ML18142B321

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Comment (6) Regs.Gov Regarding Holtec-CISF EIS Scoping
ML18142B321
Person / Time
Site: HI-STORE
Issue date: 05/22/2018
From: Public Commenter
Public Commenter
To:
Division of Fuel Cycle Safety, Safeguards, and Environmental Review
NRC/NMSS/DFCSE
References
83FR13802
Download: ML18142B321 (8)
v • d • e


Text

1 ADMRegs-Holtec-CISFEISCEm Resource From:

ADMRegs-Holtec-CISFEIS Resource Sent:

Tuesday, May 22, 2018 2:37 PM To:

ADMRegs-Holtec-CISFEISCEm Resource

Subject:

HOLTEC #79 Attachments:

NRC-2018-0052 DRAFT 0069 #79.pdf; NRC-2018-0052-DRAFT-0069 # 79 ATT.pdf Holtec CISF FDMS Comment Number:

DOCKET ID: NRC-2018-0052 83-FR-13802

PUBLIC SUBMISSION As of: 5/22/18 2:23 PM Received: May 11, 2018 Status: Pending_Post Tracking No. 1k2-9339-kofq Comments Due: May 29, 2018 Submission Type: Web Docket: NRC-2018-0052 Holtec International HI-STORE Consolidated Interim Storage Facility Project Comment On: NRC-2018-0052-0001 Holtec International HI-STORE Consolidated Interim Storage Facility Project Document: NRC-2018-0052-DRAFT-0069 Comment on FR Doc # 2018-06398 Submitter Information Name: Kevin Kamps Address:

Radioactive Waste Specialist, Beyond Nuclear 6930 Carroll Avenue, Suite 400 Takoma Park, MD, 20912 Email: kevin@beyondnuclear.org General Comment See attached file(s)

Re: Docket ID NRC20180052 Submitted by Kevin Kamps, Radioactive Waste Specialist, Beyond Nuclear, May 11, 2018 Public Comment re: Risks of Loss of Institutional Control, if De Facto Permanent, Surface Storage, Parking Lot Dumps are Abandoned, Containers Fail, and Release Catastrophic Amounts of Hazardous Radioactivity into the Environment Attachments 5 11 18 Risks of Loss of Institutional Control if De Facto Permanent Surface Storage Parking Lot Dumps are Abandoned as posted at Regulations dot gov Page 1 of 1 05/22/2018 https://www.fdms.gov/fdms/getcontent?objectId=090000648325f3d9&format=xml&showorig=false 6816,5HYLHZ&RPSOHWH

7HPSODWH $'0

(5,'6 $'0

$ $QQWRLQHWWH:DONHU

6PLWK-LOO&DYHUO\\ -6&

&200(17

38%/,&$7,21'$7(



&,7$7,21)5



G

&*

-1/03-//21+



#!% !  %#

% #00%

1/03



$     

 #    #%

 &  # 

 #      "    !

 



A."88*,.'(.) (,!3B1,(#(#.-8HFFH#(&



A(0#,)('(.&

'*...'(.B)(."*,)*)-/)/(.#(50

(.#)(&/,#&/'* ),"#!"&3,#).#01-.-5.".&)--) #(-.#./.#)(&)(.,)&

)0,-/, -.),!-#.-.,.),-1)/&0(./&&3*,)0.-.,)*"#5# .")-

  1. (*((.-*(. /&-.),!#(-.&&.#)(-A#,,#.(/&, /&,3-%

-.),!B1,()((&..)."#, .8



)--) #(-.#./.#)(&)(.,)&'(--)#.&,%)1(5-).".'#(.((5,*#,5

(,*&'(.) #(,-.,/./,(-.),!)(.#(,-. )&.? 1)/&

&)-.)0,&)(!()/!"*,#)-) .#'@#( .50(-#%()1&!) ."0,3

2#-.() ." #&#.3#.-& .",)/&(.#,&3&)-.? ),!)..(-)'3:



(.,)*3'(-.".."#(!- &&-*,.5)0,&)(!()/!"*,#)-) .#'8

.#-."

-)(&1) .",')3('#-5.,&&:1- )/-)(."#-"**(#(!.

