ML17138B709

Slide Presentation Re Seismic & Hydrodynamic Loads

ML17138B709
Person / Time
Site:	Susquehanna
Issue date:	12/18/1980
From:	PENNSYLVANIA POWER & LIGHT CO.
To:
Shared Package
ML17138B710	List: ML17138B709 ML18030A478
References
NUDOCS 8101130472
Download: ML17138B709 (46)

Text

i f

~ r I

~

~ ~,r t

r

~ ~ r

~

~

~

~

~

r

~

~

NRC MEETING AGENDA

'ETHESDA, MD DECEMBER 18, 1980 SUSQUEHANNA STEAM ELECTRIC STATION

" 'EISMIC AND HYDRODYNAMIC LOADS

~ 0

~l

'I, INTRODUCTION'Y. PPSL

~

~

4

~

~

~ ~

I I

I

~

~

4 I 1

1 II.

BECHTEL QUALIFICATION PROGRAM

- BOP Equipment

~ '

IXI;-

GE.QUALIFICATION PROGRN

- NSSS and Contro). Room:Equipment IY.

SQRT PRE-SITE YISIT DISCUSSION V.

PP4lL SUSNRY AND CONCLUSIONS

\\

A

~

~

~

~3 c' /PA

~

~

~

r

~

~r

I r

U.S. SEISMIC ZONF MAP,'I 120 I ~

I I'

1)0 100 eo'I

~

80 70 SEISMIC DATAADAPTED FROM: EERI, JULY 1976, VOL.'.10, NO. 4, ALGERMISSEN 6 PERKINS, U.S.G.S., PG. 78.

co NUCLEAR POWER PLANT DATAFROM: NUCLEAR NEWS

. AUGUST 1979 / VOL. 22 / NO. 10 40-I

')ATTLK

~--

l

~

~

,r)I)I I

I b

I IIl arreeat a a

~

~

I)

)I

)I)I

~

I II) )

~ I II)

)

~

I)I)I)

~', '

) I) l)l I I)I) a -.a qb'p A,R

~ kN YORK 1

Vhk I

~

h 5

ETA(N AI t

-50' II I

I, )),I I)I)I)l I I I)

II)

I 7

)T 'A b

SPA

+ab

))()I I I)I r w IIIII)4

.Q g Ill

,b I

'IG P

I'

>>r

\\

N I I Il),ll III I I

)lt)

~

N

'llI~ I l lib')I)IIISl I

)I 'II)l)

I,'.;

I I I I I.' ')ll)ll

~ ~

~

~

. I I I 0

~s I,I I.Es bg LEGEND' I

A44

~

) I )

Ij0)I) I

< I

)I~

)III... ) I I I

)I

~

Pb b

I I

~ ~

~

~ ~

~ ~

0 0.6 g

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~

~

~

~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~

'I

~ r I I I I I I

$ 03g

~

~

$ 0:I g MILES 0

'200 400

+~>>

.I '

~

>>% eel

~

>000

$ 0.1 g gb bb b

~

." 0 200

'400 ICILOMETEAS

~

l."

IAMI

~

~

~

80

. NUCLEAR POWER:

PLANTS...

A OP ERAT)NO OADEAEO OA UNOEA

"'- - CONSTAuCT)ON

~

'1>>t I TieT T ~ "~ iT >

~

50 40,

~

~

f ft

/

~

~

~

~

vPENNSYLVANXAP(NER 8 LIGHT CO.

SUSQUEHANNA STEAM ELECTRIC STATXON r ~

'I r

~ -f

~

~rg

~

'CQLlaASt'air (K

L.,

~

CC, K P

~Ulled+

~ r/<<egr

~L&t l IelrIr/r<<r(

I~

lIg 4 \\g%

~ a W 4

~

~

~IW C

C 00~0000000 0

C

~

IO 0 I

I Kk ~ Irtr'I eI<< Ie

~I+%+ +IC/+I I<<s

~ak tltt

~ oe, s&y OOOO rr<<Cikla'tr o

/

I,0

.I OOOOOI

)OOOOO

%OOOO(

~ I

~ o<<e)

I

~II/IC

~ rr C

Irrr+ll

/

~

~

atrtl ~

(f/Ir TtNkh WXttt fflKCVLN(fI CTCCC t/ (I(W AI(Alt<

r ~

UNlT 1

.C

0-I'

~,

I PENNSYLVANIA POWER & LIGHT'CO.

,SUSQUEHANNA STEA'M.ELECTRIC STATEOH

~ -

~

I

~

~

~

4i a

I IIj gl

~ 4 I

'I

~ 1 i:

~++w4 Ckl AA>Ot

~~

0 OI 0

0 O 0<

0 0 C !

CCOC 0'OCOOCO

OCCCCIIO, 000000'OOOCO

~~OOC

, H

(.

J4 rhJC O~ 'g. cs,asii

~, oa;r

rItvhWl, a4N1o<

/ri

~/

y)

IJ usa~

I

'J I I

~/

o+4l k wnl llCTN UN(T Ch2

~ 0

~

~r

~

~

~ T r

~

. ~ P.

