ML17209A926
| ML17209A926 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Saint Lucie  |
| Issue date: | 04/08/1981 |
| From: | Guttman D SPIEGEL & MCDIARMID |
| To: | Stephens C NRC OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY (SECY) |
| References | |
| ISSUANCES-A, NUDOCS 8104140246 | |
| Download: ML17209A926 (9) | |
Text
I LAW OFFICES GEORGE SPIEGEL. PC SPIEGEL 6 McDIARbfID ROBERT C. MCDIARMID 2600 VIRGINIA,AVENUE, N.W.
SANDRAJ. STREBEL ROBERT A. JABLON WASHINGTON, D.c. 20037 JAMES N. HORWOOD ALANJ. ROTH TELEPHONE (202) 333-4500 TELECOPIER I202) 333-2974 THOMAS N. MCHUGH.J DANIELJ. GUTTMAN g
PETER K. MATT pp DAVIDR. STRAUS
~
IJT " "
~98Ie3 1l t/
,CO 2 RE0
'g
+IDq~>4'pril 8, 1981 SUSAN T. SHEPHERD C
ROM M.LANDSMAN BONNIE S. BLAIR ROBERT HARLEY BEAR THOMAS C. TRAUGER JOHN MICHAEL'ADRAGNA CYNTHIAS. BOGORAD GARY J. NEWELL MARC R. POIRIER MARTAA. MANILDI JOSEPH L VAN EATON STEPHEN C. NICHOLS PATRICIA E. STACK Chase R. Stephens Chief Docketing and Service Section Nuclear Regulatory Commission 1717 H Street N.W.
Washington, D.C.
20006 DOCKETED Ug~).l. t' At R 9>S8) 5 Office ef '~
8-"- f-.g Byj Cb Re:
Florida, Power 8 Li ht Co. (St. Lucie Plant Unit No.
2 NRC Docket No. 50-389A
Dear Mr. Stephens:
Cities'iling of April 7, 1981 inadvertently omitted an attachment (Appendix VTF), twenty copies of which are enclosed.
Sincerely, Daniel Guttman Attorney for the Gainesville Regional Utilities, the Lake Worth Utilities Authority, the Utilities Commission of New Smyrna Beach, the Sebring Utilities Commission, and, the Cities of Alachua, Bartow, Fort Meade, Homestead, Kissimmee, Mount Dora, Newberry, St.
Cloud, Starke, and Tallahassee, Florida Enclosure cc: Florida Power 8 Light Company NRC Staff Department of Justice
'~~p9
&I/
/*
~
e ~
r ~rrr~r r ~rr
'i
%4
~
.IN IR PONOIKNCZ yt7 AppENDIX VIF
'.. g
/ "'
P J)BQP P
<.oc*s<o~
West Palz-Beach To
'M=NO TO cIL= ll
~-
Uo""."
October.13, 1970
.91981
.'A<
R D, QQ owcE to Mr Zr. Lr Br eedlove Q<b, s<,cÃtNl S
M=. O'. Browning EMCLCCY<
. 'Dock<.<i<<.~
BtN 000[gEy P~g~P~>+'L y,.
/ROD. & UTILFAD.QQ~+
A zaeetmg was held in Mr. BreedIove's office this morning, October 13th wiA'xMr. Bathen and CarL Port-. of the R. W. Bectc h Compa"y, along with Cozazaissioner Lee Nelson from Fort Pierce, who was accompanied by Miltozz Davis, Ci.g Manager, aad Bob SMnner, Dis~-
bution =ngineer, and M. Breeclove, Mr. Browning and myseLf.
Discusse<i by the'g oup <vas the tie that had bee+ negotiated fo-emer-gency and scheduled serrice the firs of this yea" with the City of
~ Zort Pierce 3'.
I The reason for additionaL discu~sion was that rece tly the City had difficulties with their geaera4ion.
ance some of the generators were offfor as much. as 30 hours3.472222e-4 days <br />0.00833 hours <br />4.960317e-5 weeks <br />1.1415e-5 months <br /> The emergency He liae. was to our. 69 Kv Line at 29th and Virginia. Avenue frozen the Rhode island substation.
%'e were aole to supply Fort Pierce at the time of the iater~ptioa wiA appro~ately 10,000 or 11,000 Kw.
