ML19242A365

Forwards Complaints Filed in Us District Court for Middle District of Pa.Cases Include Park Vs Met Ed,Ca 79-906,Mars Vs Met Ed,Ca 79-912 & Ward Vs Met Ed,Ca 79-769

ML19242A365
Person / Time
Site:	Crane
Issue date:	07/26/1979
From:	Carrier W AMERICAN NUCLEAR INSURERS
To:	Saltzman J Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
NUDOCS 7908010491
Download: ML19242A365 (40)

Text

• >

?

}

\\/E

\\

V i

\\

l CFFIG OF THE GENE % COLNSEL

\\v i

.cw w w =ne

e nese ou sew

a

\\

vl t-u BURT C.PROOM.CPCU Pseudent July 26,1979 Mr. Jerome Saltzman Deputy Chief Office of Antitrust & Ir/sinr.ity Directorate of licensing U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission Washington, D.C.

20555 Re: Three Mile Island

Dear Jerry:

I enclose copies of complaints filed in the additional suits now filed in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania:

1.

Jack Freedman t/a Babies Specialty Shoppe versus Metropolitan Edison, et al -- Civil Action #79-892 2.

John Park and Lenetta Park, husband and wife and Jennifer Park, a minor by her parents and guardians versus Metropolitan Edison, et al -- Civil Action #79-785 3.

Frank Allen Park versus Metropolitan Edison, et al -- Civil Action

1. 79-906 4.

Donald Mars and Leah Mars, husband and wife versus Metrupolitan Edison, et al -- Civil Actinn #79-912 5.

Ms. Jo Ward versus Metropolitan Edison, et al -- Civil Action

1. 79-769 Yours very truly, p

b..e.. ' c c.'

s William C. Carrier Claims Counsel WCC/pbs Enclosures 485 283 Ad/S S//

7

.. g n -

79 08010 g g

d

't 10 SO U T H M A R K ET SCU A R E PEPFER. H AMILTON & SCHEETZ

"^"5"u"

'7'

• 717 233 8493 AT1 o RN EYS AT LAW t

123 SOUTH SRCAD STREET W AsHtN T t,

.OC 2C006 PHILADELPHI A. PENNSYLVANI A 19109 202-as2 7 500 Mk 211 f 9 3 3 0 0 0 k

' ENTU R Y P A R K E A S T kg G EL E S. C A 90097 e

213 8734 e04 4

JcMa A. GUERNSEY h

215-8's3 4343 24n m.3 John F. Wilson, Esquire Lawrence W. F o:<, Esquire Assistant Staf f Counsel Drinker, Biddle & Reath Metropolitan Edison Co.

1100 PMB Building P.O.

B o:t 542 Philadelphia., PA 19107 Reading, PA 19063 Michael M.

Maney, Esquire Elizabeth Ol:'sted, Esquire Sullivan & Cromwell Sullivan & Cromwell 1775 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.

125 Broad Street Washington, D.C.

20006 New York, 1;Y 10004 Richard Sandler, Esquire 1

James H.

Agger, Esquire David, Polk & Wardwell General Counsel One Chase Manhattan Pl[;a y

Catalytic, Inc.

New York, IIY 10005 ' 3 \\

Centre Square West

(

j 1500 Market Street qV Philadelphia, PA 19102 I

/

Re:

Jack Freed.an t/a Babies Specialty Shoppe v.

Metropolitan Edison Co.,

et al.;

M.D.

of Pa., Civil Action No.79-892

Dear Gentlemen and Ms. Olmsted:

Enclosed is a copy of Cceplaint in the cbove-captioned action.

Sincerely yours, i

w - ~.

John A.

Guernsey JAG /nbl Enclosure cc:

Willian C.

Carrier, Esquire

/' 85) 284

,w anc.

gI, < tpgaj\\\\. -

7;,,,,.7 7.,...

,n 4

4 m

ed g.

s "

N

4 r,'

, L u L.# v ~'( b % -

f If tb a

i,.-

1 i.

JUl U N I

w* c. CARRIER I

I:I THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT j

FOR THE :1IDoLE DIST."ICT CF PE::::SYLVANIA I

I I

. JACK FRE.".D:'A:I i

i t/a 2ABIES SPECIALTY SHOPPE t

I

-; 3370 Faxten Street j

lHarrisburg, PA 17111 v.-h_p rg ;

V.

f l'd M Q[Ah Ll h l

I/ t/

METROPOLITAN EDISCN CO.

2800 Pottsville Pike

CI;

1. ACTION I

Muhlenberg, PA 19605 and i SABCCCK & WILCOX CCMPANY i

i 161 E. 42nd Street

't'lNew York, New York 10017 d

and

'l J. RAY McDERMOTT & CCMPANY, INC.

1010 Ccron Street

', ew Orleans, Louisian: 70112 i

'I and l

l GE::ERAL PUELIC UTILITIES JURY Ti'IAL C"'4ANDED

.260 Cherry Hill Rm.i Parsippany, :!n Jersey 07034 j

p - l _.,

and A

1,W. BW',2g 5 4,l L, L[.

JE'SEY CE:;T?a L PC'JER t.ND LIGHT C3.

l

',Madiscn and P1 achbcul Morristcwn, ;ie. Jersey "mm l

~.,

and W

^~

i h

"' E EUIT.V,0,vM,7 CATALYTIC, 1::C.

1500 ':a rket St.

6

'}, '

g Centre Square best

. g. Q. c4'

/ ' e Phila., PA 19102

o.

i CrPLAI"T

+

1 f

1.

The plaintiff, Jack Freedran, is the cwner and i,

operator of Babies Specialty Shoppe,'.hich is an establishr.ent I

^

lin the buainess cf selling baby furniture located at 3370 Faxton

.f i

9 Street, Harrisburg, PA 17111.

t i

f 4

f l

it gt 285

-}'9j B K U ngM M Lj n an o w.n j

i

- # ~ ' A I 5 ) f >' ' ) )9As4 y,

N.,e 4$

• C i s **

• t p '

• C' 7 A t.

C i. e a, a r ~ c..c c e s... c a a v c a v = < s : enet w -

n C

C;

^ ~.

-c

.ac-az.;sc.-

w a. -,. s - e n a

-1 d'd t(

'.C"

{V,

,*')

e "4

1. s ru c, wr

<$4 as

.T 2pv

a.

s t

2.

(a) The defendant, Metropolitan Edison Co. i -;

i Pennsylvania corporatica doing basiness within the Com:cm eal.th of Fennsylvania with offices located at 2800 Pottsville Pike,

! :'uhlenberg, PA 19605.

(b) The defendant, Babcock and Wilcox Co. is a New i

I t

Jerscy corporation with officen located at 161 E. 42nd Street, i' New York, New York, 10017.

t i

j (c) The de fendant, J. Ray McDermott & Company, Inc.,

i t is a Delaware Corpcratica with offices located at 1010 Cc: mon l

l i

! Street, New Crleans, Louisiana 70112.

I (d) The defendant, General Public Utilities, is a i

I

'j' Pennsylvania corporatica with offices located at 260 Cherry I

l Hill Road, Parsippany, New Jersey 07054.

l (e) The defendant, Jersey Central Iy.ver and Light Co.',

i 3

i has offices located at Madicen and Punchbowl, Morristown, New I

i l Jersey, l

i (f) The defendant, Catalytic, Inc. is aPennsylvaniaj l

j corporatica with offices located at 1500 Market Street, Centre i

\\

l i Square West, Philadalphia, PA 19102.

3.

Jurisdiction is based upon 42 U.S.C.A.

2210 et seq.

and tha 'ecunt in controversy exceeds Ten Thousand ($10,000.Cl)

Dollars.

4.

Service of process upon the defendants herein has l

been cada pursuant to F.R.C.P 4 (e

.nd Title !.2 of the

'l l Pannsy!nnia Censolidated Statutes Annotated, Sections 5322 and

) ms.

485 286 s da dime l p

9 4

l m a,.om u.

.1

. '.' S u.

~~.1

3

'. '. I t. r: 3 TE " " = t T :: '. " J iF==:CA:: ' C t. '. E L

.3

!* trop M a*3~ "- u h6f C'

[1 C.. I' r 1:4 T'/ ELL C ?.'3 te a r s. f A s

~.j' ( * *[ C 8

, c..,, _,,, m.,.,.3, y %.,,,,, u. n

,s,,

.ra***=~

1. sw vw w v r.

-a v r :

r u c. m r c a,. -

'/ _..' _...

l

-a' T.**

D

.a_.. _. _ _.. _.. -

7 3

e r.

r

'w 7

/)

,t j -

., 3, c'. ~cri-

-t

/

! l ti * <

J i

tn

~!

/. - i m <_

5.

On or a'aout ". arch 23, 19 79 the de fendants through their agents, servants and employees at the Thice :lile Island Nuclear Pouer Plant caused or allowed radicactive substances to b.

emitted into the environment, a fact which spokepersons I

for the defendants ackno -ledged had occurred.

6.

The emissions of radiation into the environment I

i neared such dangerous levels that Governor Thornburgh for the Coconwealth of Pennsylvania ordered on Starch 30, 1979 that all pre-school children and pregnant women evacuate from trithin t

five (5) niles of the Threc tiile Island Nuclear Pot;er Plant.

7.

However, due to the uncertainty created by the con-i i

' flicting statements of the defendants' spokepersons and state t

I and local and naticnal government spokepersons regarding the l

langers of radiation exposure and r-potential for a i

i catastrephic radiation e: posure, large numbers of individuals cvacuated the area surrounding Three Itile Island Nuclear Po.er

' Plant.

q I

8 The defendaats all centributed to the constructica, i

I maintenance and operation of the Three >1ile Island Nuclaar i

I "cwcr Plant cad its ccmponent parts.

9.

The daca;;es sustained by the plaintiff tare caused i

t i

, by the negligence, carelessress, recklessness, willfulness and i

i l vantour. ass of the defendants:

t i

i (a) in failin; to properly design the said nuclecr

' po;;er plant (Three :!ile Island) and its conpenent parts; I

(b) in failing to prcperly construct the said nuclear I

power plant and its corporen narts;

-3 I

485 287 Ph a

~, e p e n t, e 3($ h Ih 1 i

dukh t

1 rq*Ae"; % 53 sana u.

we

_r, f f. '" 21. t.,,

ri'-

.<..m...~,_..,m.,.,,

J.. u e at -,, - -.

c_ - s - c, -.u-ru 6

, -r m.

.3:

3 t, _,.... ;

.t

,,, ~ ~ ~..

[

e T

fa j -

i s'

i --

a i

i l

I 4

(c) in failing to properly inspect and test the said i

t 4

i

, nuclear power plant and its ccmpacent parts; i

(d) in using faulty and defective ccmpanent ma te ria ls :

1 i in the ccnstruction of the said nuclear pcwer plant; i

fe) in exposing the public to such a defective power I

, plant; i.

l i

(f) in failing to warn the plaintiff of the defects l t

in said nucicar pcwer plant; i

I

/g) in failing to exercise due care in the engineer-l 1

ing, compositien, design, constructica and operation oc said nuclear power plant; (h) in failing to exercise the high standard of care,'

I required in the operation of a ultrahazardous activity (i.e.

l q

i i

januclearpcwerplant),

l j

1 c

10.

