ML18017A139
| ML18017A139 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Susquehanna  |
| Issue date: | 03/27/1980 |
| From: | Perkins J AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED |
| To: | Bechhoefer C, Bright G, Paris O Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8004220032 | |
| Download: ML18017A139 (10) | |
Text
James L. Perkins 5!arch 27~
19CO Rr. Bechhoe or, Nr. Bright, and Dr Paris ASL3 for Susq,uehanna 1 and 2
Docket??50-397>
388 US%'.C Washington D.CD 20555 1'echhoefer, le. Bri,".ht, and, Dr. ?'aris~
I attended the hearirc on Varch 20 in the hope of beinp; ablo to:make a limited appearance statement.
Ho'~oyer~
duo to another commitment and to the lerpthier than expected he,".ring I missed uy o",.portuni4y. I ho-.o. you ~ill..cce",.
thos s'x+on conmcnts as ifI had been ablo to":presont them.
I have oevoral pointoe the first is relatively ='nor.
I ~ado a limited appears>co state"en to you in January,
- 1979, regsrdi>>g the use of the Hasmu
~ en-Report by PPAi for public relations purposes.
At.tno lurch recess that day I.a='.ced
?.'r.
Bechhoc':er ix I "..culd;res~-'.vo a reply. I this~ ho c":-ic.'I
~ cull
?Auch lator I received a:l~:".t'r ="om ilr.
utch.'n ".'in~, in effect tha+ neither the Staff r?or, ~AT~ noodod to archer..y statement unle.",o it had a dir.'ct bc:.rin?: on.c
.ain issue Hc.hen completely rJischaract:rizou.
-.,y.tate"e>>t and as";u aZ me my concerns ve??o?rithout; a?'o-,ort' re"pcnded to cl ri v r~
position, but rocoived no further word; Ao uzi>>s thr t neit3:c the Staff nor tho Ppplic,".nts seve supposod to respond because of Pr. Cutchin's letter, I ~vo up.
Later still I road"by cnanco a copy of the Special Pro-hearing-Cenferenno Ordo of 1!arch 6.
On popo 77 it r~ado;.
"During the speci..l prehearirg conference,;re heard a
number of limited,a~T?ear."ncc sects-..nt offer d in accordance with 10 C.":,R 2.715(a).
'<'e.=:ked the Ap-..iicant and/or Staff to pre'iiare ro..pc neoo to those statements not comprehended.
by the admitted cont ntions."
II As I'e read the contentions, the=e io none that mention'."-PZX'o
'ublic relations ccmpa,~.
That io a o",.all r:bettor, b-t it does eau.",e me to;tender abnut the good fai.h of tho attor.".ey for the Staff.
I'd like no+ to share vith you several ouotation 'hat seen gers,"ne o this hoarin."...
On pago 2i; of the Zec:ony'o;.~.:iooion Report reads tho folio~?irg comments I
aELat g> ccnoiGor crucial 8 >14'eihor the F)roQosed chc..?p'ol?
are c'l ried c" b p telic oa'a le or,can~.z'? iiono ( u>>cl?a>>~co)?
t"ith tho same kinds of ur".c iccs
".nd
%ho sar,".o at"itu'oo that vere prevalent prinr,to tiie ocoide>>t, i>o long as
})rogooed imp ovements are car icd out in a 'business cs usual'tmosphere, she fu>>domo>>x".I cha>><;os recce't'"t;d by the acciden' Th. oe i:.ile Island can>>ot oo realized."
0 James L Perkins So we must look to tho
?lRC and the.utiX~ty for improvements in.
attitude> for true concern and for a new way.
On Parch lO, 1980'lan
- Parr, the HHC project manager for the Susquehanna facil3.t-'~
was quoted in the Harrisburg Patriot!
"iihen you come out of a situation like that> (T;tI) you'ro a little bit'unchy.
You have expended so much effort in a very nar.ow arei.