'26w,. the Ci~~p, aecause t~~s temporary line is buil", is ve~'desirous, of maV=.g it a permaz:ent tie
~ Hs tie would not be sat sfac.ory so faz. as the wr'te
'.s cancer" ed because ou-system would not 'oe adeouat ly protected aad would not be practical to para11el or syn-chm~e into the city', nor couLd we control the supply when we, could not a~~ord to suppLy Rem.
j ~
~ Since ~~is eques has a lot of elec.acaL ramifications, we told them,
.the City Manage and City =ng -ear, we would disc.ss
~>s wi~A our pLaaai g group aad would advise them; but we felt compliance w the agreeme t would be the only way we could practically sewe the whea power was desired and when powe was available.
During the discussion it was brought out that on Novembe= 2 Lair 33 z=egawat. <'t would have to be out of se~ce for aooroxi=ately Z~i weeks cue to maMenance and overhaul.
They are ve~ aceous N utDi=e ~s t e for at least this emergency, 'm~g. se~ce avaD-able to the 3"ode Island subsection a supply of appro~tely 12 megawatts
~
<-0!lP7&y 'iYI3(S PRtKRQS
-ca ~ QP'o*.,P<:; Ycz:R c M<RA<<Y.
N'3R YcUI f0 <<ae
~ 1
~ c > ~
I ~
~
~
~
~ ~
~
~
~
f ~l~
~ kt
~
~ lo p\\
~
0 ~
'", The not matter oi fi~power was discussed but we told theat. we wez interested in supplying fi~power at this time 3athen bzought up the quest:on of a na.."onaL discussion regarding displacement of nuclear powe V7e told him, we would not discuss nor make any comznents at this time; that this matter was unde dis-cussion in higher circles and when we had any knowledge we would advise him.
He, in behalf of Zozt Pierce, is thinking of displace-ment in the a ount of 40 megawatts.
It was intere'~g to note. that last year's peak at 2'oz Pierce was 45 znegawatts ance ~~t they are growing and pla=ning on the basis oi lZ~>o cozzzpounded pe yea.
In other words, by 1985'hey expect to have 250, 000. Zur deznand There were. a number of other side-'play remarks bu, while they wer a part of. this discussion,. were not important e ough to coznx=ent
FOAM -'E4QC PIOC 44
~i 1-LORlDA POWKR Gc LlGHT COivtPAiXY
~
IhlYgRWOMPAHY CORRESPONQKQCE.
pc(
a.
TO Memo to F'ile LDCATI OH OATC West Palm Beach, Florida October 20, 19 70 r'gg 8,< ~
r
~ y o~~
COVltK TOR" J'.
G. Spencer, Z
raox Z
L. Breedlove
~ 0 o
e
~ 0 Meeting October 13, 1870 W'th Fort Pierce Reoresent'atives
'an'd
'Cans'uL'tants'hose preseni were as fo3~ows:
Mr. Lee Nelson.
Hx'. MiLton Davis
~
Hr. Robert'ierce Mr. Bathen Mx'. C. Portex' Ca.ty of Fort City of Fort
. Distribution R.
W. Beck 8
R.
W.. Beck 8
P'erce.-
Couniy Comm:ssianar Piexce -
Managex'ngineez Company '- Engineer Cansultan~
Comoany - Engineer Consuliani Mr. R. D. HiLL
.. Mr. L. P. Brownin Hr.
O'. L. Breedlove Florida Power 8 Light.Vice Px'esiden Florida Power 8 Light -'ivision Engineer
.'lorida Power 8 Light. - Division Manager WMMWMMMMMM~MMM~MMeMOWWWWM Mr. Bathen ooened the meeting by reviewing the px'aoosed tie wiih ihe City of Fort Pie ce as out~ed in the agreement present d Co them several months ago.
Hr. Bathen inquired as to the possiblity of ma'~g the tamporazy 69 KV 1:ne, wi h necessa~
refinements, a, oemnanent con-hection with the 81 substation, wh'ch is located ai 25th St eet and Rhode 3:sland Avenue.
This is the substation served during the rec r.i
~
power faiLv e experienced by the City oz Fort Pierce.
Mr. Baihen a3.so mentioned a parallel tie for an undeiermined per'ad of time.
Hx. Bathen was informed by me thai we could not plan on using the tempora~
Line for any given length of time, and that th's line was noi normally energized.
Also, we did not know what our Genera3.
=-ngi-
'neer Section had in mind as far as futu e usage was concerned.
At this point during the can¹rence, eve~one exceot Hx..Nelson, under-stood he difficult.~<, waste oz man 'nours, and equipment, ia mak the
. necessaz'y arrangements at 91 substation.
i~4~. Nelsan's view seea;ac' he that since:Florida Power 8 Lighi had, made it clear that we wou'd help Fort.Piez'ce only on an ":f power was ava'lable", bas"'s, thai they,.
ihe City, should not soend money to make the temporary tie permanent and not have assurance against power failu es.
