LER-1978-032, /03T-0:on 781218,during Surveillance Test on Emergency Escape Hatch,Containment Integrity Violated.Caused by Personnel Error.Personnel Reminded to Exit Containment Personnel Hatch During Emergency Hatch Inner Door Repairs |
| Event date: |
|
|---|
| Report date: |
|
|---|
| 3131978032R03 - NRC Website |
|
text
e
.o s
4 NncFOHM 3t4 U. S NULL E AR REGUL A10HY CO*.tMISSION P 778*
LICENSEE EVENT REPORT EXHIBIT A
/
CONTnOL SLOCC l ! I l l l tr
- E PnlNT OR TYrt ALL P.E QUlHID INFORMATIONI Io1iIlAlRlAIN O I 1l@3sl 01 01 - 1 0l 0 l 0l 0l 0 l-l 010 l@! 4 l1 [ 1 l1 l 1 l@l l lg 7
uu~su wi.,
i.
uu. i ~u. o.
.s ua Nsi,,,. u
,, u i w CCN'T O' s LL_J@l015101010131113 l@l 112111817 l 8)@ 01 1l 117 l 719 @
J llL1J a
u ooc ir su c,rn u.
,. J i,...i o u.
ot,on t ou, E VENT DESCRIPTION AND r,1CHABLE CONSEf 3UENCES h 1During power operation, while performing the semi-annual surveillance o 2 LE l test on the Emergency Escape Hatch, the maintenance personnel opened the outer door while the inner door was open, violating containment i
n
.i Lintegrity. Heal,,t.h Physics personnel were monitoring the hatch and there o
IoIr.Ilaas a slight negative pressure in the hatch; therefore, there was no i
lo Iil I release of radiation to the Atmosphere.
There were no similar occur-
", ' Lrencee Reportable._per_L S,.6_.12,J _1..b.
1 lu s, uie u t. r. a i.us,
, o.D E c0CE LOct 5( Bi Crt u r.'
NL N T i Ot,E l, o l 'i l S I Dl@ U@ [CJ@ l ZlZ l Zl Zl Z l Z[g ' t.,]"jg yg
,yg u
n n
St u 'F s ti At
' at - i H isi
... e t st :
HI k lii r4 m ' ' i a '
ao va' oo ou
@,"a a au 17 181 L,--J L.o i 3121 y
1 0l 31 L.TJ g
W
.o j?A" u
_v
'n','T '403 c",'E r
%22' E) ' ",f s.TO',.%.:",',i "C
,, f.?."'# "
U.U@Lx.j@
l Zig LZj@
l0 l 0l 0(}7 l [Njg [Njg d.J J,7g
-[ Z l9 lhl,,'lo.9lg ot... s JJ 34 J
Jw.
'I a.)
el 42 3
e4 af cAuse utsCni, TION AND 40HHEC OVE ACTIONS h iThe inner Emergency Escape Hatch door seals were being replaced, dis-l i
o tabling the inner. door, when the outer door was opened for a few seconds i
i.
Iii/Ilto' allow evit.
The M,intonnnce Supervisors F, personnel were reminded thatl ti iii i they were to prepare for exit through the containment personnel hatch' l
Iwhen repniring the i.mer inor _
l i
4 f 9 M
S T'A 5
% POWE ft O r.*E R ST AT US
.t.
- VfH, i s' sf H v C.E:LH.P f ac.e.
I i I s I lE,j@ l 110 l 0 l@l NA l [B_j@l NA-l Ni,,v,,, c#,m
=
., llc.J L.LJ @ L,1JSL,,_ NA.vuos10,,nivn, @ l
. ;..,s ur. a m @
4u sw or anu si L
[__NA o
o e
i t se'.s u
'.l t [ k,51:.t #H15
,t..115 5 6 T 4 6'f Ci. is 84 e e sO.e fit 1 10 10 I Ol@LZ_J@l NA I,
u.sosd', ears a
mm.,,..,@
1010101@l NA l
ii.
