ML19256E413
| ML19256E413 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Trojan File:Portland General Electric icon.png |
| Issue date: | 06/29/1979 |
| From: | Fitzgerald J NRC OFFICE OF THE GENERAL COUNSEL (OGC) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19256E414 | List: |
| References | |
| SECY-A-79-054, SECY-A-79-54, NUDOCS 7911050170 | |
| Download: ML19256E413 (8) | |
Text
.
f" UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION June 29,1979 W ASHINGTON, D. C. 20555 S_ECY-A=79-54 CONSFyT,,n.a.m inan JTEM i n MUJ U Vlu l V K I wb
=4 Q S.4 e e.
f w.
- s...
. a.
w i
l T. wa.
yg a.3 A.
T.4 6..".e.a..n.s.7 A 6
w
.4 S S.4S *..o. e d.-
. m..e.e
- 2. 7 C.. e. S a. 7
.6
.O, u k. 4 a. a. *<..
3 7*[** T*A' CT 4.T n.";, " 't, *. ( *12.". '".*T O
- 7 D r* O.'.**
- n* ** *w**
9 4
,w.
. w.
, s s., w...D * \\I7 3 - nT. \\
- M
.C r.*9
)
t*
% *T.D 4.T.e C.'**.v*...*.
n J
4_
n.
w e,d g e.
SJg g i.a. c.w 3
- s.e. *. f.3 %.^ a C 3 a. d n.=..c..e.d...a. a. =-
T. s.c.8 7.J a n.
9
- t v...
s
.y
< r.
6,. m
- 3 a..me J ~.
.C, C w. o ga.
D. e. e. *.
'si. n d. 4.**.a..e = 4 m
w.
3..
- e. v 3 a.
- m.,
4.p.a.
"1...a L w.m. J... Q Q...e.
3.e.
A y.w..s.
a
+. w a
.J i
ea
..w.
- C &." A d*.*..*.S*w*D w rA W"..'."...
~ ~,4C "y..*~,."'..'.S V.
^
w
<s
.#Cw- ** a. tl. a td b.a *v.rg
- h. a. a..m.
. o. n. a. 4., a. d
- p..e. d J
w w
g.b. 4 m.h. y
.m..e,
- e. e 4.e. 4. w.*. g y. a. 3 A. * **
4 v.
a
- w a 4 ~ #
Q. t "....
)
y.
.c 4 4. 2,.
4 S.. a..
e.ea.
.a.6 Q.
Review Time Excires:
Extended by Cr fer of 2e Secretary, ew u..=..... r N.. * *. "..
'r. 3
'. 0,~/, 3
. ". =..'.-y..o..'
- ..=.w n.
s 0
=
y
- J
. a.. e. S..e. $.
T e. g.w A.
2...J.w.=..a. A.
e A.a. a.db. m.e.
= h..g =.
J d
p
. s a
w
. m..=.= 4 6. a d.
m.e.
.d r. w. o. o - a.
.d.a.
= %.. a. Q.w.ot.
ew
-~aw
-a
-Q s
y a s e s. a.4 =.,
- h.. a.
...a..
- e..
.==w m.h.a.
=
. e m. e..
g 5
yC.
wy w
y y
.. e.
..o. U
.e.m C.4.*.*.,...
.O. s.,.s
- .O O. _ *rP ". 7 ",,
8 O
w j
' '. * /.* O *t 3\\.
- k.. a.
3... a..s.* O.*.3..% A. t =Q J. a. r. d _
\\
./
yy Q.w..p r*..'J*..O.,, 2 -
- A a..S. =s
.g. =..W.
- W w a. s.
=.. e 4 w
J 4e i
- 4 ss.p
.=
- J
=4
= *.,.
... a. Q s.4
- e. Q
.,l.%. a. =. %.. =..w
..W. s... m. a..e. Q..e. $
ae A g
e Y
y t. =
- s. e w a. a. *.
4 e.
%+e.*..
4..J
% S
e o
6
.w.
- * * - - **=
=
.* m.g 3.
- ,J.9 c
- a..e.=..a
.J i3.%=
Q < 3.. g g e.
- w. A.,.
.d
.yt s
y
%. g.* 2.* # ** *
- A *h y' ^. ** Q".. *. * ".
- a..*\\.2.".*..d ** O. *e #
.y.
sj 2.
=< w p =. 4 7 s..;.
. 4..t.
.e. a 3. a. q = =.w.y
.g b.. a. =<.W. a. w.
= %. a.
s....
.c Q
, 3
- w. 4..J...... Q Q
,. f.;
.e d.pa.
. m.J.
. =.
- e. A 2 ** 4...
a
- w.
yw
.e J
Qy.
- . s. *.
- s..og 4 g
- J a
J g.. w. c g. s.
. % a..o., J e. g.
.3 4
%. a.
=s 3.hQ
,4a.
3 g.. e. s. e.. J. =.
- n. e... J w e e.
- s..e. =s. *.
=sw i
d.....
a
.w
- 3.
- J 4
.=e'.; = s. = c..e..
.g.s
- r.
w a. 4. =< * -.
s j
yy.
2
.=. 4 q
w 3
.,[.W. a. v.W. 4. e.
e a. w.
- S.J e.
. =.
,4..J w=..=
=.c.
= %.a.
"wa J
= 4 e.
..s,
..e.
=m
=.
