ML16078A412

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
NRC000236 - Crack Growth Rate Comparison - Eason Pathania Model to MRP Model- Excel Spreadsheet
ML16078A412
Person / Time
Site: Indian Point  Entergy icon.png
Issue date: 03/18/2016
From:
NRC/OGC
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
SECY RAS
References
RAS 51011, ASLBP 07-858-03-LR-BD01, 50-286-LR, 50-247-LR
Download: ML16078A412 (5)


Text

NRC000236 Submitted: March 18, 2016 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Ratio, E-Operating Effective CGR P/MRP, Temp, K YSU YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) YS(rcw,d,T) Tref deg da/dt da/dt da/dt (mm/s) Ratio, E- with Material CW Fract dose(dpa) deg C (MPam) (Mpa) YSI (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa) m (Mpa) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) C u v Temp Adj (mm/s) K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) with Margin P/MRP margin 304 0.2 0.45 319 3 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.01E-09 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54363E-07 1.69 0.01 304 0.2 0.45 319 5 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.44E-08 4.55 1.2E-06 8.4753E-09 3.60475E-07 1.70 0.04 304 0.2 0.45 319 7 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 3.34E-08 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.71655E-07 1.70 0.09 304 0.2 0.45 319 9 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 6.27E-08 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.88841E-07 1.70 0.16 304 0.2 0.45 319 10 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 8.16E-08 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 3.99944E-07 1.70 0.20 304 0.2 0.45 319 12 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.29E-07 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.27628E-07 1.70 0.30 304 0.2 0.45 319 14 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.90E-07 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63186E-07 1.71 0.41 304 0.2 0.45 319 16 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 2.65E-07 14.56 2.2E-05 1.5525E-07 5.0725E-07 1.71 0.52 304 0.2 0.45 319 18 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 3.56E-07 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.60407E-07 1.71 0.63 304 0.2 0.45 319 20 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.63E-07 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.2321E-07 1.71 0.74 304 0.2 0.45 319 22 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 5.88E-07 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96182E-07 1.71 0.84 304 0.2 0.45 319 24 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 7.31E-07 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.79818E-07 1.71 0.94 304 0.2 0.45 319 26 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 8.93E-07 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.74594E-07 1.71 1.02 304 0.2 0.45 319 28 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.08E-06 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.80964E-07 1.71 1.10 304 0.2 0.45 319 30 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.28E-06 27.3 0.000106 7.4737E-07 1.09937E-06 1.71 1.16 304 0.2 0.45 319 32 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.50E-06 29.12 0.000124 8.7823E-07 1.23023E-06 1.71 1.22 304 0.2 0.45 319 34 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.75E-06 30.94 0.000145 1.0219E-06 1.37395E-06 1.71 1.27 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Ratio, E-Operating Effective CGR P/MRP, Temp, K YSU YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) YS(rcw,d,T) Tref deg da/dt da/dt da/dt (mm/s) Ratio, E- with Material CW Fract dose(dpa) deg C (MPam) (Mpa) YSI (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa) m (Mpa) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) C u v Temp Adj (mm/s) K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) with Margin P/MRP margin 304 0.2 0.45 283 3 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.26E-09 1.79E-07 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54363E-07 0.54 0.00 304 0.2 0.45 283 5 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.54E-09 6.44E-07 4.55 1.2E-06 8.4753E-09 3.60475E-07 0.54 0.01 304 0.2 0.45 283 7 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.06E-08 1.50E-06 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.71655E-07 0.54 0.03 304 0.2 0.45 283 9 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.98E-08 2.81E-06 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.88841E-07 0.54 0.05 304 0.2 0.45 283 10 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.58E-08 3.65E-06 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 3.99944E-07 0.54 0.06 304 0.2 0.45 283 12 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.07E-08 5.77E-06 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.27628E-07 0.54 0.10 304 0.2 0.45 283 14 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 