ML19210A910

Notifies of Completion of FSAR Amend 19 Review.Applicant Summation Accurate Re Aircraft Impact Loads on Containment Bldg & Other Protected Structures.Leaves Final Judgement on Structural Response Portion to More Qualified Persons

ML19210A910
Person / Time
Site:	Three Mile Island
Issue date:	05/05/1971
From:	Proctor J NAVY, DEPT. OF
To:	Case E US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC)
References
NUDOCS 7911010620
Download: ML19210A910 (2)

Text

y ..

nona DATE OP OCCUMENT: DATE RECEfYED NO.s Ma1- aIs IO ppyg gy.Q - # #

klYOE 9 LT R. M EMO. R EP OR T; O TH ER; J. F. Proctor ,

- OAH34 C OTH EA; gason G. Casa I signed ACTION NECESSART O co~cuaatact O o^rt aas*EaE=:

NO ACTION NECt5$ ART O Co== Ear O ev:

LAa &a F; POST OF FiCE FILE COOc U .W 289

, , , , , , (Consultant File) w ESCAiPTION:(Must 89 URCl8SS4hed) REFERRED TO DATE RECErvED ev OATE r furnishing c,euments on hadt # 19 FSAR...ra Alteraf e Impact Design... A. Drazerick 5-8-71 W/3 evs for Acff0R DISTRIBUTIGt cwav ats:

C =- f Reg Files E. Price & Staff -

Morris /Schroeder 3*T4 _

DeYoung 3 A B j A T p\ L i n VC Ei!,i a Case /Maccery .)U AU t s 1ees/Earas (W/ Orig &3 ns)(Orig to be ratt rned to sw ..,

016) 5 n'U

,, , i

.- ..a,.w .a---

S fod u.s.4Touc cuano? comumsson MAIL CONTROL FORM Poau*ECsass t,.S. G O V E R.4ME N T P WIN TI N G C i' FI C E 1970 406-979 D 'T D ((i)ggr

]A ntliK 1

oks o 15S9 200 7911010 6?C g

S - *

c. w. : .. N AVAL OP.DN ANCE I.MO.'t ATORY * * '" *

'.f . ("w',N, g D V.HI T 2 C A!' File Cy.

~-

- 7;. DCCMTED Regula.tcry

+. ..- UUIC

. .i

.v. . - n , it. -

O E R SPPt.4G. A' A RYL AND 209 M *4AE*LY E F C 1 'C. -

c. v . ..

1971

• r

" ",-2" E.o. m .. f MAY7 r

O MML REGULATORY

'ECTiCN ' p; .3 q

. \ \@s ' - f O',, -

• DCCKET CLERK e. '

. ' . , .</

G co m s -s s'y v- -.- . '

s

./

- ~, .

v, e.o,,. n . C va o., u"* ."". 'v o."

.,a -

- v.. j , .

~

.e ~

v... . . 'i %n%, ~, ~_

Division - .~

of Eesc*mr  :,

Standa-ds -

.y , .' . .,/l ..

{-.

1.r. . . nvo 4... c -...o m p~, n., ,o . .,. c ,.

1.'ashington, D. C. 20545 ).

4

xq,*),' '

a ,e.'

a p.. e ., n.,,

T-

.. . C u,,. a e.. ., 3. y

, . . - _. . .. ._ ..7.,. . ,

s -, n.. ; , .e.. p.4.., .c. 4 o f

.. e..n .ms. <v..-.i J

n ,e g .'e 2 ., ce. .n. . . . .w. . . i ,. . *. ,C .

< = ..,.* , L. 'a* .'. D. s , ..s m'qm o. a

• • i9 .e -

.. , r.- p . .m s.. r. *%.

. a

• wo.4 - . . .,%

~v .s. ,v. ;,. ,, . > L 1, .'.aG.~,,,. , .-

s s .a. .aw s ..f,,, ,c . Q .. .m.h. < g '.,

w . .,. s - < ,

• 1. .w..

3., .. 7.

.....v 3 n n. - -.. . .,

u.,.-..s-1.. . .. -

v. . ... ..f,.s..-....

, s 4 ,. .r ,,,..,.

r., y. . t 3 *w-

. ,. 3 ,, A9v c., u'. .'/ r,

.3. ef. i -o ,.y1'I

.o. p **s.",...,..