Dewog$g
.s n. w,= =
A. v. s. w m =. J.=.e.
...4.
% a.
...s A. s.
3.m.
. y y.
w g.
<w y
- m. * =. %.. g
=. g e. h..e..i a. 3.. q. s. a..J....m c. =.. e.g 9J J
J y
m.
.e. m.."34. A.
J
- J
=..W. g y.
v..
=
a v. a. w g
.J..e. s
. a..e..;g
,(
44
.= *... ; ;......'
g..
.y g
... =
w 2.....
- a.".
. s..
- 2... s. e s.. a.
.* J e.
w
- J aw
...A.
=..w..J. A...*
w.d y
.N.
s
...w
.J
.* J a
.p.
J
,. 3. C,. J
=.==4e...m.
.. a.
J
- e. s. a g a
.s
....g..
...Q s.
.,f.'. J.. b.
w a.... J.,.. a.
m.e.
J =.;.J
- . =. 2. v. =..<.p F %,.,
w
. v.
J g.
J s......
... g.. g w 34
...
- 4 3.g.. g...
9,. g
.g,gw4 3.
.,d.... 3
..g J
J
.=.. a..w a. 3.
we.
w4
- 3. =. s.
- e. 4 4..= =..g ; s. A.
..e.
g. e.. a..e..=
7y.
y.
j
=s m g g,4 J J
4J
. w....e. t G w e. =s.% s. w
='.g......e
- .e.
. 4.J.
.==.w.
g y.
........., a. e.
- 2..,7
- 1..*.;. O.,
4.
.J
. b.w.=
.J m.=g..
e..
t..
~.
}
9
- -c.
l 3
- f. )C /4
. =. =.
.O O. 2..=. a.= #. " ",
.'J'*,
~
- 44=
.."=...f..=
.g
.J.3
....y:..
'. ~ ~
- 7911050 /
O
4 2
Discussion:
1.
The Environmental issue Intervencr Susan Garrett argued that the Licensing Board should have considered nationwide cumulative effects of spent fuel capacity enlargements and the alternative of reduction in pcwer cutput to reduce the rate of spent fuel genera-tien.
In affirming the Licensing Board the Appeal Ecard noted that, viewed in isolaticn, the evidence established
.d
. w...c u..,cn...a.,
4 n.w3
_4 s. a, _, _4
-.e
...-_ve e
the new racks and operating the pcci with expanded capacity will entail ne mo." =. '. ha.n n e -'.d
.' b '_ a.
- a. ".v _*." r..e ".. _$ '
s_ s a impacts.
The Appeal Ecard the"efore characterized the subject of Ms. Garrett's concern as "the centinued generation and on-site storage of nuclear wastes on a nation-wide basis withou: any reasonable c s s,, a n e,o.
.w,-
2
,., w e e.. e.. a..... acl,e*4cn
....e y
.- s l a.,.-.s _n s
e
.a.n s *e e
....n.2 - o....a. r..
in e
.. y
.v yha. e.e.r _s. s. n m u..e s~,y y. a.,
=,,,A.,< ane-a
..A s
a
_v
.s.. a,,..a..n. a. s _ _o.4.q e d
.4 e.
- h. 4 a c e nc a..w e. *c ho.
w w
.. o o
3
,... a c a. a. d d n 3,
a_a' _: 2 : o~,
.g o.
c o. o_ _4 w 4 a.
s'. _a.d "e
_~
e and ccncluded thac Ms. Gar"ett's argu-
= =. ' a. c '. e d _* r. "<
- a. w s.....'.' a." 1 s "o.
d a
C n....-.s e s _e n. n, "a-
...e.i.
uo.
~ n 4....,y.,. 4 n. 4, n C.o.u.a e
1,,
t
.u
,4 d_4 _
,e n o.acc._o a.
_ s s,..., a.
. u.a.
w
.s methcds of safe permanent disposal of high level wastes can be available when
-a.a.da.d."
. k.. a.
a' " - *. _= _' = c a.-d.
..c ~. a. d,
k..o w -
yy
. v 't
=. v fi e e. D-..m..c a =. h. a. _. J a.[ a..n, = h.G v
.da s
- n.. e. e.
ah 46 3
e a.
J y V.s.
J' a.n.w o = *. f.
c C w.. w..n n.. s.
aa a
'A.s. c ~ w m. a. s, ~
e e ~ 4 ~. 4 n e.a. A.
- mm
- -~...~..._a~~_4ne.
m a... J_ 1. 4 vc.
. y
.v.
v.
.v ao v.#
^ _ n_0. 0, 0 7_
- e. m.. 6..h..JQ m
_J e s p a.,
.Jn em.w.Ja,.7gw
9 w
ym..
4__.
- a. m. n s.4 4 a..n if =. k.. a. c.ge.n cCoq.J k s.7 _J.J.
_wg*
=a
= =...
c,
k a. n..~ ~.. a p,. 4Y a
s w
- a..o. n.%.
.~.~..a..n 4 _2 T_
m..G g A a.
w a. _e. v ~. n. m.
n e,.
a w
.ca_._.y
.n
- .d*Jh.
.# c_ a. b. v
.d 3 s #.3
.. m 9,
sew.e6M e_a.
e no sv.
a A"*.C w 3
~.."..#c' c u a. c' ' _' C r. *.*.?.