2 i-y, L t r,:'. 8,6 7 4.) A U.,(,1 T O F As ti f f f fO ivec nt.cne r i m.
l!.1d y@! NA l
.t 15 g,
DE nrptsON
' N '
I?.l O., i g @l NA l lllilllllt;il 7
e -
ic c.
e..wt cs entP AHE H bTiS N-Sb i V.017_ -_
t' W a 501-968-2519 790124 oAo /
.T-Reportable Occurrence Report No. 50-313/78-32 2.
Report Date: 01/17/79 3.
Occurrence Date: 12/18/78 4
Facility: Arkansas Nuclear One-Unit 1 Russellville, Arkansas 5.
Identification of Occurrence:
This R0R concerns the violation of reactor building integrity by opening the outer door of the Emergency Escape Hatch while the inner door was open.
6.
Ccaditions Prior to Occurrence:
Steady-State Power X
Reactor Power MWth Hot Standby Net Output MWe Cold Shutdown Percent of Full Power 100 g Refueling Shutdown Load Changes During Ro' utine Power Operation ___
Routine Startup Operation Routine Shutdown Operation Other (specify) 7.
Description of Occurrence:
During power operation, while performing the Semi-Annual Surveillance Test on the Emergency Escap~e Hatch, personnel opened the outer door while the inner door was open, violating containment integrity. Health Physics personnel were monitoring the hatch and there was a slight nega-tive pressure in the hatch.
e
. heportable Occurrence Report No. 50-313/78-32 8.
Designation of Apparent Cause of Occurrence:
Design Procedure Fbnufacture Unusual Service Condition Including Environmental Installation /
Construction Component Failure (See Failure Data)
Operator Other (specify)
Personnel error 9.
Analysis of Occurrence: -
Since the reactor building integrity was compromised for only a few seconds and there was a slight negative pressure differential across the hatch.way, there was no hazard to the health and safety of the public.
e O
. ' Reportable Occurrence Report lio. 50-313/78-32 10.
Corrective Action
Personnel were reminded that when the Emergency Escape Hatch Inner Door is being repaired,.all exits should be made through the containment personnel hatch.
11.
Failure Data:
NA G
+
9 e
|
|---|
|
|
| | | Reporting criterion |
|---|
| 05000313/LER-1978-001-04, /04L-0:during Fourth Quarter 1977,average Noble Gas Release Rate Exceeded Max Allowable Rate During Outage. Results Possibly False Due to Airborne Radioactivity in Counting Lab.Monitoring Sys Design Being Reviewed | /04L-0:during Fourth Quarter 1977,average Noble Gas Release Rate Exceeded Max Allowable Rate During Outage. Results Possibly False Due to Airborne Radioactivity in Counting Lab.Monitoring Sys Design Being Reviewed | | | 05000313/LER-1978-001, Forwards LER 78-001/04L-0 | Forwards LER 78-001/04L-0 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-001-01, /01T-0:on 780105,during Soluble Boron Shutdown Analysis for Another B&W Facility,Boric Acid Vol Deficiency Found.Caused by Change to Tech Specs W/O Changing Calculated Vol Requirement.Cycle 3 Tech Specs to Be Changed Soon | /01T-0:on 780105,during Soluble Boron Shutdown Analysis for Another B&W Facility,Boric Acid Vol Deficiency Found.Caused by Change to Tech Specs W/O Changing Calculated Vol Requirement.Cycle 3 Tech Specs to Be Changed Soon | | | 05000313/LER-1978-002-03, /03L-0:on 780113,steam Supply Valve CV-2667 from Generator to Turbine Driver Failed to Open Remotely.Caused by Defective Valve Operator Torque Switch.Switch Replaced | /03L-0:on 780113,steam Supply Valve CV-2667 from Generator to Turbine Driver Failed to Open Remotely.Caused by Defective Valve Operator Torque Switch.Switch Replaced | | | 05000368/LER-1978-002, Forwards LER 78-002/01T-0 | Forwards LER 78-002/01T-0 | | | 