ML18030A003

Deficiency Rept Re Defects in American Warming & Ventilation,Inc SSE Sys Dampers.Safety Impact of Defects Being Evaluated.Vendor 800506 Ltr Encl

ML18030A003
Person / Time
Site:	Susquehanna
Issue date:	05/19/1980
From:	Curtis N PENNSYLVANIA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:
References
PLA-485, NUDOCS 8005290423
Download: ML18030A003 (8)

Text

REGULA TJO INFORMATION DISTRIBUTION OSTEM (RIDS) (A CHOATE:

ACCESSION NBR:8005290423 DOC 80/05/19 NOTARIZED'O DOCKET FACIL'. =

usquehanna Steam Electric Stationi Unit 1E Pennsylva 05000387 50 388 squehanna Steam Electric Stationi Unit 2P Pennsylva 05000388 A T ~ AUTHOR AFFILIATION CUR QSPN,N ~ Pennsylvania Po~er 8 Light Co, REC IP ~ NAME RECIPIENT AFFILIATION

SUBJECT:

Oef iciency r ept re defects in American Warming 8 VentilationE Inc SSE sys dampers Safety impact of defects

~

being evaluated, Vendor 80050e ltr encl, DISTRIBUTION CODE: BOIGS COPIES RECEIVED:LTR J ENCL J SIZE:~

TITLE: Construction Oeficiency Report (10CFR50.55E)

BOOTES: ~4 W W g Q ~A<

REC IP IENT COPIES RECIPIENT COPIES, ID CODE/NAME LTTR ENCL ID CODE/NAME LTTR ENCI AC T ION: 14 PM HfhIE 4 1 1 15 BC I MRNA Q 1 1 20 LA t.b/$ 41'g 1 1 21 AD LA(W 1 1 IN TERNAL: 01 EG F IL 1 1 02 NRC PDR 1 1 05 2 2 07 EDO 4 STAFF 1 08 MPA 09 OEPY OIR OPM 10 QAB 13F IELD COOR/ I E 1

1 1

1 1

1 ii 16 STANOROS AO FOR DEV ENGR 1

1 1

1 1

1 17 AO PLANT SYS 1 1 17 AO/CORECCONT 1 1 22 OIR OPM 1 1 23 OELO 1 AO/RC I / IE 1 1 AD/SITE TECH 1 1 AEOD 1 1 DIRECTOR OSE 1 1 GEOSC IENCES BR 1 HANAUERESB 1 1 IRC SYS BR 1 1 MATL ENG BR 1 1 MECH EIVG RR 1 POWER SYS BR 1 1 STRUCT ENG BR 1 1 EXTERNAL: 03 I POR 1 1 04 NSIC 1 1 ACRS ie MAY 30 1980 TOTAL NUMBER OF COPIES REQUIRED: LTTR 48 ENCL 48

PPai TWO NORTH NINTH STREET, ALLENTOWN, PA. 18101 PHONEr (21S) 821 518 I NORMAN W. CURTIS Vice President. Engineering 8 Constructton 821-5381 May 19, 1980 Mr. Boyce H. Grier Director, Region I U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 631 Park Avenue King of Prussia, Pennsylvania 19406 SUSQUEHANNA STEAM ELECTRIC STATION AMERICAN WARMING & VENTILATION, INC REPORT OF A DEFECT IN SSES DAMPERS ERs 100450/100508 FILE 840-4 PLA-485

Dear Mr. Grier:

Zn the attached letter dated May 6, 1980, American Warming & Ventilatingr Znc., notified the U. S. NRC under the provisions of 10CFR Part 21 that defects existed "in the workmanship and design of some wiring connections" of dampers supplied to the SSES project. Through subsequent cor espondence the notification was forwarded to Bechtel Power Corporation and PP&L.

Upon receipt of the information, A. R. Sabol, PP&L advised iM. R. Gallo, NRC Resident Inspector of the AWV, Inc., Part 21 report during a May 15r 1980 telephone conversation and acknowledged its relationship=to equipment which had been supplied for SSES.

