ML18144A275

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comment (12) Regs.Gov Regarding Holtec-CISF EIS Scoping
ML18144A275
Person / Time
Site: HI-STORE
Issue date: 05/24/2018
From: Public Commenter
Public Commenter
To:
Division of Fuel Cycle Safety, Safeguards, and Environmental Review
NRC/NMSS/DFCSE
References
83FR13802
Download: ML18144A275 (7)
v • d • e


Text

1 ADMRegs-Holtec-CISFEISCEm Resource From:

ADMRegs-Holtec-CISFEIS Resource Sent:

Thursday, May 24, 2018 9:45 AM To:

ADMRegs-Holtec-CISFEISCEm Resource

Subject:

COMMENT #85 Attachments:

NRC-2018-0052-DRAFT-0077 # 85.pdf; NRC-2018-0052-DRAFT-0077 #85 ATTACHMENT.pdf Holtec CISF FDMS Comment Number:

DOCKET ID: NRC-2018-0052 83-FR-13802

PUBLIC SUBMISSION As of: 5/24/18 9:34 AM Received: May 18, 2018 Status: Pending_Post Tracking No. 1k2-937r-8nkl Comments Due: May 29, 2018 Submission Type: Web Docket: NRC-2018-0052 Holtec International HI-STORE Consolidated Interim Storage Facility Project Comment On: NRC-2018-0052-0001 Holtec International HI-STORE Consolidated Interim Storage Facility Project Document: NRC-2018-0052-DRAFT-0077 Comment on FR Doc # 2018-06398 Submitter Information Name: Kevin Kamps Address:

Radioactive Waste Specialist, Beyond Nuclear 6930 Carroll Avenue, Suite 400 Takoma Park, MD, 20912 Email: kevin@beyondnuclear.org General Comment See attached file(s)

Attachments 5 18 18 Why Are All These High Risks Being Taken in the First Place Page 1 of 1 05/24/2018 https://www.fdms.gov/fdms/getcontent?objectId=090000648327e0b8&format=xml&showorig=false 6816,5HYLHZ&RPSOHWH

7HPSODWH $'0

(5,'6 $'0

$ $QQWRLQHWWH:DONHU6PLWK

-LOO&DYHUO\\ -6&

$0..&/5 

16#-*$"5*0/%"5&

$*5"5*0/'3



I

'+! .2014.0032,



"!!%# & !# ! !&% "&

%14&

2014



  

  

 



"3,&&."-"#!",#-%-#(!.%(#(." #,-.*&;),()!)),-)(

1".-)0,:,.#(&3()..)( #.*/&#"&."5- .35-/,#.35),(0#,)('(.&

  • ,)..#)(5-*#. )&.

(.,(.#)(&?39 C)/(.#-D(,!3&&#(

A )&.? B5((/&,*)1,#(/-.,35&#'-(9-*#(.).")(.,,38



,/.".)&5#.<-.).,(- ,.#.&5&##&#.35)-.-5(,#-%-5 ),.""#!"&3,#).#0

  1. ,,#.(/&, /&5,)'."(/&,*)1,&.,#&/.#&#.3)'*(#-.".

!(,.#.5(*,) #.,)'#.-!(,.#)(5)(.)."%-)  ,&.2*3,-A# 

."88*,.'(.) (,!3AB#--./%*3#(!&&."#&&-@(?),)(.)."

%-) (/&,&.,##.3,.*3,-5#  )&.? <-&)3#-.-( #(!&--

.)."')(#-,'#(#(!#(."/&,-./() ,-B8".<-*,..3#!

0),.).")'*(#-@#( .5#.<-/(#+/#(&&) #(/-.,38



() )/,-5#  )&.? ('%&,!*,) #.-A.*/&#2*(-B5

=.'*),,#&3-.),#(!>."-"#!"&3,#).#01-.-A ),LH3,-5.)IJH3,-5.)

!*,'((.&3B51#.")/."0#(!.)-")/&,(3) .")-.-5),,#-%9&##&#.#-5

1&&5.".1)/&1),%1&& ),."':



,8,%))*,) ,')(. 1"))&5#(',JHIK5#("#-2*,.1#.(--

)(.-.)."88/&,!/&.),3)#--#)(<-AB/&,-.

)( #(?)(.#(/.),!) *(./&,/&

A(0#,)('(.&

'*.

..'(.B*,)#(!5&/&..".." #,-.JHH3,-) ),#&#,,#.

(/&, /&-.),!1#&&)-.FJIH.)KMH#&&#)(A3-51#."B8A"#-2*,.

