L-2014-113, Refueling Outage SL 1-25, Steam Generator Tube Inspection Special Report

From kanterella
(Redirected from ML14127A008)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Refueling Outage SL 1-25, Steam Generator Tube Inspection Special Report
ML14127A008
Person / Time
Site: Saint Lucie NextEra Energy icon.png
Issue date: 04/29/2014
From: Katzman E
Florida Power & Light Co
To:
Document Control Desk, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
L-2014-113
Download: ML14127A008 (23)
v • d • e


Text

0FPL.

April 29, 2014 L-2014-113 10 CFR 50.55a 10 CFR 50.36 U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Attn: Document Control Desk Washington, DC 20555 Re: St. Lucie Unit 1 Docket No. 50-335 Refueling Outage SL 1-25 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Special Report Attached is the St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification 6.9.1.12 steam generator tube inservice inspection special report for the Fall 2013 refueling outage (SL1-25). This submittal was made within 180 days after the initial entry into hot shutdown following the completion of the steam generator inspection that was performed in accordance with TS 6.8.4.1, Steam Generator (SG)

Program.

Please contact Ken Frehafer at (772) 467-7748 should you have any questions regarding this submittal.

Very truly yours, Eric S. Katzman Licensing Manager St. Lucie Plant ESK/KWF

Attachment:

St. Lucie Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SL1-25 Florida Power &Light Company 6501 S. Ocean Drive, Jensen Beach, FL 34957

L-2014-1 13 Attachment Page 1 of 22 Engineenng Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ- 14-002 Attachment I EC# 280879 Page 1 of 12 St. Lucie Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SL1-25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12

Background

This report is provided in accordance with St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification 6.9.1.12, "Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report" for the inspection conducted October 14-20, 2013 during the SL1-25 refueling outage . The SL1-25 outage designator is also commonly referred to as EOC-24 (End of the 2 4 h Fuel Cycle). SL1-25 was the tenth refueling outage following installation of the Babcock &

Wilcox Advanced Series PWR replacement steam generators (SGs) in 1997. At the SL1-25 refueling outage, the replacement SGs had accumulated approximately 13.85 EFPY (166.20 EFPM) of cumulative operation since replacement in 1997. Following the SL1-25 refueling outage, St. Lucie Unit 1 initially entered HOT SHUTDOWN (Mode 4) on November 1, 2013 @ 05:18, which marked the beginning of the SL1 -25 operating cycle. Therefore, the report is due to the NRC by May 01, 2014.

The SL1-25 SG tube inspections were conducted in both 'A' and 'B' SGs as described below and meet Technical Specification (TS) Section 6.8.4.1.d.2 inspection requirements for the first half of the second sequential period of 108 months.

a. The scope of inspections performed on each SG The scope of this examination is summarized in Table 1 below and is established to meet the following requirements:
a. Technical Specification 6.8.4.1 "Steam Generator (SG) Program"
b. Technical Specification 6.8.4.1.d.2 "Inspect 100% of the tubes at sequential periods of 144, 108, 72 and, thereafter, 60 effective full power months. The first sequential period shall be considered to begin after the first in-service inspection of the SGs. In addition, inspect 50% of the tubes by the refueling outage nearest the midpoint of the period and the remaining 50% by the refueling outages nearest the end of the period. No SG shall operate for more than 72 effective full power months or three refueling outages (whichever is less) without being inspected".
c. Steam Generator Management Program: Pressurized Water Reactor Steam Generator Examination Guidelines: Revision 7. EPRI, Palo Alto, CA: 2007. 1013706.

The basis for bobbin and +PointTM tube examinations is given in Table 1. Applicable industry qualified eddy current examination techniques are provided in Table 2.

Diagnostic rotating probe examinations (Special interest, SI) were completed as required based on the results of the bobbin coil.

Prior to starting the eddy current examination at the SL1-25 refueling outage in 2013, all of the previously installed hot-leg and cold-leg plugs in Steam Generator "A"and Steam Generator "B"were confirmed to be present in their correct locations and were confirmed to be free from degradation and visible signs of leakage based on the visual examination.