~

~

~

U PENNSYLVANIA P9'E'ER AND. LIGHT'COMPANY IN THE EFFORT TO FIND'AN J

ACCEPTABLE SOLut5ION TO THE PROBLEN OF NEH HYDRODYNQ1IC LOADS CAUSED BY"STEAN CGNDENSATICN IN SUPPRESSION POOLS OF ROILING MATER REACTOR PLANTS.

hLOPED'ND TESTED T-AuENCHERS TO SOLVE III <<<<RUUIURUI.

THE PR03L'EN OF SRV ESSES..

~w kRKED HITH M TO ARRIVE AT LOADS RESULTING FRY UXAe 4

EFFORTS TO ACCURATELY.DEFINE~ STEAN CONDENSATIN LOAD FORCING FUNCTIQ4 NE HAVE> SINCE 1978~

BEEN KRKING TO EVALUATE:

5 EI35Z:

~ETt'KGS TO DEFINE THE TRANISSION OF THESE I<<X<<llfllcLRH<< IIIR<<it<< IHE Rl<<I<<IIRER RHU.

'Et;+P:

NE'RODS TO EVALUATE THE EFFECTS OF THE C0%INED'

~ ~

LOAN) ON EACH ITEN OF EQOIPNENT IN THE SAFETY-'BATED STRUCTURES'M)p 3jjjg,:

TO RED@.IFY ECur~ENT ERICH DID NOT ~ET OUR SPECIFIED QUALIFICAT'ION REQOI REPENTS e

..O,OUR PRESENTATICN HERE TODAY IS TO:

33'PLAIN OUR EQUIPKHT QUALIFICATION PROGRAtta 2)'NFORN YOU OF OUR PROGRESS AND RESULTS, 3)

PRESENT OUR CK LETICN SCHEDULE.

~ 0

~4

~ %

1 CTON 0

/

I k

'h OR I G INAL QUALIF ICATION 0

SEISMIC LOAD

'a

0 REQUALIF I CATI QN h

0 SEISMIC AND HYDRODYNAMIC l OADS' MULTIAXISp MVLTIFREQUENCY INPUT REQUIREMENT

~

~

~

~

PHASES OF QUAf IFICATION PROGRAN 8

PHASE I; SEISNIC LOADS ONLY:

Q BECHTEL INPUTs EXt SPECS F1CATiONi RESPONSE SPECTRA r CRITERIA (SPEC t b 10)

ETC i

,'.6 REVIEH QF QUALIFICATIONS DONE BY 'VENDORS e

PHASE II: IN-HOUSE EVALUATION FOR COISINED SEISNIC AND HYDRODYNANIC LOADS, 9 COMPILE LIST OF EQUI PMENT ]

Q DEVELOP TECHNI'CAL CRITERIA (SPEC"G"22)

. 8 REYIEH OF EXISTING REPORTS 6 IDENTIFY PROBLEM AREAS P

~

~

~ ~

~\\

> ~

1

~

~

~

~

~

PHASES OF QUALIFICATION PROGRAM (coNTD,.)

. 9 PHASE III: REQUALIFICATION EFFORTS IN-HOUSE EVALUA'(ION OBTAIN VENDOR S CONCURRENCE

~ ~8 QUALIFICATIONS BY VENDOR BECHTEL REVIEW

~ ~

~

~

QUALIFICATIONS 'BY OTHERS;.

CONSULTANTS TEST LABS BECHTEL REYI'EN OBTAIN VENDOR S CONCURRENCE

~ ~

I P

~

~

0 ~

PHASE IY: 'MODIFICATION OF EQUIPNENT OR EQUIPMENT SUPPORT IF NECESSARY.

~

~

~

~

~

6 MODIF ICA7IONS BY JUDGENENT EVEN BEFORE ANALYS'IS OR TEST 6 MODIFICATIONS FOLLOWING THE ANALYSIS OR TEPT

~

~ ~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

r

~

r P

~

~,

>V

~ 0

~

\\

NO OF PUR C H AS'E ORDERS

~

~

aa DlSClPLI N E.

SEISMIC

'EfSMIC+

ONLY -

-'YDRODYNAMIC I

ELECTRfCAL

. CONTROL SYSTE.M ME.CHANlC AL PLANT DESIGN:...

I TOTAL 0

12

~

I I,

~'

t "TOTAL, NO. OF P, O.'S

. 74.

1

~

t

~

~

N 1

~ 4

~

~

I>>

1

'l

~

~

r

'- NETHOD" OF..QUAL IFICATION

'LANT DESIGN EQUI'AMENT (VALVES),'

W l

r

~'>>

l ~

~

~

~

~

'.. P,O, No.

P-.10B P-11A DESCRIPTiON 6008 NUCLEAR 2" 5 LARGER-CS 150-000¹ NUCLEAR 28" 8 LARGER."CS.

ANALYSI S I

l

~

r

~

NETHOD TESTING ANALYSIS 4 TESTING X:

X X.

