ML13070A069

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Appeal - Please Review
ML13070A069
Person / Time
Site: 05523694
Issue date: 10/03/2012
From:
NRC/RGN-II
To:
References
55-23694-SP
Download: ML13070A069 (1)


Text

From:

Muller, David Sent:

Wednesday, October 03, 2012 3:34 PM To:

Jackson, Donald

Subject:

Vogtle Appeal - please review Attachments:

VogtleSROSimscenappeal2012 rev 1.docx

Don, Another rough draft, and I have NOT put in your recommended changes yet. But I did modify the grading a bit:

Scenario 5 Event 5: EHC pump trip now has two errors for RF 1.d and RF 5.c Scenario 3 Event 4: PZR PT failure now has 4 errors associated with it (up from 3). Added a hit for RF 1.c.

At the very back, Scenario 7 Event 5 (PZR PT failure and as the OATC she failed to close the PORV) this has now become a missed critical task.

Please contact Jack McHale with any issues and if you are OK with the overall grading (I know there are some cosmetics fix), pass on to Region II.

Dave (out of the office until Tuesday)