V w, . . .,'. v' . . . . ,

t. . r ., s; .w.,. . .'. .n. 9. *; * ..,..P..

e

• f e. 4v %. .4 .e., c rs.- -f Q s, aL w =W. .. . s.o.n.v- 4* n gf. .f ...

. n. m n. . .=. A .' ".s. ;P . ^v %..o ns=f.*.'.^".^...,

a , .

e 73

^

Q .4.i O. '6 n, .. M $4.M 6.%. r,, *"

v .'I.17 .f M. .rI

- .T.*., r,a.

P '

.o v6A 1... 's e..s ** ", * . f.i,. w. " E.e a e .d.. ,r., *, r.**^'.'A**/*'.'.l'*

. . T.'.*.*P **"*.

-.,,,a., . .

wL ..

-...v. .' 4:. . .....

• v v . s.

6 n....

. ./

, -.m

.. .,. n

, v. v. m.- ..vvn . .s. n.

O. p, :*s r ,. <<,r>

m.. , n . .

J. '

• d ( a4 .wg

.'. t {

(.s.ps v .. . .eo .*e, s . . j. sv. 4. ,3. %. e f" '.g. %. y, 3..

. 9 e

=.-,, .s

- y.. . .o.sw.d. e. 4 .,. a. , .

c. . v.s. .1 . . p .

........,.a.3 / * * * -

g A" 49f.$-

v.a.: r C ." .4'". t# .'.'."4. c ". I.i t I.. n. .'U. , .d. . "3" A P, F,1 m. ew r. c^.%...".'" I* ' # r.* @. . f' t' 9 3 '%..*.",

1.

V o " .. * , r2 f. .=

.r . v. .g M. . P .,1 .a,g o r., *.

• y * * ...s .I. k. *r , . . .

• r w J ee .* .= e 9 p.AJ.aA*~ *..,#*,.a.ve.

. ., ... . .- . <. a

.. ......g,-.A

.{t. .- v, eie p h g

. . e.

a

..I. pu. a a hs .?. . .....,ur.

. f.,.

r w. .v.. . . -

e,. .

. .. . . G3 v . .. "I . .*.).

e. /

. ,. . f,. 4< .w.g ..i ..- . 'I  ;. . s.s.* ,..c ,e.

........u.....

. , u ., , , . r. . .

. . ~

, .. . , ~ .

ana deficcrienc. '.!ith respect to my co 1cern en the uno of more concervative dynamic ' load f actors (DC) on flat uall type

,,,,....,.,.o..s..

construction, the ,, .: . .

anplicant did ,.. . .. .. .

not ch m e hic bacic t... . . . . . . . w .s s. .. . . s . 4 . ..., L.,..., .w. . ~ s . ; n. .s y..,.,.u,.,.,,.... rp s ,. v..a ....:.

,,3..,....,.

.. - ,,-,a. ..-,i ,,...-e......- -

. . .. .. .,.. ..s. .a.

J3 r c,. ~v; ,, g. g. ..v... .. . . : . , . ,

. i.

-p -.n.(.

a<. ..,:.v

. f -. - .

.. . .. .a

.. . . , ) . _ , , . . , ,. . . . . ~ ,... . , , , -r.

.s,

.. s.

L. . . .,

w. -yi.>..

.9 9 ,% z .,., v. .a c .t ,. ts~. a .;m rg , s m... ,,1,,., ,, v,, r e ,

the con ervatic1 sho.m here ic cufficient to alleviate my concerna uith the DD approach.

In conclusion, it is my opinion.that the applicant has presented. in Amendment 19 an accurate summation of the aircraft impact loads en the containment buildins and other protected atructures. However, with "ecrect to the high cetprcesive atressoc induced in the concrete containr.ent deme by the impact loads, I leave final judgenent en the at uctural recponce porticn of the anni'/cic to core qualificd percena in the ficids of prestrecced structures and cc:ncrete beh2vior under ccabined loads auch as Dr. Alor.is Glucic an of your staff and Dr. Unthan Newmark, your structurce consultant.

D R F' D P DN " Very '

truly yours, }5 [ 20 M". m udj / b.

U yF o . r, . m. ,,,,z.,

an Air /Cround 's plosionc Division

.n.

9 I ; ,u! i