ML16340D764

Board Notification 83-171:forwards Info Re Allegations Concerning Small Bore Piping & Supports

ML16340D764
Person / Time
Site:	Diablo Canyon
Issue date:	10/27/1983
From:	Eisenhut D Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:	Gilinsky V, Palladino N, Roberts T NRC COMMISSION (OCM)
References
TASK-AS, TASK-BN83-171 BN-83-171, NUDOCS 8308310064
Download: ML16340D764 (98)

Text

Docket No.:

50-275 OCT 27 MEMORANDUM FOR:

FROM:

SUBJECT:

Chairman Palladino Commissioner Gilinsky Commissioner Roberts Commissioner Asselstine Commissioner Bernthal Darrell G. Eisenhut, Director Division of Licensing Office 'of Nuclear Reactor Regulation DIABLO CANYON - ALLEGATIONS CONCERNING SMALL BORE PIPING AND SUPPORTS (Board Notification No.83-171)

In accordance with the procedures for Board Notification the enclosed information is being provided directly to the Commission.

The Boards and Parties are being informed by copy of this memorandum.

On October 27, 1983 the NRC staff received the enclosed allegations concerning the analysis and'esign of small bore piping and supports.

The NRC staff will evaluate these allegations.

We will inform you of the results of these efforts when available.

Enclosure:

As stated cc:

See next page Darrell G. Eisenhut, Director Division of Licensing Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation DL:LB¹3 HSchier s g.yt 10 83 DL.

¹3 J /

83 ghton 83 L

DL.

L 1 ck T

vak 1

/83

/

83 8308310064 F00 DL:DIR DGEisenhut 10/

/83

F F IF

I The Commissioners cc:

J.

F. Wolf, ASLB G. 0. Bright, ASLB J. Kline, ASLB T. S. Moore, ASLAB W.

R. Johnson, ASLAB J.

H. Buck, ASLAB SECY OGC EDO Parties to the Proceeding

s i

n~

I I

~'

DISTRIBUTION LIST FOR BOARD NOTIFICATION Diablo Canyon Units 182 Docket Nos. 50-275/323 OL Ms. Elizabetk Apfelberg Maurice Axelrad, Esq.

Andrew Baldwin, Esq.

Mr. Richard E. Blankenburg Mr. Glenn 0. Bright Dr. John H. Buck Philip A. Crane, Jr.,

Esq.

Mr. Frederick Eissler David S. Fleischaker, Esq.

Mrs.

Raye Fleming Arthur C. Gehr, Esq.

Mr. Mark Gottlieb Mr. Thomas H. Harris Mr. Richard B. Hubbard Dr.

W. Reed Johnson Janice E. Kerr, Esq.

Dr. Jerry Kline Mr. John Marrs Thomas S. Moore, Esq.

Bruce Norton, Esq.

Joel R. Reynolds, Esq.

Mr. James

0. Schuyler Mr. Gordon Silver Michael J. Strumwasser, Esq.

Paul C. Valentine, Esq.

Harry M. Willis John F. Wolf, Esq Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Panel ACRS Members Dr. Robert C. Axtmann Mr. Myer Bender Dr. Max W. Carbon Mr. Jesse C. Ebersole Mr. Harold Etherington Dr. William Kerr Dr. Harold W. Lewis Dr. J.

Carson Mark Mr. William M. Mathis Dr. Dade W. Moeller Dr. David Okrent Dr. Milton S. Plesset Mr. Jeremiah J.

Ray Dr. Paul C.

Shewmon Dr. Chester P, Siess Mr. David A. Ward Mr.. Malcolm,H. Furbush Resident Inspector/Diablo Canyon NPS Dr. William E. Cooper Mr.

W. C. Gangloff Mr.

Owen H. Davis Dr. Jose Roesset

A O'V~ ~

V I

~

~ 'I I

v A I h

C A OC

~ t, ve

~

~

I v

D C

0 A

~

~

~

O v

1

~

~ t C

<<Ckh A<<

\\

I I ~r

~ ~

Vh l ha

~ a A

A A'A

~

ar ~

I ~

A

~

~

AD C '1 t C

CADI>>C h

I 5

~

va et C anc

~alvch S l1OA Ih

DWt, I S trow, h>>Dl e'or 0"-'"'

"'" " wl.'. i D",".armer:.;o C111 tht >$ $g,.

Fl Dvl t

~ ~ c D

m c,~ 'Dto Dr 'd des' ar p,pl, c.h c cet I

h r C

SY OCh A

I

'C C

Arhr 1>>O v

S1h C'I V

+t

~

v 0

~

4 I

D

~

'vva I

~

~ I qth~o~hhqi th Ao <<'>>h<<oc Woll c

+'I o <<h~o cr

.I<<'o vl oo C ta ~ I

~ v 4'

v Ck

~ e v

A, a>>

e c)v Ir~ ~

~

~

S>>v v

VO c

~ v'v

~

I

~ ~

si~ s:an=arcs that would otherwise insure t>roper Uafeiy operation at Diab 0

?. ee scho " '

Ca '

(lo'

'00e oa "nR'; 0

~

&Bc.". el

~

h I V

~

\\

r D

~ r

~

A IDI D<<C I VCOC>>11 C

C 1

~ r

~ 'I

'hh ~

O I + O<<h 1 A A 1<<<<D<<+

<<the

~ IA OqAA v

v

~

Ivev 1D I V>>v

~

I P

ver ah 1

~ I voC>>

~

~ vD v tv

~

1 ~rh I I

~ A C

~ Aaa>>

~

~

~

~

<<g>>>>

C C

O<<C D<<A

~

~ >> <> ~

~

h vve IS 1

h 'l

~

v' VO 4 ~ ~ ~ a v

vv

~ ~

va v

v v

va

~ ~

AD ~ ~ v

~

~

v 1

T.

o..:n

~ ~ \\1

~ ~

I CQ I v

~

~

I O

C LAO v

vr ~ \\

C VV Ir Aa A

p<<heahh 4

S v

AD A

~ 1 S

<<D ~

~ ah h

V c -'A CA l e /

A C

e<<O

~

h D

<<D>>A1 w

v ~

v I

4<<e P

v

~

VV~

a.ta ShS av D ab'0 Oh>>

O I

A>>

O v

tran v'

~ '\\ A

~

r I

r

~,>>

C AIC' ht v

S

~ VC>>

ea" "= r "=an".

<<O C

1 v

v

~ ~vh vC v t

CM vv

'.ita":";e".."'Cu >i l, inc cc".ies o

"al-,s's c-pC~ an" g--~g a..c va" s shee.s v

v J

-r-e"'-'"" ieC."~"'nues

"'.'"OA '"W-'e "'0 en

>COSed 0V

-E aa event

( -Cer i.".e ""eC.'Cn I

0 gr ~~A<<, D <<It a<

I C D '<<O'Ca ~

~ <Or.,

1

~ IVhO<<thaar h OA '

1C A,,t v

~ I, 4

v ve

~ vr 2

~

~ v veC

~

v 0

A vv ~

~

vth P 'es

~

ap t'

> 5a

'>,',a~pe.,?e v,~S 0 ',1eC v

CC>>e ee

='" ers

.-.: ihe e~waica'l sta=f that such c?ocell~r tec.""icues yviDlc e ro..oc s

Ires'l"s and, suosecuentl-,

lead to v:clat ons of code ecuire-e..ts ard a=alysis

-rocecures.

Yanagement,

however, nas reacted o these ccncems by "pulling" he

-=.".::-: es awa":

-c.-v Conc =" " sta and re-assi Itin'e... to Dn~m e s that are

-C.a:y cog. -ant of s anca c nuc ear analysis ""oce'-es pn", cr ~ci"e inDs.

Oce c

e h "0 -

S 0

D S

~D~

~

o S

Dsc 2

' 'c I

~

I ys.e,"..s in t1ni

" neec not.e analyzed.

ec"".-Cues 0

m""c>>i ~ -v""-ili"'os -'

>>ro A 'J<<>>A

<<c<<ADv >A t

I vtt

<< ~ t C

I I O v CC v

~

1

~ SC>>e

<<1 t r<<va I

h h A>>

Sav va 0 v

C t

e>><<

cec,alai eao iou I,

~

ho..t t saD A

C

~ 1 I

D<<A

~

I OO C<>>

<<O C

~ '

~

I v

4 IAt I

a r s lA?i e

S

~

0" 1

."C-

=

=

e c-'ec

~

~ ~

v

~

vaa' a

Vh C

I A L exa...

