ML19256B492
| ML19256B492 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | South Texas, Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 06/12/1979 |
| From: | Poirier M SPIEGEL & MCDIARMID |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19256B493 | List: |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7907170117 | |
| Download: ML19256B492 (18) | |
Text
N n3
%rouw
/
u oyl$
b.Q o
UNITED STATES OF" AMERICA Nf (1 g S lPM
\\
~
BEFORE THE
]
QY dhh
]
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
e m
)
HOUSTON LIGHTING AND POWER CO.
)
Docke t Nos.h0-498A et al.
)
and[50-499A
)
(South Texas Project, Unit Nos.
)
1 and 2)
)
)
)
)
TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING
)
Docke t Nos. 50-445A COMPANY, et al.
)
and 50-446A
)
(Comanche Peak Steam Electric
)
Station, Unit Nos. 1& 2)
)
)
)
TO:
Marshall E.
Miller, Esq., Chairman Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Panel APPLICATION FOR ISSUANCE OF SUBPOENA The Public Utilities Board of the City of Brownsville,
(" PUB") pursuant ta 10 C.F.R S2.720, hereby resubmits its application for the issuance of the Subpoena for Production of Documents attached hereto to the Keeper of Records, El Paso Electric Company.
PUB first submitted an application for the issuance of a subpoena for production of documents to El Paso Electric Company on March 14, 1979 (A tachment).
The Board has neither issued to subpoena nor denied the earlier application.
The dccuments requested are relevant to the effects en actual and potential competition of intrastate-only restric-tions, including the participation agreement governing the generating units that are the subject of this proceecing.
CE) 19c27 (;po u 1 835 2'65
- The requests relate to actual and potential joint actions and tre.nsac tions involving El Paso Electric Company ("El Paso"),
a utility located partly in Texas and operating in interstate commerce, and municipally, cooperatively, and privately owned electric systems located in Texas, including those electric systems that are parties to this proceeding.
Areas addressed include potential joint generation (including nuclear plants); potential transmission service, interconnections and interconnected operation; potential s=
of power by El Paso to utilities in Texas; actual studies and other documents relating to advantage of interstate and intrastate operation; and other documents relating to competition of various typt s between electric utilities in Texas.
The Public Utilities Board of the City of Brownsville, Texas requests this Board to siga the enclosed subpoena F.J return it to the undersigned at Spiegel & McDiarmid,
Washington, D.
C.
Respectfully submitted, s
I. i
~c\\ - ~.
,u s Marc R.
Poirier One of the Attorneys for the Public Utilities Board of the City of Brownsville, Texas SPIEGEL & MCDIARMID 2600 Virginia Avenue, N.
W.
Washington, D.
C.
20037 (202) 333-4500 June 12, 1979 8 [p')
26()
Subpoena For Production of Documents UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Matter of
)
)
HOUSTON LIGHTING AND POWER COMPANY
)
Docket Nos. 50-498A THE CITY OF SAN ANTONIO
)
50-499A THE CITY OF AUSTIN and
)
CENTRau POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY
)
)
(South Texas Project, Units Nos.
)
1 and 2)
)
SUBPOENA TO:
Keeper of the Records El Paso Electric Company 303 North Oregon Street El Paso, Teas 79901 YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to make available for inspection and copying at 303 North Oregon Street in the city of El Paso, Texas on the 9th day of July, 1979 the doc ument ( s ) or objects (s) described in the attached schedule.
836 267
Subpcena for Production of Documents Page Two BY CRDER OF THE ATOM:' SAFETY AND LICENSING SCARD BY 1979 Marc R.
Poirier Attorney for the Public Utilities Ecard cf the City of Brownsville, Texas SPIEGEL & McDIARMID 2600 Virginia Avenue NW Washington, D.C.
20037 (202) 333-4500 10 C.F.R. 2.720(f)
On motion made promptly, and in any event at er before the time specified in the subpoena f or cc=pliance by the person to whom the sub-poena is directed, and on notice to the party at whose instance the subpoena was issued, the presiding officer cr, if he is unavailable, the Commission may (1) quash or modify the sub-poena if it is unreasonable er requires evidence not relevant to any matter in issue, or (2) cen-dition denial of the motion en just and reasonable terms.
835 268
SCHEDULE TO SUBPOENA FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS 1.
Please produce maps sufficient to indica te all actual and project sd El Paso Electric Company ("El Paso")
transmission and subtransmission lines located within the State of Texas.
2.(a)
Produce all documents relating to each offer of particpation in any nuclear electric generating unit, made or received by El Paso.
Exclude documents solely concerning contract negotiations or power supply planning for applicable units.
(b) Produce all offers, inquiries and principal policy documents and analyses relating to participation, actual or potential, by any electric utility in the South Texas Units, including the terms and conditions, limitations or restrictions of such participation.
3.
Please produce all documents relating to transmission services, actual or potential, by El Paso to any electric utility that is a member of ERCOT or that is located in whole on in part in Texas.
Please note that transmission services as defined includes transmission of power and/or energy generated by El Paso.
836 269 4.(a)
Please produce all documents rel:.cing co pclicy for interconnection and/or interconnected operation cf El Pase with any other electric utility located in whole or in part in Texas.
Exclude routine billing and log data.
(b)
Please produce copies of any interconnection agreements entered into between El Paso and any other eleccric utility located in whole or in part in Texas.
(c)
Please produce all other contracts or agreements between El Paso and any municipally er cooperatively owned and/or cperated electric utility.
5.(a)
Please produce all documents relating to policy for the sale of power, actual, planned or potential, or to establishing terms for the sale of power, frc= El Paso to any electric utility located in whole or in part in Texas.
Exclude billing and leg data.
835 270
_3_
(b)
Pler.se produce all documen:s relating te policy fer participatien, actual, planned er potential, er to establishing terms for any participation, by any electric utility located in whole er in part in Texas in any generation fac. ity of which El Paso is whole or part owner.
6.