- ^*
" S. *..# ^.w '_ a. ^#
^
..S w.
g
'. m.3 s. e..a A a. n.., c_ J.m n..,
- o. p.
.q.>..Jm %.
~>..a.
~.,>.a.
D. m o. n wJ a u
w A.n n a. _a.l Q c o.w s.
w a..l _Jo. A.
_.e.
n ' n_0_0 0 7, o.w a.
J i
9
.s cu._
yy u
n y y
_e _7 -
gc,*.a c.#
- k.a.
w a. n. a. n..
- p.e.
u aJ.
Aa..
s-ea e
a w.
. w
.v VO..N. 3 9..*.
..w
- J
=4 J
- T J r.e. a g =. = a..
a _ m.s.
_.n.
h q b a.
4 w
v.
.' yv. " G. _ ~. 3 4. Q,
(.'.T._o n
',73,1
~ _. ~.
.n a. c- ~y v..a-a.
~. ~.
3 me i
j
.3 a... _ J......_ s e _.,.-....r.o a. 4 J
J
,w-
- e e J e _d e r.
... a.
4
.w
. w e c,
. c n d ".. s c...a. >'..d.
~. '. ~. c a a. =. d..'..,~
.o d d_.- a..e.'
. a, a. c. =..'.e a. _'
e c. o. _
.kg w a..* g
- J,n.- b.J e,
- h. o. =..g a. m. e..
g e -
s l254 255
2 w
expansions and the availability of off-site o.--2-.
ae.d/c d4 -c c w, a.,.
w.e uu,n.,,..,
.c.4,c ca e.
sy 6..b.e we.,.4a.4 *v+w.
- b.u o 46 4 q
=..pm..c.na.e.d,.,.m
.#.n c m..
es e
i w
_w C 2. a.w
.Pnem
- hp
..{ 4.e n.a. s c 6. m_
A g m..J J e.e.
- 6. b a 6, 6.hg
- a
. w.
o m
o v u
envir:n= ental issues in ALA3-531, and partic-ularly the Appeal 3 card's reliance on the s..c u., d n o.
..,i.. e.. 2.4. 4 a o-,ae.d a.n.
4,n, w
a w
ow
.w go unreviewed, but review of these generic questions should take place in the pro-ceeding in response to the " curt of Appeals'
- d. c.4
.4
.e.
.h..
.w... a.e.4 e.
. w..,.
- e..,.. r.d.. c c c.., x.
a w
n a c r o. a 4 n., 7.,
.d.
be.,.4a.u..
w.e r.e n A_O K m..
a w -- s w
,s Cc mission should not grant Ms. Garrett's netition for review, Rather than sinc.ly
.av.
4.r.e 7.ew 4...e,oysa.
w_' *. k.c u w a c...a. n *,
. 4 w
however, as may be done when the Commission declines to grant a petition for review, the C c...~...4 s 4, n s..v u., a.
- a. r. ~. e.-, u n. a..r w. s a..
un a
e.c ~. 4.e.e-a
-L.). w. u *.. >.e
.4,s,, s
.d..,,
. a.
. a e... n, p.< c.
.s o
4 w
w w
a e.8 (2) ~..na.
.ec-~.hcc~..4.e.3,
- e. a ne < c e.n n e a a. d.s.e s,.
,w y w a..
e c o.,. A.
ayy ea2.,
c.
...e
- m.. c j,.e.
w w
- e. e..
c.w a
v r...
e pansion, though not set aside, remains sub-ject tc =cdification based on the cutccce of
~ n a.
- a..n.a..4 c p.- n c a.a.d.4e.3._1/
w o,.4 c.< ~. n. u s ma e
w. a.
e 3
w w
...e...C. 2.e. d u..
2
- g _,I.
O.
". k.e 7 8.# 6. h.
7 a a. w. w.
ew *. s m u. e w
T e.*. a. w..l e e.e w a p n -s t o. d.
.d. 6..%.
. a. s m a. C *.
=.w
- 6..b a.
J w
a
. w.o
.. e y
i
. 4 =[o,
.#.2 9 * * " s
'd'
.J o. h.
". b.e I 9 Cm.. 4
- w,.4
- e. 4nC.
.v.
n v.
ww.
- Q e.n m.an a.
q p +.
mp6
.P m..m
.o. C e. C.4 A a..m n *. 4 m.e.
d.e.
7es
.w
's w
w.
wa
.w
- 9. 4 m. a. p q &.e. g-p. g. 4 n n c
..e.n.. a. n..gg w a..g s. o p p m
um t
w
..w.
w..
ow w.
y C w.4. g..
~..>.d.
n
- e. ~.. e., m t.e. g-
.c., a.. c e. v.
nn n
-~
Q V w.e..
-,a w.en
,m 6
p w
s.e,e...o..P 4 m..o.e.n s.
Q.. e ue.'4 k.s.
a
- a.. / g e.
.4
~m 6 %. a.
g w
w
<w s.
M ~ a '.
.P.a.P ~..k.
.Po. n ~. v~ m..
.d *%. a. s. k. C.
am
..amm e.m
-... w w
, 4 m. a..n. w...e. g.
2 ^
- J o c. J Q#- o.,a. w a.
w e. s *. w. 4 4. *. d r e.
J a
me
.w.
v..
...w.
w'
=. W. 4 Q
... m a.
.d p,w.
