Outlines Objections to 810204 Document Request Per Intervenor 801209 Motion to Permit Entry Upon Facility Site. Proposed Monitoring & Areas of Insp Are Too Nonspecific.No Change in 801224 Position.W/Certificate of SvcML17340A760 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
Turkey Point |
---|
Issue date: |
02/19/1981 |
---|
From: |
Coll N STEEL, HECTOR & DAVIS |
---|
To: |
Chonin N CHONIN, N. |
---|
References |
---|
NUDOCS 8102260760 |
Download: ML17340A760 (18) |
|
|
---|
Category:CORRESPONDENCE-LETTERS
MONTHYEARML17355A4601999-10-26026 October 1999 Forwards Revised Epips,Including Revs to 0-EPIP-1102, 0-EPIP-1212,0-EPIP-20110,0-EPIP-20111,0-EPIP-20132, 0-EPIP-20133 & 0-EPIP-20201,per 10CFR50.54(q) & 10CFR50, App E.Epip 0-EPIP-20107,has Been Deleted ML17355A4301999-10-0808 October 1999 Forwards Rev 16 of Updated Fsar.Info Accurately Reflects Plant Changes Made Since Previous Submittal.Rev Incorporates Changes Completed Between 971015 & 990408.Summary of Accuracy Review Changes & Instructions,Included ML17355A4461999-10-0404 October 1999 Notifies NRC of Change in Commitment to Perform Periodic Testing of Critical Welds & Parts on Special Lifting Devices IAW NUREG-0612.Use of Ae Technology Will Provide Same Level of Testing Quality as Did NDE Methods Noted in ANSI Std L-99-208, Forwards Changes,Tests & Experiments Made as Allowed by 10CFR50.59 for Period Covering 971014-990408. Summary of PORV Actuations & Results of Plants SG Tube Insp,Which Occurred During That Time Included1999-10-0404 October 1999 Forwards Changes,Tests & Experiments Made as Allowed by 10CFR50.59 for Period Covering 971014-990408. Summary of PORV Actuations & Results of Plants SG Tube Insp,Which Occurred During That Time Included ML17355A4291999-10-0404 October 1999 Forwards Response to NRC Telcon Questions Re License Amend Request Dtd 990727,proposing Amend on one-time Basis to Modify TS 3.8.1.1 & TS 3.4.3 & 3.5.2 to Extend Allowed Outage Time for EDG from 72 H to 7 Days ML20212M1601999-09-28028 September 1999 Refers to 990908 Engineering Meeting Conducted at NRC Region II to Discuss Engineering Issues at Lucie & Turkey Point Facilities.List of Attendees & Copy of Presentation Handout Encl ML17355A4251999-09-22022 September 1999 Forwards NRC Form 536 in Response to NRC Administrative Ltr 99-03, Preparation & Scheduling of Operator Licensing Exams, Issued 990820 ML17355A4111999-09-0909 September 1999 Informs That Thermo-Lag Upgrades for Fire Zones 47,54,113, 114,115,116,118,119,120 & 143 Completed on 990726,per GL 92-08 ML17355A4131999-09-0707 September 1999 Forwards Revised Relief Request 20 Re Requirement to Perform Exams as Required by IWL-2524 & IWL-2525,Table IWL-2500-1 for Exempt Tendon Insp,Per Recent Discussions with NRC ML17355A4141999-09-0202 September 1999 Documents That Util Has No Concerns or Challenges Related to site-specific Written Exam Administered at Plant on 990830 ML17355A4041999-08-23023 August 1999 Forwards Info to Support Assessment of Potential Risks Associated with Proposed Civil Aircraft Operations at Former Homestead Air Force Base to FP&L Turkey Point Nuclear Facility Units 3 & 4 ML17355A4071999-08-23023 August 1999 Informs That FPL Has Completed Review of Info Listed in Reactor Vessel Integrity Database,Version 2 & Found Listed Discrepancies,Re Closure of GL 92-01,rev 1,suppl 1, Reactor Vessel Structural Integrity. ML17355A4061999-08-23023 August 1999 Forwards Semiannual FFD Performance Rept for Period of Jan- June 1999,for Turkey Point Units 3 & 4.List of Events Reported & Summary of Mgt Actions Taken,Included ML17355A4001999-08-20020 August 1999 Informs That on 990722,util Determined Blind Specimen Submitted to Smithkline Beecham