ML19220A312

Exceptions to Initial Decision Rendered by ASLB on 770405 & 770610.Certificate of Svc Encl

ML19220A312
Person / Time
Site:	Crane
Issue date:	01/08/1978
From:	Jarboe C JARBOE, C.J.
To:
References
NUDOCS 7904170395
Download: ML19220A312 (7)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:. C.UIL J. J:'."20E 2 > g g D E.,.._ n -'. 0 5 !. f._ .Wehnnh'sberg. l'a. Zip 17 0.a.> s In the retter of ) ) .v _ ! i.. ;.I; M ;; I. 3 0 *:.. I ) .I c :;T </.L ; ;. 3 & IIGd~ 0 :. ~;T ) occket *o. 3c-3:.0 and ) i.":C ! *.V .i l, _ L. " T'- I 'T ) ~~ ) ile Island Muclear tation. ) (Three d Onit .io. 2) ) January 3, 1973

. 0_1TI;;L.

to INITI/.L D;0IJION i - Chairman Lutom stated u.au. ',gt.c'.cally tha t the evidence and views presented by limited appearors will play a'solutely no part in the decision rendered by the Atomic S a f e t y ;. Lic e ns ing 3a ard. 1-4pril 5, 1977, tr 165 2-June 10, 1977, tr 2756 3-June 10, 1977, tr 2757 This view of the Commission's responsibility is inconsisten t wita the.intional 3rironmental solicy Act(37J4) of 1969 and is therefore illegal. The 32.J A of 1969 re;uires the Co==1maion to evaluate all the consequences of the proposed licensing action sad of alternatives to the licanalng ac tion, regardless of.ho the party raisin;g suggestions for consideration by the Comal.msion ha;, pens to be. H - Chairman intoa repostedly states or implied that advance notice to the Conalsai..a is retaired to present a limited ap,earance. 1-April 5, 1977, tr 183(llae 19,20) 2-Jane 10, 1977, tr 2665(lines 3 L 4) 3-June 10, 1977, tr 7.665(line 7) ine notice of the licensisg hearinga is the local newspa per sta ted that elso. ~ The ::venine News, asunesday, *.src h 50, 1977, p. 61 Thia la en added on, arbitrary condition placed on limited ap;earances and is not sup;orted by 10 073 coetion 2.715a. n-e. 0. O*.~ .e* f b 7 9 0 417 039E

O ~ pa<e = ))],- Th e gr an t136 o f us o;*rsting licenne to Unit 2 o f

• hrs e Mile Island la unconstitutional.

There is no private insurance available far protection against nuclear rmliatien. *c t:e facence of any isourence coverage realistically related to potential cost for a nuclear accident, th e dranting of this license is a violation of tse equal protec tion ;ravisiwn that is incladed within the Jue process clause o f tne Tifth saentment. It places the coat of the benefit to all of SIU's customers on an arbitrarily chosen segment of society, we here in the sarriseurs area. 17- 'he Atoale "afsty & Lic ensing 3 card, a branch of the NFC, sitting as judge and jury in this proceedir.g. and 4cother brsach of the same organiza tien, the :..d staff. ;articipating as an advocate for dranting of the license is an innerent conflict of interest and renders the whole proceeding ludicrous. This is la conflict with the separation of prciotion of nuclesr pcwor and protection of we the citize ns from the environmental effects of nuclear power as mandated by the act of Congress in 1974 establianisg LT.]A and the 53C. V,- <a a citizen living within 15 air miles of Unit 2 of TNI, who will be affected greatly by the environmental consequences of daily operation and asy accident at yMI 2 I As outraged that the Ioana. Cept. of arironmental Pescurces and the U.'. .iuclese Regulatory Commission "taff, who should be asaisg hard questions to protect my health and welfare, analogous to

• hose of the Intervonors, are participating in the proceeding as advocates for granting o f this lic e ns e.

This is in direct conflict to the statutes of the Otate o f k e nna. and the "nited Jtates whieb created these agencies and sanda ted that they provide for our environmental protection. It is also a violation o f the 31. A of 1969. VI-The 3hc ".taf f's reliance on the Rasmussen Reactor Cafety 5tudy as objective, a meanindful estimate of probable risks associsted witn the operation of present day light-water nuclear Tower p1sats, and methodology receiving a brosd and incremaisg endorsement by the informed scientific ceaannity is completely contradicted by fact and there fore umwarranted. va the contrary, such evidence has surfaced showing the study to be heavily biased, the results meaningless, the me thodology " leading to silliness **, ans increasing criticias by the informed scientific community. Y!!- There is no regulatory requirement to notify the gener el public of: 1-allowable esployee doses of radiation at auclear plants, reproceseing plants, etc. 2-incressed genetic risk to of fspring of plant enployees f-reports o f past f==t ly and social disruptions due to contamisation of an employee at a plant A= increased genetic rima to persons and of f a; ring by marriage to a plant employee This lack o f re rila tory re,uirament to inform the gener=1 puolle of tais very serious environmental impact o' nuclear power plants is a groms violatiac of the M.} A of 1969. t"3 },~ .3

