ML18058B922
ML18058B922 | |
Person / Time | |
---|---|
Site: | Palisades ![]() |
Issue date: | 07/07/1993 |
From: | Rogers D CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.) |
To: | NRC OFFICE OF INFORMATION RESOURCES MANAGEMENT (IRM) |
References | |
NUDOCS 9307150160 | |
Download: ML18058B922 (22) | |
Text
consumers Power David W. Rogers Plant Safety and Licensing Director POWERINii NllCHlliAN"S PROliRESS Palisades Nuclear Plant: 27780 Blue Star Memorial Highway, Covert, Ml 49043 July 7, 1993 Nuclear Regulatory Commission Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 DOCKET 50-255 - LICENSE DPR PALISADES PLANT - REQUEST FOR RELIEF FROM SPECIFIC CODE REQUIREMENTS - SERVICE WATER SYSTEM LEAKAGE - ADDITIONAL INFORMATION Our July 1, 1993 letter submitted for NRC review and approval a relief request from certain provisions of Section XI of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel (B&PV) Code. Attachment 2 to that letter, provided the calculation and drawing for the temporary non-Code repair for the 16-inch service water line.
In the same letter we indicated that the calculation and drawing for the temporary non-Code repair for the 4-inch service water line would be submitted under a separate cover letter, as soon as they were finalized. The attachment to this letter contains the calculation and drawing for the non-Code repair for the 4-inch service water line.
David W. Rogers Safety and Licensing Director CC: Administrator Region Ill, USNRC Resident Inspector, Palisades Attachment 1301Z2 A CMS' ENER5Y COMPANY f/O'f1 11 I
ATTACHMENT Consumers Power Company Palisades Plant Docket 50-255 REQUEST FOR RELIEF FROM SPECIFIC CODE REQUIREMENTS SERVICE WATER SYSTEM LEAKAGE ADDITIONAL INFORMATION July 7, 1993
_ --ALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT - - Sf:J-o J,Y{p - C(Q ENGINEERING ANALYSIS COVER SHEET rota1 Numberot Sheets /q Title I tt:1::1.~M,'/ M1::.t - (Aa,;: PPAJfl 61!::. Pie.<£ ~¢wi4[..b 7J.l.MJ.~Cz.
nm,, HI "~-~M r-.C VA1 ti~ M V-S0 /"'<{~. .
INITIATION AND REVIEW Calculation Status Preliminary Pending Fi~ Superseded 0 0 0 Initiated Init Review Method Technically Reviewed Revr Rev Description By Date Appd By Alt Cale Detail Review 9ual est By Date Appd By CPCo Appd
~(6% .~.:"
'S/n ~ ~A
,,. ~t:..-.,..., '1L 0 Original Issue ~- RIOC\ ../
r~ a~'lC~"'~ s.
Fi I\ f..1-/. s. 'A AN~L'/SIS Po,a... Tf!:M Pof<M-j M OfJ/Ac...AT/ON No. Tr1-'13-070
- r_ OB:recr1vG~
I. ..sJ.IOW /)/AT TNe Sl£V& AND ASSa::..JAreD ArrAU#t~r (.,(.)a£>.S
/-/AV§ . .SuP,:./c,,/ef.JI CAPABJury ro w1-msTffU> /H~ PIPING LM.DS. 4t.eEV'6 1~ i..o~re::D °"' rl-B- J. 3- 4 "PJhNG oN me ~
-.S~M 67YIJ o,: MV-..sw l:ICo ( 4T /JM; $7TWcl...b).