05000368/LER-1978-002-01, /01T-0 on 780920:during Inspec,Discovered That Valves Had an Interference Between Valve Gate & Gate Guide. Caused by Design Problem Which Could Prevent Complete Valve Closure.Valves Returned to Manufacturer for Repairs | /01T-0 on 780920:during Inspec,Discovered That Valves Had an Interference Between Valve Gate & Gate Guide. Caused by Design Problem Which Could Prevent Complete Valve Closure.Valves Returned to Manufacturer for Repairs | | | 05000368/LER-1978-003, Forwards LER 78-003/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-003/03L-0 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-003-03, /03L-0:on 780203,mist Spray from Reactor Coolant Pump Seal Leak Contaminated Reactor Bldg Areas.Cause Unknown.Leak Isolated & Bldg Areas Decontaminated | /03L-0:on 780203,mist Spray from Reactor Coolant Pump Seal Leak Contaminated Reactor Bldg Areas.Cause Unknown.Leak Isolated & Bldg Areas Decontaminated | | | 05000368/LER-1978-003-03, /03L-0:on 780912,during Mode 3 Operation,Cst B Level Dropped to Less than 80% W/Cst a at About 10%.Caused by Inability of Makeup Tank to Produce Enough Quality Water to Maintain Level | /03L-0:on 780912,during Mode 3 Operation,Cst B Level Dropped to Less than 80% W/Cst a at About 10%.Caused by Inability of Makeup Tank to Produce Enough Quality Water to Maintain Level | | | 05000368/LER-1978-004-03, /03L-0:on 780916,during Mode 3 Operation,Prior to Initial Criticality,Autotransformer Tripped from Timed Overcurrent.Caused by Feeding Both Unit Auxiliary Loads After Unit 1 Reactor Trip.Overcurrent Adjusted | /03L-0:on 780916,during Mode 3 Operation,Prior to Initial Criticality,Autotransformer Tripped from Timed Overcurrent.Caused by Feeding Both Unit Auxiliary Loads After Unit 1 Reactor Trip.Overcurrent Adjusted | | | 05000313/LER-1978-004-03, /03L-1:on 780211,four Hydraulic Shock Suppressors Found Inoperable.Caused by Maladjustment,Corrosion & Metal Shavings in Valves.All 69 Suppressors Tested;One Had No Deficiency.Deficient Suppressors Repaired or Replaced | /03L-1:on 780211,four Hydraulic Shock Suppressors Found Inoperable.Caused by Maladjustment,Corrosion & Metal Shavings in Valves.All 69 Suppressors Tested;One Had No Deficiency.Deficient Suppressors Repaired or Replaced | | | 05000313/LER-1978-004, Forwards LER 78-004/03L-1 | Forwards LER 78-004/03L-1 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-005, Update to LER 78-005/01x-1:on 780302,during Inservice Insp of Tubing,Five Tubes Exceeded Plugging Limit of 40% of Nominal Tube Wall Thickness.Caused by Oxiding Aqueous Corrosion Mechanism.Defective Tubes Plugged | Update to LER 78-005/01x-1:on 780302,during Inservice Insp of Tubing,Five Tubes Exceeded Plugging Limit of 40% of Nominal Tube Wall Thickness.Caused by Oxiding Aqueous Corrosion Mechanism.Defective Tubes Plugged | | | 05000368/LER-1978-005-03, /03L-0:on 780916,during Mode 3 Operation Prior to Initial Criticality,Onsite AC Power Distribution Sys Deenergized.Caused by Bus Feeder Breakers Tripping on Low Voltage Due to Overloading.Setpoints Adjusted | /03L-0:on 780916,during Mode 3 Operation Prior to Initial Criticality,Onsite AC Power Distribution Sys Deenergized.Caused by Bus Feeder Breakers Tripping on Low Voltage Due to Overloading.Setpoints Adjusted | | | 05000313/LER-1978-005-03, /03L-0:on 780302,steam Generator Tube Indications Exceeded Plugging Limit on 40% of Nominal Wall Thickness. Caused by Defect Near Upper Tube Sheet.Tubes Plugged | /03L-0:on 780302,steam Generator Tube Indications Exceeded Plugging Limit on 40% of Nominal