ML18101B088
| ML18101B088 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Salem, Hope Creek  |
| Issue date: | 11/03/1995 |
| From: | Eric Simpson Public Service Enterprise Group |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
| References | |
| LR-N95169, NUDOCS 9511090188 | |
| Download: ML18101B088 (6) | |
Text
. ' '
E. C. Simpson Senior Vice President - Nuclear Engineering
,1\\: "*
~~'
Public Service Electric and Gas Company Public Service Electric and Gas Company P.O. Box 236, Hancocks Bridge, NJ 08038 609-339-1700 NOV 0 3 1995 LR-N95169 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 Gentlemen:
ASME CODE CASE N-532 SALEM GENERATING STATION UNIT NOS. 1 & 2 HOPE CREEK GENERATING STATION FACILITY OPERATING LICENSE NOS. DPR-70, DPR-75 & NPF-57 DOCKET NOS. 50-272, 50-311 & 50-354 Public Service Electric and Gas Company (PSE&G) requests approval, in accordance with the requirements of 10CFR50.55a(a) (3), to use American Society Of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Code Case N-532, "Alternate Requirements to Repair and Replacement Documentation Requirements and Inservice Summary Report Preparation and Submission as Required by IWA-4000 and IWA-6000 11 (Copy Attached) for Salem Generating Station Unit Nos. 1 and 2 and Hope Creek Generating Station.
The use of this Code Case is not presently referenced in NRC Regulatory Guide 1.147, "Inservice Inspection Code Case Acceptability -
ASME Section XI Division 1 11, Revision 11 dated October, 1994.
Code Case N-532.provides an alternative to the current ASME Section XI repair and replacement documentation requirements, and regulatory reporting requirements related to Inservice Inspections.
NRC Letter SECY-94-093 dated April 1, 1994 provides the NRC's recommendation to eliminate the need to submit summary Inservice Inspection (ISI) reports to the NRC following each refueling outage in accordance with ASME Section XI, Article IWA-6000.
The NRC recommended that code reporting requirements per IWA-6000 be modified through its representation on the ASME Code Committee to reduce licensee burden and eliminate the need to submit the ISI summary reports.
Consistent with the recommendations in the NRC SECY Letter, it is PSE&G's intent to not submit periodically the Owner's Activity Report identified by Code Case N-532.
The Owner's Activity Report will be completed by PSE&G in accordance with Code Case N-532 and will be available for NRC review upon request.
The cost effective alternatives afforded by this Code Case have been determined by the ASME to provide an acceptable alternative to existing requirements.
The alternatives provide a substantial
~
Printedon
~
Recycled Paper
'0" C f1 f'~,f:<l.j F
.;::)...._; l.J 4 /
9511090188 951103 PDR ADOCK 05000272 P
Document' Control Desk LR...!N95169 2
NOV 0 ~ 1995 reduction in the overall administrative burden each of PSE&G's plants are required to meet in accordance with the requirements of IWA-6000.
Further, this Code Case does not create any technical changes that would impact the existing ISI programs or the Technical Specifications at either Salem or Hope Creek, and does not introduce a condition that would compromise existing levels of safety or quality.
Should you have any questions on this submittal, please contact us.
sincerely 'f re c
Mr. T. T. Martin, Administrator - Region 1 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 475 Allendale Road King of Prussia, PA 19406 Mr. L. N. Olshan, Licensing Project Manager - Salem
- u. s. Nuclear Regulatory Commission One White Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Mail Stop 14E21 Rockville, MD 20852 Mr. D. Jaffe, Licensing Project Manager - Hope Creek U. s. Nuclear Regulatory Commission One White Flint North 11555 Rockville Pike Mail stop 14E21 Rockville, MD 20852 Mr. c. s. Marschall (X24)
USNRC Senior Resident Inspector Mr. R. Summers (X24)
USNRC Senior Resident Inspector Mr. Kent Tosch, Manager, IV NJ Department of Environmental Protection Division of Environmental Quality Bureau of Nuclear Engineering CN 415 Trenton, NJ 08625
"'l!j.. ***' *'.
