ML19242B938
| ML19242B938 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 07/31/1979 |
| From: | Gilinsky V, Hendrie J, Kennedy R NRC COMMISSION (OCM) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 7908090566 | |
| Download: ML19242B938 (8) | |
Text
.
/
1-.
~
i 7 / (_
(
\\
1 l
N U CLE A R REG U L AT O ?.Y CO MM!S SIO N I
t I
IN THE M ATTER OF:
i i
W ' 7 D U7c - 7 s
...--.'ir s d a _n.-
, a,._.,
r-r
.s.e r r..u - m_ e n.,
o e
.v 4
o 1
l l
Picce - Washington, D.
C.
-s,, o.-,:,..
2-a'a
?=ges, - -
Date -
I L
t 1
z s
i t
..r....,-,s,.,
a r or rs. r ow;..\\ L.
- r. r.m.> r L 4.-.
t
. r J
-.L
.s i
O.f.Hc:ai Re.Do cen i
424 N:r, ::i :t 3-ear WO$f':*g!OF,3.C."CCC' N AT!CNWlOE COVERAGE. D AILY b,
O.-
y i
y u
L-r)
L,j
- R6259 1
DISCLAIMER This is an unofficial transcript of a meeting of the United States in the Nuclear Ragulatory Commission held on m era,..
71 1-
'o70 D. C.
The Commissions's offices at 1717 H Streer, N. W.,
Washington, This transcript meeting was open to public attendance and observation.
has not been reviewed, corrected, or edited, and it m y contain inaccuracies.
The transcript is intended soiely for general informational As provided by 10 CFR 9.103, it is not part of the formal purposes.
or informal record of decision of the matters discussed.
Expressions of opinion in this transcript do not necessarily reflect final determinations or beliefs.
No pleading or other paper may be I'. led with the Commission in any proceeding as the result of or addressed to any statement or argument contained herein, except as the Commiss?nn may authorire.
h/ ?
-l ua
i 2
26259 l
Ij!
UNITED STATES OF A.'iERICA
.l i
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 2
3 PUBLIC MEETING 4
AFFIRMATICN SESSION 79-23 l
S t I
I 6;
I 71, t
l Room 1130 3
1717 H Street, N. W.
Washington, D.
C.
9
~
Tuesday, 31 July 1979 10 11 The Commission met, pursuant to notice, at 5:30 p m.
12 l BEFORE:
i DR. JOSEPH M.
HENDRIE, Chairman 13 ja VICTOR GILINSKY, Ccmmissioner 15 RICHARD T.
KENNFDY, Commissioner 16 PETER A.
BRADFORD, Ccamissioner JOHN F. A F.E A B N E, Commissioner 17 P RESENT :
jg l
i 19 S.
Chilk.
20,
l 21.
i SS !
g
- i 23 !
l l
i 24 i A 2 Federse R epcmrs, is 25,
203 L
J i,... >
l
259.01.1 3
- sh I
CHAIRMAN HEiDRIE: The rcom will please quiet --
2 ene assemblec multitude. I would lik e to ask my co lle ague s to 3
Join me in holding a short notice meeting on an af firmation c
item.
5
( A chorus of a yes. )
6 CHAIRMAN HE:!DRIE: So or6ered.
7 MR. CHILK: This is SECY-79-59-A, a procosed amendment 3
to 10-CFR, part 73.55, to extena the implement ation date for 9
certa in complementary and alternative measures f or the 10 protection against the insider threat.
.11 Th e purpose of the paper would extend the time for 12 imolementation of pat down searches until February 1, i980.
13 Four of you have voted to approve that paper.
I have not 14 heard f ron Commissioner Gilinsky.
I believe he proposed to 15 abstain.
16 COMMISSIONER GILINSKY: I would extend it for a 17 brief interval.
18 MR. CHILK: Commiss ione r Ahearne, in his aoproval, 19 has suggested that the period be restricted to November 1st.
20 CO M.MISSIONER AHE ARNE : That was the only grounds I 21 voted to approved it.
22 MR. CHILK: I have three votes, then.
23 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: Pihat was the base date?
24 CO VMISSIO:i?R AHEAONE : Six morths.
25 CO MM I SS I O:iER 3RADFORD: Vihy dc Pt you consider me to n:..
J c;. J'
- q Qj
259.0 1.2 4
ysh ce.toining John at c!ciember 1st, and tnat way, tnere would oe 2
three of us who don'- tnir.k it ought to be any longer than 3
that.
4 C0!SISS!otlER KEMEDY: de are just making suostantive 5
re-arrangements to the paper.
I would like to have further 6
time to consider it since this is just an affirmation item.
7 MR. CHILK: If we don't act on this paper, then the 8
plt down search becomes e ff ective because it e xp ir e s --
9 COMMISSIONER KENNEDY : dell, we're just violating our 10 own rules.
We're supposed to come to the table and vote en
.11 the issue th a t is hafore us and not discuss it. And he re we 12 are having discussion and making a fundamental ange in what 13 has been decided.