Defendants knew cr in the exercise of crdinary care i

i

! had reason to knew of the dangerous effects of its nuclerr pcwer -

i i

plant.

11

(

d, The said nuclear power plant and its ccmpeneat ccapositional parts were u:,de. t!e sole and exclusive possescica i

~ and control cf the defendant s, while it.was being eng,ineered, l

1 ccepcsod, dasigned, constructed and operated.

12.

De.le..dants operated said nuclear pcwer plant and its component parts in a defective cead!tica unreasonably dan:;erous i

to the plaintiff's property and harm was chareby caused to the l

I plaintiff.

l

\\

nens eE r ne,ud ? l !

p3 n,

i

! : n I

h,J UniNs5W

• 1 485 288 I'

J I

f

.f

~ c:m e m r,r.

a: m

.vGr.t _ _

TI c '.it. c. m c.c ceen arfr ;i.t=:=:c::: s.va a:

U ZZ, u [jD,:3

-'t

- 3 _, 3 3,,,c,cg3y,, c.,t, m,,,,,,, c n g g.,, y,, q ;, g g w ~,.,3 g.,, y 3

. q :r. ~ -

- - cu. ce e c ta c T ees ssNw u<w_

,[ ~

" C 2. 5 t " C 8 t is'C C s <

• 0 T ", p :

l0 n %

..r,.c,,:,..

y.:..,

r._,,,,,c

.,, u. s. c,.,.

. 7 Y '. ' ;!.::

c,2

4 i

i i

i i

h 13.

The de:endar.ts are engaged in the business of 1

i i

I i designing, manufacturing, ccastructing and selling of the com-l

- pcnent parts of the said Three Mile Island Nuclear Power Plant t

I and those ccmponent parts ucre expected to and did reach the

{

nuclear power plant without substantial change in the condition i

I lin whi:_h they were designed, manufactured, constructed and sold.

l i

t I

14.

The defendants in construccing and operating a I

l nuclear pcuer plant and its ccmponent parts in such a defective

!condician as to be unreasonably dangercus to censumers, violated

. the standards of Secticn 402A of the Restatement of Torts (II).

I I

15.

As a result of the foregoing the plaintiff's business *i t

has suf fered irreparable econcmic losses which include but

[

s I

il I'

l are not linited to lost operating time and loss of sales an i I

)'

property devaluation.

1, I

i 16.

Further, as a direct result of the defendants' l

i lccaduct the public interest in sNpping in the area sorrcunding l

l the Thr,ee. ile Island Luclear Plant area has been so reduced l

1 i

'that the plaintiff will never recover fren the econcmic loss.

l i

I l

17.

Further, the public's fe.r of contaminated rerchandise

.I 4

has nearly rendered the plaintiff's prcducts and services olucrthle n-1 i

13.

Further, the plaintiff can shcw uith its receipts i

i 4

h

'_he rarked declina in business im edi.itely f llcwin;; March 23, l

i i1973.

I i

6 19.

Fu:ther, due to the extraordinary negligence cn the i

part of tha defendanta and in ieu of the irrepirable ecenc~ic

. I ca s surf 2rd by the pla in ti f f, * 'm plaintiff de-,nds thit i

i i "' i t iVe da~'.]es be

.rda3 in itS fa'.or-a pp?q('3h

/

3 % A f 7 *"s 0 $TA5

,,;t

~~

m. c. -._

' ' '^ * ' ; i c L,,,,,,,,M CJ SI

'* *~~

..,-,-.- so:

' a t.

., u : C: AJ;

==}.~~,

~

', e

'~

74 7 - j M

,., p a. a s ram gg p.

( P7 % I.

. C,',,,7,.g 1

. 9 2

'e

g

• C#

"*E

-(

s a.

. _. -. ~

~

- i.

gfy J e%.N.Na d

]

-3

).

~

\\

'i 9

- - ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' -

~

1 I,

i i

20.

Further, the plaintiff demands a trial by jury on all issues of this action.

f

'31EREF03E, judgrent is deranded j ointly and severally I

j against the defendants by the plaintiff for economic losses in an amount in excess of Ten Thousand ($10,000.00) Dollars as i

I well as punitive damages in an amount in excess of Ten Thousand

-l ($10,000.00) Dollars.

I I

l t

(-

4 I

O !,,

f 8 ':L?

O/2raa.

I, JC:i:1 J. O'd RI F., J R.

p 1

i

/ ICIIARD F.

ROSE:l R

l JO!i:1 J. O'3RIE:!, III l

I I

f

.I

,I

'l

?

J s.

l

' l' i

l i

4 I

.' I I

I]

I i

l

'l 1

i 1 %.* r.n = 7 -l h ;'

[': J s s ::

I 4qp

.sl t, e I

f'

_g

]

48$

290 l

6 m,

m u.

m.__.__._._.;~..~

c

-

,=m,

.:;. - s :=::

a l

r ri i

1. c t, t 3 r e

s. r s e r..

c.y a. a r n e ". r.vf

• ,sf (j

,[ * !

5.

~**7'd 8

,,,,... r

- _..,.. - -... ~

T

, y

.c <,.

..;.c,.,c,,..=.a.,

p r - 2 L. A. -

.L-2=._-=?:-

7.

-_7-

..~;-

l h..t t[L@ S

.i.n q TI.L'ii{ U:t.r.t Wi l-)TF. TW[y'.,[i td a

r

,9

.P FCR THC Js n_

<m \\;.,e u

-u

..a

.mu_ar.ou c _cr_t:

a-J W. C. CARRIER Civl'. A CTioN FtLc No.

JCH ' '7 ' '.: a n d II: "TTA PARK, !!uaband and Ji f e and JL:; I!i". PAFK, a ninor Ly her

'. ra n t.3

.1 n d gu.rdiar.s JC!i:; PAR' and 1.,,u..,-.

P,,,..,

u.

.....n

cu:h Yor St.

Caldsboro, Pa l':ai:W T g,.3'310 NS I

Cv.Y;

.-.,,.,_r-.- 6, c.,,,,

n

,~.

es.sv..

~.

c r. d I

t I

n

, - ~,,

--,~.r.

e..

A, v v..

r,,..,.

ww.

a

%v

.n..

and y

..,,-3,,.-.,,

5 su..-.'a'..,.,,

u.

van.

. s t..

.Jr.

.a and C'.'e'..*L'

&" 'v' 'e.L'.A'%

'w"A" A'.'J'A.~)

A -

3,7 :

v m...c.2 m. C.,..'..'

t" r "7

r.

T 'u9--*

m, '..n.*>. 1*

3 -j li.. r i: ! i j

u.a.aaL.r%

I...

..w l

To t',9 ; 5

.. ] p. 3.,

..13' a,!40: 3f"

) R t. c L: p' 7.1 J T' J.

O'Brien, EC].

i l's a 'l r ' E 5

- O I'

'4

' A I l.k l t'

" ~,, ', g e ' g l i[d 91 31'..' 19 } 'j )

g 1

l

. 'l 1e'-'( 4^ ', h ' ' ; p

't'

^=t

'{(

(

. [ i,.!

Q} ;y

} mV

)j9

.{

P

(

L C*

't'f 5( ;

o

- 1 '.

1

.J;

, g' c'

s,4 t

\\ '

1. .., [

f i (.

(...

h

~

..y

,/. -

s -

h 5

f.

.e f00I)F>r-L

%mmu

~,w, 485 291

< s : "

~

a a

e

(

I

(

e 7,

...;+.

,..-.)

- -. D, a, 5.,.g L, V u,,,.

1..

s

.1.

s.es;ma

.v.

n.3 i:-

,.,.,7.

v. a.... p.-

s. m.,.,.

C y..., q.....,.....v.m

..Jwu c.

v I

i p, - {.,'

D..\\ > r.

--,4 C.T i,' LT, c.e a 'tC'.,'

9 ui o

~

...a LE..i.TTA Pr.F., 1:usband and '.li fe

_ /

C-7h and JC:' IFER PNG, a :,.inor by her

/

ocrents and tcardicns v

3.? n.t' Tr.

m!. L. ;.,n,4a t ~v..= ~a k n o N., ;,

.2-

. L a s

80Uth YO r.C St.

Cold: boro, Pa.

1/.

vga.ov

.a r a r,

._.D T

a+,

a.

a-I

...r,n.,C..

,;..r, CO.

.ma o t.c

. :.. u s..

[3 []n

. 2300 Patt:.cille Pi.<c u.. a..

f f,I,!!

,.m [a],

'uhlenber~, Fa. 19605

. g c-,.' ' D*' N _

n, c c...

u

. p_o g..,.

C ."m'.?.."t" r

. uovea v

161 E,

/.:ni Street l'

g CClaic p..

,.m..

ork,

..a.e Yorg 1C017 n,

// > w-and Ecp

,,,.,;..,..'~.L c.

u" C.' '..'

e' v.,

7.".."a.

~,.

.n.

i

.a...a

• s 3...,

1010 Cr_ an S tree t

~Nr i,cu Cr_2cns, Louisiana 7Cm12 ar -1 m

• t r.- *. r. L. L L... J L.i ~.....r

- T. r-1-wu&w V

250 Cher:,r H ill. P. a a <1 Parny -n.,

i.e - Jersey 070 %

and 7..,7-.,

~... -.,... L

.a.

C3.

...)

... - t

..a a

.m _sor nd Pun

50. 1

. '. 3 r r i s c a ' in, i.eu Jersey and e.~.<,

,'_F, T'*L.

^

L. ; ru L &

v

.5 :0.' u xe : stract Cc. e : r e S q ua ra '..c s :

p,

, m.. m

~. g.

m.,... a, _2t,.. c_.a.m, r

s-g

.---..7-J

..U

[ E A. I' w 5

v2

.6.

Cii.

h.

$n

• . r g

.y

-' w6

,ater, vara.

Pn.,

a r '

c. i c i.. _.., o f u.

r.- -

i t '. t "i ' l. '.' ~ " i d 0Li J

.2 2,

!L s 'C

, C3 ;

~,.

w(h O 7 T 0

p 4.%. j>

r^-

,, ur, F

t.. s a

s

,)

ef

,i..fn

., 3

.o.t, ?

.A 1 :

4 w 4 f obM J $,) Ig" 4.I 485 292

e d

u 2-(n).hc de:. cad nt, c-:2 tropolitan c.Ji oa Cs., is c Pennsyl.-cnia ctrpor2 tion doin; ousiness

!. t!. i n the Cor. nan::c.lth y

of Pennsylvania *cith offices located at 23 3 Potts.rille c ae, Muhlet rg, Pa. 19305.

