ML13056A520

2013-02- Exam Performance Analysis

ML13056A520
Person / Time
Site:	Columbia
Issue date:	02/12/2013
From:	Hettel W Energy Northwest
To:	Garchow S Operations Branch IV
Laura Hurley
References
50-397/13-002 GO2-13-023
Download: ML13056A520 (23)

Text

~ENERGY W. Grover Hettel Columbia Generating Station P.O. Box 968, PE23

'-'NORTHWEST Richland, WA 99352-0968 Ph. 509.377.83111 F. 509.377.4150 wghettel@energy-northwest.com February 12, 2013 G02-13-023 Stephen Garchow U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region IV 1600 East Lamar Boulevard Arlington, TX 76011-4511

Subject:

COLUMBIA GENERATING STATION, DOCKET NO. 50-397 INITIAL LICENSE EXAMINATION DOCUMENTATION

Dear Mr. Garchow:

Attached is the written examination performance analysis documentation as delineated in ES-501, C.1 for the SRO and RO examinations that were given at Columbia Generating Station on February 1, 2013, and a revised copy of Simulator Job Performance Measure (JPM) g administered on February 6,2013.

Specifically, the following materials are enclosed as attachments:

1) Written exam performance analysis for questions missed by half or more of the applicants.

2) Written exam performance analysis for the applicant scoring within 2% of 80% overall.

3) Written exam performance analysis for the applicant scoring within 4% of 70% on the SRO-only portion of the exam and within 2% of 80% overall.

4) Documentation to support a change to the SRO-only written examination answer key for question SRO-86.

5) A revision to Simulator JPM g providing clarification to JPM steps 5, 6, 12, and 13.

The Examination Security Agreement, ES-201-3, will be faxed to you as soon as all post examination signatures are complete.

INI1"IAL LICENSE EXAMINA"nON DOCUMENTATION Page 2 of 2 No new regulatory commitments are made in this letter.

If you require additional information, please contact K. P. Smart, Manager, Operations Training, at (509) 377-8327.

Respectfully, LJ-4---~ ___

w. G. Hettel Vice President, Operations

Attachment:

Exam Deficiency Analysis cc: w/o attachments NRC Region IV Administrator NRC Senior Resident Inspector/988C NRC NRR Project Manager AJ Rapacz - BPAl1399

Attachment 1 2013 NRC Written Examination Periormance Analysis Category: Questions missed by half or more of the applicants.

Question Periormance Question Training Issue or Comments Data Issue? knowledge

~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~-~~~ ~

deficiency?

RO-24 A: 2 No. Yes. Not No specific learning objective for KA 295013 8:5 specifically AA2.02. TREQ 13-0034 generated to address C: 5 trained. the issue. Knowledge deficiency will be 0: 1 corrected in gap training.

RO-32 A: 1 No. Yes. Knowledge Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B:7 deficiency. deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 5 0:0 RO-45 A: 6 No. Yes. Knowledge Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B: 1 deficiency. deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:5 0: 1 A: 1 No. Yes. Knowledge Covered in initial training program. Knowledge SRO-78 B:4 deficiency. deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 3 0:0 Page 1 of 2

Attachment 1 A: 1 No. Yes. General Covered in initial training program. Corrected SRO-80 8:4 misunderstanding. misunderstanding during the exam review.

C: 0 D:3 SRO-86 A: 3 Yes. Keyed Yes. Knowledge See Attachment 4 for an explanation of the 8:2 answer (8) is deficiency. question issue. Knowledge deficiency will be C:O incorrect. corrected in gap training.

0:3 A:O No. Yes. Knowledge Covered in initial training program. Knowledge SRO-89 8:4 deficiency. deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:4 0:0 Page 2 of 2

Attachment 2 2013 NRC Written Examination Performance Analysis Category: Applicant (Docket 55-42481) scoring within 2% of 80% overall.

Question Performance Question Training Issue or Comments Data Issue? knowledge deficiency?

A:2 No. Yes. Selected A. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-2 8:0 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:O deficiency.

D: 11 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-5 8:9 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:3 deficiency.

D: 0 A:4 No. Yes. Selected A. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-6 8:9 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 0 deficiency.

D:O A: 1 No. Yes. Selected D. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-23 8:11 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:O deficiency.

D: 1 Page 1 of 3

Attachment 2 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-32 B:7 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 5 deficiency.