- .o.r'e aro
~tr in.".to relesw.".ou;re sore Ooin;. busioes.". be-ore
" (coos sis and parenthetical corn"ent mine)
I u~:;oat to you', that the St f, upon which you rely for support and upon whose judgement the'n igh-bors of Susauehanna may someday have to rely for their well-being, has not learned, the le"cons of T.".I~
On the national lovel this was'ommented upon by fiemeny on page 56'Pith its present.'or~nization~
staf and attitudes the NRC is unable to fulfillits responsibility, f'r providing an acceptable level of safety for nuclear power plants,"
(On a personal lovel, this was reconfirmed by my experience at the special prehoaring conferenoe last week.
Aa X took. notes for Dr. Johnsrud, I was startled to have a Staff at.orncy shout at her right over my head.
Uninformed though I may be> it oertainly seems that requests for a party to refrain from interrupting "hould bo directed to the ciuir=an or at least politely to the individuals 'uch behavior does not seem to represent changes in attitude which are positive
)
Of all thoso quotes and thoughts>
perhaps tho best summation was offered by I'.itchell Rogovin in The Propnoais on page 171'Ve are not reassured, by what we see so far."
So> here we are in another licensing situation.
The Applicants had moved to throw out one intervonor and exclude two others from oral participation in making the record complete. "
>hat has been the method used to bring about this sit~ation'?
Xt certainly seems that the attempt has been made to bury the representatives under massive requests for information.
As!:
them to list every docw."ent and. every conversation they'e ever had pertaining to lo.~-level radiat.'on;.
Ask thon the names of the Applicants~ plants, and then ask them whore they got that information.
Ask them for.infor ation that no one knows such as the amount of radon due to the plant should it over oe allaed to operate.
And then, when the answer is we dcn't know, or this is unreasonable, the response ha" been. to demand the an=wor again and to threaten the intorvenors with expulsion.
I don't think the attitudes of the utility seem 'to have changed much either
D~~c 3
Jf)mes L. Perkins (DlcQ. n
~ cu
~ 'e tf <I cilc. )xi n in tap". face )
cL 3.iz'c to 4;..zt(
'J'QU to
( 0
':.05)c tali:"':0.":ltlvc~
J,nrc i::.
- e. vtilit'7, ":5, j'!hictl:
1 )
Gc c(I 10 t nPOQ t<'. Do!el ~
iL))))I)G11;8 till: corzgi. I)j
- -:<11."-,
OV.t.".i('.0 i "O
". 0) V1Cn
"."<.a 3(1 DCrCC l" O":
I'.ore of thr; tpt.".1 lovh it
....11=-
to it:: cu."tor1 r,i.
Ip'the 'L>~0~'n 1
i7'" n Q"ly "1>>t C (1:-:.-..I>er Of i'..",.'-,7-l: C:n~ilox r;ltn, I-,O the of )1v l"10;!1"II...c.
2) h:..
sacr u 'OI.'
i@6 511110-'1 Ciollc+.I".': u"
((P."ue>
l)g,t h~.t'.n)".(>,!)lc n(. th;..t l cv rn).t "t1'1.t>>
~
c 'll "io<<'
"<ji 10"'"1 1 6
'3 "1 0" l.
0>> (. i
- 3) in I g1:,;t~ te 1
<>>(~
g 1'(~ thrft)v-hogt the
~ tgtn h;
been rcDrescntc('(
oy it<; public rclatio)l-.
peoplc a
continuinr-to buil>pltt)I'alt)r 7
~ iV that i>>
j <>Gg>
uhC cQ, ID~))41, fprcc(l;t j ill< lc;..+0(
"',I. y '.;oui d thn pl:-Int, b).;
tf "u na'h (:0:1't.
'."hc"0 repro"..Cnta,tive.';
.-::ly the coijil.D."~1~ nv't kccD b)!il(.i>>."",
in or<(er to rccollY) th.
D". 't i!"ve:Itl.'lent Thc (Ivc.)tip> 01.
th(I need for po'!"..1 i:j l'n.".1, I>vt not on" th"t c'n bn o('..Qrc,.:ac('.';
the
..rc.'t".xt 1)Iulic Uuilit~
(tolls!gl.