The plant TS requirement (TS Section 6.8.4.1.d.2) to inspect 50% of the tubes by the refueling outage nearest the midpoint of the 2nd 1SI period of 108 months has been satisfied by the October 2013 inspection.

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 2 of 22 Engineering Evaluation PSL.ENG-SESJ-14-002 Attachment I EC# 280879 Page 2 of 12 St. Lucie Unit I Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SLI-25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12 Secondary Side Inspections Secondary Side Inspections (SSI) and cleaning during the SL1-25 refueling outage were performed in SGs "A"and "B", and included the following:

  • Sludge Lancing
  • FOSAR (Includes post sludge lancing visual assessment and foreign object retrieval)

There are currently no known foreign objects remaining in the secondary side of the steam generators that require tracking.

Supplemental Primary Side Inspections to address Westinghouse NSAL 12-01 Issue

Description:

Visual inspection of the SGs at a foreign Westinghouse designed plant showed indications of degradation in the cladding and/or divider plate-to-channel head weld, with exposure and wastage of the channel head base material. Westinghouse issued NSAL 12-01 "Steam Generator Channel Head Degradation" on January 5, 2012 and included recommended actions for the visual inspection at other plants.

Although the degradation is not credible for St. Lucie Unit 1, a visual inspection of the primary side channel head bowl was performed in accordance with the requirements presented in Westinghouse NSAL 12-01.

Results:

Based on the visual inspections performed, no visible signs of degradation or other abnormal conditions were identified.

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 3 of 22 Engineering Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ-14-002 Attachment I EC# 280879 Page 3 of 12 St. Lucie Unit I Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SL1-25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12 Table 1 Basis for Tube Examinations Technique Examination Sample Required or Basis Degradation Supplemental Mechanism Required to satisfy SR(1) 100% full length of all active 4.4.5.1 and TS(2) section tubes in each SG Required 6.8.4.1.d.2 and to Wear Bobbin support 3 cycles between inspections Supplemental Screen all dings/dents < 5.0 (included as Pro-Active PWSCC volts in the freespan straight part of the (Per Degradation ODSCC lengths 100% full length Assessment) exam)

Supplemental BWI Bulletin No.DTF-Screen U-bends periphery (included as 61.1.00003 tubes for proximity of part of the Wear adjacent tubes 100% full length (OEM exam) Recommendation)

Tight radius u-bends Pro-Active PWSCC

  • 30% of Row 3 Supplemental (Per Degradation ODSCC
  • 30% of Row 2 Assessment) 50% of HL Dings/Dents > 5.0 Pro-Active PWSCC volts in the straight freespan Supplemental (Per Degradation ODSCC sections Assessment)

+PointTM All Dings/Dents in the u- Pro-Active bends and at HL tube Supplemental (Per Degradation PWSCC supports Assessment) ODSCC BWI Bulletin No. DTF-Test largest bobbin proximity 61.1.00003 indications in U-bend (OEM Recommendation)

Array All HL & CL expansion Probe transitions (+3.0" to -2.0)' in Pro-Active Foreign peripheral high (3) flow regions upplemental (Per FPL Procedure) Object Wear Notes:

(1) SR - Surveillance Requirement in the plant Technical Specification (TS)

(2) TS - Plant Technical Specification (3) "Peripheral high flow regions are defined to include the two outer-most tubes exposed to the annulus, all tubes in Rows 1 through 4 along the tube free lane, and the innermost two tubes adjacent to the outer circumference of the stay cylinder.

L-2014-1 13 Attachment Page 4 of 22 Engineering Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ-14-002 Attachment I EC# 280879 Page 4 of 12 St. Lucie Unit I Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SLI-25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1,12

b. Active degradation mechanisms found (Note 1)

The SL1-25 examination results for St. Lucie Unit 1 identified mechanical wear degradation at the following locations:

  • Fan bar and connector bar tube contact points in the u-bends
  • Horizontal lattice grid tube contact points There was no evidence of corrosion degradation during any of the SL1-25 examinations.

Note 1 : "Active Degradation" is a term used in the Steam Generator Technical Specifications and is synonymous with the term "Existing Degradation" used in EPRI Report 1019038 "Steam Generator Management Program:

Steam Generator Integrity Assessment Guidelines" Revision 3, dated November 2009.

