ML19220C945

Forwards Antinuclear Flyers

ML19220C945
Person / Time
Site:	Crane
Issue date:	05/10/1979
From:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
To:	NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
References
NUDOCS 7905160087
Download: ML19220C945 (6)

Text

ga.

50-320 Anti "uclear Flyers 118 179 70052600% ]

x %m,.[,, Ovs!.:.,. sm, / { 7,h

.3 %e nn. s J:.. g-.M

.-O p f?

5,

]~

\\ [ V - [ s[p {k 3

. ] Q '[$ 7 ~,[ G [.[

}$;l h-Uh.;)

3 3

f 9

r.

2., a s ism

.m r,. s s>y

.:.m.t.-m

..;...rr.

-~-~m.-wsr.y.~e.r -wer -- a m. y '.C-? _.,... m.a:m, - :n a.s:..u.. m.:a....~.e,2

- s-

,,..a.ww._ m... c-

.~...,e._

...g.

.m

. ~.

3

+~

u 1

g.

^

M}

^

a r,m:

a '! R*lb

^ **.: >. %

/s,.,,

s r

. w r.a.. :....x, -

,+ e

~

e-u,

s

• O

. 4.

,w,,n

_r,,,;;-.....,'-<

s

.x j

g

?

. *. - y:w >.

8 ;;

' '- l **', ; '~';~ '

• _ y

>i e

d a'

,, y

' L;h -

r ~,' - <

i m,

.c x, c..,

~ q,. <

,m-

]. F; m

c,. m..~,;

~

f m

s s.

4,.

p.f t

. x,,,. ).

~ p,., ~,

y

..,u s

,.,x-

.,7 m,.

,- er p.

y.

Y

'~

.n.

..n.-.

ny

,y.-.

~~ ~.. ^.

r,

,..a

. y,,..wg!:.,,'i^

,9 s _.

• J.

/

b*

_,f

,).:.,......,* w.,...';,.-**.

t ** <

y

.~.-

,e

~.a se n

,<y ue: - #. p q.y

.,e g # y.f ; m. ;L,,,;'

y e

',,. a m 4

.,m~'.

1-U.

f-4p

.W f,,. -

^ ' ' $,%,a > c

-O.

.j _. p 'r V - -

n -s.~

~%?. ' l'l.Q

.,ryjs-l

~ % yk., X

• 2 m u.

i'9'

., s m

p.

c 1

, +g

<.. -v

~. '

, v,,.:.u~.-:

,a a. =r '.

s

&, -< 7.,-.1 r.

%

• t.-

., s m.

-se

,/-m.

, - g ;. y 7.-

t, s... ~

y 7 4,.c.

,9-,.

Q q.

' +.:.,,..

~.s 8~-

w N

s#4-eg yp -, ~,,

s g.

yg

,o

'.,,.,.',%,.4, r,,/.

i

/

,p-;.

o i -

s Ly

.,.m,..

-: a.:

• 4 3".v 4,,,

..., 'y

, ~./ : &;.

3

.,J.,3,g

.~--A

/

- J a.f

1. l. ;, w,.,,',

,y

.c, c

,y

,, ;y,g.

a s,,,,'..

. ;, a _

3,

+

..w.

. { ;.

-m.

-, w.

,e

.f v

,4

.p.

L. :

n j

w._.. c4

', j'./ j '

x j

.,7 s,-

y

,p:'g

,.r.

..n.;.,. - v,

..- ?f,4 3

_ ~;

. ~.

., ~. ~ 3.. s,

-...,v,..

,. ~.

-,-t w. -... =

a.,

w..n

. ~. -. L...a a

,,;w x.w a.,

.a s

.-.:c.----.

.... a., J... _

,c.

..m..

.. _.s 7 +.

a.

w.

3.,.

.2,

_... u,. ~....;

z r e e.

.- m

'r pl,;t inc i do :t is, r.2 sti..

is.

- cacrdi 2:e. 1: t = -m t to deliber2: _.

e:

't s ! : 'c e ze r s ic-of t r. e Caiu%:a nictures m.>,

"Se chi - 5indr:

c.'