"loll~ It 1,
~
0
<Iuc!'ip'1 th t ov;"ht to 0<I
'.0((1 c<i i C(l.
no'.v ir. li,-ht of thc "..'.1::. rccor(f."i of 'uhe 1."..".t z::;j y'".r.i
".nd E'I'":L'.. notable record a,='o)1.,<.xv<ltion T.roponentv.
A" ion:7 "" thc cpn:-:tr).).ction y ruit fo'u;;(uch"r lL i" in pl.".CC, P.,"I. fc<:1." the.!eight of th-..-..il)-.,to;0::rpv::(j i;. nccl:.
"t, co.", j:~)p;;.u::t
='.=<<c~ c<):1':tracti;~=.
uh".
',rec(..(I
~I'"-0;)0"".'lip 0->>cns:ivc ~l.':t: 0 fo'uh" i)no.~ln Of thn U')%n>>
i>I)0('v 0 h(l>>'~R v""
Icy
) fOr PPi'::L And f0
'.1 7'"":T. cv.;to;I'nr" I 1
'I,.':
yoU to, I.:."'")nn('uh.
co;l., urvc uic.".
>>cr~vit for
.":.I) =.( Igeh.")lnP.v)Itil:in d)l("nj)e.')Ijc)lt (Lv(:iti7!,,
rl ip
~~ivc)1 f'ri. C(IO..
g".v7)r.: in= "nc sccc::.", to
".IZ:Ii r,.cori,.",
tp Ii 'w Q 'M tit <!
CO),,D
> wpti <
j') t~nQ f<)'f'n
~,
~ i y (.'o cQ, i r O,I Q cp)gpn<, IIp)loot.
I ll(';.jjlp r ii j th tf)i!,'(.,))I;,!1 v,'.)1 ~
..vj) I > c
~
4
~
~
Q'+
'I
( 0~ ~ 11 i~ t [0>>
% 1 up>> ~ ) < I'g Vet tn t' CQ>l spun ecpi Q i
>I'"t '1cl ti uo the cc j~trI)c L'1 one
'ivc.
'- "Uo".)G)1"ion ':it-:;out )1".,ju(
".'. Cc.
I 'f<)vl"
." i ~': ~"C
'I'I 'Ct'"
i)'O' 0 '
~ I ni 6 i'rci.! thi:I follJ'
/pe
~'n;:t ':!i'..'!'.c. fur
>> s< +Vn)' %t 7 ~ two%I I p Ic3gc.
c vop c /oPf' c~i'd sa l ~i'l
~i4 c
~r~
Q 1 3
..t". u
('.. I J..-..
p:;
1
(,1 74ti s 4i.~ pit'rrvr',
7j~~
h lk
EDNUND T
SULKEYICH ~
6 7 0 AL T E R S T H A Z LE T O N P A 1 8 2 0 f 4
p Orat I
03847iS105 04/14/80 ICS'PMMTZZ CSP WSHB 71745tt5131 MGM TDMT HAZI.ETON PA 124 04~ftt 0225P KST DOCKET NUi(iBE gROQ,a uJKia.. 0~9~>g,g CHAIRMAN NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 17f7 H
ST NORTHWEST WASHINGTON DC 20555 t
9
~
~
e.
P DKAR, MR CHAIRMAN A NATIONAL TELEVISION NEWS BROADCAST RECENTLY STATED THAT THE NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION HILL RECOMMEND THAT AN EVACUATION PLAN BE ADOPTED BY PUBLIC UTILITY COMPANIES HHICH WILL USE NUCl.EAR REACTORS TO GENERATE KLECTRICITYI AS A
MINOR STOCKHOLDER IN PENNSYLVANIA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY WHICH HAS A N"CLEAR POWER PLANT UNDER CONSTRUCTION ABOUT 16 MILES FROM MY
'HOMEp I AH HONDKRING THAT IN THE EVENT OF,A MELT DOWN AT THE NEARBY PENNSYLVANIA POWER AND LIGHT:SUSQUEHANNA STEAM ELECTRIC "PlANT IN SALEM TOWNSHIP NEAR BERWICK PA WHAT WOULD BE THE MINIMUM AND MAXIMUM RADIUS IN MILKS FROM THE PLANT WHICH HOUlD'HAVE TO BK.EVACUATED AND FOR HOH LONG2 SINCERELY EDMUND T SULKEVICH 14!26 EST MGMCOMP MGM oceano 8
UsNRc APR g ~gso Dcctefi~g g+ >
BQflC5 CA?