14 Tnat is not an a f firmation.
15 Co?SISSIONER GI LINSKY: Well, we have done that 16 before.
17 C0!GISSIONER KEidEDY: No, by God, we haven't.
18 MR. CHILK: de really ha ven't, except that this one 19 came upon us just at a particular moment in time.
All of you 20 have been in meetings all day today.
de did go into this 21 meeting with three of you voting to epprove the paper with the 22 date that the paper calls for, February Sth, Co mm i ss io ne r 23 Ahearne saying November.
24 COWISSI0 DER GILINSKY: de ll, we could vote on a 25 c u i c discussion meeting.
majju'
~
,r
,c L- ~'
259.01.3 5
gsh CH AI R'.i AN HENDR IE : Let's go back and unaf f irm it.
2 I think we have to act on it.
Those in favor of a snort noti:e 3
meeting to discuss the problem bef ore us with the oat do wn 4
searcn rule, will please say aye.
5 (A c us of eyes.)
6 CHAISMAN HENDRIE: So ordered.
7 I take it that the sta ff has esked for s ix months.
3 MR. CHILK: The staf f asked for six months on the 9
basis tha t. you've got to assess the hearing board 10 recommendations.
You've just gotten a new paper on that and 11 they believe that it will take you several months to do that, 12 following which they've got to put in the imp l em en t at io n.
13 And that was their reason for selecting Feoruary.
14 GH AIRMAN HENDRIE: Gentlemen, we can make it No vembe r 15 if a majority want to go there.
But I think that that is 16 a guaranteed extension because I don't think that tne 17 c o mm is s ion, sinc e the conmission has to take an action on the 13 clearance rule, and since that is a some..Jt difficult matter, 19 it seems to me where I must say it is not clear to m3 where one goes from here on it.
21 I don't think that there is any possibility of 22 clearing the pet down search rule area by 1 November.
I 2
would recommend the six months.
But if tnose of you would lik 2-to kseg it on a short leash would continue to pref er to do 2$
that, e ithe r whethe r you egr ee or disagree with me escut an
, 3n l' U) 0
%'. ':1 C,
6
'59.01.4 ash I
accarent need to come cack on.;c ves:oer 1st and extend in order 2
to get a c t io n.
If a majority lies that way, I have no 3
objection.
4 COMMISSIONER AMEARNE : My first pre fe rence, frankly.
5 was for not ex t end ing it. But uson re reading it and sort of 6
s em i-r e luc t a ntly, or reluctantly going along with an e xt e ns io n,
7 I be ieve that the three months was acout as f ar as I could 8
realistically say that I could go.
9 But I would have no problem with not extending it.
10 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: Well, I don't know.
Do you
.11 remember the discussions about that?
12
O MM I SS I O.1ER AHE ARNE : Yes.
13
'HAIRMAN HENDRIE: I don't know if that ha cp e ne d r
14 befo e yo came.
15 COMMISSIONER AHEARNE: dell, I have been to a lot 16 of stuff on it.
17 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: All right.
I have a vote for 13 November 1st, willingness to extend until Novemoer i st.
19 Who else?
20 CO MMISSIONER KE"NED(: I've already voted.
21 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: I will vote Feoruary 1st.
Vic?
22 C0 "M IS5 :0NER GILINSKY: November ist.
23 CO MM I SS I ONE R B R AD.000 0 : I will jo tr John in 'lovencer 24 ist, with a request that, in f ac t, if it has not been dealt 25 w i-.. by then, give us a little more w 2rn in g.
-/',
t' ['i /
.I t. a
!59.01.5 7
Jsh MR. CHILK: les, I tnink the staff was late getting 2
it up. I think we goof ed in not inviting your a ttent ion to 3
the fact tha t we didn't pic k this up i m.n e f i a t e ly.
4 CHAIRMAN HENDd!E: It c ame upon us all of a sudden 5
here.
6 MR. CHILK: Nobody picked it up until last night.
7 CHAIRMAN HEdORIE: All rignt.
I will rule that a 3
majority of the commission is silling to extend until November 9
lst.
Please note that, if I may, Dick, tnat Commiss ioner 10 Kennedy and I agree with the extension, but think tha t the
.11 originally requested sta ff mark of Feoruary 1st would have 12 been more appropriate.
13 COMMISSIONER BR ADFORD: I would gue ss the November 14 lst deadlins would drive us toward at least an early cut in 15 SeptemJer at the clearance rule procedure.
16 CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: Yes. That is one of the things 17 that we've got to turn to after we get off the budget.
And 13 also, as part of that, why so7sbody, the counsel or somebody 19 has to figure out some ways of ;etting f rom where we are now 20 to whe rever we're going to go.
21 I felt kina of de f eated by the complexity sitn which 22 it ended.
23 Gkay.
ile have an order to deal with t h e th i ng.
The 24 Secretary will please i ssue it.
25 (Whereupon, at 5 : 30 p.m., the ". earing atj:ur ec.)
r
- uo u - -