ML19225A043
| ML19225A043 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Comanche Peak  |
| Issue date: | 05/22/1979 |
| From: | Fouke R, Jacobsen N, Jacobson N CITIZENS FOR FAIR UTILITY REGULATION |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7907170243 | |
| Download: ML19225A043 (4) | |
Text
.
f
{
Lc:E /T i.
"RS $o-64$ Ai!D 50-446 NRC PUBLIC D00TND7f ROOM 1
i t
n.
'to..
- e..r
'l..-.,,u.c,
.ccr0Rs-
.m.
r, t
ut-
'.*: 2; G:'.J9ATli.G COMPANY I
NUCLEAR REGULATORY CC. lISSION
".. E {RATII'G LICENSE I
0F THE UNITED STAT;;S A
T CC:1AiCHE F1
- STEAi.1 I
,['
S.
x
.LICTRIC STATIO:. UNITS 1 AND 2 I
b Y
e, yon "g
p t,saa c t
i MOTION TO AIGND
'f,g i 5 L b.,l,o, >
t StiPFLEMENT TO PETITICU FOR LEAVE TO INTERVEi!
u,\\
c.. a s, e.
A C".,,
BY CITIZENS FOR FA7R UTILITY REGUIATION (CFUR) CI y @kw g
.us j iM \\
l T!OV.' COMES Citizens for Fair Utility Regulation (CFUR) and 1
l' files its Motion to Amend Supplement to Petition for Leave to In tervene and in support of the Motion would respec tfully show I
i the following:
{
- 1) Tne 05/17/79 NRC Staff Memorandum Regarding C ontentions i
proposed substitution of "V! hat the Staff beliaves is an acceptable j
contention encompassing all of the concerns expressed" is nct an adequate or accurate representation of the eignt CFUR contentiens ccntained in Secticn I'l of CFUR 's Supplement, or of an-j c ther CFUR 9
contention.
- 2) CFUR iculd respectfully ase the fern of the staff propcstl tu:
j change the substance so as ;c accura:ely reflect -he ccncerns of CF"-
and its v. embers.
t
- 3) CFUR the M ore prcposes the follcwing consolidaticn of he eight CFUR contentions contained in C ontentions IV A-E for ::urposes l
of clarity and ccnvenience.
In so doing, le recorve the right to i
t present CFUR Contentions IV A-H in their entirety if CFUR it adn_tted i
i.
j as a party:
' /]
i 7907170 347 00
"The a7plican c 's failure to adhere to the qual _ ty 1
assurance / quality control provision required by the
^ o.n a" r. "u,., t i c "1 ~.* * * ~
'Vr. rn,, iutt-u
....u A
s.
o W
'n.
to 1 i
o t
2, and t"e requirements of Appendix a of 10 CF9 Pa ri 50, raises subs tantial cuestions as to the ai nity of the ax.licant to conduct an effective QA/ C Q
i progran during the opera tion of CPSES.
As a result special operating conditions are necessary before r.o
- i..i i s c u e u" a
., _ ^' " a-.
~
u'.-
c - a. a *. _
-n
.c u -.1 s =.
_=a 3
...~
"In add'ition, the practice of the NEC has been to require calculation of the consequences of accident t
that have small consequer.ces whi1o ignoring accidents that have large consequences.
No matter how well-in-i tended a QA/QC P r ogra.T might be, CFUR contends that this prac tice aould compromise the effectiveness of
+"e e". F r. a.m...
Th i ~.N2.C e".'ntico v..
b'c b o l ; "v..' e d the o
.~a u
serioucness of accidents with large consecuences in the i.. i..d c c.' "..u v-7 +u:.
"y o w n.
"t;x' a n 'v o'yx m o~
a a. ~. -
av> m.
a n. a-c} q O,. $
yuu
., ~ ^*
u a'
'. A
.,_a*% O. P.u, Dt*b.l.1" 4
Y ** -
P P.v;
.$ 1 O { W.
G iY o--
v m
s c
.,,r-.
s,,.
Je. i.m.% -
t (.' ' * ( 's
,h m.
w
.S.4.g 4.. L, C.y.L-,.Y l" a 4-..c."J v V e.s.-sE.i.,,w.
v.
e n.P G h.,,.
e
. ] ;.
n, v.., g r..,, e t u~
e E
~. G
+'..'.vs my.m
-.m..
a v~.
A v
..v4
.a sw.
4
O. q vt 4 9 s
%s.
. LE.M s t]. h M
. g %.N Q O.D.
P.'d W. C. W.L l.$-
o <%v-ca.' -6v s
f
'S
]dN
-.%-,)
Y.% ) a* ',J1
. O y1 C. '.
m.
o v, a /
an
,+~n~1 C.e n o n _ L, c.~:,.p,.1 _:...o.
u. mf o v.
G n,..:.
..v..,
t :
.i r.-. w v.s.
it NRP "a +, ' A' f.'.
- s _i.v' u
- 4,
1 a
i m
.i.r. v o ' s c d.
. ~..
- n.. e '. i' :.3.. - '. ' - o, a <v;
+ b. u, l,.
u, vCw,.r.6 - oi p - - r..
e-
-o e
n, a
mW-v.
..v.A
+o o C'*t.' n o.i '9 1 j' ' " "i a' 's ' " *~
','5.'. t
~
v a e
-2_
Irl o u-
the pro'clen.las not reneated in the future.