\\ e N-532 Ai:iproval Date: Dec11mbur 12, 199*f Seoe Nwr.~rir: Index for e>cpl~arion and any ~a~irmation dates.
Case N-.532 AJtemlltlve Requiremenl:s lo Rcpaia* and Reph1ccment Documentatioll Requirements and lnser.iice Summary Report 1'1-epar:ition. and Submission 3$ Required by IWA-4000 and IWA*
60001 Section Xl, Division 1 ln.quiry: What alternatives may be used to the r~
riuirement<; nf JWA-4910(d) and IWA-6210(e) fnr completion of 'Form NJS-2 following repair or re-placement, and IWA-6210(c) and (d). IWA-6220, IWA-l'i230(b), (c), and (d), and lWA-6240(h) for preparntinn and submittal of the inservice summary report nnd 'Form NJS-1?
Re.ply: It is the opi11ion of the Committee that as an alternative to the requirements of 1WA-4910(d),
IWA*6210(c), (d), and (e), IWA-6220, IWA*6230(b),
(c), ancl (a), and IWA-6240(b), the following provi*
sions may be us<.:d. This Case shall be utilized at least until the eml uf Lhc inspection period in whic-h it was invoked.
1.0 CERTU:'lCATlON OF THE REPAIR OR RR'pLACEMENT (a) The Owne~*~ Repair/Replacement Program shall identify use of this Cnse.
(b) A Repa.ir/Repiacement Plan shall be preriared in accordance with JWA-41401, and sha!J be given a unique identification number.
(c) Upon completion of all required activities as-
~mciated with the Repair/Rcplac=ment Plan, the Owner shall w:~9are. a REP AlP./REPLACEMENT CERTIFICATION RECORD, FQRM NIS-2A..
( d) *Form NIS-2A shall
- be p1"CSCntcd to the l:Iispcctor for certification.
'All rcfcrc:nc:c.~ tO IW A-4000 and J W A-6000 \\l:;cd in lhi~ C"'..<iile 1*efer ro cbe 1992 Edition.
(a) Thi!: completed Form NlS-2A sha.il be main-tained by the Owner.
(fl The Owner shall maintain an index of Repair/
Replacement l'bms in accordance wirh IWA-63'10.
The index shall identify the identification number required by (b) above and the inspection interval and period during which each re.pair or replacement was completed.
2.0 OW.N.1£R.'S A(."fMTY REPORT PREPARATlON AND SUBMl1TAL
.An OWNER'S ACTIVITY REPORT FORM OAR-1 shall be prepared and c:crlific:d upon com-pletion of each refueling outasc. Each Form OAR-1 prepared aurin.Q an inspection periml shall be sub-mitted following the end of the inspection period.
Each Form OAR-1 shall contain the following:
(a) Abstract of applic11hll:l examinations and tests with tbe information and format of Tahle I.
(b) A listing of item(s) with flaws or relevant con-ditions that required cval nation to rletermim: ac*
ccptability for continue(!. service, whether or not th-1::
flaw or relevant condition was discove1*ed d*irins ;1 sclicdulcd examination or test. The listing shall pro-vide the informi:!tion in the format of Tub1c 2.
(c-) Abstract for repairs, replacements and correc-
. *Live measures performed, wMch were required due to an item conLaiuing a flaw or relevo11t condition that e:tcceded IWB-3000, IWC-3000, IWD-3000, IWE-3000, IWF-3000, or I\\VL-3000 acccpu:mce cri-teria; even though the discovery of the flaw or r<.:l(;*
vanl cundiLion chat necessitated the repair, replace*
ment or c.:urrecLiYe measuce, 111ay"11ot have.-1'esulted from <ln e}:'aminatiun ur Lest required by thl£D~sto~.
