5 $3 2-R.

C.

DeYoung cc:

w/o enclosure J.

O' Leary E.

Case A.

Giambusso W. Mcdonald cc:

v/ enclosure S.

H.

Hanauer

.J. Fendrie R.

Ballard A. Schwencer H. Yaulkner L. G. Hulman DIST RI BUT ION _:

y 50-289 & 320 7 Docket File L:Rdg.

L:SAB L:AD/SS 22i 100 omcc > ; L

  • S.A,B,,,,,

,,,,,,'l,,,,,e,y,p),,,.

,j., h :p/p S L:

B i

Q.

gnton!

j sunNaut > L..O..W...... a. n...:..b a s W &m i l l

,......H R..

8 /h?./.7 2 I 8 / J <D 7 2 I

nc > i...8 /2.5 /.7 2 u.$. GOVERMetEMT PRINT 1M4 JMQ.Het M4-598 WFD2 AEC-3. 4 tRev. S-53)

HYDROLOGIC ENGINEERING CONCERNS THREE MILE ISLMO DOCKET N0. 50-289 & 50-320 It has ccme to our attention that a large pu=p storage facility is propcsed for construction on Stoney Creek, upstream of the Three Mile Island site. Provide the follcwing infor=ation, in sufficient detail to allow an independent review to be made, to assure that this proposed facility will not adversely affect tne plant:

1) Provide sufficient information to a) assure that the pro-posed pu=p storage plant can adequately pass its local pro able maximum flood; b) adequately pass the basin probable maximum flood; or c) in the event that cases a) or b) cannot be satisfied, that '.he effects of the failure of the facility during such floods will not adversely affect the Three Mile Island site.
2) Provide assurance that the proposed facility can adequately sustain its local safe shutdown earthquake.

In the event that such a conclusien can be furnished, postulate the arbitrary oeismically induced failure cf the structure and analytically demonstrate that the resulting flood wave will not adversely affect the Three Mile Island site.

3)

In the event that the situatiens described in 1) and 2) above cannot be satisfied, that is that it cannot be shown that the Three Mile Is:and site can safely withstand the

\\

20c1

_2 effects caused by the inability of the proposed Stoney Creek pump storage facility to withstand the s3:e level of natural phenomena severity suggested for nuclear power plants, describe hcw you intend to provide adequate flood problems for the Three Mile Island site for such conditions.

20' 102 c

v.