)(.-.R

"..*-7??18,"#08),!?1?JHINHQHQHLJMLI?"..*7??1118(#,-8),!?,1-.?

2"##.JHIK9IJ9IN',%))*, #(&&,.#)(8* S5-1&&-.",&.*,--

,&-.R"..*7??1118&((,!38),!?JHIK?IJ?IQ?1-.9#-*)-&9(,?S8B



#--.#'.--/'.1)(.,&#4#(.,#'-.),! #&#.#-A

-6(-#.

./,(-)/.5 )&.? #(12#)5(-.)(.,)&*#&#-.-5 #(2-

AB@$/-.KP'#&-,)'").",@"0()1)."**&#.) ),



)(-.,/.#)(()*,.#)(&#(--B5)(*,'((.!)&)!#,*)-#.),3A/,#&

/'*5-/,,(.&3.,!../)/(.#(50B5()(!)#(!)(9-#.

-.),!.(/&,*)1,*&(.-5-(8 #-&/&.#)( .#0&3)/&."

)-.-) (/&,9!(,.&.,##.35/-.")-#,,#.(/&, /&

'(!'(.)-.-"(0,()/(. ),5().#(1&&)0,"& 9(./,3) 

),#&#,,#.(/&, /&!(,.#)(#(."88A." #,-.#0#&#(,.),



J

!()*,.#)(-5("#!"&3,#).#0#,,#.(/&, /&!(,.#)(5.

"#**#(!*),.5((-3&0(##(IQMO5NI3,-!)8B



"/-5(.,&#4#(.,#'-.),!5-. )&.? #(5-1&&.#(5

1)/&3.().",-#!(# #(.*/&#-/-#35( #..#(!."(/&,*)1,

  1. (/-.,35)(.)*) '),."("& 9(./,3) -#!(# #(.*/&#-/-##-) 0,#)/-

-),.-8A."(#)() )(,(#(.#-.-<JHII,*),.R

"..*7??1118/-/-8),!?(/&,9*)1,?)-.9(/&,9*)1,?(/&,9*)1,9

-/-##-9,*),.G8 K 4L%S5 ),)'*,"(-#053.-.#&&().2"/-.#05

)0,0#1) ."'(3--),.5/('."3(3).",#(/-.,35*/&#-/-##-

."(/&,*)1,#(/-.,3"-($)3)0,."*-.-0,&-8B



.*/&#)(.'.#(!-#( )-5((,1-5#('#98JHIO5

,7."

*,)*)-&5."(A-#(,*&B5)&.4,5*/-"%

!#(-.."#-,#.##-'8 -#.".." ,&.2*3,#-&,3)&#!..)*3

),#,,#.(/&, /&-.),!5/--#!()(.,.-1#."(/&,

/.#&#.#-#(."'#9IQPH-5*&!#(!.)!#(=.%#(!)/.."!,!>A'31),-5().

&.4,<-B#(IQQP8 *)#(.)/..".."/.#&#.#-"0-/ ),,") 

)(.,.5(1)('!-,)'."88 /!'(./(51"#",1-.2*3,

/(#(!,)'."88,-/,35(/&,9!(,.&.,##.3,.*3, /(#(!

,)'."/&,-./(8



A-/-*(."&#(-*,)#(!5..")'*(3<-,+/-.5#(JHIO8

)10,5=/(,(1'(!'(.5>'3!#(="#.."*&3/..)(>)(#.-

=*/->*,)#(!5.(3.#'()18),'),#( )85-7

"..*7??11183)((/&,8),!?(.,&#49-.),!?JHIP?K?IL?),()9,091-9

#'9.)9,0#09-*(.9 /&9-.),!9*,)$.8".'&8



(1<&&-5/,#(!."#'*(#(!(0#,)('(.&-)*#(!*,)#(!5-1&&

-."&#(-#(.,0(.#)(",#(!-5#  )&.? /.#&#4--#'#&,),#(.#&

,!/'(.-.)<-5.)*/-"%!#(-.)**)((.-8B



1-,#!".)(."#-)(*)#(.788.2*3,-,"'),,"!#(!FMHH'#&&#)(*,

3,#(."-'!1,-5-3)(/&,,*),.5(1,()/.513

%#(JHIHR"..*7??#,8),!?1*?1*9

)(.(.?/*&)-?JHIH?HK?1-.#-*)-&)(.,.-%!,)/(,

 K8* S8



/.)/,,#.##-'./&&3-.#&&")&-8(,."/&,-.)&#3.5-

'(5."(/&,/.#&#.#-A'(#(!."#,&.,##.3)(-/',-58%88

,.*3,-5-1&&--",")&,-B,,-*)(-#& ),#(.,#'-.),!) #,,#.

