ML19220A242

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
For Comment Issue of Reg Guide 1.144, Auditing of QA Programs for Nuclear Power Plants
ML19220A242
Person / Time
Issue date: 01/31/1979
From:
NRC OFFICE OF STANDARDS DEVELOPMENT
To:
Shared Package
ML19220A243 List:
References
REGGD-01.144, REGGD-1.144, NUDOCS 7903070079
Download: ML19220A242 (3)
v • d • e


Text

  1. N U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION January 1979 I

%w REGULATORY GUIDE

/

l.

~

OFFICE OF STANDARD? DEVELOPMENT

  • m*

REGULATORY GUIDE L144 AUDITING OF QUALITY ASSURANCE PROGRAMS FOR NUCLEAR POWER PLANTS 7

A.

hlTRODUCTION

!!.urem"ni Pha, N uc!ea r P w.

Pimt' ld i Riy 2 ;. 1971 u;rav H"m,

' < m

.IJ Appt ndix 11 " C. 4 du' A s s u ra n a ( 'rit m i i f< r

..! KiSH laU, %ihna :n y u hty A n u r-Nuclear P"wer 1'! m t, md 1 ucl Rep; in g a r.

R eq uirmen P Du rity the il nst ruct t 'n Plan t s to 10 ( lit Part :4 "IL

, st v Pt t Nu&ar Pow"r I'lant s J.ned N n lii.

1.ieen sing of Pn niuc ti,n and Utuvat:

Fad-1 *il

(; +enBk. Dvm n 6 )

utan, in d' t i i t a ",

establishes.wrall quabty assur m r-H+

n 1,

. t prvp a stand u ! N b __12 quirer ents fo r the d" sign. <,'nstra t.

n ml ti, 1,r 22, 1 %4). whn h & u

'l to the c pe ra t inn vf

,af e t y - r elated structur+

W'

  • aff the rca:udi n i a;.;.

'di fr t em s, and < mpi nent s ' f nudcar p.

lant-n o ' ccthn y r

N

.m.i i per iti m

!n e n es t

Criteri. n XVIll. ' A u. hts f Appen a 11 AN w!. A:NE N-15 2. !;- h77 rt t !

t J, vet p at ID (TR Part 7,0 nt.d hsh, r"que nt ; '. r f r. a the pr p-of "rs o n iuln! in th.

.o

.,nductmg audit s i.f t he quaht, a'

.2 r.i n pr -

d. Ve WA Sil d cua. nit gram This guide de' ribe, a me t h. i a.

cpt-able t h" Nlt(' s t af f f< >r aplyin z w i' n the Aft"r Wmn !

tb rt m'it uW C< mnus +n's regul tti w it h reg ird t.-

au.ht-issyd

f. i: w n the puth nt p.r:,l.

me of qu ihty ass;rinc pr. gnm3 f r n:

ar

\\NS M.1 N ;, 2 12-l % 7 u dl, Il n e N;,_ 12 p%er ;lant s (Draf t H'i,n 1) at un.i m U NH.,,

n! '.ASHi.'a,n th-

+ nduati

'. f pr F

,d B.

DISCUS'ilON auur ' < ;

n!are-f*

t h" a; p h.m t 's qu iht y

< id J m n.fr w t:

, can p:

an,

+

Wrkmg (;roup N h-2.12 i f th. An "rican Na-p' t :m !. per ding h m. a; pN a r

i >nal StandarW ti mnattte NF Hract r Picts and th"ir M tinten me h n prep ired a stan !-

The tatf L

-a!uat d +o

na-ard that provides requircru nt s and gu M m 1 m e.1 m A.N S i A> E NL_ 1 ;- l ii,

anii for estabh,hing and unph mentmg i ay: '.

'f thm e,

r dd Ju14 o ntifm th.'.

that ir.

nti rnal and e xternal aude i.!

mihty atsur-apatant 1

> d, t :.

Ihe : n. h o.i t i

.,I i

m-mcc pt <. grams fr nuc!mr pm: pi m t s, in -

ant

, n tv.i Jd

-it thh re iulit ry cluding th" prep trat < n, p e r f. rir. i n c e rep '<-

Juide in an a;q.. - dien w it h..i t iu ilf n ati n i

n g and fi lhiw up ' f audits I,y lo th th' autht-can t h 'd the r+ ;u em, it ANS! ASMI.

ing and audited < rg maati;ns Nb2 12-13.,

as < ;; ps at,J & c e

'6 r. in i.