P-10A NUC, 28" 8 Scat LFR-SS 0 ~

~,

~rl A

r l

P-108 P-15A P-16A NUCe 2 R.SNALLER-.CS l

BUTTERFLY VALVES 2 LARGER-SS

\\

~

r

/

P-17A 6008.2" 8 LARGER-SS

'-178 690¹ 2 R LARGER-SS" 150-900¹ NUCLEAR 28" R LARGER-SS" P g1 BUTTERFLY NUCLEAR 28.

0 LARGER

~ ~

.PASSIVE VALVES E

~

~

NETHOD OF QtlALIFICATION

~ ~

~

MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT P,O.

NO..

N-22 N-30" M-58" DESCRIPTION

'MERG ENCY SERVICE."

'ATER PUMPS RHR SERYICE HATER

'UMPS REACTOR'BUILDING CRANES DIESEL GENERATORS'.:

REACTOR YESSEL IHSULATION DIESEL OIL TRANSFER'UMPS NETHOD ANALYSI S TESTING X

X-X ANALYSIS:

8 TESTING X

~

~

I P,

N-60" N-87 N-90 N-109 N-160A M-160 H-192 N-302 DIESEL FUEL Oi L STORAGE TANK

-HYDROGEN RECOMB INERS..

FUEL POOL SKIMKER'URGE TANK CONTAINMENT'YACUUM RELIEF YALYES SUPPRESSION POOL CONTAINMENT NITROGEN..

GAS ACCUMULATORS NUCLEAR SAFETY REE.IEF VALVES MSRY DISCHARGE LINE VACUUM BREAKER VALYES CRD HYDRAULIC SYSTEM-HIGH DENSITY SPENT.

FUEL RACKS EXPANSION TANKS

.X X

~X".

X X

X

~

X'X QUALIFICATION REQUIRED FOR SEI'SMIC.LOADS ONLY:

~t

~

~

(

Ip

~

~

(

0 METHOD OF QUALIFICATION

.MECHANICAL EQUIPMENT (CONTINUED)

>ca~,

i.

~

~'r,f

~

\\ r lr 4r

~ lg

.c.

~

~

P;0, No,,

N-307 M-308

'"309..

M-'QO M-320 M-321 M-323C M-325 M-327 M-336A DESCRIPTION'ENTRIFUGAL FANS YAN'E AXIAL FANS

'IR HANDLING UNITS'.

CFRTRI FUGAL HATER.;.'

CHILLERS REACTOR BUILDING UNIT COOLERS DRYWELL UNIT COOLERS HVAC INSTRUMENTS 5

CONTROLS STANDBY GAS TREATMENT SYSTEM AIR SAMPLING STATIONS' HIGH EFFICIENCY'ENTILATION FILTERS COOLING AND CHILLED WATER PUMPS HVAC CONTROL PANELS

.HVAC DAMPERS SGTS CENTRIFUGAL FANS'HILLED..

WATER RELIEF YALVES'

'"X '.

X C

':-"X.-.

.X

~ ~ r X

X '"

~

0 METHOD ANALYSIS TESTING ANALYSIS R TESTING

~ ~

I

~

~

.x Pr P ~.INCLUDES CHELLERS R CONTROL PANEL) CHI Ll ERS TO BE QUALIFIED BY ANALYSISrCOt'tTROL PANEL'O BE QUALIFIED BY TESTINGS'

~

0

4

~ ~

~

~

~

METHOD OF QUALIFICATION CONTROL SYSTEMS c"~,-".4i~?)

E

~

~

5 ~

~ ~

P,O, No.

DESCRIPTION J-03A FI ELD MOUNTED INSTRUMENTS J-17

~ CONTAINMENT OXYGEN 8 HYDROGEN ANALYZER-J 03B PANEL MOUNTED INSTRUMENTS

..J-05

.coNTRQL PANELs..

J"058 CONTROL PANELS.-

EN 9 ANALYSI S TESTI NG

.,X X.

~ '

ANALYSIS R TESTING X

-X-

~ I g

~

~ '

h

~

I

~-

J-27 J-31 REACTOR COOLANT 'PRESSURE BOUNDARY LEAK 'DETECTORS ANNUBAR FLOW ELEMENTS

'TD ScTHERMOCOUPLES ~.,

8 THERMOWELLS

':. X J-65 coNTR0L YALYEs J-69 P ILOT SOLENOID VALVES J-.69B J"70 PROCESS

. SOLENOID.VALVES

. X.

EXCESS FLOW CHECK VALVES TRANSI ENT. MONITORING SYSTEM X

( ~

~\\

~

~

~

~

NET.HOD: OF QUALIFICATION

. ELECTR I CAL EAU.IPMENT

~.n r

~

~

~

~

.. P,O.

."Io.