Please produce all studies and analyses relating to the pcwer supply, transmissien recuirements, and/cr competitive pesi-tien cf any municipally or cecperatively owned and/or operated electric utility located in whole or in part within the State of Texas.
7.
Please produce the rates of El Pase for all classes of customers since January 1, 1970.
8.(a)
Please produce all principal documents relating to each reason for which El Paso does not operate in synchro-nism with a.9; electric utility tha't i: a member of TIS.
(b)
Please produce all documents relating to the relative advantages to any electric utility of cperating solely within the State of Texas and operating in inters. tate cc=merce.
e'9 4
8% U\\
(c)
Please prcduce all dccuments relating c any study or repcrt by any electric utility, er by any state or federal agency that regulates electric utilties, the subject cf which relates to, in whole or in part, potential cperation of any electric utility or utilities actually cperating solely within tne State of Texas so as to place such utility or uti-lities into interstate commerce.
( For purposes of this request, cperation in interstate commerce includes the defi-nition in FPC v.
Florida Power & Licht Co.,
404 U.S.
453 (1972). )
This request includes documents relating to com-mmunications between El Paso and any cther electric utility relating to any study or report described above.
9.
Please furnish a copy of any informatica or docu-ments provided formally or informally to any party or agency (including CP&L, WTU, PSO, SWEPCO, CSW, TP&L, DP&L, TESCO, TU, EL&P, the Texas Public Utilities Cc= mission, the United States Department of Justice, the Staff cf the United States Nuclear Regulatcry Cc= mission) relating to any of the following proceedings:
(a)
In the Matter of Housten Lighting & Power Cc. _et
a e e tus wn (b) In the Matter of Texas Utilities Generating Ccmpany (Comanche Peak Steam Electric Statien, Un:.:s 1 and 2), NRC Oceke Nos. 50-445A and 50-446A; (c) In the Matter of C_entral end South West Cerroration, e-
_al., SCE Administrative Proceeding File No. 3-4951; (d) West Texas Utilities Cem=anv et al.
v.
Texas Electric Service Compan et al., No. CA3-76-0633F, United States District Court (N.D. Texas, Dallas Division) ;
(e) In the Matter of the E=ercencv Eearing en I:.trastate and Interstate Service of Texas Interconnected Sys'.em, Docket No. 14, Public Utilities Commission of Texas.
(f) Central Power & Licht et al., FIRC Docket No. EL 79-8.
INSTRUCTIONS The period of time for which docunents are recuested includes the entire pericd from January 1,1965 to the date of which docu-ments are made available for inspection and copying to the Public Utilities Ecard of the City of Brownsville, Texas ( " Browns ville " )
or its representatives.
Brownsville requests that the Keeper cf the Records identify the specific request er requests to which each document is respen-sive.
Where pessihle, the Keeper of the Records is requested to maintain the intergrity of El Pase's filing and recerfkeeping systems by prcducing together dccuments respens:.ve :c this Sub-pcena, which are found together in the Keeper cf the Reccrd's files.
- +
. If ycu claim that any dccumen: recuested hereunder is privileged, with respect te each such dccuments, plea:e pre-vide the fellowing:
(a) date; (b) type of document; (c) identity of author and addressee; (d) present location and custodian; (e) any other description necessary to enable the custodian to locate the particular document; (f) the basis for the claimed privilege; and (g) a detailed description of the na:ure of any judicial protection alleged to be necessary to protect the privilege or confidential nature of any such document.
DEFINITIONS A.
" Documents" mean all writings and records of every type in the actual or constructive possession, centrol, er custody of El Paso, its directors, cfficers, employees, con-sultants, or agents, including but not limited to centracts, memcranda, correspondence, reports, surveys, tabulations, charts, books, pamphlets. photographs, maps, bulletins, minu-tes, notes, diaries, icg sheets, ledgers, transcripts, micro-film, ccmputer printouts, vouchers, accounting statements, telegrams and telegraphic cc=munica:1 ens, engineering diagrams (including "ene-line diagrams"), nechanical and electrical reccrdings, reccrda cf telephcne ccmmunicaticns,
speeches and all other records, wri::en, electrical, mechani-cal, cr c:hervise.
9J$
}jf P
E 051 OD
~ - ~
pan A
t, e-*
t u.;:
!d U' lc a y 4
'q UdB G
_7_
"Occuments" shall also mean ecpies of dccuments, even though the originals thereof are not in the possession, cus:cdy, or control of El Paso, and every copy of a document which contains handwritten er other ncs tions; cr which in any other manner does not duplicate the criginal, er any other copy furnished pursuant to this request.
B.
" Communications" shall include, without limiting the generality of its meaning, all conversations bet?een two or persons either in person or by telephone, all state-mort ments, speeches, declaratiens and comments, ar.d shall include documents as defined in A.
above.
C.
" Person" shall mean any natural person, company, association, firm, corporation, cooperative, rural electric cooperative, municipslity, joint stock associatien, or any r elitical subdivisio t, agency or instrumentality of the federal, state, or m:nicipal governments, or a lawful asso-ciation of any of the foregoing, or any entity that produces, generates, transmits, distributes, purchases, sells, or fur-nishes electricity.
g\\
835 2/5
m en
~
?? ?.'ss.
Where more than one request in this series asks for identification cf a document, cc==unication, legal entity, er persen, in respense :: the second and subsequent
- requests, please provide the name cf a ccrpcration, lec.al entity c:
persen, cr the date and autner er =aker cf a decc=ent er ec==unicatien, along with a reference :: the respense in wnich a full identifica:icn was provided.
y76
_[
J
- I v
_9_
E.
" Representative" shall be understood te include, without limitine. the c.eneralitv. cf its meaning, any direc:cr, Officer, em levee, centracter, or censultant, of anv cerson as defined in C.,
who at a particular fermal or infermal meeting, er in a particular document or ce=municatien, appears to participate n the =eeting, or in the making of or the receipt of the document er cc=munication, en behalf of er as agent for, said person.