~here we~e various comments exchanged as o whai additions would be required to make ne temporary connections su"'.ab3.e for parallel ooe ation, what the casi would be, how much cou'd be sa3.vaged and irarsfer ed io a fuiur con-.
neciion point on xhe Fart Pie ce-St.
Lucis 69/L38 KV line wiinoui anv verv definite conclusion heing reached.
i+~41'Ec 2~ ~
i IOl ILQlil\\
c,'if.I(l TC'll (C"Pl"T
~
r r 8 Octobex 20, 1970 r
0 sl Page'-
2
~~Bee
~ ~
~ t en+
The point of the Conference seemed to be to influence Florida Power 8'ight to accept a substation connection scheme that would give the City the benefits ox the. contracted for arrangement, but permi-the City to defer or save permanently the cost of a transmission line and" switching station-3:t seemed to me that if'he emporary connection was made permanent and connected for paralle3. operation, the con-tracted. for plan would be permanent3.y'bandoned and there would be pressure to place the futux'e 3.38/S9.
KV t ansformation in Florida Powex 8 Light's Fort Pierce substat'on; a3.though this was not dis-cussed.
~
The City asked how long they could keep the temporary normally opened, emergency connection.
They were told as long as necessary provided.
that they proceeded in good faith to follow through under their contract with Florida Power 8 'Light to construct the transmission 1ine and'witching station.
They requested power, during an upcoming un'verhaul, Novermber 2,
for two and one hal< weeks.
They were advised that this would have to be coordinated w" h oux maintenance and overhaul schedules, and that we would adv'se them later.
r'.
Mz ~ Bathen qu stioned us about the availabil'ty of nuclear powe from
'ur Hutchison 3:s3.and Plant.
He was informed that we were unable to.
discuss or make any comment, as to power from the nuclear plan
- t this time.
There were several other minox topics of discussion.
None other than
- the ones mentioned above were significant enough to mention.
JLB/ca
FLORIDA POVlER & LIGHT COMPANY INTER oFFICK CQRRKSPCNQE.ICE
%caco fo r ile LOC*TIOH
~ t p October 11>> '1973 VT. H.: Sanders I
Iaquiry from ~. Pierce Utilities Authori
- St. Lucie 0 2 COMICS TO
~805<g Mr, Zowie Settle, Chairman of the Utilities Authority, recently made a verbaL request. to Al Zinni for a meeting with ZPhL to discuss the Authority purchasing genera.in@ capacity from St. Lucie 9, 2, Mr+ Settle, Al Zinni, and l met yesterday mo min~ to discus s the Authority's inquiry.
The follovring.is a suaunarication of Mr. Set'le's rema&,s:
- "t~ Pierce is nova ad~&g a stean generating unit which was originally supposed to handle thei:.needs through 1982~
Know appears that they willhave capacity problems as early as 1978 The present plant site is inadequate for fu. %ez expansion.
Therefore, the Authority is now faced with a rather urgent need to ente into a site study contract at a cost of froze $300,000 to $400, 000.
.on Prior to doing this, M, SettEe feels the Authority should consider other alternatives - one of which would be pu chasing capacity frora St. Lucie 8 Z~
He has read the Lavr on this and. is a~are of &e Authority's rights'o intervene.
He stated he has no intention oX intervening, but would ver y 'rauch Like to explore such a purchase with us.
lt is both his and their consultant's (Reynold, Smith 4 Hill)opinion that purchasing additional capacity f om us willnot prove feasible Howeve",
he feels he wou dbe derelict in his responsibilities Lf he did not make at least a superfic:a1 investigation into this alternative S
Ve discussed the relative costs of nuclear vs. fossi1 fuel plants and differences i" Lead time requirements, He gave a10 some backg ound
~
infomation on the origination of the Authority and some oi their prob-Lezxxs ~'
~+ r
~
t
~
~
~
~
hiero for Filo
~
~
I Oetabei 1I., 197'gO ~22 The meeting eras most cordial and A1 and I frere car'ocul to exhiait a positive and coope ative at".itude.
A1 has exceDent rapport arith M", Settle.
Cur oniy coo mitmeat was th*tl would pass on thei" request for a meeting to our folks in ivQanxi and that we would be bache ia touch with him vrith details as soon as possible
~
~
~
~
~
~
~
VPQ:gz
%', H. Sanders
~'
~
~
~
~
~