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 5 of 22 Engineering Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ-14-002 Attachment I ECO 280879 Page 5 of 12 St. Lucie Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SLI -25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Tecluilcal Specification Section 6.9.1.12

c. Nondestructive examination techniques utilized for each degradation mechanism TABLE 2 Techniques Industry Damage Demonstrated Extended Site-Specific Review Technique Qualification Mechanism Applicability Applicability Detection SizinA 96004.1 1 Bobbin Revision 13 Wear Structures None Yes For Service 96004.2 Contingent 2 Bobbin Revision 13 Wear Structures None Yes Sizing of Wear Within non denied 3 Bobbin 1-28411 Axia ODSCC drilled TSP and within None Yes N/A Revision 3 drilled TSP with dents 5 2.0 Vpp.

Freespan with or 4 Bobbin 1-28412 Axial ODSCC without dents _ 2.0 None Yes N/A Revision 3 Vpp Within Freespan.

1-28413 Sludge Pile region and 5 Bobbin Reiso13 Axial ODSCC Broached TSP with or None Yes N/A without dents < 2.0 6 Bobbin 24013.1 Axial ODSCC Freespan. Dings None Yes N/A Revision 2 < 5.00 Volts Drilled and 10013.1 quatrefoilI tube 7 BobbinI Axial ODSCC support plates with None Yes N/A dents

_<5.00 Volts N/A - Use 27091.2 PL erPLP Wear PLP Wear Applicable ApspliSSafro gBobin 8Revision B01 (p.2 not present) IWhen Pa Present) yes ETSS from ReviionI War PPPP War LP earTechnique 21 Loose Part Tube to tube wear 9 Bobbin 27091.3 Volumetric Wear Freespan, PLP in the freespan or in Yes No Revision I (Part Not ar contact with art Present) (part present) adjacent tube 10 9603.1For

+PoinC' 96703. 17 Axial PWSCC Dent or Ding Freespan Yes CM/OA or tRevision lnfo Only Contingent Lattice Grids and Contingent 11 96910.1

+Point- Revision 10 Wear Broached Supports Fan Bars Yes sizing of wear

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 6 of 22 Engineering Evaluaton PSL-ENG-SESJ- 14-002 Attachment I EC# 280879 Page 6 of 12 St. Lucie Unit I Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SLI -25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12 Damage Demonstrated Extended Site-Specific Review Industry Detection Sizing Technique Qualification Mechanism Applicability Applicability For CM/OA or Info Only Dings, Dents, See EPRI 12 +Point- 1-11524 Ciuc Expansion Tubesheet and Non- Yes ETSS Revision 0 PWSCC Transition dented support 20510.1 for structures curve and sizing informatio n

13 +Point' 20511.1 Axial PWSCC Expsnsion Transition Non-dented support CM/GA Formtfo Revision 8 structure and Yes or Only tubesheet Contingent 14 +Point4 21998.1 R19so.1 Volumetric Freespan None Yes Sizing of Wear Dent / Ding 22401.1 Axial ODSCC Dented Support Freespan For CM/OA 15 +Point" Revision 4 Structures Dent or Info Only U-bend Freespan 21410.1 Dings. Dented and For CM/OA I6 +Pointr Revision 6 Circ ODSCC Expansion Transition Non-dented support Yes structures, Sludge or Info Only Pile, Tubesheet Sludge Pile; within non dented drilled R731-28424 Axial ODSCC TSP and within drilled For CM/OA Revision 3 TSP with dents (or Expansion Transition Yes or Info Only Dings)

_<2.0 Vpp.

Freespn. within non 18 +Point' 1-28425 3 Revision Axial ODSCC dented broached and within TSP broached Expansion Transition For CM/OA Yes or Info only TSP with dents (or Dings) _: 2.0 Vpp.