~s d E.w Dn.

k

^

th.in s in g !"

l>ur*4.+ r t,u y' tra m e e

USNRC REGULATORY GUIDES c<-ec's swa t.e we to t*e se.wy o N (.cw w.or u s N s...,,

%www cm*r ssum w

.,r DC 7H6 ht<

Du =.t rs aN Retzwtvv Gwdas e's ssued to deserte and men e awe let.e c) +e puts c,.r.,r e e ns h i

e.ds aa ec+ab>e to +e N AC s# M irr'r ee"t'no sta ' e m"s o' t*e b/"fT':S$' W g P4QJiilt'f M"it TO deMed'e !89r brwbeg used by tN St3M m vm j NJed*h58'# h ed "t*@bMW tr, 'ODm84 dwiWT $

gt.

J Sper, AC l t N4F3 Of [Ky$ta af ed 6f ( gjpM5 qt tQ g.K v ad4a g, % (p fp GEee anf 5 R eg a'or', Gucas af e not gutgves br regE w r*, and arve I D** % tMS 6 N F'S gearve with them is ret ver3 psed Ve $Od5 8'd Bs WLt.OnS l"are t h3m these b "$d"

  • 4 M bl S 1 7 I'MN'FD F r

tpf CNt of1 The Q adat w'll l'e Sf t PC *aNe t' they p*99pte 8 PkeV5 f Jr *e *.r@rgg 3 E *H189d Wer d'5 f5t id *9 8 I) C ul&T' cli He*C

s e.,

4 Ee rw-w aN S N 9

A-+

i i t -

eu

-w

'8tth# # TO the %8T F W UV ' '%d N e N p ter'%t or ' Cen%e (OFfN4ggy

$ Vd'ar,A g gN P3 t taw

,f

' Gee. Wed' C_,..__._,_,_e,_e._

47 44 tFF"el Grid gu.dp5 wdl be rev'wed 3g 33w,3f,p ate to as (C wWate, ore

[.3.pment on gn gut rgy 1et t w 4t f. y gmg es r egg : f,t., r p g. odes 8

r'er't3 and 10 f 4* tit nesvt e'GtmAsOn Of em per enre tuswevet C omrv.pr'g rr 1 sy9 4, % r g g*%t 1 be r'ndde o we tmg to fP e U $ h s 'ed' bbM'Orv Wg gur je rf regr esved wit *"im st w,yt two rMe*%g a++ Pt 't3 886 '4N A e'D E.8 C N 44si C A 4%rorge DC 7N 6, A t+entm O ver %

D.y9nn f

cs'acu#v vee *W r evatat'nq tse rw ad 'or an aer's rewe Tm *muy fr*w %n aM Dew car t CertW e

A e

1 -

/

kk b)[

suppia '

t nei !

M in t a c.. u n, th" 1.ur-

hegun, a t --

(( )p. rat 0 n ),

sh.uhl te ti.1 -

h.t u ! '. l ! 1. ] ' ' t.

.ill jille t<

je II I'la. ill t'ltfl'

}s il i

e th" upph r n

!" h a u ', t' thin. n<

ur-4 i nL the tun.t a r xt,'-

<!)

).

n a..J (;'nst ruct; n Ph e

.\\ c t t V -

chr+r

.,r4 r t,

la }.tilit s

! I!U wil j i' }l it ;e

.\\ }, j. !;.s t ! > b '

e In r !!! '

- i :'

.n;'I!b'n

i;u iht s a

.u ra n.. pr cr u

. ! to au 1 f t if at C.

PC3UL, n

r; TION Ic a. ' innuiUV

,r at l>.i s '

it hm t he hf ra'h rt+r the ici tu t s. w ho h-

[ I,.

[e s;'.

[1f-i;r'

<1,

.!} ; n.T N,4 l r

'i a

! 1:

m hti

.ur-h I.xt4 rnal.iushts

+

1; j

iI

[.

j I1 :

i!*

j.i

. i!! '

1:: !

J1<j' in t

f'-

' [) ! \\tr t n il tuslll '

([t

  • r I h'

.ih t r$l ' 'f.i

~

i <

s u.

t a th+
' ' 'o n t

.n ? ' u t.

