ML18113A983
| ML18113A983 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Prairie Island  |
| Issue date: | 11/16/1978 |
| From: | Lainas G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| To: | Schwencer A Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 7811290076 | |
| Download: ML18113A983 (3) | |
Text
MEMORAl1DUM FOR:
FROMf
SUBJECT:
- NOV 1 6 1978 A. Schwencer, Chief5 Operating Reactors Branch #1~
- Division of Operating Reactors G. Lainas, Ch{ef~ Plant Systems Branch, Division
- of Operating Reactors FIRE PROTECTION REVIEW - PRAIRIE ISLAND NUCLEAR GENERATING PLANT> UNITS l AND 2 In a letter to the licensee dated January 31, 1978,. we requested
. information and presented five staff positions that re$ulted from our initial re\\ln:ew of the licensee's fire protection program.
The licensee provided tne'::information and his responses to the staff positions in a letter dated April 18, 1978. Subsequently, an.additional review was performed following reassignment of the task to a different review team. This review resulted in the development of requests for additional information which were teletyped to the.licensee on September 13, and September 19~ 1978. This request for additional information is included as Enclosure l to this memorandum.
During the site visit the licensee provided the review team with infonnal responses* t_o the items 1 isted in Enclosure l and. agreed to confirm tillese informal responses in a letter.
During the period of October 16 through October 20!) _19789 the NRC fi.re protection review team visited the Prairie Island Plant.
On
- October 20s an exit meeting was held with the licensee to discuss staff concerns ~rid positions. The list of attendees at the exit meeting is provided* in Enclosure 2.
A summary of the items that the licensee agreed to complete in response to the concerns raised by the staff is provided as Enclosure 3. The staff concerns and positions which were discussed with the licensee at the exit meeting and rEmctlin as open items are listed in Enclosure 4.
The review te~m*s review of the licensee responses {NSP ltr. of April 18, 1978) to the first five staff positions resulted in modified staff positions which were discussed with the licensee at the exit meeting.
These modified staff positions are listed in Enclosure 5.
- .During the site visit the licensee provided responses to the additional information requested*by the staff. A review of these licensee re~~onses
~ogether with a review of the notes taken by the review team fiuring *
- , the site visit have resulted in certain additional staff concerns
- and positions which have not been discussed with the licensee and also r.emain as open items *. These are identified in Enclosure 6.
1~ l\\ ;>-qoo1c;,
OFFICE:11'-
'suliNAME ~
..................................................................................................... ~................................................................................. -
ElATE,..............................................................................................
NRC F0RM 318 (9-76) NRCM 0240
- U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 197e -
626-624
-:-.,~)-
'*-~-*'!"--
- NOV 1 6 1978 In order to obtain a timely resolution of the noncerns identified in and 6~ these concerns should be transmitted to the licensee and the licensee should be requested to address each of these concerns in the following way:
- 1.
Commit to implement the staff position;
- 2. Prppose an alternative method to resolve the staff's concern; or
- 3. Provide the basis by which the present fire protection program addresses the concern without further action.
It is requested that a meeting with the licensee be scheduled approximately one week after receipt of the licensee's response to the open items listed in Enclosure 4 and 6.
Enclosures:
As stated
Contact:
V. Panciera X28077 cc w/enclosures:
V. Stello D. Eisenhut G. Lainas B. Grimes V. Benaroya R. Ferguson P. Matthews T. Wambach G. Lainas~ Chief Plant Systems Branch Division of Operatin~ Reactors M. Grotenhuis J. Riopelle I. Asp E. Sylvester V. Panciera M. D. Ricken - I&E, Reg. III DOR:PSB ~
E. Sylvester 11 / \\le /78 C. D. Feierabend - I&E, Prairie Island NRC PDR PSB Section C NRC F0RM :!18 (9-76) NRCM 0240
- u: s. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE2 1978 - e2e-e24
,' /
-~~-
MEMORANDUM FOR:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
NOV* 1 6 1978 A. Schwencer, Chief, Operating Reactors Branch #1~
Division of Operating Reactors G. Lainas, Chief, Plant Systems Branch, Division ofoOperating Reactors FIRE PROTECTION REVIEW - PRAIRIE ISLAND NUCLEAR GENERATING PLANT~ UNITS l AND 2*
In a letter to the licensee dated January 31~ 1978, we requested information and presented five staff positions that resulted from our initial review of the licensee.'s fire protection program.
The licensee provided the information and his responses to the staff positions in a letter dated April 18, 1978. Subsequently, an additional review was performed following reassignment of the task to a d'.ifferent review team. This review resulted in the development of requests for additional information which were telepyped to the licensee on September 13~ and September 19, 1978. This request for additional information is included as Enclosure l to ~is memorandum.
During the site visit the licensee provided the review team with informal responses to the items listed in Enclosure L During the site visit
, the licensee agreed to confirm him informal responses to these items*
fn writing.
During the period of.October 16 through October 20, 1978, the NRC fire protection*review team visited the Prairie Island Plant.
On October 20, an exit meeting was held with the licensee to discuss staff concerns and positions~ The list of attendees at the exit meeting is provided as Enclosure 2. A sun:mary of the items that the licensee agreed to complete in response to the concerns raised by the staff is provided as Enclosure 3. The staff 9oncerns and positions which.were discussed with the licensee at the exit meeting and ramain as open items are listed in Enclosure 4.
The review team's review of the licensee responses (NSP ltr. of April 18, 1978) to the first five staff positions resulted in modified staff positions which were discussed with the licensee at the exit meeting.
These modified staff fil.~sitions are lf;sted in *Enclosure 5.
During the site visit the licensee provided responses to the additional information requested by the staff. A*review of these licensee responses together with a review of the notes taken by the revi-ew team during*
the site visit have resulted in certain additional staff concerns and positions which have not been discussed with the licensee and also remain as open items. These are identified in Enclosure 6.
.......1
- I I
I l l
- lsURNAME ill'-
NRC F0RM 318 (9-76) NRCM 0240 U. S, GOVERNMENT P~INTING OFFICE: 1978 -
626-6~4