Whether or not a representative has actual authcrity as an agent of the person is irrelevant to his or her status as a representative.
F.
" Relating to" or " relate" means censisting of, referring to, reflecting, or beine. in any wav lec. ally, logically er factually connected with.
Requests " relating te" a sub-ject er item shculd be understced to include possible or con-templated actions as to such subject or item.
For example, a request for documents relating to interconnection plans would include dccuments relating to intercennection arrangements that have been considered but rejected.
G.
" Electric utility" means a private corporation, cecc.erative, rural electric cocperative, municin.alitv., i. c in t stcck association, er any political suhdivisien, agencv. c:
instrumentality of federal, state, or municipal governments, er a lawful asscciation of any cf the foregcing tha: cwns, centrcls, er cr.erates, er c. re. ceres er is studv. ine. the c. e s s i-
-4 4.-
e
- w..<. -,
e...
3 4..c.,
e, 4
<-4 ee..
4.e.,
c-----
3 the genera:ica, transmission and/cr. distributien of 3 '3 ?/7 e....
Q W,t u. Q p' -
/~' l%,. f] 3.2 q p y p3 7
pq
.c
?
transmission and/cr subtransmission systems of the electric 41
+n utilities in the same manner as electricity ficws along the 4i32,)
WT1 lines of an individual electric system, whether er net such ESNnd tzy m flew of electricity occurs pursuant tc the ter=s cf an inter-
,mjh a
m.:
cennecticn : reement.
" Interconnected operatien" includes
--o#-
wa all f nr:s Of ::.terchange, including sales, purchases er
{ygg wo exccanc.e c:. e n e re. v. cr cacac;tv, reserves sn.a r : n e., ::r= =cwer, 3
e = e r c. e n c v., maintenance, seascnal, scenc=y exchange, s inninc.
835 2/8
( t r i,lo4 E h f313Q RR D.:
'l ff
- 4. w. o. <, n !, n. q qA
_3 _, -
- ' yu v d ub c :gy.g; a
a3 J
y;j reserves and any similar transactions.
"Intercennectien agreemen:" shall mean an agreemen:
governing the rates, metering, and other ter s and conditiens under which interconnected operatien cccurs.
J.
"The Electric C0=pany (El Paso Electric Ccmpany)"
or "El Paso" shall be understeed to include its parent, direct er indirect subsidiary, affiliated, or predecesser companies and any entities providing electric service at wholesale er retail, the properties or assets of whch have heen acquired by El Paso.
K.
" Central Power & Light Ccmpany" cr "CP&L" shall be understecd to include its parent, direct or indirect sub-sidiary or predecessor companies and any entities providing electric service at wholesale or retail, the properties or assets of which have been acquired by CP&L.
L.
"Ecuston Lighting & Power Ccmpany" cr "EL&P" shall be understood to include its parent, direct er indirect sub-sidiary, affiliated, er predecessor companies and any enti-ties providing electric service at wholesale er retail, the crocerties er assets of which have been ccquired bv EL&P.
~
~
~
835 2/9 M.
" Texas Pcwer & Light C =pany" cr "CP&L" shall be
- nderstecd t include its preent, direct er indirect sub-sidiary, afdiliated, er predecelscr cc=panies and any enti-ties previding eletric service at whclesale er retail, the properties 0: assets Of which have been acquired by TPEL, N.
" Callas Pcwer & Light Cc=pany" cr "OP&L" shall be understeed 0 include its parent, direc cr indirect subsidiary affiliated, er predecesor cc panies and any entities pre-
~. i d.i.. -, e ec..4.e se.-v. ice a. whc.iesa'a
.a...=.'
..".a.
- - -. a.. -
ties er assets of which have been acquired by OP&L.
O.
" Texas Electric Service Cc==. anv. " cr "TI. SCC" shall be understecd to include its parent, direct er indirect sub-s idiary, af filiated, or predecessor cc=panies and any enti-ties providing electric service at wholesale er retail, the prcperties er assets of which have been acquired by TISCO.
P.
" West Texas Utilities" cr "WTU* shall be understecd to include its parent, direct or indirect subsidiary, affil-iated, er.credecessor cc=panies and any entities revidinc.
e electric service at wholesale er retail, the prcperties er assets of which have been acquired by WT.U.
Q.
"Scuthwestern Electric Power Ccmranv." c: "SWIPCC" shall be understecd to include its parent, direct er indirect subsidiary, affiliated, or predecessor ccmpanies and any entities.crevidinc. electric service at wholesale er retail, the properties or cssets of which have been acquired by SWEPCO.
R.
"Public Service Ccmpany of Oklahcma" cr "?SO" shall be unders:ced to include its parent, direct er indirect sub-s.'.'.' =.-v., a.'.#.i.'.' a. a. d, ~ ~ ~ ~. =. d a. c = s a -.
---, a...' a s a..^ a.. "; =.....' -
. 4 a.,
-..y4;4
.. t a..... e se 4.-a.
a' ho'asa'a. ^ -. =.. =.#.1,
'. a.
e.~.4a.s
~~- =sae.s c.
w".
c
...=va.
". e a...
=
--. d c m '. - =.. ' v, r.-
Service Cc=pany c f Oklahcma.
gj j /8[]
h jh) bI,
~[1 g
- Q n
- s...r W
. m.,,w u
o ca...,, -
.cu-Wes* "-..c.=..'-.."
- * " = "n '
a.'.=--
-~
. a.
a
... d o..... c d..
4 atoAe 4. a-a.-=....,
- d..'. *. C. -.
...d..' -*.c. -"-'~ s.'.#.* '.*v,,
.a y
.$......S
- AW Q
.M W a
5g 8
3...
g M...
.N
.MM
...s 7..
g w
g y.
--..y
,.444
- o. T a c.. 4.
se..4=a
.-b..e i a..q a t,
. a.. s.' '
- ". a.
. w. a.. e.
3=
-i3-ies er assecs Of which have been acquired by CS'd.
T.