(/&,*)1,*&(.-#.-5# #,,#.(/&, /&1-()(.", ),0,8

/.."-'#-.,/",8/-.",!/'(.#(#.-/

-13) 

  • ,--/,#(!-..-A(."#,)(!,--#)(&&!.#)(-B.)-/**),.."*,)*)-

0/'*-#.5&-.-/".-.,)*"/( )&#(."#,)1($/,#-#.#)(-(

#-.,#.-)0,.#'80,'#(.".-*,.&3(/*!,-.)- .3(

-/,#.3.."-,.),-#.-"0!)(/()( ),3,-5(-:



"*,0#&#(!(.#)(&(0#,)('(.&')0'(.)(-(-/-5-#(HFFH5"-(

), ,((9#..),!A B5-&)--*)--#&.)."*)#(.) !(,.#)(5

  1. (),,.)*,0(.-/",#).#0,&--.,.),-#.-8."..'(.) 

,#(#*&- ), !/,#(!/&,-...),-51#."#.-&#-.) -#!(.),3

!,)/*-8P"..*7??#,8),!?1*?1*9)(.(.?/*&)-?HFGF?FI? E



 EI9 HI9GF28* Q



#(-.#./.#)(&)(.,)&#-0(./&&3&)-..." )&.

(.,(.#)(&?39 

C)/(.#-D(,!3&&#(A B(.,&#4#(.,#'-.),! #&#.3A

5),.

."-.)(.,)&*#&#-.-5 ')(#.),,.,#0&-.),!AB-#.#(

(,1-)/(.351-.2-5$/-.IN'#&-),-).)."-)/."-.)  )&.? B5

."-.),!)(.#(,-1)/&0(./&&3 #&5(.-.,)*"#&&3,&-."#,

),0,"4,)/-5"#!"&3,#).#01-.)(.(.-#(.)."&#0#(!(0#,)('(.8

4,)/-(0(&3 &&)/.1)/&."( &)11#."."1#(-(."1.,-5

)1(1#(()1(-.,'A-1&&-)1(."!(,.#)(-5(/*." ))



H

"#(B5)0,!,.,(!,.,#-.(-5)0,(/(#'!#(&3&)(!.#'*,#)8

'',5"#!"&3,#).#01-.,'#(-"4,)/-50(&35 ),.&-.

'#&&#)(3,-#(.)." /./,8"#-1-%()1&!3."88(0#,)('(.&

,)..#)(!(3AB#(HFFN5/(,)/,.),,5#(#.-/)/(.#(/'*

,!/&.#)(-8



((0#,)('(.&)&#.#)(5$)#(3."..) 05 #&&1-/#.#(HFFH5

)$.#(!.)<-..'*..)/.) ,!/&.#)(-./.,$/-.GF5FFF3,-

  • )-.9/,#&) ."1-.)(.#(,-8"88#,/#.)/,.) **&-,/&1#."."

(0#,)('(.&?0)&#.#)(#(HFFJ5),,#(!%.).",1#(!),-

)(#.-/,!/&.#)(-8)/,3,-&.,5*/&#-"#.-'#&&#)(93,-.(,8

.

  1. --.#&&-#!(# #(./(,-.#'.) .""4,<-*,-#-.(5")10,8-/.)(

2'*&5

)#(9GHO5(,.# ##&,#).#0#-).)*5!(,.3,.),-5(

  • ,-(.#(#,,#.(/&, /&5"-"& 9&# ) GK8M'#&&#)(3,-8

.-"4,)/-

  • ,-#-.(#-.&-..(.#'-&)(!,5),$%& :B



/"#'*.-)/&2.(.)-)#&5!,)/(1.,5-/, 1.,5 &),( /(5

2.(#(!.)-#!(# #(.#-.(-)1(1#(()1(-.,') ." )&.? 

-#.5'#13A$/-.)0,IF'#&-.)"B.1(,&-( )-58"

,#-%-1)/&&-)*,-#-.)1(."!(,.#)(-5(1),%."#,13/*." ))"#(

A)(.)*) 1"#"5"/'(--#.B5.",)/!"*,)---) #)9)((.,.#)(5#)9

/'/&.#)(5(#)9'!(# #.#)(8



.55$/-.IN'#&-),-).)."-.9-)/."-.)  )&.? 5."

  1. #.&3$(.5(*,"*-0(/(,&3#(!5!&&&+/# ,51)/&*/.

