ML19207A347

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Submits Comprehensive List of Alternative Sites & Modes of Generation in Case 80008 in Compliance W/Notice Requirements of 16 Nycrr.List Will Be Narrowed After Further Review of Sites Is Conducted.Maps W/Site Locations Encl
ML19207A347
Person / Time
Site: New Haven
Issue date: 07/05/1979
From: Grey R
NEW YORK, STATE OF
To: Matiots T
NEW YORK, STATE OF
References
NUDOCS 7908170253
Download: ML19207A347 (11)


Text

' l! ',' r J , :

- 4 STATE OF NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SERVICE THE GOVERNOR NELSCN A. ROCKEFELLER ggL w,wE,q EMPIRE STATE PLAZA ALSANY 12223 *

'P300. & UUL, EAC %-$ Sp DUBLIC SE AvlCE COYMISSION CH AR LES A. ZIELINSKI DETE A s. SCHIFF Cnarrman g kn.

a Generai Counses i

EOW A A D p LA A KIN '

SAMLEL A. VActSCN CARMEL CAR AINGTON MAR A Ih ,

Secretary MA R OLD A. JE R AY, J A. W a j,

ANNE 8.VEAD MAR EN S. BU RSTEIN AICHA RC 5. BCWER

%1g Colu m%g July 5, 1979 ,

~l 9

Hon. Thomas R. Matias [-

Administrative Law Judge b State of New York Public Service Commission g

.-+ p\,, g( jcp\go[

N3 Empire State Pla::a a 4, Albany, New York

  • 12223 'l

/> '

  • 9 7 Re: CASE 80008 - New Haven-Stuyvesant J

Dear Judge Matias:

Please take notice that pursuant to 16 NYCRR 70.20 (Evidence on an alternate site), Steff of the Department of Public Service hereby names the following as alternate sites and modes of generation in Case 80008:

Arthur Kill (fossil)

Somerset (fossil)

Pomfret (fossil)

Sheridan (fossil)

Ginna (fossil, nuclear)

Shoreham (nuclear, fossil)

Sterling (nuclear, fossil)

Jamesport (nuclear, fossil)

Nine Mile Point (nuclear)

We have named a comprehensive list of sites at this time to comply with the notice requirements of 16 N'NRR. We believe that our list will be narrowed as Siting Boards take final action on other pending Article VIII applications and as we have a chance to conduct our own review of the sites in greater depth.

7 00 81 r og3 700ZS3

Hon. Thomas R. Matias Page 2 July 5, 1979 Our selection of alternate sites is being made to comply with the notice requirements. It should not be construed as a position st.itement of Staff with regard to the need for additional generating capacity by either applicant.

Very truly yours, 4' /

, , t . --

ROBERT GREY Staff Counsel Enclosure cc: All active parties (with enclosure) 70CTSO

. .q, 024'b N' Match Line g ,~

\ ~

'.l,' i **N C

& -Q k/ ' ',

,,i a g',

,' (' f ,

a <

./,

g' s q

/

,i ;'

,y T rovls '

,/ / '~~ k w

% l '~~

ri~;, ,

,r tu% .

. ,/ {.

  • y'N IQ' ,l -

//\r -

o

' */ \ l, h, '

Y' .N *

'\ ? h:

'y ;p p 3 b]"p%l a, i ./

,e

\W -

_.~

CIW +;c  :, '

32 ~ 'a

. ' - N' $ ,1 -'

M' e EY ~~

.D

' \j

%_ .+. _- .

-,'2 N

, i

  1. N'

?4l' - -- . . yw

~3'"

- . , , ,/ , s N ,

, ; i ,f, ,# 1 ARTMuli. F464. ,'

/ # #FLTE 10 I fre s y l' l U 13 3Cn d #

f4 I(

ilM 2 2/ i U .;O Y.'  :

L

g !

,orv e MGCdQwt

.?