" Texas Utilities" er "TU" shall mean Texas Utilities Generating Company, its parent, affiliated, direct er indirect subsidiary and all predeceaser cc=panies, including, but not limited to, Texas Utilities Company, Dallas Power &
Light Company, Texas Electric Service Company and Texas Power
& Light Company.
U.
" South Texas Units" shall be understood to refer to the nuclear generating units for which applicants in the above-captioned proceeding have obtained a construction per-mit frem the Nuclear Regulatcry Commission.
4 a
.e rm. e.te.Js CN c r. n,?v ar e
Received this subpcena at
............................ en and Cn
.............. at served it on the Within named
......... by delivering a copy to h.....
and tei.dering to h... the fee for cne day's attendance and the mileage allowed by law.
Dated 19..
By.......
Service Fees Travel
.............. S Services S
Total.................S Subscribed and sworn to before me, a this........ day of 19......
$+%
835 282
ATTACHMENT LAW CF8 acts SPIEGEI. & McDI.AR3IID 26CO VIRGINIA AVENUE. N.W.
WASHINGTON. D.C. 20037 TELEoMONE (202) 333 ASCC RC B E RT C. WCOI APMIO TELECCPIE R (2C2) 33.4 2974 RCS E R* M A RLEY SEAR S ANORA J STRESEL TMCwAS C TRAUGER RO B E RT A. JA B LCN
.'C MN MICM A E L AO RAG N A JAMES N MCRWCCO CYNTMIA S SCGORAD AJN J. RCTM WASSACMWS E'?S Sa# Q%U 84ANCES 3. FRANCl3 G A R* J. N EWE L.
D ANIEL 1. D AVIOSON M A RC R. PCiRIE R THCM AS N McMUGM. JR.
O ANIEL J. GUTTM AN SETE R st M AN O A VIO 4. STRAUS March 14, 1979 Chase R.
Stephens, Chief Docketing and Service Section U.
S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.
C.
20555 RE:
Houston Lighting & Power Company, et al., (South Texas Pro]ect, Unit Nos. 1 and 2), Docket Nos.
50-498A and 50-499A; Texas Utilities Generating Comoany, et al., (Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station, Unit Nos. 1 and 2), Docke t Nos.
50-445A and 50-446A r
k
Dear Mr. Stephens:
N The Application for Issuance of Subpoena for the Production of Documents by El Paso Electric Company filed by a
the Public Utilities Board of the City of Brownsville, Texas
("Brownsville") in the above-captioned proceedings en March 13, 1979 was inadvertently not served on all parties as indi-cated on the certificate of Service attached thereto, although copies of the Appi1 cation for Issuance of Subpoena were mai; ed, first class, postage prepaid, to The Electric Cc=pany ( El Paso Electric Company).
Enclosed for the files are forty-two copies of the Application for Issuance of Subpoena with an Affirmation of Service attached reflecting that it was today served ca all parties.
We regret any incenvenience this may have caused.
Verv. trulv. veurs, fr-x wa Susan G. White
/
/
i
Enclosure:
j As Stated D
3 c'T m.
p
.a
. e0 3
so cc:
All Parties 13O D(o 2]l 7
wee B h.,
7_8s
CNITED STATES OF AMERICA r.eOPe
..e. r c.
s L C. r.me.
.m e. G J, n-m. r u.v.
Cn.v u.
.e.e. t. mJ
~
v.
o w
In the Matter of
)
)
ECCSTCN LIGET!NG AND PCWER CO.,
)
Cocke: Ncs. 50-498A et al.
)
50-499A
)
(South Texas Project, Units
)
No. 1 and 2)
)
)
)
TEXAS CTILITIES GENERATING
)
Dockets Nos. 50-445A C C M r J. N Y, et al.
)
50-466A
)
(Cemanche Peak Steam Electric
)
S ta tien, Units 1 and 2)
)
TO:
Marshall E.
Miller, Esq., Chairman Atemic Safety & Licensing Board Panel APPLICATION FOR ISSUANCE OF SU3POENA The Public Utilities Board of the City of Brownsvillc, Texas, pursuant to 10 C.F.R.
52.720, hereby makes applica:icn for the issuance of the Subpcena for Production of Documents attached hereto to the Keeper of Records, The Electric C0=pany ( El Pasc Electric Cem=. anv).
The documents requested are relevant to the ef fects en actual and potential cceretition of intrastate cnly restric-t i. e n s, including the ticipaticn agree =ent governing the generating units that are the subject cf th.s proceeding.
The requests relate :
actual and pctencial jcin: actions and transactions invciving The Electric Ccmpany (El Pase Electric Ccepany), a utili:y 1ccated partly in Texas and cperating in
'jj 2dk
~
D 9 fgl '
u} a u A ]
d P,nors4 DD'Mua
, g! '
~ "1 y
-- nterstate ec merce, and municipal'y, cccpe.ra tively, and pri-vately :,wned electric systems located in Texas, including those electric systens that are parties to this preceeding.
Areas addressed inclade pctential joint generatien (including nuclear plants); potential transmission service, interconnec-tions and intercennected operatien; potential sale of power by El Paso to utilities in Texas; actual studies and other documents relating to advantage cf interstate and intrastate operation; and other dccuments relating to cc= petition of various types between electric utilities ir Texas.
The Public Utilities Board of the City of Brcwnsville, Texas requests this Board to sign the enciesed subpoena and return it to the undersigned at Spiegel &
McDiarmid, Washington, D.C.
Respectfully submitted, 4A (
Marc R.
Po rier One of the Attorneys for the Public Utilities Ecard cf the City Of B rownsv ille, Texas c e. r _r -r_ * &
.v.C D. a n,_= M.-,
.. u 2600 Virginia Avenue, N.W.
Washingten, D.C.
20037 (202) 333-4500 k
Cated:
?. arch 13, 1979 s
8~v 2 8< '<,
G s.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ATTACHMENT BEFORE THE NUCLEAR REGULATORY CCMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFE *Y AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
EOUSTON LIGHTING & PCWER CCMPANY,
)
Docket Nos. 50-498A et al.
