ML18221A676

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comment (3504) E-mail Regarding Holtec-CISF EIS Scoping
ML18221A676
Person / Time
Site: HI-STORE
Issue date: 07/30/2018
From: Public Commenter
Public Commenter
To:
Division of Fuel Cycle Safety, Safeguards, and Environmental Review
NRC/NMSS/DFCSE
References
83FR13802
Download: ML18221A676 (9)
v • d • e


Text

1 Holtec-CISFEISCEm Resource From:

Judy Williams <jkwilliams24@gmail.com>

Sent:

Monday, July 30, 2018 2:21 PM To:

Holtec-CISFEIS Resource

Subject:

[External_Sender] Comments from League of Women Voters of New Mexico Attachments:

LWVNM Response to HOLTEC Env Rpt 7-30-18.pdf Attached are comments on the Holtec EIS from the League of Women Voters of New Mexico, which has a number of members who work as nuclear scientists and experts.

Please advise if this is NOT the correct email address.

Thank you, Judith K. Williams, Ph.D., President League of Women Voters of New Mexico

Federal Register Notice:

83FR13802 Comment Number:

3504 Mail Envelope Properties (CAOwcK5rLYjCoPUkS6eE7u=UfWZ8R9Sv794_m2ZdCfCn0tJRiug)

Subject:

[External_Sender] Comments from League of Women Voters of New Mexico Sent Date:

7/30/2018 2:20:54 PM Received Date:

7/30/2018 2:21:44 PM From:

Judy Williams Created By:

jkwilliams24@gmail.com Recipients:

Post Office:

mail.gmail.com Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 311 7/30/2018 2:21:44 PM LWVNM Response to HOLTEC Env Rpt 7-30-18.pdf 451792 Options Priority:

Standard Return Notification:

No Reply Requested:

No Sensitivity:

Normal Expiration Date:

Recipients Received:

  "#( ) 



 ! 

 $/,%.,-3





J

,3

 #) '#(#-.,.#)(

#&.)*?P?OI



-"#(!.)(6KINNN?IIIJ

 ?



E(,9!)0



&  

 !  

'.-120.-2'.4'-3



0&/.." )&.(0#,)('(.,*),..).,'#(1".",."*,)*)--#.1-

-/#.&9"#-0&/.#)(#(&/).")()'#(-)#&((0#,)('(.&#'*.--).".

#-#)('%,-(."*/&#1)/&"0+/.#( ),'.#)()(1"#".)-#-#)(9

(#.#)(.)."./&-#.6-)(,3&(/-#'*.-A-/"-/ ,,-6+/3) 

,)-6-1,-61.,61,)(-#,9 #'#. ,-)/,-*,'#..,0#1) -.#)(-

,--#(!.,(-*),..#)(61.,6"3,)&)!36(!)&)!39 )(,(-1#."."

+/3) ." )&.#-/--#)(#(."(0#,)('(.*),.,#(.# #71"0-)'

)(,(-)/.1".1#&&)(-#,(+/.,-*)(-9



.#--.#'.."..",&#-..#'31"#"!)&)!#&,*)-#.),3)/&)'0#&&

),  

 1)/&KIMQBKIJL6K9J6*!9PC9"#-'#(#'/'.#'*,#)

(."*,)*)-JOI?3,-.),!,+/#,)(-#,.#)() #'*.-.)).",-#(.-(

(.#0-*#-#("#.#(!."#-,!#)(9")(&3.#0#.#-/,,(.&3)/,,#(!.."-#.,..&

!,4#(!()#&(!-*,)/.#)(9"*,)*)-'$),#.#)() ."

 ),*,)*)-

3  #-'$),"(! ),.",(#.-/,,(./--9



)(,(FJ@.,0#&#&#.3



 

         B KIIP6**(#2KC ),

1),%,-.."-#.9")-.-) #'*),.#(!1.,(.",&##&#.3) ."--)/,-.)