,i (b) The de fe ndant, Cabcoch and..ilco.x Ca. is c :cu

,1 Jcr;cr corporation uith cffices lor.ted at lil E. 42:,:' Street,

!!cu Yan, Uc:, Yan, 10017.

i (c) T::e de fendant, J. Ray McDermott & Campary, Inc.

i L is a Daiavare c.rporation uith offices located at 1010 Cc c.:n i

E

et, h u Crleans, Louisiana 70112.

l'

( 1) The defendant, Gauural Jublic Ut li;.;as is a u

Pernsy_vani; correration 'eith o ffices located at 200 Cherry r.

Hill ". cad, Parcip.:ny, n,.'e rs e y C 70 5!..

c) The dalendant, Jersey Central Pocer and Lir,nt Co.

s I

ha; off ces 1 catcd at.u d ;s on and Puncc.;o.:1, S.arristn 1,

.2u i

.'erse; I:

p (f) The d2fandant, Catalytic, Inc. is a e;ns;_. aia r

carnor:: 'a vita of fices loccted at 15 's 0..re..e t Street, C? :.2 S qu ar a '..e s t, Fr lcs.alphia, :' a. 19102.

3.

Jurisdictica it 'csed u un

'.2 U.S.C.A.

2210 et _;;. cr H..-

c.m ent in a :, t r w a ;. >

';:2 2 e d -.en n:uar ad sJib,C:J.~0) w,,,. 76 a

=e e f -

e,

.= =e z e... m m

' ;) U r '

7: to

- ' ?

)

?. n j ;. ;.. e i? oj,'.e I

6

,,_.,L.*

. s L.

t-

--w t

a t,.

3 J.,__

s

.s s

...a o

_..m

f. El.f _J J ', '6 E f1

%I1

'{

abJ s' c t,(>

485 293 1w 3

" " " ~

r

l e

e d.

4 T

t 5.

'a n ; s.' a c '. ' r:b 23, 13 7, t. h e d e f c.' a:, through

..i,,.

.,.. a,

c, a.r u-'.. w a-j,.,

u.....

u. --.c* Q j. t. o > -

u u. a ' e. 4.

a..;. 0 3 - ~. 4., a

.e,..'3-

-t

- c u

-a am...,,S

_O 1,,,.

e.. :.. C,a c-.,,,

a A..o r,--

,,,...., C e. c..<*.-..-,_n,

.i

,x.. u a

-6.

uuu.

J 3 pot cparsons for ::12 de:endants ackna ;1c d ed S2d o:: rred, 3

o J

ct th2 Three U. le :sland.,u:lcar Peter Plant, i,'

6.

Tw2 c:aiacions of radiar.on into the envirr:ent r

i

r. cared such danprous 1c eels that Governor Tharnburgh fo r the i

I

? Co men:.ealt'a o f Pennsylnnia on ::arci 20, 13 '9 ordered that all cre-sc, col c,u.,.tcran anu, pregnant.ior:n evacuate t r e m. u t t,.: t n a

fice (3) miles of the T:'re 2 hie Island..uclecr Plant.

M.:eset, due to the 'm ertaiary created by the c on flic t in;; statement; a:

th0 d 2 :C a d.:.n t s ' 5p c..O p J r SG n 3 and SCO~e, 1CCal GT.d national s

o u,u _--.,.. _>

,. o,ard..,

s..e _... _,.a o,.

~...dn,~.

v.. _(

...s a a

.a en,caura, rhe plaint f s felt compellee to evacuate the crea

^ct

' ! = :. c in saf2.

t 4

.a.

b

.- '.. vu b-6L, A-km. I/n y O'. a n C C :' ~ nc e ' '. ! Operation a f. i..'.e T'.T rC e [le 1310 ;'. 3,. 0 010.7 t

.33. 1 6s

a. aaa.

._a

(.. -,,n...,sa.

3 sa.

i r.,

n

~

gt~-

1 w

.s..,.

A...,

ac; w... -,a - J 6.1.,

r,

,) ;, 1 :.

.r

..,..u uu..v- -

aa

.., a j

.n,.1..,.4 1

D.

-,c....,. ~..i r n

,.,'.7.1-s.,. < -.- c L

..u.,.

,3.,.,

u,.

3,,.,

2a3 a

2-sa,

.... 4$,

.u

..~..s.,_.

n&

L4i -

-6

..iJ

( a,> ~...~.

. s g..,..

u_.._,

.m_.

j.' s

. g 1 e.

. /.,, Cu 66i

,i

1.'

,'..., a T

.3

)

..n,,s.,-.

v.

(a a

--s.

~..-

(as 4

.,.s 3.,..,v....,..,,.. 2...

f

.n

• .s-

,,,.1

3. f,.

L..

4.

t-

,*...L..a s

. 2 I

p a

j -,

a 9n L

L 7

A

..,a y.

.I m,.,

n.-

s 3

g -

6 -

I.

m,5 g e j. 4 *, n4 4.

g -.

A, ej g

r y-,

en uuu.

485 294

t 9

b

(

t (c) 2--

u s t.

fc 2..

a.m J

._;;b/2 c c y... c t

. r i a i..

c., na..s_._.. m. a.a

. a..._ u2

. _ m.., % -s.im..

1 -.._,

m

.._u..

(2) in e:.:pos n;; the public to sca a d2 factive pc..cr plant; (f) in failir.- to warn the plaintiffs of the def2 cts i

4

.a a..d.

,... i n_ a p.,.., p c., _ _.

3 e..%

( ~.;) in failing to a::crcise due care in the en;;inaar-

..T, c cmp o s i tica, design, cons truc tica and ope ratica c f said i

nucicar po.cer >lant; (h) in ~ ailing to c:.:crcise the hi;;h standard of care f

requir ed ia the operaticr. cf cn ult:chacarcus cc.veicj (i.e.

.i a

3.-r,=l.1 a w.

-m.yw..L..

gs a u. a d

1.-e 9

Defand;"ts kncu or in tr.e e:'.ercise o f orainary cara 6

• L,,.i a.. C s e n.a C D

r..,

r.,,1 C~

s L.,. n.

,1 ow

...s.

J

..f_.--a su,..,,.n..r.

f,.C.t* C C e. a-Ol ;

s.~.,,,.4.p,-.

ea n

y._. a s h

plant.

ige

~ s. a..Ci*b

,...i.n,_,L

- : I w..A

.,1 -ee'.

-a..u A

ww-.,-)..bo~6 y. (.sw

,, J

, 6s 3..

h m.ee..

w C v'.~~ ". a" i * #L.1 ". 3 '*

p w' " "% a

..-^".6' kl "., ',' 3 ".

'.'".w

s" v' I '

w" ". #.

c'.~.^.'.'s'.a. '. c "p "a a" ' r 's' '. #. C.

c

.s

~

v w-I

.,.,..n.t n.:.. -

y.i v

a, a Gn..,.,.,.....a3 i -

1

,..3 D C _. '., e-'..',.'#"..~."".^"u, i

...,3

.m

.su.

d 1

no-

,-.-J 1

w e -. 7 e a u. u,

,s, a.: a,..,,

-.aam..,.cA u.. A.

.~, a

. u C n..

..) C, a. a_ u.

n t

-o, t'

"u,s,.,J,.,-

r, u........, d.- e-

..7 l

...a me

.... -.,, 0 p.

.7

-u-c.c1 i- -..

c 6

1 w

v..J

.. d..

-.)

.N a L:.,.c.,..

. :w._.L, Cn, i:,.,

-,.,-..., :. w.. J v. 4 L. ) 1..

sa

. a...... _,..

4, b-

..%.s..,

6

• j 6.

0 u.1_, p 'L u _.,.. -

e ;. u.: -

t.a..-

~-a

.. 3

.,~,L,..,

4*

-.,.n.,...

m

....a z.

.-y, u..-

u-y C1 3%

)

s 2 n i n. "t C L. E D.

12.

~J. e a fer 2 m,re er.n

.n ncaus;r.en of n

~

C n_

. a-e...s.w-.e.. &

c, L.',e..-

3

,.,.y

,,,I

e. !. n_

u, a..

A&

ac 6.

.....e..ae,,,_,

.9

....A.,

I i

-i=,..,,.+.-

3

.g g..

4J

%i.g a

.-J

• 'J

• =i**~a

• • w

.wa.-

.s

,,7,.

mN ff

"'A (.

k', L. : h.

}&eS e

• g s' O

k r-4 J(-

L9D 9

d i

.6 i

s

'ind O.ose can... a c. t pc:.s..cra c>:ccted c) and did reach

..u

6.. - t u d..

9; 9.,. p 5 m, a. _..a.

.. a a s., w n g :,..

u..u.,.,,,

c.,

u. m, a.

v s.1..u..., -

in v'lich thy ce rc u s i.~,ne v, r.a nu f a c turc ', constructcJ cad sold.

n.,..r _, a..,.- a 4.,.

c o. - ~-. " ^ 4..~,

m.. e" t.,.,,

v n...

.a v p m.i.3' a c.--

q 4

I auclear pcuer plant and its componcat parts in cu b a defective concition as to be unreasonably dangerous to consu.2rs, violated b

i the standards of Sectica 402A of the Rest ite -

-t o f T'r s (II).

h 14 As a result of the f o r e g o '.ng, the plaintiffs' I

home and their pr0 party have decreased in '/ clue and de plaintif -

h Mvc 2150 suffared 2c:ncmic har., incluc:in; but n o '- liniited to L,,, s.

o e.

-a

..-m..-

a _.. a-_.,v...,

,..2 1.4

,,) m.,.. a a

..u..;.,

e,.,.._.,.,,.

i.

,5.

-.._u._,

,, l u.,. :a..-

.:o.,

i.~ e.o c.

u 1

e. --,,... _.,

c_ o

..m c

- u s

b,. :.'..h-a ee:--.,

u..,

__.s.wh

,A b.6.:,

..4

.,,k,.. A %A. h N,.c _. ; -. h.i 4..

We.-%.h tw

. & %. L&

)

w -

mi=e 6

.'w

?CUCr p'Ont ha d Suf fdrOd physical and CCO Ciona'. inj CriOS Ond 3

.i n t i r.M to CJ 60 100 C n inCC 1.:ll. t3 per 0w.

e e.

e y

1 c>.

7.. I t.,.,

.r....,

u.,. n_

p m :.,...4 a

.. ~.,i---

' 1 w

.,.2 i

._ 9-

.,.)

.e uical e:.....in2 ttan s e n a pericjic basis ta determina t r.c fuil n.m., l., -..u. m...

...s.4_.

a o s.1 - oc - m.., - - AL

- i

,...iJ--.-J us u-

.a 6

+

n,,

m.p w e.

L.

. a

.,..%E,i

.I I

aa.

ea s.6.e.

._4 I

-'-a.

s-bw.=.

w-b,.

A

.. p, r'I,w e

,w..m. "a.

w'*',

O,.

(=e

. V a.

6.,4L^.J,.'n.

b.

..-:...,.., -., s.. C.. : ~~. C.-

....,s....-n G.s~ -., -,

( * 'J ')

.,~ a. a.

C :..-....

t,.v,+a

~

u u.~.;

1. ~

r._._

J.

p..... *,

t :.<-.-

...,.t.