)
and 50-499A
)
( South Texas Project, Unit Nos.
)
1 and 2)
)
)
)
)
In the Matter of
)
Docket Nos. 50-445A
)
and 50-446A TEXAS UTILITIES GENERATING COMPANY,)
et al.
)
)
( Comanche Peak Steam Electric
)
Station, Unit Nos. 1 and 2 )
)
AFFIRMATION OF SERVICE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, ss:
I, SUSAN G. WEITE, being firs: duly sworn, affirm that copies of the foregoing APPLICATION FOR ISSUANCE OF SUBPOENA in the above-captioned proceeding have this 14th day of March,1979 been served upon the following persons by deposit in the U. S. mail, first class, postage prepaid.
Marshall E.
Miller, Chairman Joseph J.
Saunders, Esquire Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Chief, Public Counsel &
Panel Legislative Section Nuclear Regulatory Ccmmission Department of Justice Washington, D.
C.
20555 P.
O. Box 14141 Washington, D.
C.
20044 Shelden J.
Wolfe, Esquire Atomic Safety & Licensing Board Jcseph Gallo, Esquire Panel Richard D.
Cudahy, Esquire Nuclear Regulatory Cctmission Robe rt E.
Loe f fle r, Esquire Washington, D.
C.
20555 Isram, Lincoln & Beale Suite 701 Michael L.
Glaser, Esquire 1050 17 th Stree t,
N.
W.
1150 17th Street,
N.
W.
Washington, D.
C.
20036 Washington, D.
C.
20036 835 286 John D.
Whitler, Esquire Joseph nutberg, Esquire Ronald Clark, Esquire Antitrust Counsel Department of Justice Counsel for NRC Staff P.
O.
Ecx 14141 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.
C.
20044 Washing cn, D.
C.
20555 Joseph Knotts, Esquire Chase R.
Stephens, Chief Nicholas S.
Reynolds, Esquire Docketing and Service Section Debevoise & Liberman Office of the Secretary 1200 17th Street,
N.
W.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.
C.
20036 Washington, D.
C.
20555 Douglas F.
John, Esquire Joseph I.
Worsham, Esquire Akin, Gump, Hauer & Feld Merlyn D.
Sampels, Esquire 1100 Madison Office Building Worsham, Forsythe & Sampels 1155 15th Street, N.
W.
2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 2500 Washington, D.
C.
20024 Dallas, Texas 75201 R.
Gordon Gooch, Esquire Spencer C.
Relyea, Esquire John P.
Mathis, Esquire Worsham, Forsythe & Sampels Baker & Botts 2001 Bryan Tower, Suite 2500 1701 Pennsylvania Avenue,
N.
W.
Dallas, Texas 75201 Washington, D.
C.
20006 R.
L.
Eancock, Director Robert Lowenstein, Esquire City of Austin Electric J.
A.
Ecuknight, Jr.,
Esquire Otility Department Lowenstein, New=an, Reis &
P.
O.
Box 1088 Axelrad Austin, Texas 78767 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N. W.
Washington, D.
C.
20036 Jerry L.
Harris, Esquire City Attorney William J.
Franklin, Esquire City of Austin Lowenstein, Ne wman, Reis &
P.
O.
Box 1088 Axelrad Austin, Texas 78767 1025 Connecticut Avenue,
N.
W.
Washing ton,
D.
C.
20036 Richard C.
Balough, Esquire Assistant City Attornev Frederick E.
Ritts, Esquire City of Austin
~
Law Of fices of Northcutt Ely P.
O. Box 1088 Watergate 600 Building Austin, Texas 78767 Washington, D.
C.
20037 Dan E.
Davidson Wheatley & Wolleson City Manager 1112 Watergate Office Euilding City of Austin 2500 Virginia Avenue,
N.
W.
P.
O.
Box 1083 Washing cn, D.
C.
20037 Austin, Texas 73767 835 287 Roff Eardy, Chairman and Chief Don R.
Butler, Esquire Executive Officer Sneed, Vine, Wilkerson, Selman Central Power & Light Ccmpany
& Perry P.
O.
Box 2121 P.
O.
Box 1409 Corpus Christa, Texas 78403 Austin, Texas 78767 G.
K.
Spruce, General Manger Morgan Hunter, Esquire City Public Service Board McGinnis, Lochridge & Kilgore P.
O.
Box 1771 900 Ccagress Avenue San Antonio, Texas 78203 Austin, Texas 78701 Jon C. Wood, Esquire Kevin B.
Pratt, Esquire W.
Roger Wilson, Esquire Assistant Attor.ney General Matthews, Nowlin, Macfarlane P.
O.
Box 1254 8
& Barrett Capital Station 1500 Alamo National Buildi;;g Austin, Texas 78711 San Antonio, Texas 78205 Linda L.
Aaker, Esquire Perry G.
Brittain, President Assistant astorney General Texas Utilities Generating P.
O.
Box 12548 Company Capital Station 2001 Brysn Tower Austin, Texas 78711 Dallas, Texas 75201 E.
W.
Barnett, Esquire John E. Ma the ws, Jr., Esquire Charles G.
Thrash, Jr.,
Esquire Mathews, Osborne, Ehrlich, Baker & Botts McNatt, Gobelman & Cobb 3000 One Shell Plaza 1500 American Eeritage Life Bldg.
Houston, Texas 77002 Jacksonville, Florida 32202 J.
Gregory Copeland, Esquire Robert E.
Bathen Theodore F.
Weiss, Jr.,
Esquire R.
W.
Beck & Associates Baker & Botts 1.
O.
Box 6817 3000 One Shell Plaza Orlando, Florida 82803 Ecuston, Texas 77002 Somervell County Public Library G.
W.
Oprea, Jr.
P.
C.
Box 417 Executive Vice President Glen Rose, Texas 76403 Housten Lighting & Power Ccmpany P.
O.