5.99E-08 8.48E-06 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63186E-07 0.54 0.13 304 0.2 0.45 283 16 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 8.36E-08 1.19E-05 14.56 2.2E-05 1.5525E-07 5.0725E-07 0.54 0.16 304 0.2 0.45 283 18 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.12E-07 1.59E-05 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.60407E-07 0.54 0.20 304 0.2 0.45 283 20 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.46E-07 2.07E-05 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.2321E-07 0.54 0.23 304 0.2 0.45 283 22 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.86E-07 2.63E-05 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96182E-07 0.54 0.27 304 0.2 0.45 283 24 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.31E-07 3.27E-05 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.79818E-07 0.54 0.30 304 0.2 0.45 283 26 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.82E-07 4.00E-05 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.74594E-07 0.54 0.32 304 0.2 0.45 283 28 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.40E-07 4.81E-05 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.80964E-07 0.54 0.35 304 0.2 0.45 283 30 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.04E-07 5.72E-05 27.3 0.000106 7.4737E-07 1.09937E-06 0.54 0.37 304 0.2 0.45 283 32 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.74E-07 6.72E-05 29.12 0.000124 8.7823E-07 1.23023E-06 0.54 0.39 304 0.2 0.45 283 34 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 5.52E-07 7.83E-05 30.94 0.000145 1.0219E-06 1.37395E-06 0.54 0.40 282.7778 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Ratio, E-Operating Effective CGR P/MRP, Temp, K YSU YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) YS(rcw,d,T) Tref deg da/dt da/dt da/dt (mm/s) Ratio, E- with Material CW Fract dose(dpa) deg C (MPam) (Mpa) YSI (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa) m (Mpa) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) C u v Temp Adj (mm/s) K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) with Margin P/MRP margin 304 0.2 15 319 3 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.53E-08 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54363E-07 6.46 0.04 304 0.2 15 319 5 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 5.49E-08 4.55 1.2E-06 8.4753E-09 3.60475E-07 6.48 0.15 304 0.2 15 319 7 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.27E-07 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.71655E-07 6.49 0.34 304 0.2 15 319 9 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 2.39E-07 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.88841E-07 6.49 0.62 304 0.2 15 319 10 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 3.11E-07 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 3.99944E-07 6.49 0.78 304 0.2 15 319 12 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.92E-07 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.27628E-07 6.50 1.15 304 0.2 15 319 14 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 7.23E-07 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63186E-07 6.50 1.56 304 0.2 15 319 16 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.01E-06 14.56 2.2E-05 1.5525E-07 5.0725E-07 6.51 1.99 304 0.2 15 319 18 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.36E-06 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.60407E-07 6.51 2.42 304 0.2 15 319 20 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.77E-06 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.2321E-07 6.51 2.83 304 0.2 15 319 22 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 2.24E-06 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96182E-07 6.52 3.22 304 0.2 15 319 24 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 2.79E-06 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.79818E-07 6.52 3.58 304 0.2 15 319 26 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 3.41E-06 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.74594E-07 6.52 3.90 304 0.2 15 319 28 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.10E-06 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.80964E-07 6.52 4.18 304 0.2 15 319 30 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.88E-06 27.3 0.000106 7.4737E-07 1.09937E-06 6.52 4.43 304 0.2 15 319 32 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 5.73E-06 29.12 0.000124 8.7823E-07 1.23023E-06 6.53 4.66 304 0.2 15 319 34 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 6.67E-06 30.94 0.000145 1.0219E-06 1.37395E-06 6.53 4.85 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Effective CGR da/dt Ratio, E-(mm/s) P/MRP, K da/dt da/dt with Ratio, E- with Material CW Fract dose(dpa) Temp C (MPam) YSU YSI YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) m YS(rcw,d,T) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) Tref C u v Temp Adj (mm/s) K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) Margin P/MRP margin 304 0.2 15 283 3 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.66E-09 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54E-07 1.97 0.01 304 0.2 15 283 5 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.67E-08 4.55 1.20E-06 8.4753E-09 3.6E-07 1.98 0.05 304 0.2 15 283 7 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.89E-08 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.72E-07 1.98 0.10 304 0.2 15 283 9 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 7.30E-08 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.89E-07 1.98 0.19 304 0.2 15 283 10 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 9.50E-08 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 4E-07 1.98 0.24 304 0.2 15 283 12 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.50E-07 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.28E-07 1.98 0.35 304 0.2 15 283 14 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.21E-07 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63E-07 1.98 0.48 304 0.2 15 283 16 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.08E-07 14.56 2.20E-05 1.5525E-07 5.07E-07 1.98 0.61 304 0.2 15 283 18 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.14E-07 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.6E-07 1.99 0.74 304 0.2 15 283 20 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 5.39E-07 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.23E-07 1.99 0.86 304 0.2 15 283 22 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 6.84E-07 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96E-07 1.99 0.98 304 0.2 15 283 24 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 8.51E-07 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.8E-07 1.99 1.09 304 0.2 15 283 26 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.04E-06 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.75E-07 1.99 1.19 304 0.2 15 283 28 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.25E-06 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.81E-07 1.99 1.28 304 0.2 15 283 30 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.49E-06 27.3 1.06E-04 7.4737E-07 1.1E-06 1.99 1.35 304 0.2 15 283 32 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.75E-06 29.12 1.24E-04 8.7823E-07 1.23E-06 1.99 1.42 304 0.2 15 283 34 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.03E-06 30.94 1.45E-04 1.0219E-06 1.37E-06 1.99 1.48 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Effective CGR da/dt (mm/s) Ratio, E-K da/dt with Ratio, E- P/MRP, Material CW Fract dose(dpa) Temp C (MPam) YSU YSI YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) m YS(rcw,d,T) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) Tref C u v Temp Adj da/dt K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) Margin P/MRP with margin 304 0.2 4 283 3 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.37E-09 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54E-07 1.43 0.01 304 0.2 4 283 5 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.21E-08 4.55 1.2E-06 8.4753E-09 3.6E-07 1.43 0.03 304 0.2 4 283 7 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.82E-08 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.72E-07 1.43 0.08 304 0.2 4 283 9 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 5.28E-08 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.89E-07 1.43 0.14 304 0.2 4 283 10 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 6.88E-08 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 4E-07 1.43 0.17 304 0.2 4 283 12 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.09E-07 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.28E-07 1.44 0.25 304 0.2 4 283 14 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.60E-07 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63E-07 1.44 0.34 304 0.2 4 283 16 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.23E-07 14.56 2.2E-05 1.5525E-07 5.07E-07 1.44 0.44 304 0.2 4 283 18 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.00E-07 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.6E-07 1.44 0.53 304 0.2 4 283 20 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.90E-07 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.23E-07 1.44 0.63 304 0.2 4 283 22 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.95E-07 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96E-07 1.44 0.71 304 0.2 4 283 24 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 6.16E-07 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.8E-07 1.44 0.79 304 0.2 4 283 26 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 7.53E-07 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.75E-07 1.44 0.86 304 0.2 4 283 28 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 9.06E-07 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.81E-07 1.44 0.92 304 0.2 4 283 30 