.,-.3-.-a J.e

-. - e) s,.

~.

v

__.s g

-n..df,t 4wQ m.6 d', -

,i..

,J'A s.',a=

..,/3.,-'b^

.-=d

br3,

.w..,-

u.a, -

4 Ab..

4 --.

c.

{

2 44*

,.*i=

,ss, 1s.., -

C'"'

-I.^**=I=. '

r.. o.. J,

=-Le d,

A

.'d," A"'

'L-b u'"6

'.'-'**"='A

L-J s 6 t.6 J p g

s J

%v- ^

,% 4...

-)

w -

3-y e 3

g*.v L

m p

m e - 's a.

a 1

g L.,,

~ -.. -,.

s--..a..

.L.

3

.. -,J

+

s

- m.,

a.

J

./

r og

'"*n 8 I' f I

{

4

,d

, d a, ' ': r s {

,g,a, nr h * > i '.t.. s ' -

1 8

s.

NO 6

h 485 2n

,J&

g s

v

i 7--..- - - - -

, L;n:nt ;s cc: _1_a d j oin-ly g, 2 r; ; ;.,.

c;;ainst tL2 d 2.

.- a.t s bf :ne plaintiffs fx cccacri: losses dCd '.siCal and CIOtionl11 inju;-iOS in an C.~.Junt in eh; css, p ;

of Ten Thcusand ($10,00].00) Collars as. ell as punitive damages ia an arount n e:: cess of Tan Thouscad ($10,000.0J) Dalicr3

}

,/,!

M, 4

v t ;- A.

.v....,

,,,c_

',/ J.:n a s,0' B r ie n, J;.

v Richard r Rasan w C 13 J.

dee n ;~ I. C 3,

i i

-+,

u 14; i.

S O C O LT.0 f S L C r ;'13 inti f "3 1:

t-i;

+

0 h 8bN3 I~' ) '

485 297 IUU!I [7,-I#;CidkddML g

3

F" 41,,P S. "57 *** S gL2 pp t i e.

y '

r._e, r.,' $ '

k 't., p s

s, t >g jq NI b 's. 4 * $pbJ h

,~

'. I ti O

H s

L.

r-e

,~s e

J',

f; o

-ra s

e4

(*

e W.

()

ED

'J D

\\ 's'(

s

.n r,

e ca r.

n O

• j

,4

- -. -Ol

, e

• u r*

- ' ~ - -

's

• - L *

. -- -J{ N

c. s t;

N r

w' L*.

e o.

'3 0

N.'*

u e

,-4 e

s K

f' L,

4e

r.,

t-

,4 ti 5.

.r p

s -

+

u 7 Ie '

fl "J

l b.

I L,

b L

lt y a r:

,3 e

r*

=<*e h

4.

q,

. 3,_'.

=

0

- L' d

1;..)

L 6-I j

'l 7c.'

sa. A L,

-3 n

h "c

' f *8

. 5 s

e-I

.4 (i 6e 7.

..'-l<

5 f.

!. ". ). '

l

.t ', :J O 4

'\\,-

i J

T

1

.4 h ;

.t.

D'.'.-d '0 U

.".1

• -4 I#

sa

.c.

O

(.l...

a at v

s s

. -e u

%g i

a

- C 7

o,.u o

4...m t

a _-

• " CO 9 7-3

c. :

il.*

~

-;.o.s

~-, 7 t..I L' ;.'1 O

a H, k, g.

r c :

's, ti

-J w

7 Ee GC C

<e,' U T ^ ' 3 *, H 0

^

's J

j -.

o O 61 t4 g

(; -

p; }I;,.n.

t e-el "a

s - *.

,; L-s.'. :l, ; l-s 7

'2 r:

M aH g'

"?

...T.,

O

=

-o

. ea s

t.

s !)

u,a % v,o u u..a,'f.;a u.

H e

=

p,.i...'.',q u

1

, c; t-

.O. ' j-. ;;

c3 J-i u

-4

.4 r

p s

x,

.f c4.,s.!l-r3 de s

,2

- < F.

i s

v.

4 f

,), '. Hj d c

,d ', %N -]

u ;, *. l. q U. 2

(, l~.. -; - - - * -

i c

c e ',!

c ";

H -s u

g*

_e u.-

a;:.

C

- a r-r:..;

t.

v.

...<1*l'._

5 r.,

-a r;

(.

o >-

.ja.,

r, L.4 w u %) es

^.

-g

.e - ;

r,

~4 o

..1 u s

. t

• - n l

i 4 Fe

. ;.. -U,% ;# O O !?

r,. ' - )

O tJ - J j. !; > + 0 (-4,

',,)

l i

~

'2 l

F.L W

". (n U. l, s

^'

,8 e

C

• i) **

p-e H c O

] [ *. J' f*

u" l O Uo c -. 3' 0. :p n. j r e l > ;.) /.1

. 1t L do e

1. a " ".-

2: n 1 ;!

,'7: e 'n 8

4 n-a

.., e e

..i uw<c

. o -. u

,1 q.n i n7t:,

c. v '. -*

• 7, + Jr.'

.Oa f

b 1*

s 6

i f

l

.aj p-i u

IN THE U:!ITED STATES DIST2ICT CCL'3T yy_ a nie l

FOR THE MIDOLE DISTRICT OF PE:;SYL'/ANIA i

W. C. CARRIER

. FFX"4 ALLEN PARK

!109 Scuth York Street I

iGoldsboro, PA

.I I

VS.

i v

'T l

Tr o... m,_

I F

f (/

l e

' METROPCLITAN EDISON CO.

b' ifs Y J.

I 6 '

2SCO Pottsville Pike l

lMuhlenberg, PA 19605 i

an; I'

I

CIVIL ACTION

BABCCCK

'2 UILCOX CC:fPANY t161 E. 42nd Street

] Neu '.'ork, New York 10017 l

..l and J. RAY McDERMOTT & CCMPA ;Y, I::C.

',1010 Cor2.cn Street New Orleans, Louisiana 70112 J} GENERAL FUELIC UTILITIES and

}

'260 Cherry Hill Road

. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED l

i

,lParsippany, ::ew Jersey 07054

[y > -l,-l y,

and lla da iji.jd-l

.2

' JERSEY CE::TFAL PC'!ER A:.'D LIGHT CO.

j i

a Madison and Punchbcul I.

UMNM. t Pt t'

l

,Marristo n, Neu Jersey l

Aq g g,j j

and

.'OQyaw g gg;'r.

CATALYTIC, INC.

';!1500 Marhet gm

' 7 '* O,q p '3 - -,.

Street

-a1

" Centre Square West

"'W DL -

.;Phila., PA 19102 l

No.

l.

I' I

CO'i?L' IT I'! TRESFASS I

i l

i 1.

The plaintiff, Fra u Allen Park, is a citizen of the

,Cctmon.ealth of Pennsyl'ania and resides at 109 South York Street, I

t poldsboro, PA.

i t

i 2

(a) The defendant, Metropolitan Edisen Co.,

is a

, Pennsylvania corporation doing businas s within the Cer.cm.ealth i

t 1

i f

i 485 299 D F u i m--Mdh u uu'a t

- + w y ;.4 I

4r 3 i +

[j {g C t. d e r *

• as " * *.< '.'. ^ { 1 * 's a 4 8 A4L (2.. u p r a s 3 gra, M *,,i r

-/

s f. 54&I

'a w W.

~8 Ia.**4

'F d s't $

• j f f; F ? ( 5 4 4,e., f 3 mi.** #, A ~ * ]1 y

c..,

c., [ c > - :. r.

4 4 ~. s

..,e-

< v_..

.r

~.s.

.. ~ ~

. 2

,,,a..,-,-up-'M

"^

i.

i 1

{

I 1

i'

. of Pennsylvania with ef fices located at 2300 Pottsville Pike, Muhlenberg, PA 19605.

l

('v)

The defendant, Babcock and L'ilcox Co. is a ::ew 16l[.42ndStreet,

! Jersey corporation with offices located at

ew York, ::ew York, 10017.

(c) The defendant, J. Ray McDermott & Company, Inc.,

is a Delaware corporatien with offices located at 1010 Common t

, Street, I;ew Orleans, Louisiana 70112.

-l j

(d) The defendant, General Public Utilities is a l

I a

260 Cherr,

Pennsylvania corporation with offices located at

[HillRoad,Parsippany,I!ewJersey07054.

I I

(e) The defendant, Jersey Central Pcwer an? Light Co.,-

i i

has offices located at Madison and Punchbewi., Morristcun,I;ew

!j Jersey.

i I

j<

(f) The defendant, Catalytic, Inc. is a Pennsylvania l

'carperatica with offices located at 1500 Market Street, Centre i

i Square 'Jes t, Phila., PA 19102.

j 3.

Jurisdiction is based up n 42 U.S.C. A. 2210 et seq.

I 1

I I

' nnd the a= cent in controversy exceeds Ten Thousand ($10,C00.00) j t

{ Dollars.

l 4

.\\

Service of process upon the defendants herein has l!been made pursuant to F.R.C.P. 4(e) and Title 42 of the d

1 P2nnsylvania Censolidated Statutes Annotated, Sections 5322 cnd I

i 1

sl 5323.

J l

t i

,I I

1

.i DDDPa [m uu. M l!

lEll nUJ

l 48S--

300 i

t l

..,. ' '/

~~'g.

! C 3,

.32-

%c.

r5 ' s w a 2 u 1

• s w 9 e n e O - a m'e2s s u f

,.3i

,---y f

[;

j f

i

j. 1 A *A F. e 5 'a4( 78PA** O1 *tQem % (", ta 7 0. ' q{$am.

• 2 4.% $ & - ' :'t w t m.a cc,

,.,~.e.m...

m.,c.

o.

..r.

-...:~...-

.r e m e

. ~.

}

5.

On or about :brch 23, 19 79, t..e de fe nda n t 3, th: ou:;h 1

their agents, servants and empi es caused ra '.oactive sub-stances to be emitted into the environ:'ent, a fact hich spokepersons for the defendants acknowledged had occurred,

at the Three Mile Island ::uclear Pouer Plant..

i a

i 6.

The emissions of radiation into the envircrr.ent i

'l i

I neared such dangerous levels that Governor Thornburgh for the i

I Commcavealth of Pennsylvania.on March 30, 1979 ordered that all l

I ire-school children and pregnant uomen evacuate frca uithin i

five (S) miles of the Three Mile Island J' uclear Plant.

Houever, {

j due to the unce-tainty created by the conflicting statements of

]

i c the defendants ' spokepersons end state, local and naticnal

.I I

government spokeperscas regardin3 the dangers of the radiation i

I f

exposure, the plaintiff felt ccepelled to evacuate the area i

i I

. for his own safety.

l t

i i

7 The de fendants all contributed to the cons truc ticn, I

l ruintenance and operation of the Three Mile Island ::uclear I

1 i

Pouer Plant and its component paro.

I g.