(/&, /&8,&.2*3,-,,-*)(-#&A/( ),./(.&35().(5

/(1#..#(!&3B ), #(&#-*)-&5#(-)9&&=*!)&)!#,*)-#.),38>



"#--#'*& .5(,/&) &15 ),'."-#- ),((0#,)('(.&)&#.#)(

&..,.)#(.8JHIN5*)#(.#(!)/..".."&#(-**&#.#)(#-#&&!&5

(.".."!(3-")/&-(-#-.,)'*,)--#(!#.8A



K

"..*7??11183)((/&,8),!?(.,&#49-.),!?JHIN?IH?JN?-*#.9

-.%-93)(9(/&,9(9&&#-9)(.#(/9.)9"&&8".'& ),#.#)(&

  1. ( ),'.#)(8B



)- )&.? #(.(.) )).."#&& ),#.-

#(-88;)-#.#(.(.)

--/'.#.&(&##&#.3 ),."#,,#.(/&, /&;,1#&&."(/&,*)1,

/.#&#.#-,.#(.#.&(&##&#.35*3&&)-.-5(--/'&&,#-%-;

."#-#-."-5

."(1"3)-(<. )&.? -#'*&3/.#&#4.",#0./&.),!5 AB



5&,3**,)03)0,!);5.,!..."%/&&&&3

)-"/.

(#(-,0.#)(#(1-.51-"#!"&3)(.,)0,-#&@/.)#.-&.(.

(0#,)('(.&#($/-.#5),#().",1),-5,#).#0,#-'99/..".#(<.

  • ,0(.,)'/&.#'.&3,/,9-.'*#(!."-"'8),'),#( )85-7

"..*7??,"#0-8(#,-8/-?,1-.?-/&&0&&3?-%/&&0&&38".'8



&&5."-#'*&(-1,5()*(-,.5#-7 )&.? )-(E.1(..)-")/&,

.")-.-5,#-%-5(&##&#.#-8A#.",)-."(/&,*)1,#(/-.,38B

)&.? 1)/&*, ,A.".#-.2*3,-5(?),,.*3,-B-")/&,

.")-51"#&#.-#'*&3*)%.-."*,) #.-8



A

(,#&350(.")/!" )&.1)/&"0*,)0#&&L5HHH(#-.,-(-%-

.)-"#*(-.),."LH5HHH'.,#.)(-) #,,#.(/&, /&.,!..."

%/&&&&3)-"/.-

(#(-,0.#)(#(5#.&#'-#(#.- )&.? 5



(0#,)('(.&*),.AB.".1-().&#(-5(),1-(3).",

5

35#(."*-.8"#-#-&.(.&3 &-:#&#(-5)0,!)5

-*#.1#-*,)**)-#.#)(1#."#(5(,)--.")/(.,38")-()..)

/.#&#4#.-*,'#--#)(,)'.))(-.,/.()*,.."

#(8

(3)(

-")/&%()1.".&#(-5#.-")/& )&.8 )1(&&)1 )&.

.)'%-/"&.(.&3 &---,.#)(-#(#.- ),."

#.#-.,!.#(!.-88

;:".#- )&.<-').#0.#)( ),-*1#(!-/" &-"))-#(."&#(-

**&#.#)( ),."

-"';B



/,,(.&1,+/#,- #(&#-*)-&,*)-#.),3.))(-.,/.()*,.#(!

A().$/-.&#(-3B5 ),(.%.#.&(&##&#.3 ),),#&

"#!"&3,#).#0#,,#.(/&, /&1-.-5(-.,.*3#(! ),-/")-.--

.,(-*),..#)(.)(#-*)-&..".*,'((./'*-#.8



*3 ,&.2*3,)&&,- ),*,#0.&39)1((@)*,.

-5

-(.&#(-5)(-.,/.5)*(5()*,.#(!*,'((.!)&)!#&

,*)-#.),38"#-&!&*,)"##.#)(**&#-.)." )&.? <-

-"'#(5

(<-

-"'5KP'#&-13#(8"#-#-().&!&/(,."/&,

-.)&#3.5-'(58%88/,,(.&18



#--%#(!((,/(,)/(."#-&!&)(-.,#(.8,/.".)&5&*"(.#(

.",))')/.5-).))#- )&.? 5&.")/!"."3'3.))-003.))'

,#!".)/.(-3#.#(."#,&#(-**&#.#)()/'(.-8





L

"#-#-0,3,#-%3 ),88 ,&.2*3,-5(?),(/&,&.,##.3,.*3,-8

"&#(%!.1(()*,.#(! #(&#-*)-&,*)-#.),35((.,&#4

  1. (.,#'-.),! #&#.3A

B5#(."/&,-.)&#3.5-'(5#-.)

