ML19209B208

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Amends to Contentions 26,23 & 24.Magnitude of Stress on Each Stud Bolt in Reactor Head Has Not Been Adequately Considered.Applicant Reliance on NEDO-10527 Is Erroneous. Certificate of Svc Encl
ML19209B208
Person / Time
Site: Allens Creek File:Houston Lighting and Power Company icon.png
Issue date: 07/24/1979
From: Doherty J
DOHERTY, J.F.
To:
Shared Package
ML19209B198 List:
References
NUDOCS 7910090326
Download: ML19209B208 (2)
v • d • e


Text

~

)f '# .. U. 3. NU?"C'." TOTJ~ S SY *03:I5*, ION Y2* T O9 ~

~

BIN TE *,T**:IO 3 W2""'

'.!D LICE"3ING N G3

,, 't In tte Matter of: l Houston Lighting and Power Octoany:

L. 11 ens Creek,Muclear Cinerating Ng ..,_, , (!;tation, a Unit 1) ,

Docket j 50-466, OL

u. <

J.3% F. DCH4RTY'S A:iENDENTS TO CC::TINTIONS NU'i3I2ED: E,2 5,& :3 INTRCDUOTIC!

John F. Doherty, Intervenor in the above co:struction license croceeding since Marea 15,1979, filed 50 additional contentions

? cst ALAS-535, the A' peal Board': finding that it was suitable for Intervenors to raise contentions which had been previousiv e.::lud ed . Both Staff nd Aeplic:nt responded to those Contrntions.

The 3aa.-4 resp:nded to a 3tstf =2me that it would entertain

.endments t: Texas lublic Inter:st Research (Tex IRG) post ALA3-535 cententions, and Soth An licant and 3taff seen fit to respond
t'. se amend: cats. This Intervener, awcre of that ru'.ing files this rous of anenied contention: n o n- re ri s tim , and reserves the ri-'t to file ::end:ont to other c:nts ; ions than these. This Intertenor beli2ves that this vi. expedite the proceedings, as o;her intervenors will no doubt re: pond to the June 15th Federal 7e i-ter n:tico.

A e,'2" Contention @6 The 3:fet? Anal.vsis for the pronosed ACNGS is inaie uate be: u c:

(:) There is i afficient s. nur4.:ce tist e:ch stui bolt is the res:::r hesi :e te cie uite ninicus staudards for yeild strencth duri...- . nti:1 sted transient with-out scran conditfons, (b) the =s nitude of the ms :iru 'ri=:ry tensile c: ponent h s been in:duquately c:nnidared, and (c) the sa nitule of stra:: on each stud has been inade-quately ::..:ilerad, as as: the storing of strain aner y in the reactor heat flan"e end how it provides the =e-chanle:1 =esns b; which 3: 1 stud bolts will fail if a first one fails.

TO .3 7'N7;N?IT*; 793 Inte-vanar conte:ds a pre:sure trsacient vhen the reactor

1. operatine at 1.02 ti:es :he li:ensed 7over level is a cred-idle event and a subsequent lar e or s:all co.*lant pipe break LOOA is a lo,-i:s1 cutcome of t!.i credible event because the a

ortssure surra fra1 the transient will issart a load to the co.lsat Sicing which, if the p pe is weake:d by latent defects Ou h as ern: Mini or any other delect, will break. Further, that a pressure transient at full power .

(a) with consequent increa:e in power, or 7010090 3 2 e5

__ (b) with no incresce in power

~~ ~j q >

1el l )y _ /

.. . . , .. . . .... a ,1- ,

... . . .. .. , . . c s

+

3

.a........ . . .. 4 . 1 4.... .. . .....,.,.3 .

P00R ORB M e

.. a. . . . .

. .r..... ... . .. , . .4... .

4..

.. . .. 4...,s.-. .w1.

.3 ..s

....n_. . ..,a,

.. .. 3 . ..- w. ..33 4 i. . 4. . ,. .

. 1. J.

43 .g 4.

s 3 .

.g

..I. ,w. ....... . .n....'..4.-. . ..a.

.. . 3.2.

.. .. ,. .. .. ..."1.. *. -. . . .. ... . .. e.. .; ,.. .....,. 3. .. . . . .. .. . ., .. . a. .. . . . ... . . O .r . .,a..u$s a.. e 4.

...... . .. ...i ....s

  • c.,,.,...

,. . ,.,.s....,-.

..~ . .. . . . ....4,.. . . .

,.. O.,.a . , . - 1..

.e.a , ~s ., . .i.,- 4. . . . -.- . ... .. . . , .O i.,.* . 4. w .w.

1. . .r.. .. . - .. . ..

d

.y

. s* S . . ...1....4 . 1... 4 A. .. ..a . .1 .4 . . .'.,3...

a.

. a.  %..- . 4. .Ia. s.

a3 m.,..

.. . 1'

  • 4

, . ",* * . K*,, ... .* ., 9."., ..

,, a 4.. 4. . ... m........ .. 4. .-- % 3. . .,S A. .O

. .. -2 . p , ,. , .

  • a. w. -....p. *
a. .- . 4....

~

. ,.... g .;,. . ..3 . . .. *.".2'

  • -*-i*-*. * **. -**'4'4.

.O ...a.

i a, *

. A. A.'."..* .

    • 4.*."

. .- .'9."."

^

. 4'O,-- . * %. A ""5*E*'.'**.

.44

..... .L .

3,.. . . - . . . _.. 4. . .

. . ..,.. . . . .- . - .. 3 . * , .... .

. . - s. . e .: , c c..

.w .s

.i e a ...e. . dn. ....s.... . s 3 .. . 4. .. . ..