-#'#&,&3.,#-%8A.",,/-.'*P"..*7??-,.,/-.('8),!?1*9

)(.(.?/*&)-?HFGL?FH?HFGK/*.9",.-*9GG2GM8* Q ),&,*#./,

) ."&3) ."&(#(-88(185(."&,!(/',) #,.35(!,)/-5

("4,)/- )--#& /&5(/&,5().", #&#.#-,&,3&)..",:B



"!&&&(&-))(-#,)1(1#(()1(-.,'8+/# ,-#,.&3

/(,),$(..))/&#(#,.)/(#.#)(1#."."!&&&8&-)5

)1(1#(),)1(-.,'-/, &0& &&)/.,)')/&0(./&&3 #(#.-

13#(.)."!&&&5.",)/!"(./,& &)1*."-A&)1#(!1#."."1#(-5 &)1#(!

1#.".",#(-(-/, 1.,-5*)-#.#)()(.)(#(.)-)#&5)1(1, &)1.)

+/# ,-B8"!&&&5),."',#<-&,!-.5*,)0#---(.#&,#(%#(!(

  1. ,,#!.#)(1., ),'#&&#)(-#(2-512#)5%&")'5 (--5)&),)5

,-%53)'#(!5()/."%).8-."1.,*,)..),-..".(#(!

)%#)/2,#,-,0.#)(-3)(."#--)/,##0,#(),."%).5  5

.,

- # 8"#-1-'0,3&,3,(.,#(%#(!1.,)(.'#(.#)(

#--.,-#(&#(.5#"#!(6",&-.)(5-.#,!#(#6."(#'-#0,#()&),)5

12#)(."6()&)5"#)8,#).#0,&-#(.)5),

)(.'#(.#)() 5."!&&&1)/&.-.,)*"#5 ),'#&&#)(-)1(-.,'8(

    !           

        

          

 #      #  



I

                  

       "



(#.#)(.)&&."#-5!#0(."#,*,)2#'#.35."/'/&.#0#'*.-5(#(.,9

)((.,#-%-5) ." )&.? 5(5

-'/-.,--8

)1'/"5(#(1".13-51)/&.-.,)*"#,#).#0#.3,&-.."

)&.? 5

5#'*.."5

;(0#0,-8



%#(!."-,#-%-&&."1),-5A."88/&,!/&.),3)#--#)(B"-

&&)1+/&#.3--/,(AB #&/,,#-#-.)*,-#-.#(."88(/&,*)1,

  1. (/-.,3 ),().3,-5/.-8"- #&/,-2.(().)(&3.))(9-#.

-.),!-%-.,.),-5/.&-).)."-"#**#(!-%-5(139,)'9,.),

-.),!-%-8"-0#)&.#)(-5-*#&&3#( ')/-,!,#(! )&.)(.#(,-5

1)/&,#-%,&3 #&/,) -%-.." )&.? 

5&.&)(0(./&

!,.#)(,"-)0,&)(!,.#'*,#)-5-/.)1.",#(!5,)-#)(5

),,)-#)(5.8) ." )&.?  #&#.3(-.),!)(.#(,-5-/.)&)--) 

  1. (-.#./.#)(&)(.,)&8



(/-.,399(0(991"#-.&9&)1,-&&..(.#)(.)."- #&/,

,#-%-GN&)(!3,-!)53.&#..&.)()."#(!"-()(.)),,.."'8"-

,0&.#)(-".))#,.&31#." )&.)(.#(,-8

(/-.,31"#-.&9&)1,-,

"#,(#+/-.#)(."-.,/./,&#(.!,#.3) 9**,)0(#(/-.,39/.#&#4

)&.-.),!(#-.,-(-%--#..#(!-.#&&5!)#(!4,)'#&-*,")/,5&.&)(

.,0&#(!LF'#&-*,")/,5), -.,5)(.",#&13-A),.,0&#(!.-&)1,-*-

)("03"/&.,/%-5), &).#(!)(,!-5.)!..",#&9-#4)(.#(,-.)."

(,-.,#&" ),.,(- ,)(.).".,#(.,%-#(." #,-.*&B8"#,(#1-

%/*#("#-&&!.#)(-3#1-.!#)(,3-%-.),!#(-*.),5,8

)-- (-'(51")1,(="-")/&-.)*."*,)/.#)() ."-%-5/.

."3)()."0." $.))#.8"#-#-."%#() ."#(%#(!."./---*

-"/..&-.)"#.."!,)/(8>



=/,3) -,"#,(#<-/&#.3--/,(#)&.#)(-!#(-. )&.

.),!?,(-*),.-%-8>P"..*7??11183)((/&,8),!?(.,&#49

-.),!?HFGM?J?K?-/,39) 9)-,9-"#,(#-9&&!.#)(-9) 9+/&#.39--/,(9 08".'&Q



/" #&/,-5-")3-#!(5(-")3 ,#.#)(5) ."-.),!?.,(-*),.