Further, since AWVr Znc., has reported the defects under 10CFR Part 21, PP&L recognizes its additional responsibility for evaluating the sazety impact of the defects for their potential for repoztability under the specific provisions o f 10CFR50. 55 (e) .

Upon conclusion of its evaluationr PP&L will advise the Commission accordingly and will identify the date by which a formal report, submitted as required by- 10CFR50.55(e).

if necessary, will be Very truly yours,

'J,Q LEAP~

N. W. Cu tis Vice President-Engineering & Construction Attachment ARSImcb 8008a9O

~~~

PENNSYLVANIA POWER 8 LIGHT COPAPANY

Mr. Boyce H. Grier 2- May 19, 1980 cc: Mr. Victor Stello (15)

DirectorOffice of Inspection & Enforcement U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Mr. G. McDonald Office of Management Information & Program Control U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Mr. Robert M. Gallo U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission P. O. Box 52 Shic}cshinny, Pennsylvania 18655

UIllC-IIi"" fl VVQtfTII(~C

~ j e and venlilalinq

~

i i'lay 6> 1980 TO; U.S. Nucloar Rugulatury Commission ATTGBTIOHt Director, Office of Inspection and, Enforcement IROH- American Marming & Ventilating Inc.

1.310 Indian !iood Circle Haumec, Ohio 43537 4t SVDJECTl Hotiticetion of the 9;1st,euce of a Defect(s) par Title 10, Chapter 1, Code of Federal Regulations - Energy, .Part 21 keporting of Defects and Noncompliance

2

.'q REPORTING ACKNOW:

N:h]E: Donald E. Sloen quality Assurance Hanagcr ADDRESS'merican Harming & Yentilating, Inc.

1310 Iadian 4'ood Cir'cle Haumee, Ohio 43537 ID'>TIPICArrou OC CO>>PONL'!T SVPP LILO:

Jf ALN t]odel Ho. 870U Back Pressure Steam Isolation Dampers C' and AblY Hodel No's YC-41 & 70 Volumu Control Dampors CDEN111'ICATIQN OF SUPPLIER:

~Z American alarming & Yentilatins, Inc.

. j310 Indian Wood Circle Haumee, Ohio 43537 R

e 4C 0 $~ ~ ~

~ ~

~

~ ~

IK

~0 4e 4 JL

Ca U.S; lear Regulatory Commission ilay 6, 1980 Fagu 2.

h HATUKI-; OF DEFECT S3:

Base<I on findinga at the Limerick Generating Station by Bcchl:el Po<>or Corporation ond America<<Warming &

. Ventilating, Inc., personnel 1 di:Frets mist in tlute workmanship and design of some wiring connections, I)ATE OP HHICII THFORHATION OP PHOBI.BI WAS 081'AIHCU:

y 2, 1980 AFFECTED PRO~Et.rS/UHIVS:

I.. Pk(UECT Limerick Generating Station, Units 1 6 2 OliNER Philadelphia Electric Company EHGEHEERS/CONSTRUCTORS - 8<:chtel Power Corporation Snn Francisco Power bivision Ouchtel Job 8031 AWV JOB HO- - 90186 AWV E/UIPMEHT - Hodel 8700's DAIIPEk YAC HUHBEBS SHEPPEU:

BPD-201-2IA BPU-203-42A BP D-501-68k BPD-201-2lB BPO-203-42I3 BPD-501-688 8PD-201-ZZA BPD-203-43A BPD-502-1044 RPU-201-220 B?D-203-438 BPD-502-1048 BPD-20l-23A BPD-001-IA Bl >>-502-118A BPD-"01-239 BPU-00l-II: 81'U-502-1188 BPD-302-67A GPD-001-2A 8PI)-503-1A BPU-202-6)B BPD-001-28 BPI3-503-18 BPD-201-68A BPD-002-IA GPD-503-3A QPD-201-MI3 BFU-002-IB IIPD-503-30

.B"U-202-104A BPI)-002-."-.sK BPU-503-4A BPD-202-1048 B?U-002-28 BPU-503-413 BPD-202-118A BPD-003-IA BPD-503-9A BPD-202-1188 BPD-003-il) BPD-503-9B BPD-203-lA BPD-003 4A BPD 503 IOA BPD-203-18 BPD-003-4B BP D-503-I OB BPD-203>>3A BP D-003-.') h BPU-503-16A QPU-203-3B BPD-003-5II BPD-503-16B BPD-203-4A BPD-003-6A BPD-503>>17~

BPD-203-48 BPD-003-b8 Br U-503-17B BPU-203-9h BPU-003-7A BPA-503-20A BPU-203-9B BPD-003-78 BPU-503-208

U.S. nuclear Repu1atory Couunisaion Hay 6, 1980 Pape 3 (f.i~erie. ConL'~.)

HPlJ-203-1QA BPI)-003"BA BPU-503-23A I

BYU-203-1QB D-203-14A BPU-203-14l3 BPD-003-Bled BPI)-009- lh BVU Ol)9-l lk BPU-503-23U BPl)-503-25h BPD-503-258 llPD-203-1 6A 8 P U-100-2A BPU-503-26A BP))-203-16ll j) P f)-100-2)> Hl'D 503-268 BPD-203-17A BPU-100-3A BPD-503-27A BPl)-203-178 BVD-100-3B ~

BPD-503-276 BPU-203-20A BPD-100-4A SPU-503-28A, BVD-203-208 BPD-100-4li BPD-503-288 BPD>>203-22A SPD>> l 01-lh , BVD-503-29A BPD-101-18 .

BPD-203-22G BPl)-503-29b BPD-203 23h BPD-101-2A BPD-503-30A BPD-203-23B BPD"101-26 BPD-503-308 BPU-203-24A BPD-101-3A BPD-503-31A BPD-203-24B BPD-101-3B BPD-503-318 Bro-203-25A 'PD-400-2A BPD-503-37A BPU-?O3-25B BPD-400-2B BPD-503-370 BPil-203-26A BPD-400"3A BPD-503-3SA

'GPU-203-26B GPD-400-3ls BPU-503-38B BPD-203-27A BPD-400-4A BPD-503-42A HPO-203-27B ~ BPD-400-4B BPD-503-42B BPi)>>203-28A BP0-401-2A BPD-503-43A BPU-203-28B BPD-401-20 BPD-503"438 GPD-203-28A BPO-401-3h BPD-202-33A BPD-203-29B 810-401-3B BPD-202-338 Bi'U-203"30A Bl!D-401-4A BPD-202-40A BPD-203-30B BPD-401-4A BPD-202-40B BPf)-203>>31A BPD-501-21A BPD-202-41A,,

BPD-203-316 BPD-501-215 BPD-202-418 BPD-501-2ZA BPl)-,502-33A BPD-203-37'PD-203-378 BPD-501"228 BPD-502-33B BPU-203-38A BPU-501-23B BPU-502-40h BPD-203-389 Bro-502-67A BPD-502-40B BVD-203-39a BPf)-502-678 BPD-502-41A BPU-203-398 BPD-502-418 TOTAL QUJNTIT'C ~ 173 DA"lPERS

2. PROJECT - Susquehanna Stean Electric Station, Uni.ts 1 & 2 OM'ER Pennsylvania ?ower 6 Light Company EHGlHEERS/CONSTRUCTOkS - Bechtel Power Corporation San Francisco Power Diuision Bechtel Job 8856

~ ~

V Ro U.S. cleur Regulatory Commission W~y G, 1980 Pape 4 AIR JOB NO. '- 90125 I