.o e n<.t ne <

ir;

f. r p r. c u n nt

.lr.

\\ [ ;" '

'\\

It

  1. ctF ns e, h e r.

.t ect ; t anil

..f the J r< iluc t

u. In

,j4, i

i t.

l' l ' i: ' I!'

. t I

'+ t !!

-s i 4

'. ! in.

h tt h %Y t 1.n 1:1 2.

'.\\ t '

t [ >.in e i

(

4 n mc in i e

  • 'n.

<.f

.\\NSi Nis ' IS-to 1:<

t i- ;l

\\L,.

1.. - l ' ci,

c.,,

'y ihts

.\\ r u r.in ce h,qua, a nts t.'

i i

,p;u dt b<

4' n t r, ! : P: u r rn n t

,f It :n in < ! u r"ic o,t.

th e t '. i ' o.

l'I.t ll t ',

as suj.i..

n t t.! I,y

rs!

ile f. !, . t i -

[i ! \\

.'[

sir }i he '

l!:

i i.

t j. I! '.t i

i

,,n-

<b

!u

.!.i h,

i! it r s

(;.nl~

l 12.,

"yu iht

.\\ s,urance t:

' + '

i I }!r I:i anti

!1t' fF l'!

('ll t ( : lit a J l <!1-

!lva j ult e

!i')

j < '

r t

i i

i

\\ 11, ' i t

} N,h c [-

18! i:> t,

in this

'I

[!

  • j, ',

i.j-

,r, e'b('-

I' 1 11 I-

.!r n[tt,j.

}lr fli; ti L '. ( l l11 < !

I'.

3 i

e i

I1. s

,;,j,.1-

!o i

\\'

i+ !

1. E

!he r I > r: U!t : o nt.u'tb n-

.,u.llt,

,i i

(,

ihi ni! li t t il d '-

sl+'

'i! u ti in e'ItInt I d i J 4

t

'i1...

a o e b

().i j + j ; i j. ' t ! > l. e ' ' le Int II I -

i

.4 ij j !-

. t.

e j

a' t'

1]I] i t

' li l'.i i:

j)'

.[r lM

h. u l< 1 to I-ii l

.i '

i.' Ib t'.cii if I.

!! < [. f ill h t '.

.it

}e 1st

.t G nu t[lV

<*r

, 1 i

it althin t h<

h!

<,f

'h.

act:nt s,

o i it ist i

f' L -

ct+

t.

..t t t, r 8

i i I'

.1 -

il' n,

4 i

<!i

.i j j ' l('. il a !r t

4 i I, his i.i i

! u ji-t e i

i

}.l

.(( : t r ' !1.. U ! <l I;*

' l i' i 1 j !:i i j.1 i s j,

11

' t i., ! '. ' i 4

s

. i ', n l j l'. t !:

e u.t.

,b m;.at a

'h

'b g

imi.t.

tc te,

,n herr n i t r..
nial I nh.

ni

i! ! !

q.;.

fh, fi, s t tb.

t ro nn al tu< hts sh ul j to

..n-il !.

i il IJ.

,jt;.'tto!

4((li 1: n t hi!'.

t-In { >R.[ P ' 5 s it) t-i t

r in ! -

tt N

t!-

i r<'

th

.!'r n :n.

sh,th r the r; int /at:

1.

I[!

j.i

, i t ).

.j;I t!!t i 13. u r.t n.,

[.l d

( ~ '

I I, 5

n.

as s

[);

.t!.

NI f

f i

il-h.,!

th, rit :

.t hh>

i. :l t i-i i

h, V.

i '.b i 1..

,i -

y i fic a t i n th.it P.

+

'rm*

..r ii ntri t i

1

?l)

!tr; t he-

},.

,f a,-11\\* t t c s 4';

1 j'

i' j: -

1,:

1-

!! i :' e

.1 t:2,'

s,

! ! [ ',-

j,, 1:

.i{

I,

'h,

,in, ' u j,{,[:' I is i x' a u l t 'll..i n r

oi.h

' l

(

i.f.

L! '

olu '. i! t the m ere:isc.) ' -

o c'

. i 4

'. h

.l.

\\ \\ N

.i?

,ii_

-l

i j t; Sta

'i, stifI;n

.1 n> u t rlt a n t.tl i

i t'

I;

}.-

3 :v I.