C C At-D C

v van A

~ g AI v C ~ ~

v

~ ~ ~

~ ~

t'h A IS I

~ V I

V e

SCSC VP>>

n-C D v h

r

'0 CE anc Q> the Cua Ctt 0"

CA

'<<D =tsex-.

to t.".ese 'z"oned :lex bilit'-vbalarces.

I gl

>>D. 'r rh h tr V VC I

t 1

I Crt>>

<<o r'

Cr C>>>

~

rh

'V h' rhett

~

L

~

't C

C

.". c Ie="

~

<<D>>

P V

CD~

Ih

'h V

Q V

plan s~

~ I' h

c C

'V v

~ I cc L<<o vC<<

CD OIh ci'e c

~ '

D C

~I I rh ~ <<1 h r C c V CV r

p

DS)

I ~ e t I

\\0

<<D h

~

~

~

C

~ -C rhl co pr

~to I r

~ t

<<'-C>>--

v Lo v

tr

~ I

\\

v

<< f

~ ~ Co

~ e L<<

I Uac 's" ec

~ aCC

~

~ V<<

to -".=rove these

.""ass-(l ere" "8'""<<es

=ech.el

.-.Snago...ent

.'"Vas to -

ci

" oc

. 0, e>>liovees t 8 a>>o I occ co Alleg 0

c'01

. 0

~

r' r'g

<<I

~ no hh C

en r<<

~

~ ~

'h

~ Ih e ~ rh<<<<<<thi r rh

~

v cC v

c ~

Lh 11 Se v C

I v

~

d c v L

hrc i hv v L D>>

ar I

tion vhe bas'c doc'mentation of ~<<lysis 12-3M reveals the rance=

e=;1oyees a=o ca=a"le of nak'nr du=is-he analvsis o

Ciass 1

<<hh 'i 11 v v~ ~ ~

ehc

'i ntt 0) h i ' 'IcLV tc rr

. rr r

thL r>>O ttrni vo I

i<<

r r r L 1 Wv)>>

v C

rtvit 4

COL 1

VC 4 e>>

eC

~ <<

, ~

L

~ <<n

<<r c

Ihht Ih c>>,>>r iih>>

. c>>oiht ec <<Lrh

~ s 1

<<t r r c

p>>D

~ t<<eh c

~

c v I

~ 1 v <<v 0

~<<v 0

5 Cess vo tra

<<v

~

I8 JS vt

>ov,"

.-.c.".c" hc;,8

=- -e'en. '."=-s over<<r i""e. -'.:is war"='"." ='" 8-..

/1 e-'-"".-= -0 "'<<'-; e=i L',".e>>eCeS--"'.D I"'O>>S"..=C--'Cn LO fm +"- c ah 1-'n~

VSLe.-~

n l.

rvhc rt

~

<< 'c' c

(

I n

. IA>>ih>>t<<r h<<

~ Dc ht r

'<<Lrh L'

~

I

~

v

<<8 e I'v

~

~ ~ I v

~ v 8

I 0

8 e

I I

A I rr t

'<>r I

<<o r t,

>>rhrrh<<

'>>C v ~

~i vC C

v r

C 1

~ h CC 1

C'<<<<1<<C

~ C

~

D <<

'Co>>>>

L o

~

h D

~

I h>>>> rol1 I lo I>> Itd tr c'c

. Dc hi r 'Ite r' I e..

L v.. C;...

-- P I 0 --'

~

ih

~ h I

V i

C'C a BSS>>>>'>>

S Ste l

pve VI Cu>>-

L is Lt>>>>estd

<<0 "e ie 0'L'q'C 8x." Cn p= tne '.."ech--.ass

.ec.=". '

Le. ' 8'o 3i:8catch) ~

I r

~

h '

L -( r<<

~tt 'L r c hpo>>

nththl (IVAN Lrt, <<c>> hh 1't>>>> cn<<<<la c t viih>>Le h e e

I I

I o

e '<<>>rh>>LC D>>

ih <<'

Dh I 'hh D>>>>ln C

~>>Ih>>LI v>>

ti

~

v C

I v

vv r e 8

1 v

~ iv 8 <<I rvv v

v faili"""oa"s <<=ll be 0-'s r=""u e" a."..Cog he,new su"pcr s.

s

.'.".is ".,z" ",.he

."-.a,:le ~.puorts can be re@or.ed as W~x ng passed t"..e load allowab'es.

1!arageneni lus f'es these new supe~

adc tions under different reasons t, her zl expansion.

--oble-...s, seisvr c Cbl -s, e c,) to hice the real reason o" the fix: A :"ailing

~ (4'c lC oc".;e. 8L l

. a 8 ned in L..

S e

0 sp cb. e

~

0>> '>>c o th cn of Lho

<Ce 0>>e 8

d 8 e

i agi>>gs of

0. L lc 8 C..s, he n

LL 8" 8-u l "SchietrCcs s.. sc3 e

ed can

-C--.c a.-.=

.":8...

e st >>wrts...and L'.".e ft'.".al c=awin-s s'no the a.".d" then o=

>>ew s ~~orts e

C V

C v

~ h

~ ~

Lo "ou "u I

e to the acl: of res=ense C

~ V Lo"""'"ue 2.

~ ~ Lko

~

~'lri c v C

n

~

>>nb ve L

c

<<t

~

C'>>

~

~

r>>

~

0 cL t -'

~

D>>rh C

~ r

~

rh v v'C

'Lr ~

>><<Ch, Artc V

vh o

ec g

I t V

V neo'"

0 0

I hni C

c r c

~ <<e n>><>

n'tt o

I t't r

'<<f r>>

t hr e1 8>>r louver DCD Ohr CLh>>I rh 't C

r

~

~

~ ~ rh

~

~

p

~

L C

J a

1; v'>> e'~'.--

n L

..a. v C

)

..".e

~ 1 1>L

~

~ 1>>

vh Lh soeci=ic 0 nli i 8

"<<anc

~ob elv w'..

he parti

~

h

'L Lh Le c" '8 an8lys s'

0

~

~

1t A A'v

~

I

+~p v,'/

r v a.'~6 c

<<c>>

1 v v oA c

<<r r

v

~ <<C C v tp I

VV A

a

~ qr'e rV 8'v V

I.

1 (Ir<<<<<<.al 8 ~~~141 v'-4 Oe 4l I

I I

Donue at' guess-work L"

ed-r ass node3.l~ 1's. mclu 'o of anchor Veld design 8

rocednres r ~

~

C

- >-'<<<<C<

aC<1 r<Or

~

C V v v

v v vl v

~

~

W C. ~

<<<<CA<<

I o

c C

c 1

I C'

~

\\

v C1 vv e

a IO

C'.-

-la--ed. tc ='""ica.e the ac=. a1 c.edibil

~

o c- ~

e

.e s-~1l ~oe

~

~

a@ cu~entl~.

wv

~ I iA C s<<v v vv v vv v

-'~o:~ -""-"-'-'

a~a""a"ce co"cerns a-e

~he..se1ves, c= se

~ ~noQ ',"-eac of

~ C".i "e=1O'~i-"'~~eSit'm

+eC e /~~=. m~ uSe vc C'n" a s-+te-d, -a-ey- ~c='"" a.. Diab o

tho c=1v 'c~~ erence bei.".a 't?zi these

-."e ~c~~ to ~a-'l

<<r

~

A v

~

~

4 I

.~

~~e

- ~

realiza

. cn of.he stv1 exist a

Diablo nay neve be see":

los

~

he acceptance of,he pass-

>lte ed =ailmes'

~ and, in the process,

.he pass-altered Sa~le itself.