- 4 wa.3%.*.
4.e.
-.-h-=
J Oaww
<m.c.=...
m g
..i.
.j y
- h.. %.ow.
=..h. o. et,'U.4.a 4.c. e a. w a. Q s-=.ff 2,8 T a. A..
9
- ^
.v yw J.
O.. a.
S..
Q^O.]4.
w
.o.Cq. e.. g=
- k..sw
.'.2 9
- O*w J
e g
..w.
3 e
r m.a. g~ w n w.m -. a. A. k..o *
..e.
O,* w.
n o
=
.m>
~.h.a.
w".w.p s
m o.
w.
ga w
w s.
- d
.. m a. n c.-a mm,.*
4 400 a.
n.w.d.a n
.s m...m.'o. =. 4 s. e.
- m y
.w b y vva.w cma
~a 77*7 p h e a. r. =. ;.
m.e
= b..a.
-cae*
. s a.. v. w.n c. g.
J..w 3 Opw..,
a
.ww w
e S u..n.4.J e. g. k. w *.
Q h - = G.e. <.,c.'.
n
.J
- h. w.ow..d w,..A o
wQ<
u w
- b. a n,d.JQw
- m. v., w
-a aa w.
/
J w..w-.a e.
u..~. a. 7,.,
u.
y a.,, a.. 3 u.
Q,4. u.., e.
- n.. s a. -
. w 3. a.
- e. J..
,+,
=--
a w
e
- b.. a_
w c.=..=...
.J e..e.
%._g s a,t.ik. 1 4 w..,e c e..r.e p e. a s. A_
- e....e._."
- 4. a. 3. 4 _. m e.
e.
-..a. s.
S J.
4*
- J g
.2 owJ
..a....,=.s
.,, w..
... a. -...
e - c a a. e c.g.
n...
w.
g..w.
y.w w
.w-n o n 2,,0.' Q. c. 4 e..
A. w o..# =... v.. a.
e.#
w y a.c. A.
- J m..a.
.# a.n w a...Js. a. g
- m..e 9
- 10
.g
}
- J w
m w
a 1_. s. e.
e.
- c. a. c._ a. _.,._.y,-
..-e..
--a.
.._.,-.a.4
,~
.a.n=..-,....,.
1254 256
4 The Appeal Ecard found no basis in the Commission's notice to support the inter-vencrs' argument that the fifth facto" was mean to be centrolling.
The Appeal Scard reascnably concluded that if the Cct=ission
.o ncn.,,
.J..acu,a
.m..a. an ~o e..u.e.e 4.e. h.ea n + o.w v
w w
w.
have said so.
The Appeal Eca"c then found that the othe" four facto"s favored expansion of the Trojan sto" age pccl capacity, and concluded that "no warrant exists for pre-c It, d.4.e. s,. w a.
a x y a.e.Q.4 o e. cn
.w... a.s *. w a..r. e.
- w c*.ha.
e w
1075 notice.",
We see no reason -
~
Cc==ission's
.a J.. n- ~..u.e My-e e a. _= c a w a.,s
.o n.e.c.4.e. e s
n
~.c d.4 s,gwa.,.
y.
on the facts er en its interpretation of the Coc.m..4 s s 4 c n f,
.J e. w. a. n +. 4.e s e *. *. 4 n 3-c,a.
~ u. m..e d.Aa C
i
.cac.o.ns.
A c c e w A.d.e. o,..,
.se w.,.4 e.no.ua.
- w4s wo
.w
/
w.
"fifth factor issuu' does not present a subject en which the Cetmission shculd grant review.
2 w.
ocnn4,2 e a,4.e.4,2
- d ww
.w..s.esua.
er w.
.4.
.._ w ww.
ms.e Ayp _,. = c a w d a.r.e 4 w m a A.
- s. u. a..r.J, a..e. s.4.. e.
.mw 3 o a."d ' s." a.'"m s a '
- c m"d.a."
. w.a..'.c '. a s. w n. n *... a.
w.
amended operating license of a number of
- e a k.r..' - a ' s ' a. c.".*.* ^ '. 4 ^ r.s
." ^ c v C a. d. "o"
..". a.
w.
v y
w w.
3 v.
S *v a*. a.
^&
C " a e- -..
3.."..c
. 3
-"..a"
."..d
. 3 0, c"a.3.n
~
~~
-+
v w.
we v.
p." w p o s a. d
..k.a., d a. a = o k. a.....* s ~. ~. ~
.e..d.
~ +...."y. " =. "w " a.
a..
s w.
w.
'.4 m.. 4
- e 4 e..w. o 4 a. d
.J.a
- h.. a.
epC..Js. c.e. *. Q al 7
f=
.A s. w.4
- e.
q ww w
.y,
.w g
4 w o. n
.w e O..e..wM.A
=h
%~
SAs m a.w *< m.e
- h. s.
- s. n..W.I. 4 93.7 s
- wC
...w w.
o.
m yV yC w
s O p n..e.4
.o. s.
.e. w 3 d
- J e
..e. A 6 %.. a. n o..rm w a.
% a.
%.J.e.h.d e. g.m
~ma g
v a
s A
w.
w w
w w
s..
Q w w 3 s. e n c.e.*.1 n m... e A.J.*'.4 s. A.