!/,!#(-.(.,&#4#(.,#'-.),!,)')'#(!!*,'((.5

-/, -.),!5=*,%#(!&)./'*5>.")-.-5&##&#.#-(,#-%-) 1"#"5."88

,&.2*3,5(?),(/&,&.,##.3,.*3,-5'3!.-./%1#."5

  1. ( #(#.&35), ),0,'),8



"#-(,/(,)/(."*,/.#)(,3&#(%!.1(()*,.#(!,*)-#.),35

()(),'),(.,&#4#(.,#'-.),! #&#.#-5.".-%-5(0,3

&#%&3 )&.? &-)-%-51)/&"/!))(.)."(/&,*)1,#(/-.,38

.1)/&2*#..".,(- ,) &&)-.-5,#-%-5(&##&#.#- ),#,,#.(/&,

/&5,)'."(/&,/.#&#.#-.".*,) #.,)'#.-!(,.#)(5)(.)."%-) 

88 ,&.2*3,-5(?),(/&,/.#&#.3,.*3,-5-))(,,.",."(&.,99

0( ), #(&#-*)-&,*)-#.),3#-)*,.#(!8 )(! ),5./&&37."<-

')-.,(.-.#'.5-.)1"(,*)-#.),3()*(5#-JHLP5KH3,-,)'

()1:/.0(.".#-0,3&#%&3()0,&3)*.#'#-.#)*(#(!.:



/"-#!(# #(.&3&,..,(- ,) .")-.-5,#-%-5(&##&#.#- ), ),0,

&35"#!"&3,#).#05#,,#.(/&, /&5'(-."(/&,/.#&#.#-(

1&%13,)'."'--."3<0'&&."-))(,@'(3--))(,@."(

1)/&).",1#-."-/(,/,,(.&15,')0#(!.")-&#(!,#(!&##&#.#-

(,#-%-,)'."#,)1(&!,-5)(( ),&&8



#-&,)/..")-)-.-5,#-%-5(&##&#.#-8"-(, /&5'%#(!#.

&#(-#(!)(#.#)(5.".&&.")-)-.-5,#-%-5(&##&#.#- ),."#,,#.

(/&, /&1)/&-)&&3)(@.".#-5)(88 ,&.2*3,-A(?),5# #.

( #(!&5(/&,&.,##.3,.*3,-50#--#(!."/&,-.

/(B81#&&*.()() .")-)-.-5,#-%-5),&##&#.#-8"#-) )/,--.-/*

'),&"4,1#.""#!"&3,#).#0.1#-.85*,#0.5 ),9*,) #.)'*(35

1#&&"00,3#((.#0.)/.),(,-5(.%-"),./.-)(- .35"/'("&."

  • ,)..#)(5((0#,)('(.&*,)..#)(5#(),,.)-0')(35())-.#.-)1(
  • ,) #.-8.,&&5@88 ,&.2*3,-@1#&&-")/&,#(!&&)-.-5,#-%-5

(&##&#.#-8

(3."#(!!)-1,)(!5#.1)(<.<-*,)&'@#.<&&."

.2*3,-<*,)&':A(?),.".) (/&,&.,##.3,.*3,-5-'(.#)(

)08B



(#.-&#(-#(!**&#.#)()/'(.-5 )&.? "-('),-0035(&--

&.(.5)/.) 9&)#(!)-.-5,#-%-5(&##&#.#-)(.2*3,-(?),,.*3,-8

/.# ."#-#-.,/&3."-51"3."()-(<. )&.? -#'*&3/.#&#4."

&#(-,/,9-.'* ),

.,!...#(35&)1#()'.#0

',#(.,#&,-,0.#)()/(#.3#(A."%/&&&&3() )-"/.

(#(-B;",-)(#-5(#.", )&.? 5(),."(/&,*)1,#(/-.,351(.

.),.#(."..#.&5(.")-)(-+/(.,#-%-(&##&#.#-5&.&)(*3&&.")-

)-.-5--)#.1#."

-:





M

/")(-#,.#)(-,1".#-./&&3=,#0#(!>#-#)(9'%#(!5-/"-

)&.? <-**&#.#)(.) ),*,'#--#)(.))(-.,/.()*,.

#(

-888







%14&2014((& !!# &%

"*  !# ! !&!#/%"(( 

"!!#$ !  !'!!'--$$$(%"(-!#)$ !-



"!"$*   !!% ! !'

!!'--$$$(%"(-") ! -

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML18144A275&oldid=4989628"