'#(.#()*,.#)(/,#(!."*,)*)-.#'*,#)-")/&0&/.9

"*,)*)--#.&#-#(4)() 2.,',)/!".9)*).&!,)/(1.,#-%()1(.)2#-.

  1. (."##.0##(#.3) ."#.9"&&)1!,)/(1.,#-*,-(.#((/',) &).#)(-#(

.",6/.1.,+/&#.3(+/(.#.3,',!#(&.-.9/") ."-"&&)1!,)/(1.,

(,."-#."-(#,.&3),#(#,.&3#( &/(3,#(#-",!-,)'*).-", #(#(!

),)#&(!-*,)/.#)(9



L9N9K9J!#)(&,)/(1.,



&-#(#.#(!0,!*,#*#..#)(#(&/#(!-()1 &&)(-#,.".#'*,#)2.(#(!

,)'JRMJ?KIJO6/.."#-0,!)-()., &.*,)$.,#-#(.'*,./,-(

,-#(*,#*#..#)(/.)!&)&1,'#(!/,#(!2.(-.),!9





  "#( ) 



 ! 

 $/,%.,-3





K



M9N9N6M9JK9M)(.'#(.#)(()#--#)(#(!



)#--#)(#(!&(1)/&*,*,.."() 

#&#.3&# (1)/&#(&/

)(.'#(.#)(6#-'(.&'(.6(&(?/**,)/,-7'."))&)!3(!(,&

)(.'#(.#)((&(#(!'.")-7(1-.'(!'(.*,).))&9<

.#-().(.##*.

.".."-.),!-%-),*-1)/&"0,-#/&,#).#0)(.'#(.#)(/-BC."

(#-.,-1)/&,'#(-&1"#&#(."

#&#.39=")0,&&#'*..)1.,

,-)/,-,)'D.#0#.#-#-*,)$..)'#(#'&7 1)/&&#%#.#)(&.),

-)/,-.)-/**),.($/-.# 3."#-*,)$.#)(9



)(,(FK?,(-*),..#)(



.#)(L9R-..-.".."*,.'(.) (,!31)/&,-*)(-#& ),.,(-*),.#(!."

-*(.(/&, /&,)'2#-.#(!),#&(/&,*)1,,.),-.),! #&#.#-.)."



#&#.3#(12#)9

.*,)0#-()-)/,#..#)( ),."#--..'(.6(.",#-()

  1. (#.#)()(."1-#..".#.1#&&,-*)(-#& ),.,(-*),..)."#-

9



)(.#)(8,)0#.") ##&)/'(..#)(#(1"#"."-..-.".#.--/'-

.",-*)(-##&#.3) .,(-*),..#)(.)."#-)(-)&#.

(.,#'.),!#&#.39



.#)(L9R) ."(0#,)('(.*),.-..-<**,)2#'.&3L6III(#-.,-,2*..)

.,(-*),.)0,MI3,-9=.#)(M9R9L-..-<)0,.")/,-) .")*,.#)(&&# ) ."



#&#.36 )&.1)/&,#0/*.)JII6III-) #(**,)2#'.&3JI6III(#-.,-

,)')#--#)(-"/.)1(-#.-()*,.#(!,.),-#.-9=



)(.#)(8),%)1() ")1'(3(#-.,-#.1#&&,#0(,)'1"#"

#&#.#--)#(.,-.*,.#-(.&-..,%."-)/,) ."-..'(.-9



.#)(M9R9J) ."(0#,)('(.*),.-..-<)(-.,/.#)() "-J) ."

#&#.3

1)/&,+/#,(1--,),)'99 #!"13OK>JQI((1,#&,)-*/,,)'."

2#-.#(!,&-,#&,)-*/,.".(-.."

(.,*##(#(! ),." #&#.3L9Q'#&-/

1-.) ."#.9=",#-()#( ),'.#)()/.."+/&#.3) )(-.,/.#)(.".1#&&)( ),

#.",."--,)),.",#&,)-*/,9",#-&-)()#( ),'.#)()/.-)/,)  /(#(!