2., AJ)J)~ ./Jlr..Sl&N oF A .DRA1N ..DCTAI'- Tl:> rAt::JLIT>'lrr ~
WIIl.J)JJVt;. aF l't ~60N~ L.El41<1NG '-1/\J~ ~
Form 3619 10-91
- sP-o33l(q -o-~
-ISADES NUCLEAR PLANT
,,, AN'ALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet 'Z.... Rev 10_
~#'J rn1*11a1 Reference/Comment 3
4
/. 7j/t;: P1P le')l~ /.S Loe-A Tl!t) Ar T!f6 lo~ or ~
5
. ~:ri We-1..J) (VALV s~e) 7Jl.AT .TOl~-S 7Ht!' ~'1 6
E'NJ) or VALV ~V-..Sk)/.J'(p ro 7Hif" HB 4 II 7
P1',o1NG. J'j/ IA.IALL /)fJNAJIN(:, IS ~7!Au.Y 8
Llt4'f ITQJ Tb 71#" Vt~N/rY OF n+8 N~. ti/ UT /?B'ft,A_r!;,
9 TJ.f tc..~N.S. ...s: HG>>Sv 1{1=.MeNrs. "'2gyt£)1-LG:D ONa i.LJl4n lf\J >trotutMl:lNTS.
10 IN 7W P1P8 !+-D:JltUl'lr n TJf6 w1.JJ Ar 0./87 JW/J 1 ~z.
11 A-No~ 111 o, 1qo. ONLj ON !Zf!:YWIN~ (_ o.'2.z~')
12 WAS. oi3.T'AINII'J) ON TH8 llALVg' ew)",, fHa /H/Nf\160 13
~ 15 APP/<-oXJtlMf nn./ I w1.Dg" av~ AN ARG of::
11 14 fl&;LA. r 12.0°. U..r ~lf)4{;)/NG.S TJtH<BYV oN ~ tv¥L[)
15 INt;;WD~ ~ ~8/N~H87VI or lfff1l!WJM-1fo/
16
>>0 , IM P1P§ SLE;iUG WJL'- .[3/(Wc;,5 7?.ftF 17
.f)§6~a.J) /<$6/()1\/ /I\/ nftI VICJN IT'/ Or 17f£ l3uff 18 We:LO ~
19 20 22 23 D~1GN: /Do PslG .,f 3oo°F 24 No~~ ~s- Psi& ~ ?S'°r 25 M/YXIMJ>M: /10 f!JG ~ 12-Dr 26 2
1 No-,-c_t>~.-~A--~t. ex~w MAt-)'s1..s M~ Nor l<.t!F. 4 28 P.~&1t[/)
h~ f't;?e s~s ,(Sg-~ me 29 /Y..~. S~tU:r Tlrr-1~77A.1<.£" /-S. Beux.J 30 I 50_~£._ __{_5~ :S.I0 3 I t:?F ;u-r, I)' ~ P1PIN6 ,:s.
31 NoT IN A F.ATl<:JM g-t.JVl!!.DNMe:J'\J.I.
32 II * ..
33 3, )Id 4- P1PIN6 _
34 MA~AL! ASrM A-S.1 GRB . Rfi"r. u~ +
35 .:s1c-s- : 4"NP~ x o. 237 (.sCl4 4o) WAU- ~ ~ 0.\ /0 36 AP1N(, D1~ne&1Ql W6/GJ-IT /~ING /AJSl).LA11oN ~ * ~/./ /0 11F R.fiF 4 37 c.c~r~ r.s 1 ~ ! / 7, t.P #/;::r
- 38 s~~5J-oi= 1~1<sL r.:s::: ~()KS/.
'------...;;.;~~...;...i"-'-~~--'-"1---~--...;.(..;..... Y.s______________
=:SS--Ksl 1Aq;. .z!4
- ' 6 ._ _ _ _ .....A.__.
Form 3650 10-91
- -sf-03.jl(g -o<.p
-ISADES NUCLEAR PLANT I
ANALYSIS CONT,NUATION SHEET Sheet 3 Rev # 0
- -*rs YRll:IUI Reference/Comment 3
4 5
4, VA-Lva i1v- s~ 13t; f<GF. Z,4/i1 81 6 11 4 loo#' G.ATC (HAb::. No. 2.'f ./Jr 111-260 /2//3 .
7 wa-1 Gii r - I 2 (p # .S,; JNC..t..U..1J1A.J6 WA~
8 MATBf<..tAL- A - V~ G~ WC.-B 9
-Sc;_/ S;, == 14 f<S I I TS.::; 70~~, I Y-S ::;. 3&; K5 I 10 11 12
- 5. :SL&nie {_ PtP8-)
13 1'1A~IAL:11 AST/'1 A-JO~ GI!... 8 14
- s t:t:. : S N PS x o, 37 s(sct1 Bo) uALL rn1cJ<NgSS ~ 10 15 O,,_s n<.tJSL-trro W&1 &r11: Z0.8 ~r
= 4 ~ A.J~/6HT ~ J#
11 16 lg'f\JG,rn 17 ;LD.-== 4, 813" ( s1 t;eJ) To ,.c:ir ov~ ~TTwl:fl.D 18 P$iNFol{~ &VT ,4-N.Jj I/ALI/a f3aD/ ~).
19 20 Sc.; S" == 15i<SI J T.S =(ao /c::.SI J Y..S == 3S-.k:Sl /!d."2.1 11 21 22 6, SuP- ON Fl.ltNe:,e (JOA. CoMP1tl{l.Sc;J wrrn. SL£i\/tr) 23 /!.ATING : 150 # CL..As.s / M~Tl!;1{1AL.: ASTM A-10~
24 t4PP/lDXJl'1AT~ Hld3 f/et(;HT (!<MJfAL. [)1iST1+NC4 F~M 25 r.D. Or HuB TO o.n. OF H~) 01~/ol\'is. .h?A 4 II 26 15011 5uP-oAJ Fl.ANC::£ I x;: . ~~II
...j 7/(# J vv =4,s 7 p~ //OtX' £:;: 7 27 HU/3._ 1~ r == .P-:z:_~ :::= o, ~ 7 / ( mts. 1~ A M>rXJ'""""'i 28
~~---TH >< 01M~slo1V I~ 14-r Wll<<li ..J3AiS; INC 29 fhs:~ _'{Hf('. ll'N./) W~g n+tS r=.1./1.c..uhF~IAL 30 r1'-4!+/-tu1U .ro 77hI" /1f'lr o.D, 1~ LJ?(;.AndJ ,~ Uis.s) 31 C<YVS~b THtr /lu.13 77tPE1'2-.~ Ahrt(': ~ SYs!rM 32 O~t~tJ ~01nONS1 A S'-113-oN f'l.A1Jt,6 15 ~.
33 7. -17tu PIPJM6- I .S PF\~ OF nf8 C/QncAL S@fJ!c.B UM~
34 Sjsnn'-1 oN 171" DtA.TL~T OF CAN~.T CcouNG {£,A~
35 %"4r ~~~ £s-4 -B. Tl+t~ P1P1N~ )$. Sltffr/
36 f<.1SLA1f:D1 Cp Lb J)~1GN 6..A.ss I* .
37 38 Form 3650 10-91
- SP-033/v-~
-ISADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet 4 Rev 1 =O_ _ __
Reference/Comment 2
11L. _A~~PTloNS 3
4
/, ::S~~ M'\n:flZfAL 67'<0.Slo'\//Co~10lfl ~
5
~so Na~LJGl/31.£ ./Jlll§ Ti> T1fC P~ce 6
oF. TH8 sx1.:sr1NG 1 G..3- 4" P1P1N~ 1N.si1Jtr..