?.,

ar _, and its cc-ection to tb_ 3 ree "ile Island inc i d e.it,

t".e cercl

.t-of certain me.bers of the Nuclent ~ egulatarr C rr.issi:r ir pr:ductia. of the,-

and n c u e a t w n a'a. o decisians t a.< e r at the S re e l e Island p;;ri, and the '1 ' s recent shutdown of fice creatb', operatin.; nuc1 car 3r_s, a l '. cc.e togetar as acrt af lmes Schlesi.zer's e: ergy p oli c:. for the United ;tates.

?!s o p e r a t. 3..,

aari.:ation m t' 5 ': l e s i n.;e r ' s oil hoax, the Cc--

Da. d enerzu consere,:icr pal m, 2r? the British atterpt tc tue a ter the U.S.

ha i; ses:cm,,re

_2 1.

ai.ed at 5 ::u t t i c,

d ow-'

the L.S.

ecencr" Dr.

'4 0 r r i s I.e : 'tt, a nucicar physicist and leadin.; authoritt en energy tech als; ao drect:r of the Fusion Er 'r ;y reend n ian, wl 1 detai. the aacedre for the 3 ree '!ile Icland incident 2nd the ongoine "ener.;, ceracne."- the "' ew N r> Aces" scenarie of 3ertrand Russell and tis environmental preze-nc i ~. ~ u o m..

.s a.u.

t...._.u...

n x e.,.,

Wednesday, April 4, 3:00 p.m.,.Uarvin Center, Rm. 410 THE BRITISH ANTI-SCIENCE NEW DARK AGES STR ATEGY OF BERTRAND RUSSELL AND H. G. WFi I S rn

\\\\8 ou Dr. Wrris teutt

'13.. ( c.e % nt er n R e<.er s e; l'h D. C olu m tu l n n erun H ecent pu%wons: m,tt:manni Stan sucal Ineort : Survrco n. actu m Rne art h,.;na Th eor y; Ihr \\f echamcs v.i ( ar"vt E secutn e Direct..r. Fuuon Enerr..s I oundmon

.%;'onwred hv l K 1 abor Party C:ub. and b rudents Ior The 1ds ancement qf I wian Enero : jbr more infor.=:: ion e.:.I

(:0:) Lt 7.I'!% 19)J j In \\ ? % (?),t::,.n f

A"CHEISHCP CARRCLL HIGH SCHCCL 4,,,. n

,s c.-

H,.., u,,n n n,,00 st u w

WASHINGTCN D.C. 20017 We are students from Carroll High School here to crotest before the Congress the increas ing development of nuclear energ,. in the United States and around the globe.

Some si:. eecks ago we began to study the f acts of nuclear pcwer and have new unanimously cencluded that it auct be abandened as a source of energy for our nation.

Contrary to public beliefs, it is ne: Lae r clean, no r saf e, nor cheap.

It is deadly as poses the greatest possible threat to ct

'uture ana the future al cur children.

C nsider tS follcuing facts-

\\ single nuclear power plant produces tons of plutonium as a by product.

An invisible 1*-

. article weighing less than one-millicnth of one gram can cause cancer or lukemia.

2.

assive aucunts of radioactive wastes are being p roaecca cach tear oy every nuclear power plant.

Much of the waste remains radioactive far thousands of years.

Neither the gove r--men t nor the utilities have come up vith a solution concerning the storage cf these wastes, and many scientists argue that there is no safe solution.

,, np s,c.i r e, o r.,.cnta-t.a x.

'uc, car power plant meing oun,t t xay (suc.n as in s c a u r c o s., :. e t 3.

,a gue, Massachusetts) costs over $2 cillier.

'.fter 30 years of use, su a a plant cust be abandoned due to t'c.e high le cel o f radioact i. ity.

The problea of w to discantle such plants is yet unsolved.

4.

Certain types of plutonica produced as by-products of newer plants can be made into atacic Scabs.

3.

The Unica of Concerned Scientists, a group of s =e 2,CCO biologists, chemists and banded t a 3the r a.;ainst nu le:r pocer.

engineers haD u 6.

There are alternatives.

Hydro-electri p.. e r, s ecti.e use of coal anu oil, <eind,

a-ther al, f usion, water, and particularly calar cr q ies can and must be neveloped i-' u v, projects tha; a a u.; e sciar power cell now.

The renowned scientist, Issac built in the desert of the /c erican Gest could more than meet the country's needs.