),1".",12#).2*3,-1#&&-%.)--/'*),.#)() .")-.9



)(.#)(8")'*(3(-.)*,)0#'/"'),.#&#( ),'.#)()/.."

,)6#(&/#(!."(!#(,#(!-*# #.#)(- ),&),#(!*#&#.#-9

.-")/&&-)

  • ,)0#'),.#&#( ),'.#)()/..",#&,)-*/,#(&/#(!&),#(!*#&#.#-6

)1(,-"#*6((3*)--#&)-.),&##&#.3.)12#).2*3,-9









  "#( ) 



 ! 

 $/,%.,-3





L



M9R9L

(#(.,

'*.-



(-.#)(L9R.")/'(.-..-6<#0(#.-*,)2#'#.3.)."-.

-)&.#)(#&).&(.

B

C&)& #, #!".,-6&1( ),'(.(',!(3'#&-. "0(.,#(.)

,-*)(.)(3',!(3,-*)(-.#)(-.".'3(.),/."-0,#.3) 

0(.-,&..).,(-*),..#)(#(#(.-#(0)&0#(!."

#&#.39=",#-()-)/,#(! ),

")1 )&.%()1-1".."-..) .,#(#(!#- ),."- #,-.,-*)(,*,-)((&6(()

  1. (#.#)() ")1'(3*)*&'#!"..,#(.)&1#.",#)&)!#&',!(#-),")1

."3,+/#**9



)(.#)(8"- #,-.,-*)(,-"0(.,#(.),-*)(.)

1-.61"#"

"-'/"&)1,&0&) ,#).#0#.3)'*,.)."-*(.(/&, /&(*,)$.

*#.3) ."#- #&#.39,)0#.#&#( ),'.#)()/.."./&&0&) .,#(#(!6

)'*&#((,#.#)(..#)(+/#*'(. #,-.,-*)(,-1#."#(NI?'#&,#/-./&&3

  • )----6(1"..#)(.")'*(3*,)*)--.),'3(3 ##(#-9



    



",#-()-*# ##( ),'.#)()/.1".*,#-&31#&&-"#**6.")(#.#)(),!) 

."(#-.,-#(!-"#**6."2*.&# .#'),0/&(,#&#.3,.33,-) -.),!6

1".",-"#*'(.-1#&&#(&/-"#*'(.-) '#2(#-.,+/&#.36-)#.#-",.)-")1(3

,#)&)!#&2*)-/,(&/&.1#.")/.--.).".#( ),'.#)(9)'..,")1

!))."-).1,6# ."#(*/.#( ),'.#)(#-*)),6#.(().2*..))*, ),'

/,.&/&.#)(-9



)(.#)(8,)0##( ),'.#)()/.-'*&&)-,)')() ."*,)*)-

/-.)',-) ." #&#.31#."-*# #.#&-)/.."(#-.,-.)"/&6.")(#.#)() 

."')-.0/&(,&(#-.,-.".1#&&-"#**,)'.". #&#.3(-'*&,#)&)!#&

2*)-/,-#(."0(.) #(.-9

(#.#)(6*,)0##( ),'.#)()/.."'#(#'/'

+/&#.3,+/#,'(.- ),(3(#-.,-B()'..,1",."),#!#(C.".1#&&-.),9



    



"#--.#)(#(&/-."-(.(6<#'#&,&36#(."0(..".-*/,#-().)(-.,/. )&.

1)/&.,(-*),.."." #(&L9Q'#&-3"03"/&.,/%9=)-."#-'(."1-.1#&&

"/&)(12#)*/&#"#!"13-5



)(.#)(8,)0#.#&#( ),'.#)()/.1"#"12#)"#!"13-1)/&

  1. (0)&061".&),#(!,+/#,'(.-1)/&( ),.")-"#!"13-.)- 6(

1".%#() ) &)#(!+/#*'(.,)'.".,#(.).".,/%-1)/&(6(")1."