7
/Hrf 6A t£aLArED e-/c. /<Are- o F o, 014 11 ~ A l<JJr; J4 8
A!;f(Jo 0 o P: I Yi.. y'~ 1 /AJi '-'- Nor Cor-iPtEn?:Ly 9
~ova m-e i<-.~AIN1AJC P1Pa/wl!J..[) M.4~4.L 10 R_~f:\JN/NG. IN*S.IL,a" n+z" ~t..~W~ ( f11Allf'-(~ ii\ A~H z.
11 11tlG/OVc3S.. Ml!:A~ /Jf I.A. I I~ 0. OCf4>/.$"i<O.ot4~
12 -
13 14 Z.., f~ !+r-NUHt!:l<.rr 2../ T~ VA/.:18 l?DDY nttGk>I~~
15 UJ,4~ 11~ PrT ON LocA-110/\/ N~ 77-1 LPl!t::.
11 16 Lo(.;AT/ON* /M' /1tr>4.S.""24Mt!NT oF 0, 2-1-8 IS ,,
17 US:S TAftN * /}18 MINIMUM WA.LL Or O, 2.SD 18 SPl!i"c1198:[J /IV* Tlti3L$ LS' OP A-NSZ" 8/"...34, 1JU 19 S//ouL/$R. oF nf VAt.Ve ~ * ~LOP~ P'"' Fi~tf 20 2 or Ai'J.S.Z g /&;,. '2-S-, /HS ::S.LE:JNe f..S /AJnrN()QD ~
21
..158 A~D ro TJI VAL.Ve:- ~ &YD~ 7718 22 e:si£ ()F me & rr* tA..Jt!J..[) ( sunrvcr I J), >- P1M o ..D.
23 MD VAUlt:i o.n Arm-&: Wtn.f) PRl!P), ;rr is AS.S:~e:-D 24
?Jb\-T me surnve ArrACJ'4M~r Li>cATION ~"'
25 11fg' VAL~ /30.D/ t:S 1N 4 f!.g-~tJN oF nf8 26 VPrW§. fHwlN~_ A WALL "T}fldt::/V63.S oF ,fr ~T 27 t), ?._~'!__>.. ltL_2-3 7(ftP11' No/-llAJAL... /)fill_ 7'1-u)::NtfSSJ 28 ,
I 29
- --- - i- ; . '
30 - '
31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 Form 3650 10-91
--~P-03.31b-o~
-!SADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet S: Rev 10;__ _ __
Reference/Comment 2
3 4
/, JM /3rtSIC. APPf&,Au-~ IS. T?:J ~ ~r T>+tr PIPE 5
- SLe:ZrVtr E?-fl'J.OYS:O M"2.. nf6' l<..'A411<.. l.S Qu1v1V..SNT lo
. II
- 6
~A~~ -ni8 S~GIH oF /1ht" lfe,-z..3 - 4 /1P1Nc;.
7
_,-~ Bf't.SJ.5 ~~ JJer~1N1NG ~ s1r:,1~ "r 7?hl' 8
t11<..0<..H~6Nr1AL F1l.LlSr w67-.Ds t1TTA<...1-11Nc; nki 9
SU:!.b-YB ~~ 7D IH \)AL.Vtf A-7\LD P1P I.$ 13,Y 10
/-1a11Nt; n+C /<..1.rCQ tA tf'2e"M87\1 r ,;.:::; ,q.._ S '-' P - oN 11 FLANG" ATIN:fiHe:NT (A SLIP -oN rJ..Ar.J64' is
- 12 P~1ss1814 A'~ THe I~ lfs~T15M ~~ Cu\0 ~F. 7- ;(i; 13 14 15 2~ ::fNTI9'<NAL P~ssf.AA." (Nat.: 77-16 L011ic.1ruf)1NAt- ~s 16 Io1N1N6 Tflt! ~ ~ve J..lALl/g...S Al2E h,tu. ~TlcJN ~OIJYe 'k/WV 17
~ ~QllArloN "3 oF /04.1. ?-. A ro EV./¥.U4i6-mrf' 18 SLJN'l/B UG>No1'!JN~ CL>~::.J()'\} t4LLIJW~~ ~A) .
19 20 L -=- f Do P== /DO PslG.
/I 21 2- (~e +- Py ) Do , Q, s-b~ ~ 10 22 SS- :::. /~ DOO 23
./oo/(s-,s-b . ! ;o,4 24 t,,_ =z.. Js;ooo +Qoo o.4))
J(
25 26 27 t.... - o. 0 I BS; A~ CoMfM.Ql W1t11 Tit
. _. _ ---* nttuc:JV~. tJ,37s JX!.75 s,imv:(
-l> o,01es 28 ;
29 30 31 32 33 a., C.0MfAf<JSbl\/ OF W/9-D /<..1J"Qu11<EM~- Fot<..,JLEJ!Ye 34 IYPa c../~AS'fl.£Nr1AL .:T°OJl\ITS w1TH siM k"dltl1~~~
35
- A:>lt.. A r=lufSI lJD..O ::J;;;1N1N6 A 3.JP-oN FU+f.JGtrro A- P1Pa.
36 37 A S1...&N> seE 11/.(.p. I G or 631.10 p~ G.4/ M1tJ. ~-r-: 2.