~<v<<

=ac ~-c Pas " ~ec tc Oo

.".o".he s Of Peace~

San Luis Ob" spo ne "an =rancisco Ch.onicle San 'u's Obi~o elean-Tribune

~ \\

~

~

\\

~

~

1 ~

I I, i sr+

1

~

1 1

~ /

~

~

1 i/

~JC 4~

~ i <<VIOL)e l)5 ~

'1' CIV

~

)V ~

I 1]/Q w/QQPr

'1 gZwr

~ wl ~

)

p

~0 Wa

~

~

p

~ V ~

C

, l

)

N I P

~

t 4

i Vr

~ r, r'

t

~ 't

~

I Jf

~ (l p )

p e g) w 0 r)g ~

I

~~

~ iV0

~ 0

~

~l~

~ 1

~

~

I 4

~

I JQ (1 ~

~/ g/n

~

/

~ !(p( Q 7>>

II /

Qre

~y~~

~ I I

CV <C

~

~

~ A I

~

v

\\

+e a

=- IC).

~

~

~

~

I

) l

<aew ~

I 'IV

~ Ivb I

~

~

.":Ie io.

~

I va.ivaaeC iv

~

ev QPQ lc(

o C" yo D-e

~

~ I I

~ ~

v

~

~g

~

St; =. m, Sys,, cr C"mpcner..

Cv<iw D~a V

(c'v cQ3

~ ~

c ~-

~

w C CclC"I

'C15

~

8

~- ~

a V

v ~ v

<4I.

l eiefiie WF-UlfK I', ~~~',.

l<

gtl,'Vl I

'QC V.

I

.~no 4 ~

~

~ r r

~

Jl yv r

~

P' lo'Pi~u~ife Djr(ear I)rae/%egpw

~ c>rc.el

~ f "it<

l"=rol " '-cari Suce."ri or e

p(

al

~

~

~

~ ~ I aa Ii

(.e22CA.df

. Yield:l I

, C.".e=.ec l w ad s

~ ae VoI I

I I

I ~i

'I ~'

~ ~

ep

~

V ar, C

~

~

I a

v

~

8 0 l(,

4I

'lC A?fC(el Or W K,hHhLY<lg ii(j ~aoci(c I

(a( j laire ~'ciai p

Ir' (pvCj l (raarae7

~

t 1 vf/'P 4 r F c'A g R g 0 k c I I d h/ I

~

~

C L

tVa Ia

~.P V ~

+W v ( vaJ

~ C'p e(>

aa C '

~

~ ~

~

. ev ev 'sc e

c e i

~ '~i

~

s C

clos H8~34

<<O.

'1 Oh 0

~

~

i

-2 5-8 IC 1t 01%

5 is

~

~

i

'a

'iIsV

-o-8 H8-42

+v 0 N,A AC

~

7")

-83)> ~

C. ':=':

i

~ OV Dezc

~oac 007

~

~

D

~ c ~ ~ L analysis

'st, chzn"es --de:

(

s ic< S-(

-. cv

~

~

c

~

1 A

~

."-r O

1CG-"=-'1

~

1'C

- ~'-

e e

ec c <<'cs zte" cowngrzcec (See Aooe ic x C)

I

~

C ass-='

zccc=cznce Due to =od C G'00, ca

~ii ~ e~'1 e

='"g Zinir.zt o

s

<<c'&c~ spo n s:.~+60>>

nn~t-be.

q1 a i >ed vs s.

pipe s ppo=ts ttached at

=he us'ng*.lead's de"'ved f"ct1 t'h's

875, i'i~

~ i e;

Pev-1 is be" g issued fo= the purpose of reducing loads or 512>>4, 512-2, and 512-3 attached at node poinrs 475,

510, znd 516.

(Stif'zness values were int-oduced in the t1odel.)

suppor ts= -.~;-

535, 585 0

qiiii s"

c oc :

z cns l>>QQ~

~ yii

~ 4 i yp

~

c ~

R".".ARK5

~i 12I xc0 iC 1 yQc 145

!iew New (*)

QQQ 132

lew. {*)

Modify ex's"

nstal1 new Install new

..o 'i y exis t

nsta'ew 1 C I

v"-direct'on ng't

"-c'rection 0

zn anc.

~ 0

~

v i g 4 d )

=ig d)

~

(

nr.

(

hor.

restra'estra' zr. anc z

D r

g V r

~

~

~

(W)

. ~~a 1l1o" gap

'-.. botn c'rect'ons.

Ci

~ Isi

~

e&

V I Approval "ate:

I

I alle&e~

'1 is 1

eeJ'o'I'eev

's4<e<

et<vcJsaJ4lles QVa ee ii

,I

~

~

e ee ~

((i) e) I,

,I I

< >/r <(<.tl s

~

~ ~ r > I.")IE

.I.'. ':.,) /

1<

J-4-';

,jl!.-'(.I

('It),'I jja A

s) ~"(y)

(/4).

h" P

. Pnr [i I)

't'I ll 6l g~ II I-!It<.tt A rtt). I'ttr;. I!Cr).

pg Q [

tssjtltt I) I:ht)VOII I'ltll)I.GI nt) tl.vS>IS ISSIIC

>Itut.. <<<). rl.<n/~ttcv. l t.*e'.It A I I

>I i~tvSt I..c..yg~ycysh,g)

I' I:tttC~in t-l.. gt.l)-I)'-"'4 1.

N I'lit)v<.O

,Br,

'<Its 4 Q I

~

~

I I

Ol Oil t I:-'

4

(~g

~

'~~

II

(

)%~.~ e) wV 1

I!I!t (I.'l 5ov ~y 4>

III

+ger) < '

~

~ ~

I ~,

(

~

Ie I

~ I q)

~ )

'<jan) Il I ~

I I)I I

II

\\ ~') Is I

~l e,

Is I

~

~

<1) 4

/I r. /r, tent' I/e ). "')/

I

~ ~ I//

('

+gg hIp/i

'.",)

f I

~

(I.) (III r,l

/

~ 4 rs I

es I

r ) I r,'(.r/. /'

('i)<)

tl q

~ ~

( )

(Ief ef y'et Ie"II LI

', i '/('I.I

".os'

.II e

~ ~ <1 1

I I))

I I

'I'e

u aeeenueCI)eenq Ie I

~eleeees r

~

ee ueereieu)eug'c.. '(Als v'uI)eeLORJLfiFARIlcEwzo I) e'SIC'TR

(

I

'e g err r)l prlr 77/JR=Elf J)Ir(?:~ ILJ I'.Ill OfkÃYA!'~.

I pe f)

I l.

)7

('gf gn g I

).(: ~ (I

~ I(().I(((i >>Il')

Ll 6! 1. I)"'(ll(ll ( ' (IIII) I e(I)>> (

I ~IVe)l,\\ 'I

~ (,IQ(t(

I IAa. ((I fj-.lny t ij(.

A. a.l

.Ik'"I L..C. l'().)ril+)) C.Q

(

~II I(t (I (c.'. I.

l;,t. ( I Ig'r $(e Qo (ui)f ".

(Il

~

r

[II%))

)( [.

)i) r,ll) aft)I ~g I~f IIl~(l

(

tf

<n-0""

ee C'..

~ "

I I i'L't

~pl

'(c~)

~e A

il I

Ie'ellI

,ee I) II (l7)l r,) ((j(

) (I)))

~

ul I

)

((,

'( (I

)~I I

(,)

II li)

I

4 JI~

~ ~ Jl

(

"% ~ ~ ~ ~ 'Ma JW 4 a e IX"VLIZ'IPJ{J'J)I

> J 'Il FRIZ

)

~

Ii

~

la>

'(>

~ j I,

(:Il)t:n)l) f? I h>'II)(l)V> I >

J)t>1 C)QP

(

)~(

> I.{Cp g )

()h((

(f,df jm)

Q(cp)

+'II Qll I a(g (Jl))

I

~ ~

~ I

~\\

o In

~I riFe isa

>') ue u>

~ (I-r.to

~ r

~ r

~ ~

~

~

~ I

~ ~

~,

~

~

~ r

~ v

~

~

h

~

I

~

0 A

~

r C

hr

~

~ v' her I r ~,

~ ~ r

~ ~ v

~ I I 'I P

~ Irr

~

~ AhV)l h

~

~

v '

Lr C

~ vv O

~

4+v/vVy

~ ~

gJ I

e I

a "'fjJVLl

" i".'~ P V T =

r qr

{

OIhr LLo~g,5l s SS

)

(

e "-SI

)

I C QvoVTi D

'LG~"BL

~

~

r ~ v v-.S 7AP1

~ 432

~

~

~

~

J

~

v v I I'

~ c'

~

- ~

vl ~ v

~

w

~

~

~ v'rv

~ I "'

4 C COv

~ P, r ~

~ r 1

rh ~ ~ a I

I I t v $ V

~

h L ll

~

4 ('

r r/

~

g

~

~

r I r

T P

1 3 5..i

~

I,

~ ~

2 '4 SJ-:

P IJ XP "RS ION r

~

~ ~

1 Z

'U ~:o v

g45 4%"

44 P 1? 71J5 Ih ~

274bc

~ b81

'I, u<-",$

S.