The daages sustained by the plaint iff are caused by the negligence, carelessnecs, recklessness, villfuln233 rnd l

wantonness of the da fendants :

{

l (a) in failin", to preparly design the said eclear j

i parar plant (Three Mile Islard) and its corponent parts; (b) in failing to properly construct the said nuclear l

po"cr plant and its component parts; f

1 (c) in failiny, to properly ingect at test th2 cald i

i nuclear pct or &nt cnd its cc menent par t ;;

i I

I 13 i'

a psupw}, epm a

zJ

.l h

t FJ A r

f

~

'!N

/

[*

]1 l 2 e.

,e 4

r

,L'.'i

)sieaeeaas. a Pi s 'w a *. s. '; r *?-%=. %)$Ar 1

/,

w,

,<s-4

. w c r :a

~

.-~sm

-w t? ' ~

C.

9~,

~

' * ~'- ' ' < ~ " " ' - *

"~r

,ga(

08 4

7 4

]

f r

-- - - - - ~.. _ _ -. - - -

e

.-w l.

y (d) in using faulty and defective component ma terials.

I I

in the ccnstruction of the said nuclear power plant; e

(e) in e:< posing the public to such a d2fective power l

'l

.l plant; I

l (f) in failing to carn the plaintiffs of the defects in l

l

,said c.uclear power plant;

[

fg) in failing r o e:<ercise due care in the engineering, 4

I composition, design, construction and operation of said nuclear q

-i i pwer plant; l

(h) in failing to exercise the high standard of care I

'jrequired in the operation of a ultrahazardous activity (i.e.

i 1

1 i

, a nuclear power plant).

)

9.

Defendants knew or in the c::erc*

if ordinary care m

I had reason to kncu of the dangerous effect, of its nuclear pcuer i

I f

,1 t

plant.

I 10.

The said nuclear pcwer plant and its ccaponent

'ccmpesitional parts were under tha soTe and e::clusive possession l

s i

and control of the defendants, whila it was being engineered, 1

ccmposed, designed, ccastructed and operated.

g 11.

Dafendants operated said nuclear power plant and its

{

i Iccmponent parts in a defective canditica unreasenably dangercus a

i lto the plaintiff and his property, and harm was thereby I

'l

- caused to the plaintiff.

12.

The des.:danta are engaged in the business of 1

i

cesigrina, rancfacturing, cc~;tructing and selling of the cc=-

l: n m nt parts cf th2 said Three ':lle Island suclear Po~er Plant i

-l i

l

\\

P(

)].j d,,,....

n g c.

'l 4

.i.

t J cuthiW wa

=

j 485 302 i

4.-.

- n;y " '/

C C3 I C 4.

• u-<,.. : n i 4

t 2.u c.= % u.<., a 3 n.n t r t

2-y 3 :. s~ r sa :n. u :.a c., m c, r a n

-s s a-. r n:.s a -.

i c/,

, m. ;,a c.., 1:, m

.........c...m._<...~m.,_-.,,

l f

l '

^~~ ~.- -.. _ _ _,,,...

- - - = - -

• 1 d-n sf fandthosecomponent parts were expected to and did reach the

.l

.a jnuclearpowurplantwithout substaatial change, in the condition Ih in which they were designed, manufactured, coastructed and sold.

~

)

13.

The defendants in constructing and operating a

l l.( nuclear power plant and its ccmponent parts in such a defective

}

iditica as to be unreascnably dangerous to consumers, violated c

tce standards of Sectica 402A of the IMstatement of Torts (II).

14.

As a result of the foregoing, the plaintiff's

{,,homa and his property have decreased in value and the plaintiff l

4j has also suffered economic harn including but not limited to

] loss of inccme and travel and living expenses while an evacuee.

i 3

l.

j I

j 15.

Further, the plaintiff, due to cae exposure to

!}

l

' radioactive caterial emitted frca the defendants' nuclear i

I i

power plant has suffered physical and emotional injuries and l

! uill continue to do so for an indefinite period.

l i

16.

In the future the plaintiff vill need to endargo l

medical ex2minaticas on a periodic basis to determine the full of his inj urics as a result of the defendants ' ne;11 gent l

i extent l

l and :rengful ccaduct. The need and expense for these examinaticas vill exist for a minimum of tuenty (20) years.

y 17.

Due to the extraordinary negligence en the part of the i

defendants in view of the potential risk t'at a nuclear pcs:er a

1 plant possesses, plaintiff also demands that punitive damages i

i i

1

he suarded in his faver.

1 13 Further, the pl-inciff demands a trial by jury on I

I i all issues of this actica.

I l

-l m en,r

-r,r n n y

([

>k

\\

t e,'

9 5

4 e

2 f

O k b bO " O*

-S-i j

l 4 B*b 303 v

7 i

i f

r*-*'.-,

r,.-

ny y

f

[; [: (2e na 4 -v.,_, a a 4,..aes,a

,v.

a

, m m

.,_.r

~ '.

4

-s c

n -,_ _-.

/

)

~ - r..

m 3,. 3

, ~. ~

m..,,,.....

s-.

't me

^--.%

. _. - - + - - " " " " ^ " " ' - - " '"

~"

l i

i tiliEREFCRE, judgmant is demanded jointly and severally against the defendants by the plaintiff for economic losses ll and physical and emotional injuries in m amount in excess of Ten Thousand ($10,000.00) Dollars as tiell as punitive damages l

?

! in an amcunt in excess of Ten Thousand ($10,000.00) Dollars i

r is h

Y<...

-e f,

',.c.

/- John J// O' 3rien, Jr.

//

,a Richard F. Rosen

-j Jchn J. O'Brien, III

'j Attorneys for Plaintiff i}

.l J

!l Fl l

c.

l'

,1 i.,

'I i

1 o

N

.i d

l I

I I

i l

'l I

i 1

.i 40 9

t PDs Obkh o w.

l 485 304 1

f

, u.

_2 a

2: C1 l 2 i.

- -l -

..r-

.<so r.2 -

s a c i m3 e ~a

_,r u s.

a,

,,,, s ::,-

a -. -.a t

f]

[., )

]

a -

3

,a w

,.c g

..r s

a e*1

, ( o 4<

Y 9

-=.-

w.-

l !

4, I

i i

l I

j I'; T112 L".IITED STATES DISTRICT CotTRT I

FOR TI!E 21IDDLE DISTRICT OF PE::iSYLVid;Li i

i fi; LO::ALD MARS and

CIVIL ACTIC:I i

! Fiddlers Elbow Road

[T };f

. LEldi ::ARS, Ilusband and Wife 7

}'A' p3, p

p} it,7 k g, Af Q, i

( @

b; IIiddletown, Pennsylvania 17057 i

i V.

i

JURY TRLE DE;'?

;DED j MITRCPOLITICI EDISO:I CO.

. 2300 Pottsville Pike 1

1:uhlenberg, Pa.19605 l

and Eld 1CCCR & UILCOX COMPA:1Y 161 E. 42nd St.

I cu York, I!cu York 10017 and J. RAY McDERMOTT & C07.PA:;7, II C.

I

! 1010 Co =on Street l 1:ew Orleans, Louiciana 70112 El and C"';ERAL PL3LIC UTILITIES fi 260 Cherry Hill Road ig l I

~ <. -

)

{

j

! Parcippany, Lev Jersey 07054 r

j i

and

{

Qqog pg

}

J~~

~ CE';TRI.L PO'.;ER A';D LIGiiT CO.

il I a cnd Funchboul i

M 17 D l

4

" ctm, I;ew Jersey i DCE-) it SZiqY, Ct: M "nd

/ p-r y ga d CATALYTIC, II:C.

c w 6<

!i ;, 15CD Market Street

', Centre Squarc West

Philadelpbin, Pa. 19102

. I:0 i

i l

l j

CC:"' AI::T I:I TESPASS E

o t,

,1 1

1 Tba plaintiffs, Donald ::ars and Leah Mars, are citizens s

i, t

of the Cor.on :ealth of For elvania and resid2 at Fiddlers i

h r

4 Elbow Road, Middletom, Pennsjlvnnia 17057.

l i

l-L

,e i

Y

. c d,E1 t al U M b

. m'- 1

+

I fi.)S t.

i Gik 485 305

i l"

(

i i

I 2.

(a The de fendant, !!2tropolitan Edicon Co., is a 11 Pennsylva".ia corpc.ation doing business withilt the Co:anonuealth l

1; of Pennsylvania uith offices located at 2S00 Pottsville Pihe,

uhlenberg, Pa 19605.

(b) The detendant, Babcock and Nilcox Co.,is a I!eu j

Tercey corporation uith offices locate (. at 161 E. 42nd Street, f

eu York,1:eu York,10017.

I l

(c) The defendant, J. Ray 1:cDermott & Ccepany, Inc.,

i i is a Dela;are corporation uith offices 'oc

e at 1010 Canton d

Street,I!eu Orlea ;, Louisiana 70112.

(d) The defe dant, General Public Utili:ies,ia a t

Pennsyl>cnia cor, ration uith offices located at 260 Cherry i

p 11111 Ro ad, Pct ;ippany, !!eu Jersey 07054 (e) The defendant, Jersey Central Pcwer and Light Ca.,

li

, has of ices located at Ldison and Punchboul,

:arrista:m, neu p

i i

L Je rs n.

I; (f) The defendant, Catalytic, Inc.,is a Pennayh: Inia i

corporation ith offices located at 1500 ':ar;:et Street, Centre j;

i i

l.

l E Square L'e s t, Pailadalphia, Pa. 19102.

j i,

3.

Juri:, diction is based u;;:n 42 U.P.C. A. 2210 et ceq. nnl the a:. count in controveray c::ceeds Ten Thousaad ($10,C00.00) l I

i Dall2ra.

o 1

h 4.

Service of procer c ca the defendants hercia has y

h.

j been made pursuant to F R.C.P. l+(e) an 1 fille 42 of the

! Penacylvania Carroli.dat+1 Et.Lutm Annotated, ations 5322 mu J,s ~.b e c

n, t

l

.2-4~85~

306

4 4

i

.I 5.

On or about March 23, 1979, the defendants, through I

their agents, servants and employees caused radioactive sub-stances to be emitted into the environment, 'a fact which 1

t i

q rpokeperson; "or the defendants acknowledged had occurred, i

j et the Three Mile Island ';uclear Power Plant.

1 I

6.

The emissions of raliation into the environnent i

t

}' neared such dangerous levels that Governor Thornburgh for the i

j Commenwealth of Pennsylvania on March 30, 1979 ordered that all i

pre-school children and pre 3nant women evacuate fron within f

l l

five (5) tiles of the Three Mi'c Island Nuclear P?. ant.

"owever, i I

i

! due to + he uncertainty created by the conflicting statements of !

t l the.efendants' spokepersons and ate, local and national i

I government spokepersons regarding the dangers of the radiatica l

i l

l.

e:cp osure, the plaintiffs felt compelled to evacuate the area for t

! their own safety.

i

.I l

n e

7.