3a c, g 1st
"'-----.-:::~~~~~~1....1.1--=~~--..~~;.;.;;;;;;;.a.;.~..-..ii~
. l(o,u ~ :i.q .lo.~1so *
.......-.....-.,..i;-..........______ ___.
Form 3650 10-91
@*M-- -ISADES NUCLEAR PLANT AKAL YSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet
- 3P-o.33 /(o-cxe, V Rev # .-0'------
Reference/Comment 2
I .N AN ALYS IS 0 (Cot--JTJNU..e.""IJ) 3 4
3, o._, C~nNuroj 5
p~ G. s- 711£ /"11NIMb<.M THRLJAT .Dlfl.f~e>V JS I l<trF. '2, 6
o.B7'5" t~ 01<.. o, B7S xo,i.31===- O/"J,.o7~r 7
8 o/J... A F1LLe-T '-6 .:SJ tet" &'r o,~1 = o. zq3'~ X',
9 10 h~ A* -SLJP-o/'J FL..AiJG.b1 :S~ FIG. I 2.. 7
- 4. 48 4J/ltYZ-8 11 XMtN) nt' MJNIMvu-1. F/U..ISI ws:LJJ LE"~ -SJ~e 1s.
12 G1ve:N A~ J. 4 t_, WITµ, t, ~Ql<Al. TD me 13 MINIM.UM PtP~ lUftLL n+1c..J<N5SS (o. g7Sx ~) I PtrF.17 14 XMIN = (J.4.xo.8/S )( Q, 2-3 7") :=:: o. i_qo,, ""\/ 7ft;L-e-~,
15
. ~n 16
~RJ~ -,W:- MINI~ FJLl..£T 6..JLJJ SI-Ce 1~%-
17 USe ~ U-c, ALL£r w81.DS n> A-n>tut n£ s;'cf 18 . f!Pe -SLJ<<Ve (Ji,,, I.VALL n+/d::Ne:ss.) ~ TM H.B-2.3- 4" 19 Pt Pa tr1'LD VAJ..11£ 11 v- s w 13 6:J 1 i l TM!: r/1.Le:TUAW
'-' II _\
20 l.S A FULL SI?:£ ~ff lf-.S ..5~ n+1G/c::MJ:s~ V.JQ...[)
21 tu1114 LeG. .:S/ :C. IN~fdf) .4.s /VeC.i!CSS~/ "Tb 22
~"'T l=o/flll.. ntB GftP 13&Tt<Jtd:'N nt' t:S~G 23 A1'lD ~ P1Pe.
24 25 NbnI" 7).J.i\T ~ /)IFA:rll8'Nc IN T1S"NSIUF P~P&l/:rl~
26 N'/JJ ALLD~ABt..C ~ &-r~ nt 1#1W"h\U) 27 Sl.&IVcf/f'1,0~--~~AW J;S 4JN.S~ /~IGIV/F~
28 1AJ1nt___ ~!Wf:J)L n H~ l<.J6UJ S*61VG7H/&i~C:
29 H~rj,M. nttr wn..o J01N1N~ /II< VALv' 30 A1UD. 5~- ~ _t:3$SNnA-'-L;/ ~ -SkMa ~AS 31 7Hf' l-A.Jil.D -ro11J1N~ ~ ~~~ l+NJJ P!Pe-.
32 33 .b. lo* ~1AJ mt! Hl.l.irl 4;1!:1.J) LL& SI~ #e&)Q) "le 34
.()tfv~ TH6" CltPAOT'/ ~F -rH,, "f "~ ,... P1P8 Qi1fU.. f f IJ, 237;'
3s 1 /N l:f"Ff7:sz.T!ll6 TJl4t+r oF' o, 2.37 /.5 IZ6li2U1/14JJ {).SJ/\IG, 1
36 I M~llJ~ ~Gn.4 t.uno A~ }1A7l!:12.IA'-. !,W- Ftl.i...6T, 37 I lUtrl..{) LJ:(:;,I f_J IS .J!:::: _k, : ; fZ' Z.17;: 0, :14 "V % 'tct..
38 I 61rH~ 4s A-BoVE ) . o. 7o 7 o, 101 ~ I I Form 3650 10-91
~
.ADES NUCLEAR PLANT ee SP- 03 Jl<O - Ck:>
ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet ~ Rev 1 ~O~--
Reference/Comment 2
~. ANAL.,y'.SI~ (CoNTl!\/UGD )
3 4 .. Pit<.. .4~~ I {A. T (}f1C.,C:::.Nlf$S H~~o.m.
J 4
or T}ft5" t'l-13 -Z.3 - 4 "(Jll°e D?vJNS~ oF HV-5 SW13& ee-YoNiJ nter Al'<.Sr~ Pr/'/@IS~
6 INiJICA ~ T?ftJ" t°lfB W/fLL 77+tc.i<N~~ /~ C-<..;/7J.llN 7
ro~u- {_ .....l 0,87Sx 0,237.: c;. 2...07") r=D~
/I 8
,+ c~1ce oF /o _eeypl'f.£) nni- t.JOUJ, ~ ~1~
9
- SU::~e E?:XTDV.OS &r/t>NJJ --/;W L-c UT1DN 77-ftA,.( /S &2.dw 10
/)~; J7:>lfii2Arl\1~ Ll/<11 r; TJld?..Fo/(£ 1 7MI' P1P1N(, IN 11 trf I~ lft<=-IN 1ry /1116 Sur:Fl<:./@Vt /,¥1c:KIV6'"3~ lo 12 11/t1Nrn/f\J TlfC VAU.Dt 'TY oF ~ Gu~ 5/5Tn'-1 ;eBP: 4 13 s~s #t!rt.,Y'..StS,,
14 15 5: P/PIN(., S7'(~S:S t4~ti' EvALuArt:JiJ"JD~ TNti 16 1iM" Ml~ 1N ~~ /hrent.S/r/CATloAI )7coM* /.1 Ar ~
1 7
VALV§" ~ ~17/0N lo 2,J ~ rw-18 C-J/<!t:..tA.M~nA1..... A'-lfi"T ~~ .t1T7~N~ ~
19
-s~r ro nnr f11'11¥=J,. -rw .s~ //ALLA£:s P.Sd:D.
