ML19224A350
| ML19224A350 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse, Peach Bottom, Harris, Wolf Creek, Saint Lucie, Hope Creek, Seabrook, North Anna, Sterling, 05000000, 05000484, Washington Public Power Supply System, Cherokee, Marble Hill, Hartsville, Phipps Bend, Crane |
| Issue date: | 12/21/1978 |
| From: | Duflo M NRC ATOMIC SAFETY & LICENSING APPEAL PANEL (ASLAP) |
| To: | |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7901020014 | |
| Download: ML19224A350 (5) | |
Text
-
NRp-PORziC Do qO f2Ny*n0037
~
m.. r m..e D e m A T e. S 0 c n..:e R r,n,
.c
--ev n.OR., CO n.,.rSSA.e a r,-..r c
,1 L.C r.,-u.a a
a.
- n r=
avO+
==.f, nr'p=nu O U.
-n ri. U,.y,.A D n;-.,mir 4%4 u ul
,ma g
,,tn yv f..r.4 01.4 u
,.f
%} g03!
f*1 e-o Alan S.
Rosenthal, Chairman
.n,v
/
. g'W, Dr. JChn H.
Buck V
Michael C.
7arrar
- m. "v,.. 6, y
\\
2
~
h ['O s Richard S.
Salzman
.g Dr.
W.
Reed JohnsCn O'
>Q JerCme E.
Sharfman s
W'#
t.,/.
/p g
)
m;,ru
, /
o u.e L,.
n=
1..
e.o s.
)
- ^.,-
c c t p s. "4-a_ _ -
,i r., C. 2..
.s o u.
, e. r..c u.. r n, r r ~ R r_,.
u vm...
.s
..n..
ov c :
< =. e a n-C
.,m n~ ~. m.< -
- o. n w,,,.
c,
.a,n,
)
s Units 2 and 3)
)
s
)
_m,,
)
n, c,1.La..
.4s.
.;..n
, eD r e rv. C C.v.e. n.,4..y o
s
..ir..ece. c....s4 v
- ~
)
(hree Mile Island Nuclear Station,
)
+)
)
r ', 4 4.
- v.. O.
/.
u...-
)
.u 77a
.s4D o Ce. tr R o n,0.,v.y
)
a C C,< 2 u..C s.
.,- G rs.I I n, r. -.u, R., r av or n
4
\\/. a w.
.ss
)
( vC 1,
3.....,
, C.,v.
,4,..,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
)
-,- ~. u~. R.,
n.sI D c, c-m,C C.< e.
v.. C o. J u - J' n'
C 2 r,.;'c u *.. cras.us
~ ~ -. - - -
ur an l
O J ' J' :.e
~n C O D.' '4' v.
)
( u.n., e
.,,. n. a.,s c,.u.1
.,2,, :
a -.,. u c
)
. wg
',)
T
,3..A "a n.4.-
wa
\\
/
~,
,.C.
D '3 a,3 a.
..A...
u, C C.,. &.
G -.y o,.. y
-. u
, v.,
.-..r,
- uu... r,,an a c t,u.- -a
.m e aun.
.a
)
(w.c..
.t.L, - 4,.
3,a...,
- r. n.4
.'4 0. e)
)
)
2 t-n. --
.4.
j uCC.<e
,cs.
00 100
.4 s
CAA si.,n r. h s R n,.,, D
- u..
..r,
,, n A, r n...,
c.
3
)
50-421
,a,C.,,. a
- 0.,,.d m_
- 2..,.,...,
)
a.e.n,,4.
=. a. 4..S 4
r, b..n a.-..
-w
+
v
.,A t)
)
n' v. -.
e L;-
6.
w o.,,,
., s
)
. x.m n y ;. e,.-
03._.m.., C - *.. a- -.4."
~2
..'. =.u. y e =.'
..w..- m. t,.
,,....,e-a s.
v y
...g C 2. A d.'.~.y~ o~
. '. ".'.v'.'..'C..
~.. ' ^. ^.
"'.'.^.~w#^^o~ -.'.s-.#.".".
a v,, a-
,4. g,
..u 3
..v
". e." ^..'.*. ' v' c. ". A ".m'.de.
3 e C ' " S e
^,.,.#
".'". e ^,, A" o." ' s'..'p'-
C,.'1
~. . e
- u.. g.,.
. v, e p. A.s..g
,.' c.q a..,. a,
a,L..