- 2. 3 A a. y *s
- q k.s. w a.
e
~n%
kn wj 1
gew
.g w=
7*.4 a c..e. s a.
o m..a. e. d =...s. e. *..
v e 4 M.w s. e 9 4.m.
w h. 4 e 4 = = =6, a.
w h.a.
9megg7 I
.. A
..n.
Qw Gww aQ a
.00 M yy...
w
.r.J.n s a.
. a.. e d p r4 a. d.
- h. a.
_7.e. s..w.., A n. =.
.S.m. A A h. v C d w
a e
v 3s m
" v
.m...J w h.a.
w..fa m.*
QwJ w o. g,4..q
- 4 m. e. a S. m. A.
S e e.
'i. Ash mw aq Se Q
<.. Q
.w.
- auwa w
s.
- b. w *.
4
- b. a.
g,m.e. =< s.m..=y.* *cu 4 = c..
ge b%=W
- b. a.
4
..n 4*
w b a..
.w w
w.
Mw s
. e. A =. %. s.
w a. g=,4.7 m e..d e. n. D 4q c h..G s
=. s. a. b..e..J.a S.*
.e. y. n.d.
g w
w a
e m ma
.w e
w
.e 4 % e
- 4. W... V.e. w.o. o.
% s.
w a. w e.w.. o. A.
.e + w,k.e e s.
3 e
w
. e s
. ww v.
w
.M..d a.b.
- h. C J =..m a g h
a y b w. s,,
4*J e
m..q s. h. a. w q..
CQ
<w aa m= c.
g w
..g.M wJ m4 w w.n.d.d
- J. a c..q
'. 4.=..4 * ; ~.J e. e Q ma m
s w.
. ew
,we.
s a y. m.
w w.
.s w s. o
- s. e a. w e = J. e 6.e.
.-O ww.
y.
A s. s. ~,.a. A e.s. a a..g e o.w n 6 -w J
)
4 4
w ww sw e h..J. o a s.
= h.s.
ep =
y w D* Q 4 %. J..4*..
- 4..e S..e.
= A c. a..n =.. c..'
ww /
.4 e
sf e.
e.4 =.,w, w s.4w.c-r w.
- c.. p s. e. *.
= J.. J.e. g..Q.
sw wJ -s
=a cy a
s w
.S e.
3.s J..m..a. A..J o s.
- b..w a..c o
= a.
- h. s.
e g h. *..J...s..'.
g W q
= b.
+
a s
s.
y w w.es. =.. y
" T.w..n.>.=q ~.J 0
~ 4 p y..Jc. h. '.
- e.d.=.%.
c.e. n.
q,, m m i 29
.- y 0
w a
w s. g. g w 4 w v..a.m..4 m m...g e.= Q
..e.
S
.. a. a..m. =e n. o f -
- *==
=
J
- J
.. a ww s
J tc#
Seg*. g 4. Q w a. m e n
- h 4=
.. e. 4.%..
- e. V s
.J.c.,
w w. s. w g w..,j e..
n=
eV.
- w w
yw. <
..a..m.. s. w. e =. s.
O C.'s.
7, J
Ad.
w. c. a a. m o s. e..g s g 3
- h. o.
-a 7 =.. a.
ea. Q ga
- w s.
2 = s.w A
.e.
- e. a. A
.J. m s s. q '..
. =..n.. t
- %. G s
- > s.
ee
..es q
2
.b.
4 4
yy w
g.} {* g l4J4 L J{. =
5 monitoring of the licensee's "equired yearly report en changes at the facility (10 CFR 50.59(b)) will guarantee that any undesirable changes can be ob-served by the staff and remedied before safety is affected.
The Appeal 3 card noted that because of the 2cw corrosien rate c" the circaloy-clad
- uel and the stainless steel peel structures a change in water chemistry and/or temperature would not pose an immediate safety hazard.
The Appeal Board concluded, in accordance with its view that technical specifications
., a
- e c n.v
. c *.. e d _' a '. a.
. h." a a ',s,..k.a.
water chemistry and temperature need not be included in the amended operat-ing licensa.
.o.....n4 m..a o.o
- e. _ r. 2 _
C. 3,n,s
-,.._4-4..
2
.~
m.
y
=2,
- akas
_4s=ua. w d '. k.
- e A "y c a..n.' "cn.ad'-a sa.
emphasis on immediacy.
Cregon says that the Commission has not previously m.~..-,a,2w.d 2,~ u, n d,.- s a-a ov e-
.-roa n..g
.n.
m technical specifications and asserts in o n e C s _4 ~.4 c.e.
. u.e n< e n e a. =.m a.- A r u.a ~.
n
~-
yy w
wv yy
.. o..e
- e.n
- wp AC.
.e C w
- k. e.
.n o -,4.1 o - e. n.s a
n.
w...
i...
5
- s..ek.psa e
.4....ad_4_mcf.
C w. e. 3. n.
-n.
i, w ~ a. a-y.
e m.
- h..b o
- M.sh q *.
m..o *. a. w s 4 -_a
- b. p f % n..e.6. w. 7 _* 4.e
- 4%.
. _ _ e 4-w*a
.a--...]1
- gw
- k.. a.
1 4.cm.
e
- m m s
- -.n o
-.n.C o.
y w
Oc -w.
.12.-
v.e 2
a
.a4h,_n
_w.~.a 4
m w..
y--..w r...
L :. enn,4s. a-
-w.
c 4
a.,'.