The defendants all contributed to the construction, a

f maintcacnce and operatinn of the Three ':ile r

i Island.2 clear

,'l Pater Plant cnd its component parts.

i t

y 3

Tha damages sustained by the plaintiffs.ere caused

", by the : egligence, carelessness, rechlessness, s111 fulness and i

lI 1

l, unntonness of the defendants:

h (a) in failing to properly design the said nuclear a,.

pcuar plant (Three hile Island) and its component parts; Fj (b) in failing to t roperly construct the said nuclear n

} powar plant and its co-porant pr -ts;

(

(c) in failin:; to proparly inspect and test th? caid a

nicar pou3r plant end its component pares, n

. i 485 307

11 i.

j i

i l

l f

(d) in using faulty and defectiee component materials i

l in the construction of the said nuclaar power' plant -

l (e) in expoaia; the public to such a defectiera pcwe r plant; (f) in fai.iing to uara the plaintiffs of the defects in.

i jl said nuclear p wer plant; i

}

(g) in fAiling ta exercine due ca-e in tha engineer-l I

i in3, composition, design, construction and operation of said i

'l nuclear pouer plant; (5) *n failing to exercise the high standard of care i

I h required in the operation or an ultrahr.zard;us activity (i.e.

b p a nuclear power plant).

+1 f+

9.

Defendants kneu or in the ex2rcise of ordinary care o

,0. had reason to knou of th2 dangerous effects of its nuclear pouer a

t

plant.

c l

i:

10.

The said nt: lear po.:er plant and its ermponent i.

j cc pcaitional parts 'cere unde - the sole and exclusive possessic:,l l

[: and control of the defendants, uhile it was being engineerad,

-[

i eccposed, designed, co- - ~ 'd and oparated, j

I h

11 Defendants ope: rated said nuclear pouer plant and its

,. annat parto in a d2Cectice condition unreascnably dangarcus cc:

I to the plc atif fs end their property, and nar:n vas thereby I

l'

' caused L,

sae plat:itiffs.

{

l

Tm defen.'anta are e:m;ed in the businaas cf i

de a 1:;n in g, manufac uring, c<:,;tr ucting and sellin ; of the con-i m _ ;t parts of tha

--' '~ m ' 112 Iclin1';ucIcar co.sr Plant.

i l, -

I 485 308

f l

hll l

t i

e ll3 and those co:ponent parts vera expected to cad did reach the I nuclear po::er plant ';ithout substantial change in the condition l

e i

1 in chich they uere designed, nanufactured, ccnstructed and sold.

l l

13.

The defendants in constructing and operating a l

I j

nuclear power plant cnd its component parts in such a dafective li condition as to be~ unreasonably dangerous to consumers, violated :

i i

the standards of Section 402A of the Eqstatemar c7 Tart, (II).

14.

As a result of the foregoing, the plaintiffs' I

l! home and their pror.erty have decreased in value and tie plaintiff-i i

i If ha", ' Iso ruffered economi-hara including but not i

limited to 4h3 of income and tre.rel c id itvin3 expenses chile evacuees.

t i

i l

15.

Further, *he plai ntiffs, due to the exposure to h

I if radicactive ra cerials emittad from the defendant '

I nuclear 4

[l poter plant ha ' suffered physical and ecotional in;uries and i

! uill ccatin" do co for an inde finite period.

16.

In the future, the plaintiff 3 will need to undergo tedical e::"Cnsaicas en a periodic basin to da termi..a the full Iil I]t extant of

• heir injuries as a result of the defendcars' l negligent and urongful conduct. The need and c:: pense ror these e exacinations vill enict for a cinimum of twenty (20) years.

Fa n

17.

Due to the extraordinary negligence en the part of the C

tU da fendants in

.-12:,

I of the potential rick that a nuclear po::ar q

i

plant possesses, plaintiffs alca de~utnd tb at puaiti.e d

magas 4

'l be r-mded in their favor.

U ll.

Further, the plaintiffa le and a trial by jury on all icaues of this action.

I',

485 309

j '.

I,j l

lj l

.l t~E22F032, judyene is demanded jointly and severally i

! r3ainst the defendants by the plai.atiffs for' economic losses p! and physical and emotional injuries in an amount in excess a

^

t of. Ten ~osand ($10,000.00) Dollars as uell as punitive damages in an aunt in excesa of Tan Thousand ($10,000.00) Dollars.

li I

h ll (v:l-7fiv -

/V.

l

./$$$ as,,

1

{;l

/ Jaa' n J/ U' 3rten, Jr. "

/ Richard F. Rosen h

ji John J. O'Brien, III Attornays for Plaintiffs t

L e

h

)

i l

f A

is l,

Y!!

if il r

i o

e i

l l

i I

l i

e I

c._

i f

I I

i.

i I

485 310

e I

3

_. j.

e(' mW 7 7 +p.1 J d,g l I

h f g

1 I:T TPE l'"ITED STATES DIST'lICT.'CdUhT 1

'r.'....'s".' 'u",.'w" 'a\\ ~

"C7

'"u. :-

i. ~

.o..r D P I. ".

') I ".,"i.'. T.C'" N.

3 t.

v u

w.

L,,.,a. C. um. C A. RRIER s

. >. e 0.,,,a

.a m

c.

1 451 eadeu Drive i

Ca mp 11i11, Pa. 17011 i

3 V.

f^, - -)- - /

E.,,,

.i2,.,-

I

/

./.)

, r.

,. :(

.s v-O -lO r

h.

'h

'/

V c

.* 4, l' ZOO 20LITAN ZDISC'l CO.

2000 Pottsvillu Pike bhlenberg, Pa. 19605 and

. JU.Tl TRLU 'PdETED P

I3ABCCCK & UILCOX CCMPAT(

161 E. 42nd St.

I

':cu York, "eu York 10017 and J. PAT McDE?F.CTI & CC: IPA::Y, I!!C.

l 1010 Co=on Street

zw Orleans, Louisiana 70112 and r~"'7L PU LIC UTILITIES il

-h e rr'/ Hill Road n.i 3

L..c.ppany,

2u Jarcey 07054 y-' )p J

and b.

J222Y C";T"M PC'.F.2 A';D LICiiT CO.

7 c e r,.1T o,,.

P, Madicon and Funchbowl

'\\

i u "' f 1 '" ' 3 te Morristown, ;!cu Jerse;r pl nnd ggy,q,,r) g,SE yiv,O Y.

.i s

..x.L iIu, I..C.

ny4 p

l$00 'ar'.at Street t,duWC M

.i C2ntra Square Uast 4

Philadelphia, Pa. 19102

::0

e. ~. '-' L' T * ' *"

T. '.. c. n..c.a^

m s

1 Tha plaintiff, Ja 'Tard, J s a citican of the Comen-3 9

,j aalth of 2annsylvania and reside; at 451 'andou Dri.m, a

Cup "!.11, Pa. 17011.

i l

I i

i i

4 i

l 5

L jf, Q t)-

T a o.,e w.

I

_.l U,

,i !

J I

' l.

.s_

.g j

]=

}.

1. 4

=.VC.

. )41 4 e#4-6E%*

'W'#

1 ?.

E'O*.-

I

], s. w s, ss e.* 49 -

r.)

e.'-

i 3

~

e w

a

_... _ =., - - - -

ff i

2.

(a) The de femit nt, "etropolitan Edison Co.,

is a I

8 Pennsylvania corporation doing business ;ithin the Co munwealth s

r t

of Pennsylvania uith officas located at 23G0 Pottsville P!ke, l

t i

l'uh le nb e rg, Pa. 19605.

I i

l

[

(b) The defendant, Sabcock and '.Hlcox Co. is a Neu I

Jersey corporation with offices located at 161 E. 42nd Street, f I

New York, I:ew York, 10017.

l

I 1

(c)

Th.s de fendant, J. Ray :!cDerrctt & Carpany, Inc.,

is a Delauare corporation uith offices located at 1010 C mon

Straet,

'ew Orleans, Louisiana 70112.

(d) The defendant, Gener21 Public Utilities is a Pennsylvania corporation with offices located at 260 C: terry 11111 Ro a d, Parsippany, Neu Jersey 07054.

]

(e) The defendant, Jersey Central Pouer and Light Co.,

l l

l has offices located at th.fison and Punchhoul, :!orristc en, Neu 1

l

Jersey, (f) The defendant, Catilytic, Inc. is a Pennsylvania j

crporation ';ith of fices located 15C0 ihrket Street, centre 1

3l Square 1.'e s t, Philadelphi.1, Ps. 19102 3.

Jurisdiction is based upon 42 U.S.C. A. 2210 et an.

the a cunt in controvarcy e: ends Ten Thousand ($10,000.00) anu l

Dollars.

1 t]

4.

Sur/ ice of prccess upon the q

darendants harein ha.;i

'ce a < uda pura rint to F.R.C.P. ((2) and Title 42 o f the I

j Pennsylv:nia consoliated Ctatutes Annotatad, Sectian:, 5322 rd d

JJ.J.

l,

l 489 7s.1 7 o' n c

U f

h..!. ~.

.f

'..'. l ;

i I

Y e' e.9'. %'h&

b, f

)

'h r

8$6 I

g e

• 4 4

e

,C,,p.,

n

(

ae ;:.;cJast u<'A.-

a

\\

J

,g 5.

t or abcut.hrch 23,19 79, the de fendants, throughl i

il their agents, servants and c. playe.n caused radioactive sub-l stances to be enitted into the environment, i

fact which i

a spokepersons for tha defendants achnouledged had occur 1

red, i

the Three file Island Suclear Pome Plant' at i

6.

The emissions of radiation into the environnent d

neared cuch dan ;ercus levels that Covernor Thornburgh for th e

q Corron cealth of Pennsylvania on March 30, 1979 ordered that all pre-school children and pregnant women evacut.te frcn uithin a

]

five (5) niles of the Three Nile Island Nucicar Plant Hottever due to the uncertainty created by the conflicting stat e

e. ents of tha defendants' spokepersons and state local and national Covern ent spokepersens regarding the dangers of the radiation i

c: posure, the plaintiff felt cogelled to evacuate the area l

for har a:.Tt s a fe t f.

Ij 7

d The defendants all contributed to the const:uction y

caintenance and cperation of the Three Mile Island Nu l s

1 c ear Pe m r Plant and its cog onant parts.

i l

1 8

Ths dana;,es custained by the plaintiff were caused

,

d

,s,

-

• Y k

} ) >9 't y ~l y#, 12' e..

'*gg, 3

~a.9f q 485 Jg l

I O)

s. t \\

y

,s).

e

., -. ; r; v3 u....---~-------

w 4

=

h= g

'4 g-p

$84D N -$

7

,a JJM O I l

kN' 4

g

,l

,b5 4M Ydm4$*

N

< !, y g

,c4

..v.,.,

.. < u

-. c -

x.

3.-

m.-.

44 I

l

s

.i

~

.i l

i (d) in using faulty and defective corponent naterials; q!

in the construction of the said nuclear power plant;

'i

','e) in exposing the public to such a defective power plant; (C) in failing to earn the plaintiff of the defects

'l in said nuclear pcrer plant; (g) in failing to exercice due care in the engf.neer-y d

1 in;;, co gosi. tion, design, construction and operation of said il i'

nuclear power plant;

]

(h) in failing to exercise the high standard of care required in the operation of an ultrahacardous activity (i.e.

t a nuclear power plant),

t t

O 9

Defencants knew orin the exercise of ordina.y care i

L l

had reason to kncu of the dangerous effects of its nuclear pot.er plant.

