ML19224C241
| ML19224C241 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Allens Creek File:Houston Lighting and Power Company icon.png |
| Issue date: | 05/21/1979 |
| From: | Lowerre R TEXAS, STATE OF |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7907020002 | |
| Download: ML19224C241 (5) | |
Text
.
,.c-i1 9,h g.
C m
y, e~ cp s
/s g
u s. <..
d4
,' 1 UNITZO 5 ~.'IsTES OF A!EP.ICA 1a NUCLSAa REGULATORY CO:01ISSION j
tw, q >', i. : ' A. 'y r- ;
~
M l'~
BEFORE TL ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD
',' \\
W.' ~I o,i C
c..a
' k, v[i.[
g ptmLIC DOCGEC #
/
<v'T I-
- ' - '4atter of X
-- w:
1 I!'.; mTO: LICIITING & POWER COTIPANY I
Docket No. 50-466 X
(Allens Creek I,. lear Generating X
Station, Unit 1)
X RESPONSE OF THE STATE OF TEXAS IN SUPPORT OF APPLICANT'S MOTION FOR SUPPLEMENTARY NOTICE, WITH MODIFICATIONS On May 9, 1979, Applicant filed a motion with this Board requesting that the Board publish a supplementary notice of intervention procedures.
The State of Texas fully supports i
Applicant's position that a new notice is necessary and would endorse Applicant's suggested notice if two problems ccn be resolved.
The two problems that exist with Applicant's sugcested notice are discussed below and the State of Texas respactfully submits that this Board should issue a new notice similar to that proposed by Applicant with certain clarifications.
(a)
Parties ho have never Ecfore filed a petitie..
T'.e suggested supplemental notice by the Applicant would allcw additional persons to file for participation :ut would also require any party who has not previcusly filed a petition tc intervene in this proceeding to file an affidavit stating that the failure to file was a result of the restricted nature of the original notice.
The af fidavit requiremen of the suggested supplementary notice should be reviewed closely by the Board for
.) o< u, n a f) e c
t_ c v
~907020 00A 7
L could be too restrictive and zeuld scourage a parson
.A otherwise would file for party status.
If oweve r, the more inportant problem with the supplementai notice suggested by Applicant is its failure to m n2!in cle'rly that persons 2'
have a full right to petition under the late filing provis o:
In keeping with the intent of a notice of a hearing, the Board abould encourage persons with an interest and the ability i
to assist to ta', part in the proceeding rather than discourage participation.
(b)
Persons nreviously filina f ar narty status.
The more difficult issues raised by the supplementary notice I
requested by Applicant involve the questions of the rights of the current parties in this proceeding and the rights of those persons who filed for party status but were denied such status because their contentions were not valid contentions under the previous restrictions.
The supplementary notice does not address the issues of whether these persons or parties can fi le now contentions.
While the State of Texas is not muggesting that this Board issue a new notice that starts the whole pro-ceeding over, we do 'suggest that those parties who were not represented by attorneys and who did not appeal the original decision of t:.e Licensing Board should not be put in a worse pcaition than persons who never applied fo. party status.
In any case, the State of Texas respectfully requests that the Board clarify its position on these issues if the Bon.d issues a.y supplementary notice in this proceeding.,} r. i.
p-1 f
Fespectfully submitted
/
bl_'_
i(
/
TCliAlo - aW.
foQpRRE Attorney for the State of Texc.--
- .:ay 21, 1979,)
e n.-
r, LCD c.',_',_'
A s
s.
N
/, </
c:
\\
uss..
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA fi7
_p
,i,v. >' ;
L NUCLJAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
,. 7 4 y--. J j
v
- g ;..,
,~
c ~ ;'d, ".f,/-l BEFORE THE.'.TOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARC '%
r-
,s d7J. /
lQ; Q, d< N /
s g
In the Matter of I
X HOUSTON LIGHTING & POUER COMPANY X
Docket No. 50-466 X
(Allens Creek Nuclear Generating X
Station, Unit 1)
X CERTIFICATE OF SER'IICE I hereby certify that copies of the foregoing Re-sponse of the State of Texas in Support of Applicant's Motior for Supplementary Notice, with Modifications were served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, postage prepaid, tnis 21st day of May, 1979:
Sheldon J.
Wolfe, Esq., Chairman Hon. John R.
Mikeska Atomic Safety and Licensing County Judge, Austin County Board Panel P.
O.
Box 310 U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Bellville, Texas 77481 Washington, D.
C.
20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Dr.
E.
Leonard Cheatum Appeal Board Route 3, Box 350A U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Watkinsville, Georgia 30677 Commission Washington, D.
C.
20555 Mr. Gustave A.
Linenberger Atomic Sa f 'ty and Licensing Atomic Safety and Licancing Board i Board Panel U.S.
Nuclea_ R.egulatory Commission U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Com.
Washington, D.
C.
20555
' Wa shi ng to n,
D.
C.
2]555 Chase R.
Stephens Steve Schink, Esq.
Docketing and S2rvice Section Staff Counsel Office of the Secretary of the U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Con.
