ML19260E104
| ML19260E104 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Crane  |
| Issue date: | 01/19/1980 |
| From: | Sholly S AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19260E105 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8002130368 | |
| Download: ML19260E104 (8) | |
Text
.
.. ;f r :
a...-
U.';1TED STATES OF A'!ERIC A NUCLEAR RF/jlLATOP'1 CC9! L S51P:
'l.s.
^,
.cb O
HEFnHE Tile M t ;4T C S? h F1 v AND L f CI",SI NG
-*);'
In the Matter of
)
)
Docket No. M-2b?
, i r. f av ~oi L i c. 4 r.rJI 0 0a- - -i r~a.s, e
)
i s
cc n
1 m
( n,o s t, t ')
)
(Throc Mil c-Ialand, Uni.t 1)
)
INT ERVE':0R STEVES C. SilOI.LY DESPn's. TO FIPST SEE nF NHC ST AFF f NTEPRrG ATn q T US Intervenor St even C.
Shally herein respor da to NRC Sta f f I n t e rro6 a t o r ie:i wi th proli.mi nary arwei n L. sed upon informarion a vai.la bl e thi: date.
Intervonor regrett delay in answering 1.
' ' h w ei dm i n part. to an illness o f soveral day s.
Very general answers to Questi ons 1-4 were conununicated t o Ms.
Marcia Mulkey on 11 January 1930 by tele 3 hone.
QUESTION 71 Intervenor has not yet identifted any witnesses for speci fi c content i.ona at t h i. s date, although preli mi n.try contacts have l'oen rado with a few persons with regard to Contenti.on 98 (Ewrgrmcy Planni ng).
The ability of thi.s Intervonor t o present *ci t nes s ea on the many wirious c ont e nt i. o ns will to dependent largely on the availabi.lity of fundi.nt, to cover wi t ness - related cos t s.
It is very posnible that lack o f such Eundi.ng wi.11 force this Intervenor into reliance on being,ay own " expert" and on c r -:; -e:.<.:ni cat i cn in order to advance M'
CaSO.
AS econ ah a
',li.t n eS S LS identifi.ed 8002130 b@
2_
supplom m al responses to th!s it errogatory will te i.csued.
QUESTI00 J2 I na s ane'h te.
the discoery process is !.o t.
>L co,jl te, t h i. s rtua n t i on is regarded no o D je c t i ona ble.
Test; m it not rec}UI.rld t o 11'; fi3ed 'Jith Staff uhtil }5 days P r i. o 'J tG the session at t; '. i. c h i. t is to to prosented (10 CcR 2.743 (b).
Wi.th rcforcrce to docu'. n u to ut i li.n:d i.n prepa rin_,
the to,ti.aony, a: testimony.elll Le limi.ted to NRC and Li.censee docta:e :t s with, at this date, a few except i.ons.
The only excepti.o > whi ch are identi.f i.able at this dato are:
ENVIRONMENTAL GEOLCGY OF THE GREiTER IIARRISPURG METROPOLITAN AREA, by Williata G. McGlade and Alan R. Geyer, Pennsylvania Eureau of Topographi.c and Geologi.c Survey, 1976.
AFTER ACTION REPO!:T :
THREE MILE ISLAND NUCLEAR INCIDE',T, Commonwr alth o f Penns ylvani a,
Department of Mi.li tary A f fain, 7 June 1979.
Documents prepared by the President'a C ommi. n s i on on the Accident at Three Mile Island, i.ricl ud ing Sta ff Reports and Analyses.
As other documents are identified, suppl emental responsen to thi s i nt e rrogatory wi.11 be issued.
QUESTION v3 No such documents core ut i.li.zad.
QUEST !T:N ' 'i Steven C. Sholly is the only such indi.vic cal nt this dato.
3 QEST mN J14-1 Evali:ation of Licondto :ana r t:roct a r.d admi ni st r.1-vo ca pa b il i.t ies i. s ccth oujecti.ve (co:apari ng Li cennee org. :i mi.on,
- v. o c. ~ and.tnuustry i
rules, p ra ct i. c e n, procc dun m, etc. aca l. n 3 L s tan hrcis) and u tbject i '.e
(:aaking an asSev n. cut of the capati l it i.e o f the Li.consee i n t.orir.
of protection of publ i.c hm.:lth and safocy whilo dec. ling with the unirlw t i.t uati on per > er.t ed <c a result of thJ Unit 2 acci.dtat).