C m. e. 3..
4 J
w...
.3 s.ag~e~e u w s wv..a.
- w o.
C v-...._4 s a.4
.r.
a a-. = w...4 - >
ou o..
- 4..' s. a.o
.e. u..A..s 4
.c, -
_4.... c ~.4
~. s a. w.. _
o 2
v.
y a
.3
.n..da a _7
- m p o..d.#.d a. a.J. C a-
.o.r.d n.#.es..ws ce... ~
J
.e ap.
O,w, e e..q u e m C
.~a w_
" ~ ".c a a. -.a.. =.. s, w ". a.
".. a.." '^a-a.d "y..
-o v.. a.
ae n 7 4 e m..e.
-w
. a. - - 2. a. a..r.
2. 3 m e...e w
ry.
v a
y.
Aa
-..m..- e..a.. o.. a. f a
a
-* %.a..m 8 a e A v m..r.s~
.n
-w
.r
~.
-4 4
.go.
.e m. p.3 -.n.e~
y.w g e p e,
w.k. 4..
- 2..* e.
..a 4
< ud s-a. d
.m a. e 3 a a"'I
~. *. Cbv'o'.^.
'.".a.
a
,e g 3.c-
_ _7 _4..i (w
.s. e
- 4.,j s..m.o. n..e )
JbJ w.a C., =. _.
..-_.c.--.....-.-_..=...
e _4
.__ _...- _ a _ e.._..,,, _.. _,,.
._a.
- k.. o. a,c. h ' _d b.o. o.
m..e. A
.c.s..y o.... _-. -...,. e
',. b..
e
....,.,,_s..,
1254 258
6 The NRC staff oppcses Cregon's peti-4 o n.ecw
. e../.4 a.e c e.
.# _2 4.,,,, e.oh,nus, w
-w 4
w-_.
arguing that the technical specifica-tiens proposed by Cregon "are simply not necessar'/ for the protection of
+he u.al w a.e.d s m.c a.../
v,.c
- h a.
wa o
p u., _4, t' w
o w
and wculd not be justified under either *he Appeal Ecard's standard er Cregon's proposed standard.
Thus the staff a'icids havine to take a fir y" o s.4 '." ^v n e r.
- u.ba " v.~ ~. a... ".e s a-c.e
- ". a.
w w
o a.,,.d.2.wa.. yj
.".:c a. A t -
ft.4...a. a _eo a., tt ayyea.1 9
ne.
w - o
-n
-s e a,.4 a..t a.
~..w.a u.ne aa.4, u
u -
4 s,. a.
ne a
w.
what the standard should be for inposing
. e o.u e..s,a,. s o e o t.e.4.,.,t a n e. o-
_4 -a s_4 -c.a.e4c
.e.r.
m
^
w v.
e.4 2.e.d ecw.-n/, o.c w,,......, a s. e, n
- o... a.c.
4 o n.
.r.e.
4
./.4 a..e
.e
~. u. a.
a s a., c.w./ w a.e..w.,. 4 o.e.s e n n,...... o s 4,,n
.e l m.x _a w a, s...
.x..a. n _, _> v, a n., e u
e v.
.w w....s p...e e.d a n*. e o_ w a.
w e m.., _4 w o A, * %. e c.,., a q
- 4...wn a
m vf.sh m*
.h..o s a-b e 4 m a.l t2 4 ad
- .e.
7.J.a n..e.s e
_d.e.
a o
a uw
. w.a..c.4 w. e.,
- n. a.
oc a.
.a u =.= o.#
aono_*de"a."w'_a.
4-
.. 3 w
......a.A 4.2 a.
_4,, u. e.w a e...a /..
va e a
.wa.a.
.a _4..w.
, u e w
u e
Appeal Ecard (and-with Crecon) that there has
"*<" n.o c'a.a."
o. c." ~ a.- d., k u ~. w a.
.o." a.
.". c o "--."a
~~~ d
...o
. w.a.., u.
te4.
ed4ac.f.
s-. a.,,.4 a.e d wa o.
- c. u. w../. w.a.
/
-a Appeal Ecard meets all the considerations w"..* c a h
." y ' _' ~... " ".. k.. a.
A ' r....* c 7..".a " ~ /'
a-. " =.
w 1
.u s.
A a.
.# c k,., 4
,.C e
e..w.a.
w a.4 4... O _h_. C.e
. w.e
.3..,
ea
.o.n - a. a. s
- ,o w o. m,4 w a.
. k. c.-...u.e
- a. c b..e. 4 a..o -
w s y. a..d _
p yy 3%.
'.w! n a,.4 e. n s
.2.m.n.,, A a.
c _'.'
2.a.
an6.d
.o..
C'e q
r 7 4
- e.7 s a.
G " "y '.#O a *..* c ". ^. "..
'# "..# * *. b. a.
?.^~..~...'.*w*.'. '. ".
_ w
~
y w
/
o t
w a.
Q. o..c. u.a
.e.
. 2 e, a. n..n
- a... w..,.1.,. _4-Q,4,2- _.
ow
. w C L.,
.w._.,
---e 6w Q
Q,G..
yy S. w d.
..e.
.# m C *o n o a.
70 C.#
C e m c o.4
- 4. 3n
.v
- n. w a. me. n. f s e a.. 4,
4**
q m
. 3.
y w
w
.o yy w
,.43.n
,Ca.
c o.o.c
.= J
., 7.