Clinical Labs on 990721,was Reported Back with Unsatisfactory Results.Attachment 1 Is Summary of Investigation of Unsatisfactory Performance ML17355A3941999-07-27027 July 1999 Submits Response to NRC AL 99-02, Operating Reactor Licensing Action Estimates, for FY00 & FY01 ML17355A3871999-07-16016 July 1999 Provides Supplement to FP&L Response to NRC Request for Info Re Y2K Readiness at Nuclear Power Plants ML17355A3851999-07-14014 July 1999 Informs That Pages Missing from 1998 Annual Radiological Environ Operating Rept, Contain Info Unrelated to ODCM- Specified Sampling & Were Not Included as Part of Rept ML17355A3711999-07-0606 July 1999 Forwards Revised EPIPs 0-EPIP-20201, Maintaining Emergency Preparedness - Radiological Emergency Plan Training & 0-EPIP-20126, Off-Site Dose Calculations. with Summary of Changes ML17355A3591999-06-30030 June 1999 Forwards Turkey Point,Unit 4 ISI Rept. Listed Repts Are Encl.No Eddy Current Exams Scheduled for Unit 4 Steam Generators ML17355A3661999-06-30030 June 1999 Forwards Florida Power & Light Topical QA Rept, Dtd June 1999.Encl I Includes Summary of Changes Made to Topical QA Rept Since 1998 ML17355A3571999-06-28028 June 1999 Informs That Util Voluntarily Reporting Facility Readiness as Outlined in Suppl 1 to GL 98-01.Encl Is Y2K Readiness Disclosure for Units 3 & 4,reporting Status of Facility Y2K Readiness ML17355A3521999-06-18018 June 1999 Forwards Response to NRC 990415 RAI Re GL 96-05, Periodic Verification of Design-Basis Capability of Safety-Related Motor-Operated Valves. ML17355A3491999-06-0404 June 1999 Forwards Summary of Corrective Actions Implemented by FPL Re GL 96-06, Assurance of Equipment Operability & Containment Integrity During Design Basis Accident Conditions. ML17355A3441999-05-27027 May 1999 Modifies FPLs Consent to Confirmatory Order to Reflect Resolution of Four Issues Identified as Pending in L-99-031 ML17355A3451999-05-24024 May 1999 Requests Waiver of 520 Hours (13 Wks) Required Parallel Watchstanding in Control Room Prior to License Application Submittal for W Conley ML17355A2921999-04-22022 April 1999 Forwards Rev 35 to Turkey Point EP & Revised EPIP 0-EPIP-20101, Duties of EC, Per Requirements of 10CFR50, App E & 10CFR50.54(q).Summary of Changes,Encl.Implementation Date for Both Documents Was 990330 ML20205M0431999-04-13013 April 1999 Eighth Partial Response to FOIA Request for Records.App Q & R Records Encl & Being Made Available in PDR ML17355A2891999-04-0909 April 1999 Forwards Relief Request 20, Exempt Tendon Insp, Requesting Relief from ASME Section XI Code,1992 Edition,Paragraph IWL-2521.1(c) Which Requires That Each Exempted Tendon Be Examined IAW IWL-2524 & IWL-2525.Approval Needed by 991001 ML17355A2861999-04-0505 April 1999 Forwards COLR for Turkey Point Unit 4,Cycle 18,IAW TS 6.9.1.7 ML17336A0681999-04-0101 April 1999 Expresses Support for FP&L Request for Waiver of Applicable Review Fees Upon FP&L Submittal of an Application for License Renewal for Turkey Point Units 3 & 4 ML17355A2751999-03-25025 March 1999 Informs NRC & Staff of Fp&Ls Plans to Submit License Renewal Application for Turkey Point Units 3 & 4 by End of Dec 2000 ML17355A2641999-03-19019 March 1999 Requests Changes to FPL Official Service List for Turkey Point,Units 3 & 4.Add s Franzone & Remove G Hollinger from All Correspondence ML17355A2651999-03-19019 March 1999 Forwards Annual Radioactive Effluent Release Rept for Jan-Dec 1998 & Rev 7 to ODCM for Gaseous & Liquid Effluents from Turkey Point,Units 3 & 4. ML17355A2621999-03-16016 March 1999 Forwards Special Rept as Result of Turkey Point Unit 3 End-of-Cycle 16 ISI of SG Tubes.Rept Summarizes Results of SG Tube ISI ML17355A2631999-03-12012 March 1999 