20 ,+s ~ £1t..5~ ~ 77-lo.:sE ~ 71ftr ~T 21 Sp(.4:f.S..S /lnAL'l-.:SJ..S Ar Tl'f~ .D~~ eND ~ /<!er: 4 22 VALva 11v-s~13 ~ / /t/c:;o~ PotNr "'. (t.lorB 23 .:s.r 1~' ;1-Pl'L.1~ ro SL p Ai.so ,1 :51..Jt;Hrif~11<14")
24 lA* DaADWtEIGJ./T 25 26 27 28 j
~---
29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 l'Jor8; 5~ AM ~y ~ 1N n+LS V1r-1N1ry, ,,,u, 00.S 38 ~ Z..~~o oF nhr hAXtt1.ltM P~1T71!:fJq Form 3650 10-91
.~-
.Sf-03~!; -~
~SADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet 8 Rev IO_
Reference/Comment 2
3 4
0, .8/ IN..SPa.no/\./ 1 wr n:; 7Jf8" ~e BoN~
5
~~; /l<>"'VI~ w~'-L nflC..k:N~S /'f7V./J S/1Hl3 6
.M4~AL -S~GT/4 IT-~ CcHPM..ro Win+- 'T}+r$'
7 l!.v.-N P1P8 / ~ ..s~ 1.s. l10~~ultW ~
8
~ / H P1)SJm Pl PING Lt; A!>.S , ~11>.tJAJ~ SdV'J°"' /'1.JJtx,,~ u~
9 VAt.ue-$ : ~ S~-V$::: 7, 43 JN!.). 3,Z./,N? = C/1P/5" ). \
10 7, /~ A-D.Dcm l<)6!G#r OF ~ ~~ (7#l_;
11 Ms N~G'-IGLBLff IM P/'JC.7. o/V 7/18' f1PtAJC, 12 SN<g~~* AtVAL.'/S!.S.. TN encsz.r /.!::. ro IN~B ~4 13 T*J' UNC<PV~nt) W576H I oF T>hr VA-LV8 14
( A-fPl<.o.J(, I 2-D # W/ntf>~T (.JtFl6HT OF '<;~)
15 TJ.18 ; NC/<S'>'l.Sf:° I .l I 3Jf[ 0 ~ /, O ~ o~ "/o 16 IN~~S~.
17 7fff5 l~t:f" 1..:s lVlfLL wrnf1f\.J nh5" Zo?o 18
. /o~U ON~~ ~<d-IT P~
19
..~DUN~ A>~ APING :sys~ ~uAr1~
20 11- T/Yklt1'1t5N T ~ 7?> H -11~(Q J*
21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 Form 3650 10-91
e.ISADES NUCLEAR PLANT 1- sP-on1re -OLe ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet q* Rev# O,_~---
Reference/Comment 3
4
/, TJlti ~g- {)e;31~ 1t01J~ ~1/\1 Gc..JtLL /1ecvtDe 5
P~~ ~~'//~~ntML /N~~ry ~
6 nlrS '4PPLJCAIJLZ L.1;/ro1Nb CoNiJ/770/1/S. (f*!rs.s.~
7 GRAVITY ~ S~/C,..) J:=O~ n+t:: .JE~ APING 8
1-oc+r8'0 J4r n+r:r ./J~~ t:7'JI) o,& !'1V-SW/~
9 10 Z-. fM ONL'/ SIG.NIFIVA/VT ErFez-T oN 7Jf6 C<,,i~T /2.ef. 4 11
- SY.sn!7'-1 .s~.s 11-NALY.:SJ.:S. I~ "1 ~LL llV~
12 IN 5 71<0.:S.S. //\/ n!:N.:Sll=I~ ;t-T n-/ ~
13 LotATtoN Dua TD ntr!" u.so oF' AL.J..Jrr Wgt..Os n""-
14 S.L@nl~ l'f~tE?VT: P1P/!'1G ~s w1LL 15
~l+1N Wt!LI- Wrn11N ~ A-f'P'-ICAJ3L.B LIH1T.s, /!d: I 16 If 17 3, 7Jte X NP..s SLB:Vtr" Dl!A1N ~~ uA71~FltI.S ~ z..
18 B31-I C-/JJ) l<K"Q..lU~t!:"M&.JT..S.
19 20 21 22
- *..* ~!.
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
-* "---~--- ..