These are facts.

We are not dealing with a questien of pollutian, but with the fact of deado radioactivity.

'.se canno t afford to take the rise;s involvea.

In a let ter which we nave sent to President Carter, we stated :1e folicwing :

In cca Cu5ica, tec 'wald a5!: you tf nudcatf.caat L5 tac.CCy ;ccith Lt?

IS t!:2 quast fc1 yte flt, pc; eat, and lb Ltiz55 censu mtica ca ancigy ;ec Ch ganztations af cwicet, lu.bania, and Ccd only unas tchat cthat 'c t~ 5 e f 'adiatian-inchecd iLinc55e5? Ve u.

cten cht2dian, a.5 teale c5 <s6tc, et?2 ce patt c f the s tatistic.5 Rnen the C25aastl25 of udlatlen pcL5c.tOtg ata 15-5e5cd.

De tec havc ihc ilsht to fc. zut contaninate the gicbe?

Pcopic of tan say, 'I dcn't ;eant my kids to sit a:cund bt the ccid t:ezaty ye115 f tam ac;c '

Eat.the c clt 'tt:Cica e f na:Le=t pc; eat nalscs the me.tc het.ttant ques ticn o f ;chota 'i thata all2 Ec anycnc aCLva ucan ty y atis f e m ac;e.

We thank you for taking the tir.e to consider cur case.

If :<cu would like further infor-nation en this issue, contact one of the groups listec below.

Union of Concerned Scientist Public Interest Research Group 1:03 Massachusetts avenue P.O.

20:: 19312 Canb rid :;e, Mass.

02133 ashingt;n, DC 20036

\\\\8 1n1 0

\\p

,..g.=.

a.g

[

d a

Ier NM O<'

%I a

p# 4.

b" 5

.\\

h

.D8

.V.Yb

=h

• T7 t'W C ti TJ

=CO

- %{ E,[a^

'i TC

\\t U.LILP 16 h

v

_., ~ -

U~ NETHER D F.C % h O LB. h11 s R,,1 s.

3.Tr7 T

.1 4 v 2t a n

s

?, d;U, " r ' ! 5

@' )'

.:.;w) j~u.u

=

a

.; L A

e.c.

B 7O:);n;m;1

ya a

u v-.

4, a L

r s, p ;1,.q

.3

,a u_

m

/

2j. the pubu,.c lcnew wnat m.,e facts :are, ana, if they had to choose between nuclear reactors and candles, they would choose candles,,

Ralph Nader 118 182 a

g

'-hsh 0

W 1E r%'CD_.wk r' a i

q fg v

, v-m n[F n

i. :f s,.

7 p e Lu n:,

s v u ey.

v R'F'M C*D i ny Q 1 WuLL,b UL LE e

m n

e i-A r

py v ts f, s

\\ \\ f f \\\\}\\ 'u\\

.l i

. bHUT ALL R5;;cToRS 6.-

i pp

\\.,,g x/' y <J) smv nssnemass a N

j

/, EvacuaTres Resea,asats r!O4 X j' /

.l. Mc.uTom vM cN ALL

\\

\\

m3 M/

Nu: J~

928C3 f

WITH US 3 cute.: LAFAYsm ?X.(iGo K ) To V,,,b. G:JTOL.D. P.BQ i

VW NGCL A.R P.EO. COMMISSiCN...W5ST!NGHOUSC, BA SCC CX :. WILCd;(, G.E., ATcMC IN DUS mi A L FO R0nt ED)SOM E!ECT?!C !.%T. s. c?Ros e ebr.NUCLL;R PMTER

]NFO:?rc'!vit!.:{"g.58F'5 ViG!L tc i;lHiB Ha. usa. mit 4 3 118 osgum

,,,, m j.

___.m w.

2

. = P @=.

N7q.R g.g ? -M.~y - /

M

-C

,h ty 9, J. A,c.,

' i,1 r b.w-.*j 5.4 t.w

.L'

• a i-

-l-

, c= -

J.. '

6-t t

1 t. y,".

• n/."s _ m l%;f-d...

3 ua s.

.,s m

O. ore are currently 1,500 nuclear fcc-her2 ar2 m:ne curreat:ly un"c r cr.s trw ilitie s in exis tence in the Un'*cd States.

tien.