Forwards FPL Decommissioning Fund Status Repts for St Lucie, Units 1 & 2 & Turkey Point,Units 3 & 4.Rept for St Lucie, Unit 2 Provides Status of Decommissioning Funds for All Three Owners of That Unit ML20204C6991999-03-10010 March 1999 Requests Amend to Turkey Point PSP to Modify Requirement to Post Security Officers to Provide Continuous Observation of Entire PA Perimeter in Event of Security Computer Failure. Change to Security Force Staffing Level Also Requested ML17355A2451999-03-0909 March 1999 Submits Info on FPL Current Levels of Nuclear Property Insurance,Per 10CFR50.54(w)(3) ML17355A2501999-03-0808 March 1999 Informs That Licensee Reviewed NRC 990228 Ltr Issuing Exemption Requested Re Fire Rating of Raceway Fire Barriers in Open Turbine Bldg.Tabulated Summary of Util Comments & Marked Copy of NRC Ltr & SER Encl ML17355A2441999-03-0101 March 1999 Provides Update to Util Written Notices,Dtd 961120 & 970627 of Claim Involving Alleged Bodily Injury Arising Out of or in Connection with Use of Radioactive Matl at Units 3 & 4 ML17355A2431999-02-25025 February 1999 Informs That FPL Does Not Have Any Candidates from Turkey Point Scheduled to Participate in 990407,Generic Fundamentals Examination (GFE) ML17355A2301999-02-18018 February 1999 Forwards Semiannual Fitness for Duty Performance Data for Period of 980701-981231 for Turkey Point Units 3 & 4 ML17355A2361999-02-18018 February 1999 Forwards Tabulation of 1998 Occupational Exposure Data for Turkey Point,Units 3 & 4,per TS 6.9.1.2.a.Reactor Coolant Specific Activity Limits of 100/E-bar Mci Per Gram of Gross Radioactivity Were Not Exceeded During 1998 L-99-042, Forwards Rev 13 to Turkey Point Physical Security Plan,Per 10CFR50.54(p).Util Determined That Rev Does Not Decrease Safeguards Effectiveness of Plan.Encl Withheld,Per 10CFR2.790(a)(3)1999-02-18018 February 1999 Forwards Rev 13 to Turkey Point Physical Security Plan,Per 10CFR50.54(p).Util Determined That Rev Does Not Decrease Safeguards Effectiveness of Plan.Encl Withheld,Per 10CFR2.790(a)(3) ML17355A2341999-02-18018 February 1999 Provides Response to RAI Re GL 97-01, Degradation of Crdm/ CEDM Nozzle & Other Vessel Closure Head Penetrations. ML17355A2231999-02-0808 February 1999 Informs That Util Will Comply with Commitment with Respect to Units 3 & 4,in Response to Ja Zwolinski 990129 Ltr.Util Also Agrees to Incorporate Commitment Into Confirmatory Order Modifying License Effective Immediately Upon Issuance ML17355A2031999-01-29029 January 1999 Forwards Rev 3 to Turkey Point Nuclear Plant Recovery Plan. Rev Does Not Decrease Effectiveness of Plan ML17355A2171999-01-20020 January 1999 Forwards Listed ISI Repts for Turkey Point Unit 3,in Accordance with Provisions of ASME Code,Section XI ML17354B2241999-01-0606 January 1999 Forwards Annual 10CFR50.46 Rept Re Changes To,Or Errors Discovered in ECCS Evaluation Models,Or in Application of Such Models That Effect Peak Clad Temp Calculation ML17354B2081998-12-15015 December 1998 Informs That Fpl,In Cooperation with State of Fl & County Emergency Response Agencies,Will Conduct Exercise of Turkey Point Radiological Emergency Plan on 990210.Scenario Package Forwarded to Emergency Preparedness Section Chief,Region II ML17354B2091998-12-15015 December 1998 Forwards Price Anderson Guarantees Annual Financial Rept,Per 10CFR140.21.Exhibit 1 Submitted to Satisfy Annual Financial Reporting Requirement of 10CFR50.71(b) 1999-09-09
[Table view] Category:EXTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE
MONTHYEARML20045D6731992-10-13013 October 1992 FOIA Request for Documents Re Effects of Hurricane Andrew on Emergency Planning & Preparedness for Plant ML17348A3351990-06-19019 June 1990 Forwards Corrected, Effluent & Waste Disposal Annual Rept for 1988, Consisting of Summary of Radioactive Effluents ML20012E1451990-03-19019 March 1990 Advises That Author Had No Hostile or Coercive Motives in 900307 Ltr to ATI Career Training Ctr Inquiring About Recipient.Author Intended Ltr as Independent Verification of Facts Stated in Pleadings ML20246P1831989-07-0303 July 1989 Documents Oral Agreement for 30-day Extension of Time to Respond to Licensee 890621 First Set of Discovery Requests to Ctr for Nuclear Responsibility & J Lorion Until 890710.W/ Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML17347B0211989-03-15015 March 1989 Ack Receipt of 890126 Ltr Re Draft Effluent Info for 1987.No Comments Offered ML17345A5051988-10-31031 October 1988 Requests Investigation of Util Violation of 10CFR19 Re Util Harassment of Author Due to Communications W/Nrc Concerning Series of Events at Facility ML17345A1671988-05-13013 May 1988 Forwards Suggested Changes,In Form of marked-up Pages,To Draft Radioactive Effluent Info for 1986 ML20138L3461985-10-28028 October 1985 Notifies of Util Disagreement W/Intervenor Request for Extension Until 851109 to Respond to Licensee 850920 Motion for Summary Disposition & 851015 Supporting Response. Certificate of Svc Encl L-83-599, Responds to Requesting Review of Info Summary of Radioactive Effluents During 1981.Info Verified to Be Correct1984-01-13013 January 1984 Responds to Requesting Review of Info Summary of Radioactive Effluents During 1981.Info Verified to Be Correct ML17340B0151981-04-0707 April 1981 Advises of Agreement W/Summary Disposition of Contention 5. Related Correspondence ML17340A9331981-03-27027 March 1981 Advises That 810101 Plant Survey Repts Will Be Compiled & Available for Insp & Copying.Neither Documents Nor Info Contained in Documents Are to Be Disclosed Per ASLB 810324 Ruling.W/Certificate of Svc ML17340A7601981-02-19019 February 1981 Outlines Objections to 810204 Document Request Per Intervenor 801209 Motion to Permit Entry Upon Facility Site. Proposed Monitoring & Areas of Insp Are Too Nonspecific.No Change in 801224 Position.W/Certificate of Svc ML17340A6441981-01-16016 January 1981 Forwards ASLB 800723 Order Re Steam Generator Repair Proceedings Per 810113 Order.Certificate of Svc Encl.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML17340A6101981-01-0808 January 1981 Confirms 810107 Telcon Re Preliminary Informal Conference to Discuss Facility Repairs & Schedule for Proceedings on Proposed Amends to Ols.Proposed Schedule & Certificate of Svc Encl ML17340A2251980-09-29029 September 1980 Requests That Resolution Mentioned in Motion for Leave to Participate Be Submitted.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML17339A6331980-01-31031 January 1980 Confirms Telcon Re Pleadings to Be Served on N Chonin & Hh Harnage on Behalf of M Oncavage.Updated Svc List Encl ML19225B4411979-05-12012 May 1979 Forwards MP Oncavage 790424 Reply to Florida Power & Light 790330 & NRC 790406 Responses ML19274D7141979-01-19019 January 1979 Expresses Concern Re Plant'S Effect on Water at Biscayne Bay ML17266A0151978-12-20020 December 1978 Forwards Matl Status Rept for Period 771001 to 780331 for Lic#DPR-31,DPR-41,DPR-67 & SNM-1514 & Nuc Matl Transaction Rept for Lic#DPR-31 & DPR-41 ML17338A4031978-06-14014 June 1978 Forwards NPDES Permit for Subj Facil.Permit to Become Effective on Date Noted Provided No Request for Adjudicatory Hearing Is Filed with Epa.W/Encl EPA Correspondence 1992-10-13
[Table view] Category:EXTERNAL LETTERS ROUTED TO NRC
