ML19254E674

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comments on Proposed Rule Re Clearance Program for Individuals in Licensed Nuclear Area.Important to Weigh Implications in Terms of Natl Security Study Memorandum 216
ML19254E674
Person / Time
Issue date: 10/04/1979
From: Huberman B
NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR FOR OPERATIONS (EDO)
To: Gilinsky V, Mason, Rowden
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
Shared Package
ML19254E653 List:
References
RULE-RM-50-7 761004, NUDOCS 7911020146
Download: ML19254E674 (2)


Text

.

rW %.

t,;mm :; nts

.,f,,

,o N U w, r.,. R R.G.J. A R Y

, W I S,.,.nN

. 4, w iu

~

r T' 9. )

'o, WASHINCTCN. Q. C. 23 E.\\D~p',.N!

o* _* s g af s.-

gC.:b e:

w,, 3 pto g*ws j 4

.ta *.

ra., 4..a.".

O.. 4d e *.

.v_- v.m. a,.q.1.,e.

,A.

w...

n C w~

  • a a- #..-.. * ~

','.d a w-..

01 pbp* gN., (,

w y

[.H I g

0 1

(%.

,J.,S.JC3 v..?.#

. 'c.*/

E h2

  • d J

ha

.a.

J C

J.3 6.w., %. A,.,.. d..

J

/

o

7. ACv.

Og. rg%. g.., /

., /.f,,

ii

  1. ./

J -*

? p %s4.

3 %'A' 'J.;.i v.

".w**.,.

.Of.*..*,*.=.

.=er?

" *m -"o.*. f

  • O :.

m..*..*?.

.. T e. N.,cn i.s b

.w t

.h w w..,*~A m..i w v ?.. A.f S t., f, C.

%.. S.,..

s 0. - u J. s.,.

J w3.,. a,

. s..

  • ~.t.c a e.

3 w.

4. s..

a 3...

.i

.a a

a r..

C.n a.3 n.

a s.. A a f e 2..,. 9

1. a <...

...ae, 4-S,S.a

.w c..

,=S w

f s.

w.

a..fg.a a g-..-..

.u..t g g. a..;

et..g a s a -.-

-r-----

w'3-

'a e.as: _, 4

.-a..

..; a. y a..,.

f.

w r---**

a.; Sw a. 2 2.:.s.. 3. t e.

.t.. a. e A a A,.

.t.,.; 6

--.::t-n.

.w a..

a.a..

a f.,

3 <- -

  • r*
c.. a 3. a -. u. 2.... y
v..,. *
  • 1..

.n

..a L w,. C...

1.

. u. a.

a..

a,. J,. 2.

. %. a c.rg,

f..-c.,-

%. p.

g.

  • 4gA. u.c.'

3

.a.,.w......a

=

rf.

cA..

.,, ~,. a

.a.

,....a a...a...

g T C*=* e V a..**,

,.C.#.'*.*.

'I.^ t ".E**".

". k...# -

d '

w a '..#=.. *..,

b. a.'.#
  • V a.

_#~..~.~~.c**.*.".

a a

4.

4.