DESCRIPTION

~ ANALYS'IS NETHOD TESTING ANALYSI S 4 TESTIN

(

,, ~

~

I.'

pic

~

~

J

'rC a.r.~'t: ~

\\

E-109C E-112" E-117 E-118 E-119A E-120 E-121 E-151 E-152

'-155 0 16 KYA 'SWITCHGEAR LARGE INDUCTION MOTORS LOAD 'ENTERS MOTOR CONTROL'ENTFRS FUSE BOXES'ATTERY CHARGER S IBATTERY MONv

.BATTERIES AND RACKS D( DISTRIBUTION PANELS 9

LOAD AND CONTROL CENTFRS P ENETRATI ON8 TRANSFORMERS MOTOR-GENERATOR SETS AUTOMATI C TRANSFER SWITCHES CONTROL SHITCHES,.

X.-

~

~

X X

r X,R X

X QUALIFICATION.REQUIRED FOR SFISMIC LOADS ONLY

4 0

0 DETERMINE QUALIFICATION AWARDS 0

. 0 0

r h

REQUEST VENDOR (OR CONSULTANT) QUOTE RECEIVE AND EVALUATE QUOTE PLACE PURCHASE ORDER

~ ~

0.

PERFORM 9UALIF ICATION 0

0 REVIEW TEST PROCEDURE REVIEH ANALYSIS METHODOLOGY BEGIN ANALYSIS OR TESTING r

" 0 FINAL COMPLETION '(100X)

RECEIVE AND REVIEW REQUALIFICATION REPORT FINAL APPROVAL OF REPORT

~

4

~ ~

~

~

~

~

0 I

1 PHASE II 3N-HOUSE EVALUATION

. COMPLETE S

OF COMPLETE

'0 PHASE III o

QUALIFICATION 100X COMPLETE o

QUALIFICATION

'EING PERFORMED

~

~

22K"OF TOTAL NO;;

01X OF. P': 0 'S:

SC

~

~

'-'- - -o===-QUALIFICATIO'I

- WORK

. BEING AMARDED 32K:=

, ~

~f Z

1 1

~

~ ~

~ ~

-0

'CHEDUZZ

~

~

e ~

~

O 70 Actual I

I l

l r-

-~'recast.

".j 1

I f.

I, I

I l

1 I

Forecast t

.I Qualification.

)

Being Perf ormeci I

I I

I r-- ~

I

~ Qua 1ification Comp 1ete-100%

I'

~ ~eh I

l I

Actua1 100%

75%

50%

25%

~ ~

0 NQV DEC JAN FEB HARCH APR HAY

~t

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

TORP

~ '

DYNANIC ANALYSIS'OF VALVE BODY TO DETERNINE NAXINUN "6" CAPACITY f

o STATIC TEST OF ACTIVE VALVES TO NAXINUN."G" TO VERIFY FUitCTIONALITY o

DYHANIC TEST OF ACTUATORS--

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

'0

~, ~

ECHTE Sp CIF Cf-'.T NS

~0 0

QUALIFICATIQH CRITERIA SPEC<

8856-6-22 BASED ON REa.

GUIDEs 1.92, 1.100, IEEE STD, 390-1975, FSAR..

RESPONSE

SPECTRA SPECs ~~856-6-20i BASED ON LOADS DEF I NED IN,FSAR AND'AR~

~

~

~

~

~ ~ <<

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

g J

~

~

~ ~

~ \\

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~ ss ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

r

~ 1

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

o

~

~

~

OARS; ON.'AjI:1'Pt":.'!tIti

~

~

~ q o

"oo

~ o V

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

6-20

~

.~

PYNAi",IC LO~BS (;RESeoNSE SPECTRA)~

0 SEIlSSRC: (1'ASI.S';:

FSAP; SEC'. 3.7S.,l).

SEE SP C.

o."

.',GBE oi SSE 0~

HYDRODYNANIG (SASHES

'AR, PEV; '2)

- o SRY< (c~u) o~-

LOCA> (DpFR);

OTHEP.'PERATLI<!6 L'OAQS 0~.

PRESSURE TENPERAFURE

~

~

o:

Hozzzz LoADS

~

~

oo

~ o

~

~

e o~

~

~

~

o e

~

~ oo

~

oo

~

o

~

~

ro

~

~ ~ ~

~

~

oo

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

o

~

~ ~

~

~

~

I

) ~ '9 ~ ~

~

~

~

~or,\\

~

~

~

o

~

0

~

~

r%

o

~

~

oo ~

~

~

~

~

oo

~

~

~ ~

o

~

o ~

~

t

~ ".so'~t +>>'+'!t; oui o'o 4)~i. o";fo't' oogoo t +~ ~

5

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

o

~ o

~

~

ooo OooH oO

~ ~'4

+o l go oo Q ~

~ ( ~

~ ooo~

oOo

~

~ 4 ~

)oo

$ ~

~ 'ol

~

~

~

oO

~

~ ~

or

+I g

~

~ p

~ 0

~

4 P ~ \\og ~ ~ ~

~

~

O oor +\\

oo

~

o

~

o

y

~

~ '9g l ~ )g

~ oo o

~ o ~

o

~

~

~

0

~

o.