-"* are n? - plannel for tb i-.e11 ate f.:u rr The U.S.

g :ve rn.e HN A '.UC'.2AR P T W O s et a tar;;e t L.te tea years in.

'.ture '7r the *:rst per anent site.

Ve ry si: ply, a nuciar pcwer riant i Evan his s1* ' h as a n been confir e '.

N.h lika 2,2ny c:he r elect ri:1 :v-p ne r at in '

"- ;. in; ire -lag.43 sith centra.src

acilities.

'Jare r is haated into ste, in i ran criti:=

?'

ting cat that the s t a as i s u s e d tc, t a m a tu r'e ine which p r a prN

-. sil. n t be able t-dutes electricit The diffe enc' is-

d

. *

• mterial safciv-- u radicact*

core is used t e ra 14F

-"o

. c erf.

a in a nuclear facility.

t2 0)rarv st: 1:' fe' lit',

• hr qh^ n the cov ery.

In :b Washintren, D.C.

'Ci a ? ?L\\S* W ETV 4 tea, t

' r :'

.% 9 a n.d ea r - a pl i had to a2 far N rri.s!;- t o c:g r.7 d it -

Because the heating el m n: of a n;:.ccr nsta s a r:= > ficil *fes :niv two m.

pl.at is a vaa:ile panen, t.re are m n s '. t.

.mn. -

p-rat'cn.

Ot er w:(-

p rchle ms witn nu. lear pwer :'

co et arv s:cr q

.es s a

,4 th se in E rr-exist with o*her types of p:wr p. ants.

O rd,. m ia

- 2n j i c.

c

~ ;.e radioactivite mus: be contain d

i;w-lea in^

• nr 1.; c

nte t, 1-n ever, radioactiv> corea cr.nnat be t,ta!.

J>

-.. : -i f n

.a-d I weer.

Fa!-

. hut '.-

A : cal pl at can - :,.

,-.: =

$c r.

r, c

t i t.:.,; au: :ne...

t

.. -,;an cn

-n*

~.

zcc.:

~

a the c:her na,d, alway

.m p

n z; h

'n.

F i t,1 -.* i-ff er 3

c c ] l i n g s y s t e r.-- e v e n,..- c b --' e i -

can ">

],

• '.~2

=r hr in

't

_re.

re, t.u : r

.2

.a.

c

' e l t d r.-."

cr 1.

c :: ntial t2 thrai a'

- tainment tru:t n,

A

-J-

'. wll re e,s e in u P S a

N1 p-n:

,lich cacid resul-in tne d :it. n'.s a Wi-in ro :

!q r 9nce yn

-s, M prsans and 3'.i.

. - - r r. m -r m

t a 'i a t*

z p (.R :I c Z..e rc

m.

t.,c).

~":ri

- m C.e

'- br:e cv Cere c:al.rn W,- ( ^ C- ),

hi,.

1 -

.;~'

Thi nr m:

2 'avice pr en-3

. an.

!.a c,

. O far f ail

't,

- c c" -

e i

a seni-A' L fire. n t h,-

tra. -- -,.

r: :n '.. t c. - r i :r in.M a a

.a nu d:e 7%i.

o:

-il "a

at

-. r,:

s, cL s.na over

'2, m-ages and r e-.1 iver:.,,..-

n ia'.

nania.;c;. _

n e i t i..r.. Th ECG did not functi:n r-17 :... t ic s hac n..

sec<ec called upcn.

Icws ? > -- i inn trin v crt n.,,

. a e r12. 3 thrw n their tound :ica, a:.d - -

g,,,.,

y 2

tes are pm ir - similar.,131'ti^n

,e,. s..

v., -

u T"'~

- -\\

3 i5

.q' ['

',- f g 5

Q j.g [

Cc

.n:f

.n-h c-

-m,

'.'M ) 1,}.

is the

.: 1 '. - t i, Of. - rirm.

With

', f

.1.9 r u n.

.a ra!si:ti.