O 9 ~ f- <, 5 7!!!- There is currantly no per-snent method far the at: rage of nacisar w.ntes. Th a elitiniti:n er the reprocessing option by excestive arter of the t re..i ie nt and the uneconomica of reprocesning in the priv,te ae: tor has rende. ed vald nuch of the 'r0 taf f's projecti'.ns regarding nuclest wastos fras T"! 2. This sease that e,ent fuel vill be left at TMI 2, compacted, and year by year pose an increamlag hasard to the health and safety of employees of TMI 2 and citizens of the Marriseur area. Nia is in violation o f the.m o f 1%9. r. n; et.. - p ;- - -- a p - I hereby certify that copies of the isrescis _zeentions to Initisl OectrianP. in the matter o f M !"0;; LIT.5 7.;IJ1N 0; a .MT, et. sl.(Three il e Island Maclear lenerating,tation Unit 2), Ooctet ;1o. 50-320, datad January 3, 1978, have been served upon each of the persens listed on the following service list, by siil, ,c o s t a g e prepaid, this 9th day of January,1973. O / 4 n Carl J. Jercae .t'7:r_ L:: - 1 ~r. Chauncy P. f e; ford 6-Snatave A. Linenberger 2-larin m. Carter, la q. 7 Lt. srnest C. Calo }- Erneat L. E1.k e, Esq. 3-flan s. r.ceenthai, .sq. k-Henry J. WeGurren, sa q. 9- ;ocketing & ;ervico Zection Jrecory n. Tesa, sq. 1G-Jirector ot'..uclear.<eactor hegulatic.- 5 sdwrrd *nton, Es q. a e J. 6 a

eD e h0+ 7 tl;,p(kiilip i1/2 t, ka/03dd$h ( I 6?.'7..?l 9

r-t. ,2 c. a-E.t r:- i-c 6 . e i s. _I_ .p.;t- - -m . c i m. x i< m ~- y-E I. a, t : s,,. c : ...s-6 _e 2 r, -, :. a.- .j g , cn c 6. s 2 2 >-es..e s s .2 - i e, e- =- - ; - J - s _t _ e_

se 6 -

t-4 a c. s e: 1 :m: e rg ; 1,: e>r _ e r-6e-s 2 -:s =, 4: *. e: - 7, 2 ^: e t *2 - =.,: e r,,-+- "w n n V, a -1 c_.. - 2 e 6 -9t =,E_ s 9 ;- 3, : e r, as c; = =. e ,=s , r. :' 2 s

6 t

e-s: < - -2 2-- .. :- s 5. :. -a, s- . s. g w r = e,cse s - - s - c <.s s, ~un c = a_ r m 6. < g _y. _i s. ae- ,5 ~ e<- a e_s s .. e s. c.- =

s. E e,

- e. s _s - x e s =- s 2 v 5 e -5 S, -,- - -e s.- : 2 s- > c =,> ,c w- . 2 _*- -- c- , > _s e.- 2-5 r E ..:: 7 4s -'l c*- 3 :: st -s 16 > 52 i27 2732 F: > 8 Ja E _ 3 2, g '8 g -J

i e

. 6 s a 1-i:s i s ?.: .i _m s..' >: i $ss = 6 o. ,x .s os ,o _r.- ; t _- r e .6 c-s.

. - 2,-

t.5 5 e e r r5 -r -7 -x6 >2 -.- - - r..

q

. cy?. 5-s ri is 3 -7 T -,. s. -- t: - - $ s-c ;- ..-~; e s - : - Ee.c .a g v s: e-3: 1 - ,t -c=sc, s, ex--c <,. e -c 2 <c e; - = - =

sa.