30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37
..___________________________________________________&-________~
38 Form 3650 10-91
E.-SP -03~1'2 -0~
~SADES NUCLEAR PLANT ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET I0 --=O'------
- -*ws
- 11wu Sheet Rev 11 Reference/Comment 2
fl~~~-
3
/. 7!rCJ1Ntc..AL SR;o~1c!fr10N M-1qs @?)- r~~rN'UtL~,~t).JT\
4 nA ~~6AJ ~ ~~Y..SLS OF :54.&"0-71'<,.¢iJ..RTZf'() /.?PMJG~
5 INS T"}tJ.AHfn.J.'I 77A8/NG/ ~- 3 .
6
- 2. ?olV~ Ar>1N~ Caoe/ A/\l.::r &1.1-1q 13 tu17}f fJ/V.S.Z 7
" B3/, I b -1q73 :SuMMt:!Y<. A~,
8 3/ DwG t1 Io I ..Sfl z7 441 !<av. Z. / STJ(!ffs.:. :rsoHtm(J~/
9 SgX VIC§" t'urt n;r.;i.. F/2-0M £/VG. .5.4rt!'GU~ .
10
- 4. P1f'1NG ~neg-"!_s tAu:- A -SP- 0::!.3/to -o~ l<tN- /
11 5., H-2~(/I :5.~ 3/116; l<J::v. 9, f1P1N<::- (!.LA.SS 12 SuM MA;e.. y, 13 (p. 11- 2-~0I S/lf!:CT J/#£5 I ~-I 11 P1P11-1c;. CLA-~~ ~
14 C..LAS.S. H B.
15 7, LAJ:J1~H F1rnN~ &tT>4LDu /Vo. ~~
16 B. PL ID M-2.08, .:5Jl££T IA/ !<.1IV- 21; s~v1c.B 17
~TBA.. SY~nrrt *
. 18
- q. N r<.t- GDv~e- L.e-rTl!:Y2-. qo -o s-; c, /ls-/;fro .
19
- 10. N ~1.1c.o t=>1P1Nc, 0An4~, /Onf- eo 1 6)//74.
20 I I, A-s rl"t A--/ Ol# - t:/O 21
/2.. f1--z_{s,/ 1 MA-~~ I/AL\/ t.Jsl1 :Sllewt 4
- 22 /:1, A-srM A--2JCP-Btf 23 14, CALc... aJ4- sP- 0331~ -041 r('tn1,o ~ TH1NNJAJ(;,
24 S\IALJA.~TtoN) , . .
25 IS: M~L B/fo, 34 -1q1~/ s~ BuiT-tUU)l/tl6 26
~ VALVe~.
27 I~, ~N~ . /3 Jfo, is - 1q?q 1 f3u:rrw~L()IN6 ~s 28
- 17. ~-A-5"~-qfJ 29 I
-~---*--
30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 L--------------------------------------------------------------~
Form 3650 10-91
-SADES NUCLEAR PLANT
- -SP-o J.3/(q -o~
ANALYSIS CONTINUATION SHEET Sheet / / Rev 1 -""O"'-------
- KW5*#'SFllllUJ Reference/Comment 2
3 4
/. Ncx-JDe:sr,Q.w:_-nvtZ IEs.rJNG ~e;-~v1~ TJ.1.1GK.f\J~
5 M~(.,).~GMIZ'l\JT IEXAMJNA..TICYV ~t.r",.q:,~T;' Slleff NP, f<C::J'~-
6 0~ 2P/i./qJ/ P~e&..r No, Z.4~3JS"2.ZSOSto (3 ~),
7 8
2-, NoND~sr~r1ve Ttn:TINC,;, .S~Jee.1 TJ.11~
9 Ht:J~/'-f.1\JT E.xAMJNAT/01\J f<.~ ~~rM.MFS-10 0 3/ ~/)o/'1~1 ftJ.o.reC..T )Vo, 2Jq3JS- 2-2.SOS/ (z. ~..s) ..
11 12
- 3. DRAWIAJG SK-TM ~q3-0701 SlleeT // )(tn'i118.1,,
~61Zv1c.B wAr~ P1Pe .::SL£E:Vtr JJE.TA1t.S.. flB-l~-Lf.
1 13 14 15 16 4, T@:U+/VICA'- ~/~ .:S/lslrl u) 17 S-: Doe-uM~I f<.tSV1ew ~~ ( I )
18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 i '
29
. *-*--+---1-. . *-* ..... .*---*
30 -** .* -I 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 Form 3650 10-91
l J, A-SP-D3310-~
1.