- 3.,.p -
. 33,,,,,. o g.; - n, '-
-k a
>n
. ~.. -. -
.v y
,a
.s.
- +
v.
g- - d
.'.,a _,.
.'.3
"' " C C o. o d.'."'y-*o"
.g.;. x.
.- a, e. -
3 4
,. g, r-w n.a.
4
^*
-no v..
w g.4. 4.g g
.f'.C u ' 5 "a
'.'. 'w"v' G *..". '. d-
'., * /.I~.
.. w 4. w.
w3,,
^
.) _(s L
. '.1. J
3 -
PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY OF INDIANA,
)
INC.
)
)
(Marble Hill Nuclear Generating
)
Docket Nos. STN 50-546 Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
STN 50-547
)
TENNESSEE VALLEY AUTHORITI
)
)
(Phipps Bend Nuclear Plant,
)
Docket Nos. 50-553 Units 1 and 2)
)
50-554
)
MEMCPANDUM AND ORDER Decemher 21, 1973 (ALAS-512)
In ALA3-509 (December 1, 1978), we called for the filing of certain papers in these radon proceedings.
We now have before us motions frca the intervenor in T._vrene (which nlans to join forces with the intervenor in Sterling) and the appil-cant in St. Lucie.
These motions seek mcdifications in the schedule and procedures we adcpted but do not challenge *he
'/
basic format we laid down. 2 For good cause shc.m, both T.otions are granted.
Because this action will affect the parties in other proceedin s, we cutline below what its impact on the original schedule will be.
_j/ Compare Public Service Ccapany of Indiana (Marble Hill Units 1 and 2), ALA3-511, 3 NRC (December 13, 1973).
_s.
4qq LJ 1.t > U
4
_ 3 _
7/
O nD _r o r D. -
n Tu 4-
.n
- w as sv
.s.
nL CARD
,33
- OR s-s o
n C
Wg
/
Margaret E.
Du Flo Secretary to the Appeal BCard
' e _#^"e we v. e"a " cad"j
-o'easa 'h.'a-C y.i...i ^ ", v. a.
--_o f v'" S "-
- ^
~
w-vo
." e C a.iV A. d
_# _" C n. ".". e S ~v - _" _'.'.".y'
......v..".C" a
"..sC u.' C n
_# ^ " 9&.c'_'.'"
""c o
w m,r. n m. e
- m.. o.. o..n.n 8 -
.60 p.i e.n.
.Je.
4
_4..
- b. e.
- O.4.n. 4.n.c
- c.. u. c..m. _
.e
-.n.
,-vi
- o y
3.4 n v
- 4.. e.
.TC 1_' r W _i."."3 v.'*Se Ou"
.i m
v
".e e ' s~
+ _~. e '. "
~
- C
. 3
- m. w. a. - o c-y w.. s e C y y O e.a _4 u. _4 r..n.
- o t.,.
- k.. e-
.ce.m 14 ~
..yy--ou
- -~
..~
C O " " a C '- ' "
.".C " c. S
"..h.a t '." o.
.C ~. P. ".' 4.". C_7C "- 4 C."-
_4 ". a~ $.' _#
f--
"~*
4 o. g,o, 2 4 - 4 s.... o ' s~ C "..
_v.
- ^"
~.. e '. A. y'" o. S ~o c~ d
- 3..X *m e ". a~.iC r..
2.C 'w' -
.a.w 4. w.
4.
. jC4..s-
..w 4 -
- o., c..r,.. o.
_,.e e
..C__4,n a... -.u.
_w w L.
o
~.
".". e c ~ s _* i i.". C a y" y".'.' w ' *. *. a "y " a " 3 '. ~..' " ". ' d
.".C "w Sea". -- ".i7 c s'
~
y y
a, - y 7 a.
, g.. c.4 2
_4 r.n.
.eg u..w.e " oC" e S ' e #
- e.'
7.
1 ". A, ' o~
,n w
y w
' i "c-- adv deC.dd.ed
~.".a'..'.".
0 "u."
C ".'."..i '. r. 4.*.4. 4 ". w' *. o. s, We
.b. ' d w
f
"..". e "_ V, " C i. a_
a..v. '. ^. 7 s~ _i ". r.
S.".* C ' d - y "fi ?,
" h e C.4 """"..S *..'." C e.c
.~
2 aS n.