Sludge Pile and 1-28431 Drilled TSP with or For CM/OA 19 +Point"M Revision 2 Axial ODSCC without dents None Yes or Info only

___2.0Vpp FIree Span, eggcrates 1-28432 and broached TSP For CN/OA 20 + PotntT Revision 2 Axial ODSCC with or without dents None Yes or Info Only I 1 1 *_ý<2.0Vpp

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 7 of 22 Engineering Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ-14-002 Attachment I ECO 280879 Page 7 of 12 St. Lucie Unit I Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SLI -25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12 Industry Damage Demonstrated Extended Site-Specific Review Technique Qualification Mechanism Applicability Applicability Detection Sizing Detection of Foreign Material based on material and proximity of foreign material to the tube, 27901.1 based on EPRI reports 27902.1 Freespan, TSP and 1020631 and V101561.

27903.1 27904.1 Expansion Transition LP Wear For sizing of PLPYe Yes 21 +Point, 27904.1 PLP Wear Mphlogy wear when part is Yes When Part is 27906.1 Dependent present based on EPRI NOT present 27907.1 (part not present) Report 1020631 on an as needed basis.

(Al I Rev. 1) For sizing of Tube to Tube wear in the freespan or when in contact with an adjacent tube based on EFI 1020631 96511.2 Axial & Circ Low Row For CM/OA 22 +Point'T Revision 16 PWSCC U-bends None Yes orlnfo Only 10411.1 Ax and Circ and ODSCC, For CM/OA 23 +Point" 10411.2 Axial ODSCC U-bend Row 3-5 Row 2 & Higher Yes or Info Only Revision 0 Rowo-ndl

_____________ _______________ U-b en d a_____

Volumetric degradation IPLP Wear') at Top-of-Tubeshect and 20400.1 Freespan.

24 Array Revision 5 Circ ODSCC Expansion Transitions. Axial ODSCC at Yes N/A Expansion Transition Circ ODSCC Freespast with/without Deposits (including sludge pile)

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 8 of 22 Engineering Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ- 14-002 Attachment 1 EC# 280879 Page 8 of 12 St. Lucie Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SLI-25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12

d. Location orientation (if linear) and measured sizes (if available) of service induced indications INDICATION LISTINGS FOR SL1 -25 (EOC-24)

Indication Description Enclosure #

SG 1A Wear at Fan bar/connector bar locations 1-19%TWD Enc 1 (2 pages)

SG 1A Wear at Fan bar/connector bar locations 20-39%TWD Eric 2 (1 page)

SG 1A Wear at Horizontal lattice grid locations 1-19%TWD Enc 3 (1 page)

SG 1A Wear at Horizontal lattice grid locations 20-39%TWD Enc 4 (1 page)

SG 1B Wear at Fan bar/connector bar locations 1-19%TWD Eric 5 (2 pages)

SG 1 B Wear at Fan bar/connector bar locations 20-39%TWD Enc 6 (1 page)

SG 1B Wear at Horizontal lattice grid locations 1-19%TWD Enc 7 (1 page)

SG 1 B Wear at Horizontal lattice grid locations 20-39%TWD Enc 8 (1 page)

e. Number of tubes plugged during the inspection outage for each active degradation mechanism St. Lucie Unit I Tube Plugging EOC 24 (SLI -25)

Degradation Mechanism SG A SG B Total Wear at Fan Bar Support (FBS) tube 79(1) 51(1) 130 contacts (Preventive Plugging)

Wear at Connector Bar Support (CBS) 4(1) 1(1) tube contacts (Preventive plugging)

Total 83 52 135 Note 1) All tubes exhibiting wear at FBS and CBS structures (in the ubend region) were preventatively plugged to provide margin. No tubes required plugging per Plant Technical Specifications because no indications met or exceeded the Plant Technical Specification limit of a40% TW.

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 9 of 22 Engineenng Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ- 14-002 Attachment I ECO 280879 Page 9 of 12 St. Lucie Unit I Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SL1-25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12

f. Total number and percentage of tubes plugged to date St. Lucie Unit 1 Steam Generator Cumulative Tube Plugging Summary SL1-25 SG # Plugged  % Plugged 1A 97 1.14%

1B 53 0.62%

g. The results of condition monitoring, including the results of the tube pulls and in-situ testing All tubes satisfied the structural integrity and accident-induced leakage performance criteria based on the condition monitoring (CM) evaluation performed at EOC-24. No tubes required in-situ pressure testing for either tube burst or leakage. Therefore, all tubes met the structural and leakage integrity requirements of the St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specifications.