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.08E-06 27.3 0.000106 7.4737E-07 1.1E-06 1.44 0.98 304 0.2 4 283 32 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.27E-06 29.12 0.000124 8.7823E-07 1.23E-06 1.44 1.03 304 0.2 4 283 34 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.47E-06 30.94 0.000145 1.0219E-06 1.37E-06 1.44 1.07 NRC000236 Submitted: March 18, 2016 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Ratio, E-Operating Effective CGR P/MRP, Temp, K YSU YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) YS(rcw,d,T) Tref deg da/dt da/dt da/dt (mm/s) Ratio, E- with Material CW Fract dose(dpa) deg C (MPam) (Mpa) YSI (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa) m (Mpa) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) C u v Temp Adj (mm/s) K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) with Margin P/MRP margin 304 0.2 0.45 319 3 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.01E-09 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54363E-07 1.69 0.01 304 0.2 0.45 319 5 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.44E-08 4.55 1.2E-06 8.4753E-09 3.60475E-07 1.70 0.04 304 0.2 0.45 319 7 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 3.34E-08 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.71655E-07 1.70 0.09 304 0.2 0.45 319 9 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 6.27E-08 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.88841E-07 1.70 0.16 304 0.2 0.45 319 10 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 8.16E-08 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 3.99944E-07 1.70 0.20 304 0.2 0.45 319 12 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.29E-07 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.27628E-07 1.70 0.30 304 0.2 0.45 319 14 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.90E-07 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63186E-07 1.71 0.41 304 0.2 0.45 319 16 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 2.65E-07 14.56 2.2E-05 1.5525E-07 5.0725E-07 1.71 0.52 304 0.2 0.45 319 18 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 3.56E-07 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.60407E-07 1.71 0.63 304 0.2 0.45 319 20 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.63E-07 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.2321E-07 1.71 0.74 304 0.2 0.45 319 22 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 5.88E-07 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96182E-07 1.71 0.84 304 0.2 0.45 319 24 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 7.31E-07 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.79818E-07 1.71 0.94 304 0.2 0.45 319 26 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 8.93E-07 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.74594E-07 1.71 1.02 304 0.2 0.45 319 28 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.08E-06 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.80964E-07 1.71 1.10 304 0.2 0.45 319 30 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.28E-06 27.3 0.000106 7.4737E-07 1.09937E-06 1.71 1.16 304 0.2 0.45 319 32 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.50E-06 29.12 0.000124 8.7823E-07 1.23023E-06 1.71 1.22 304 0.2 0.45 319 34 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 474.64397 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.75E-06 30.94 0.000145 1.0219E-06 1.37395E-06 1.71 1.27 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Ratio, E-Operating Effective CGR P/MRP, Temp, K YSU YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) YS(rcw,d,T) Tref deg da/dt da/dt da/dt (mm/s) Ratio, E- with Material CW Fract dose(dpa) deg C (MPam) (Mpa) YSI (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa) m (Mpa) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) C u v Temp Adj (mm/s) K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) with Margin P/MRP margin 304 0.2 0.45 283 3 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.26E-09 1.79E-07 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54363E-07 0.54 0.00 304 0.2 0.45 283 5 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.54E-09 6.44E-07 4.55 1.2E-06 8.4753E-09 3.60475E-07 0.54 0.01 304 0.2 0.45 283 7 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.06E-08 1.50E-06 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.71655E-07 0.54 0.03 304 0.2 0.45 283 9 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.98E-08 2.81E-06 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.88841E-07 0.54 0.05 304 0.2 0.45 283 10 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.58E-08 3.65E-06 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 3.99944E-07 0.54 0.06 304 0.2 0.45 283 12 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.07E-08 5.77E-06 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.27628E-07 0.54 0.10 304 0.2 0.45 283 14 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 5.99E-08 8.48E-06 