ML19224A839

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Responds to Re Tmi.Info Partially Withheld:Name & Address of Recipient & Portion of Document Unrelated to TMI (Ref FOIA Exemption 6)
ML19224A839
Person / Time
Site: Crane 
Issue date: 04/12/1979
From: Bradford P
NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:
AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
References
NUDOCS 7906060167
Download: ML19224A839 (2)


Text

.

j

' '4, U.'H IE D sT AT E S M.

N,'" LEAD REGULATORY COMMISSIO.'{

+

^

-j

)

w.us:.sc ;.; :, o c. nus

~} _,.

w..

,c

--%~'

April 12,1979

.c t

i (Name 5 addtess deleted - Exemplian 6)

V I

Dea r I

Thank you for your letter of :iarch 28 regarding Three Mile Island.

l-There P.re several points in it that are simply not correct.

Ho. lever, I am not sure that the corrections would necessarily alter your conclusicas.

Y' i

iPo.ttion deleted - ur.telated to Thhee Mlle Island)

Fourth, all of the Commission's previous probability calculations would shovi the events at Three Nile Islar.d to be far nore unlikely than the chances of an earthquake at one of the fo;r sites.

There is simply not a sufficient data base ' lith regard to either the nuclear irJustry or the seismic history of different regions to state the possibi'.ity of failur2 v:ith meaningful precision.

It aey be true that in any cases t2 err on the side of caution, but I,think that the consequences of a nuclet.r accident are such that te cannot permit ourselves to ere the o th e r

a.v..

y 169 013 700606016, il 1

Y W.

,5;95=4sasV Agair., thank you for writing, and let me close by urging that you keep in mind that the Commission does include tuo physicists and a nuclear engineer.

Its unanimous decision to close down five plants was not arrived at either casually or politically.

Sincerely,

,,./

fl&.S-7(/ & [- ^

Peter A. Bradiord Commissioner 169 01 %