11 I

+N.e j;

i*

4 i 1 ti i}

f I; t !.*

i i i l. ; ; n', s ' n t e s !

.1[I]<!; n i[ II;*

\\si' t.

t j'r.

!i!

('

e

,.j n Xi !

.u;f

-d., :b! la pert rra J ann'I dli h h-re Is.'

wilu:it i n

'h ohl f. i i.

  • In t, >

<!J 1:

i

.1:'

..ts i

.ru i:.

i !: -;t-a

'; t (

I,

'.1, w.,f s u p j,i te r - t u r n i' h ',1 (i uu-s t

l 3'

'i r

),

t - + 1 t ill.il e

'f(

!!! i i r:' i i n s ' t '

n-a i

s e n!

oir 11 F rt t' t iV e' lic t ! n s

.i n ' t i i

't 5 i >._. 11 -

j a t',

' 1 113 j[i Ut ! 4[lt a t i in s i

p s

  • c

' i'

,! t r

!.i.}-

t tli !fx

. tit (l o s 1 Vin;' :!! s j >i c ' f i< a r l ',

1JJ i;Jn r-

,:l' i

2

\\j4 I l-i[

Ii j a Ofi.Il l'

. t }.t r J,;>-

II:

' it

!..j:

t'4 tt t

s a $1 \\

41:,. t o I:I r MI' h' ! I;\\

f},e

.it M s ti j.l,[h r, :inij ( l) t-

!!r t.'

n..u:t -

.c o h '

f:,au <,t he r p.

't..

<,u n <

iji t i. !;I '

i li n IMI. A.' ' '

'r N I!( '

i'f ;I s

,-}e et, j,

t i

I t il' I

lia I f fit

  1. l l i. f ' l ;I)'

1[l' f fi 1I8 il I>

I fl8 V f 'I'I )

'te L l",

,f A: il A M l; NL>

1;-l%7 i < n-4

( >;.

il Ph e t urmi.n t h- ; i! w in e e eti >ns h iVe s ut ficient t

-+

i-

l' (i

't}-

"Q'4t.4' 1.

I'!

![

.t!e t) a j o,1 ?.111 t In i n lit * 'il t h e '

a>

is t he-4

} } Il* O h

)]

a e'

~7 U

t equirerat nis (indicated by t he verb sh d!") t.f D.

IMPL EM E NT ATION the standard The pu ri a rse i f t hi, 3+ cti.an is to p ri >viJe in-fi, rm i t i n to apphcants regarding the NHU staff' i la n s fc r usmg thi-re gulat o ry guide a.

Sec t ion 3.5.3 - The guideline concerning Except in those cases ni which the appbcant supplementing regularly scheduled a u dit s for p r<.po s e s an acce pt ible alternative meth nl for items 3. 5. 3. 3 thru i ~i 3 ti ci.mplyin g w it h specified p+ >rtions of the Com-Inissi.n's re guliti ns the methm! de sc ribed he rt in will t>e useif in the e valu a t io n of sub-mittals in nne eti4,n with cc nstructi >n pe rmit b.

Section

1. 3. ' 7 - The g u id"lin e concern-and i.pe ra t in g heen e applications di ec ke t e d in g correc t ive acti.n on program deficiencies af ter St pte mber M.

1973.

identified du rin g p re v i<,u s

.iu dit s in this regard, corrective a c t ii.n

< in p ro g ra m def t-If.in appiicant wishes to use this regulatory ciencies id"ntified d u ring previous audits i.,

guide in den 1 > ping submit: ls fc-r.ipplica t ion s con s t r u ed to na an t i:t rective acti >n en pro-ii scket ed.'n i >r be fore Se ptember.W. 1973. the gram deficiencies in the area ' h :i t being p e rt inen t ;,rt i,ns of the a p p hc.s t io n w ill be a u dit e,!. '

evaluated, n t he basis of this guitic n' Q a

\\L h U

l.111 >

LN:71D ST ATES NUCtf AR RE&t ATCav COMwS510N wAss.satos o c ::ss5

)

p g,,, c.,, e,g s,,;g e,, a At ;s stss

,;rl;,"/, -l;;.;:l, u,_

n~Atn ica,.urs ua. swo e

44 U, ;! b, f,

-

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19220A242&oldid=4907544"