(#-.,(-%-5'(-.".."#,0(./& #&/,5(,&-) ."#,&3

"4,)/-"#!"&3,#).#01-.)(.(.-51#&&)(&3"**(&&."-))(,8



&.")/!""#,(#( (-'(<-,0&.#)(-1,)/. )&.-%-A.,!. ),

/-.."39 (,!3&&#(*,)*)-(.,&#4#(.,#'-.),!-#.#(

12#)5(). ,,)'5B5<-#()'*.(.-.5),0()&&/-#)(

1#."#(/-.,351"(#.)'-.)-%0#)&.#)(-52.(-.)).",-%')&-

(-#!(-5#(&/#(!A/&,--/,(),*),.#)(B(,0A ),',&3

%()1(-)!'5/.,(.&3,(',()B(#-.,(-%-.)/-.



J

58&.")/!"." )&.? 

?-#.#(1)/&@*,-/'&399

  • ,)'#((.&3/- )&.(#-.,-(-%-5.")'*(3#,!#(#.-



&#(-**&#.#)()/'(.-.".#.--3-.')/&)).(3(&&

9,.# #(#-.,?-%-#!(#(."88"#-1)/&#(&/(,0

(#-.,?-%')&-5-1&&8



/&,--/,(),*),.#)(AB)(.#(,@.)/-.55(

  • ,"*-&-). )&.? 599 #&/,-,) -*# #)(,(8 -././'(5

-")31&#(!3&.).")..)'&#.,&&3 &&#(!)/.) (#,,#.

(/&, /&--'&3.,(- ,35&&)1#(!.""#!"&3,#).#0A(

(!,)/-&3,!#&5#(.,'-) -"),.9(&)(!9.,'-.,/./,&#(.!,#.35!#0(."

2#(!."#((--(,#..&(--) ."4#,)(#/'&#(!)(." /&,)-B

--'&3.)-.,#%.")..)') ."-.),!*))&."&%#0,/&, -#(

(.,#)5(8/"1&#(!&&-#(.)+/-.#)(."1&-)(-.),!(

.,(-*),.)(.#(,--1&&5-/"-.")-*).(.#&&3.)/-. )&.? 5

A(,.#(&3.)/-.5B8



.."0#-9--.)'#,.),)(.",. %--"),&#((,)&)5"#)5

(,0-#!(,(-(/&, -.),!-%1-&)1#."#,,#.

(/&, /&5-*#.&)&(0#,)('(.&!,)/*&!&#(.,0(.#)(-.)-.)*#.5.,#.

1-,0&."1&&-) ."#((,(#-.,")&#(!.""#!"&3,#).#0#,,#.

(/&, /&1-.1,!,)/(.))."#(/,#(! ,#.#)(5#(0#)&.#)() ."

-#!(<-."(#&-*# #.#)(-8/.0#)&.#)(-) =."8-*-8> ),."-#!((

'(/ ./,) -%-#(."88,-,'*(.-0#)&.#)(-8,0

,(-(/&, (#-.,-(-%-1)/&/-.55()/&

&-)/-. )&.? 58



&&."#-)#&-)1(.).",#-%.".*,'((.5()("#!"9&0&

,#).#01-.-/, -.),!51".",.5), )&.? 55)/&

&5-))(,,.",."(&.,5.)-% #&/,5(.-.,)*"#,#).#0#.3,&-8



/"&0&) .#&)/.-*# #0#)&.#)(-) (."8-*-85,!,#(!).",

-%?(#-.,')&-A-/"-."(,!3)&/.#)(-9HJ-5=(.#&..),!

-%->")&#(!HJ*,--/,#41.,,.),#,,#.(/&, /&--'&#-B.".

)/&/-. )&.? 55)/&&-)#.8



5#(#.--)9&&=/&,-.)( #(>,.(0#,)('(.&

'*.

..'(.A

B5--,..".51".",)(9-#..(/&,*)1,*&(.-#.-5),.

139,)'9,.),AB

-A-. )&.? 5656.8B5.")(.(.-

,)' #&#(!,3-%-)/&-#'*&3.,(- ,,#(.),((1,*&'(.

-%-8/.().-#(!&-/".,(- ,"-0,.%(*&#(."88.).5.#(!