Box 1700 Maynard Human, General Manager Ecuston, Texas 77001 Western racmers Electric Coop.
P.
O.
Ecx 429 Anadarko, Oklahoma 73005 835 288 W.
S.
Robson, General Manager South Texas Electric Cooperative,
Inc.
James E.
Monahan Route 6,
Building 102 Executive Vice President and Victoria Regional Airport General manager Victoria, Texas 77901 Brazos Electric Power Ccop., Inc.
P.
O.
Box 6296 Michael I.
Miller, Esquire Waco, Texas 76706 Richard E.
Powell, Esquire Isham, Lincoln & Beale Judith Earris, Esquire One First National Plaza Department of Justice Chicago, Illinois 60603 P.
O.
Box 14141 Washington, D.
C.
20044 David M.
Stahl, E quire Thomas G.
Ryan, Esquire Jerome Saltzman, Chief Isham, Lincoln & Beale Antitrust & Indemnity Group One First National Pla::a Nuclear Regulatory Ccmmission Chicago, Illinois 60603 Washington, D.
C.
20555 Knoland J.
Plucknett Jay M.
Galt, Esquire Executive Director Looney, Nichols, Johnson &
Ccemittee on Power for the Hayes Scutnwest, Inc.
219 Couch Drive 5541 Skelly Drive Oklahema City, Oklahoma 73101 Tulsa, Oklahoma 74135
.J
/
x{
WA Susan G.
White SUBSCRIBED AND FWORN TO before me, a Notary Public in and for the City of Washington, District of Columbia, this 14th day of March, 1979.
6 4
I VD V wh w
w
!47 "--* '*? I:,J:as Septe=tc m, Ig s pl on
~ _ _
- j k
- - a &.u.
f *g..,
g
.-,s.=..
,.4.
- e.,
.1..
fe M.
=
v.. p...
1w%,
.e.
.=i %
4".. w
./. - V M.
. d"
...l
._. r.
- e....u.. -
..g...s.
_--.h.
- a.,.
.v. 3....
1
.u.
.. e..
w,..,.
Lw-a..
}
C C.,...
=. r. w
.m%S.
=a
- q ;; -
.w.
.;w
. y.,. -a, eu a.
C.e. ~ c.e
.ca.q 1.
- p. 4 e
}
2..c o u _ ~n.0 c r'.
=a
'. ". ". ". C.i. Y.C.# '".
.. S '..i.1
)
a w..n..
1.'.
.T. 4, u.. L w-a
.I
..a s
i s. C C..'. ~' a 'C S S O
- C,', A. C *. f
~ '. ". ' '.'.'iC S.
}
.&. 9'*
9%
./.
.w C~.'.'s'.'.*_.'
".. '.,'_./' '.
v.
_..~
.. y - a,.... _.y
. 3.
mya esoga.r
,2 c
.y w.-...
w--
.w w
.g
- ,,.,. ;,. 4.. ;
v.a w i. y
- m. e...e. c ~ y a,...y
- t..e ". C "... '..
"m". a
".".C "< *. "" S
-.' "w.*. a. d w-
- ..,. c a c. A
- '. e ;ag.
3 *. cp2
.a a
.1 1.
. 4
- '. V.
C G "g. C S.' ". ". ". " '. *.
.=
=_.y
.m
.,.. m. /
c.
. w.i.l. p 24.
S.
w.1. 3 S S p C S. s.
a,.
. m.. d.4 4
- 6. 4. S
- u k.
= w.s. a S s
w m
w wf
-y e-.
-2 w
.ef 1.3 "/ o.
.v.
.a.---
.?.
.v. -
e.
(,%. a.4. a C S e -.w.
a.
3 4
.a.
=
.c. a..
C a e, ;;,.
-p w..
w-a.
,s : a ; -
- w,..m. 3.;.. c, t e c. e. s w
.a f
n o.a..'.,.,.
t= - n.o..e. a..T.
. n. - -
. - -.... a
,- a r'
i a w.
- s
.; 3.
e 1
.?.gc, 4 g.1 g 4.. a.
C. c,w.
4..
.v s { L.,. T a.=.w
- 0. a. r., 7 2. *.= **. *. *f
(.*. =. =.*.e..e.i r* **
'. e . a " ~ ~...: ' C.#
w L'.e. w.' 'w* *-
~
w..
g
- ~. e..%.
- m. e.. e.
r.
- n.J w;;;
a :..
w..f s.
3 C.
- CX
.T '.' *r.1 7
- yg e h..i -.
- p. f m,.
(.
O. d,, d..* =*r 6
.y 4
t
..%. a.1 A.
W C.1.. Jap 42 %, w _4 3,.
?...
w.
=2
. ~
3...,..
w -.r.S.4 C c. w a w C.e G.e.h.
.d.? _' m
- w 1.,.
. a.
1... :s
.a.
- 3.
a.7 wf 0 4. h. a J n.
..J-a.b..,
?e%.-==... a.
. s- %.
'.r
- g. L. i%. 3~3 O.. s,..
- 1..m.
- w..y
=
w'*..o 4. 3;>.3c e
...'.a..
. =.
w..
.t. a..
.e. % n.
3
.a J
w.
w
.f
- -g g., a.
n.
(.
- o..::;
".". 3.b. g, P.. c
?.
. ; 6.3 a,.
s m
Co w u.4 =. a.
e
.V.
. = a..t
- r. T. s e ;s. w
.T..e. w-.* 4 = m.
1 ^ ~, V 7 */
.b.
.C.
m.
.,. f
^
V.,
w.
p w
w.
.1
- V. e
- a..c.
n3
- g..
.. S.s..;
C..,.
W
.f ac s.
- s..
S. e,; 0 e.
~~,N w c.a.
m
- t A
..%. ~~..!
'* %.T :
h a
v C....
WC
.?.a.
.r..e -...
a.
w.
a.
b.
O...
.a.,
7.;. w-. 4...
a.
3 7. J ( *.3.
g r r ~e ",.,,. 3 w--
s
- f
- - =
- ...-.,..e...