,,C,a. a, w.c-,
wa=
a, o.w. d. <,..w a.
..y_/,
. c.2 o,m, 9.,,.,
y.
't. w.. a.
4.e. _4.4 w...
.#.3._
o a e.a a. A.
.o..n. w_4.,Coe
.a
.c,
,a. n. w..,,.4,2.,
o-
-o w
q
-a
.iy 43 v-oy.p4*J
.. v.. e !? anu
.a 4
4-ft.. e. s. o. p r
??
.d
. % a.
p -..., 4... a s. w.. t q
_w J
4 J
-4
-e ea..
4
.n.
vw
- m. u o..,
_4,. a.
e.e
.o,y e.. A _4.e. g.
3. _ n o 4 e. e. a-
_4.q g, 4 n... w a. z,... o. ~A a.
a.
v w
a w.r...,7 3 -. k..o m. a. a. u. A..
k.a.
2. 2.# # 4 + a. s. - s+.-. C.... c...
- m...
-o p
.a ra mv C - a. e-s p t 3.
3_.4 4
c,
m
~ ' '.*.. e." ~ *.",. m$.
.C a..# a "j " 2. ' ' ~ a. d.."*."y"a.-
e 2
w 3
c. n. w w. 4 r e. c-aAe w,
. k. a. eLw7s..
_7 _4.,s.e.s a.
o n e _'442 4.. m..e. -
4
,a.
e-o w.
w y
o
. yy a.%. m.,., ' w
.e. n e.
'C p
~
_A w
. c L, % 2 a. n.
, M. e.e. 5
.d.
%. -,a, s
.e. a.
e.,%.*.2m.
e.n. _an a.
4 e
-. a w,
<w
. w yaw w
o.e.,A h.a. =o w.J.e. g-.
v y,i, v., w.
- 4..,=.4o. g
- o. '.# g w d. a. A b.,
- %. s.
Seemw
,,e
- J.. w. n..c a.
3.
- m. e. A,
a a.
wj w
s.
.... w
..4.
.= n C b, A. A e. w.A e.
p.
w w. - J
$g
- /
w
- q J = -,
J -
-e 9
. a... a. A. J C n.,. p
.O
- h. a.
v a.wq.,. 4 wg4
.A
_4 *, h. a.
- -._.[
,o e a.
J * *.
d
_w..
.w 4
.ww
..o
- w
... a.
A a. g-w a. s.
Y w..e. k..
o.
. r.e.
. w,, n. 4..-e..
-aw e
w 4,
.. m..'.4. s w e
.v o
w
}v. dw y.....
=Q b e e, e. d b..
- b.a.
w o. n m a. e p e..J v..Q-
=..=.J.a.
= %.,.
- J
.. w. e. c..e. $ k g *.w d ma.
4 e, c i
s.
w v M.
w wJ y.
.3.. G w
c..e. A - k. a.
ngk7Ja A... w d
. _ k. a.
e w g g a. a. A..J
... _.e y.
..e a.... a.b.
,.W. a.
,**")
e=
.*wJ
.g.o,
w y
w-.s s.
~
w w w G..e.a. A.
P C. P x-et
. a. n. s..
..a..e.A a A.
, %..o,..%. a
- ~ ~. ~...t.e : 2
%. s.-
.t e. _t.
n w
-e w-w s.
v..
v v
g 9
.g Q.
w9 9
.. Q... d.., 4 A.'.
...a
.-99..,
.g
- d.. 8 gg w.
--.. a
7 D.anec s
- e~~. *.*.* *., a.". 'w
= a.1 _' _= n. n. '.. n....d '.". e~
'. ". a ~.
1 the plant may operate safely, not just these w e l_a e..a.n.3 ~. o.< m...e d.4 a ~.,, s a.c
~ h.m a. a~. s.
_ s.
- a. n,e/
o may fairly be arzued that before a licensee can significantly depart from the procedures and specifications which formed the basis for a
1
~.
o ". _* s*.* n.a _' '..* c a.".s a.
" ha. " u "a..* a. as s"ar..7 z,
- v."s.
y well as the Cctmission should have an gpper-tunity to review the prcposed changes.1p In sum, we believe there is enouzh uncer-
- a.*.*.*.*] " a s a"d '.".s--. k.e a d a. e" a e.v ^ '..".e
., o a.~ d ' s.'. "..e <* ' _a n. ]' " s $ ".da."d
- v^
m n a e.2,
.y terit Cetmission attention.
As with the
, n,t..~ n
- a..,. *. a,. 4 s n,,a. s. e _4 s e d
.4...
.n_4 s
,2
-a.,
4
-2 however, the technical specifications issue, insofar as it has significance worthy of
. s
- 3. a.a.."
- c
- h e C c ". 7.. ' s s." c r. '.s
- m. '.. a. n..* ^.*.,
- a.
mm
,4 4
n ccu,a
- 2. a..,.
%...u s, a h.4., a n,
.w...a
.. o
.e
. ~.
ad d"a s s '. h i s c,a.".a. ".* ^ _ s o u a.
=,,
h ' s '. '... a.,
e c c ~. ~..a..a.d
. "._o.,
". e I' c ~..~...' o' s.' c. "..