-2*eri_l,

[ if

~f trece 1;

'n increas - cN v,

c-th

.,*%jg' : ~.,

. tre;

-.5

.; p an ; c f p a -- 12 p;

-s;, -a.h ratarial rc;ila' at a hardsar_ st :>

fT c '

~

cn :m

? sni to c:nstruct 1

• 15,

prevent. --. - socle r terra-ist t -

1, 13diticn to electricit enther far n rce is ' to se are.'vil libert

.y-pradact of nuc;*ar p:wer is rad : active r.utri *:c s w iIr

.M.aut

.., t. u zau,,ons et.

5

a. ve.

-r4 a

3 p,,,

,,,. 4 A

-~ rcial was*, have tee-pr; 2

v.ar w

l %s f

.n 'he P S.

Scne 235 illica gl.1 ars s A,_

a 3

p r'.ic ced by 1 10

!hir waste'inc.m 'e s 237

) Q 04

. t r m t i t.2.- 9 0, c e s i u=- 12 7, an! pi m -.,- m,

/ t'm j(1,.r) 4-II? q n,

'ik $, f ^I]/

4

manf cthe rs al. 5

rhl,

n c c u cos.

- k 1* in estinate-1 : hat at car - - -- n r li'i ed N---

- -- 4 --. e J r i t.> c.' p.., d 2.- - i n,

• ye-

.,'. t.

s,-^,0 j # ~\\, " 4 - ' ^M.'*.,.

~'

I#

f e... % )

ns.. P la t e.;n i v:- 2.

alae by *he par g,

) N (

J-. S.a* y */g.

This p o u cn wi..

enain ra.:ict*"e i ', n./

kI ~* 'u-s iI dar?ercus ', - c v e r, " J, ' ?.)

far; v

,) / $

Q) 3 e

far, *her' is no saye way t; 4, c s

+

• ,'. C

...n-1

waste, t,

i

, (#

3r e

. ',(,

- " r an t sis.

J.

sal fa. 1.t

/

7 J

e, YW.

.3 1

u f

A b;. ~. %

...-n.-

/

.m n

1=

...;. c2 m

3,:,.

,e y a, u

,, P

.r

~~.,' :'2'~~'\\, y, a

i uns W

mwuma,.Gd 4

A

.--; r

e..n.

e. r.. s,

' ia. I m,-

y t.-

r

-. ~-

v-:

One or the ::; ore disheartenin; c: cerns N a :lt T- - wr is a Gvett.en.

sussidi

th nuticar

,c.

- la : hat it is

..ec'n-In!

trv

-.~.

ral sn e *m n t pr -

??tcal It is overl expens ce.

Already vides a ne'ded :

e SS, feel eari F~e-:

at e

resi de n

• s o f 'li rrin i. hav ex:1-s.-

.wt

!c - c J an te f ulli:

4 at 13'. utility rate inercase because or is

'=in-ccnd-cte j at.ne rren t exrensa au :le a r p 7 e r To unders tand t his p; en; -

n-re aLPer incid. cal cas;3 are bei:q certain aspects of the n / l e a r a-'. 3 c. ! i m ill ' hv the p. c r r.o t ircludi u.d n t ry m u t be stadied.

Firc:, thera p 12 " 4ecurity, t ransporta tica secur;:

a: the r in i u.7 m ani Fiv

me-

- crc es3

, r. i aj.~.-.41 de elc p >n:

es.:entral Sa' af the ranet.

.ec;nd, F ue cast, are not paid ; r. eur mat,1y

. er' are the in a f ac t u r: n.; r ? v11e

• 1:

bills, but tru@

• e 9rd at t re are only four, with

.*re cal Elec t ri:

2tc t c.a:e s.

and 'destinghcuse 32:ng th cp t co.

Fin-ather ig riant biddea : cst is plv.-

cli the r

• are the utilities.

T"ey are f. Tmi<. 1071 r.

r.nle ar p wer plan t s

'. t a t e-regula te d r: ep o lics The s t ne will last ;nly far*

years. After th,t 1:

tai littic powe r to tell a < tility ca.m-will %

• hi;;51y rad 1; active, an d mu s t H pi

. hat it

_an

,a in :. a r., a., pc d;,

' ' *:.e

.>to 4.,

uv.

r. :

tructirn; ae. :1te 's po% r

• w >

yrt been ta?ulated, but :ne facility in 1-st saleDy in eter-taine if :e a:1 -

"innesot, was decr issic N i at the cc;t are re c e i c..;; i fair prcfit <a re;-

cf.

n i. 4.

n ecliar, I t..