~

~ o

~

0

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~SH, oa

~ g o

~

yo oo t t ~ 4 O>>lgooo ~

~.s too.

o oo ~

.0 LOAD COI'<8INAT Oi'lS ND 'A[.L01 A~LE ST,ESSES (BASIS; SEcT'o 3,10C,1,4 8 3,10c,1,5 OF.FSAP, TABLE 5,0 oF DAR.

n C

W,.'J

~4i I

l I

USES

~

1 OBE'.

'OBE + SRY SSE OBE '+ SRY + LOCA SSE + SRV + LOCA LOH STP. SSFS 1,25 Fs.,

1.25 Fs 1,50. Fs 1,50 Fs 1,50 Fs I~

FS = ALLOWABLE STRESS FOR NORMAL'ONDITIONS l.EX.!

AISC ALLON)

NOTE:

DEAD LOADS AND OTHER OPERATING LOADS ARE ADDED TO.THE ABOYE CASES<

0 h

~

~

~ ~

0

~ 4

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

J'

~

o

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

i ~

~

~

~

~

~ p

~

I i

0

~ re

~

'I 0

~

ANPIH-VA UFS (REF, BAR, SECT, 7.1,7,0,1,2)

'BE

~ ~

SSE OBE + SRV OBE + SRY + LOC'A 2X:,"

SEE.+ SRY + LOCA HIGHER DAMP1NG MAY BE USED'F THERE TS TEST EYTDENCEs 0 ~

~ 0

~ 0

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~y h

~

~ 0 g

~ o~

~

0

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

r 5 ~

~

~

~ ~ ~

~

~

~

~

~I

~

~

~

~

', ~

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~ ~ ~

hho

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

~ C t

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

1

~

\\

~ '

~

h

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

I

~

~

~

E

~ ~

'0

~

~

~

CT ON E

ONS SP CT I

'I

0. '" ENVELOPE FLOOR RESPONSE SPECTRA

0 CONBINED SPECTRA. OF VARIOUS DYNANIC LOADS (08E/SSE>

'SRV~

. LOCA)..

SUYi O

ASS O

SRSS 0.

EXAHPLE (NEXT WO YIE'i'(-GRAPHS)

,0

'I

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~0

~

~

~

'I e

~ 0

~

~

~ I 0

~

~ ~

4

~ ~

~ ~

~

+ ~

e g

~

~

~

~ p

~

\\

~

~

~

S

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

I~

~

~

~

0 ~

~

~

~

~'

~

~

~

~y

~

~

,oo

~ '

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

0

~

~ ~

~

4

~

I

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

P

~

~

~ ~

~

~

"IIIII I I" I

~

~

~ ~

~

I 'IllI 0

) I'I

III I I'I I

~

~

~

j yl

~

I I.

I

~ f S.o I ~

t4

~

m giO 01 Z

O'O I

J>0 OO 0

~

G.w 2i0

~

~

~ t CO(

'O SS 1B E

BEEP,/AS SUN

~l h

/

S'S LO.CA

$ R.Y, 4

6 8 gp..

<<2 4

5

. Supp 4

6

$ lpp

~

~

'REQUKiICY-CPS ACCELERATION RESPO,"ISE SPECTRUH,-

FOR SGTS CENTR I,FUGAL FANS CONTROL BLDG ~

EL806 0

". E N DIRECTIOll'.(SSE + SRV +. LOCA) t 2'AHPING s

~

~

~

~

~

'0

~

4

~y

~

~

~

"~

~

~

~

~

e

~

~

=

~

~'l.

~

~

h

~ ~

~

~

hh I

. S.o

)0 4io 07'z.

. 0 r%

w~OO OUC 0:

0 0.~

2.0

)0 1

o'.1

~ a1 V

~ hV 0

h

v. ~

OMB.INED.ABS. SUM- ".:::..

QHBIPPD 'SRSS

/ ~

a SSE o

SRY

'0 LOC 4hfi 4

B "8 L0 O','.

~ 8 810.0 4

5

~

8 100

~.,

FREQUBlGY.CPS I

ACCELFLERATIO."1 RESPONSE SPECTRUM FOR SGTS -CENTRIFUGAL FANS CONTROL BLDG) EL806 -.0,

~

~

YERTICAL DIRECTION'SSE- + SRY + LOCA).e 2'AMPING

~

~

~ ~

~

~ HO 0V ~ ht

~

h

~ ~

~

tV

~ ~ ~

~

~

~

Wt hh

~

0 IVOR

~ V ~

~ at

~I

~

~

~

~

0

\\ ~

.s

~ I 4 ~

~ r ~

~ ~

i

~

~

'L

~

~ i,~

~

I

~

~

~

~

~

I r

- 'UALIFICATION'ETHODS I

I 4

J

~

e

. BASIS IS SPEC,.l

'..G-22.-'..',=,

NADSIS (RESPONSE SPECTRUM METHOD) 8:

STRUCTURAQ Y. SIMPLE.