5 .t % = _1 =. : e s. .. s, -s 6 s c s: e . s, s .,s e ss 2 e. -e r - e,9 s s s-a s 6 r e i s e ; =.. o ~ < - .-=a. a c - g c -- g s A - ~ c -- 3 .s t 3 (g - - -: < 6 Y-u!g=-t-s-x -a- , e ~: _ e:, - s . =. 22 6 g: : c cL. _s -e ,- aw_,=e e e c: e>, s-u 6 e 2._-. : ; - c s _ s r s-r- ~ 2 5 3,: e s,t 7 !. ? ? # 7c O IEEli: sh 3 I3 E _s-E,i sE-c._.-: r, s,- c n s.- e e t a e r , s-5 : - ,9 5 . _= ce - 5: - = >c.ce5 c s j _f 3 <c g -{. c: -e s,. r ; e G-s-e i<g s e, >s - - 5 6-2

- - JIp

• r w,
• t[

7 ; s E e.. - tse - Ci s 9 - O r .o =v t. e

• , e

-;. y w- : s -s a i, s <,t c. e> - 9., 5, < - t:: s:- c 3. te < 6 s e s _5 w es 6 =. c, i - s - E e <C 2 e: og -

s s ::

r - s, ,1 s -.s -r

c. -

9, - e ..-.- - ~,- - 2- - 5 s -2 ,e e

- :. - x:

-e >.6 r

,C> ; r t,,.,.

- r - t

• x. ;" - < -:.

.gc;tC s

s_. e ,.1 T.;---. > > g m e w. 2-T s i - s e ; 3- - es e s.- er sr: c e s, s, 6. 2 s s -, +. -=s. -e$

gegg.

,s ri ra c.<e: ga 2

- s, <

2 e. 6 - e;. - < - - 6. e, e,i s. w-:- .c 6 s- - e,<s s c.s ou : s - - sL -

• s-,.

-- - c.. - e. _- t., -.u.,x. - , _<, c - - -- s 5 - t x c 5.. 1, vsO';$s?_ E e t ~ s

TziE - E L. 2 t

.7. ' - C c T E.t 'i -

• A

Jas, are ree:::

s e..e e c s e- _e $r v -C' - = -210: j6 ...-. cc 6C C s r ;c _. s, s -e5-s ;; - <- 7 t9 [s -t

Et :--

/ 6: e .? < ? a n E 3 :% -w-4 s. ; ", r 5.[ h i 3 . ey u s e _u s = 6, e

• .: :. - - r r-

,t s-- v4 e, _- s E _6 >

k. _

s. -,c 3 i $ } eSS- - L = * * - v. E E L f 'C - e c EJ4 3 - J E EC < [ L $ g C e<< g - c J E, := _ s E E e, Lt*5E t c> O a. e - t r

-El C s

f..t s;EEtr-6 V C i

fe i

22 e

, >c.- w -r st s -g:: - xv sr s s v - 4 6 c : R <2 8N r-- t- - e5-,& o. - - s t : m v7

e

"?wC .5

• 17 Z e

- f5 ->v 7 a- [- c v (- 6 c

c. :<,

'L - dr. C -3 6 6 : s 6

• L s

4* cs : - l ? t t. e e s, - u, q<3 c.. y n-5. - - C - :-- [ s..., Ja,E Zs-r ~ 4*:-- ci 5.: r -- < 3 .>_- - 3e s c : - - O. -, s - ; ir s c ;t r-c g " :: c gr<-c e- - s 5 - : r+ -er 6 s- $5/T EE - i l 5rIf - / lt I shN' ?YE $ $, 2b h53 2 :- t

: - +

. s: ee

- : : 4>

c5?852: 5? -: $12: s: E-Es -E t ~f g - t : C C *-*te e tv< >c eS-7c : : i C-r. O' -.E e t ::: r ba l_i 5-c.g..- 6 cs. 4 las 1j - Of.- e .s - s r s .c a o-s >r.e .r r gg - c S s s.: t-wa. e -@ r y- ,vh.t -s= e C -: : y - s * -.: ' t .- - s ,7[ C

• ET*

7* -N-g- g r 4. c : -e_ .s -m;--" -{

r.,--*

t

< a s I 7 A I G, CS3 t -C;. g P - ' 6 e. - c2 .L-g- rsbec- - s J CV . { s * -s L -AJ re a : 61 e5-

• -gT:(ti _i{EE

-,g. c

• n --

J <t-s s s Ete.<; s 5. ;. <c[ s 6 v e7 w m -- -..r s - 6 s rg w ss-. _- w n

t e-J'( .) A u s[ s u n. p] s o s-a 3 l a s d t ep j u e ey pn u e s u s mse pos u g o u u o tu4 ad sos s g s a t q es u s s' ja p u g my s t. s s a e a _ g u y i. a A i u e a. p" ) k gJ u = A s u o3

s. 3 s

g a4 sog s 39 q etg e ts se t e u egg n s i e o sug y p o' jgua s g . d q o e o nn a j u g p e.g s sg n. g g m q s o n' gmso o u oee g u .i s s i o A min e p i s iu a s

gp.