N. a. dc..oe attempt to rasclve the question by rev'ew of ALA3-531.F instead, we recccmend w.. o.
- w. a. W..~..." s s.* r. ". a. s " e *.,*.
a_ o w a.'. * * ' a.#
-w
- w..
e
- v. e d a c- *." _S * * '.d.'/ a.".d
.#.n. e y. g
.w a. p-o.w d.
- g
- w J
s u.' a h _' a.
~ v 0"y e o.#
_S
."" _' a. "..a ' ~ '.. ~ a _#..a. d
_S.
"5 w
r_/
a-ngo*
"w nyy __
=.C a.wa e
.w 4--4 y.. e., C.4 4
s
- n. o, -....e
...a.
pw
...e
. a..l. a. w
_ca.3....
w
.3.
_43 m a a. n u g *. e
- v-3 3 c uw s.
o a. a. ', J' Wh.a..".
..".a.
'..# ^ a. ".s a. a.
-.a e'*.a a'
- a. b.a n z_, a..c.
3
..w.a a e
- r. e,.. 4,o.c1.,a.
4.,t...a. s. a. a.
. w w a 2. a-g.r,.
C, c a a,m. e., o.
- w. a.
mv e
.e.s.e.
- w.. e.,
.w.e p u.w 7 _e, v s w.e.w.*.
v-
,, a. a L, a..z. 2.. a. 2.w.e.. 3,
.w..a.sp
.a w
g v..
o.
7.a.e.
... 7 s..e..,. w.a.
o.. 3.,, -a
_2. _ z,.e.. a.
2.,, a.
e.
- 4. w. a.. s-a s 4
..e
..w. a.
.a
~, a_,, u.e. 4 a O a. C.d.e.4,a ~,_4 n,,.e ren
.u.a.
,,..u. a..w
.u. s
.,I a.
,,~,p
~. u.. c- ~.
s.., -.e. a,
,.o.
..v
.o
.. a.= w,s
- a../. h.e e uik ' _4 a a a.n.
_e.1 c.,, _e _4.=. a.
w J -
4
_m.2, as -.
2..r.f, c
m..
w..
m
. 4.. a..
7 0 r. 7.. -. O F., 4..
o--
2.l
- ..n.
. k. _e -d v e g a.,
6ga. w a. g e w A,.
a' w
4
..a.a.
w.. o ", ~. 'a. n w o_, s..w
.a w a.... c.. j
- w 3 ~~w" e
2 w.
.e d
'i '. e. s ' '.' "
- r. a. ".. c a " 'o.o.
.A.m.
- 2 4. *. O.2.#* a.
_o.'.'
9'fa. q.
g ". ~s,1 ' a- "a.l *]
4
~
- t..
)
s
-a4x*a
.c M.M 4u - 4,. v.
- w
... a.
w a..g *.
y..a.w 4.... =. 4.q
.fw.a. w...a..
- wQ, oc y 4
y.
q e.
q
,g w
g
...3
...a.
. a..,w..
_44,,29
...o.
. e w..e w_e-a w.. rws-me a c n 7.. A a A 4
.w
.o_c.A
-.,-w-
- - wa wj s.
-b***
<* S - - s
--*- - ^~*---
w..r..e s.
..
- k _J - nac-a
... o.
O m., c.w A. 3.. 4..a.,
- 4. 4. ~ w a. = J
., w. a
'..d
,a
- w 4
. n3 3
a w..
v a
w w
_s
- . m.
- m. A.
. w.. a
. a..e.
4.e
~ w.a
'.4,m a.,. s a a.
- n. u...e.e. g-a pwe.
~. a.,. w..e. e... a. 2 4.,.
n y, g... '.4 m
-w w
24
. w..e.,
3yy.wr. 4f.. 2.
2
,n.,. a. v. J o,a.
wa a
a w. g d.. ~j
...a.
.n.
.v n
v.
.'.nm
,4**
- a. r., v e _' 4
.. a.' s.
.a,. s. a-... w e s, m i, 9 A. ke h,,= e'. o.r.
- a..r ^ w o.
.o..m.
43 w
-c*
u u v
- 22.#w..,,1 '. !.'_4_ \\.
- a..y #
.O e a.
7 9,,
8 7. %..
O S. O,"..
.t 2. a.
o _.=. e.
- 7. v*
e'.7 .-
~
J c..
sv s 3
e 1M4 260
8 formulating a standard for imposing tech-nical specific &tions to resolve this lack of regulatcry clarity.
A draft memorandum to the staff is attached.
3 m
, g-ammons James A. -?'itzgerald Assistant General Ccunsel Attachments:
1.
ALA3-531 2.
Draft Crder 3.
Draft me=c to staff Corm 11ssioners' ccmments or consent should be provided directly to i.he Office of the Secretary by c.o.b. Friday, July 13, 1979.
Comissica Staff Office comments, if any, should be submitted to the Commissioner; NLT July 9,1979, with an information copy to the Office of the Secretary.
If tre paper is of such a nature that it requires additional time for analytical review and comment, the Commissicners and the Secretariat should be apprised of when commentscomments may be expected.
This paper is tentatively schel en for affirmation at an Open Meeting during the Week of July 16, 1979.
Please refer to the appropriate Weekly Ccmmission Schedule, when published, for a specific date and time.
DISTRIBUTICN Comissioners Corm 11ssion Staff Offices Secretariat 1254 261
/
l
.w
-