  • \f s,

f v'q  ; u

)

' ~

s gtoof f k li }

,' /,, c. . ., - 2

- $.)J

.* 'e, i 0

gI Ft . , *

' l N t c l si , , 'i N3 ISLAND

[' ; ARTHUR K!LL Fossi! - l[. '

/ I '2H00-7kh MIN.QUAK:M,'St.E. ii M.Jh%,'/ ,,;/

AgTHUR K: LL-

_n. _ _ . _ - = -

t

3. 'b g-

,' , /? p

/9^ +' y

,Y /

\

m ,  %

"' f

~

)

/W'L:(f / 'by:-

s. ,

A RC S3ville < ~:-

C

% j/

,\ ,

5 Q - W q ,,

s 3 m m 9 ' . , )

~ N +IT . .f" o s ;t

% ;/

.- m o-t .\ r-

,y g e.it c..ri. -

4 a c. . - i a p

\ wa  %  %

\ 's, V g "'

7002S5 4of

/

sx

,3,\.\ 7p ,

/ --

lI Match Line M /

I 78'37'30"

,.nn. w = -- --4 w coo _ i___...__._.-_. L---------- -~

pay ,210 m .E.

i 7l \j n

1

?

pitC" 2.s c.

  1. ' "p T A l

,,, o* ,,,, O 3 M x-

.e -

A gg ';

L; e .- .

l

\

/

/

s '- $ ! t

,# I

\ n

s. ]

~ e.

./ l

/

\  :

/ ..J :0 i~

&m[ .

90MERSET !i-

\ ,,.

l i  ! _-

$ } ~T_ c  ; y <  ! i. . -

'

  • t -

- \ s -

,, ,t^Kh [. i, /

/. > / y,' id. /

r ,

e N 9 .- .

, . 2

. I i fa g

o

=

122o cco

-t $50.D \

,\

a q d '

Q N)

, ~l =

~~ . ^

p O m -

@ e;7: -

f

/

r.4 /

U \ /_

4:

05 m N. , r f ). /

l  !

q (

) i

/

w . ., O i M S t, R' .7

- i }

N{

~

, v umsau r ) i N ,

,a,o\ { :

,i

k. -

h e

,a .J'8

/

f , .

\i e-p -

, { o p_ "i i C 9 L

./ s

( L L

i f

L_0* / , ,

of w. ,

j./ J a 6 cr.vinst sut l

  • sa 321

/ i .

! I

- li ' W'81 Hill eG 1

{J. -

s. - .do v = l j[

. ,~ [:-+... .merset . .: _n

~csr T.. sg ssen p g

- ' = v . -

=.

3.s

  • S l , , , . _. a o' - -

l arse so-unse

+ n so 90M5Rs5T stT5+ FoMIL- -

' O t , n e f.o n n == )!.at aJ=t -

  • NM **d* 4 * *)#,- # f

e wyWWw a p 61l le M . Q^,'N (,e47 . "

A

' <'.ei p . ,

N. r*jp/t IA' dt;)

m h,

L 1 210 000 - h'# , s '

,- -( -' #t

%>  ; / ' } 1. 5

. f.

6

'l , ,: *

'j ,-

  • ei ,,

t ) ,  ; - , , .!

4 n t.

s . g ; ry:.-]p J

I*

..:g_{

< +

,_ [ = **%"'" *

'O ' U. w., s s J 4.)  !

-l J

s w~..

Cwery Cao _\s.;,

/ (

. e,

, .. , ./ i. . /.'^'w' . .

-( ' .- E"n1<1e1<L,2  :) /

j f.

,... .c. .

.r- s. i b , yx,

. .. '. . . . - . r-

..- s. J. - '

IW D U 5.,;:.K I R K 2 g.4::. ,- ..

5 .- ,-

gs - .

. - / n,

- =

// L

..s

. ._ N - - p;a N a // c p4 4

-s Van Huen .

L J /. - r

van euren P;tq/j j. ?~p% sav u .- . . . < 3./

,i.., ..

c-e.1.