- O
- k.e na e a-L, e
_e
..i
..17 y y
.. e
.c u e 7 4.,. ~
4.,. *..c.mI e.n. O -
.w On One 21rSt 1SSue inVO,Veu, and to al_ parties CC O,ne e.s e C,41.e.
,k C.
.C
_ o. - s C.
_2
- n* _4-do-... 4 4.3l a-4--,
7 soJo.
w a
--" C i.". ~. ". ".
" i " ^ ^ ' ' " a " o.
". "..C S G
.# ".*. c " 7 ^. ".C _" S
- . " *. 7..
- _# ' _i."."3 a
-a....
y
" o.i." ' y _" e S a n. ". = ~ _iC ". C-
'..".e _i _" " " e w a-
"m '.. e v_
.=. A =- s _' _" o_.
^
Cf. 10 CFR 2.715a and ALA3-539, sucra, 3 '.72C a t
.*m..
-L) ".1. u.
U::iTED STATl'S OF M'IR!CA
- UCf. EAR REGU!.A FORY CC:C'!SS IO::
In the >;ctter of
)
)
>2TROF0LITA:i EDISO:! CO)1PAFf,
)
)
)
(Three ' hie Island f nit ::o. 2)
)
)
)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SZ?"!CE I hereby certify that I have this day served the foregoing document (s) upon each person. designated on the of ficial service list compiled by the Of fice of the Secretary of the Cc= mission in this proceeding in accordance with the recuire=ents of Section 2.712 of 10 CFR Part 2-Rules of Practice, of the !!uclear Regulatory Cc.unission's Rules and Regulations.
Dated at k'ashington, D.C. this
. M A b day of h 4C-197 r.
C j
L
/
.iu,GU ~ i LiwLum Of fich 6f the Secretary of the Co==ission Y -5 vM5 / fv L L iT[k:.'l 01 L.w I
U.'.. ? '. e )
4 L.,..
_D n.._
S r
.,,., -__. C i.
Shf #9L 7.i O, O 7 " T *T._. ". o. ?.' *.
C^o*.r**P q ~ '.n.
.m
.. - ~..
In the Matter of
)
s
/
METROPOLITA'i EDISoli CC"P.'C Y,
)
Dochet Mc. (s) 50-323 ET it.
7 (Tc ree.dle I.ilar. ;, Cnit 2)
)
SE??ICT LIST Edward Luton, Esq., Chair an Chauncey P. Kepford Atomic Safety and Licensing Board 433 Orlando Avenue U.S. Nuclaar Regulatory Co= mission State College, Pennsylvania 16801 Washington, D.C.
20555 Honorable Karin '7 Carter Mr. Gustave A. Linenberger Assistant Attorney General Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Depart ent of Envi:o.= ental Rescurces U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Co _ission 709 Health and Welfare 3uilding Washington, D.C.
20555 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Dr. Ernest O. Salo, Professor Miss Mary V. Septhard Fisheries Research Institute, WH-10 Citicens for a Safe Environment College of Fisheries P.O. Box 405 University of Washington Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17108 Seattle, Washington 98195 Dr. '.I. ?.eed Johnson Counsel for NRC Staff Atonic Safety and Licensing Appeal Office of the Executive Legal Director Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Co==ission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Co=nission Was hin gton, D. C.
20555
'ia shin g t on, D. C. 20555 George F. Trowbridge, Esq.
Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge 1800 "M" Street, N.9.
%'ashington, D.C.
20006 Alan S. Rosenthal, Esq., Chaircan Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Coc=ission Washington, D.C.
20555 Jerome E. Sharfman, Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U.S. Nucicar Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555
-c.49 O
1.1.J D
r m.4
- m. e n e--
.e v. 4. e. v n r.
.%v.r.o.r c.n v
.s v
w NUCLEAR REGULATORY CC:01ISSICN n. C u..r C S n,.r.e.. v.
3Dr-e v..
-,..o o. r.m 2., t,n,
.J s-n.
a
,ce, 1
u M..
a Alan S.
Rosenthal, Chairman
- jet,
/
'e
-No 62 Dr. Jchn H.
Buck Y
Michael C.
Farrar
,,c[
Richard S.
Sal: man
.n $ \\"
, ',g w
g%.b',, ','j Dr.
W.
Reed Johnson A
s -
i?
Jerome E.
Sharfman v.L-%
)
- / ig V
In the Matters of
)
)
PHILADELPHIA ELECTRIC CCMPANY et al.
)
Occket Nos. 50-277
)
20 473 (Peach Bottom Atomic Pcwer Station,
)
Units 2 and 3)
)
)
METRCPCLITAN EDISCN COMPANY et al.