SINGLE DEGREE OF.FREEDON SYSTEM r

STRUCTURALLY RIGID

,~~ 33HZ (SEISNIC) f ~~'80HZ (HYDRODYHANICj I

..STRUCTURALLY.. COMPLEX

~ 4 NODAL ANALYSIS."

I

~

rl 9 NODAf COMBINATION OF RESPONSES-SPATIAL COMB1NATIQN OF RESPONSES

i. -

BASIS FOR RESPONSE SPECTRA IS SPEC.

~

6-.20

~

t

(~~

I I

~

~ g y1

~

~ e

~

eo

~

~

o

~ ~

~

~ ~

~

%1

~

o'o' o ~ P

~ ~

' 'o

~

P,A

~ 44 e

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~ 'r

'e ~

~

A

~

Ve ~,, >/o o

g>> oQ, o>/4 g lgi~'

~ ~ +, '/

~ + ~o.

~

OO g'e~) r + 4, ~ g~,'>> '>> rye, >.4 oo'o o

~

~

4>>

~

~

o e

~

~

~

~

~

e

~ '

~ ~ ge

~

q>>

~

~

~

~ o i jC"T 0H H-RODS.

~

~

~ e

~

~

o

~

~ ~ ~

~

~

.0 BASIS IS SPEC' 6-22 0

TESTIHG 0

. Ih'.-SITU TESTING.

0 FOR SIMULATIOH.

1 0

. '=

FOR VALIDATION..

e SHAVER TASLE.TESTING.

0 RESONANCE SEARCH QUAL IF I CATION TESTS Tp$ +.

pp$

I el o/

o NULTI"AXIAL~ RAHDOth l>OT I ON CONFINED ANALYSIS AHD TESTING 0

'*. BASIS FOR RESPONSE SPECTRA IS SP'iCe 6-2"..

e'

~

~,

~

~ o ~

~

e

~ ~

~

e

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

. ~

~

~ ~

~ oo

~

~ ooo>>to ~

~

~

~

~ o

~\\

~

e

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~ ~

o'

~

~

~

~

~

~ 'o

~ o g

~

~

~

~A

~

~ ~

~'c

~'b

~,

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

g

~

~

e

~

~

e ~

~

e

~

~

~

~ ~

~ a

~ ~

~

f

~

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

~ ~

H

~

~

~

~e

~

~

~ o

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

I

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~ I

~ W

~ 'I

~

~

EXAMPLES OF QUALIFIED:EQUIPNEtIT

~

'I

~

0

~

=

~

l' EQUIPYiEHT QUALIFIED-BY ANALYSIS EXl HIGH FFFICIEHCY YEHTILATIOH FILTERS

~

~

/

ANSYS FINITE ELEMENT MODEL

EQUIPNEHT QVALIFED BY TESTING EXi SGTS CENTRIFUGAL FANS>

0

~

I

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ 0

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

ot g; ~ >.

I

~

~ ~

o J'.

I I.

i"

~

~

~

~

~

y o

l.- ~

~

~

INLET

~

o

~

~

~

~

~'

o ~

~

o

$$...~

~

~

/

~

o

~ ~

.~;- .

~.

-,t-,V go

-0

~

~ ~

~

4

~

~

q5+qG+

Q

@y r

o ~

'1

~

~

o

~.~

~

~ 0 4/m o

~ i'4P.'I.

~

~

~ o I

~ ~

~o

~ ~

~

P

~ o

~

~ ~

~ ~

~ o

~.

~

I

~

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

~'

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

"~

o

~.a

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ o

~

~

~o

~

~

~

~

~

~

C

~

~

~

~

~

k

~

~ 0 o

~\\

~

~

~

- g

~

. ~

~ ~ '

~ '

~

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~ i I ~

~

~

~

~

HIGH EFFICIENCY VEHYILATIOH'ILTERS-CABINET'SEG/lENl'S'ELATED TO HODEL"--

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ \\

~

~

<<0'

~

<<<<ow

~

~

o

~

~

~

~

<<o

~

~ o

~ '

~

~

~

<<<<oo I

o

~ o ~ <<<<o<<<<oo<<<<<<<<o <<o 4

~ ~

~

~<<

~

~

~ ~

~ ~

4

~

~,

~

rt

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

t ~

. ~,

0

~

J

~

~

~

~

~ y )

q ~

1 of

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

'I

~

~

~

l.

~

~

~

~

~ ', ~

~

g

~

ee

~ y

~

~

~

~

a ~

~

~

)

//~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~ ~

~

~

~

+

~

~

~

'0

~.

~ y

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

0

~

~

~

~

I

~

~ ~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

.:.:;.NATHBlATICALNODEL (SSYS). -',

~

~

~ 'e w

~ A

~

oo ~see o

~

FOR HIGH EFFIC1ENCY.VEHTIL'ATION FILTER

~ I

~

~

~

~

~

~

~,

~

J

~ ~

~ ~ ill 0 0 WO ~ ~ ~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

'L cl.'

li~ATURAT HODR'REOUEIOCXES

~

~

HIGH EFFICIENCY VENTILATION FILTER

.:.I Ho8e

]

Q g

1

~

t..'

