ML19254A797

Comments Re Rule for Protection of Spent Fuel in Transit,Per ASLB 790618 Order.Rule Has No Effect on Rejected Contentions.Contentions Were Properly Rejected.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19254A797
Person / Time
Site:	Susquehanna
Issue date:	07/02/1979
From:	Cutchin J NRC OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE LEGAL DIRECTOR (OELD)
To:
References
NUDOCS 7908300128
Download: ML19254A797 (5)

Text

~

<h TE R. h July ?,

11J s

t iiLS 0 E,

( f.

j h

@d yg3(

h L:.U fu) s.

NUr.L r a !:r ci 'a,igay La ses[(J; gN y

[J D

'. ; f

_'l J.lfj " !?

F"'D

/<

/,,

bjp _T: - '. i : L i.I C

'O

,M q

6 In the ibilt.r of

)

9*j',8 p

A

)

it.

Qv

'y# 4 h f'; m '; J:!t :n nR,J:0 tic m co.

)

D: d t Nas. ^ J. 7 n

e g

'O f-

%g% [A'*}+x

/d.L - G:i! '. Y E i. !. C T P, I t EnD:mTIE,IF

)

5N. l';

3

)

. a.

\\

.y q. qY (Susquehanna C, t c. ' Elect rit 'i t 1 :. i n :,,

)

\\

" 99 e

lni Ls i m d ?)

)

D 4

c3 S'l i.F F ' ' Cn" ill!.\\S TO T" (fFECl Ih ' N N F ' ' 'O!. E F 0" a

Mi0i L L1 IU, Di S;'E ;T. if t l ', P, s Fi f a TP, /s.3 LYSIS 0: t c'![F;: f!GE, ' ? r c. i l D [ ' T; At ny i t:, ", v:H m a m! C re'e r.h t e d J u'. _ 18, 1"/9 t!.; f:cccd invited th, pac l>

to this prou Ming to.ub :it co.

..t :

v, to th-f i c. c t,

m y, o f ' '.. v I 'l rule fcc m e hct i on o f n'. n t i'uc i in trcn ih t'.e a i b,i: of r >

.w ire raisina questicus ebaut af f-site n,o r t c *. i o n

, p m.

fo:l that jected by the Faard in its 9 > :i r l i' m he:m i n. 's -6 9 ::e ' e d,: r c a t i..ro A

l- ~

ihe Staff is of the vie that tH nca rule h.

n, ef f( ct on the analv 15 v5it '

re":lted in rejection t:y the Coard of nach contentions-th.ise pcrt 'w, of Contentions IC, 2C, and 4C 01 "s.

"2rsh, tonierttion 1 of SEA and Cuntotirn l?

of CV D that sought to raise que' tiuns eb:)ut e f f '.ite tr:e nort ation 0l sgnt fuel--and that those contention.s wern properly rejected h, the Board for the reasons set forth in its Order.

14.: nn,i rule will establish requirer ents for physical protection of irradilted reactor fuel in transit.

Thus, the purpase of this om rule is analogous to that servod by the rule requiring physical protect ion En tinst sabolage at 1

3 0 ~ C#

/ 44 Fed. Rog. 34460 (June 15, In79).

b 08800 / 2e 4

y m p: ty n o.uk n. #.

n 1,

s s -: "I 4

,,.i.

, ig g gi gdji,,

g_

fixed,itus -to lessen ?!.; pntentic I l or ia odm '. inn of a inu', rodiol a:.;!

ccm ', nen c e' to th pu'ilic Iy<cu nt

'.'g i a aver, n ) m lid i:,..

To an allega tion o f twi-c(,21i.ne uitu He rul" ill exist cu t i l.*

.c 1; beco :e ei fec tiv-en,luly 15, 197".u:' ts T.pp l i c n i s ' t Hai' t.hoir pl '

in.

2/

h cc x: < ca lhe n" ' rule '. d e io irral m n t i n" i t.

Obyw mly,,ilt:

in th inf or:al ru!ema!:iun u c.