f1mUtHe:Nr
/ oF .:S Examiner ;C,Al.P~LL J..JL L L..S Level Jr Date 6-~ -?3 Sheet No.~u.1- o~
CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING SERVICES Examiner.Afi/,'J> #ecK..sL l.. Level __::iz=_ NOT Company _,C""-'--'. -=-*
- L.* _,,~=-=P~-- - - - - - -
THICKNESS MEASUREMENT Proiect No.~'19.3 /.5 ~~~s~
EXAMINATION REPORT Job Location At ,:s...,~t:.s AJu~Lbf,e_ A."'~ r Total Hours Worked ~/A
~**--------------.J.:::.::....:====~~======~==~::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::===-__:_:::=-:~~if'J';;;.,MJ~=-==z=================4 NOT Procedure N.PT- ~r- o:L Rev -...5 - - Ultrasonic Equipment4u...1n,-csd4'>£ f Serial No...17¥- ,po..3..S:.S Cal Due ?-/0 -:&1
' /_
---~;P'----------~--
! Search Unit Size/Fr~uency , ...t .. I 5,,.,N z. Serial Number / U 0 9 Reterence Documents --~,..M-'
...______________ Ultrasonic Couplant S°*N11 rAAc=L fo Batch Number t? 9 /O LY
~~ Mechanical Equipment 1.M Serial No. ~M Cal Due ~A Material Type Nominal Diameter
-"ll!~/.s=------
- ~ .,
--=-7_ _ _ __
Joint Design c:;""t-..Af~--
Nominal Thickness ...z...J 7 **
A,.4,~,;.,~ OJ;;w...snt1.vr~'6>/1c.f"f!>
Item ID Number .itcl"A~ v~ 4'..__.., im Name .S w.S
~ Sub Proiect Number
. /_
A//"
/ ""'S...a I !(c. ' /
Item Type J.-/ *1 LI'
£1-'.1.AJ& Line Number ~ /,JJ ' ISO/Drawing No...... e¥_Ut_________
Thickness Measurements 2 3 4 6 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 16 16 17 18 19 20 21 J.So ,1.'17 ~'I .~7.5 .J?o .2.'lo .~'I' .:J.'13 *.236 .~'I'- .~'if
~~--~.L..-.+-=
.111 .l.J.l. .~27 l..V~
. .~3B .:J.17 .,VY ~<L"l .lJ'I .~7 .27~
, .1.'12. ,J.'12.. * .J.Y.5 .~'ID .25'1 .,2.56 N/A .:UJ ,2417 ,.Uo ..Jfe Page Rev9192
j A~c.HILIB7VT J J &.-A-s.P-033/~ -ocP
- z_o;C 3 THICKNESS MEASUREMENT EXAMINATION REPORT CONTINUATION SHEET Project No. ,,:l 'l'J.3 1.5.2..2...5o.5~ IExamination Report Sheet No. A'>MJ - "I loate 6 - :<- ~..3 ~age ;2_ of ~
Thickness Measurements Item Location 1 2" 3 4 5 6 1 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 n .2.SY .:1'11 as1 ~2 * .UP .2.5.3 .;15.S *.1'17 ~'If ,.45, -2<<
Al ~,,
_1J.s .2'1'1 :J..J' :l'/1> .:U'I ..u' _.J..JS * .U8 *-'.1' ..1'1"
- Al*r-6 * .
Ii::'."......... ~s ~
~..,"' ~ I> A ~* ~"~ l.41t~A
- -* '~ G '~"A~* /', i.1,./r .'n.J ~L,, l,s°,NT ls' .... ~ .... J ,~ ... <"
I I
Rev9192
4 Tf"Y(UIH©\Jr I / . 6'14 - s P-o,33/&/ ~ o (o 3 o/-3
~
- l *~~
@ CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING SERVICES Date . Attachment Sheet No ,._._.___
hammat*on ReP.ort Sheet No _1.D_W_____*0....l.____ _
SUPPLEMENTARY SKETCH WO/MO No .uJ A
~fjic;'~b't& ~iJ*'-b~
_J item Type/No
\I- ~'4J -1.!t
- if:
Ulf\\\ \h~t""'~ tf\tf\\\)f t t\t'f\\':> \P..\t~ l\f\ \ **
L~f\~ l~~~1t ~ *\I\ \Ut\l ~t\'4)u~ lnw\ . L" l..Z.<\~
ii.At,
.l~" 1'1yt I
- t *********
. 5 "t ~ I, , & I\ lO \\
A
- 1> al I) t,
~
l" E.
ii Arr~BNT 2 1
~-sP-0331<0-ow
/oPL I"\. f. SnE:;.fLJ,,J 1 N
~ Examiner Level-:DL-- Date "- o '1 Sheet No. MEs-03 CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY
~ Examiner - - -
- NI e ________ Level 1!l.a__ .Q. f,oQ._/~(~M~Q~S-~-----~
NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING SERVICES
""°
NOT Company THICKNESS MEASUREMENT Project No. ?..?>~?, \ $ - Z.. -i.eo5 \ Requesting Dept _ME.<-..!\. e.)""{_
EXA~NATION~l Job Locatio~L-\SA.08:":.t Total Hours Worked NOT Procedure t.\Q"( -U1'-0't,..: Rev 5"' Ultrasonic Equipment ?t.N.. 1'C. DL-+ Serial No . C00:35"5 Cal Due ~ l1ol~~*
Search Unit Size/Frequency _o_._-z...___ 5 Mt!i--
I ~~~-- Serial Number l~~o~
Reference Documents _ _...f'l..=..,J...,A
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Ultrasonic Couplant SoNOJ'QAC.\i!. YC Batch Number O~\O\~
\H~OIUl\N1'UtN O~b'i Mechanical Equipment N 11111 Serial No. ~IA Cal Due tJ/a Material Type ---=C=S""'----- Joint Design _ _ _ __
Nominal Diameter
., Nominal Thickness 0
- i !>1 Item ID Number _ __....A_......J......__ _ System Name Sw:> Sub Project Number * ?.
Item Type ':\ SeCZ..\I \C. ~ u) A~E.C:... line Number - - - - - - - - - - - - ISO/Drawing No. M-?,bl fr\J \A Item SUPPLEMENTARY SKETCH Location s~e- A~"c...'1M~ s'""~~, .
c..R.ouJN \~ E:.-SS~\\/atLL-'I c.o"'10\-rlotJ .
t>o~ ~ 'Z.... ol l RE-- 'BR.v~ t-\ u.)f\ S u SE:. D It> C...L~~ ..\HE:..
t----------f Su~~~'--~"5 VR..\oR.. -ro Ul-\RASo~\C... E:.AA f\-\ \ tJ >t 11 or4.