2 I,

~

I i

~I' I 't*

21 89 28.13 50 28

50'8

'2.27 L ~~ ~

6 ~:

2 79

53.13

~. 8 '..

57.33 9

60.02

-:".."':" - -:.10 67.56'3 3.

'74 82

.: t ':~12 '7 23

.;."'.-.".--13

. '-82.50

,-::."X4 '. '9.89

~";: ".:.:.::-:,3.5 97.64

"=-"'-"-.'-.-."..~.':;.:...3.6..:-.,';.

98 75

'.-. '"...:".-.,'f '. 1$

-. 103.0

.::.'" 18.:.

',03.':-".".'.

. 19', 113.1 20 '13.5. 0

'21 1>8 7

~.'..".

..: )i-

. 22 '20.9 23 3.33.1 24 140 3

.25

.341 4

0. 03:17 0.0189 0'. 0310 0 743 1.124 3 ~ 232 0 0925

'0 ~ 0325

0. 0317.

3. 399.,

0. aSSi 0.;.0916

3. ~ 636

. 1.309

0. 151

. 0.0684

. 0.0264 6 l2'20 0.0192

'0603.

0. 676 0 3052, 0..032

0. 0748

0. 0635 Participati Y

0.0301 0, ~ 0784 0.0171 0.356 4;.095

2. 422.

.0.777 0,100

. 0.192 1.214

0. 195

0. 0917

. '.365 0.758 0.844 0.525 0-0273 Oi 200.

0.0476 0 '266 1.828 0.349

'0.1133 0'. 0673 0.

874'actors I

7I

'.15

2. 12 0.519

0. 03.31

0. 0755 0.0414

~

0..0141.'

~ 239

1. 103 0.'0424 '

0. 855

.1.44

0. 119

0. 114

0. 160'

'. 6l6.:

I ~0aM 0."J)~0,9

0. 135

0. 086.

0. 3.04 0 ~ 326 0;767

0. 234

0. 032 on.

y 0

~

~

~

STRESSES

~

0 Cabinet Hembrane E3.ements Sealer: Hall Txus Elements Carbon Bed Perforated Sheets

~

~

'1. 4 ksi 3.8 ksi 4.2 lsi

0. 35 ksi (shear) 0.7 Rsi (comp. )

I

V.n.

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

I

~ 'h

)I

~ '

i

~

~

~

~

~

~ l

~

~O~

BllFFALO FORGE FAN 70 91665 aoel 135479-1 HORIZO'ALAI"0IAXIhf PAIR 'lW DANPING 2+0%

'rgb 5

6

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

~ ~

e

~

~ '

~

~

~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

.F.

'p'4 0

Q

.. ~

H 5.

U 3'

U ll 1

)

C

~ 0

.2 ~ 0 I lj

~ ~

yl i

g ~

~

'+0 V

y

~

j 0

l

~

~

~

~

~

I

~

~

l

~

)

~

~

O~

40 60 80 100 Owl 2

~

~

h 4

~ 6

~ 8 1

2 4

6 '8 10 rasoOzwcr-cp TRS vs.

RRS FOR. SGTS CENTRIFUGAL

~ ~

h 20 FANS:"

~"

I

~

~

~

~

~

~

~

K

~

IF'ICATION PROGR T.ION P

AN E NP S

St(ITCHSEA 0

..-.o INSIT0 TESTING BY IYLE TO DETER~)IHE ST.UCTURAL.

DYHAilIC CHARACTERISTICS.

~

~

0 SIi36LE CELL CGilFIStjPATION o

MULTIPLE CELL COHFIGUMIOH l'.

SHIP UNIT 2'UBICLE TO HYLE LABS o

SIflDLATE, IIISITIJ CONDITIONS ON'HAKER TABLE'i 0

o SINGLE CELL o

HULTlPLE CELL o 'HAKER TABLE TEST

/

o DEYiCi<STRATE TRS RRS

. 0 "

6EiHERATE.VIBRATION ENVIRG;"<YiEi<TS FOR CONPOiNEHTS SHAKER TABLE TEST FOR COMPONENTS FI;"lAL REPORTS

~

~

~ I

~

~

J ~

p

. 0 e

SQRT

~ ~

PREVISIT INFORNTION FORNS

~

~

~

w ~

+

~

o.

7C Yi/R o

190, FORf'iS

. QUALIFICATION SUNNRY FORNS

'P

~

~

,SORT

(

'REVISIT. INFORNATION FGPPS o

70 NIR o

190 FORNS QUALIFICATIOH STANNARY..RBHS

~

~

0 GE SQRT

. PROGRAM REVIEH SUSQUEHANNA STEAN ELECTRIC STATION NSSS EQUIPNENT SUPPLIED BY GE RH: F'AB/1825 12/15/80

~

PROGRAN BASIS o

. NRC LETTER OF FEBRUARY 23, 1979 FRON R, S,

BOYD TO THREE LEAD PLANT UTILITIES (ZIMNER, SHOREHN. LASALLE)-

o IEEE-STD-300-1975 R,G, 1.92 R.G, 1.1QO SRP 3,9,2 SRP 3,10 o

MULTI-AXIS trlULTI-FREQUENCY CONCERNS HYDRODYNAf'1IC + SEISNIC LOADS OPERABILITY RH:r m/1826 12/15/89

~

~

~ I

~

.GE APPROACH I

/~.