%.)."0(.) ,3-%-.),!A.."/,,3(/&,*)1,*&(.#(#,!#(#B

  1. (."'#9GONF-8"#-5-*#.." ..".(/',)/-,3-%-5-.&#--

(/&,*)1,*&(.#(

5,%()1&!3#(/-.,3(?),.)

 .#0A." )/,."9HJ.)&).&#--5#( /(GOOJ51--))(

.",.,%()1&!3."(/&,/.#&#.3.)"0 .#01&-6-*#.



K

  • &!#(!5/(,)."#( ,&)/,.@(*,)'#-#(!."*/&#99.".*,)&',3

-%-1)/&-#'*&3(+/#%&3/(&)%#(.)."-.),!*))&5HJ3,-

"0*--5(&#--"-)(()-/"."#(!1#."#.-'#..&3 .#053.

/&&3&)5,3-%$/-.GKF3,-),-),)'."1.,-)  %#"#!(5-)/,

) ,#(%#(!1., ),'(3.(-) '#&&#)(-) *)*&)1(-.,'B8



--,.#(#.-=/%-.)('>A-,#.#-/#.B

.".()(9

2#-.(.=,3,(- ,3-.'->A-B)/&/#&..-)'/(-*# # /./,

.51#."()%()1(-)/,)  /(#(!5.))'*&#-"."#--%9.)9-%.,(- ,5

1"((8-*#.'(3.")/-(-) */&#)(.-2*,--#(!)(,(

)/.-/"()0,&3)*.#'#-.#5-#( #.#)(? (.-3**,*&(5-.))3#.-

,3,(- ,3-.'=)( #(>#(#.-#(&

A<-*",-=/&,-.

)( #(>".)"(!3."!(35.)."/*"'#-.#=)(.#(/.),!

) *(./&,/&5>-,#.#-" .#0&3"(!."*",-.)."

,)!.),3=/%-.)('>:B



,#!".(#(!&35-'3 (.-3*&()(1"#"( )&.? A(

B(()../&&3&#0,8

(.".-5()('(.(0(./& #&/,) 

/(.("#!"&3,#).#01-.-.),!)(.#(,-. )&.? 5(5#(

."?),,&(-5)/&1&&&.).".-.,)*"#,&--) "4,)/-

,#).#0#.3#(.)."(0#,)('(..".1,()/.-*)--#&.(/&,

  • )1,*&(.-#.-5#(#.-/)/(.#(#(&

#(8HFFH:",#-%.".-)9

&&=#(.,#'>),=.'*),,3>A-# JF3,-5),GHF3,-5),IFF3,-5),0(

'(3-),(./,#-&)(!,5)/&0,&&=#(.,#'>),=.'*),,3>#(

." #,-.*&:B-.),! #&#.#-1#&&)'*,'((.5-/, -.),!5

=*,%#(!&)./'*-5>-#!(# #(.&3#(,--."-&)--) #(-.#./.#)(&)(.,)&

(!,-8



)/)(<."0.).%)/,1), ),#.8,8&&#-)( ,&(5.""#,'(5."

!(3<-.)*) ##&(-*)%-'(51,(#(().)'*(3#(!",/&,

-.)( #(0).-0,&3,-!)5.".&)--) #(-.#./.#)(&)(.,)&#-&')-.

!/,(.)0,&)(!()/!"*,#)) .#'8

(."#-,!,5-"#-!,1#."."

-. A1"#""*,*,."/&,-.)( #(,.

B5-1&&-

", &&)1)#--#)(,-5&&) 1")'2*,--)( #(.".#(-.#./.#)(&

)(.,)&1)/&&)-.5(.".-/",#-%-(().1),,#)/.8/.-/"

&-)( #(5),)0,)( #(5()0,&3)*.#'#-.#--/,(A8%88

."()&)!#&"/,#-B5 &#-#(." ) "#-.),3A()'..,1"#"-)#.35

  1. (-.#./.#)(&)(.,)&#-0(./&&3&)-.5-."-)#.3 &.,-( #&-B5-1&&-
  • "3-#-A."-)(&1) .",')3('#-5."#(!- &&*,.5(.,)*3#(,--)0,

.#'B8,8 ,&(#-(#(.,(.#)(&&3,!,(./,&-#(.#-.1")"-

0).",,,.)-./3#(!(,--#(!."-)#.&(."(#&,#-%-) 

'(!#(!"#!"&3,#).#01-.-8



'%!%#

) ! 

%!.# '' !" 



L

!  (#

)"%&

&,,"""'# ',!(",



Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML18142B321&oldid=4990266"