N,
- e. 4..'
- a 3
a.
- ,,..,....e w
ys
~... ea9 s ;~
.C., 2 4 e,.. :
~
C.,=.'..' -r a *
- 9.... ' s. s -
..a s,.'..s.
a.
ie.mi.
= =. e. 2....,,,..
.s.,.,,.9.e Mc.
- w.
...j a
w.
- ~, w c.a.
m.
t*.
^~;t.
.p
.r k
7..
,... ; f
- 7..= w-...,.
=.
w.e p e
...s.g
..g gg..A E
=..
.w g m.we
.g 6
8
....M.m j
g
...w g
g
- 8....<w...
- n
.g 6.
.I' J..
.C.,., f." S.. s..* *;*
. '.' w"i
.=L'.=
,c.. = = 2 a
...g
..g S'
- a,
.t.
e....'.
3.
- 3 J
w, m
..3..;.-.....
.;.4.
agc. e.. _,. _
...f q* ' 1 1.
6.
^ ?, :
m
... =
2-
.~ w e e - b.
WG.a..=...,
_ a g "..- =.
~
' C u c..' _= s r.
. C '6...,
r - - ".i _ =.
_ag-f C. s.m y,
"J. 3,
- a..
.r s..? 4
.M.a.. l. y n..
S..
.C g = =. e _13,
- r..e. w_ o.._ - m.
.l 'c...,
b 2
w
'1A-1
. _ c o..a d.is C r. C #_ # i - =.. - -
u - - - -..c, WC. =.." a,. C. s v...'. =. &
ca...
e -.e 1_:: 1.:. _w
.ea..,
N.
W.
001 : - v, = ~
~~a.
ct' _i. =. 7:y^0 WashingtCn, D.
C.
20024 Dallas, Texas 75201 C.w-. JC n G C C C.'"., _7s gb'.4 - =.
-ye.7Ce" C.
.O.a. ' V a. _2 7
- g-"-.i - =.
C-C l-V w C.o.
- m.... a *.... a', ? s g- ".i.- =.
WC ". a.". =.*,
.TC ". a V,..". O
-e w
~=
- a. :.e a
= s,.,. m. - a C _.. s ego _t =. y e.. _ we,
eg.4..
,=00 1701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.
W.
Callas, Texas 75201 000e-nashingtCn, D.
C.
4
--.. C C.'<,
L'4-=.C
=
R.
ra.
w
- h e. ~ T w e.r.g. a. i.g, _ 3 g-n i - a.
C.4 *..] c3
.a.g-4.m.
r _i s C *~ _ i_C e.
-w u.w i.l.i y re " a "..'e...
- C th..i c.'. *w,
v' "..,
_T s C,"..i
- a.
y.
v.
a.
LCwensCain, Nev=an, Reis &
P.
O.
ECx 1038 axe _ rad Auscin,,.exas e: <=<
107: C.... a. C. i C"w.
a' v =..". e,
N..
- i.
"n a _c h..i..,
- r.,
n.
C.
'.001o' ue"- v, r.
= a.-. i. a,
7_ a n-"..i.- =.
s u
C.4.v, a'
-...ev
-- gu.d -.
C 4
- v, C-'
a' u s. 4.7
=., p.g l.4.3,
g.4 _1 _1 _4 _,5 u.
re-I 08Q 2
O.
0_ C.
No..
an, O..m..i s
- -.
- m..m. s. s _i.m.,
=
_w.
nX e _7 r a c.
austin,.exas iOrc/
1 n. 7..: 4 C..i n.. n
- a..n. L, e,
- y..
W.
.a..
w W a s.".... ; ~ r.,
D.
C.
700.'6
.% _4..". a. d. C.
=
1 a C uc..'., r e u _i.- =.
--g a'
- s i s ~'.".. C.i
- v.
a'
- "_.. a. v,*
-- gu.i.- m.
C.4 ".Y, C.
n' u S " 4.".
7. a. d a.
- i. w.g 7_. =. 4. ~. 5,
re-r aw Q4:__.4cas C.
NC.
.b.C" 7'7
- 3..
0.
- C-10.28 e O 2 4 3 ; 4..g a u, s. i.,.,. x, s
, 2. i e,,
J L --.
na..
3-
.,c...-..,
D,.
C.
z003/
a-w d.7_A c -.
Fan =-. P 4
.w.
u WC _1_' =. s w r.
C4
- v.." a..= c, W h..e = - _' a,v a.
_l _' _1 7 Wa.a.
a =.
C##_4-=
u _d _i d.i.. c, C _4 '.v, C#.'. u s. 4..
w-2600 Virginia Avenue, N.
W.
O.
O.
ECx 1088
.00,7 nus 4
,,s e././
Was.
g_.,n, D.
C.
w
~
..C _ # 2 2.* #. ";,
C.'. S.i _-
a.*. 2..d F%.. i =, #
FC r.
.O..
O_ u _' =_ _",
?_
- g t'.i. =.
m e
-.g s. c ". 4 7 a.
Q34.;-o=
On e o. A,
Vi-a,
- 4.i k..s. e. w p-,
-e e -- -..
n-
__ ~.
~
C a.... _3 _1
=.cye 3 r.4 r C p.ea..y
=
co...y w.
a
- u.
a
- Cx 7.171 m.
O.
=_C x
.1,a 0 c.
o.
V.
--'O.'
.'.u s.i..,
=. s = c 1
- .I
% -. :u s CS...- i. s..i, ~. =..x = s 1 2n
.s.
_C - _.. g o, da..a. -s i M. 3.. g g.
.V.e.. ; u.m.
C_ o_. =.. _..s.w, r e -._. _4. s.
v y...
S
--g 0..-
J.
- o. Og,.J,
M e d i._. _. e, *. q.b..-. J - s.
- 4_*.e. a.
._W 1 _. -
P e..y 4
w
=...-
w 2
P.
2.c w.s
.' o 3QQ P - =. 3. s..c.e.