MONTHYEARML17348A3351990-06-19019 June 1990 Forwards Corrected, Effluent & Waste Disposal Annual Rept for 1988, Consisting of Summary of Radioactive Effluents ML20012E1451990-03-19019 March 1990 Advises That Author Had No Hostile or Coercive Motives in 900307 Ltr to ATI Career Training Ctr Inquiring About Recipient.Author Intended Ltr as Independent Verification of Facts Stated in Pleadings ML20246P1831989-07-0303 July 1989 Documents Oral Agreement for 30-day Extension of Time to Respond to Licensee 890621 First Set of Discovery Requests to Ctr for Nuclear Responsibility & J Lorion Until 890710.W/ Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML17347B0211989-03-15015 March 1989 Ack Receipt of 890126 Ltr Re Draft Effluent Info for 1987.No Comments Offered ML17345A5051988-10-31031 October 1988 Requests Investigation of Util Violation of 10CFR19 Re Util Harassment of Author Due to Communications W/Nrc Concerning Series of Events at Facility ML17345A1671988-05-13013 May 1988 Forwards Suggested Changes,In Form of marked-up Pages,To Draft Radioactive Effluent Info for 1986 ML20138L3461985-10-28028 October 1985 Notifies of Util Disagreement W/Intervenor Request for Extension Until 851109 to Respond to Licensee 850920 Motion for Summary Disposition & 851015 Supporting Response. Certificate of Svc Encl L-83-599, Responds to Requesting Review of Info Summary of Radioactive Effluents During 1981.Info Verified to Be Correct1984-01-13013 January 1984 Responds to Requesting Review of Info Summary of Radioactive Effluents During 1981.Info Verified to Be Correct ML17340B0151981-04-0707 April 1981 Advises of Agreement W/Summary Disposition of Contention 5. Related Correspondence ML17340A9331981-03-27027 March 1981 Advises That 810101 Plant Survey Repts Will Be Compiled & Available for Insp & Copying.Neither Documents Nor Info Contained in Documents Are to Be Disclosed Per ASLB 810324 Ruling.W/Certificate of Svc ML17340A7601981-02-19019 February 1981 Outlines Objections to 810204 Document Request Per Intervenor 801209 Motion to Permit Entry Upon Facility Site. Proposed Monitoring & Areas of Insp Are Too Nonspecific.No Change in 801224 Position.W/Certificate of Svc ML17340A6441981-01-16016 January 1981 Forwards ASLB 800723 Order Re Steam Generator Repair Proceedings Per 810113 Order.Certificate of Svc Encl.W/O Encl.Related Correspondence ML17340A6101981-01-0808 January 1981 Confirms 810107 Telcon Re Preliminary Informal Conference to Discuss Facility Repairs & Schedule for Proceedings on Proposed Amends to Ols.Proposed Schedule & Certificate of Svc Encl ML17340A2251980-09-29029 September 1980 Requests That Resolution Mentioned in Motion for Leave to Participate Be Submitted.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML17339A6331980-01-31031 January 1980 Confirms Telcon Re Pleadings to Be Served on N Chonin & Hh Harnage on Behalf of M Oncavage.Updated Svc List Encl ML19225B4411979-05-12012 May 1979 Forwards MP Oncavage 790424 Reply to Florida Power & Light 790330 & NRC 790406 Responses ML19274D7141979-01-19019 January 1979 Expresses Concern Re Plant'S Effect on Water at Biscayne Bay ML17266A0151978-12-20020 December 1978 Forwards Matl Status Rept for Period 771001 to 780331 for Lic#DPR-31,DPR-41,DPR-67 & SNM-1514 & Nuc Matl Transaction Rept for Lic#DPR-31 & DPR-41 ML17338A4031978-06-14014 June 1978 Forwards NPDES Permit for Subj Facil.Permit to Become Effective on Date Noted Provided No Request for Adjudicatory Hearing Is Filed with Epa.W/Encl EPA Correspondence 1990-06-19
[Table view] |
Text
STEEL HECTOR 6c DAVIS SOUTHEAST FIRST NATIONAl. BANK BUILDING MIAMI)FLORIDA 33I31 WILLIAMC.STEEL LOUIS J HECTOR PATRICIA A 5CITZ PAUL J, SONAVIA TCLCPHONC I305) 577 2800 DARRCY A, DAVIS ROIS CRT J, IRVIN TELEX 51-5758 CLWYH L MIDDI.CTON C ROSCRT DONALD M. MIDDLCSROOK5 dURNS'ILL WILLIAM4, KILLIAN CRNCST'.
JOHN M. I'ARRCLI.