<, to b.ilj

.r ve s tnent Th..

i:. usual d r.e by app. -

th pli. %u 3 riillier dallar; a rata m rc : e rn

> an

-,y ir ve N -e 4 : als,

• p-Nati31. t in c,

-'t.

mm inve-ted, rre c-=

--3 ar, i t

anc. ;--- r i a d_

in pre! :

.ir: i ca w r. s t !. e ate 2.<-

- : inser' ~.I ar ?? i s far at A nts

se' plant, the me re pr nit h*'

is 2 2,

tre >

.te-b a an m:

a 2.'.e n

m - - 2n s oe : t3

• t i

.h s

!!r:

em e

a'l...

s -' iSE u rn. Ar i r. w i ir -ne r ei n t.

,r ni..ica a Mest all pn!by the r; e rn t

ms se t,

k ; i '. 3

• n any c:her vpe -

,,r o'

't..,.*'

S.

s

' r 12.. ' ' ' - -.

".7'.

w N. "' 9 ss g

e eA 3

r?CliCNJ..

r3

ne 2 4,,.

• t

. IJr is in ' cl CCep:3J1e GO ic1.

I

• d i. a

! r p r% t r

") 1 ('. :

~.

A i, 2 re.

t-

., r '

-'1 C - l'J e, * '.

v*

2" pr's_.Ns.

. ; r ul in s aa t r,. he c; o t rt r..

3f b; m li tali c.acerna e *-

W2 are

• [jn s 3 ',

+-

t[T e

~d

+

,1 an; s

,,-p se i

4: -

f i'

• 1-.'

- wer n! ant r3.

i.i. ~; e

• cr!

n,

• Sac it is t !.-

- i a r:

a:er r ri -,

..are p rm.i n.w.ar ne m _s.tr ind st s 11.

't

,i te 4..

c:s a!! cver : _

.a.

r..

.)

-~L

tr

- ~-

in

• h* At*^*

ar a, r a t 2 -'a 0 Ai!l9-is

-n c : r.e l...'

13.21 p r:11 fe r at i nuclear - er :lant naice c: cern 2 Clear p W r *1aIt3

• s '. e a e e -:, 3 r;

--2_

.siliance is -he

- :,.t.n, p l c... :

t al

.h mu.. v -e - a N i~3t>

ai 7'

..e: south of e.

..zt.:n, 3.0.

te j.b s

.t r e s a a r il., t 1 a: _

in auiaa 1 -*

' i r.;in i 2 5 15 plant i

I

- J ?w t ds tN

-i l r. e s t t. :n i ajar tlq1 cal fault a. -i ce a

s.1 7'.10le a r p :% e r % ! 11 ';

50 b

') m..

173 M the 120i' ty is s i

.e. i n.;.nto 5

"J. l.1 s d t e r s e l.'

' t *h? r e "~.1 :

'r C! th.

g r Un i C a

• 2 [n f ' an ge r.i cf a

, pe

,I, t inf a 7y n L "f i,

eT

-  : ~ JCd C ' r4 "'e [

t

.e 3 2"I j 5e*.

25.

! ' i, ". nA

.s r D 1 s

• "TD.T.enr3 ten po;.1:

r, u t hw Pant

- 2 will create, ir *2411ty n:h plan:

c' Wl, M,'.'

'"p._*

..s tC, y v,

% y ** t.,,1a A

+

e

.11ed perscns.

(,lecte cut n! mil :a Pot: u- -lii m,

".0.

Ecx 7 ~; %, D. C. 204 3)

I % w il.ib

re infcrma:

5 a

1.

.. m ce and/cr nuclest powr

_, I -.id like :c Le on our nailing 1.s-Y {

. *. a A..

%..(*.

rc v

,npup,J

(

5

..),

__..f

{J q

i

.t

+.

(

(

te help in :--a

f. c..

n;11n

- ;e t-

..r

1. ) I.

e =

• P' b5 k

=.=w

_.4

.'%9.

w

.mm

• --'***E'-"---4.eee-

--m----gi.------ee.eee-e.--

e-----we--6---

.Be4-*4e'---)+

k*$e -* bd*-*.'"

.