No tube pulls were warranted or implemented.

h. The effective plugging percentage for all plugging in each SG No tube repair methods (i.e. sleeving) are approved for St. Lucie Unit 1 that would have an effect on the effective plugging percentages. Therefore, the applicable effective plugging percentage is synonymous with the % Plugged in item f. above.

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 10 of 22 Engineering Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ- 14-002 Attachm ent I EC# 280879 Page 10 of 12 St. Lucie Unit I Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SLI -25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION The following information is included to assist the staff in their review of the information provided in this report.

Abbreviations and Acronyms EPRI Electric Power Research Institute CBS Connecter Bar Support CM Condition Monitoring FBS Fan Bar Support ISI In-service Inspection SG Steam Generator Outage Nomenclature EOC-24 End-of-Cycle 24 (Synonymous with SL1-25)

SL1-25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Operating Cycle 25 FIGURES Figure 1 provides a side view of the installed St. Lucie Unit 1 RSGs.

Figure 2 provides a view of the fan bar arrangement, connector bar location and the top (#7) lattice grid support locations.

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 11 of 22 Engineering Evaluation PSL-ENG-SESJ-14-002 Attachment I EC# 280879 Page 11 of 12 St. Lucie Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SL 1-25 St. Lucie Unit 1 Technical Specification Section 6.9.1.12 Figure 1 B&W Advanced Series PWR Replacement Steam Generators (RSG)

BWI-222-7698-FIV- I FPL St. Lucie I Replacement Steam Generator

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 12 of 22 Epnee-,g E*hatim PSL-EDtGSESJ- 14-002 Attachmai 1 EC 28079 Page 12 df 12 St. Lucie Unit 1 Steam Generator Tube Inspection Report for SLI-25 St. Lucie Unit I Techmical Specification Section 6.9.1.12 Figure 2 Detailed Fan Bar View Lafi d o e 7 Lattice Grid Cold Legq 0CC

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 13 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 11:49:06 Customer Name: St Lucie Unit I Component: S/G A Page 1 of 2 Bobbin Fan/Connector Bar %TW Indications: 1-19%

QUERY: QueryMl .qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION 71 10'0 15 F05 +0.91 71 112 11 F06 -1.70 73 94 10 F06 -1.41 75 92 7 F09 -2.39 77 58 12 FPO -1.17 77 92 17 F09 -2.30 79 92 13 F09 -2.30 81 92 11 F04 -1.92 81 98 9 F06 -0.68 83 64 14 F06 +0.86 84 99 15 F06 +1.33 88 93 12 F04 -0.51 90 93 9 F05 -1.61 91 78 17 CBC +i1.78 92 77 10 CBC +0.42 94 93 8 F06 +0.90 95 92 16 F09 -2.05 96 95 9 F06 -1.73 97 92 11 F09 -2.12 98 77 11 CBC +0.53 99 72 11 F04 -0.77 13 F05 -0.97 9 F07 +0.62 9 F08 -1.02 99 78 16 CBC +1.92 99 106 14 F05 -1.02 100 101 11 F04 +1.21 100 105 12 F06 -1.02 12 F07 -1 .30 13 F08 -1.10 102 99 13 F04 -1.21 16 F05 -1.15 9 F07 -1 .08 9 F08 -1 .79 102 111 8 P06 -1.08 103 84 10 F05 +0.57 103 92 12 F09 -1.99 104 73 11 F05 +1 .26 105 84 13 FlO +0.73 105 106 11 F05 -1.21 106 83 12 F06 +1.23 14 FO5 -0.99 107 58 11 FO5 +0.82 107 62 8 F05 +1.28 107 92 8 F09 -1.84 107 94 8 F05 -0.63 107 100 12 F05 -1.08 10 FOB -0.57 107 106 12 F05 +1.31 108 55 7 F06 +1.64 109 122 13 F05 +1.54 110 67 14 F07 -1.11 14 F08 -0.64 110 101 10 F06 -1.01 110 103 7 F05 -1.34 111 94 16 F07 +1.39 112 71 9 F05 +0.91 112 73 16 FO5 +1.04 12 F07 -1.04 15 F08 -1.22 112 79 15 F05 +0.42 9 F04 +0.35 10 F07 +0.11 112 93 8 F04 +1.08 8 F05 +1.10 14 F07 -1.27 12 F08 -1.23 111 98 19 F06 -0.74 14 F06 +1.08 113 102 6 FO4 -0.55 12 F05 -1.25 15 F06 +1.23 7 F07 +0.70 8 F08 +0.71 114 67 10 F04 +1.13 9 F05 -I1.02 10 F07 -1.22 114 75 17 P06 -0.94 115 74 15 F04 -0.33 8 F05 -0.35