<<V hl

~ V

~

~

~I

~

P(

I.I +i

, ~

I g ($

vv

~\\ P&%

cc 9 P l<r I

~

~

)c "-.5/

5't."c -.Y 9'~

r t'g> G V,I".~. ~l 7

~./'T. ~a+

H,PJ, ~~

Pip P.f.'O I ik

~ I J

~

3' h',r"g

. so D g,PT, tl 0

~

~

~ ~ I c

io i

~ par

< a<c.

<F Cg<~)

. Sc

~

~ cp 7'pc QKQi&QLMTQ ~SN9 PS TP<

4. FTb. I~0,2.f;5',

~i/i

~ ~ 'I

~W I ~'j( p i g ~~l<t:~

i~ ~ ~ r l'. l

~pi ~a<C2 p t:q.

Qoa~,i> N (

(Lh C-,

1 LJ 5NUfi P gk.g.

I I

{ gl ~L 'b) g=RE Fv7

t ~

' \\

J

'I~ ~l g

~M ~

~ ~

C

~~ ~

~

7r, a

.-)5-p%

7~<-' "~i

~.

I 8 I P C f 2-lJ

/Cc!d, C~>

~ egg I

\\"

I v

~>k lhL U C; c i w(~,etc.ou4,g xl ~ W

@Vga g j /r/it'G V'4 5>r'7/-'S I '

Z.

v I

c I

C,::P g,~)I

~,

~

~

v~t ( g

~c'g~h t LvV ~

vhg

y. gg,y i-,.ig 5 8 0:

~~ ~-, tt~~t

~1,gast

'ttVrl~v Qa L>N~iv~~~v t

~~~wi c-.L')Qg-Po L'Vl-a N, c-6

-'Y'4tL-p-. ~ p. iv g ) (

F." a v,~<

WGP.T<oa oP T<~

ARRAN'I~>4 A h ~4Th ALIT M 4Q HobELE5 AT

~it:VoiWf p zq~

vE45 C '

PP<E:

t ilohl. p((+

I,) ]3

>~

I

~

t

4

~

~

~

~

<<g

~ ~

g ie<<,

~ ewe r

~ rv vlV p

~

a~

"ECH I ='

v i Ic."". CG-",."G."".~i/CiV To v

~ <<<< ~l I

r Cl C

=- -o ~ or'~ ~~ ~r

~

'J>><<a ~ ~ W~Ma<< ~'UW C~ ~i'c~

S~:TH=o 0: 5~~

Subject c~t~aibb

"-G67

<<o1

~~>>

oS-

'm C

~C~l ~ S"'-

S C=

2-2 c

<<o cC. lc c

~

I

~

1

~

V ~

~v =.=26 '".

E I <<<< ~

~

r l

r P

~

~

E=B 8

~l'".

+<<l( Q~%

~

3<<62 '~l'I.J L. ~'~~a~/

Wc<< I Qn

.oc-or

~~ ~

~l<<

%l r ~<<4 Q ~

I C

~ >>>>

C" 0

WIG ~ ~ L

~

s q

<<~/P C

r I

Se='s= c/='osg='r 5 Se'cf c/D".

~

0

~ V 7.

vu a. i'=SS Dea" 'oa"

=-",';'!/DJ. /DG"li~=h LIBRARY G.O.

r;2 "o

~ 0C ~ ~ L A ~ ~

C

~

<< ~ ~ 4 s

s s"pe:se 'e"'".~ ys s au=hers (Se's='c a".c."-'ex):

v +rr,//f0 r.

~ r r/

C tg,,r, 'r rip

/.

v ~ IZrr,sr

~d rid Ik<

Ca+SICSe&

-I-=CI. IC..

A~r"gc SQ~QDCt PuAEI~I/rIf/

~ If

~

g

~ ~

t

~ 'r'

~

~"

tg

~ ~

C r

~

~

~

= su"ports o" supporc aodif'a"fons required:

rfg vie-D

~=SINAI"-.gIIg g5-7Z n~

g P Pry/(

/, <

N I

hpproval Dace:

~.,

~ \\

P

H

~ 4

~

• r p 8 ~

~

~

8-l~

~-.r 'au'~carr

~ ~lr

~ ~

pip4'a~ Si+& Tnt ups

~~ N'6 ( ra ~/ + /~

g/jr ',l/) g/Q 1 ~+

< ~

~ /

mg A

~

Q Il

/rV 'g v

pg(

/-,

E

~

~

~-.rri~ <r t ug

~-

4 =C'r/

I'~(

e g.

Si'~$

P~(P~ f/t. 7/~>rY j(

" E'H)4 Q PI f /'

~ Wg

~

I

~ ~

~~~~mWi ~

~ 5c ~ c5.. ~lW~

~~+-Z~d~"r WmK '~W"Sct'S~id-

~

II' I

" hP Z=5er~i~+ 6Ã~r +cJ '=8 p"ill'P< F2a jir4 r'p'.rz~g~ g.

.Ql ~

fi'<'

$ep 7 /g@

1'L'I+g

~

~

C L.lAD M & Us&

vAI>'Ys

~

~N

~ ~

~

I

+~/> W.r/,'CK r I

~Tl Io

?

/

~. r'r'vr I+

I I

~~+~a&

Pd Ss! ~G:. 7?? rough c ~rA,/qd i C,>Jr-,4~~/S c'2c

/5

/A'5'>/A i. 3

, gg..'/

l~/ Zu'~ 5/~ 8i AND yd'/ n

/"Cr4 88CZ,>

g OA zilch pz~zr'r" -/ou was

, n.

<'==~=-P r.S 8

8 Z~~

~ Or<4-r/5778 e

.n /iC --/i~I

-.~

r.

riod ~SF',I'-

en=

E r

~

I Y-r r CX/~-'I: Y 8-re-

~ >.5 r

/

trf~

h6>>'~

a ys s

4 vCv :.eviev s"=e=r c

S eis=~ c/dos gm

--v

"-:):

/ V'/C

//

8uG

/9 -~

/ =C//-/C

/td( f't/1(I f

~l

~

~ v>> +'rI t r v r v~

~

r IC r'

'L t

r C/ /Sr'r/<.ED'/k4'A~5'k'6j

/ / /ZS/L)Z~Z

~g z~~/g

~ug~ g'/

u >Hi/.../M/-/oA/

~ g

. ~....

t

~ 1 ONLY

."r~ supports or support modifications required:

o A'0A' gEQv/Z~~D T )om gP'//t 8/ DVZ gECd n

/W

/Z/'AD 5'C-/49

(~ada 6<5 )

g) f5~ -g5 (rvcc'c g) o 5'o /+t (IJc& Eto)

'ssued By:

Approval Date:

,g

~ ~i ~43

I V~

I I

!~J l4

~~

P-

~i z~

~.J.

Q

+h~

~

~'I

( I, -r:ov I'y' l

I J

~ r p

~

J r:jI+r DSSSI4>

I/;f J4'g v a~

lt~ Arindj 5 /5 A rg ~

'y'g(=%

/'/~ f,~=

/

r r/>>

I 1

v

'r r.j

) I C, /vg). A'~~:-., r J'5

~

Dil.7c.,~L ~~i~~zd ira~dYSLS

/(0 RESrirr,au-,'~

~)E.i~ i-I"">,'

.DP '~4~(bcL<7$ "

. r,j'l q.'

'+J'J- )

SF

~ gg@

~ ~) +~~>>.