)
Cocket No. 50-320
)
(Three Mile Island Nuclear Station,
)
Unit No. 2)
)
)
VIRGINIA ELECTRIC AND PCNER CL 2ANY
)
Occket Nos. 50-338
)
50-339 (North Anna Pcwer Station,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
)
PUBLIC SERVICE ELECTRIC AND GAS
)
Cocket Nos. 50-354 COMPANY
)
50-355
)
(Ecpe Creek Generating Station,
)
Units 1 and 2)
)
)
FLCRICA PCWER ANC LIGHT COMPANY
)
Occket No. 50-339
)
(St. Lucie Plant, Unit Sc. 2)
)
)
CAROLINA PCWER AND LIGHT COMPANY
)
Occket Nos. 50-400
)
50-401 (Shearen Harris Nuc' a =- o wer Plant,
)
50-402 Units 1,2,3 and 4)
)
50-403
)
- Three members of the Appeal Panel constitute the Appeal 3 cards in the two prcceedings in which tne notions discussed herein were made.
Because of the order's impac: cn the other prcceedings, h c w e'/ e r, each Panel member was consulted with regard to it; each one agreed that the proceedings On which he is sitting shculd be governed by it.
M bi
_ o
_L.e.. (
LJ
. PUBLIC SERVICE COMPANY OF INDIANA,
)
7_..C.
)
a
)
(Marble Hill Nuclear Generating
)
Occket Nos. STN 50-546 Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
STN 50-547
)
L.
)
,Ja.
S a-e a mm m_
)
(Phipps Send Nuclear Plant,
)
Decket Ncs. 50-552 Units 1 and 2)
)
50-554
)
MEMORANDUM AND CRDER December 21, 1973 (ALA3-512)
In ALAB-509 (December 1, 1973), we called for the filing of certain papers in these radon prcceedings.
We new have before us actions frcm the intervenor in Tyrone (which clans to join forces with the intervenor in Sterling) and the appl -
cant in St. Lucie.
These actions seek =cdificaricas in the schedule and procedures we adopted but do not challense the
'/
basic forman we laid down. 2 For goed cause shown, bc h T.ctions are granted.
Because this actica will affec: the parties in other proceedings, we cutline below what its impact On the original schedule will be.
__1/ Cc= pare Public Service Cc=cany of Indiana (Marble Ell-Units 1 anc 2), ALA3-51., 8 N RC __ (Cecember 19, 1575),
mLJ AtAJ
. 2/
It is so ORDEPIDI FOR THE APPEAL BOARD 0aA-4s2 E. & b Margaret E.
Du Flo Secretary to the Appeal Board
__2_/ Just before we were ready to release this ceinicn, we received frcm the Sterline intervenor a motion formally joining in the Tyrone :.ntervenor's notion for an exten-sicn of time.
Folicwing close en its heels came an o c. o s.i
- d o r.
..
- b. a. S'a
.14..~-
= r---=.n*..
-'i^
- ".a- -asyc.se c ^. - e c -.1 v
.c t e s
.". = ~
..w.e a~ a _ '.d..c.
m.. c *- 4 ^.
4*-
' - a
,_'da
--ae--
u o--
s insufficient reascn for the recuested extension.
Mcw-ava.,
~..".e
'v -. e ~..o *w d -... ~. w. hic.h i* 4c.'..s
'u w.".'-k.
~
-a
~
the Sterline. ac..c lican t a.c. carently had not seen -- gives ample Just;.fication for che recuested delay.
And, as c "e.- c p d...i.n
.4..d i c a
- a s, we ".. = d a 7 - = = d v.
d id ec-ed-... =. -..
the circumstances the Tyrone extension should apply as wa.'.'
'o
- k.e yace s ""e.".--..
-"a S
- a..'.i.n e_
- a-
.... - v a... c -
cn the first issue involved, and to all parties on the de ninimus issue.
We can th:.nk of nc reason at this
,c.i...
o d.isc u.aca
~..'.v~s e
.4..~. e.- v e..^- -
.".- m # '.T i.. ~3 a
a a" c.i.n * :- - a. s e... a '- i o c.
.". a.i.- ". d aws." -"
~..'.a. v.a-
- e s.i - a.
d Cf. 10 CFR 2.715a and AD.3-5C9, supra, 3.;RC at M.
- =M
-e6.
W
."