4 e b
- d:. n:: > N . i, l.'i..:..'

- '~'

s 1 . .. .' #.

/ / /x s .. .

'a ,>/x van

!/U ., . Van Bure, t. - ur n e

I!.T;fPoint \

p?F-l I Bay pan i sureb p# *v""

~*u" L *2nq ., f J-

" -- - jD-v r o*o

- Q -_y y.." L J , - 4 * ,""' ~

- . _. , : . . . . _ _ __ . . c I. -_ in s N -

,i \ . . . _ . . qa7 s .

j 1

r ..e, .

x r

-  ; anei  ;- N .

'sx 3* . . . .N. _ s _ . so ,

[

e " <

/

. Greenerest Nf?

.- l g \ y ,

  • /

t ...... _. J' x i s N -

\

\ <

N J

.- *. ,o e s:

lj: 3 9 k N

s h _,f i 1

i ls . . ... C ..

I  %

% / *M j T

] \ / / (; d'

,' 4

~

f N ,, y\ /f.i 1g -

( . . ... / - .. u l -

\. .

c"

- ' S . . . ;.  : Gl

~

='? %' m /

- . _ _ 2 3. W .j-  ;', v *",'

i-

". "" a ' .

.,~. -

m l

2, /

\

sj Qa-l n

)'.

, y  ;,

o,

. x a

/. l

/ ,

/ . w ,

=

s i Ie, , ,/

J

.4 A

/*. .o c 'Ns,

- , i s -

1

,' ,/"

.\\ '

g.

(

N  %"k I 7 N

,)

f ,!

i N l ;l i x ,, ,, e

\,  %-

i 1 p c w . _ y ,,,.. ,,, j

_j s . .,I -

t b

) ',/

[,%

L] / l

,, -; ,r: , .j' '

I  ;

.sg

. /.

I I i .6 /_ t r.a 8 YP ~

.Ji,

\ . ,

l "

e -

\ l /,) POMFRET C>lT5 + i cOSSI L. i 26' i 2+ coo-m/:2 min.cuAc,w.e.5 u'

,e i es .n.

., x i// a gccr c N d. 3 u N xi a k i *'

gt $5002, e X/

y, _. 7 p . n _'

i' a280 ccm r* f 3

m _sm 1 .

.i

/- .Lamberton i

/

r I '4 . c; //

/, t.L p p ,cM%l'%:nsr>r j' J

s ,,. m: ' .er ec e ~n by wqt..qL q.)b d a buU h h h,['

y. l p ,a
  • I a .

.n -

a

,g *, ,

.l' 6 s s ' -

m

'{-

_e

\

e o "

.v 7o, _must umg_./.9 _ _ _ _ _ p _ _e _ -

_ _ _ _ _ s..N _ _ ;1._ _ _ _ _ _) __s

.5

  • x . .

, g g.

d.

M q-

. - m; w..u

  • o3

.*\ A \ , - .3 . )

.= s .**

T

\

w-N J si I! i 3 x, f , . x ..q

.. / <

,gj .,,,

N

. a-

- ../

\ (, .*

2 ', m

\ \ ,' It rr

,  % O3 '

i .m -

ATh- *

-t

. I( A% N .

[- -

N -

_!: S 2

? -

.s g

e -

  1. t D. ' . .\'-' ' .-

g -

[ L5. \

C

\- t- ,. \'x i n

$,, x \ ,.g- 7 fJ ' .o\.K .-<

<\4

_ 44 3

N s -3 .

.N.

g. s.2, <:-p

. m e

1 9,

f "

\ e E-m .

~$

. 4

-\

/ 1: , T 4

.)ko l '

/ ;4 . I

, j l'

. .gu . - "?" - \ -

  • =

z

  • s*\. ,

a

=- .../

r

/ ci

\..

- Q $. \d .

s

\ '.

f. #

7 . .* . 4 ,

l-

,g. . ..\ s

$3 ,

v. .f nY-  ?.

