ML19208B502
| ML19208B502 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 12/21/1978 |
| From: | NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML19208B496 | List: |
| References | |
| REF-10CFR9.7 NUDOCS 7909200449 | |
| Download: ML19208B502 (11) | |
Text
...
....-m e
.r., -
s
. m-,..-...y.
..;ww.;.:.pp+s. :
,, y.7 4,>.a
.;c~,-
w 4%,%. > o.ss:2 w:
a-m..m+~
.~
. ~. 6' DC.w [5.y.
k
-i m..m%a.,".M*
. i..-,v~
i'h M f.".c..t r-i
-#2
?"
r f I '
....m..m..<,
.n
.s. - -
e. -.
.n w w w.m.
A M.,A.*it.,.c $/[.3$..%.,... 7 *.'*
~
-;T.'-i. N.s.
".'I# k*S'e [dfah, E'.a~a'l_hacCrwes s
. +n f.-% p;T 'f4l' SiWtah S
sdA aw4 TEM - f R.'QhpW:.f.Gi~.vkWA&i.%}:
~
-n a.
m h iNW:'*----
=iv&4%
4..A.
<tw.Q,, W E,.k4.-@vr 'N'U.,.CLE A.,R 'R E G U_LMO R YT C M M.1 _
.. o' JL.".-
- y..-r
,.w...
r,.:. - ! :.,,,,. -
er.' -w
~
r mas or.--
c p
m-
..=-v
,. 4;. L '4.
....n..u.,%..'..
.-r
~.
em.,%..
<,s 2
.+> >
.m, he-F. - -
c
- -~
~. '".f. * 'w [,..,}j f> * *r)
. 't ; y_- -
. : -;;. )
~.
.s.
g
... s.
- . :a.
,...m...
p..
o.,
.e
- .%v
.1 -
- r. W.e*':.<.D
- %.$.* ~~
. v'.,
a.
.,~.. A y + C
- .f.
- 'e J.,, :4 e,.
.s
'. ~,.. ~ ~.
~.. -
'. h ls sh"y ~ p. -..-k V*
....,;.o.e. :C'.s
~; ' Q^::[&.. '**%':
- An.-
.. v r.
~g i
e;t
.l q.T '.'n?.
.. Q:.; u C h ~s q -n., - -. ~* ui.W. - *
- 5^ *
.W.> C ' W:
.T'.
-n.
Y '- M *o-A*" W ~*h:' ' '* *f W' r
- IR.
,d W*
..' 5 ' ~
.k-
.m.. k.
N
- 1..'I*e:N).,
.,. ~._...
d'.n....>.
."sh.
- 3. ~n
%. -.~.s a.n s
w,,.,,-..~-
x e.a
..,.., r.~
y6..... w w.c
.. y.,m. _....n,
..u+..
.e q
g
' '7,. - ge y,
.n.,.4 g tw-W54 h t *r
- rg=...s. w..g..4
,, W e,
. m.m,.:.
.. p.u.y,,'.,:p. en*,c=
- 2. w.r.
- *w
. p..
w.
- q. u
't ' -#6 a.
a w.
. v%.
u.
cm v4.J,..., w.: m w- -~~g+e.. hg,e.,N.r:.
r
..,: r_j,.egy,.. m e. d..,, 4 496,.w.cflu t
%. g..:- :M Wm. w.
M
. x.. - -
~-
. ~.,Ne n.-
..m..
'N THE MA TR ' C F.-
-.. - ~ -
'm..%..
.c.~.,~%..
m...
.u Closed Meeting
~
u.
pr.:~
..~-- m ~-.-..
.p---.
n
.. r
.x s
DISCUSSION OF s.e...
. - -.. ~.-
NUCLEAR EXPORT-RELATED MATTERS
..w
.-.~
- 7 7.-
.n
~ '.
v.s
....,.x.
.; m.<-.
.. c :y m..,,v:a,..,
- 1...
.q _,..
- s..
a
... r.... r... -
n.
. n..,,....;.
s.n,.. m.w.c.2 p :,-;.+..
