ML18092B402
| ML18092B402 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Salem  |
| Issue date: | 01/20/1987 |
| From: | Corbin McNeil Public Service Enterprise Group |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
| References | |
| NLR-N87001, NUDOCS 8701280559 | |
| Download: ML18092B402 (4) | |
Text
Public Service Electric and Gas Company Corbin A. McNeil!, Jr.
Vice President -
Public Service Electric and Gas Company P.O. Box236, Han cocks Bridge, NJ 08038 609 339-4800 Nuclear January 20, 1987 NLR-N87001 United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 Attention:
Document Control Desk Gentlemen:
CONTROL ROOM DESIGN REVIEW RESOLUTION OF HUMAN ENGINEERING DEFICIENCIES SALEM UNITS NO. 1 AND 2 Attached for your review are copies of Salem Generating Station Human Engineering Deficiencies (HEDs) Nos. 109 and 113.
These HEDs were revised as a result of a conversation held with Mr. R.
Eckenrode on December 18, 1986.
Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us.
Sincerely, Attachment flOO I 1 / t
To the Document Control Desk C
Mr. D. C. Fischer Licensing Project Manager Mr. T. J. Kenny Senior Resident Inspector Mr. v. s. Noonan Project Directorate #5 2
1-20-87
ti A 1-
!:~ M (II U C L. E: A
- I<
G E N 1::
I~ A T I 1,1 t;.
B T A l I
IJ 1'1 HUMAN ENGINEERING OBSERVATION/DISCREPANCY rlU:
1~9 PAl-/El. I DEl,l'rI Fl ER COMPONENT IDENTIFjER
- ,.,,.,,..,_. '""".... 111* -*-* -.* Htl 1** "" '""'" -* t*I WI'""""""' 'fOI 1*1 U*lolooo ****t **&MH -
0001 'fll... o -* -* '"' '"" ***-*-,..,_, -
-.. -I UMoooO**--* *ni,., 11,.,_,,.,. 1 UUIWI -*-,..,,._.,j 1101, __
, "" -* '"' '""",,..,,,, "" o*O '""-
cc-2 eves F.ll:.zr:::LS AM})
CHAl~G HIG [IEZEL
~---------------------------------------------------------------------
SECTION CODE:
- 8.
PANEL LAYOUT WORKSPACE:
GUIDELINR N0:6.8.1.3c DESCRIPTION OF DISCREPANCY:
- THI=: '3 CVC~I t:n::z.E:LS Al~E MOT GfWLJF*E'l> TOGETHEH Al~l) THE
. CHARGING BEZEL COULD ALSO BE BETTER MARKED.
m*------------------------------------------------------------------
H~D CATAGORY CODE: 4 LEVEL:
SCHl::.DULE~
- *11.. 1 I! ** *--* *--ullr-r*a*-*-*- -* lfU l~U *-*-*-**-lfHl91111111t-***--1"1 rl* '"*-*-**,. P91 t*1l-*o0* *- r** IM HU *-***-**,.OfOflo*o -**o *-UH IUll*- -
- - 1*1HHlllO I_, __ 10flll1'1111 I-*--,,..,_*-*--*-* -
fltf ftH f~E:COMMENDAT J; CJMS:
.CHANGE RECOMMENDED.
COMMENTS/JUSTIFICATION FOR NON-CONFORMANCE=
THE CONSOLE AND BEZELS HAVE BEEN_ CONFIGURED IN A LOGICAL ARRANGEMENT" THI;:.
M~RAMGEMENr AMD l..Afll:::IN:[NG :rs CONFJ.GUFU:.I) LEFT TO l':IGHT IN A1'1
. ALF*HABEl'IC~AL r!iNl)/OF~ MUME:fUCAL.
BE:!~UE:MCE.
THE CO"IFHrl.mATHJN MINrtHZES OPERATOR SEARCH TIME AS EXPLICIT PARAMETERS AND FUNCTIONS ARE GROUPED TOGE1'HE:F~.
F'LJfnH1:::F~ DEMAr~CATHlM WILL E:l-IHAMCE. l'HE DIBF'l.AY ~
S A I..
l:'. M M U C I... I! A I~
G 1£ 1-1 I::
1:;:
A T ! M G 8 T A T I O H HUMAN ENGINEERING OBSERVATION/DISCREPANCY REVIEWER; DOYLE 113
-*-... _._....... ---**** *.. *-*.......... - -*........ *-*,., 111**-*-*.... '"' --*-*....... *-*-11111 1-* _......... **- -*........ -*-* -* ****-* --* __,.............. **** **** *-**-*-*............................. -......... *--*--*............ _, **
CUMF'01'1El'l'r I DENT IF J ER
~----------------------------------~-----*~----------
.. cc-2 eves
-* -*- -* "" Mii *-*--***10111 "'**-*-*I-I Hll --*-***I*'"**-* *tt lrll IMlo** -*"II !Ill...,-* '°'11*11..,.,..,,,., UH*-*--* -
- UI "'" -* **** -- -1111 - --* lftl-l **l~-1rn llU -*--*1111111&-**-,.,, HU*-..,,,_-* <******-***oo -
SECT10N COOE~ a.
PANEL LAYOUT WORKSPACE:
GUIDELINE N0:6.8.2.1a-2
~---------------------
DESCRIPTION OF DISCREPANCY:
ARRANGEMEN1' OF CONTROLS DOES NOT FOLLOW A FLOW SEQUENCE OR OPERATIONS SEQUENCE. SEE BELOW FOR AN EXAMPLE. THIS PROBLEM IS MINIMIZED ny CROUPING OF CONTROLS ACCORDING TO SYSTEMS AND BY THE MINIA1~RIZATION OF CONTROLS WHICH ALLOWS OPERATORS TO HAVE ACCESS TO DOZENS OF CONTROLS WHILE STANDING IN ONE PLACE.
CONTROL ARRANGEMENTS CSUCH
~S THE ONE PRESENTED BELOW> SHOULD BE EXAMINED ON A CASE BY CASE BASIS AND EVALUATED WITH RE$PECT TO OPERATOR WORKLOAD AND CRITICALITY OF
'THE Ol!)El~ATlCJM..
-***-*'llll --*-*-**-* *** '"' I"**,,.,,,.,--*- -*t.. 1 HllHll.... -* -**-*,,.,,,., llil 1.. 6*-****-* _,.,,, 1*11Mo I**--*-**
.. **** 1,*I ****-*-* llU........,_. --..,,,,.,Hit llfl_I_*..,,*-******
1 oro* *HI *U *-*-* *-* -****.... rut,,., *._,-**-
~ED CATAGORY CODE: 4 L F.'. VE I..:
SCHEDLJl... E:
- - t*I -* 1*1 1- *-* '"',.., llU I******-****-*-* I-*- t*I IWI *- *- *-,,., 1'" 1
- llll 1* l-.1 *- *-,_,.., o*I llll lllW -
H* *- *- *-* *-* '""' HH o*I UU -
- - t** "" "" tlll I-*-*- -
- P*,,.....
11 f~ECDMME:Nl>AT I O~IS:
.CHANGE RECOMMENDED..
~----------~--------------------------------------------*--------
COMMENH3/ JUST xr:1 CAT ION FOi~ NON~-cor~For<MANCE:
REFER TO HED 1~9.