ML18120A106
| ML18120A106 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | HI-STORE |
| Issue date: | 04/12/2018 |
| From: | Fenoglio E - No Known Affiliation |
| To: | May Ma Rules, Announcements, and Directives Branch |
| References | |
| 83FR13802 00038, NRC-2018-0052 | |
| Download: ML18120A106 (4) | |
Text
May Ma EUe~Joan Fenoglio 4427 Avenida dei So: NE Albuquerque, Nl\\r, 87110-6178 (305) 266-1955, FAX (505) 266-7815 email: EllaJoan@HighFiber.com April 12, 2018 SUNSI Review Complete Template= ADM- 013 Office of Administration Mail Stop: TWFN-7-A60M E-RIDS= ADM-03 A~d= ilnftJ1n~ wcJk.JJr S>>n""
US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001
--S,/1 (!~~~ ~Jsal)
<?3 H.: _ -;_3/'3_QJ~o/~
Re: Docket IS NRC-2018-0052; Holtec lnternational's HI-STORE CIS Facility for Spent Nuclear Fuel, Lea County, New Mexico
Dear NRS:
I respectfully submit -theSEfscoping coh1ments on ~he 1-ioltec Environmental Report (ER) which proposes to bring up to 100,000 metric tons of spent fuel, high-level radioactive waste, from nuclear reactors around the country to southeast New Mexico.
f'subrr1it ftf~se)9qm_rn~hts 'b'ecailise l do*:_~c'fcdnsent fo New Mexico becoming a national
- .. l~. '*'.*. _,~
~l~
~
- ......... ~*:*o.,r..,.*
~....
'.t.. ***-**
""'f--,-~_,...
~
rad1oact1ve *waster dumping ground. !'do not consent to the transport of up to -10,000 cariisters e>f ~igNy radi~~ctive wa~te ~hrough thousands of communities nationwide. I do _'not consent to the cohtaminatiori of cur la'rtds:' aquifers~* air *and !health Of plants, yvildlife and*Hvestock':'- I 'dd':n6t '66nsenHo eridarigering present and* future geherations.
- ... --~
.. *:-::.1r**:. '.i.. *.:*;.
"_;,.* :*:...... i*:.i:.-~* *:.*... *.: r>
- .;:*.:**.*.. \\::*~:
- .. *-~,,
Hofn,ailiretjues't'.a'60~day*Extensiori 'OfTime for:'this Comment Period..
- The.
543~page technical document is too extensive to allow comment in 60 days. We need
- rnbre'time'.. Thank* yoi{(~r 'cohsidering the Extension request..
.This Holtec Proposal is* contra~) to-~urrent law. Holtec must -.remove'from.its Environmental Report copyrights and _alFredacted*m.ateriaL The ER fails to analyze the impacts. of permanent storage. And more alternatives must-be analyzed by Holtec.
,-..:* *-,~):-* __ ::~:._.**~*-.:~.. ::_:*_/:ff'. ;*~*.1C.~~:L,::.?ti-f. :~~ f"";-:,, ~;_/_i(:i;*;~t*\\:.:.. ;(*1 '.:)l~\\.,,:/...-\\t_; :**:...LL.* t;...i:-t.-.~ ::..: !-./,... : :*:.. ~\\.-:
. ~** ::
. The_ER. is: lnadeqtiate'for~everal niore*:reasohs:'ifdoes** not contain.an adequate dis~ussion_ o~t~~ Jrans.portation risks, of the cons.equ~nce to an accident-exposed.
ihdividu*a1, bf the-cracked and, leakir'ig casks,*'of tfle*seismic impacts *on storedicasks, of the imp~c(ot' r~tease fro'm WI PP,* and of future:raiiroads and* electric lines.
.. ~
- .' }.:~~
1i" :.~:***~:<**.. :~~- * *.. :',: :.*~.,.f:.:.,.:-- ~~-*-<.. **t..
(*;*~*4-~(~;-.:~:1~.1 ')}. *~.. _.. *J U~,**;t} 1 _?
-*~
~
I.
- . *'.* ::. *Hov/man'y Ofthe'estfrrfatfic{ 135jdbs:created'.bYfhe Holtec Proposal.will.be given tcf loq~I' re~*idents:r? . Hrdw h1'ucff Jbb' train ihgiwHl~ oe ;provided tcHhose *employees?< ** :
- .. *:.. : -*i 1
tf._. ;-.,_.. '.G.. :,;**.i' ;~.,*;:.~** t;~** ;\\_:*~. ::.:*~ *'... :f*:~*:/: ~?t/~:*;~_lq '}*!:; CC.'~L1.fi.AJ\\. ~':.f';.:-,_rp\\.*.~.:;*: *
... t\\t\\\\~-~~
'1Ct*
....... -,ti.:_>.,~;*~ i\\~;..,v);; (;t... ):*_.f-,.. :*:.:,.) ~,-h*t _;-:-.':.?L~(:,(:.~.;:*::._:, J(;. <:*:".}f} :.. t*... *,p.;t:*. [t:"1:..J~* r:,;... S~JCL:"[,r*1,.~.:?
... d.>'J*h-
- Tlfati'k you:fo'r'y'ot:iri'atte'r1tloii to my cortfrnehts artc:Hor.-y'our:tiineHuid efforts on
this issue so important to New Mexico.