In t
addition, allegations concerning the adecuacy of construction abouna in this com. unity and when prerent3d in context with the documented proble:,.o id:ntified by the Nr.C staff, bec o:..e much more c re c _ ale,
ever. in the a'osence of the identity of the worker in'<cived.
CFUR contends that the adecuacy of con-struction prr.ctices !.n these areas of non-compliance, (Lack of Organisation, 'c.'e lding, S t e e l, Groundwa ter Withdrawal, C oncre te, Expansion Joint end Frac ture Toughness fe s ting), should be included as an issue to ensure that the facility has been constructed in a mar.ner necessary to meet the requirements of Appe d x 3 of 10 CFR Part 50 and for safe operation.
CFUR further contends that the NRC should undertal:e non-destructive testing immediately to ascertain
+c
..a 1 4 d.;.+e y.
o.
+ k..,a c
cl m ef v.;
nn,u...t&c,.vt,d."
- 7 n ~n +
m >, +
w.a o
.o-
.c
.'!h ere f O re, ?renises CCnsidOred, FU? r"'uests acceptance of Q_yy. -
wv
- ^
^i^-
- v'".L. --' o.i.". 7-'
I t, s C"..
's o
.S.... c " 2' " ' i - " ' e.. _2 '. ~,
t^
R.-' ', A
.v" a n. 'a 'w4
+3
- v. -.i sa 7
T,,+_..m.;,..
..4--a v.'
+.,a, u.# #
-..a.m.-
,- 7 c
- 3. y-4
-c,
.,9,
.-. e.v.
q 4_
^
. +q.. ;
vyw% --,
p-q v - s v
uu
r. i * ?
g.
+ c, ye. 2.r, wr
..v.
v v-
..w w.
v v.s
-~
3,-u_1 O a o- + n. n, *v.#
r
-,. rs~
4-s 0av..v o.,
2,
p n
G/
pr s'
j l
,o
.W _)~g~
isi */ ; / ;
- f '.,r # / -s
<3 4
7},.
C,., a /
3,.
r p
w r.
a 7
g,
.'/
n..
L.
2Cufe MICR2rC.
o2nc}
- r. D i s &.a chcOO3Cn
, i L;.p V 2 U P.
r- -
-m, s
1669-5 Carter Drive
~4'10 It.,. 4.r 3-t v, r&, T w,o - v~
e i
o (vV n
-)-
3 O _)i
\\ ~i
)h/
_.' U
~
G' ' '
a ~n n 'v' 'u. ~.
C ~:. n 't 'u 1 C r'o"n r
I hereDs" certif.y th-t conics of the Motion to Amend Sucalc: ;n F 'o
. ?.1 1,1.'. [Or Ee:1.' 9 to IntOI *...e D [' C a '. b E - !. s eor 7U r bub-I hogulati.on in the above caotioned proceeding will be hanu-a.livared 1
u or nailed by May 22, 1979 to the follo..ing parties:
Elina'oeth S. B o,ce rs, Es';
Chairman Richard M.
Lowere, E m'.
Atc.iic Safe ty and Licensing Ecard As sis tant A ttorn=-y C':neral U.S.
Juclear Regulatory C on.ission Envinrrnental Proi ccIlon Wachington, DC 20555 Division PO Box 125L2, Capitol Static:
.;.. u:
m., w, 1.1 L n.. o
,.- n o a..,, 4 v,
.e c 1
..m.,>,.,
e n.
.u 1
<m A tcnic Safety and Licensing Board U.S.
r'uclear Regulatory C ommission A tonic Safe ty and licensing
'ilashington, DC 20555 Board Fanel U. S. Iluc le : Regulatory Richard C ole, Esc., Membe-C omic cion A tomic Safety and Licenc Soard Washing; ton, EC 20555 U. :',. Nuclear Regulatory Commission
'clahington, EC 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Panel La'.tr ^ nc e J. C handler U.S Iluclear Regulatory Office of Executive Legal Director i
C or.ic a io n U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555 Washington, DC 20555 Decketing and Service flicholas S. Reynolds, Esq.
Section Debevois & Liberman Office of the Sccretar.;
1200 17th Street,
.'4. ' ~l.
U.S.
i.'uclear Regulatory uv u.,~
C c _u _..; :
4.-
.o rc
. n
. a _ c.,
maa..
, von,
.~
- u..,u - :.. 4.,.$ v e m.
._,,_)
w t,
- t. s Ti
,n..:%
.r.
- 1 w'
. 71;e L'..,,,.<
's at.
w C+
. M.f*
u'C F9 t v, v.,.~
1
't C & g n'~
. " v~ a, J
w.
. ~; a f.,
rm =
- ~ -
e4 ti.e p
1.
a
'=*b
- ..r -
Ln.,,,
n_.,
s
-y
'? ;. ?
"'1
~
.T n e n.1
.G O v < r.i
.'se~
- -.~a ms-
=
+
w-a s
O,,.1 u a..e.g i
- t. T
~.
f*-
'~
'*,7,.
7,.
i s a g. [_, V p p w vv
... a.
Elu ".cuaten Street e.
< A.. c._
r
. o.,
u
.s,.,
my s
,....,,.,,,u.,...;..n n6...).s._.
- 3. y a
-r w_
/
l, / Qu.Q.,, ]/
- - 7 : u M U ;n'
!x
- i p/
o s
,1 v
s hichard L.
Fou.e CFUR
~N~
,qp (U U ' t
-. h }7
-