Wall Thickness. Caused by Defect Near Upper Tube Sheet.Tubes Plugged | | | 05000368/LER-1978-006-03, /03L-0:on 780916,during Mode 3,prior to Initial Criticality,Raw Water Tank Level Dropped Below Tech Specs. Caused by ECCS Actuation Due to Loss of Relay Power to ECCS Components & Inverter Failure.Tank Level Increased | /03L-0:on 780916,during Mode 3,prior to Initial Criticality,Raw Water Tank Level Dropped Below Tech Specs. Caused by ECCS Actuation Due to Loss of Relay Power to ECCS Components & Inverter Failure.Tank Level Increased | | | 05000313/LER-1978-006, Update to LER 78-006/01x-1:on 780305,during Reinstallation of Primary Manway Cover,Two of 16 Studs Sheared Off at Base of Nut on Second Torque Sequence Pass.Caused by 90% Crack in Diameter on One Stud | Update to LER 78-006/01x-1:on 780305,during Reinstallation of Primary Manway Cover,Two of 16 Studs Sheared Off at Base of Nut on Second Torque Sequence Pass.Caused by 90% Crack in Diameter on One Stud | | | 05000313/LER-1978-006-03, /03L-0:on 780305,studs on Lower Steam Generator Primary Manway Cover Sheared Off.Caused by Crack of 90% of Stud Diameter.Studs Ultrasonically Checked for Cracks & One Removed | /03L-0:on 780305,studs on Lower Steam Generator Primary Manway Cover Sheared Off.Caused by Crack of 90% of Stud Diameter.Studs Ultrasonically Checked for Cracks & One Removed | | | 05000313/LER-1978-007-03, /03L-0:on 780308,ventilation Dampers Failed to Seal Properly After Actuation.Caused by Sticky Air Supply Sys.Bladder Pressure Gauges Replaced & Air Supply re-adjusted | /03L-0:on 780308,ventilation Dampers Failed to Seal Properly After Actuation.Caused by Sticky Air Supply Sys.Bladder Pressure Gauges Replaced & Air Supply re-adjusted | | | 05000368/LER-1978-007-03, /03L-0:on 780917,RCS Chloride Concentration Reduced to Less than 0.15ppm.Engineering Evaluation Determined Condition Should Have No Effect on Structural Integrity of RCS Based on out-of-limit Condition | /03L-0:on 780917,RCS Chloride Concentration Reduced to Less than 0.15ppm.Engineering Evaluation Determined Condition Should Have No Effect on Structural Integrity of RCS Based on out-of-limit Condition | | | 05000313/LER-1978-008-03, /03L-0:on 780320,turbocharger for Diesel Generator 2 Caught Fire.Caused by Bearing Failure Between Air Inlet & Exhaust Turbine Bladings.Turbocharger Replaced | /03L-0:on 780320,turbocharger for Diesel Generator 2 Caught Fire.Caused by Bearing Failure Between Air Inlet & Exhaust Turbine Bladings.Turbocharger Replaced | | | 05000313/LER-1978-008, Forwards LER 78-008/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-008/03L-0 | | | 05000368/LER-1978-008-03, /03L-0 on 781005:During Post-Core Hot Functional Testing,Pressurizer Code Safety Valve Was Gagged to Eliminate Weepage.Weepage Occurred Following Corrective Maintenance.Valve Was Allowed to Cool & Proper Oper Proved | /03L-0 on 781005:During Post-Core Hot Functional Testing,Pressurizer Code Safety Valve Was Gagged to Eliminate Weepage.Weepage Occurred Following Corrective Maintenance.Valve Was Allowed to Cool & Proper Oper Proved | | | 05000368/LER-1978-008, Forwards LER 78-008/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-008/03L-0 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-009-01, /01T-0:on 780413,B&W Advised Util That Results of 0.04 Ft Squared RCS Pump Discharge Break Analysis Unacceptable.Caused by ECCS Analysis re-evaluation Performed for Newer B&W Plants | /01T-0:on 780413,B&W Advised Util That Results of 0.04 Ft Squared RCS Pump Discharge Break Analysis Unacceptable.Caused