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 14 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 11:49:06 Customer Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G A Page 2 of 21 Bobbin Fan/Connectot Bar %TW Indications: 1-19%

QUERY: QueryMl.qLy ROW COL %TW LOCATION 11 F06 +0.02 115 78 12 FIO +2.09 115 82 15 F05 +0.97 115 84 11 F05 +0.11 115 92 11 F04 -1.11 13 F05 +0.96 14 F06 +1.20 115 96 9 F05 +1.21 17 F06 +1.24 12 F08 +1.39 10 F09 +1.39 116 65 12 F05 +1.22 116 97 17 F03 +1.22 9 F05 +1.19 6 F06 -1.11 116 105 14 F06 -1.08 119 58 10 F06 -0.70 119 60 14 F05 -1.17 119 76 11 F03 -0.13 119 92 9 F05 -0.53 120 63 11 F02 -1.06 12 F03 -1.19 19 F05 41.15 120 71 16 F06 +0.91 11 F08 -1.57 120 75 7 F08 -1.88 121 100 12 F08 +1.17 122 65 11 F05 +1.17 18 F06 -1.00 10 F09 -2.32 122 73 8 F04 -1.55 12 F08 -1.24 8 F08 +1.19 122 101 10 F06 -1.10 124 71 13 F04 +1.66 12 F06 -1.22 10 F07 -1.19 13 F07 +1.22 11 £08 -1.06 12 £08 +1.37 126 63 10 F05 +1.15 16 F06 -1.04 10 F07 -1.06 127 70 14 F06 +0.39 12 F08 -0.83 128 51 10 FI£ +0.51 128 65 10 F06 -1.04 13 F08 -1.28 9 £04 +1.26 9 £05 +1.50 128 71 14 F09 +1.17 12 £04 +1.62 128 73 14 F03 +1.22 16 F05 +0.93 11 F06 +1.17 15 F07 -1.35 15 F08 -1.37 131 94 13 F04 +1.34 18 £06 +1.41 11 F02 -0.46 9 F03 +1.45 132 71 12 F04 +1.30 18 F06 -1.02 133 84 17 F04 +0.00 12 F06 +0.11 17 F07 +0.11 15 F08 -0.02 Total Tubes  : 83 Total Records: 147

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 15 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 11:50:16 Customer Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G A Page I of 1 Bobbin Fan/Connector Bar %TW Indications: 20-39%

QUERY: QueryMl.qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION 120 63 24 F06 -1.13 23 F07 -1.15 122 65 25 F07 -1.11 24 F08 -0.93 122 73 23 F07 -1.22 128 71 21 F07 -1.39 21 FOS +1.46 128 73 23 F04 -1.02 131 94 22 F07 +1.36 132 71 20 F07 -1.17 133 84 23 F05 +0.07 Total Tubes  : 8 Total Records: 11

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 16 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 13:03:39 Cu*tomer Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G A Page 1 of 1 Bobbin Lattice Grid %TW Indications: 1-19%

QUERY: QueryMl.qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION 64 11 14 04C -1.51 97 144 11 01C -1.52 107 138 11 02C -1.43 116 37 12 06H -0.70 139 74 12 03H -0.79 Total Tubes  : 5 Total Records: 5

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 17 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 11:57:29 Customer Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G A Page 1 of 1 Bobbin Lattice GrAd %TW Indications: 20-39%

QUERY: QueryMi.qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION 97 144 21 02C -1.55 Total Tubes  : 1 Total Records: 1

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 18 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 12:04:32 Custonler Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G B Page 1 of 2 Bobbin Fan/Connector Bar %TW: 1-19%

