ML13322A224
| ML13322A224 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Palo Verde, San Onofre, 05000000 |
| Issue date: | 03/10/1987 |
| From: | Rubin S NRC/AEOD |
| To: | Knighton G Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML13322A223 | List: |
| References | |
| AEOD-T702, IEIN-82-19, NUDOCS 8704270149 | |
| Download: ML13322A224 (2) | |
Text
VAR 1 0 1981 AEOD/
MEMORANDUM FOR:
George W. Knighton, Project Director T702 Project Directorate #7 Division of PWR Licensing B Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM:
Stuart D. Rubin, Chief Reactor Operations Analysis Branch Office for Analysis and Evaluation of Operational Data
SUBJECT:
POSTULATED COMMON MODE FAILURE OF SAFETY-RELATED CHARGING PUMPS AT SAN ONOFRE UNITS 2 AND 3 Enclose Ifor-yourinformationi-s=an-AEOD-lechnical Review Repor-t-entitled-
"Leaking Pulsation Dampener Leads to Loss of Charging System."
In this report, three events of a loss of charging pump suction at the Palo Verde Nuclear Generating Station are discussed. In two of the events, a failed rubber bladder in the gas-filled pulsation dampener of a positive displacement pump led to all three positive displacement pumps becorring gas-bound through their common suction header. The positive displacement pumps at Palo Verde and most other CE plants are not safety-related. A subsequent investigation concluded that a postulated similar failure of the pulsation dampener at Westinghouse plants with positive displacem-ent pumps would not affect the safety-related charging pumps in the charging system.
This is because Westinghouse plants vent the relief valves on the positive displacement pump discharge line to the volume control tank rhile CE plants route the relief valve discharge to the coron suction header of the charging pumps.
Also, IE Information Notice F2-19 discussed the failure of a suction stabilizer (identified as a suction dampener in the notice) at a Westinghouse plant which led to the common mnde failure of all charging pumps due to gas binding.
The enclosed report covers the additional potential for common mode failure of charging systems at CE plants due to leaking pulsation dampeners.
It was noted in this report that the safety-related charging system at San Onofre Units 2 and 3 was similar to the norsafety-related charging system at Palo Verde in regard to both the positive displacement charging pumps and their associated pulsation dampeners. Thus, the report concludes that a similar rupture of the bladder of the gas-filled pulsation dampener could lead tc the common mode failure of the safety-related charging system at only these two units.
Because the type of failure observed at Palo Verde only potentially affects a safety-related charging system at these two CE units, the study is being forwarded to you for your information and use as you may deem appro priate.
B1O~tOC~~S7031%
-2 No specific action or written response to this memorandum is requested. If you or your staff should have any questions regarding this matter, please do not hesitate to contact Ted Cintula (x24434) of my staff.
Stuart D. Rubin, Chief Reactor Operations Analysis Branch Office for Analysis -and Evaluation of Operational Data
Enclosure:
As stated cc:
H. Rood, NRR
-M.
- Beaumont, W
C. Brinkman, CE R. Borsum, B&W L. Gifford, GE DISTRIBUTION:
cPDR AEOD SF ROAB CF TCintula PBaranowsky JS~u bin KB1ack WLanning CJHeltemes FHebdon TGuynn, OCM JHSniezek, DEDROGR OFC
- Ro
- ROAiae :ROAB :BC
- AEODDD NAME :TCintula
- PBa wsky :SRubin
- FHdon DATE :3/.3/87
- 3/3 /87
- 3/
/87
- 3/q /87 OFFICIAL RECORD COPY