What i., sic.osted h m > i. o t' m t s ita d.v co:r. >1.ri.n wi t h NRC m
o arul i ndustrv standarA for m rral n.pe r a t i o n s i. s not su f ficient in thi.s case b2cause this is clearly not a " nor u 1" s i.t un t i on.
The presence of the dar.iaged and severel.s conta:ninuted Uni.t 2 reactor at tha darna site as Unt: 1 raw t place t hi. s case iln d o r s c:ac ',,n a t di Eferent and :r. ort s t ri.nge n t stundards with rec,pect t o raanagena nc and adrn ni.st rati.ve capa bi li.ti.es.
The typ' of acti.vities whi.ch will be goi ng on with Unit 2 wi.11 cc:.sist o f a ct i.vi.t i es whi.ch will approxi.: :at o decomi s sioni ng,
s oir.othi ng wtch chi.ch thero i s very li.ttle e?:porience (especi. ally with a reactor of thi s si.ze) and for whi.ch appli. cable standards are "oc yet fully developed Locause thi5 a ct i. vi.t v "as not antici >ated to occur for cor.m jears i.nto the future.
The t a c t. s of the accident ancl mow Licensee nanaged i.tself during the cri s i a peri a and since that ti mo clearly indicate that L i.cen see's adni.ni s t ra ~. i ve and raa nae,ome'it ca pa bi. li t t e leave s omethi.n" to be dew i. red for even nor:aal ope rat i.cns,
a
4 Licensco's "?nsLart Report" i. S Elled '.zi t h li sts of p'tsornel and tlici.c ne'; t i rlo, and r:ow pat *:or: s oi resporsi bili ty and cc *nuni. cat.
,r,,
l u r. le cc, no'.chere docs Li.cernce add r, >,
the poor snowl.!t, i n th light of the U n.t 2 accident and li.st
, men u.ade t o p: e'mnt such a shou'n i.n tiie chaye3 wnich hs.-
e future.
H:trolc. Dmten described Licensee as " t h i. n" in terms o f tecIln i. cal l al:lt, yet t he r. e is no apparer.t P.o Ve ig Li censet?
to acqui.re <,. and.-;uperior talent to be used in the conduct o f i.t s oper at i.on > at Three ".ile Island.
A showi.ng of "adequier" i.s not enot;h in thi s c a s e - - w'. 'n t 12 req' d red i_ s a showing of
" superior talent and s ki.ll s. "
Licencee nanagem nt and administ rative ca pa bil it i.es will be assa 4 sed under t hc following categories:
A.
The quality, completeness, and clari.ty of L i.c e ns ee ' s rule:., regul at i.ons, policies, practices, ins t ruct i. ons, and procrdures.
B.
The degree of compliance with these items ( t hos e in " A" ) by Licensee personnel (such compli.ance being a di. rect reflecti.on of the quali.ty of L i. ce n s ee ' s administ rat i ve and canagement akills).
C.
The suffi ci.ency and quality of Li.censee's Quali.ty Assuracce/Quali.ty Centrol programs (cited by NUPEG-0616 as the " master control system available to rt anagrent to assure that all management control.jster= are operable and
e r**
se em Off0CtiVU l. !! E 0 ri ' o f nrOVl(li.11 > ' a f U t s'" ).
1 t!j Il.
- j i}(
.O
's 1
('
1 a. b b[l!' b ('
(k I ) I.
5
> ()I-i to TGVi.UW Work (lcTm b) it9 pe r :OnriOl to Ve t i. fV that i t.
d i
'( c t i. v <.' 's ;ind pol i ci e,
at'-
in En ct offtctiV l' C tri'l e d o'!t.
E.
Tiv :m nno r i
- v. u c'i Li een ;< c i. a ::1-m o t responda i
T'it i I P.G, U a C P l. na,L C ?. '.. L L C 3. S "l, 1 TiClu }.}nb LO L Iit '-
v,b g
- 1
. Il b { lO C t 1. f)II)
((IaI! r( [ }. ( 2 d 5
{)C r i.
t)
'.('(
IV and i p +, C i. f i L ' t } l V 11GW TOCO:
n(' n d fl t i. O n, a T'i " i D!',
froa a:mh cri t i cis m and reviev [u ' ha n elled i)y I,i.Cf :r! 4 00 ! Jilh L * :i;>Ml t.