- ~ ~ '*~; ;***
- : r *~~~* r~.! \\'~ '.',;~~-*s-~ :)t,Jrj;/*i
_..,.,*.. ;*,0* ;_::**:(,
\\
- ,::._r.- **:~r. ;.* *-;~.
- \\,
. :t* :.. *'
EUr;.Joan Fenoglio 4Li127 Avenida dei So: NE Albuquerque, Nl\\ij 87110-6178 (305) 266-1955, FAX (505) 266-7815 email: EllaJoan@HighFiber.com April 12, 2018 May Ma Office of Administration Mail Stop: TWFN-7-A60M US Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001 Re: Docket IS NRC-2018-0052; Ho!tec international's Hi-STORE CIS Facility for Spent Nuclear Fuel, Lea County, New Mexico
Dear NRS:
I r'espectfullysu't:,mit.the'se'scoping 66h-iments oh 1:he Holtec Envjronmenta!.*
Report (ER) which proposes to bring up to 100,000 metric tons of spent fuel, high-level rad.ioactive waste, from nuclear reactors around the country to southeast New Mexico.
f :suomlt th:esetcOmments ltSeca~1e l Ho' :r/c't-'6dnsent fd Ne~v' Mexico becoming a* national radioactive\\Nast'e* a*ump-irig 'grourta.: !:'de/riot cohseht.to the tra1isport of up to *10,000 canisters of highly radioactive waste through thousands of communities nationwide. I dq-not c_cjr;s~0t to the c6htaminatiofi of cur la'h'ds;'*aquifers; air'and:hea!th of plants, yv1iqlite' and.-Hvestock? 1 'dc{n6f66nsenHo endangering present and-future generations:
'. :*:_i (. *.~
. i _:*.::~
'.,*. '.'* :.:*;' '.,;~_ *:-:!'
~.... ~..'":
- -~-,, : :,.,.. '::*
- ~.. * **.
- *.. ~
- - - \\-::*.... -.
rfcHrtlafly'.retjuest.-.:f EfO~day'Extension ~of.Time fo(this*Conime~t Period.
- The.*,
543-page.technical document is too extensive to allow comment in 60 days. We need rtibre' tim*e. : Tharik\\idi.do'r 'considering the Extension request..
... ' 1*'. '.
This Holtec Proposal is contrary to current law. Holtec must remove from its Environmental Report copyrights and all, redacted* material. The ER fails to analyze the irnpa~ts,9f pe.rmanent storage. Arid m,ore alternatives must*be analyzed by Holtec.
~,, ; ~.... * *... : ~..:*.....,,,..: r :;.. : :_! ~ : '3; 1 -~~.,,c;:i:: L*, ~ :)\\.: f. !8 ;-~~~l ~:-1.:G C ;_;'.:n '\\:::, (C~ ~-; ti \\)l/1 t* :,:....u-... L.5(..: [. ;:.) i:.~* \\.. : :* *. :.~ *.:\\..-:
. Th~ EFf 1s'* inad~qu'ate' fo{ §everal more* rea'sons':! it 'does: not: contain :an adequate discussion of the transportation risks, of the consequence to an accident-exposed ihdividll~I, \\>rthe cracked and* leak1ng casks/o'f ttl'e seismic :inpacts on storedi casks, of the im~~-bf6t'r~'fease fr<>nrV\\liPP/and offuture 'railrcfads *an\\le!e'ctric lines..
..i.
. t.;.: *:*.~.*. ::-1~:.. ;~*1;n.. ~.~~*::."~C=.. ~:,.,~.:. ~~.1 t* ::.1~<*::....,.i '.'... ~:,,*:.:~.. : r~:,J~*/~"::~,,.1 *~;,*~,'l\\ *:>....i~J~tJ.J()u.-.:,::
. '/,:*--.. :.,.
- .'<*,** *. H6v./rriar','.y bfthe"~~ti~natP.c{ 135"jobs* cfeatedljy tlie Holtec Proposalwill,be given lci'lo6,a1,resi~ents~( l~lov(/m'u6ff Jbfr traini'ri~::vi1Hf 15G;provided :td'those *employees?,:*: :* * * *:
- .*,.; r *:'. _., '..~:,.. ;*',::,~~c-=.*.~.,... \\.*.:_:,,*,* \\.;<-_~.. ~>*'.:_.~
... :.. _~'"',_.:...:_*,., :*-_:_._*/:.*', '.~:-.:_.~(_.*~:{.' ~H/)t**~ uq /}~ G !.:-~..: :*: ~JpJ,.if ~)C,tLtt.I\\... :.... ~**.
I.
- -~---ri.\\ /* ~:., * !:*ci
.~*} -..: 1)(:.'*:*>J(; :.. ~f'" *p.. ~c ['::~...r~* (:,_:*. S~Jf.>i.:'f _1r,c:;::*._;~{;*'.. :.. J:~ -
Tliar1*k you!fb°r'y'ot'.lrtatter1t1on' to rny conime*nts aric:Hor,y*bur:timeH3rid efforts on
'*"\\Ir:' I'.~
- l *'
- J
this issue so important to New Mexico.
\\~T
- ~**\\ ~ ~-j ;*~: :* f *\\~) r,;*:i_.::
- )<.~t~**s; *.*
- -,u,)~/\\
.\\'*~_r::.. ~*:.0-:~ {?r~t\\.,-.\\ -1
.~~;i~*~~j~... ~Jr\\~:*:.:*,.;::-
...... _J;;
- .* -.:t*
.*.,*,.