't

10. The said nuclear powar plant and its corponent 1

congositional parts w2re under the sole and exclusize possession-1 I

l and control of the dafendants, uhile it was bein;; engineered, F

\\

cc.g esed, designad, ccastructed and operatad.

a

'}

11.

Defandcnts cperated said nuclear power plant and its

,1 i

n cennenant parts in a defective condi' don unreaz onabl,- dcngerous 1

9 s

1 to t.'n plainti f f and har propert.7, and h1rn was ther2by d

A caused to the plaintiff.

13.

The dafandants are engaged in the businass of 1

denigning, nan :facturing, constr:cting and selling of the 1

con-ponent parts of tha said Three Mile Island ::uclear Fewer Pla n, a

l l

1 485 314 n;y,,yi.

..e _< p._..a em g,

t. ~

s t.

A dy i10Glifj&

,, e g v i y

\\

i

..... -:...w m..

s..... w

~

'"/

,,...~,.-..........

g e..

i.,. x

.. c_ m,, m.. :..... -m-r

_,m.c.. _.;

_m.-m...

,2;

~,

s.n

.a

,e a

,,.s,..

• ~ ' - -

_m._

. ~ _ _..

l

Y il Y

and those component parta teere c:gected to and did reach the l

nucle:ir pat er plant without su:au tantial chan",e in the co n di. t i.o n il in

Ich they teere designed, ranufactured, constructed and sold.

1 13.

The dafendants in constructing and operating a

]

nuclear pos,er plant ard its component parts in such a defective il condition as to unreasonably dangerous to consumers, violated the standards of Section 402A of the Restate. ent of Tort a (7I).

i I

14. As a reault of the foregoing, the plaintiff's propert" has decreased in value and the plaintiff has also cuffered economic hara including but not liraited to loss

{

of incora continuing to the present and vill continue to do co in the future as teell as travel and living c: penses

.: nile t

1n CVACuea.

1 15.

Further, the plaintiff, due to the c:posure to i

radicactize caterials emitted from the de fendants '

a nuclear a

\\

l poter plant had suffered emotional injuri2a and vill continue to C0 co for un 1:dafinite period, i

Ir.

1.. the J,

fatura the plaintiff vill need te a

un de rgo 1

radical c::aainations oa a periodic basin to datara!ne the full l

a e.ct e a t of her injuriac as a result of th2 de fec da n ts '

tl 1

5 nagliant and wrongful concuct.

The need and erpansa f.or th o

m d mticna vill c:cist for a mini:.rra o f twenty (20) yea rr.

4

}

17.

Dua to the e:ctr:ordin,ry nec14: 2nce on the part af 1

tha deO'ndanca in vi;w of the potential ri A th 1

at a nuclear l

r punt pmma, d

ta, plaintiff a,;o d u nd; eat pun;te..e d.,

o w>

ma m: s r (n.c,.

I 35 Nc:Ler, ' ' p l a i r. t i.?f d:: -

<;a crial '

j,:ry m

l in m m

Z thi, action, c

i i

l JO

u, a y?)

i 1

{D m m q 4

~J~

' b :-

l r

., p in',

7",;-

a,

,,g mm

- u d 44 1

.. * !. L h s.+ r+ r

• c.

ow...-.

.. -~

,y

]

1

e ~

_ ;.s l

r.g C,

..am cL,

..nv.n

. g.n,

., 3 ; e,;x,

,.e

/

.. _....~.-

. ~..

i,,

s

.o m,,.

w 435 315

I r

'[.

I'

,' l tiiCEFCRZ, judgment la demanded jointly and severally I

a"ain:.t the de:nndants by the plaintiff for economic losces a

j and c: notional injuries in an amount in e:< cess of Ten Thousand

.I

($10,C00.00) Collars as ; sell as punitive da maes in an ar ount l'

.I l

in c:: cess of Ten Thousand ($10,000.00) Dollars.

}

j l

i 3

1 o

,O

'* 0,..

%'A,

r, I

f/ John J.' O' Brien, Jr.

./

Richard F. Rosen i

John J. O'Drien, III A ttorneys for Plaintiffs o

IlI ll o

st lI I

l

'l II I

r!

n n

.t f

'l,i J,

.l

.I

!)

a

~

l i

Ir

'k

{l

,l t,

i s e q2/a 5 p' i s 'a t a.-a

.a.

j s w 1

}

~

T l

-.-. o s s.

s. j v

_ _ ;;_g 7 :

,.-.;t.~u~~.---

."t..

/

9 9

p g

• e.e*,

j, & e4

• PI

..,s.,

q e-pe If

)l

7=w

$">f W.m,,v.

.! J. f ( '

t/

o wi'

. le.

-a W. C. CARRIER I,..

S, A.---.a

n,

.- u..

D.

D.r -.,s _r C, c~m..3. -

s.

-sa

.u.1 D, Le

-. v O.- R.r. 0-a-m-..s.*us ta.

1 i..

.a 7.,w..,--,,,,,

L.,. :. F T. C,m.

Cv.r..

G.i a

A,- t igu.

u -

A.

r

.),G.R,L

m. 7 *. s.e n...

.,o.e.-J J

a*..s V.

,,,-n

-. e n,2e... C O.

., 0. 79,g29

. -i.~.v s2 I

,,0

. C C.. ; - r_-,,G C

.3 e.... 3 C C. o r r.-

t

....x.

Please taka notice that purstar.: to Rule 1 -~ ( 2) 7. R. C. P.

'.#c amend their Cc= plaint in the abote captioned case 2s a matter of ccurce.

.?-

i

- ~..

/

' JC' Ci J. O ' 3 RIF.'i, JR.

,, L~.: :,.-)

=

.s 0.=..r n.

y

,..'.J'e 0 ' )" s b'. %'

' 'e 'e e

g

.J f.

hd O Q.I t) [1 i' b i h b f' U t o%. \\\\1 t

.- D.a,... - 1. nr

c. u s a..u a

.o

t. <. c.

rCA 2. ,,,, _ L. s., ., y.. C .c....,.,A.,s.., io, - .3.... rs..odi w u

c..L... s,.. p - anw A. :.. '..sa a

C.7..... u. m,,. t v.<

1..,. -.. C R

.w.. t / a..:.= C.Lp o_.4a S C.. I-.,.,0s= = a. 390a Old Gettysburg Road C u'.- p

u..i ' '.,

"_=..n 1.'.'.. l', m".' o/ ,, - n, c....,u,, .31 v.,. C O. ..:..w :. e u.

--~

n en, ,O..4,,, , c. .wvv w.a ...c ..c.. '.ahlenberg, Pa. 19605 ':0. 73-769 and , n c,, -. a.... %.. s n.,., t. v,.,.,. C c.,.3 it

i. v' 1

?. ./.1. A S. GG*. Ca'.J *[O6., l:e*/ 'iO rk 10017 .3.J s e, p r s eem.. .w.s-.w.s

• p err.

s<=. ~.v-U L v s.,.% t.y 1.s v. 11 ...a.....= .C *. *. n r3 = se .6 -ww a a. 9 .e. .... a g a i.. ...sqqe, 8,.y g -e. d an c e,-, v - o. 3. .o. - r L. c .A.ra: .J wi. a' ' 0 C%.. ~. -, '. '.. ' 7 a c. n i ~ "ar3ippany, iet, Jersey 0 7050 and d.',, hu L,'. Cie.e,. L'c..~.,> .% e,s v %d, c,s un 6. a.". .S. t.,.a.,_.a w, '1 w..4 . ;., br.w.. a C.J. S, . l 2 5.' rr i 3 C C '.."*.,. k '.1 Jar 30y and ,,.....W, v.,. C.

b....M i

• 1*?? 5.8,'4 e
• ..,a.Dg

.#v >.f._

h. e e4

( 4.* * " '3 ,g'.% g *. A****^J y.- O L.. i 1.,. A.a 1 7.. 4 W ,.U.m.. .i F

• n. .

u m"".J '.r

• 's, *o.7

's-1..* +w '* 3 1 Ju Tf s 1 T* 7-e.: m <~. o~, ro_,,* r.. - t. u ,.v.. ..k. 3-pg 1.1..*., e. 4..[ U,a ". T I o, -2..,, >m.a,. m.*M 't. u.m. y .iu 9 3g ..w .m.4.,m.,., -.e-w u..w Sm m.- a

• ...s wa

.a. ~ -..A. + 9 ._a g*

• 4..,s

('. 'd 1

. p,. 3 q

4 --q.' * { 'A & J.Jg v. a. b., d ,.3'.J~.- I c_ a .= 4-a a <. b 7. c .a a', ,3. ..i, .b.., t.. e s. -J...p-Q a.- J uL. ,4.- a 1 7. i ~y +. w..

7..m.,.. '

,3 1 ..,4, . a. < -. g '. ca,...-._, 7 ..-a 7 u. s....., s3,- a, r,,.,..i.., p.,.. 7., n,, J... c: m,,; mw., m -

• s 485 stb 1 $

4 I t s -c-r.2 e na..m a c m.. s_m ut. .u=

w.. _ a c c.

u.a z..m :n o.:. a..,~.,.,,,_.,.:,. ;., e.e.c.e.-, - .a a ,. g.a. _2 : e o p., e..,,, -~ me ,.u.,..-.._,n.,,

2. m.,.

1c. o. 5. 2 1 (b) The defendant, Sabcock and Wil c:c Co. is a.!ei t j va s, - ~- j. a,.,. a - > c a ~.z. q.a.:.:.:, s .a .c u oc-~<.^. '. 1 n. '.. -.n' .3 '. n ~., s

'e.i Yo:-k '.. e i To --k, 10017 (c) te de ~cahnt, J.

-~ Ray McCanot-L Ccepany, Inc., l a c c -.,,,, Ca e, ,.:cn.p.uh a==.<Cn.g .a sa..-.. v.- .w u , o s- ..s -.. ~ A 9, 0 c.. .e.,.,., .". e, .%.1 cc,S, p-L, 4 .4 -..g 'e Q 1 1. 9 a - t (d) '. ~.. ' d e. a. d,.., G =. a.. ' ' .".b '.4c P -#. '.4..# a_ a, ' s a I e

3. -. -.. '

.,4.,. 2 ,.,, 0,

4. 3.

s..

-~.. .. h O.:. 34C a. a- , ~.,. o 4 i n... e a ' 3 r', n. _ ;. a. .+ -. y. 2, a.4 ,., j..,..., J.,,. a,., 0 70 ) c. ,f s... l {2) "A'.b. e d a.r,. > -. .Td '. " ^ j'

• Ca *.. ' ' '.