If acceptance c:rit.::ria rnr a paiticular item is not spe.c~fied in thi.s Division, the _pmVisions of IW A-3 IOO(b) shall be use.d to determine which repairs, replacements, and <:orr~.tive measiircs are required to be included in th~ abstract. The abstract shall pro-vide the information in the format of Table 3.
SUPP.11 -
NC
!\\)-\\] gCf
- r. \\
N-532 FORM NIS-2A REPAIR/REPLACEMENT CERTIFICATION RECORD OWNER'S CERTIFICATE OF CONFORMANCE I C!l'!l1V t1'1St t!ii!!
Flan number------
_ --* _conforms to the require:mcms ot Section X!.
Type Cao* Symbol Stamp--------------
Ccrt:ific~t" nt AUTl'lorlzatlan No.---------------- '="riinuinn 011tn ----------
Sicrncct ___ _
~---- 0<1t111 -- *..
CERTIFICATE OF INSERVICE INSPECTION I. the unucrsigm:-.1, ! 1ult:i11g t> v111id r.on1rnlsslcn lssued bv th* Natifln1i l311;11rd of Boller ar'ld PrC33Urc-V~sc:I :r"pcctor:; :;nr.t '
tl'le Sn1e or Pro11i!',ce of
-- a.id employvd by of
hlVEI ln1pe,;t.11 th* itcm1 dn;ribt=d in Ftep*ir/Re;:ileee,.,.,c.,!.
flll'I numoe~
<.JurirtcJ the i:n11iocl-. *-
to Md :stat;:, tl\\et to the be'1 ot my knowledge 11nd bet!sf, the Owm:r "~ 1.1c1fo1m~11 all the actlvltlas described in trl r.1pairlne;l11;:omc"t Plun I
~*+-in.a*ecore1ar1.:e wrm tlW! re~uirementll of Sccliun xr, By atgnlr19 tl'llS eel'll1!cate r1elther the lnspactor nor hi~ crr1ptove' mske£ an!( warr.al/"1l';, 11XpreS1Sed or impli*d, 1:11;1n~eming the activities deacrlbed II'\\ tl'e net:1ll~/ll1plc11"11~nt i:i11r1. Furtli!)rmtiMJ. 1mirhor TM i1'1SPliCtor ncr-t1l1 limploy1r 1hilll be liilbls in any ma Mer tor ;in*1 p~rsona1 il'l(Ury or property d1!l'lllg1 or :oss of ;my.. ind ari:li110 from or connected with this lnspactian.
COl'l'lmlGSlOM --------------------
-"'"* *~
Oi.te -----------
-~.;.;...-
'T'lil!! form iED01261 mav be obtain!ld from.'It;c Q.td~r iJ\\iµt., ASll/IE. 22 uw Drive, Box 2300, Fairfltld, NJ.07007*2.JOO.
SUPP.11 - NC
~*
I J
\\. e N-532 FORM OAR-1.OWNER'S ACTIVITY REPORT
.. *====:::.....:..====:........=====::".':'""".====-=======-===
Plant-~-
Unit Nr;, *-------- *- Ccr'lmC;~lsl servic" date ------------A1:fllc*lir1g outage'"'* ___.. __
C:..ir~ent il'ISl"l!!ctien i11lr:1*1al ------- -------
(l<r, 2nd. Jra. 4tl1,.. 111;11)
Date and r~vision ¢f l~spectic11 tllan -------- ----------------------------
Edition arid Ad1.ll:nda of sec:tlo~ XI upplic:sbla to n:?11i~ one!,,,,.,111camenc.. if dlffer~nt '"'"' tne in:si::ee:lcn glen--------
CERTIFICATE OF CONFORMANCE I ~~rilfv th<1t !n" "tatements made In thi~ Ow1ler'& ~lty Reper\\ ara ccrr9c:t, or.d thm tnc r.ac11min1tions. tQ!:t!l, rep;oir"*
1'6placamcnl~. eval~*;itiom1, and corrective mcDi;ur.:$ represerll*d by 1hi$ repcn co~r:n to tlic *~l't*lil'tmlentli of Se~cn JC1.