by ECCS Analysis re-evaluation Performed for Newer B&W Plants | | | 05000368/LER-1978-009-03, /03L-0 on 781006:during Post-Core Hot Functional Test,Prior to Initial Criticality,Mode 3 Oper,Emergency Feedwater Valve 2CV-1025-1,hydraulic Pump Motor Failed. Motor Was Replaced & Tested Successfully | /03L-0 on 781006:during Post-Core Hot Functional Test,Prior to Initial Criticality,Mode 3 Oper,Emergency Feedwater Valve 2CV-1025-1,hydraulic Pump Motor Failed. Motor Was Replaced & Tested Successfully | | | 05000368/LER-1978-009, Forwards LER 78-009/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-009/03L-0 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-009, Forwards LER 78-009/01T-0 | Forwards LER 78-009/01T-0 | | | 05000368/LER-1978-010-01, /01T-0 on 781102:during Post-Core Hot Functional Test,Prior to Initial Criticality Mode 3 Oper,Lift Setpoints of Main Steam Line Code Safety Valves Were Nonconservative. Caused by Incorrect Identification of Simmer Point | /01T-0 on 781102:during Post-Core Hot Functional Test,Prior to Initial Criticality Mode 3 Oper,Lift Setpoints of Main Steam Line Code Safety Valves Were Nonconservative. Caused by Incorrect Identification of Simmer Point | | | 05000368/LER-1978-010, Forwards LER 78-010/01T-0 | Forwards LER 78-010/01T-0 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-010-03, /03L-0:on 780419,motor Operator of Standby Hydrogen Purge Isolation Valve CV-7449 Failed to Torque Out. Caused by Torque Switch Failure.Switch Replaced | /03L-0:on 780419,motor Operator of Standby Hydrogen Purge Isolation Valve CV-7449 Failed to Torque Out. Caused by Torque Switch Failure.Switch Replaced | | | 05000313/LER-1978-011-03, /03L-0:on 780420,exhaust Fan VEF-37B Supply Breaker Tripped.Cause Unknown.Circuit Breaker & Overload Heater Replaced | /03L-0:on 780420,exhaust Fan VEF-37B Supply Breaker Tripped.Cause Unknown.Circuit Breaker & Overload Heater Replaced | | | 05000368/LER-1978-012-03, /03L-0 on 781107:during Post-Core Hot Functional Testing B Condensate Storage Tank Dropped Below Tech Spec Minimum.Caused by Inability of Makeup Plants to Produce High Demand for Condensate | /03L-0 on 781107:during Post-Core Hot Functional Testing B Condensate Storage Tank Dropped Below Tech Spec Minimum.Caused by Inability of Makeup Plants to Produce High Demand for Condensate | | | 05000368/LER-1978-012, Forwards LER 78-012/03L-0, 78-013/01T-0, 78-014/01T-0 & 78-015/01L-0 | Forwards LER 78-012/03L-0, 78-013/01T-0, 78-014/01T-0 & 78-015/01L-0 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-013, Forwards LER 78-013/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-013/03L-0 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-013-03, /03L-0:on 780426,emergency Supply Fan VSF9 Failed to Start Automatically During Radiation Monitor RE-8001 Testing.Caused by Defective Actuating Solenoid.Solenoid Repaired | /03L-0:on 780426,emergency Supply Fan VSF9 Failed to Start Automatically During Radiation Monitor RE-8001 Testing.Caused by Defective Actuating Solenoid.Solenoid Repaired | | | 05000368/LER-1978-013-01, /01T-0 on 781107:received Notice That Speed Switch Made by Dynalog Corp Had Design Problem That Could Cause Failure.Speed Switch Replaced | /01T-0 on 781107:received Notice That Speed Switch Made by Dynalog Corp Had Design Problem That Could Cause Failure.Speed Switch Replaced | | | 05000368/LER-1978-014-01, /01T-0 on 781107:during Mode 3 Oper,Noted That First Cycle Plant Protec Sys Setpoint Changes Req by Rosemont Pressure Transmitter Substitution Were Less than