I ..3 3...*".'..d .T. 4

• b. ". I,,0.,.

v g. .h..- p 3 3 4. e n - 1w,w .gA-3.-- .aw-, _,,4 a su --a v., 2 :, ..u..- p..., L.i.,c,..,1, .s e.,.,.,.. I c.,,, l ...n., . v_ / .p-c=*. -.a j (.f. ~.%..,.. d.,.3 3.. J -.., C,., '.. :,, T...,,. i.a i u. .u. j -_ 3 'J.,..1......f., 3.... a j _ u i c.- g a, r...- -,. .71..'. O.#.#.4.' e c' 7..*.s*.',A - '. 1..' t .C"^.*u, C'.'.*.'. s' s' c. w.p.,-..'

• aw,

.c.h.i '., d a ' g...' ', .D

1. 0 ' 0 '.

l a u s. g' 6 8 3. J L. .. a s.4 . e n *< w- -O.,r,; 2 w .a 9 + r.. c..."...e.. i. - d-a A. t, U 1 ...A- . b. --_,._.=yn,.3..._..t, .. _ _.. -.. g.. _ 3.,..J - %__,.......,J M*n .y .a a 4,7 7. .... v.s, a,*_1 g. F A ) ~ f ..a. I 2,.. a_ w, a.: ,-..,..a- ,. -, -. u. o-s +. 2 -. gu c y. a =-

s. m. 4,

u...,.,.;,.

9.. s...a

.,,3. ._,-4, ....,...g.".7.(.*..."). {.} -,.J I g-.4 -. m ._Ts d ') s.. O,-.,.. ('.,.. >..1 4 ?-, .,4.- s...,. ,4, w", .,.s 4.-..a s,1 ^ 'i. -.J. -],9 ./. w. =,%e '- f t r, a.' -g g g3af /A 1 O 47: ..t d. h 4 s4g - 1,10, v

. m. _2_,. . a.

n..,.. o

.u.. _. 6. . u. s....,.,,,

c..,..

..,,.....,. 3. .m . ~..., -.-...a c a.. s., a4,....a 4.- c - c..., -., ua-s.,..--a -aw ..,..,a oe . o,, e,. 4... e 4,. 3...o n -w s .,,. a.< - i,. - r,.,.c,y, ra m. - e_....._......, 3 .3 a v a .c,, u e r,.,3, c. w a - o.s.. s-,.., a,, d ".a 4 c - ~.ed. i -.. - - u.m 0 t. ~,,, e....t t.o ~.a a.:, a s - ~ ' c. '... o -.".. ' e...'. ' _ m..-.. ~ a u-a - m. w t i .,, r,. a,., t., i, d... ~~ a-l '.. ". a. '. - -.. ' - r " e... c t".. o.- ".'. '.,- fo. t'e o. w.. . u C.-._ -.. ". a.i. 5 o.3 3. e..ns j"1", -. ' a m. da d m. ".a - a' ', O, i c> 7 9 w.". - - u,, -. C C u..,s,.,, u q.t g,

c... A-

,a 0~2..-...- c- . p. 1, z -. g a w. .~.-..n., e./, C. 2.,w. . - ~ -,. .4 f.:..o .;. 4 7 nS O. . b.n ....a',,..,o- '. f.4 7... 1 S.,.3.d.'* o '. e.. p Gm. ~, 01, e.... 1. w. -.M..,..,..9-N.,6-, $= h..g g e... .w r C. F 9.O ..9.O. %.T.4.#.4g, j

• I.

wy 6 4 ...d a w E.4 7 1** fI .g,.. - w. /S

• M '1.,. -

a ] -,..'4 'y. r3 9.'.8 (".w'4.9. a <e... a w" 9

• Q hw w

9. m.,, 8.* a**

u . w-.. a a -. a

• 4

.3 k

c. n.. A

7. g e.

I y...J.

• !.,, q l.

a m,. g - _._ 3. y m m.a e g g. e g e. c.

== n m 9 = M.I,=.., a. e [. g m., .a- -., ----8* '. O ..a..... y i dE,.I .M .'p....% a E. u l. .m= 9.%..*.,-,.s a ..u.---.9 a,m .*.34 >.3 -..y a.- y L4 g )ar -.- %.n J c.m...n, 1.., -,,k.3,. O.f .J. , J..J s J ). 91. a,. g =. 3..e g,s. s -. ,.g .,.a2 -. a w. .+.-A.

• L. o

-n, ...1...;..,, 'M, 'a., T..,1... 6A '...7n.. 3.-.2,. 3, S.-- A .ww- .21 -. .w.... I [. ""%.. o d a s y,.=. 0. ,1 -.1 cm.... J u... a_. n_ ).o L.3-c n c. .J.9. me v. ..a. -,. :...,.,a w.4-w - a,., : m

4.,-. u.._. n n--s:' 9. a

~ L....?. ..'-.a,. ....-..w-y-.-w.,,., v- .,w,.,,,,. O'3 ,. g J. 4. a ww...,...,..* y. .a. Q ...r,.

• . J 5 " a- " '. # ~.. ^ d

'D j" * '. '. ^ - -1~#***--o. C.'.'*..~#- -n 3.- w r b.< ..b..) , $3 1 I* j -, a.g,, y, ,. q l a - =.., 3 a 3 ,,,,b..i,.-%...,.e.n .ca. 7 1..:, *.. 2 -- 3J..- 7 aa aa sj -as .w .-aa a y -.,....-.-...,a O.:. k.a. A_.~,.,A,._S.. -2....;.. ( s*.:) Ie .-.l..Ew.,-.

• • 5

>m .-,,w_.3$. 6 :- a A 5. - N4mi m

• .b. s 1

.a,E s a--M .e.-,'n..= L - ,s y Ay -w

m.,,. m.-.,.u...,

.a.. 9 a..; a-a.,_....-.-., n-.. t., '\\ 2., ,:T:. 3 a. T 0,e., a.a.Jum..... .u,, --- 4 Q.o j koe ..=b... y. .-l f. .=,7-.. u..E .I.=.a*

• m y.,. a ay a.,.

w.,..,.. M j d MW I*Mi Ukamf M' ". 485 HG ~

I ,A a.i., .aL, .. ~. c--- c.. ( s.j J,.. d.., _..,a...r. a.3w-aC .,3 ..1... -.,.1 .--a e" (' g ) [.c .,a,. .. ~. ~. c. . a.

n. C..;.,

%...e .....,. ~..--,-.,=. _.3 --.a .... 6...s ,... a-c _ _. 4. m, 3: .6.,. .e.3 4 4 .-1_.,.3.. (..... p 1_,.,.. i COO-(.3) .g u.., o g i..,- ~. '.., (. o. . '. u% 1. 4 C

• 3 a'"'.-'. - ua

^c".#".a- "yC7. e* ; a g

i l.,

1 - -... i p.,...., (.:..) .n. ;3..t.:..-. 3.., -.g n u.,,,-,<..a.:._ c: g.u.a g n = n -. 4 . s u.- 3 c. --wa I i -e. 3 _. g e_g I g 3 3 fO*.'- 'e 1 u" *.*. ~. * ,'#'#~..

4..m, 1

.4 g .--.w 1 I ( ) e.,..ra.il.._i ,.o a. n,.ia. e d,.n- ,.,.n e. .6.,- e. _i n.. n. a_ .i a a., _ d, .q .3 w .3 i I ..,, w _- y3a.:. _43., us.o.., g_......_..,.,- ..2 3 3. e,.<,.s g :,, #. d ,i a-. we, .3 I l s.,. - 1 3 3. , C'a'G '.* 'g>.. t (' w ) e..q ... 4 1.. .g g,,.n. w.: . L. n- ..2,6 3 w 4. 2,, A O_ C.a "- ' 7 n . O.'

• a_ d._

u 3 a-w. 3 i i. ".C',-'*#-*-- ".'.a-C 'e '.5 "..^ t ^ ". - C# u"-.."~~'.'#.~^Ua" l - ' C ' # '/ i ,' L' #. *. .(TT'. ~ w ) s ..,m-1.,.- -e.g.. y..e. '). ..a...,3..,.,a ..~.. ..---. w

w....

9. 3.

~.,.:.,,2-~.a

• d... a. I,,. 4 q.

o..u. n-g..n - ; e, ac

>;y w- ,u i t

4.., 4-

-,,--.e.~-.. .3 '.'.I C ~# * '. ' 'd _5".3"I'".'a' e _#.#. ^..^ 7'.,' O.# #'.." ..L.'.'a,'_'- ". ^. '.. - ' _ ' - m i 8 i i 4

• 9_.

~ u.,.. n..t t. .. - M o_ n. -, n,.4 M, ,..A. t u. a g,.~.~,~s.,..~. f...~ A. -m i t -,_;m,- a. 4 m

m..j

%e. q.. ,.6 .g .*,Io. bg I. o- -..M.. p... 3.. e-a .. g eee y ywas 4 a- ;... _ l f ..a ...q. ..,. a gy l' l l

., - - a,.

_,, d n.e,.. ;.3.

,.,.. L. 4 1. g 4.

aa.

n.., :..,_ 3,., 2,

..,3 -v.... v. s .m 3 3 r 4 i P ...y -s2, f a_.e..r.,~.., A, o.,.. a-s -. -, f m.. a m.ge_->J. u..,.,.. a _:, k nm n- .O. .f, s 3.g M..$ e.m &- C M."%******$ -.I 3 ~a -49*'*- -.,' l .'.y--.8," a r ,f..="a** S W, s.. ~~a +,. t 4 .mf % .ep. ... a -[ $.,. i,_ u'...*M..Eb_. w.. p gsm--Sq) ,.) ,,g l' w-=*ay v. =* - 8 m *. 3. -a g S e.g.-aw..-s, s u~$.,_. .;. 3 .a g,.3 >.e. 4 g ---,.e...b. p. y. y a ff.% 1'4 [g %. O W -..9.#s .)9'.. ~-... ---:*8 O )W) $I8 ) h" --~~~~ - me a m '., ; m.. ~. ;..:.:. ....a-ny w ] 4 .4 ~ N k F S,f q- {h m . i '.*dE { ' O~J !u f ee (y m 48I.) /L / y, 54 $13l;Ml:l$3im v/d 6 1 1 l

, A' I - :._ _ 3 :: ;._..., all issuas cf :'ais

ic-.

'. 2 7.Z E.U, ;;d y.an: is demaadec jcic.ciy and. severally agsins: the def2alts by the plaintiff for ecenc.ic losses in aa c cunt in cxcac s of Tea Tho. tad (310,0CO.00) :'clicrs as i i tiell as ;:u7iti.e dc. cases in ca roua: in excess o ~ Ten Thousand j ( y ig, c '.a g. n. msj. 1_1,-, v t i i I I) i / f f ' s, V /r" ((},. / } a o \\ h '/,'a'l L e *- I, ' 1. L '. g r E ' C u..". s. ',. '. -'C'.=.'..".,... O / p i c.:_2.:. n.. o~n er.i TmTw%- f w V.t e.I. O 99s a ;s.f, tiu 9*i. PWw I I f I i r 1 i- 't i 9 i ,1 i .Ia e ' h, b / i n / 1, J L. L}}