' . . < . .. ~ .,

  • e. 3 .-4 4 .
n. . l i t..
v. .

... . . ~) .. .s . . 1.C>L .

,, . : ... .) .. ... -

., .. .. . .. .. . . C .c s -

e

.4 . ,.  : .c 3,,.. ,

. . ,.. .. .i ., . . . . 1 .. . n ,. . , a .

s C,J S s.

s. o. . .n *. . w- .-- ... . . . .. - . . ,.,

. >8 a a....3 . s . . o. . ... ,.s.1

. w , r ' "9 , . . . ,

. .a .

b

3. ". . .m.

.- -.. .wa

.gs .

. C ., 4. . 4. . . . 4. . . .o ,. .. d . . .s . < . 4. 3 .i.s. ,,

,. .. .w, 4... 4

.e 3.,, .. .. ... 4

. .. .w.

- . 2 . - - .. . . . . . .

. . . . . .O

.,;,""' 49*

.. . , . .. .. . . , ,. 3 ,, .s .. .. . .s.....4.v...-

.44.

m ,s s .. . 3. . s . " 4. -

1. .a. i. .s c . .n,,

. . .?- .. .. 4.... O .e . 1,. Y. . . ... . .31

  • . ; a. ...

....,.2-.L.-,.

4

..e .s. 3, .

. , . .,. A . r ... . .. - ...

. . 1. . . /g

. .

  • S., , . 3, 'r7 )'

g.w.134 ..

. . . ... . . . .. . , , , . ...:-....,,1.. . . . . , .

.. ..1. . 3.* a o, a.d. m. A.

...w

  • P.'e.5.

t, . ,r, ., ; r. , ,t . ?. . .,

  • .*c: . s q]. *: 1 .

. .. ... s. a. m... . 4. . 4. . .. . , . 4.m... . . . .

og g g ,., .. 4. . . . a. .wa ,

y.*. . .. . ...

s..-..9..

,.3.i.. .'..) (.~1.,=. -- .. . . ."s 3. ,* D ,a ,

..l..

...s 1..... . .- .O.

.6 ......,., _

. . .n

.i -

- - . . .3A A."L. 3 ,...,.4. 3 .. .

'm ..s e. . ,,  % ,.. -- .. . ... .

.4. 3 .. . 1. .- ...4.,

.. ' .,.3..3,, 1 .

. . *D . . . .

.)..

....a

..- -2 .r .

.,.3..*

. ... . .... ... O l' ..3.

.. . . . . . . . 4,a.. ,

3 . ., .. . . .:...,4.,..

.* 1- . . . . . , . ..

')

.4 3..,.

s .e . .45. = .

.,.y.

s . ~ . ~ ~ . . ....

.4 . . . .

... ..4 .) . . s. 4 i

. .. , . .. . .,. . - - . . .- . .. e....,. ..

,r^*. *

..3.,..

  • 1 *

.3

. c 1. -

3. ..s. . 3 .. .

. ...s.

. .? .2.n ...' . ,

. .a . , 4.

  • J.. 4 ,. . .

3.. ..s. . . . . .

.....s*

. . 3.. . .

4. ... . "1 .. , i.1. .m 1.; . . . .. .

1 .... *

  • 4......

3

.I. 4. , c. ..

. e . . - .. -

-.... . ... .. . . .-. 4.=..

. . .. - .A.

s.. ....g.

s . - .,.. .a. n. - ... . .

s ".... 3..

. . . . ....,s.3,. .. .. t. a.

4

.. 'l ,.

3. . . .. - . . .. . . .

. . . ..,, . /. , ..

..s... . .... . . 3.. 3 .r . . 4.

a .# [ 4. .. .i.,.

. ,.. . . .. . e. .... , '-. ..... , . . . .. ..._. . - . , e. . J 4.

  • O..

. . ,.-4. .a 4. .

.t.

. .. . .O s4... . . . .

t

. ... ... . . . . .. ... ..w . .

.c

.. .. . .. . . .. . .. . .Oa Afa4 . . ,g. . ..w 4. ,i .T .

4

.J .,. 3

...3 .w..

. f.. ... .. '. ' %. , s . ., - o. h. .? S. m... .g . -.

. ; 4. a.1.4.. ..., 1.a..

A 3

m

.13

..i.. / .

a. .p *U p. 1. .

.i V . .. . . . 6. s . 3. .

m* y

  • p

.b , e,

,. g. g a

  • a k.....m .. ,9 3. .

. . , ,, .6

  • w.,... .. . .. . . . *
  • N.,- .i.w W

.-..t. .

. , g .

.~.

w .,

.u.', $

J..

.. . i

. ,J .

.....)

.. . .. . / V.

. . a.sa

.....i.e.

..s y . .,.G J ,

es.<sa a .~ . ,.a . o s.,. v.a,,,

.. 1, . ~ -? - * .

e.,..

.,.. ,... . ... -. _-3 .. ., ..

,s s- s

. ~.

. . ~ . , ,...,3 .

,3

. ,. ;  %.. .,o. . .,...e..- . e,... ,.

. ~. " . . R..:.: ... .r. 3. ' ( c v.

.. _...., n , .~. . , .n . , -->~ . i. . .. -. ,:.

, . ,s . . ,. .

s.

.s

..,m..,.

. ... a ,

.x. ,

.m .. .. .. ,

a. c .

. .. . . - . . , ,,  :.- . ..)

... , , . .....~..2..... . . ,-- . ,. s ,. .

. _ . . . .. . . s . . .. ,,. .,,. c., .. e . 4.

.. .. a........, ., . . s... s.. .

,..4....

).,...s

.. i np l IIJ -V

. A '

0 [  %

c- M_. ,. r:D , w ~

e

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19209B208&oldid=2502436"