.~..,. -
..w
~..-
..m..:..+,
.. a.
s Place - Washington, D.
C.
Octe.
Thursday, 21 December 1978 pag 3 2~- 68 L.
.,..~
. e.. e e..
.... -...- ~,, -- ~ w.., w..,%
_ w,. ~ ~.a s m
p
-.D 1
r l
i eeeccene:
(
..,.4 s..
ca
"*7
..A.CE. : aER.E HI?ORTT_35.'INC. ' ~"
~
,..&. i. =-. =.:, ::
. y=.:,:
_.3
.;. x,':.- y p 3 '-
,q,7.se*
, g. _
. ~.. :~
.r..y..
jj y,.y.. _*
- p, t K,4_.
g.,
K,
...-........t L4 Ner-i C:=itei streer..., ~..... _.
... m.
. o..
w p n..,.
e.r.
.. _ ~
...u
... ~
....w.
~-
N..C NW!O E COV?.D G E. C A!!.F ' ' " ' -
g g u_n old..' __
~
n m eaw-
< < /
'l-'
o s
id'
^
2 d
~
- r1888 t
"ELTZER/mm i
U:IITED STATES OF AMERICA I
i il NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION i,
i 1
l I
Cls?ed Meeting I
t DISCUSSION OF 1
NUCLEAR EXPORT-RELATED MATTERS i
I i
Room 1130 1717 H Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
I l
Thursdr_y, 21 December 1978 l
I A hearing in the above-entitled matter was i,
f held, pursuant to vote, at 2 : 3 0 p.m., JCSEPH HENDRIE,
11 1
ll Chairman, presiding.
?
il j'i P RESENT :
l'li i
JOSEPH EENDRIE, CHAIPS.AN
!l I
i VICTOR GILINS?.Y, CC:0!IS SIONER RICHARD KISNEDY, CC:i'!ISSIONER PETER B?J.DFCPI, COMMISSIONER w 3..y e 2 7_.c. g.. e, w.f.ee S q e n..r R ee.
I
- r. 4 m..
P I.
Messrs. Scintc, Rothschild, Gossick, Pedersen,
- i.,
Kelley, Shea, Hoyle, Devine, Stciber, and Chilk.
i.
_) If) } In I!p)
D li, s;h
': l
!j e
t S..g.mA c
,i ux
[, 'i i, !..,s j-. J.
q li fl-j;d i, l, i
'( o'( P(tai 3[8 0 8 IIII. f *iO ji j
7
! a l-i i
_J UU U N p.td htj [n;! L, c
3 s
.i t
tg
. CR1283
._: ~,: afz uru-I F,
_P _R O _C _E _E _D _I N _G _S.
The Commission voted on short notice to hold
.I', the neeting, and voted on short notice to close the meeting.
,i CEAIRMAN HENDRIE:
I will call two things to t
3 your attention.
The first one is a request for the
. Commission's views on the French sale of a couple of reactors s
to the People's Republic of China.
I
- l We have noted previously in this meeting that the
, consultatica period here is not all that might in some
.i 1 quarters be censidered desirable.
Nevertheless, we have --
n the govern.ent apparently is on the hook to reply by the 23rd, and there is a draft letter around --
COIGISSIGNER KENNEDY: Which day is it, the 21st cr the 23rd?
n f
Y.R. PEDERSEN:
We were asked to reply, I believe, l
l' f,
by today.
i CHAIFFAN HENDRIE:
The close of business today.
I MR. PEDERSEN :
There is a telegram circulating j
ii that I saw, that indicated the gcVernment-to-government t response was e>:pected by the 2 3rd, from what I saw.
f C: i.I?y.AN HENDRIE :
There is a draf t of the i:
le :er, ar al ernate draft of the Staff version that OPE i
e i.
if I
E'
- i
372Z44 7,
c,7 q
i
- i e r.....
{Jg ' t L e t uu m i
.i io a
ft 4
I t
!\\
,1
',has prepared that I recommend to you.
mm I
In fact, there are two -- one of them dealing with I the consultation period and one dealing with the technology I
i transfer.
So I call that to your attention and recommend i
I speedy action.