0:0 A:3 No. Yes. Selected A. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-35 B: 10 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:O deficiency.

0:0 RO-41 A:O No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B:2 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 11 deficiency.

0:0 RO-45 A: 6 No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:5 deficiency.

D: 1 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected A. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-47 B: 12 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:O deficiency.

0: 0 A:4 No. Yes. Selected A. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-52 8:0 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 8 deficiency.

D: 1 Page 2 of 3

Attachment 2 RO-58 A: 9 No. Yes. Selected O. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 1 deficiency.

0:2 A:3 No. Yes. Selected A. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-65 B: 10 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:O deficiency.

0:0 A:O No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-66 B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 11 deficiency.

0: 1 A:O No. Yes. Selected O. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-75 B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 9 deficiency.

0: 3 Page 3 of 3

Attachment 3 2013 NRC Written Examination Performance Analysis Category: Applicant (Docket 55-42469) scoring within 4% of 70% on the SRO-only portion of the exam and within 2% of 80% overall.

Question Performance Question Training Issue or Comments Data Issue? knowledge deficiency?

A:2 No. Yes. Selected A. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-2 B:O Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 0 deficiency.

D: 11 ---------- ~-

RO-9 A: 9 No. Yes. Selected D. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B:O Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:2 deficiency.

0:3 RO-17 A: 9 No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B:O Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:2 deficiency.

0:2 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-32 B:7 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 5 deficiency.

0:0 Page 1 of 4

Attachment 3 RO-37 A: 9 No. Yes. Selected O. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge I B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:O deficiency.

0:3 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-39 B:O Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 1 deficiency.

0: 11 RO-45 A: 6 No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:5 deficiency.

0: 1 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-50 B:4 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 8 deficiency.

0:0 RO-52 A:4 No. Yes. Selected O. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B:O Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:8 deficiency.

0: 1 RO-58 A: 9 No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 1 deficiency.

D:2 Page 2 of 4

Attachment 3 A: 2 No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-61 B:9 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 1 deficiency.

0: 1 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge RO-62 B:3 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:2 deficiency.

0:7 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge SRO-78 B:4 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 3 deficiency.

0:0 SRO-82 A:O No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 7 deficiency.

0:0 A: 0 No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge SRO-83 B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 1 deficiency.

0: 6 A: 3 Yes. Keyed No. Selected A, See Attachment 4 for an explanation of the SRO-86 B: 2 answer (B) is which is the question issue.

C:O incorrect. correct answer.

0:3 Page 30t 4

Attachment 3 SRO-88 A: 1 No. Yes. Selected A. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B: 1 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 6 deficiency.

0:0 SRO-89 A:O No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B:4 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C:4 deficiency.

0:0 SRO-96 A: 6 No. Yes. Selected B. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B:2 Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 0 deficiency.

0:0 SRO-97 A:O No. Yes. Selected C. Covered in initial training program. Knowledge B:O Knowledge deficiency will be corrected in gap training.

C: 1 deficiency.

0:7 Page 4 of 4

Attachment 4 2013 I\IRC Exam Proposed Answer Key Change Question SRO-86 Columbia is operating at 100% power with a calibration of SGT-SUM-1 B2 (SGT Fan 1B2 Summer Circuit) in progress. Secondary Containment differential pressure is being maintained by Reactor Building HVAC with ROA-FN-1 Band REA-FN-1 B in service. Multiple unexpected alarms are received in the Control Room, and the following conditions are reported:

• ROA-FN-1 Band REA-FN-1 B are OFF

• ROA-V-1 and ROA-V-2 (RB Supply Valves) are OPEN

• REA-V-1 and REA-V-2 (RB Exhaust Valves) are OPEN

• The "SEC PRESS ~P HIGH" annunciator on P602 is in alarm

• Multiple Board R alarms have been received The CRS should direct the performance of _ _ _ _ _ _ to recover from the trip.

A. SOP-SGT-START-DIV/1-QC B. SOP-HVAC/RB-RESTART-QC C. SOP-SGT-START Section 5.2 D. ABI'J-HVAC, HVAC TROUBLE The keyed answer is B. The correct answer is A.