5 O f bi COllS t : t; I.
} } 10 gl'.ill i.t y a ;Id C O?!'ll f 't f > n ' 3 mainte, arco pror. ram a, an ossenti.al rechanism 1)V Wlli Cil li'.a nl y', *' i;' U n t af >UrCS t}1at UC}UI pTFOT;t opGrilDi 1 ! t y and (+pPi'ali On Ll.
afCC) arU II'a i ntili !!Od.
Li.Cc u s e, 1
.a t.co o rira ry <1ut i ea at thi.s ooi nt.
Paramnunt i
i iS C}le Saf0 Cl Ganup and dOColita'Hi nat lOn o f UML t 2.
II.O SOCOnd
" d ut y" whi.ch Licensen has it to sa fely operate Uni.t 1.
L i.cen s ee must clearly red conclus ixel y
(' mon
- t rato El'at i. t ',a s the nerossary
.uag,ement and atimini.s t ra t L Ve capabi l i.t i os requi red to handlU '9th nCtiXiti_O t i ~,1.l t a n e 01! i l '.
I E C h i. S i9 nCC forced into i ts p ri:ca ry r< > s por', t ni. l a t y t 's o case, Li. co ns o. rm > t of Unit 2 ClCil!'JIP <li.(I duCont.ai.il'.ati.<_'
Uy dt..;yi.I.b
' O rlu i. : i, i C n lor NO3 tart O f CTl L C 1 unt i. l. 41;C11 t i_ O O a5 the POC46ailry FOSQUrCO:'
. are a.atn availa';1< to Licenso.
Ilm n t'<:l i c st b-a s u ~ed n
L that. ikstart ' c i. '.1 n o t.
it perniited i:x tl the NilC and the publi c are conEi.dont t:l in t hi cc ben has udded mw technical and.
' gem NL t~ al ent and ha-s u f Ei. c i en t ' ' rr>vi : 4 i itr p roce du::es o'
' poli ci es so that sal e operati o:t of Uni t 1 1.1 p
,s ibl e.
Q UESTI ON 614-2 By " rostoro" Intervenor tears the proceus of,,ahing Uair 2 opera!.le acuta as a :n telear unit.
When this conte.tLon '.as articulated it appeared that Li.cens u was conmi t ted ':o returntr o Unit 2 to screice as a nuclear uni.t.
It is now apparent that this ar.surption was r:o t c o r're ct.
Licensee han annour. cod t h it
- i. t i. a in the proco s o f studyl.ng exactly what to do with Unit 2, having menti.oned converai.on t o coal or cas o r deco'.ni.s s ioning as potential alternati.vos.
I nt e rve no r till 'oon request permi.s s ion o f the Board and other parti.es to a:::end thi.s contenti.on t o re fl ect this un ce rta i.n status and the discussi.on in rcsponse to Inter:ogatory 14-1 aboVe.
QUESTION 314-3 Intervenor i.s urable at this dat e to identify s peci. r. cally such violati.ona, how wer, Intervenor is i.n the process of a revi.ew o f NRC Ins pecti or, reports and LER's a r <1
.iill nrovide t
a II.S t i r!', of S uch Violat i.onS US Soon fiS thlS FO vi c el iS CC1pl'. I:0.
-i-Re.s r :Lfully
.l a d i l l e i.1, Steven C.
Sholly 304 South Mar' ot Str mt
}!echant e:>Lur., PA 17055 7
..,r-h.
/ 1/ /6b-10)/
- h. -
1, -, 6 - 3, /..3,/
--/
/-30 556-32']3 DATED:
17 Jan... : ry 1950 A FFIn \\VlT re-STEVEN C.
SHrd.1 X State o!
lo. ru yl va ni a
)
SS Count, oi Ci..rrland
)
B, t o re to the s ubs cri. bel-p' re,onnal ly appea rs :d S t even C.
Shol l v, who l o i nl.
duly sworn, accordi.ng to la w, doth depose and sa) that t he in formti on cont ained in Intervonor Ste' on C.
Sholly'a responsoo to NPC S*aff Intcrro7,atories 1, 2, 3, 4, 14-1, 14-2,,nd 14-3 ar t r ur-c.d correct to the best of his knowl ed :, i.n f or na t i e n, and Lelief, and further anyeth not.
L Sworn t o and subscri bed oorore r.m thi.s st ? I i (~' dr.v o f Janua ry, 1930 e
i
\\w,
,