- i:

m ',' n i i c,:, challengiu !!-

f :' cv rul" t al l-ir d ~-ibic in ih.,

lic n'.i:

or zu g l i ca b i l i tl, of the

" '1 '/

protecding t;ith:ut a sb ! ! n p o f " <. "

o l c i. 7.

'f>

lio.ever, ev"n i houl'

'ha c! li r in ni t-vi-lh

'J w v ro!

'or u<*

+ ii :i of s yat fum l it t r;,, i i.

no oi-m t h e F,, d ', a n :: 1 ; r.1 s o I t h -

L.,

con ten L ior s im'. L n.i ! 1H'o cf ienti-m u rn; r( ; i cf: ',. !im O a; i 11.c that i ::: rul ' r n r' ' h; i.o; l i c < t ' ' plan; :

i:

le, n.nq it c belit' (or itill be) ne, infor.. i. ' o n.

Foe i. i. ' rNi.on th ' 1 a f f L'el i c'

, t! : (

ti

, vi uni ty citer ): u : n r' of t h Intrrvenr:rs n y rea~,onab',

q;' 3n u e Staf f docu 'ent w L t ina for tn the Stu'+'n c c, n c l u, c ! > clout th: Wiiont-plan-fo r i n pl t..

,n t i ra t h i s n r.

rule, to reet to enise cppro,. 'i.:te con!:.,;v

-2/

Um:ever, con 10 CFL 2.790(d)(1), Pxific ra. a r.d i l n t e.

c uv (Diablo Cany, an Nucl.,ar Pi. ar f l u.t, l'n i t T J 2'),' ~/J. '

.in,

,i 11,,

review declined, CLI-77-2], 6 f,Rr ', '

(197 7) ad N ra d i s :ur.<. ion o f SLA 13 and 14 at pace 73 of Spe'i:il Prei orira Cor.rere

~r O r < !a r, suora

--'1/

Nuclear Genera ting Sta tion, ~ lim r Il ar,dD), /d 'o-2!b, h h w(nyle c 10 CFR,,75" Also, sco Po t a.

c Fle tric Fo m cc reint 79, 8l'-33, 89 (1974).

u OO o

g 3

()

200R 0!!!Gl!#I

^

~

. >. ~._ _

m_.

m._ _ r _

• 1 Iff _ [3 l . II _If ( l2 I '[', I [3 l Ii'!

('

CI ')

' O ll,1

{. L )[j I, f.

j f. l 'I f l [

fef? C ', i e' h (,

i ~. (

• i ('

a *'s'?

ia N i. f al ! '

<ti.i

+ 1:

2-r-

I,,

i, e,

,fl3

r i;: ] Pra' >1 ri nq [. :i t o r rea 3 0; ' r d,;'t d  ;) c }i f, ] [] / 4 (g[

t. ), /,] ),

t i

P 0 0 O H I M I.

r l l,n < rs ' - :-

.> "1%

, e. s.l I L. n U -, c,3 t.

.t nr.)

ce

.,r.,

.p,,'.o

- ~,.

l. i n.

! s ) ',

t.'

a : 1 V *i

' 1 T a i,

f-

! )'

rr-

. > + 3,

c-r 1

p ; i (I' I l.f l '., ' 3. -

i) -

'r' e

i s

In tb f ' 'r o f

)

)

t m., f. i,.. e, m.

c n,.

3

,...... p2 0,.

va..,

1._.

p,..

m,- n.,,i. 3,s,

. c

/

t.

s r.

L or'

< q a-lum' ' - -

t. l. r r. i c, r

.'c..!. ".',

)

cr e

)

(Susquc'h n,nc

's c -

Electric Station,

)

Unit; 1 w! 2)

)

-..ETI.FTr.TE n.;

U' C!.- -

.,- ii. I c, in N'! F E ' i r, 4:

I herr b y c c r.. i f: tin t wies or "ST-F'5 t ^ ' '

, k u, l cd.,,I. f.

c, v,.m 1,.