&)-1)/&-/,,)'*)--#&.,,),#-..#0#.39





  "#( ) 



 ! 

 $/,%.,-3





M





M9R9L9K#(.

'*.-



    



"#--.#)(-3-<3*.,(-*),..#)(-%-&#(-#(),(1#."JI,.PJ,

)(-.,/..)1#."-.(-0,#(.--).".')-..,(-*),.#(.-1)/&().,-/&.#(

'!.)."-.)3),-&-.".)/&,-/&.#(,#)&)!#&,&-9=",#-()

  1. (#.#)((31",#(.")/'(..". )&.1#&&,+/#,3*.,(-*),..#)(-% ),

-"#*'(..)." #&#.39

(6."-%- )&.#(.(-.)*,)0#,-",)/#(."&)%

) :*,)*,#.,3#( ),'.#)(9;(# .")'*(3;--&--#.#-.)&#06 )&.-3-6

<*# #&&36."

?

1#&&*.&)(#-.,) (3*,)0((81".",."3

,"),#4)(.&&3-.),(#-.,-#(,0;- ),0,.#&(#-.,-#(;-B-/-##,3

)  #."#)-(C),."&!3(#-.,--/**&#3()1?2.#(.-/**&#,-@."3&&1#&&

-.),&#(

?

9),*%!#(!)  /&1#&&,+/#, ),-.),#(!.

?

9=



)(.#)(8,)0#2*&##.6*/&#&30#&&.#&-)/..".3*) -%-.".1#&&

/- ),-"#**#(!(")1.")'*(31#&&'(!."1-.-.),#('(3# ,(..3*-

) (#-.,-# .",#-(),*%!#(!,+/#,9")'*(3(-.)*/&#&3.,(-*,(.

)/.."'.")-#.1#&&/-.)----."-.#&#.3) ."-%-.".,.).,(-*),..)

(-.),#(12#)9



"*.,L9L)&)!3()#&-



)(,(8 )&.;-!)&)!30&/.#)(#--)()&.(,*),.-9



"(0#,)('(.*),.#(&/-,)---.#)(6#!/,L9L9K6.".)-(;.**,.)

),#!#(&9#!/,LL9J61"#"*#.-'$),!)&)!#&-.,/./,-( /&.-6#--#'#&,9)."

  1. !/,-#.."-)/,- 6KIIP/.."),#!#(&-)/,-) ."- #!/,-,,)'."

JROI-(JRPI-9),'),(."(#+/-,()10#&&.)'*-/-/, .#&-

-/"- /&.-B#&)'*(#-).(,/(L-#-'#0#-)0,."#,&-*,)*,.3C9

)&.-")/&,+/-.)#&#(/-.,3..)#(.# 3(3#(#.#)() (!,) ,."+/%-

),-/-#(#(."(,3,-9 )&.)/&&-)*, ),'-#-'#(&3--@)-.-

1)/&().*,)"##.#09



"12#)#&(-#0#-#)("-1-#.1#."

'*-) &&)#&6!-(1.,

#-*)-&1&&-#(12#)@-!'(.) ."#-'*-/,,)/(#(!." )&.-#.#-

-")1(&)19



)&.)-(;.*,)0#."2.)),#(.-) ."-#.?."**,)2#'.&).#)(#-

-")1()(."'*&)16-)(."'*-#(." )&.,*),.9 )10,6."-'*-

,().&,(."3**,.)-")1-&#!".&3# ,(.)/(,#-9- )&.-..-6



  "#( ) 



 ! 

 $/,%.,-3





N



.",#-(./,&!-1&&1#."#(."-#.)/(,39"#-#-0,.#&1&&6JL6LQL .