I 1
MR. GOSSICK: Mr. C Pairman?
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Yes?
MR. GOSSICK:
There is some later inforTnation, I d
understand, tat is in the process of being given to you.
It v
!!l has been, I guess, addressed to only the assistants so far.
l
! We are getting the paper down.
l I don't know that we can discuss it here, because I
- ,of classification, and also it wasn' t billed as an item.
- But, il.~' it bears on what I think --
1 CC:CISSIC::ER AHEAR'!E :
Then as far as status
!Ij goes, that is something else there is something else that we II' are about to receive.
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
It relates to the Staff
,. position.
ik CC O;ISSIC::ER 3RADFCRD:
Is this further material i
from DOE?
SHEA: No.
It relates basically to the Staff
.2.-.
i l
tl MfMf.!f,[d U
.l IJ
'l S..v- -;4 5
<a
- rt:tw t!*C ett9L N.
N
'l
' T f.t' i..
I,.,,,': 1 F. n n.
i1 -
g; 3
Ubb i Uuuut_j
t 5
- i f
t t
bl 3
'ei position on this changing Staff position based on the mm i? information received.
1 j!
COFS1ISSIONER GILINSKY: Can't we just turn this il ij into a classified session and discuss it?
i I
MR. KELLEY:
It has been open.
cob'MISSIONER GILINSKY :
Can' t we just close it?
l MR. KELLEY:
You can vote to do it.
CO:01ISSIONER GILINSKY:
Why don' t we just vote 1 to do it.
There is a deadline.
We can do it.
9 ij i
d CO:01ISSIO:iER KEN'.;EDY :
I say we so vote.
I CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
All in favor of closing the i
meeting?
COSD!ISSIONER GILINSKY:
Aye.
COSD1ISSIONER KEN';EDY:
Aye.
Il h
CO:Oi!SSIONER BRADFORD:
Aye.
I CO:OIISSIONER AEIARNE:
Aye.
!i CHAI??AN HENDRIE: So ordered.
if i!
- i CO:01ISSICNER GILINSKY: You probably need a short-i 31! notice meeting vote.
a" CHAIR::AN HENDRII: Those in favor of short-notice meeting.
r COO:ISSIC:;ER GILI: SKY:
Aye.
~
I N
[) G'.;3 (? F.D,',b, #
S. r :c46 o
u.
- u LI.
-O ' - 'j
< ]l [ y ;., o, ' i s '
,r.
-g.
rl st:s as, i:w:= ts: :9.:
U E L E U bu uu a
'l 6
0 d
l,i i
p i
COMMISSIONER KENNEDY: Aye.
mm l
CObD1ISSIONER AHEARNE: Aye.
n i,
COMMISSIONER BRADFORD:
Aye.
l f
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: So ordered.
I i
i MR. PEDERSEN:
i 1
i.
I t.'
4:i
'l li
- i MR. GOSSICK:
il 10 d
I CHAIT01AN HENDRIE:
MR. SHEA:
l I
ii li..
9 l
l.
4.
4'
!o 11
'I 1
CO.NDi!SSIO::ER KENNEDY :
i q
i ) a p0 a
- i
- 8., "_ I -(
(
N Li> le,,,,e,j, 7,3
!u
- l
- n.. ev: m: i t.:
.?
r 3 r,
- r. 7.
u
- y ;./, ' q 4 : -
ri j li, f{
',l f
1
, Ll 'i -- (i U thj I f1] '.j ;
NOTE:
Page 7 through 64 of this transcript have been withheld in their entirety.
(EXEMPTION 1) i
i 1
65 a
'i i
COMMISSIONER KENiiEDY:
-.:n
.i
^
l'
.l!.ii i.
A t
COMMISSIONER GILINSKY:
I l
COMMISSIONER KEN'IEDY:
1
- l
!I CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
- t ii
- 1 l'
i COMMISSIONER KENNEDY:
i
~
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: If 1 throw that back at you
- I j
is the pattern suf ficiently clear for a redraf ting?
.t j
MR. PEDERSEN:
We will try.