C >'~m A A N W~ 'j-"~P" ~

~

~

v 0

~>>>>

~e I

'1 \\<<

~j>> a

>> J'I<<<<>>

aI~U 4441 4 jra1 jr<<

<<Il

~

~ h

-a ~r>>>>~ I >>>>~f a>>

j>>i'l <<~j C

7-f<<

I ~

<<tl

~E7>> ~D

'lM 7~1

~ <<

~rel r~ aV

<<IQ V<<

M o >><<

(

)

~j.ePf V

~ II I )

~

r Ha E<>

\\

I r

~

~n<<v n e

I

~ M egg~c.f qc 111

i r

r

~ V rr

~ I

~

V

~ Ir

- -'ilh J ~

r}f ~ ~g rgC

'0l 'Q )

I i

~

} V

~.>rrr>:~,OVX. 3g SW i

v, CC

> II i

I I~C g

I /

r jc Si

"..- =. I 70> 7 v=.oiS pZ =, I< g (Z>g )

p'=."-',o, vt'= "7

}.> =.2} 5(c}2>)

"x =.:-.6, >~=..i ~ -',

s P=, 04 ( HS ')

w<c 80 9x-".r/z,~r'=.Dgq z=./~y (OE tv =

~ "-44,~/-.c SS,-.Z:. =ro., M

"!a Qi= 'l-gZ.'= J~5 t.Z

)

-.:',.-:s,.'-.-..':-o (9.,

p - /r///~

~<C

~>>

~8 =.16 7,~~- /~ p,

~ r

// ( ~r~)

~ r

/

/

/

i j)/ Cr ~r. Cr5 I'6 ~A'

<A'>p pe~ ~Cr<H /n Ce~,/~ i,,r j.r-CO g~

r,1

<4(< '~j-~<g. ~ ~ // <~7 <~C!'~>'

A~ +~A/Qg/g g( / I~QCg~ Ily,

/

i

~

/

/

I i r r Io 'd inner} rl c /j jar}os @no} ur r>nr} pr snwgrrI o j toei;roar'

/

'r~}Y

's. ! 's rr / n I fj or+ I!I>I'r/pI'Ig siIrir rI'-i Ply'.

/",,'; /

Q !Fi

~IJ SA I1 /, PPf >rn d I>r>S ~ 8 fiI!ELM'I }~ry'a~

"n'jrirr iS!> ec TI>o or>a} j>>oJ gl rr iS) r}n>1 Ii IS Cone/w J< >! I nrr7 f~rrar o i nrI

I';

/'!

/

-/,

".n.'./

I'; Ii ir}'r" i

r

/

/

nq

~<.

~

~

P<

, } CIV)

I

~

~

i/~

/

r i

,}j

= 'r/ j.v

/Joi n re /rl I aorrr god n-,'~ i nor.i/

I>.. pgrs n i r'

~

"-rjIfIVJ

( r>'e TjI>'11C'iCnrd fhC},'

I'7 I

.. r: n4 ov7 i r7>i ~o i

I I

I I

herr;>( i o4rg

'i or>e. I>o}-~)r~i>'f / =2 0 F r], o (go;g~

(

~

rs I

~4 j g

yg

/.

I

~ ~

r t.

/ v

~ V /

7'P&

I

/

0 / I C5 f'

V' Q'

I

/ >v'L I

-ys-,=/

iz s i ~; J ~'n -p,j I

=d n-o pion'..l o-+

f

/

( j I

'> r r r ++C, ~

j +

l l v $5 g~

e

/

Q f

.~ jf\\

W ~~frr'T~//pgj I.,

~

I I

pIJ p

g

~ Jr

~

~

~/rn~

pp~> cf ~

//

/

4

~

~

/

C.

~ r

/

I

~

/

~ i'W I vry-.

/ Jl I

nC Cr./r b.

U f Hh

. ~ ~

~

nr

~

~

'~era IC, ~ I

~ k I ao Y;Y~N l

Oate S:-"c".'m, System, or Ccrnponerrt

~

~

~

~l~

~ ~ 7~

/

~

Type

- c.."";osa o e 'icn Gale"laions

~'g

~ C%

SAr": C,"ance

."".e" irH J ~

rre"arer l

Yes

~

>/

~ (

iso

'I Dl-kiln/Dep I

Checker mpQroYGI:

Dis"i"iine =n"-ineer GrcJp Les+~er/Supe.".~in~;

~/~!+f rA

.r. /'I=

g

~

I R~p~ oa Rcvlslorls Rev. Nc.

l Dr.e Rees=r. for Revision 1

Rev. by:

by I "-ncr..

r~i eu

~

/J'J

/J

/ Jm~C/~

4

~ ~ "C

~

~ )

Re e"

~ sc et= c ho ~

('14-l L3 P~

Z.~

D. C.UM: /

Se'

='c/"=os b Se'U c/D""

C 'L4

".."'beta y.~s De"d Load s'ys s

No ~

~

a C

c

~ ~

);e e

a ~

~

)

".s's,, 's-c~ges ~de:

's=

s perse"'e" ac=-'ysis

{C~JS J C r

'L~):

<g'

)/

t Jt '

~

br<<sr.""or-s o" sc"per=

ocica-'ons requ'rei:

( Y~)

~~~7r~o.

~le.t Z/CQ-cga g

(z)

C=//sr i pC A~~~ + Z/g ~

C~ ~ + =a w -rj/ vo/r/

ssUS Sy:

~Lvprv a

eel I

~ el

~

~ l ~

~ ~

l l

r ~ ~

~

rJ C

~lri

~

~ I c

~

~

ci'-

al ~ S

~ C

~

~ <<v el+ ~

1 r,

~

<<e Se'saic/ os~

(

Se~ sM c/D:-

~

g ~Dll " j SS Dead ~ad

.o:

""G/T')/DJ?/DOMKXT LIBRARY G.O.

":-'S S

bio ~

P eV ~

$ c eeeg <<) +$ 4 $

~

~ $

sur(e se ec aaeaea Ys'

=~ers (Sei $ '.~(a 1 ~)

..1.'

ri D=Ji,=. ~i e

'.icy sv pport,s 'o" su? lcm nod~ ~~ ca"c ops 'reau're~:

gQ')

'w~ AOQF-. ~Y:~

J~y 2(Q~-. )~

+~

~s

~<

Q

!0 L!5('

'-/~~

~i. l H~lJ,7'x,

~j-'

~

~ ~

he

~

I e

~

~

V i (>

<<lh( <<

~ei r.

e

~re ll ear vt.iv

~SS C

~ ~ e (e'

~ >>

>>>r

~

A r

A

~ ~

~

I I'

~

':Osc, O

$ ~ c='y

~

'S

$.G C'~ 'Q'

~

B S

~

~,

~ ~

~ le

~c

<<e

~a wLC L~$

<<4

<<$ <<w I "as/ ~+$ c'@'<<I g ~

1 ~

~

r'~

c4 la.

X':- j'ea r K~ t;8 B~C C'aSS L E:~ t'.-a r="n<<seis=-'" class

=

PE

y

'I

-='==-'-"- is "'> drest'~~

SUB o~ & cack valve (data pc' 25).

~

~

1 'I ~

~

Q <<+<<>> 4 g <<~

A ~

r

<<I

~

I

~

I B

Ttc

<>v 7

~ ~

"be c~ deme '

se.~'c ~~lysm.

P-c-ta po ~t 83, a ~s o=

~B "-B~~~~ F~

o:. Q~~:.-

VG B a~ceo to S~

atB o

I

~

~

~ r r <<

>>~ P>><<C'4 C <<

=-.= v=-~ o. ~w cue b'~w>y l~M IX%81 is K?B t ~1 GGK&te.

r

~

3~=...='"g ~~ c-~c~~ a~as ~~s t'm follcr=--:

-):c "'"-"a'an'lysQ:.(Fi 11) tra swws ~ tm pipe

':< r. cx;B al r~m e i-ho~-. ~w class l eni c ass E sect~o.z.

s "ell

'Jf

~ I~

4

~

~ I c'I a ~,i b) ror th tt~l expaz1sion analyses (Eq 13/14) the stress in Qa pipit is well b lo~ coae allc$$&le in boy class Z ezd clos E sect~

c) 'oy Qa >sip m~~+cua<>

(D Z ) sew'c a~="lysis (=- l2j1.2 Sn)

"== stress iz 0 pipe in t.-a Class T. Section

~ ~ all belch th ccce 1<-..ale (1.2 Fn).

En t.e ~1s E section, the s ress in t~ p'pe does

"..-" Bz"

.~e aller.~le 1=t

~

d ta point 33,

$ ~ ch is do; ~t=e~ o= t.-a sect-.~ iso =--m '~Lve.;etc e~t wr al'oints w~

"w c'ass

= sate, t:.= c-c latea s~ss coes not mc m t a Hos~

- allo"~ e st"ess (2.4

~

I

~ j IL C"

$jl

~ ~

c"'3.'

~

-I ~I II

~ $

~l C'

r

~

r<<W1

~

p ~

1

~

a rr rI

>>>>~<<~

~ c<<e>>

win<<K<<

~

&1 I

c'c C~

c

< c>>+>>

~

ci) c 'c

)

C

~

I

~

rr

~

<<vV V

)

Vr r

~

i

)c..~ e ~ss.

'i) g,

~ r

~

q ~)

I ii 4'ill3 '>>

i

%~I J J )

xiii in 0 GvhL)>>~t ~

O Lc cCULLl 0 ctZll e):"or De Fesq~

QS) e~ Dr~) De calculat@ stress w t"a c:-~s sec 5 ~ %el 0=-i >>'oce 211 w'a

-ie (2

~ ~

.1/

~

CcSSE

, ~c coce ~ n;~ e is rmt exce='e" ~;..1 ccta m'-.

-'.5;-'.'ch is C;. ~8 CO'v'Os~i-"

S"..~2 O: t"8 Se C~a

~DO c ~~n PclVe.

~ ~

W) ~

<e~i

~~ts Ca'CULPt&Q 2

=tc po'~

63 2 2

~ ~

i A,.( = =2.P g',A'(DO=~=5.633", "-~<(iH)=8.162".

m dms'~ srx:'5 tM t~e o" a.>~~-pe'"'-~~ '2'-10 112.'.~ caga poi;.t 85.

Tr~ >Ml I

'"t "-a se'~'c deQ.ect'"n cZ --e pim c 5-5/8" I ~>>

r 1-terally at any po~~ ~ the penetration.

Became oZ ~hi.s penetration, t~e md~ deQ.ect~w at data point 85 is nectd to be ao"@xi--tely r

2-i/8'y,'~~.is ~arcble to the '

c"se w-;) m stress would be I

r=='".=-1 to daQect.'.

Clearly, it cw be co..c uM t';-t t".

5

~P.

5+5525 RQ Qp pe/

Q

~ 1 1 Oe

$ dnit+Cc. tl)i 1 255 t>=n tuse c-lr'M'.

~

~

C.. tiM i= =.'5:)

~

J

~

i' ),'

T r

~" I r

).

r (i ~

i c

? rlr r

rf 4)(i

~ '

~ 1

~

~

U'

~

\\

I liC r

-S.r~o. L-r,

/',

1

~

PV

~

~

1 Cgg I Z"4

'l C. l]/

~

l'l J

'%,a fir~('

~

WI iie )

i A.~~&iGW (Z- ~~

I T':miT~

CH

'aK;,:vIIjqKIKa-.~ac!Mfa ~r'.C~,Irov&I~~

.P i~~.~~'~&i;~q; ti

= <gq,~gp ~i+ 'Q~~ng< s~

~~lgXg W 'q~~W<

~~~N<t= 7+7 1HE.

M~Gi -'< '=

<(-0

='~=~(~I8'g~

~~i;

( )~~K QQ

( y-','=

~

~t = m~= '

j'g~'>'PQ

'Liqg~& ++i DSW<'-

llpga)VWl QVB~;~ ~

'.:~:

I I

~ ~

.v ~ /

]

4> '~'

'~ J

~f ~> t-.

~ +~ ~~i+~

~JN,~~~

~~

~,, ~l.

gl/ ~~ /

( ~

e+l~~l g i 9 t ~'Z; iDt'~

~

' ':.'-: l-Ct.~-~tW

'QQ~

'Q

~

s f Xh

..==~)~~~~ ~-',

~ >,(~ N4r'U'=-'--.'2QM>

(+r" E.j==g,:,OW

, L k..;--4 ':.(4c-= >3-.=....~~~..

~,r P f lr

~

il ~/

QQ'l~~~l~~

C.~~'~~X

(

~ ~ l r

f.:

.~'

I

! W). ~ ':Vki&,-t.< ~~L Cl-'TP,~

C~e ~~ ~l&V C'

~~

a'.RIC" l

i >r C='vs C.

..~ UI"~

I l l l.l '~~ m>~M k,C~ l I

~I, C J',

I i I

' r r

~ '>,l~pg

'/'l~~

I ~

~ ~l li'v

.I ~

~

~

\\

I x/

., &MIP l

l IHl 1

.i

-:~ l33

C I't K OCs.

I C/ CCi):

~

~ t

~ l I'-A~~.

2-12 D T'~'~ ~ iH~~MI

~ ~O~ ~C~) ~-.

P 43/~<K I ~g~

/

~ '4 4

t

)-".~<Di... l.i~

t

),'. 40%..:-7'=.

=<<~a~o=-

-- lm g g ~~i grc.~..~-

1~ ~>~)t~~S

2. ~t

)

~ g&

..a-,'.WJA7= :". QO~.. 6~ C~

w)T'A.~)',<~wo.Z..

) ~P.~i'i~M C.,

i -=M-=,pal'~~)vU~

<~~U~~oi:o-,'. Cj"=~KM)=~i%.

".RDi~~)GC~:.:~': tr PPO'T 5 lYiRN.L ~.

~/

..Q~m t ~H~'.

~ ~

~

~

"SUPEPS:gE Y

EV C

OF CALC DH) 0

+~ggr 5~

rAP D t GHKD 1/..i~

p,pap pW

1

J

~

1 I

I I

I I

~

~

~(r~w~

/

~ r 4

$ ~

I<<g f

~ >

S

c

~

~

r

~

I

~I

~ ~.

I

~

~

~ I

\\

Plt s '-

I

~ff]

f

~rr

+I Pr

~ r

~

Qs nt q

~

~

Wer p'g3t Q ~i'

',P "Io QliI!~ 0;I

. Rl '=CT J

~

~

~

C

~

/

.A( 7"l.

0

~

~

~

~

l

~

w

~

~

g 0

~

r~

~

~

1 ~

~

~

~

J

~

~ I

1

~

~,

1

~

~

uz t

~

~

'4 (r l4

~ ~ ~

~

~ r r

~

~~

~

~

g

~ ~ ~

~

rr I A W

r / I

~ r

~

~

~

S r

r

~ I 1't r vI 0 r

e /

~r t n

~

~ ~

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

':I l J

j

~

v v

~

~ -r r.

"-'i7 9o

~

I (

~ A t f

~

~

~

~

I r

~ v g2~!

~ r

~

~

~

~

I

~

~

v v P'

I

~

900@D

~ ~

~

~

~ ~ ~

XC r,rv

~

r

)l.- ~

g

=

~

C r

P

~ev r

~

~ ~ IC

- 2~9j, I

~

~ 'II 1

0 r -LCVL~T j ". ~. c

~

~

~

\\ ~

f

~

= la I ~

I~

~

~

1

~ 0 e t ~,

I

~

~

ff, gP ~ l

/ <W C l(-

r.

+MrPv~

~+&i

/

l I

~

~ I

~

I I!

Jt

~ I I

s ss s st Is ~

I 5-Zg

'a Q)J (Ji) )tla)\\ '( 'I.or>>)

I') ('Is) s I.A/ K -(..0 I".hl-I'(()(.I I.l'J'

( 4':')V.((.(>. 1 I.P) 1'7'E)t-41('

.".l.

'sI s

<<( ~'

I I'.

I

.t I

~ ~

I

(

~

I

~

~

I aI

~

s C'1 Q

OJ

'.f;3 I

II('

ls1 f

~

I

~'

I ss"

I I I "1 I

~

~ '1 I)t ~ ('It) I h(.(.ss'Lsh(s(

"I"II'l(I ': II(l".

". I s I /t. I la sr I )

I

. II: I

~ (I a

~ 's

~ I h

~

L ~

s'

~

I ~ I ) I.