HCWCTT) RA MIKC 5. 4VCKNCR ARTHUR O,WRO4LC JUDITH M, KCIRCHIH M PRCSTOH WILLIAM 5ADOWSK I OF COUNSEL JCRRY S,CROCKETT) P.A, JOHN M, 4ARKCTT W I L50 N 5 M IT Hp R A JCI'I'RCY I, MULLENS TALSOT DALCHSCRTCp PA VANCC C,SALTCR JAM CS H SWCCNY)Zt)RA PALM DCACH OFFICC W. PCTER 4VRNS JOHN EDWARD SMITH DERRY 5 STEEL HECTOR DAVIS BURNS 4 MIDDLETON H DAVID FAUST NORMAN A,COLL L.POULSON OI45ON'HARYL RICHARD J LAMPCN February 19, 1981 2OS WORTH AVENUE THO5 C CAPPSp P A JOSC I *STIOARR*OA P. O BOX 2537 SHCPARD KINOpRA THOMAS J MATKOV PALM DCACHp FLORIDA 33~O MATTHEW H,CHILDSp RA JCIPI'RCY SCRCOW SARRY R DAVIDSON FRANK P.SCRVOOS)12 TCLEPNOHCI305) 555 53II NOCL H,NATIOHpP.A W OLCNN OCHPSCY SRUCC 5 RVSSCLL THOMAS R,WOOLSCY ALVIN 4 DAVIS SARSARA A SILVCRICAN~
JOSCPH P. KLOCKpJR JOHN T, SU'TLER RICHARD C,SMITH SRIAN R SRATTCSO THOMAS R, MAOUIOAR) PI* SHERRY A,STANLEY DCH HIS Ao LARUSSA) P A WILLIAML COVR5HON Do DENNIS P,COYLEpPA QQNRC 9
~
FEB 23198$ >
Neil Chonin, Esq. Qfffce of thII85R55llf 1400 AmeriFirst, Building OocfletiIINSSQHOI y
One S.E. 3rd Ave. BINIICb Miami, Florida 33131 Re: In the Matter of Florida Power If',Light Company (Turkey Point. Nuclear Generating, Unit Nos. 3 and, 4)
Docket Nos. 50- 5 50-251 (Proposed Amendments to Pacility Opera ng Licenses, to Permit Steam Generator Re air
Dear Neil:
Thank you for your letter of Pebruary 4,. 1981 regarding "Turkey Point Site. Inspection."
In the Intervenor's "Motion to Permit Entry Upon Turkey point Site" served December 9, 1980, the motion sought an order authorizing access to the site, and'he production of certain documents. Your letter of February 4', 1981 addresses both items and this letter will respond to both.
Document Re uest In the December 9, 1980 Motion, the Intervenor wishes to examine. . ."
it was stated that ".
three categories of documents (Motion, tt8):
- a. ! ". . .the Plant Survey Reports starting" January 1, 1978.
~p
~h b.. ". . .the environmental radiological monitoring data starting January 1, 1978.
~3 5 IZl o~o
~al Cgt LP S
JF~-'pl p
O
~C3cV
/I I
C
q/
0 il 0 Wq 'gU L4 / ~~>
-"~>WQoe "ggf c. w 83
~pi')g g~gNi+
STEEL H'EcTQ R SE DAYIs Neil Chonin, Esq.
February 19, 1981 Page 2
- c. ". . .the workers dosimetry records starting January 1, 1978.,
In the Licensee's Response served December 24, 1980,. FPL objected to the production of the records in categories (a) and (c) for the reasons there stated, and indicated that those in category (b) were available for. inspection at the Local Public Document Room which is maintained at the Urban and Environmental Affairs Library at Florida International University. FPL objected to the production of the Plant Survey Reports and Personnel Dosimetry Records on the grounds that the information sought was. irrelevant and immaterial to the issues and, subject matter of this proceeding and was not designed to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence'. (Response pp 10, 14.) As to the Plant Survey Reports, FPL also objected on the grounds that to require it to compile such information is unduly, burdensome, oppressive, and expensive in that such reports, which are prepared at the rate of 12 to 15 reports per day, and an. active file of which is only maintained'or 3 to 12'onths, are, reduced to microf'ilm annually on a batch basis with other plant records, and a review by FPL of all. microfilm cassettes would be necessary. (Response,
- p. 11.) As to the Personnel Dosimetry Records, FPL also objected on the grounds that same were confidential, to which the individual has a right of privacy', and such exemption from disclosure has been authorized by Commission regulations for such records in the possession of the NPC. 10 CFR 59.5(a) (6) (i). FPL did point out. that summaries of individual dosimetry records were on file and available for inspection at the Local Public Document Room. (Response, p. 14.)
In our meeting January 26, 1981, we discussed these document requests with your client and further explained the na'ture of the records and the reason for FPL's objections.
Your letter of February 4', 1981 states that "Douglas King, Health Physicist and Mark Oncavage, Intervenor" want to inspect certain records at the plant ". . .dating back to January 1, 1979. . ." identified as:
"(a) Personnel Dosimetry H.P. Records.
(b) Plat (sic) Report H.P. Records."
Your letter also requests, for the first time:
/I
/
/
STEEL HECTOR & DAVIS Neil Chonin, Esq.
February 19, 1981 Page, 3
"(c) Any supplies that may be needed- to carry out the. record. search, i.e. lab coats, TLD's, shoe coverings, gloves, face masks, etc.
(d) A site health physicist. to answer questions pertaining to the locations of the various type (sic) of H.P. records."