QUERY: QueryMl[l] .qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION 27 68 13 CEH +1.17 28 5 11 F05 +2.16 59 86 9 F05 +1.28 73 68 13 F05 -1.12 72 94 8 F06 -0.75 75 110 12 F06 -1.32 78 91 8 F05 -1.75 79 66 9 F07 +2.03 81 76 7 F06 +1.25 81 102 11 F04 -1.70 84 81 10 F06 +1.13 8 F07 +1.15 86 93 9 F05 -1.58 92 75 9 F04 -1.55 97 74 11 F06 +0.80 97 144 6 F05 +1.36 39 92 10 F06 -1.73 101 72 9 F08 +1.34 101 100 10 F05 -0.92 103 90 11 F05 -1.14 105 74 9 F06 +0.68 109 64 8 F07 +2.7C 109 68 11 F04 -1.41 110 67 11 F05 +1.29 10 F07 -1.11 110 87 7 F05 -1.78 110 91 8 F06 -1.29 112 65 8 F04 +1.56 12 F08 -1.36 113 70 30 F05 -1.05 114 51 10 F05 -1.32 114 69 10 F05 +1.08 12 F08 -1.23 114 77 8 F04 +1.85 9 F05 +1.67 116 77 10 F03 +1.78 117 94 11 F04 -1.17 10 F05 -1.06 121 72 11 F06 +1.23 8 F08 -1.56 123 68 11 F05 -1.03 11 F06 +1.25 9 F07 +1.12 17 F08 +1.30 123 74 12 F07 -1.17 9 F09 -0.62 123 98 14 F04 +1.19 124 77 8 F03 +1.84 125 72 9 F08 -1.06 126 71 10 FO8 -1.17 126 73 10 F04 +1.72 9 F05 +1.77 11 F07 -1.30 11 F09 +1.94 126 77 12 F08 +1.23 128 63 7 F03 +1.81 129 64 13 F07 +0.02 129 68 19 F07 +0.97 130 63 7 F05 +1.81 130 75 8 F02 +1.67 11 F03 +1.59 16 F04 +1.01 7 F05 +1.81 11 F07 -1.17 17 F08 -1.17 130 95 11 F08 -0.82 132 69 12 F04 -0.92 8 F05 +1.12 14 F06 -0.99 17 F07 -0.99 16 F£0 +1.30 9 F09 +1.14 132 73 16 F05 +1.08 17 F07 +1.38 12 F08 +1.32 17 F09 +1.36 134 77 12 F03 +1.87 17 F05 +1.45 14 F07 +1.28 10 F01 -1.69

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 19 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 12:04:-2 Customer Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G B Page 2 of 2 Bobbin Fan/Connector Bar %TW: 1-19%

QUERY: QueryMI [(] .qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION 136 73 14 F08 +1.63 15 F07 +1.39 10 FOG +1.61 10 F05 +1.67 137 102 7 F02 +0.60 Total Tubes  : 52 Total Records: 85

L-2014-113 Attachment Page 20 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 12:05:02 Customer Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G B Page I of 1 Bobbin Fan/Connector Bar %TW: 20-39%

QUERY: QueryMl[l] .qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION 134 77 24 F04 +1.25 Total Tubes  : 1 Total Records: 1

L-2014-1 13 Attachment Page 21 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 12:06:13 Customer Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G B Page 1 of 1 Bobbin Lattice Grid %TW: 1-19%

QUERY: QueryMl[l] .qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION 1 146 10 06C -1.47 2 127 11 05C +0.67 97 144 7 05H +1.47 107 138 12 05H +1.45 133 60 12 020 -1.51 139 92 17 04H -1.52 Total Tubes  : r Total Records: 6

L-2014-113 Attachment Page.22 of 22 AREVA NP Inc 03/28/14 12:05:45 Customer Name: St Lucie Unit 1 Component: S/G B Page 1 of 1 Bobbin Lattice Grid %TW: 20-39%

QUERY: QueryMI[l] .qry ROW COL %TW LOCATION Total Tubes  : 0 Total Records: 0

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=L-2014-113,_Refueling_Outage_SL_1-25,_Steam_Generator_Tube_Inspection_Special_Report&oldid=2452801"