/ *

/2 ,

n s; z .. .

y e ,e5

' .'T * , _m__.

7l 1 .

.h-

- >1 *: -: .* - t

% Cr. gt w .m ;

i t

y .  %,,/, .4, 4

d.  ;

9 4y.it-s!1, A-a n

s._c: s 4 g o

-i.___\.-

., s v't

.s -

a s 4 n E

< . ' ./- ,q -Dq h '.'

i:

, =

4? .._ l

\ =- z , . ,

ma .0 \'n .

3S s . i O

\

'.g<

H

, 5*

f(

(J"/ ) ~

l == eg h '

.. , t -.. .

- D it; 3' ' . . -"*

s . / ,2 - \l

(-) A

., ::: - 2 <. s( Rs'Jkf*.=

q -' C3 r* 'O U ,t t ,ZTJ.t3 0 /

s ,= =

MI

e. .,:- j - e M Y O d .s.+.M# 5

.00 I2 *.y i

.Q

,0

.aa

'l *

)

~.y I gy n?

i, vn v, g s =

2, o,. - I .5 L

i 4 m g d. >}#p m==

8 N,

.' .u D p L' n s tt

., s .

c- ,

lj  ; -

w3 y \

\is  :

nz

/

N' @42i .!

i

+u a \ .,c y es :\ , ,

J G;9

. 9, i p^~ \*Il F,7 '

[ ~

f J y- g . . ra - s. ' =

l y ,- i c :_. . JT ,

- i .M \, / \\ .pssk IO .,

_; s* . ,_ t-

, fg4.> .u.y; 7p n%c a. _

.\:

s \ s v.* l- O/ .=

.j

/-

1,

.s x

.g \*\<\. \

( l u - >'5 ,6

.< - - - _n La

/

i .:

\\ f UN t K.;

, l+ .

g3 x .w..

s .J oron% i mvc , g e< x, s ,\3 a l

r/

b) *

(~  ! ,i, , g',N a

\ *

'/ ' !

  • \\ W

-- - q -

\ ~ .,y s -

"q . se-.,,

Qs\

s

.aa '

t '

\\' ,p I e

j . I

~ '

', J ~'

b2.zs @,.:

e

e ,

-i g

0 - e -

2 8

E 0NTA R/O T 7 G1 Nt0 A 5 1T-g . po s gi L j AND TdOCLUAR fbi;30 f 4 p

~@

FUR MrN. N AC3VlL,Ls auAent., c,cs , p

: -- 2 a-3 ofNNA Smoky SITE

'\

,s~~ ,

', /7. ' i hus.2::),. J ,

7 4  ;.

' p.:. ,,,. , .,

. .=-.,

3.