.'. s. s..=. '.1 i.
w.
c..
1.-
4.,
. e..C 3
70.7
- 1... e.....
. 2..,w,.e.
m.
.C..
i.
m>v t
k.,' e m..bN t
h E
j 3. p%,u d y m
Ud e
- gced, re-u 4 -
73 -u.i - =.
- -. =.
.z o y 4.
L
..m
.s..
-e w.
.c.. ga
- o- -,....
A 3 a.43-=..
a.. e-.... y q =.... 3,
=-
g
'*:z 4'.:
.u...... w s,
N. m^ v ' i..,
"=-1=
.v..= c - - - - -..a.
O.
=cx a
=a
.o...
C2-4-,3 c.
-a.4-.
_. 0 0.:_: _,. c y a. 4 c. a 1 L.41a4 g n L, s. 4..,
- m. x.2.s e.: n, _ _-
San An:cnic, Texas 73205 c.a k e r, -scuL:e u =ca
.u.
.O a. -. ~: G.
- - 4... a.'.a.,
.. =. s.i A =..".
.a.ss s-r.-
A
-...a.v Ga..a.
= '
i
= *
.23 r.414 4
3 Pe.. c.
4., c.
- e..
C.
=cx
,'8 a
C-wra..v C=
d
=1 c"='i-
- s -. - r.
e 700'
-. v, a.. ~. ~~ a..
n' u s - i.a.,
"=x=<
78 11-Callas, "exas 75201
. =a-..=...,
-a gt' i - =.
v c b...
=. v.a..b. e w s, w..,
a r--
r i-=
s - ". - - -
s C"a 'as G.
- .=",
v..,
scu---'-=
.v.a..'. e w s, C c ' c... a.,
r 7
Baker & Ec t:s
- McNanc, Go'elman & Cc' b c
c
.000 C.. e.: F. a. ' '
's-=
1:
r4 -= 21 2
- 0 0 e'. e
- 4.. a..
.r a.
' - = c. a.
-cuscca,.exas e/002 vacxscnv 3,e,
-3c :..ca 2e--
04 G-=c_c v, C re'=.-d, T s - "- ' - =.
=..che-
. : a.'. a...
v.
-s
"".e r d e. = c.7 Weice,. v..,
c,"--.
...W.
2 e c.k s-
^~e c-'=-=s re
+-=
a saXer s = ces r.
O.
=cx ocle J000 C..
.c h.
1 1 3.12-s C. i m.e.c' c,
71c.'Aa
.:0.7 Ecusten, Texas 77002 cC e""*11 C
- L'...v,
. ".
- l * "
- ".=.V, G.
W.
Cprea, Jr.
O.
Ecx 417
- x = ~,..... 14 ce
- ..e.4e G1 n.:cse,
.x.s e.:,0 a-e-
c.
4 w
- u -
n.. c... 4.. c, s.=cve. C ~-ra..v.
~
1 v-d =
700
- c v... a - -
t n c.., G o...=.
= '
.v..=.. = c_ _ _
C.
= cx a
- us -.., " a..x = s 700' We s.. =..~~..
= --e s 7 ' a c - '
u c.
1 O.
Scx 429 W.
S.
Rebsen, General Manager Anadarke, Oklahc=a 72005 c
w r'=
eu..
.=..x s -- c. ic " c e-=
iva.,
w Inc.
James E.
Mcnahan
.ru..
c, u - d i..c.
m i'
' O'-
e i-x a w ". ~. =. V i c =-.:. =. s '.da....
-.. c'
=
- 4 -- - w 4 s<. - - - - -0.. r i
- p. s 1
.I. J -. c..
qq..g.21---..g..-g s
v4-.-
4 v.
x33 77c.0'
- =~~
c'=
=
..-= s -- c---
- e-Cc.,
.Y y
O.
Ecx 5296
.v.-......-
.u.; i t..,
r3 - - ' - =.
Wac-, " =.x = s 7 s04
- 2..
.k. a - 4 7 2p. p * '
T m -,. 4 -s w.---
s.'. =.~.,
--..c--..s
=
s'=
e--.
wud'-'
==-
's,
...".-c.,-g -_=.
... 7 4.. -. yw.. d e.. s '
- g c.- - c.. =.
~
,-s 6
p
? %. 4.seg,
- T T 4..g e -
."Q:.Q7 O..
C.
Og s l'1 **
-.9.
- a
- a e
d3...
..C....,
9
?.
', W -t -r a
%RQ ff n) f k. ' = { W M.da u b:
-c 83b 29
David M.
S tahl, Esquire Ralph M.
Rader, Esq.
Isham, Lincoln & 3eale Connor, Mcore & Corber One First National Plaza 1747 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.
W.
Chicago, Illinois 60603 Washington, D.
C.
20006 Knoland J.
Plucknett Donald Clements, Esq.
Executive Director Gulf States Utilities Co.
Committee on Power for the P.
O.
Box 2951 Southwest, Inc.
Beaumont, Texas 77704 5541 Skelly Drive Tulsa, Oklahcma 74135 W.
N. Woolsey, Esq.
Dyer and Redford Jercme Saltzman, Chief 1030 Petroleum Tower Antitrus t & Indemnity Group Corpus Christi, Texas 73474 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washingoon, D.
C.
20555 Mr. David H. Wiggs, Jr.
Kemp, Smith, White, Duncan Jay M.
Galt, Esquire
& Hammond Locney, Nichols, Johnson & Hayes P.O.
Drawer 2800 219 s auch Drive El Paso, Texas 79999 Oklahoma City, Oklahoma 73101
~
bi
[<.
7 '?, )
! '- k/ /-
Marc R.
Poirier Attorney for the Public Utilities Board o' the City of Brownsville, Texa.
June 12, 1979 Law Offices of:
Spiegel & McDiarmid 2600 Virginia Avenue, N.N.
Suite 312 Washington, D.C.
20037 (202) 333-4500 P003 O!EE 83s 29s