I o

SIMILARITYCOMPARISON.TO EQUIPMENT ALREADY QUALIFIED TO SQRT REQUIREMENTS (MOSTLY. BWR/6 EQUIPMENT) o UTILIZATION.OF RESULTS GENERATED BY GE'.S NEW LOADS

'DEQUACY EVALUATION PROGRAM

. o PERFORMANCE OF ANALYSES TO SHOW ADEQUACY OF ORIGINAL QUALIFICATION WHEN INTERPRETED TO SQRT'CRITERIA

~ ---.

--..--.-"o.-'=-- REQUALIFICATION OF EQUIPMENT WHICH CANNOT BE SHOWN TO BE ADEQUATE BY ABOVE STEPS RH: PAs/1828 12j15/'80

~

~

EQUIPMENT SCOPE o

FLOOR MOUNTED EQUIPMENT (PUMPS, MOTORS, TURBINES, HEAT EXCHANGERS)

.o PIPE MOUNTED EQUIPMENT (VALVES, HEATERS, ACCUMULATORS) o SERVICE EQUIPMENT (REFUELING PLATFORM,

RACKS, GRAPPLES) o CONTROL ROOM PANELS R DEVICES o

LOCAL RACKS 8 DEVICES o

LOCALLY MOUNTED DEVICES l

NOTE:

ABOVE SCOPE EXCLUDES RPV, RPV INTERNALS, PIPING AND PIPE SUSPENSION SYSTEMS RH'.eAs/1827 12/15/80

~

~

~

~~~

p RE-BfALiRTION STAtUS. ELECTRICAL EmIPfBG' RE-BtALNTINGXPLEH Eh%0L KKf1 PAILS 8 DB/ICES LQCAL fNCIG a.DBtICES o

RE-BtALNTI53 IN PROSRESS LOCALLYrm TED DBtICES d

~

~

e

e

~

~

RE-Et/ALUATION STATUS NKHANICALEOIRPlT

o TOTAL 38 PIECES OF ELlIPf%6' RE-B/AUNTIN(OPLHE FOR 26 HXlIRHlT 20 PIECES QNLIFIED 6 PIECES HOT NAUFIED o

t6C RNf"8 CQPLEH FOR 26 EKlIRM' MRT PACN6E CGPLEH FOR 35 EUIMG'Q tt'LETED PACNGES BEI% REVIHH

~

~

J

~

0 0

1 I

I

~7+TuZ ~d'w+~p' ELEC A'AL 7

/

J Fd Fo

~ale,.,r'eA & ~~7 f

Yc Peg~~'rp

. f'cpu+/r. Fi'eaji'~

o PCPfPA/'P.CA

~

f

>MS~

~~/r.-'ie~ A S'~A7'--

cPS pa f8p&~/'O' Cp~orz/~Ca7$ '~

I

QW~ MAL/Peg~prnm I

EL~a rA/m~

Hl4-/'4 8 h'~9-P~ae~i pZ~

gDZ W D8'V/CPS o N~CA+PJCg f NwJ Li Bemire. Yo/eat pal/ A,Cg~A~

H8'Cl 7eer4iri e 2>~- Yesse/ j&c+

CgN Ya/us~

A/PAL/pE/8'54'+

~

~

t P

N t

P l

e g&EYHLPPTI@4 do~/zA pn Wi~ump'

~

0'

@>-mQAL/&s+7~~AI

/9d'/

Q~~je~

+eaWiag Qep /%&(

I g S'em@

&4~~@ me

~/i~

g~e'iag pd'ed~/ 8'm@~P C~/d'4'fag j8Zj 4>PICA+,

I t

t

r gytW M~<<.P'i~ '.l9!~<~

~.CF'-.'c' QOvkt /)gal 7~ CdQ~~ViyL i,c: d~g

,:.C Zc&PM /a7 P2A(~.

." ggu~CS II

'L giwis9 8 &

E g'. C-OWN~~?., ~~

. R'S R,AXAcor 4~

.S.

/s~~ Cv Pic. Ifcfrc'I IPd kc l *

j. D-Z.rq&outkj

/Fav~ l/

/twZ i'r'8C

, zV12C/W/HQy3:

~z ~/s ep~~g

/AC/t f~Q:

/3~

/3e~AWi p'j p'

Kiv'rc 8;WL

~ggR EC(

p4.

5u8.up H)

A.J;78ulFPAtevDO LOS J +ldc7A'i c. -9J

@,4J. Qar/~

~

A 'uc6.

. d. 8.

P8>a8aeson f<. M gicgawsa+

~'<., /~~> i S~X SRZ P%c

/Ilgwu g~(cW~~~~~

)