0 DOCKET HUr,ABER
,,~55 5'S0'VEt I
~c~
cP a
DOCKET NUMBER gg, RR09 8 gLGLFA, 4m~-~
~4m rqc,~5<..
a
~
~
Apl~~ ()qg",
~""~
p e'M 6~~4,~~4 j).
I'.c.~~ pq'
'&~~
~o~
o
~
-.,gc OCg~
6 0$
App 0:tice,f 80>
ockfbhZegeehO,
- PPPhj,
<V/gy
- George Rogers Clark,Vincennes,g Ig
~~ cia(
gage,~q oQ X SeQ,'Vie.s~g Comw>S~LQW C US& 1 ~)t
DOCKETNUh!BER qg.g~ g tt'ROD.
8c UTILFAC.;~
Samuel Chilk, Secretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Att Docketing 6 Service Branch Washington, D.C.
20555 Mr. Chilk, P
I am writing to request time to make a Limited Appearance Statement at the licensing hearing's for Pennsylvania Power and Light's Susquehanna Steam Electric Stations 1 and 2 under construction in Berwick, Pennsylvania (Docket numbers 50-387 and 50-388).
Please inform me when and where these hearings will take place.and-when I will be able to speak.
I also would like to request that time be made available in the evenings and/or on weekends for these statements to insure greater public input.
Thank you,
T 9 C. ~ ~'"'
V ~i s
~
~
r
~~e V'
S D{YHRKD USARC
APR-a c @so ~
~~
Office of tf.a Sectetary Deckstio5 5 Setvice jp
=--
~
I t
k
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Matter of PENNSYLVANIA POWER AND LIGHT COMPANY (Susquehanna Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Docket No.(s) 50-387, 50-388 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
~ I hereby certify that I have this day served the foregoing document(s) upon each person designated on the official service list compiled by
~
the Office of the Secretary of the Commission in this proceeding in accordance with the requirements of Section 2.712 of 10 CFR Part 2-Rules of Practice, of the Nuclear Regulatory Commission's Rules and Regulations.
Dated at Washington, D.C. this t /
day of 19/~.
Offich f the Secretary of the C
ission
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Xn the Matter of PENNSYLVANIA POLAR AND LIGHT COMPANY, ET AL.
(Susquehanna Steam Electric Station, Units 1 and 2)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
Docket No. (s) 50 387 50-388 SERVICE LIST Charles Bechhoefer, Esq.,
Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S: Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Mr. Glenn 0. Bright Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S.Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Dr. Oscar H. Paris
~
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Counsel for NRC Staff Office of the Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.
20555 Jay E. Silberg, Esq.
Shaw, Pittman, Potts 6 Trowbridge 1800 "M". Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20036 Pennsylvania Power and Light Company ATTN:
Mr. Norman W. Curtis Vice President Engineering and Construction 2 North Ninth Street Allentown, Pennsylvania 18101 Dr. Judith H. Johnsrud Co. Director, Environmental Coalition on Nuclear Power 433 Orlando Avenue
,State College, Pennsylvania 16801 Ms. Colleen 1farsh 558A
-R.D.
84 Mount Top, Pennsylvania 18707 Mr.
Thomas J. Halligan Cor'respondent CAND P.O.
Box 5
Sacranton, Pennsylvania 18501 Gerald Schultz, Esq.
Susquehanna Environmental Advocates 174 Ifachell Avenue Dallas, Pennsylvania 18612 Mr. Thomas M. Gerusky, Director Bureau of Radiation Protection Department of Environmental Resources Commonwealth of Pennsylvania P.O.
Box 2063 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120 Albert E. Vogel, Jr.,
Esq.
Assistant Attorney General Dept. of Environmental Resources P.O.
Box 2357 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17120