. ; q' -

.. 't -

./

/

6 I E I [f

~} . , ., /

c

..- ],
,, 3 = -y j i Il
  1. l I fJ

~~~ ~

1 4

y

' ;l 1 /  !) ol l U l*-

.o N :I i 1 i I g t1 l

O N l

T Al R  ! 8l 0 $]

}

s M

e= '.l.

fu$

l l H l yt l

i e.

k. ;f cpupcy gg f i

\

S Rf Cx -

l.

g.Q .

[  !]'

i j ux,3;o, , E (k -

l \ Bi y e e

t'

\/  !

t-

~

J i I

f.v,1

/ I t- [

\

1 e

ei

/ -

// __L i

1 4

=

    • f ( } () 'T T ' f"3_

n . _ , -

SOUNO .

./

SHOREHAw n-sire )i /s, .~ =; . v, ; ; n .

/ .. = .

-~ -

l, My%

  • 'A M a-,,.,e..,.a.

M'* Q . ,p .

7

r. - ,. ,, 1- - M

%7 % V., j k *e v ,.

~vp~.se n .~ .* m ' .-

y+s.~

,w -

_m

)i,y - ^ *f2 ~f & 'w;>

NL g*e:%. 4 4 - -

av ..

M ns:,; ~N V  ;;1,6 - .

1. .

Ay ,

wn

,. s -

3 g

. ~

-9

\s ,f *

  • Wg

' / ,

@e 4

-y ! c;y; y-i ,. r j t p -.

. .w<W..

s: / ,. i y / -

^

  • ~--

. .a A ,a . , 4. '

  • b "e, .g *.

e

/  ; **

! ,~,,& s 4 3 . e2, '

q tu '

/Y$, n'%., ,r '%. o, <

i!QQ i { ' .s. ,-

.w,%, e )- ) ..~

.r. - p: T s , i 9 -. ,

w. \gn/

\ 7. 7'

- f

\

  • Ns
  • - c. -(=- k;.Z' ,h %[u,'t

'1 4

4  ; m, l 8

_,,,, i4 + , ,, . .

s .. %_, i i. s l .f ,

.. /

i- ~., N ..i  ::. is ___ 1. .

' ' * ~ - ~'**~

' s' W. '

Y hTu' 'u* n ,am*

s

/ L_ \

es ,,, n o 4,,~, , ,". 3 \ f

%i-Q -g i\.; ' . ,V y *

"'%qqrN,,,,,...-

m ..m s ....

, }f +..i. .

\ .,J usu,n n t- ;miimmmiummmmmimei.imn:

Q> 3 :gp ,

.e .

vs. oen. or acase. \

e : -=;ll

, \  ;

I 1

,  ; ,~ \

,'~OEPT.O,f.t.RMY, 1

L_.___.._ _ J ,

,, s .

9HOPJEHAM 9lm . IguceA,a h OR Ml.VUrs FCDSI L. . I/p y.oog-pja g!

C,UADRANC-L5 [

l.WDLU ISLAND h v'/,'OINc.Ri','gp, [

t**1\(\ O fA O

( U tI n.d.)U e

s

\:

x. N x -.

3e IS -..-......'7.

  • -E. .

sTcRUNG Smsr NuctsA.q __ s

[

& iroosiL. !doco-Th Mi i 9, N. j - ' 't "L%~: g1N s .

g somAMe: c oswScro i N '" ~j Wast $ H AN N I CAL--

  • F.@

~-y .

C s- o e

  • - \

)^'

  • [3%j. m Beach.

_- no z 9'8 P _,m, =,m y- -

=\=*

/.'1 }m..

o

,a "h;% . -

8'\8

, tw, g:-m  : .6.T

. . .,. . a ,4 '

,} . h~~. _:-..._ _1 \

/ '_ _ ~~ -] - i q _

.i- N -;d.'; - e J

..z=

- .,,,,,,,.,.. < uns r1

( .

m 1 .

(

t

. .o

.w". w

a r

>\co

/ --

( t -

,'3_-.+ f

~

STER LI NG \' t

. a N:

[ T .~- 3. .

W.'..'.".  %

{'

\

,-+_*,.4.~_4

, ,q_a r.

    • r .. M .y s

l s

- s ' '.*." s

- m.

{1 -

%/o l .

.**= * & .~

~~K' *[ ~.* * +;.* -; . -

4 a<. .,

.I

.. e~ x . *

@ .i e-

. -e i f-g 9 .sj g

a-d - ,e g

'f

  • z Sidma ns 8