To the extent that the'ocument request in. your letter of'ebruary 4, 1981 is similar to that contained i:n your Motion of December 9, 1980, FPL objects on the same grounds as stated in its Response of December 24, 1980, which is incorporated herein by reference.. In addition,, we wish to advise. you. of the following objections:
A. At our meeting January 26, 1981 we explained to Mr. Oncavage the con-fidential, private, medical natUre of individual "Personnel Dosimetry H.P.,
Records" and the basis for FPL.'s objection to their production on those grounds, as well as the availability of summaries of this data, in the Local Public Document Room. Of course, FPL's objection in this regard extends to disclosing such 'documents to "Douglas King, Health Physicist".
B. As to the Plant Survey Reports, we have made clear the extensive, expen-sive nature of the search for same dating back to January 1, 1979. . ." As to the producti;on of those which may relate to the past 3 to 12 months which may be on active file, we interpose FPL's previous objections.
C. FPL is not required to provide, and objects to your request for "any supplies that may be needed to carry out the record search.
D. FPL is not required to provide, and objects to your request for ". . .a site health physicist to answer questions
,f il
STEEL HECTOR: & DAVIS Neil Chonin, Esq.
Februaiy 19, 1981 Page 4 pertaining to the locations of the various type (sic) of H.P'., Records".
See Belcher v. Bassett Furniture Industry.es, Inc., 588 F.2d 90 ('4th Cir.
1978) .
Re uest, For Access to Site In the Motion of December 9, 1980, the purpose of the site visit was expressed to be ". . .to determine. . .whether or not there has been radioactive leakage into the various cooling canals and surrounding areas. of the Turkey Point Site . . .," and
.to do a physical radiological survey of Turkey Point and environs, to obtain samples of the air, water,, soil, sediment, and various biota forms."'Motion, g9 5,. 7, 8.)
The meeting of January 26, 1981 was attended by techni;cal representatives from Dade County who- are familiar with the current. monitoring program conducted by the State of Florida for FPL at Turkey Point.. The. location of the monitoring equipment, method of sampling, data obtained, and refinement obtained from this program were- described and discussed. of'ata The: discussion also covered- the need for those persons conducting, such activities to have expert qualifications.
Mr. Oncavage was questioned about the details of the proposed site visit and the qualifications of the experts he proposed to bring with him. Mr. Oncavage was not prepared to respond to our questions for more detail at the meeting, but, at your suggestion, he agreed to consult with his experts and to provide a letter to the parties by February 2, 1981 which describes in detail the testing and monitoring proposed to be conducted including the names, addresses, and expert qualifications of the person(s) involved,, so that we could discuss the matter further. (See my letter to the Board of January 28, 1981, 92).
Your letter of February 4, 1981 indicates that access is requested to both the restricted area and the unrestricted area of the site for "Douglas King, Health physicist, Mark Oncavage, Intervenor, Barry Levin, Ph.D, Health Physicist, and George Swensson, Fisherman. . . to collect samples for the purpose of measuring radioactivity and surveying the site for general levels of radioactivity". Neither the identity nor the qualifications of the named individuals are further described.
/
STE EL H ECTO R 6R DAYI S Neil Chonin, Esq.
February 19, 1981 Page 5 Your letter then states:
"Samples from the restricted area will consist of soils, subsoils, plants, insects, air, water, bottom sediments,. algae, exterior building swipes (including containment buildings),. and interi:or building swipes.
Samples from the unrestricted area, in the vicinity of the cooling canals, will include soils, subsoils, plants., insects, small animals,; birds, fish, reptiles, algae, water, and bottom sedi'ments."
Finally, your letter states .that you wish FPL to provide.:,
"(a) Any suppl'ies needed to carry out the proposed .sampling,, X.E.. (sic) hard hatsg TLD-'s, shoe coverings, gloves, face masks, radiation protective clothing, etc.
(b) A servicable (sic) geiger counter."
Our client has given careful consideration to Mr.
Oncavage's request to visit the site, as contained in the Motion of December 9, 1980 and your letter of February.', 1981. For the reasons set forth below, it. must continue to maintain its objections as expressed in Licensee's Response served December 24, 1980, and also to interpose the following objections:
A. The proposed onsite activities, as you have described them, do not appear to be designed to obtain any information different from that presently obtained by the radiological environmental monitoring programs conducted by FPL and the State of Florida. The results of the State of Florida program are reported semi-annually by FPL to the NRC and are available for. inspection at the Local Public Document Room., Neither the Motion of December 9 nor your letter of February 4 suggests how or that the proposed monitoring and sampling by Mr. Oncavage would develop significantly different, or more accurate data.
iN
~ i>
4
~ ~
STEEL HECTOR & DAVIS Neil Chonin, Esq.