- c.

. r,.,

,7*,,,

p ' u. l o.

m pt m n'm,'o os

-l

.e - ]

i

'(,

t I a 4.

l.

e i

6 w:1 I I.

1 e l si.

s e ie ieIi /.

I

- s 1-

', m, - a

.1,,

a n, i c s b! wfr on

>;t.it i t.'

u, ~...

t..

ire

>1 a o. r.

by d r > r's ;t i n, n;.

".)ih:'<

iil, f i r : 's le,.,

o r, c '. i'

- ' "J F,

o

!atolj C(, : -i,qion ' n b' n il i iil '

a k te r,' b) d' QS ' ; i !!

,j c i t,e '

thia.md dcj of Jul, 19/9:

Chel:

i'

• f c c.

t<

C' t i r:

D-

'i ih U N. rs

t. J ii tc.c '

, Li:

~4n, E

'm h 'rf "~ al

f. :

ntal Co'iiti-ir- -

U. S. N '. : If' ir

' y.:l

[Gi, C

. i S. i n

[.

' i( c ( fi

!!c.h i r m i n n, 11. C.

2(" a E Del e a Dc',e State.3 1,e, N 1 C ql P".

Cle a 0. Dri'.ot

/,tanic W e f a.d !ic m ina Mr. Ti.rw M. Coru: ' y ! i t r ' o, CO. led I.

2l CU; + U Oi t ' a d i e t i O n I' ! c ' r. r; ',, 73 U.S. I M ccr "- u l c t ' a,' C' si mier l'

a t -- nt 01 f.r. / i : a r,'

..tc' Uashirg:

n, DE 2J5E

<, c u r c c s Co mro f al t h 'J Pem.syl v aiia Dr OwrH Paris' P. C. 1;o ) ? C n.;

Ato,ic 51 re'y aro' Li ce n e.i ra liarrisburg, PA 17120 g

r)a r. ;)

C o a r t.

t U.S. Ne:leir Dcqulatory Cc zisrion it. Coll een ".rs h Uashin'jlon, D.C.

205 %

Bo: 53N, Ru w K: '.:n f l i n To p, P A 18707 Jay Sillerc, Esq.

S h as.:, Pite 2n, Potts and F, r", - Ircne Le 'a..icz, Chai:" ' m Tro..'bri d e

'ihe Citizens Against Nuclear l

180') M S reet, N.U.

Dangers L'a shi ngen, D.C.

20035 P.O. F.ox 377 RD'l Contick, PA 18503

.-$ r)- Ln 3

PDM OlllGML

~

SusquH;: rn a F1/ iron.

tal

/

1: So f:  :,nd Liv h : ;!i.:r.>1-iciv: af

., :1 i t o.~ ' C1 -

'i'1 1 :, " c u l i *, i. <,,

U.S. Nu'l.

c/o (o,

500 Soa;! i iver ', b r e - t L', :, h ) : i.' i c., ii. L T'Cu'.a l!ilF.r:-P.rre, i/t i f, 0:.

I'm ;.o t i m! a r.2!'

c>i;-

G 'i

'lG b!. '

(, I [ h'

. ! ' t.'

[\\ [7 ! i C b :- ' l';

i[ l I(

e l'

C ?. l !l') ~' jI ut,;l' O b. Is t":li_ !

' l l ' '. ' i '

t 7

.. i

., Cc. ii s.t i on t ! r i, i n 't c.., P.C.

2a f L.S. I,5Aloce !' yel -

' ;.1 '_ iII lti i

( i b

.)

!) )') : '. f i N.

b;:11 ;,

Pe..n cyl v,. i c Fr a ; L in!,t Cc T.o Nori!

.iii.M 1.-

/1i i O II ;e t' f.' l l, ! ti ioii:I,i e,3 s.

da.2 5 ci.

i,U LC h ill, Isr e

r I'GU F.';O l fi;r II,C S l0 l f c.2,o DV\\

U