5 4*f#.".'."..#.**.*.a~

        • "J*

^#

' w' .C '#..~.'.A.

~~~. *.* a a.* n a*'.'_-*'.**-*#

3 d e.c : a. a... a.

% e. ~. 8 a..

. %.. E f.

%w.J..

o w.2..,5 a a A

%. 4.,

4,. C. u.. a.

9

.2 2 2 -..; C. 4.. e-w.

w s

a

.J.. %, k,y

.b..>

e,.*.

4. 4as..

4.

v.1.e t.v... *

  • A.

w a

.e a

... a..t w,y S,..

.J

.e.1.e.e

,a.

s

.a w,

aw c..

.ac -.w.a

=.. %.. g a,

%. =..: v.. =..*.,. a. c.. a. g

4. 3 3 3 :.2 4.:. a...

g.:

. u.. a.

.....a.

f.

y. a. g. a....

4.

w. s.. a-....;.,..: e.t.a

...3 y,;

.w

.v..a p;,..

. %. a.

,, a,y 6 w

a..n.

,.3.S

. 4.. w y

.w

3. 3 d.,.

. C g a..J.*.*.

%. a.

.,

  • 2
  • a* c. =..=.= a.?.

f.

7

. a. *.'=. w.s aj2..s

.b J. =. 2

- - * * =

4-

.a-2 w

aa o

f.

y,..

w, a $. 2.-,

6 w..,. a a.. 7.,. %.. E

..-.a.,.

.a: 2

,.a.a..,..

a..a.

.g

$ c.,.. a, M.w.:.u.

~ 4. 3. G..,.

a. g f...

. ror

.w

a.. e.

-... 4 a.

.. c y...

.,4-

,a ta,9.S. a. %.

,.. S a.

e..

...a

,, *.f,. u..,

v

u.. 9..*. :

w a c

a.. t.,. a..-

.* -. a f.n.,.s.

s.

-. a.,. a...y

.,.a...a.A

~

.w.

.a f.

.g.. s..

. s.,. s.,..

. s. a..

g w...*;

s. q -.,
s.,.y

..w,

....<..,a..

w, a.

3.

r... 7 3. 3

..f s.

a... s.C. :,,; s.. S

,.- u. e. J,.. _' i,

o..

-.a

. u.,

.. a a 3.=..

m.

G.a./e

.a.a S 4

.a..i.s.:,... s.e., =

%. e.* t a,... a.

. u..g. 1

.a. t. i.,

s s..

.a.

.a af c.aw-a..*

...S

_2

,,.... e

.w...

u. a

.... s.. a... a.. %.

.u..,.

..Sa s

w...a.a..

yw

%.. a... p..'.s.

4..,

\\* T." V..,,,. 7. *. d..

"....b.a 2.,

. b. a.

J.=a.4.

.. =

7 w-..w

......=4..%-

.J.=

.t.

  • *.19.
  • c.,

,. -...w,. b. 2.

3.....s.....

w3.s...w f.... a

.t.

  • c.k.a

...f

.;%.. g. ' p...

....... a 4

...a..i.*d...4..

a....w.1

%.3

.g Mg o..'.....y

.i.,..

4 g w,.

-~ J.

g.*.* ;.,

.63.

2 g...g*..'.,,*

    • S.
  • a.-5*--aJ-

=* ~3 a--

Ea J

, *

  • J*.***a

-d f *. g. w

.a

- =* - - - - - - - * * - -

p.

%m.m.

.n 1. C. s...

-. a..=..a.

\\ w =./

I

  • O "' '

.u..

e

..- G.y.

  • M..3 e.

a v.

7911020 / C [

:he C: " ssi: -

sys:e=,fe: reae::: p e rs c =:el.

The rece:: review of reac::: safeguards by a jci : NEI/5F.SS/II =ca: cencluded :ha: a clearance ;;:gra: was i==edia:ely desirsble :: pr:tec: 4 aicsc he pcs:ula:ed c:e-sa internal

hrea: (see SICT-2613).

Relationshie :

the existice II0A/52C clearance svs e=.

da
he scaff p::posal NIC veuli es:ablish :. new cler'acces -

"C" and "1".

1:

er:s of evales:1ve cri:eria and i=vesciga:::7 =e:heds, :hese :ve new clearances veuld be ident' al :

the preses: "Q" and "L"

leara=:es.

"s:inguishing While 1: :sy be argued :ha: :here is sc e bene #d-d-

be: vee: :s:erial access clearances and nati:nal securi:7 clearances, -

hi k any such benefi: is clearly cu veighed :y :he disadvas: age :f having as KRC-cely clearance sys:e c;erating eu: side :he es:ablished interagency fra:ewc:k.

This view is s::engh:eced by the fac :ha: II A's exis:ing clearance s7sta= f:: unclassified nuclear =a erial is 10:egra:ed in:

the Q/L sys:en.

Pres'--eiy h2C and IIDA could c:c dinate :he..IDA requira:ents for ca:ic 21 securi:7 inf :=2:10: clearz:ces and NRC require =en:s f : access clearances : avcid duplica:e ::verage a: :he li:ersed facilities which pr: duce navy fuel.

! rece._ and :ha N2C fcLiew IEDA's practice sc cha: :he need for backs::c:d i:ves: iga:1:ns and access c:::::Is which a clearance sys:e= invelves vill be :rea ed as a= ex:ans':: cf :he leug-scanding Q-clearance pr:gra: and ::: as a bra d-new systaa.

~

Seeed ef i_ lete::2:1:n.

-21s ;; gra= shculd be imple=en.ed as rapidly as ;cssible, pa::icularly f or f acili:ics where weapecs-usable za:erial

's ;;asen:.

The pr: posed rule p: vides for i=ple=ce:2:1:n a year-and-a-half af:e.: -he final fule is published - abou: :ve years f:: new.

Since the -hrea: Of inter:a1 conspiracy is presen: : v in each facili:7,

ve years set =s :: ce a very lacg ti e.

A ;cssible sciu:10.:ight be

L_p le= en: :he ;: gra= is a phased anner Sc :ha: rescur es :a be cences::a:ed en :he =cre sensi:ive f a:ili:ies== a ;;ic:1:7 basis, vi:n

.he re=21:is; implemen:sti: b : ugh; abou: cc a reae:: - y-reac:::

c: regic -by-regi: basis as rescur:es are available.

cc: ?ste: 5::auss Sam Chilk Lae 7. Ccssi:k Kc'cer: M.inegue e

Ken Chap-'-

3e: Aus c.e

\\

arns; sc.genau 2a OC::ghue Ecuard Shapar

.. l
5... e.

u.:n

... w

.