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63186E-07 0.54 0.13 304 0.2 0.45 283 16 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 8.36E-08 1.19E-05 14.56 2.2E-05 1.5525E-07 5.0725E-07 0.54 0.16 304 0.2 0.45 283 18 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.12E-07 1.59E-05 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.60407E-07 0.54 0.20 304 0.2 0.45 283 20 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.46E-07 2.07E-05 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.2321E-07 0.54 0.23 304 0.2 0.45 283 22 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.86E-07 2.63E-05 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96182E-07 0.54 0.27 304 0.2 0.45 283 24 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.31E-07 3.27E-05 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.79818E-07 0.54 0.30 304 0.2 0.45 283 26 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.82E-07 4.00E-05 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.74594E-07 0.54 0.32 304 0.2 0.45 283 28 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.40E-07 4.81E-05 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.80964E-07 0.54 0.35 304 0.2 0.45 283 30 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.04E-07 5.72E-05 27.3 0.000106 7.4737E-07 1.09937E-06 0.54 0.37 304 0.2 0.45 283 32 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.74E-07 6.72E-05 29.12 0.000124 8.7823E-07 1.23023E-06 0.54 0.39 304 0.2 0.45 283 34 200 800 416 469.4881 0.000993 491.9168 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 5.52E-07 7.83E-05 30.94 0.000145 1.0219E-06 1.37395E-06 0.54 0.40 282.7778 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Ratio, E-Operating Effective CGR P/MRP, Temp, K YSU YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) YS(rcw,d,T) Tref deg da/dt da/dt da/dt (mm/s) Ratio, E- with Material CW Fract dose(dpa) deg C (MPam) (Mpa) YSI (Mpa) (Mpa) (Mpa) m (Mpa) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) C u v Temp Adj (mm/s) K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) with Margin P/MRP margin 304 0.2 15 319 3 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.53E-08 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54363E-07 6.46 0.04 304 0.2 15 319 5 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 5.49E-08 4.55 1.2E-06 8.4753E-09 3.60475E-07 6.48 0.15 304 0.2 15 319 7 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.27E-07 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.71655E-07 6.49 0.34 304 0.2 15 319 9 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 2.39E-07 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.88841E-07 6.49 0.62 304 0.2 15 319 10 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 3.11E-07 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 3.99944E-07 6.49 0.78 304 0.2 15 319 12 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.92E-07 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.27628E-07 6.50 1.15 304 0.2 15 319 14 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 7.23E-07 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63186E-07 6.50 1.56 304 0.2 15 319 16 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.01E-06 14.56 2.2E-05 1.5525E-07 5.0725E-07 6.51 1.99 304 0.2 15 319 18 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.36E-06 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.60407E-07 6.51 2.42 304 0.2 15 319 20 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 1.77E-06 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.2321E-07 6.51 2.83 304 0.2 15 319 22 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 2.24E-06 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96182E-07 6.52 3.22 304 0.2 15 319 24 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 2.79E-06 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.79818E-07 6.52 3.58 304 0.2 15 319 26 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 3.41E-06 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.74594E-07 6.52 3.90 304 0.2 15 319 28 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.10E-06 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.80964E-07 6.52 4.18 304 0.2 15 319 30 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 4.88E-06 27.3 0.000106 7.4737E-07 1.09937E-06 6.52 4.43 304 0.2 15 319 32 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 5.73E-06 29.12 0.000124 8.7823E-07 1.23023E-06 6.53 4.66 304 0.2 15 319 34 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 802.84979 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 1.345265 6.67E-06 30.94 0.000145 1.0219E-06 1.37395E-06 6.53 4.85 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Effective CGR da/dt Ratio, E-(mm/s) P/MRP, K da/dt da/dt with Ratio, E- with Material CW Fract dose(dpa) Temp C (MPam) YSU YSI YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) m YS(rcw,d,T) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) Tref