Conservative.Caused by Failure to Change Setpoint | /01T-0 on 781107:during Mode 3 Oper,Noted That First Cycle Plant Protec Sys Setpoint Changes Req by Rosemont Pressure Transmitter Substitution Were Less than Conservative.Caused by Failure to Change Setpoint | | | 05000313/LER-1978-014-03, /03L-0:on 780504,radiation Monitoring Sys Was Not Surveillance Tested on Schedule.Caused by Personnel Responsility Change.Quarterly Surveillance Rescheduled to Meet Frequency Requirement | /03L-0:on 780504,radiation Monitoring Sys Was Not Surveillance Tested on Schedule.Caused by Personnel Responsility Change.Quarterly Surveillance Rescheduled to Meet Frequency Requirement | | | 05000313/LER-1978-015-03, /03L-0:on 780505,electric Driven Fire Pump Capacity Found Inadequate During Fire Water Sys Testing. Caused by Crack in Suction Bowl.Fire Pump Repaired | /03L-0:on 780505,electric Driven Fire Pump Capacity Found Inadequate During Fire Water Sys Testing. Caused by Crack in Suction Bowl.Fire Pump Repaired | | | 05000368/LER-1978-015-01, /01T-0 on 781108:technician Installed Replacement Speed Switch in B Emergency Diesel Generator W/O Having Job Order Approved by Shift Supervisor.Due to Forgetfulness of Instru Technician | /01T-0 on 781108:technician Installed Replacement Speed Switch in B Emergency Diesel Generator W/O Having Job Order Approved by Shift Supervisor.Due to Forgetfulness of Instru Technician | | | 05000368/LER-1978-016-03, /03L-0 on 781109:during Mode 3 Oper,Emergency Diesel Generator B Tripped from 100% Load.Caused by Damage to Rod & Main Bearings,Crankshaft & Pistons,Perhaps Due to Loose Baseplate Mounting Screw | /03L-0 on 781109:during Mode 3 Oper,Emergency Diesel Generator B Tripped from 100% Load.Caused by Damage to Rod & Main Bearings,Crankshaft & Pistons,Perhaps Due to Loose Baseplate Mounting Screw | | | 05000313/LER-1978-016-03, /03L-0:on 780519,hydrogen Purge Lead Sys Supply Fan VSF-30A Tripped.Cause Unknown.Overload Relay Reset & Current Checked | /03L-0:on 780519,hydrogen Purge Lead Sys Supply Fan VSF-30A Tripped.Cause Unknown.Overload Relay Reset & Current Checked | | | 05000368/LER-1978-016, Forwards LER 78-016/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-016/03L-0 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-016, Forwards LER 78-016/03L-0 | Forwards LER 78-016/03L-0 | | | 05000368/LER-1978-017, Forwards LER 78-017/01T-0 & RO 50-368/78-17 | Forwards LER 78-017/01T-0 & RO 50-368/78-17 | | | 05000368/LER-1978-018, Forwards LER 78-018/03L-0 & 78-019/03l-0 | Forwards LER 78-018/03L-0 & 78-019/03l-0 | | | 05000368/LER-1978-018-03, /03L-0 on 781128:both Doors of the Personnel Hatch Doors Were Simultaneously Opened,Caused by a Sheared Mechanical Door Interrlock Gear Key.Mechanical Interlock Repairs Made & Containment Air Lock Declared Operable | /03L-0 on 781128:both Doors of the Personnel Hatch Doors Were Simultaneously Opened,Caused by a Sheared Mechanical Door Interrlock Gear Key.Mechanical Interlock Repairs Made & Containment Air Lock Declared Operable | | | 05000313/LER-1978-019, Forwards Updated LER 78-019/01X-1 | Forwards Updated LER 78-019/01X-1 | | | 05000313/LER-1978-019-01, B&W Discovered That Weld Filler Wire Atypical of Submerged Arc Weld Filler Wires Specified,Was Unknowingly Mixed by Supplier.Pressure/Temp Curves Revised Then Later Reverted to Original Curves | B&W Discovered That Weld Filler Wire Atypical of Submerged Arc Weld Filler Wires Specified,Was Unknowingly Mixed by Supplier.Pressure/Temp Curves Revised Then Later Reverted to Original Curves | |
|