February 19, 1981 Page 6 B. Neither the addresses nor the expert qualifications of "Douglas King, Health Physicist, Mark Oncavage, Intervenor, Barry L'evin, Ph.D, Health Physicist, and George Swensson, Fisherman, are disclosed. FPL is entitled, at a minimum to be provided with their addresses, and a summary of their expert qualifications including educational background (college attended', date of graduation, degree(s) received), occupational experience, and current employment.
C. The heal'th physicists, Mr..King and Mr.. Levin, do not appear to be equipped with, or have access to supplies or even elementary radiological monitoring equipment to conduct the proposed, sampling and monitoring. It should be known to Mr.. Oncavage, or at least to the persons whom he has designated to assist him, that his request, for a "servicable geiger counter" could apply to numerous instruments, of different makes, models, and calibrated with varying sensitivities, all according to the- function be performed. In any event, FPL is not
'o required to provide such supplies or equipment.
D.'o attempt is made to describe how or that any analysis or testing of any "samples" will be performed:, where it will be performed, by whom it will be performed, or what equip-ment will be used to perform it. Your letter does not indicate that Mr. Oncavage and his designated experts are. qualified, equipped, or prepared to perform any testing or analysis on site.
E. FPL is unauthorized to release and Mr. Oncavage and his designated experts would not, without a license, be authorized to re-move any "samples" from within the restricted area of the site which contain significant levels of activity. Consequently, any "sam-ples" that Mr. Oncavage seeks to remove would first have to be analyzed by FPL to determine
II il h
~
~ .
I, 7
C'
STEEL HECTOR & DAVIS, Neil Chonin, Esq.
February 19, 1981 Page 7 the levels of activity. Such analysis, if performed by FPL, will. be expensive and time consuming..
F. Plant security is an ever-present concern to FPL, and is of concern in this instance, in view of Mr.. Oncavage's. failure or reluctance to adequately disclose the identity 'and background of his designated experts, and his lack of specificity as to areas of the site. to be visited.
All of the foregoing deficiencies that is the broad, generalized, non-specific, description of the proposed monitoring and sampling, and areas of the site to be inspected; the failure to disclose the identity and expert qualifications of persons proposed to conduct, the moni'toring; the demonstrated lack of supplies, and equipment for the proposed sampling, and monitoring; the failure to describe what, if any, -testing or analysis is proposed to be done of, the "samples", or to provide for any analysis all create serious doubts about the accuracy, validity, and, reliability of the information to be obtained, the conclusions to be drawn from it, or its probative value, in these proceedings. Consequently, your letter of February 4, if any, 1981 provides. no basis for our client to change its previous position as expressed in its response of Dece ber 24, 1980.
Very truly yours, Nor an A. Coll cc: See attached Certificate of Service
0 ik 4
~"
~,
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSON BEFORE THE'ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD Docket Nos. 50-250-SP 50-251-SP IN THE MATTER OF )
FLORIDA POWER & L'IGHT COMPANY ) (Proposed Amendments to (Turkey Point Nuclear Generating ) Facility Operating Units Nos. 3 and 4 ) License to- Permit Steam Generator Repairs)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.
I HEREBY CERTIFY that copies of the foregoing.
letter of February 19, 1981 were served on the following by deposit in the United States mail, first class, properly stamped'nd addressed,. on the date shown below:
Elizabeth S. Bowers, Esq., Administrative Judge Chairman, Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Emmeth A. Luebke, Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. Oscar H. Paris, Administrative Judge Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Mr. Mark P. Oncavage 12200 S.W. 110th Avenue Miami, Florida 33176 Harold F. Reis, Esq.
Steven P. Frantz, Esq.
Lowenstein, Newman, Reis & Axelrad 1025 Connecticut Avenue, N.W.
Washington,. D.C. 20036
ik ~ ~
Steven C. Goldberg, Esq.,
Office of the Executive Legal Director U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Docketing and Service Section Office of the Secretary U.S. Nuclear. Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Burt Saunders, Esq.
Assistant Dade County Attorney 1626 Dade County Courthouse Miami, Florida 33130, Henry H. Harnage, Esq.
Peninsula Federal Building 10th Floor 200 S.E. First Street Miami, Florida, 33131 STEEL HECTOR & DAVIS Co-counsel .for Licensee 1400 Southeast First National Bank Building Miami, Florida 33131 Telep ne. (305) 577-2863 By
./
orman A. Co February 19, 1981
II 0 e I