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: Then let us please end this session now and go on to the other business we have before
[
us this afternoon.
Let us have a redraf t of this thing at 1'
L vour earliest convenience.
i.
I l
CCMMISSIONER KENNEDY:
Do you want to vote to P
withhcid the tape?
s
,-.....-..,,:. assumed tn s was a
-n....---,.
u A se: -
w..u o c A u... c i
{s,, L J ! h,,!{!
f
/ 'i p
.i, tj G p r 7;' ' (a p n'j rr 3,7 c43
.u. a:m: :
f44
". = ; i i i O]II. '. 'I I.t
- 6 a
t ;
UU U & U Utj dt La
}
66 I
~
=m classified session.
l CHAIRMAN HENDRIE:
Sorebody advise me about whether we need to vote to withhcid?
MR. STOIBER: I think it would be desirable to do that.
i CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: Okay.
That is, if we vote to withhold we are saying we don't see a reasonable statute of limitations on this tape then ought to be applied publicly, I think is what we are affirming.
'It seems to me probably to be the case.
g r
I would therefore ask for a vote.
7 COMMISSIONER BRADFORD: 3efore you vote, let me just note that I will have to take a look at the redraft.
I think I will almost certainly have a comment i
I of r.y own, apart from this.
i.
CHAIRMAN HE::DRIE : Okay.
Will v.ou trv. to get it g
in hand so that we can package i: on?
COMMISSIO!!ER BEADFORD: I have bee nwriting it.
,l
.i CHAIRMAN HE::DRIE : I have got sc.te extra language {
r
'ef: over.
a f
(Laughter.)
t I
CO:CIISSIONIR KEN!!EI'~.
3efere we leave the subjecj, I
T) fr? S' [w:
,i 5
r
{_)
s"
'l r] 7 r e;s r
1 -
S72250 j
a m. L a u lJu l',
l I
T '
n.
4 t
il ji 67 i
I l
s I
i f
3 i
mm there was another letter in that package which I have read i
il II i
and would like to endorse wholeheartedly, a nd' trge its I
l s
l early sending.
It is the one to Mr. Schlesinger 6ealing with --
l and I would suggest a copy as well to go to the Secretary
,s, s
t h
of State and to the National Security Advisor to-the l
President.
s CCM31ISSIONER AHEAP2iE: I"would like to add a l
little bit more to it.
l l
CHAIRMAN HENDRIE: John had a couple of words he i
l would like to put in. And rather than discuss that -- well, l
you know we separated out the short time the complaint l
about, for pity sakes, you know, what happened to 30 days.
And we separated.that out into another letter,;
't 1
and picked up also crevious -- vcu know, tere was such an effort of movement suggested -- (Inaudible.)
They are.
l all sort of gathered nogether and saying, listen, what 1
i i
happened to 30 days.
\\
i Okay, may we vote to *.tithhold the tape?
i l
CC:01ISSIONER KE::NEDY:
Aye.
i COMMISSIONER AHE!-R'iE :
Aye.
i l
r' CHAIRMAN HE :DRIE : So orderid.
l l
g
-, ~
' ' j l !!,
lj l nlpl f,,
F <' ' i, F v,
1, q
n hm,., r
- ggg,
.st: taw 4tMt?tE* d.0 - '
f
- j,\\'
I
-l:
i 4
r N
I b d h !)L L"
4 ri
.i l
(.
'l
.h l,
il
.i 68 ll i
n
- i
^r Thank you very much.
On to the next meetine.
,i l
(Whereupon, at 3 : 40, the closed meeting el was adjourned.)
k.
I l,f
!I l'
i 7
t I
i I
i
?
I e
\\
l t
4 h
I
(
\\.
I
\\
t l'
i,l
'l t
0
- l'.l l
'I f
,8
\\
vi s'
fi r
I, U
a s
i; l
)
i 9
-r
,,v.
mi
!'. } r
/ ', r P ( 1 -
)' 'j:
P.
i0 t
i t
j r
'9') 7 U sf"%
'h ( j j_; Y
j LIlj.'. IS $ C I M A* b d
(
,