AHV I.'QUIPilliNI' Hodel. 8700's DcQll'L'I( 'I'Al'UMIIB('IBIIIPVI'.I):

BI)lD376 4A BD1017652A BDID27670A Mll)17674I3 BDIDL76528 BUZD2767013 BDID17675A 80IOl 7659A BDID27671A I)DI0176758 BDID176598 .BDID276718 BDII)1.7667A BOI017653A UDZ027606A BDID176678 BD11)176538 BDID27605A BOID1 7603A 'OID17609A BDIU276068

.BDIDl 760311 BDID176098 BUID27605B BI) ID17604A BDZD17669A IIDID27652A BOID<76n413 BDIU$ 7669B BDIDZ76528 BDIDt7670A BI)ID27674A ODED27653A QDID1767033 BDID276748 BDID276538 Bl)D) 1 76/ 1A BOII)27675'DID276758 BDID27668A Bu?D176718 BDID276688 8olnl766BA BDID27667A BDID27609A BDII)1766SB BOID27667I3 BDZD276098 BDIU1760GA )3DIDZ7603h BD ID21669A BDID17605A BDIDZ7603ll BDID276698 BDID176068 BDID27604A UDID176058 BDlD2760<I3 Tu'LAL QUAHTITY. ~ 58 OA.'IPBRS

3. PROJECT - Highland QIA>> ER - Consumers Poser Company P'~I:.IHKERS /CO'I8'ZMCTORS - BecliI.cl. Power Corporaclcn Ann Arhvr 8cclicel Job 7220 (P.o. vH-348)

Ale'OB HO. 90236 AV/ EQUIP>fEilT Model VG-41's & YC-70's DAtPER TAC HIPIGI,"IIS SHIPPED VC-70' Ind Lcatad Others are YC-41's):

IXV-5320 1XY-55018 OXV-65728 2XV-6220 2XV-5501A OXV-6628 1XV-537nA 2XV-55018 ,OXV-6644 1XV-53168 1XV-5506A OXV-6633

,~

U.S. Nuclear, Regulatory Commission Hay 6, 1980 Palp 5 (Hj.d2.and Cont,'d. }

2xv-6276A )Xv-55ilhll OXV-6608 2XV-6276ll "XV-55ijhA OXV-6639 lXV-5305 ZXV-55068 OL'V-66L1 2Ãv-6205 1,Xv-5510 OTV-3090A 2'-62698 (VC-70) 2'" 5510 OYV-30908 OXV-5467 1XV-5514 4 uxv-5498-1 OXV>>5463A 1XV-5514B Oxv-5498-2 OXV-54638 2XV-5514A Oxv-5498-3 1XV-5442 2XV-55148 OXV-6667 1XV 544l 1XV-5520A OTV-6832 2XV-,5440 1)V-55208 OTV"6833 2xv-5439 2XV>>5520A OTV-6845 .

lXV-5474 2XV-55208 QTV-6807A LXV-5475 0>Ã-6573A OTV-68051:

2XV-5476 OTV-6804F OXV-6573'Xv-6571A 2XV-5477 OTV-6811P OXV-5429 OXV-65716 OTV-6807U Oxv-5436A OXV-6579A OXv-3067A OXV-54368 OXV-65790 OXV-30678 LXV-5501A Xv 6572A TOTAL QUAHTXTY ~ 71 DAHPERS CORi<ECTXVE ACTIONS ..

Al'v personnel have visited the Limerick jobsite and inspected a saruplinb of the dampers involved. Tha other jubsitas have bean notified but not visited as of this dates

2. Correct and calibratabla crimping tools have bean obtained and tests have been performed to evaluate and verify the per f ormanca of these tools.

3. AlJV will, as determined applicable based on si,te inspection, uriginat.e an inspection/repair procedure. Conduct 100X inspection pur this procedure and repair fireplace/correct al.l defectsldef iciencias found.

SIGNED:

TETLEl r A~

c'ATE:

cc: 'HBO> RLB, RLA, JMT)

AJH, DSL, TAT, SFG