Commission Washington, D.
C.
20555 U.S.
Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.
C.
20535 Jce Archer, Esq.
Conbs, Archer & Peterson R.
Gordon Gooch, Esq.
1220 Americana Building Baker & Botts 811 Dallas Street 1701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W.
Houston, Texas 77002 Washington, D.
C.
20006 Carro Hinderstein Honorable Charles J.
Duzek 8739 Link Terrace Mayor, City of Wallis Houston, Texas 77025 P-O.
Box 312 Wallis, Texas 77485 266,2nm es
itoneca..lc r.:roy II. Crebe Jack R.
Necan County Judga, Au s c.i a C o u n t'/
Robert H.
Culp P.
o.
P..v 9)
Lowenstein, Newman, Reis, Dellvil.2, Texas 77418 A::elrad & Toll lu2b Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Madeline Ba ss Framson Washington, D.
C.
2002:
4322 Way.esboro Drive Ho us ton, Te <ac 77035 J c:... F. Coherty 4438-1/2 Leeland Wayne E.
Rentfro
!!our ton, Texan 77023 P.
O.
Box 1335 Rosenberg, rexas 77471 Robert S.
Franson 4822 Waynesboro Drive Eranda McCorkle IIo us to n, Texas 77035 6140 Darnell Houston, Te <as 77074 D.
Marrack 420 Mulberry Lan2 James Scott, Jr.
Bellaire, Texas 774Cl 9302 Albacore Houston, Tecas 77074 F.
H.
Potthoff, III 1814 Pine Village John R.
Shraffler Houston, Texas 77080 5014 Braeburn Bellaire, Texas 77401 J.
Gregory 20peland Charles G.
l'hras h Daker 5 Botts 3000 One Shell Plaza Houston, Te<as 77002 I
i /fkCt^ /
Nildd /
l.1C HARD W.' L'.jE RRE Assistant Attorney General 3,,
9, i.
{'_ 0
[. G i
~ =.c r y C.7 m..==_
- v. = e v L=
r.-
_v.
m...-
5.nm.
C Cn,a.-
On,,,n,
- a.., u v:
nz
=
.a-
- m. u.r
. Lm_ r I L Ltm..i r T m _:
c m... ; e; r n.u.
s u.r m. u._r S m. n e_ 0r n
am ar.
r n - r e n. >l r. a a
- m. 0
- m..u.r s e.r.u m A.no_r r Cn.u. i S f n_rS.: v,.u5; m-.v n
a 4 _
- m. u..r.prm..T *1.T 011 rOn*
L' _r ' 'v _
- m. 0 T.iImr_n..t *~_'T T
n
/
O r T..u._r
_T.viIT " 0 ?..".J.r'I m. A r.
.n. _r.Tr_'. ? S 7 vf.?".. n/
4
.n 1
The People of the State of California and the California Pu'clic Utilities Commission of the State of California (CPUC) received a Petition for Leava to Intervene on May 7, filed on behalf of the Environmental Defense Fund dated May 2.
On May 21, CPUC was served a copy of Joint Applicants' Response to the aforesaid Petition dated May 18 as the date of signing.
CPUC submits that the Joint Applicants' Response must be con-sidered an " answer" filed by them under 10 CFR 2.714 entitling:
"(c) any party to the proceeding may file an answer to a Petition for Leave to intervene within five (5) days after th.a.
e e *. 4
- 4 m n
.4 s
.e 4 l e u. ff y
..w 4
.T
- a - n e _a.w e
...e O.n. e "y C n s e C # u o -. v n" "e "y ' *- *.". '. "
- w W""
u ". ' ' '~' '."
yy a
a a
s as..ov g e..n. 3
.e 4. 7 a. a.
W.4
- w 4.. : dcne a.o em e
~
ff
-#47ad" 4
3-
- w
. o e o c.. 4.
4,.
3 v..-
s a.
y ecmy
_4o.a.o.
'n,_4. w.
_7 ra n. r..
c.~f h { c ),
c-.,4 4
a 1
ew
-...74
- h. a.
4a
.oa.n.
c.4
-.. w. e.
w k _n e.d.?.
7.y o..n.
- b a g s.g O s* 4.. *w n y y.. n e.n.. - f.. a. a y s.. a.
- -
- 4 g
eon a
e.k.
,,.7 4 hp wod s. a. a. 4 e-.e
- e. n..
.uw
.a
- 4.= o..i.7 0 4 7 a,a 5 n.d a. w C
4 g n,..4 a n
.?. "( 7 O f, m. i r *: ". L" A
a..o. e
..J sk m
s..e. a. e..'.' c a e.... o..r..
s w
v.
w w
, 3 v.
.v ww.
C n U' c. 4,* An 7 4. w c.r.= s 1
" a.s y v n a o.
n oc 46 ac 7
a n
-o
... e.,
.e.. a. C.
- b.. s.
4.e. =. a. m m. e. o.
- k. a.
y s
e.
= a. c e.1 a.
n.o r n.7 4.p - -..*4 e vy w
wu w.
-o Qff
- i cv0 L.U