I'lI 's I I I l)ltA I I. I.

~ 1's I

'L J.>>J II) a I

5

-~IO at

~ ~ 'll

(

-4th,rl)~l

. ( s)!as 3

~'t SaL<<

~

(3. 45'>

sr>>..s 5

. ~

.o (Q

~ s) 8974 'Sfs '.

(s Ca.~As C.

r. s) a 'III

.: l.rit:)

wa sta~lsl I -~I ~

>7".'I Oss(g

~ s s

s (I

3I I.

I Ss (J)

T(lG l-R)r CrH.s 'a/P).(J(

s

. I....

11

~..

I

~

>>IPX=fy PA)l(.J~

1"I '1 s >V., I g I I a I 1'I ((=

).Y)(.l- ( l.'s"-.PA( I.'/a.(.l.. /

I"UPTII=(.l C)=

1~((

I sl alas' I (I I /s I.

11 E>lJQ(!)=

Ilgl'/R( 'll '

)I y g l/

Ihh'J(4

"-.rt 1.<. '.: 1../..l(ir CQQ)= ling.'i~1, W

~ I /".'

.I I '. I ~ << I C~

s~ la 7-~>>) /a'I

~

) st s tl I 1 /

~/A)

~ ts.'.

( It sl II

~ s

~ ss

~ 11 a).

fs l':)

FJ ITI

'.s>> l.'I s:4.(U ()

~

~

~

~ lss' 1st I

~

~ (s

~r t tgFIVO It I tss I ~ '

rtaa t.:n ((* 'sll.

<-',iA )'.sb(.p

~

~

s'

)'.=s.$ )+

~

~

~ ~

I Q. r(Q Qg(g (g

~

~ ~t

~

I lh B(r)Z(:. Ct:( '-

/"1 I-l C>l'.

I V)1 1

~ ls.

r>>m.l(.>>.l I" ))

(1 11..

I. 1" sI 1

OF=

ll 1(:.

7 Il II ):.

I~~ Ir c (...'.1 s.

~

~

hI]s.(CI'Z'. l.l( J..

il I

s sI I I

~

I I

I s

~ I s

I

~

~ s

/

~ (:>. Cs:$

~]-).s-$'tr

S l

I

~

~

I.

~..~v

~ t C

vvv

~

t

~

~

SB OZ I

S c Z') SLS is to P~' l. BSS

~UCB Xi I

ip

- 2'"1'~B o:

"-'B Q lccc sB c.

c c 4 ~"""~/J c 4

s.

vo y v I K1 - a SemC CIBSS I cz C'. o nCn-SemC ClaSS

~ CIvVt~s~-cI~4 S~e OT. l ~ Ct&Ck VR1VB (Cata Do~it 20)

~

I P SXc ttcS I B>> 'I BC ct

@c e nZ v

ZZZers 5 'I'O'K 'GALS DC Qt are CM~ 'aC Sl~UG~IS a~

c=-mt A

=-.~='-e Bd.0'a s-~~'c a~~ltysis t

Cata PO:lt 5

)

c.

S O

c c~s c:

~

~

~B c C tC 4

~

I P I

~

A

-c" ~a "

use oz ~

4 s=~

= ~"=s code "m~, ~~w miell is wm ~ax men cte.

.~P c>>

2 I 8 calcLIla ed sos Ave t~8

~

~

I e

~

-)

""or "

" "atic an~j-is (m'1)-tM D)1 10

~ ~

s Bss in RIB p:De is vre11

'=el

>>. c"-a a'"~ e '". boy~ ~~ class I aw class E se t'ons.

b) r"cr tM t>w ~l cacpmsion analyses (Eq 13/14) the stress in the

'Q~

~ l> is late '

u 1 cw code a1 1 OIt.able

~w both class I am class

~ sections.

c) rcr ~"a Des'~ ~sq~ke (D E ) sei~~c ~~lysis (Z" 12/1.2 ~n) s in ="e pme in tra Class E section is veil belcw Ja, code

'tt~ I B (1. 2 vn).

L1 th. class E sect-'on, tt Ie s~ss ir. the pipe oo'Bs

-.."" ~~cc=. Cme a l=>>m'e w.t'-~= ~>'t ~~,

.~cn

~ c==.a "~ c ec c~':cn 4've.

"Io e t o al'oi'1ts w w c ass

" sec-on, 1

C

cc= cc s not emcee t."w ".us~

-11G. able

---c- (/m S ~

c 0

( ~

~ N A

&I QQ

~ A< ~/

I

'C CC W

vt kOI

% vv~

~

I E!

I

r

~~ ~

Vie ~M I

~m

~ \\ ~

~'t 0

~ '

(

I

~

W I

/ ~

Gee

>>J

% c

%bc C

(

~

av'wl

'e

)

'l C>>

aL'vnc st Bss.

7w iasg= allo'~able swiss vec~"

I I >>t1 I Ccta

'OO ".t 55,;'cn x,s acr.etre~

oz "'-e ceCC 6

. cc'a

~I n

'i'>>. ve.

e,'c= ""e Hos.'~Z) e 'm~m, --

calcwlateQ st=es

'-. th 1

8 I+

~

c'ccS sc=C:on)

. EH COCie c.'

~'ao'e M not ENCE~'1

.. '1 Caic O,. = CG'=.,St cc S&e G

the Sec~

iSO c.

1 n Vc.lVe

)

~i

-W AI4 )

'. -= "c-.=-al ce'~'c ~~~"s c-'cu~-"M cata po' 85

~'

I")=2.i17 )Z((uD")=5.'E33~

) a M~4(E) 8 162 Tf'e Q cv' st'g's c?e I

')/

~ I

~

. e=::.te.~e o" a.>>.a" pe-. ~t;~ 2 -'0 4)t2 ~~ Qua.ze-~t,85. ~ va 1

=st=mt tee serac deme tion of t'-e p'pe to 5-5/8 lateral"g at arv point ~ Qa penetration.

Be~)e of t~ pene~tion, wz zw'~~ ceflection at a-ta point 85 1w e~cta5 to be apprcz~rely 2-..'8" r-'c~ 's cc--able to 'E " case w-.e"e stress wuulQ b

~~=ic, 1 to Qe Iection.

Clearly, it cw be concl&Q t'." t "r sei~-.

si=esses in ~~e p-".1~~ w~~l be si~-'c-~tip less m~. ~use I

c c

VaI V

S C N

)

C>>

CO IC 'L' e

o

c. coca

~

~

S

\\

)

0

. J

~

~

a

~

~ ~

Q ~

~

y ~

r

~

~

~ 1

~ ~

8' lI

~ IAI f gta Js.iii l I'a l I os a l ~ s o'Ihl ~

1 IV ~ %%

~

~ ~

VAN I ~

~ J qy i

~

~ +,14

~ ~

~

~

~ 1

~

E

\\

r r

(

~ ~ ~

'rVrr e

e ~ l r

y \\

<r

'e a

'gal

'reaa aeaa acre

~'

aar

~

~r g r ra I, l

g r

~ Ia

~ ( ~a

~

~ r V

e

~

I<~+S

~'

~ *4 co V~NC CF -,m EcSTRqgg<S r, deer<

~

~

~

~

r

~ r

<< ~

l

~ ~

~

~

)

A

~

~

~ )

~ W

~

P

~

~

~ ~;,

r

~

U a

~ ~

~

~

~

I

~

~

A 1

~

~

~

S p

~

~

w ~ '

~ ~ ~

~

~

• )

~

~I i~j id~.

~ ~

~

~.6 a ~

I

& ~

g?

Il

/i (i4Cc h+

+1 I

J/

ru' 1

~ ~

~

~

~ ~ i

~ /1 Qh

~

~

< iaaf Wl I = 'J~ I

~ ~ ~e l

IOI ~

~

~ <

~

~

i, 'V~

r

~ &

A re( wl

~

~

I I I

~

4 i'

I

~

~

~

~

~

I />>

~

~

~

r r ~ r+

I

/ t ~

I I

'I I r

I

~

~

~

=~,.-

r

~r'r

~ +"

I.je

.1C l)

)

~r V

r' I

~

~

I l,.'

l I

. I

\\l\\I ai'I I

(r ~,'i.l/)

,I.co'J Il

/;S'.l'T'I I,)0(',I

~'II I~I I

II. I.

Qir.