~()1e:. ~-.o'~"~ ~abf\t::.o ~I 11 I~'?> otfS
-Jr-Examiner Page _},,_. of / .
Arrf\CfiMg7\JT 2 1 ~-SP- o3.3J<o -o&
""LoFZ-M . f. Sr\E:.w.,J\"' N
@ CONSUMERS POWEO COMPANY NONDESTRUCTIVE TESTING SERVICES b*miner Project No. ~3C\'3\'5- 'Z..'l.805\
Level Examination Report Sheet No f\\f4? - O'?t SUPPLEMENTARY SKETCH Job Loc*tion ~A.L\ ~A OE.S WO/MO No. "11 !\
line No. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Item Type/No '-i" 5F2.l!(\(,f::. c..J""t~<t-
.: .~ ~ : .....
- ,1.
~: 0. 0-0.'Z,.50
'"1-.'.0()
\.4&.E-.N t) :
vJ :: 0N u> E:.4..D .*
Y-: ON flft.. ADT~
l{b~*. VAUle. '"JoD~ e:aeoA\.E:."1"<l.~
'?CUC..<-t-\lD~~ o&1'1\\t-l \tl6'
-r--t \CJIO.\~it '1> ~/Ir 0...,) P:
-<"'~ c...o~?ot.> ~\ 1\1 0-C-'e.~
<.. O "'(toAJ Rev S.'92
ITEM No.
QUAN BILL OF MATERIALS I PIPE SLEEVE 5' DIA. SCH. B0 <A-106 GR. 81 CUT LATERALLY 2 PLCS.
2 THREAOOLET 8-3X
- 3000" <A-1051 3 PIPE NIPPLE 1 'DIA.X4' LG. SCH. 80 SEAH..ESS,THREADEO EACH ENO
<A-106 GR. B OR A-53 GR.Bl LEG SIZE TO BE INCREASED 4 PIPE CAP 1 'DIA. 3000* FORGED FITTING, SCREWEO,<A-1051 BY SIZE OF THE GAP BETWEEN SLEEVE ANO PIPE HB-23-4' MIN.
ITYP.I ELEVATION LOOKING WEST 07*02 ISSLJfD FOR U1NSTRUCllON B PEfl l M -tJ-Ll7cl JLS 93 06-28 ISSUED FOR R[Vl[W A JLS 0£S 93 PER TM-'l3*ll.70 REV. DATE DESCRIPTION BY n APP CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT LOVERT. MICHIGAN SKTM7~*1.DGN SERVICE WATER PIPE SLEEVE DETAILS HB-23-4" 1--------_-_-=_-_-:-_:::=_Q~=AW=ING~N=lJHS=(R~------==----- -
SK- TM-93-070
A~* 4- e TECHNICAL BEYIEV CHEcgA Proc No 9.11 Attachment 5 Revision 5 EA - SP- o 1 ~I le- O(. REV. .o Page 1 of 1 This checklist provides guidance for the review of engineering analyses.
Answer questions Yes or No, or N/A if they do not apply. Document all corrments on a 3110 Form. Satisfactory resolution of corrments and completion of this checklist is noted by the Technically Reviewed signature on the Initiation and Review record block of Fona 3619.
(Y, N, N/A)
- 1. Have the proper input codes, standards and design 'i principles been specified?
- 2. Have the input codes, standards and design principles been properly applied? . '<
- 3. Are all inputs and assumptions valid and the basis for their use documented? '(
- 4. Is Vendor information used as input addressed correctly in the analysis? ~
- 5. If the analysis argument departs from Vendor Infonaation/Reconaendations, is the departure justification documented? NA.
- 6. Are assumptions accurately described and reasonable? '{
- 1. Has the use of engineering judgement been docW11nted and Justified?
- 8. Are all constants, variables and formulas correct and properly applied? '(
- 9. Have any minor (ins1gnif1cant) errors been 1dentif1ed? If yes; Identify on the 3110 Form andljusttfy their y instgniftcance. (
- 10. Does analysts involve welding? If Yes; verify the following tnformatton ts accurately represented on the analysts drawtnt (Output doc&1111nt).
- Type of Veld
- Size of Veld
- Material Betnt Joined
- Thfclcness of Material Being Joined
- Loenion of Weld(s)
- ApprQpr1ate Weld Symbology
- 11. Has the objective of the analysts been *t? '1
- 12. H*ave adlltnistrattve requirements such as nUllberint and.
format been satisfied? Y
NUCLEAR OPERATIONS DEPARTMENT A1Tl40f1"1tJNI S-FfMll Document Review Sheet I I MICW#'I :
l10<ument Title~~ /10N- ColJd ~/A ~Jj._ff' U!/11)/wAL..L ~ument Number Revision Number
,;ti
'77/-!,A'"..!IA./t'; ~ \Al-:..*- - -~: n~ !/ru I '8 ~V- .s ~(,._, -sP-033/~-04' O Page /
Item Pageandlor Number Section Number Comments Response or Resolution I ~E.->i'~AL *~oh~ E \) 1-r o a , A <.. ~\JC.CoE:~T\o~<; A\C.£' Al)D£0 To /, '//', - ,,,,,,.....
I ~
..:' .-ns7) lt\C ~~t C:.\C.
- >
- z._, ...H
((lloQ..Q,. p Reviewer Q~ll form 3110 10*91
~\ I°,:;;";;tlOrl l ¢ I Date
,.,_ ~- <=J::i
~~donator
, f d.,.
17M3 I ~~"
' (
DocumeQSpon'eJr L.J
- ID~,., s-f , ~