  • 61"#"-")/&(;.*)-,#-%.)."-.),!-#.9 )10,6.",1)/&!-
      • &#(,)'."1&&.)!-!.",#(!*)#(.61"#"#-(;.#&&/-.,.9-*#*&#(-(

)-#)(&&3&%(*)--#&32*&)?*,)*,*,/.#)(-)/&*,0(.."#-&%!),

2*&)-#)(9



"'#()(,(#-1.,#-*)-&1&&&).)/.-#."-#.)/(,361"#"#-

',%)(."'*9

.#-L6IKN .*(#-)*,.3,.")(#&,'#( 9

.,#-*)-&1&&-,,-*)(-#& ),.",."+/%---)#.1#.",%#(!

)*,.#)(-9 )&.)-().#-/--."#-1&&#(#.-,*),.@ 2*.-."#-.)

,--9















  "#( ) 



 ! 

 $/,%.,-3





O







 L







) "*.,L@L9Q



L9L9K9K

  

 



 -)'-*# ##(.,-.#-."-,#*.#)() ,."+/%,#-%#(.",!#)(9,."+/%-) &)1

.)'),.'!(#./"0()/'(.1#."#(KII?'#&,#/-) ."#.9"#&."

  • ,)#&#.3) ,."+/%#-,.&)16.")&)!#&",.,#4.#)(*),.-")1(&)1

B#..#)(KC#--)'1"..((().)/(. ),-#-'#"(!- )&&)1#(!,(.6

2.(-#0)#&(!-6&.")/!"

-#-'#')(#.),#(!B#..#)(LC..,#/.-."-.,)(!-.

0(.-) ."*,#)-./#.))#&(!-.#0#.39



BLC999,(.,),-BJRRQ.",)/!"KIINC,)'."-.

-)&.#)(#&).&(.B

C-#-'#

')(#.),#(!(.1),%#(#..".."-.,)(!-.0(.-,),((/&&3#(JRRR6KIII6(

KIIK.",)/!"KIINB.3*#&&3) K9N.)M9I'!(#.//,#(!."#-.#'*,#)C"0(&).

)/.NI'#&-1-.) ."#.9"#--#-'#.#0#.3#--/-*..)#(/3#($.#)() 

1-.1.,,)'(./,&!-*,)/.#)(#(.)*1&&),1&&-B KIIP6.#)(K9L9M9J9MC9

(3 /./,)#&,#&&#(!),,%#(!(."."#.1)/&)/,.!,.,."(N6III .*."9

B  KIJOC



)(&/-#)(2,*.8



#-'##( ),'.#)(,&#-)(."

')(#.),#(!(.1),%6!)&)!3----'(.-(*,0#)/-

,),-9'),!!,--#0('),(*,#.#0-)/,1)/&'),**,)*,#.9



.#)(L9P) ."  (0#,)('(.*),.,---/&./,&,-)/,)/'(.-61"#"

1#&&MN3,-),)&,3KIJR9"-,-)/,-1#&&,+/#,0&/.#)( ),&#-.#(!#(." 

-*,.) ."#(.# #.#)() "#-.),#*,)*,.#-9



(#.#)(& )(,(#-."#('(# #.#)((-/,#(!  ,-*)(-##&#.373&-

1#."(/&,#(/-.,3)1(./,()/&,-/&.#(&-- 0),&)()'#&#'. ),  

().",#(/-.,3-)/,-9)(.#(/- .3(-/,#.3) ."

-#.(-/,,)/(#(!

  • ,#'.,-")/&--/,*,#),.)!,(.#(! #(-/,.)  9



&-)(-#,."-,-) )(,(#(.# #3 #(."  (0#,)('(.

*),.9"(%3)/ ),."#-)**),./(#.3.)0&/.-.#)(-) ."   #(-**&#.#)(

.)."(2*,--)(,(-9 1#&&)(.#(/.)----  > 

)(-)&#.

(.,#'.),!#&#.30&)*'(.-( #(-**&#.#)((&))%- ),1,

.).",-*)(-.)."-)(,(-9















  "#( ) 



 ! 

 $/,%.,-3





P









-*. /&&36





























/#."#&&#'-6"996,-#(.













!/) )'().,-) 12#)

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML18221A676&oldid=4969762"