- j .

3 \

.T ,l -

?

,e s .. ,.  :

. .. e. ' ,

s .

8aAA**1 175. ,lgg ,9 4 .

@n L m .-

pemns mung . '

D~

f _ _ . - - -

y. ,.

i

<5 , . . (. m J> 5.-

Q' i .t%7 :- . *. 1- "#3% ., s.

M ,1 *

.. 2 ~ ~~ ll US '$ . ~

\

Wad 5-i eo.o _, ,

sf-F

,/

m,

\

e

'*A'@

c o> n, m 1

/

g ua, ts. ..

  • }e ,-

_/j e .

-/ .

f W -

E'

  • )

i  ;

.. .+. v, j

. n ..~  ; ( , \

/

c

\v\ ,

\ ,'

D gS -

SO '

9

,.s S \,, y ' ' , '

M id -.s ..

c.

YG / *- '

s V

.. 90 / .

\ .,

?

, , i

' \.

s. ,

, , .s. . s

,A

,p \N % '

.es .

s i tf ms L- >

, - . .N- x\

  1. ~ 's ~'

is \

\_ \-% *#

, , g '.

sh,

, - k i

\s s s

JAMESPO RT \

suct. EAR 7 v g +

\ N \ \

\ '

\ /

\

/

/

\

N

\ N .~\

k'm

\

/ )

g

\ 'N .

\

s N

5AM ESFCRT SITS NUCU3AP., E \

x

^ -

esonssin. OR POSSI L

  • I St+cco -7l/2 MHJ. h \

,,ooo"" ',; COADi2ANGLG * /A ATTITU C.K f s

5 ~._

N N

s x,

= ,

g 5 -

,/

~.

J, s -

N s

f \ -

\

\ **:p(

t v.'.o

?w J:s n

/ N p '

Ns '

r

  • 1,i , f /

di '.

a , f 75 24 slTE 91CINIT'/

47

\

9A$NY og 1 A FIT:DATRt 9 4 NUCLEAR PCWER DL ANf

$ungeg l Jd i

&y

, L, \

NIAGARA VCHAWK * (

er 9 WLE P0 \ fs ,- -

{

NUCLEAR 37 TICN .. -

< S*itchyaraf' , \

f

.r myc )

1 ,

r 2

.! .. I * -

. i ' .*=a t r >

\ / ,

s.'

.S i m yerc t  ;\ \,

' 4, .'< N * 'e o

 : pe,. _

33 \ L j I-J " . ,V{ a

, - \ _,_

Tower . N f.

I f*" , h ,'N7 \ .

b

f [ ;.. - -

(

ise ,

4 Gjw

'ars e v* p!.. p n ,. /

)"*'^

q ly

/ \ I + -

$'l, \

i j.

..( py ake h.. ew ev ,

t *

, t

  • *, t y {.

t i

l

/ l *

' I

\ * .

9 School 1._, .A,

. .=i , I

[

} \ <

No 16).s .,

( i - . t

_ ] p  ;-

I w R I B y iS. C  !

g..

\ .

w

'*%

  • 3 t.. .-r y

' * '.:r; ,p p W[(\-

1.

2,, - , ,.

\.e..>.

-e

.- . i

r. m ~ .,

3 v.h y/'

r

+

5T i-N 1

O .+ it i

1

[A coming D

I k I; ,

,1

, . _.Lk .1.a .o A --

f.I ' p.

gi.6:+ ' -%nii'- '~,~~-

,c , > ,-

,/

x, w -

mwo 2 3 3,;, . 8

.I

- u n t[Lycoming k \

It,

- I/ 7

. s

~

\ .d / h

/ (

{ .i

/

s ,

i (s

!i x

( '.., N1NS MILS PT* NUCLEiR.- \

,cor I

t3,2.4c00 ~7fS. MIN.GUACRANGt5*r.';! ~'

} . s. ,,

2=

K~T,~.

u g* bI- e n: m* w p~ P

. .,. . Mm . .- . ,d r_ ._ \

r- - __

- -q.tg Scribi w

  • 1 4

\ .@ (.

i \ \

e m

a \ '

4 g> *s .' Q ( V n.>t* ?OO-i

- (% ,

'h .

Cf GW9i P t-l I k

', , s.

S

\ J

^

a 1

, 3 1

A, -

2

,,, . _ uaoq_ j % f *.

' o m'ge;,- ~

~

a..- - $, . *

.'.' . . ' i- [.? 5~.~.^^~~' s O
w