C u v Temp Adj (mm/s) K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) Margin P/MRP margin 304 0.2 15 283 3 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.66E-09 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54E-07 1.97 0.01 304 0.2 15 283 5 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.67E-08 4.55 1.20E-06 8.4753E-09 3.6E-07 1.98 0.05 304 0.2 15 283 7 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.89E-08 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.72E-07 1.98 0.10 304 0.2 15 283 9 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 7.30E-08 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.89E-07 1.98 0.19 304 0.2 15 283 10 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 9.50E-08 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 4E-07 1.98 0.24 304 0.2 15 283 12 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.50E-07 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.28E-07 1.98 0.35 304 0.2 15 283 14 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.21E-07 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63E-07 1.98 0.48 304 0.2 15 283 16 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.08E-07 14.56 2.20E-05 1.5525E-07 5.07E-07 1.98 0.61 304 0.2 15 283 18 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.14E-07 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.6E-07 1.99 0.74 304 0.2 15 283 20 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 5.39E-07 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.23E-07 1.99 0.86 304 0.2 15 283 22 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 6.84E-07 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96E-07 1.99 0.98 304 0.2 15 283 24 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 8.51E-07 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.8E-07 1.99 1.09 304 0.2 15 283 26 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.04E-06 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.75E-07 1.99 1.19 304 0.2 15 283 28 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.25E-06 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.81E-07 1.99 1.28 304 0.2 15 283 30 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.49E-06 27.3 1.06E-04 7.4737E-07 1.1E-06 1.99 1.35 304 0.2 15 283 32 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.75E-06 29.12 1.24E-04 8.7823E-07 1.23E-06 1.99 1.42 304 0.2 15 283 34 200 800 416 797.4126 0.000618 820.90467 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.03E-06 30.94 1.45E-04 1.0219E-06 1.37E-06 1.99 1.48 Eason-Pathania Paper MRP-227-A Effective CGR da/dt (mm/s) Ratio, E-K da/dt with Ratio, E- P/MRP, Material CW Fract dose(dpa) Temp C (MPam) YSU YSI YSU(rcw) YS(rcw,d) m YS(rcw,d,T) C Q(J/mol) R (J/mol) Tref C u v Temp Adj da/dt K (ksiin) (in/hr) da/dt (mm/s) Margin P/MRP with margin 304 0.2 4 283 3 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.37E-09 2.73 3.35E-07 2.3634E-09 3.54E-07 1.43 0.01 304 0.2 4 283 5 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.21E-08 4.55 1.2E-06 8.4753E-09 3.6E-07 1.43 0.03 304 0.2 4 283 7 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.82E-08 6.37 2.79E-06 1.9655E-08 3.72E-07 1.43 0.08 304 0.2 4 283 9 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 5.28E-08 8.19 5.22E-06 3.6841E-08 3.89E-07 1.43 0.14 304 0.2 4 283 10 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 6.88E-08 9.1 6.79E-06 4.7944E-08 4E-07 1.43 0.17 304 0.2 4 283 12 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.09E-07 10.92 1.07E-05 7.5628E-08 4.28E-07 1.44 0.25 304 0.2 4 283 14 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.60E-07 12.74 1.58E-05 1.1119E-07 4.63E-07 1.44 0.34 304 0.2 4 283 16 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 2.23E-07 14.56 2.2E-05 1.5525E-07 5.07E-07 1.44 0.44 304 0.2 4 283 18 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.00E-07 16.38 2.95E-05 2.0841E-07 5.6E-07 1.44 0.53 304 0.2 4 283 20 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 3.90E-07 18.2 3.84E-05 2.7121E-07 6.23E-07 1.44 0.63 304 0.2 4 283 22 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 4.95E-07 20.02 4.88E-05 3.4418E-07 6.96E-07 1.44 0.71 304 0.2 4 283 24 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 6.16E-07 21.84 6.06E-05 4.2782E-07 7.8E-07 1.44 0.79 304 0.2 4 283 26 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 7.53E-07 23.66 7.41E-05 5.2259E-07 8.75E-07 1.44 0.86 304 0.2 4 283 28 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 9.06E-07 25.48 8.91E-05 6.2896E-07 9.81E-07 1.44 0.92 304 0.2 4 283 30 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.08E-06 27.3 0.000106 7.4737E-07 1.1E-06 1.44 0.98 304 0.2 4 283 32 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.27E-06 29.12 0.000124 8.7823E-07 1.23E-06 1.44 1.03 304 0.2 4 283 34 200 800 416 698.7787 0.000731 723.19013 2.90E-17 94,610 8.314 310 2.504 2.547 0.38776 1.47E-06 30.94 0.000145 1.0219E-06 1.37E-06 1.44 1.07