so t gg s a g pp us ) ge3g,u m l u v g o o s 4q.a n 4g .,u m' t q u b t e u e q g m s>

s. g a

pg l q u eg a 6' t v s a .s. o n ipgp.n e ) u. =i a s p is ., u p y= 3 s g a u .9. a pa s iqysi s m g. w o n o =.. t n g e pg u. l. ~ e 4 i

• p e

,t s goiup-oi 4 yn pq gg _ p .a o g ) 3 s ep,p s a3 u

1. ,g q

w .e s jg g,. 3 q. s goo 4 ed tp1 p ag sp d e i u t i u.n w s u o s' p s uqp p1 q u u. u.>g vg s up p eq t o s gas u o oo u s pce a s o e p i q e. u p )s b m t.,9 4 u p: yupu a p d p,d8 ue q3 a e 0n a) gnseO n , y>* u a o; u s u o u3 t i n ,4 m m. u i v t 3 d. n s ,u4 u u s u ) u )o su% s q s gg sp q u ug i sj o s e u a p ug sp og n l c e p p u ug a s p s x . uq nin qat h q a a os* s n p u s 'a s e p s 7 (g e u Hun s i sp u e g ta o gpg> 3 i s 3 i qu s q 1 q s s s a s. f u p# n ). 6-s" p s suJ a u u4 s e bn u r n 4 g es,u t A u i ss s g asy0 o. 2 3 s ig g i o e sg p p 9 ns i i .s ) s i watq [u a' .oq s e a a s q t ou. ig guh i b l p 3 g ey m u i ol l sa v pps ug us 0 jg t, O

s. so

" a o g.iw# 7 (s m g 1 u.o

1. y o u u n.

o s. i s p l' ) A = 'pp

s. gu#

o p 1 oq p s dt og ps 9 n 5 s p

t. bs u on

,. y ps 9, p6 s t J, e y a 3 p o) s u u u 5 ,s p 2 t 3 s ) uA p u1 pg i s ]q, . eus 3.p u t g ag u1 a sg Ay o g o g p ap o , a o p s u i g u a o p, . upu p u, 3 gsq q g p s s s, d p g'S' i sog. J o o s ,* n ie a o r i, =C p n i ip ts a t

q sA p

o m g a s d' p,)e -u y( a a a 4 1 q e a o A gu%p oq p g 3 i ong b. a t*os o u s utip u, ) ^ t

• gs n

. >9 l a A a s us a o g, s 3 .y g s a s s n, i q ' ag

s. sp i

u W' o ' iso.-, sg u 6 0 i t i p meg anrg upg g m l'gp i . s s se t u. t4 s n s a asp yg s

• kp,

uarg s q . n p s d n s o u o s a uj e u e 1 a s 4,s o .t 4 e m s'n u.

• o e.

i mA S i o. q

s o.

s p p 1 .agsy ,u su A' - up pas

1. ,Au,

g' s u t' Ap s.i d' A s so s eggo .A 0oy g u i a k H dq. mp1 . s)

s. ' A,

g A a q q. q. J s ,u u) t A s o s o' og n > p. u s ma go 1, e u nD l nat a q

o. q g 4

s , u g a p q i s 9 o n s s. g,. q ) a a. V a g

• u m

i J s q o n 4' a' q H' s ei. q g i p' gg gq' o >pd g q1 s a y s s i t a h s n e s A i p u. n,

s..u g p su egg s

i p,o p u s,m U d i d ,. uo g a a. p u i o sp o s o u s i u,. i n e n. t, q us wA h3 e,g go o m y a ,3pgp )O q o sg g sq u t n e,. y i y. p,, u o, pp u d' e nq n 0 s. u 4 euJ A %. !-p o s t e d e ' p g' s sp g u+gt o s ga a qq u is u" J u' se t o, g ) s u i p :s g s u g u e s. O

• pyq tAgg q A s p' 4 g

g gnw mae s e s s bq u4 u 1 a t s o 0 p u , a i s' mg 1 p s e. ,a o o 3 o s .a 3

pp

1. yp u0g oa uy g ]g o) i u]p lp j uq Ap ba s

) a t ) s mpl ! n) guy yW ~d g I

b. $

h w=I O

Carl J. Jarboo, Ph.D. [,6Ii77, c Oroanic Cliemist .[( j f;! 'gjg y3 lJ,.((f;l em }M& 9 East Morbio St. t Mochanicsburg, Pa. i.,, t, / <- lin ('(Jl-)pr a, J 5, Jm,,ci n ..r i 17055 - t y' I (' Director of !!uclear Heactor Regulation liuclear lley,ul.a tory Comul ation 'fashington, D.C. 2',555 9 .s .3 i:1Q}}