()au (0 pll g)> I/I 00 OI!6 Jt.:II's'ID 78'rt/4/7 etll (t)3 JlOI 7/I'Ir lrrtV /I'S 7cI ~IIII

~se I rIC I

(0(..-

+~07;.: r OR;5 ~r'II//C,'Itco

/~~CCr/Ir/- /Vecu7.oui s n.lt I/Ir~rt-.,]

Q-0/JLS'!C.'4f.l~ltCD /3F.TJIN':I/

uOC~S 3 n/.CO @

.)'- /Pet//C '.Ifl7s-R I (l I

I DFVi'/lllr //r't.l/Ir R

'I If'}

>- rl)'i r

34!C/I'OR Ite It) 8

~ 1l~

i

'))

i~ y.

d),

-I::-

yP).3

)

~

.CJ/

I I

'ry l'eal r

ss 'srs la' le I

~I I

l

).IJ

~.

.II>>

I('!

e

).J. ~

~

gs c'$C:> 0~1 1<0t+fQ err)

I'I~

~ ~.

I rr rr i C

I sX. rl II/I'>s

~

))

'.131'P)Vt'pej Qt j.lLjI js I4.') I jlli-.. 'l C'I:(>'. ( ) ~(l.t

, " f

~ )

/

.: 1/ '7 il, *J "7(/4.J,(/ ',

7,

~

,I ~ isl,li I.<IIYUel I'l.~IIIIII I.:Sl I

.C:.iel.;'l, I ~>

Pl00r',

I)I 'lI I

~

.<I Pup I

(/D')

rII

~Z ss

~ rr' p 4 I

'l [

rir.,

I

~ ~ ~ I

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~

~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ I ~

~ ~

s ~ ~ ~

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ I

~ ~

~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ s II ~ ~ II~

~ ~ ~

~ I ~ ~

~

~ ~ I~, III~

~ ~I

~ I ~III~ I

~ SI ~

~I ~ ~ ~ I ~ ~

~ ~ I I ~ ~II~ ~ ~ II II~ ~ ~

~ ~ I 1 ~ ~ ~

~ ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

~ ~ I ~ ~ SI

~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~II

~ ~ ~

~ I~ ~ I~ ~ I

~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I s

~ ~

~ ~

~

~ ag)

J

~

~

I 1,

C

~

'V

~

~

Ilt f

~

~

w

~

~'

G'

. 4 ? ?

~

y r

~

~

~

Y

~

~

~ ~ <<U I

P tI I 'lr<<'

~

I ~

~ ~

IP ~

~ ~I'C IX3 T

CIP CEI ARCS J I.'C1' t -n I'

P 1'l.

L C<<

I '. X

$ ~

(V F

~ gh 3b:20 i C."-.'

e TC" ';- t.

0 ~ I fp 3

VOT

~ U't' r

~ dC VT '](:

')

~

F

~ 10

(-)

s l3 CT"," r '.LL ~

~ '

I

~

r r

f

~ ~

~

~

~

L "~0 C '.rC S

~~L.

gT tt

~ I

~

r

~ I Pr-."u IR=-a SI.'.CC

"~l'5

~ j74 L ""C LQC LDC

'1IC LDC LDC

"II SP LACi "Irti ROT R O'T P

C

~ '.';I.

r-r<<TS F=S: '.c

=c'S c

rQ APL

~ 0 Ill

= F 00.'6 ar.

TS

':1(

~

g P

1 G,1

(

D2(

g (

hr (

g CC 5 w.

1 e

1) s 2) e

<<)

s

<<)

T

>>)

T A)i THC" 3/]6"

~ ]

'"XP=- C ~ P '

~

0 1

~

~

C.".Dc. =

SC=15

"-;D =1 rl7 31S 7 COOT.'w=

05 AT'=

rtr p~

~ P

~<<FP r S I 1

000

~

~ 15~

~ LBS /~T-"~. 1i

<<I

'I I'

~

0-4, 7

0 1

~ 9

',1" j s}.

S.T F=?

T}'I= ~

~ l T

~ L o TQf i LiC

~ li O,IIa

~ <<r'I

/ f P

I<<

~

I I g

I)

~

I.'

I. D

~ '

I

~ I, T I'I g ~

~ -.] =. ]

4T 'SS

~T 1=3'!9 2. -4

/. 1= '

1i C1SL e 0

1

~

I ~

0"1 ~

(I-I ~ "

'1 <<

4

~ ~ J r ~

TIi:I

'1 T

'I

~

~.

~ i 1

=

~ ".IO}; ~ (.aS /FT=f'n'-'=.'.

~

=i ol ~

= ~ 154 q 1'. ) /F T=D ~ ] e

d'

~

'1

~

~

t

~

~

~

~ e e

0

]

~

'I/w r

~

(

~

~

a ~

'I w v

I

~ ~

rea 1p e e<<J t B ~ j

~rS V".6'

-l r

~

~

"-'S S

~

r r r, \\>7

"-'-'HDi-"S

". CT

-I C = ~ r ~ 1 <.":(: '

JI )

J:1;I:4 a

"'!:P.:"SS

+<<v 4 v I>al>

~l I

~

e a A e <<(

r ~

I

~

~

'a

~

~

~

I r

r.. I-.wr C.'

ta

~ '

VrPT ~

~ r

'o 'Li \\

~ lr7 J

~

1 i 3 (..";~-4 )

e 4 ~ r

\\ v e

~

~

I v" ~

4 I

e" C'7 1

r e

1 r

r r

~

1 1 e+

~

~ 7

~

~

ra

~'

e Vo C.

e

~

e J '- ~

IJ 4 S

c. 4 e

<<ltt';.

4 a

oe o 'l

'o T C

o

~

P

'7 I! C I'<<'a Ih

iS i

~

~

p ra >r

~ ~

'o<<> ' 'I e' S.

CTR o]: rr t.

r t Cl ~

6-'>la YO V.

7 r

"0< ii.'L1Z-'T]0 t'SG I. ~

g<,c i:>;

I:

(e 1

1

~ ~

a

~

~ I <<

T l U>..T

~

~a

>e

~ I e

I

~,r'I I

~

ge r

~

~

1

~5 1 C

e e

I r

~

C.

'a J

~

~

~

~ 01 'i

~ 023-'

0133F f p

~

I 7 o 4

~

~

~

~ C.

~ i'- f

~ i>I Oa f JC'.1

.137" f

~ 14>7}

~

~ '

r

~

1 <<<<4 a t r',

~

~ v<<

1'

~

r'

~

5> P

~.ia.

4

~

~ 222 c;

~

a

~ r <<J~f

~.CC>O I

~ '5 4

~ <<I <r

~ 7' rv

~ ri ~

>7 C

~ DC 2l3]

3 ~ I:Ct r'

<

~

c4,I 7

~

~

~

~ r ~ v>I

'1>

I

~ 00

(. ~

1

~ 37'

~ r,7

~ 76

'37 f 1

~ 1 M 1

~

aJ

~

'I 4 ~ 4 I 21 "..-i

]~r'

~ I l g

~

' '1 1 2 ~

4 ~

Ce'I I.

J

~

o a>

l 1 ~ 3v 1,

~

~

~

'r a"

~

~

~ >'. I

~ I

~ 5 o

e'.

~ ]

~ r

~'

4 I.

~.,r <<el c'.

~.,

~

- I

~

CJ 4

~

~

~ ~

~

7 J

~

I

~

)

>5 ri~ 1 Il r

ra

~

o! Cttf 4

e'

~

'5 o 1

~

~ I

~ lb

~ 7 I

'1

~

~

~ I 1

~

7

~ I

~

~

C r

~ 4

~

a

~

4 I

~, it ]

~ 'r IJ

>5 lr f

~\\

e

~ ] <4:f

~ ]<<JDf

~ '75;f

~

'7 05

~

~ 0".'

f

~ lt 1'

~

~ ]4l.v f

~ ]

~ I'5

~

~

4 l'

71>o

~

~ > <<'

~

~a ta A

~ r<<a

~ef ra

~

~ r I I

C