C~l'!lfa:ata of Auttiori>::itien No. --------------- e.. pirallon Datw -----
(11 IDlllic:blol s19r1ed _____________ _
*-------Cate __ ~
Owl'*' or Owner'! Dc:Jlgnw, Till*
Cl!RTIFICATI: OF INSERVICE INSPECTION I, 1111 urnJc:i~ignad, hCl~lng *a valid (.'Qll'1miuion i1111ed by the NMional lit:rord _of Br.iilAr ;ond P:"essurc Vessel ln&gcclur~ and I
!!1.!! s,~ate ar 11ro11inc* at
. *--.. nd emr>'OV!?-~. nv ot,.
he11e inspected the item~--.
- I ~c:;:1 1
~ ~: ~~::::::~i;b:::.::~:~~~~===:gr~@d (~*~c'i~*-it-las-.""'r_e_p_n;::_1_cn_1:-bv-th-is r.*_p_c_rt_i_n_9_cc_o_rd:::fi;~:
1 rec:;uiremCl'!!S of S*ct~n.XI.
By s_lgnlng thi:.; c~rtifir;:ata ntltl'ler !he ln11p11croi* nor hi1 employer mtlltM 1ny w11rrinfY, expre!i5<.1rl *,., i,,.;plie::I. coneerl'llng the exam'.r<niol'la, rests, rui,Nir$, r1pl;11;e,,,enu, ev..ilu~llons anc c;gr...cti11c mm1"uru ducribod ~his re::iort. l'urttiermo-e. "!either the iru;;pr.ctor nor his empi4lver :;h;ifl b~ liable il'I any manner tor any pcr1onlill injury <11 prop11rty darr:ige or a ieH.,r ar'r( kind iltisl.,g.
!rem er ~cn:lected V'<ld': tills inspt:clio11.
I
COl'l'll'l\\IHians I
N1110nal 8G01:d, Si.I~. t'1'<**inet, *ncl EMor:iemcnt::
COUt---* *-------
Thk tnrm ;1:oo~:v) ITlilY be otimlnoo lru111 L11t 01'/Jlll' Dept.* ASMF.. 22 Law Dr've. Bo>i 2300, F;:iirfir.111. NJ 070C7-:noo.
I Jvq \\
1'-\\
\\.
N~s32 EX11min;itlon Category
--~~----
TABLE 1 ABSTRACT" OF EXAMINATIONS MJD TE'STS I
Total Exam inatlons RQquircd for The Interval Total e:xamim1tions Credit~{%)
For The Period Total Exarniri<iticns Credited (%) To Interva:
Rema:1<s I
i Ii Dale for Th~
1
\\
~*~-~~~_._ ______ _._ ______
_....~~~~~---'------~_._~~~~~
Examim1tlcn Category TABLE 2 ITEMS WITH FLAWS OR RELEVANT CONDITWNS THAT REQUIRED EVALUATION roR CONTINUED SERVICE Item Ni.Imber rtem Oest:rli:illon TABLE 3 Flaw Charactl!~lutlon (IWA-~31l0)
Fli!W or R~evant C:onditi an Found During Scheduled Soctian XI f::'.xamination or fest (Yes or No)
ABSTRACT OF REPAIRS, REPLACEM£NTS, OR CORRECTIVE MEASURES REQUIRED FOR CONT1NU ED SERVICE i;raw or Rtlev<1nt condition Founa
- Repair, l
During Sehed1.1l@d Replacement; I
S~i11n X.l Recairi Cade or Corre:tlve Item Decripticn Examination ilr Dcite ReplaC!lmen L Class MeiJSure De:;criptiu11 of Wurlt Tc-sL (VcsiNo)
Complete i
Plan Number I
I I
I i
SUPP, 1T -
NC