A: The stem states that a calibration of SGT-SUM-1 B2 is in progress when the running Reactor Building ventilation fans trip, but does not provide enough information to definitively determine if the calibration caused the trip. Also, the stem does not provide any information to determine if the cause of the trip has been corrected. Without this information, the plant response to an attempt to restart Reactor Building ventilation is unknown, and the fans should be considered unavailable.

The Conservative Decision Making Standard per 01-09, Operations Standards and Expectations, Section 4.2.2 is:

Page 1 of 3

Attachment 4 "Each individual should not proceed with a task unless he/she understands the task and is aware of the expected results. The individual should make a conservative decision when faced with a condition that is either unexpected or unsafe. If any condition arises that is either unexpected or unsafe, the component/plant should be placed in a safe condition, and the appropriate Supervisor or Manager should be contacted for a resolution."

Per this standard, Reactor Building ventilation should remain off until an investigation into the status of the system is completed.

The stem of the question also states that the SEC PRESS AP HIGH annunciator is in alarm. This annunciator alarms at GE 0.0" of water, which is the EOP entry point for PPM 5.3.1, Secondary Containment. The purpose of SOP-SGT-START-DIV/1-QC is "To provide instructions for starting Standby Gas Treatment System with a Secondary Containment EOP Entry and there is a sustained loss of normal Reactor Building HVAC." With the Reactor Building ventilation fans unavailable, a sustained loss of Reactor Building ventilation is in progress.

With Secondary Containment pressure GE 0.0" of water, LCO 3.6.4.1, Secondary Containment, is not met. Secondary Containment must be restored to operable within four (4) hours.

With Reactor Building ventilation unavailable, Secondary Containment inoperable, and the Secondary Containment EOP entered due to pressure, the CRS should direct the performance of SOP-SGT-START-DIV/1-QC. This is the correct answer.

B: According to the purpose section of SOP-HVAC/RB-RESTART-QC, the procedure "Provides instructions for restarting Reactor Building ventilation to reestablish Secondary Containment operability following a brief loss when the cause has been corrected." The cause of the fan trips is not definitively known, and the stem does not provide any information as to whether the cause has been corrected. Restarting Reactor Building ventilation would be contrary to the 01-09 standard. This distractor is incorrect.

C: SOP-SGT-START Section 5.2 is used for the routine starting of Standby Gas Treatment. With Secondary Containment inoperable and the plant operating in the EOP's, Standby Gas Treatment should be started using SOP-SGT-START-DIV/1-QC.

This distractor is incorrect.

Page 2 of 3

Attachment 4 D: While an entry into ABN-HVAC, HVAC TROUBLE, exists due to the trip of Reactor Building Ventilation, this is not the procedure the CRS will direct to recover from the fan trips. The start of Standby Gas Treatment per SOP-SGT-START-DIV/1-QC will be directed. This distractor is incorrect.

Page 3 of 3

Attachment 5 ENERGY NORTHWEST INSTRUCTIONAL COVER SHEET PROGRAM TITLE LICENSED OPERATOR TRAINING COURSE TITLE JOB PERFORMANCE MEASURE LESSON TITLE ALIGN SERVICE WATER TO THE FUEL POOL HEAT EXCHANGERS (Sim LESSON LENGTH .5 HRS INSTRUCTIONAL MATERIALS INCLUDED LESSON PLAN PQD CODE Rev. No.

SIMULATOR GUIDE PQD CODE Rev. No.

JPMPQDCODE L0001756 Rev. No. o EXAM PQD CODE Rev. No.

DIVISION TITLE Nuclear Training DEPARTMENT Operations Training PREPARED BY Ron Hayden DATE 12112/12 REVISED BY DATE TECHNICAL REVIEW BY DATE INSTRUCTIONAL REVIEW BY DATE APPROVED BY DATE Operations Training Manager L0001756 Rev.O Page 1 of9

Attachment 5 Verify materials current lAW SWP-TQS-Ol prior to use MINOR REVISION RECORD Description Affected Entered Manager of Revision Pages By Approval SETUP Simulator ICs; Malfunctions; Triggers; Overrides:

None Special Setup Instructions:

N/A JPM Instructions:

Verify Current Procedure against JPM. If any steps have changed, the JPM should be revised.

ToolslEquipment: None Safety Items: None Task Number: RO-0304 Validation Time: 8 Minutes Alternate Path: No Time Critical: No PPM

Reference:

SOP-FPC-OPS Section 5.6 Rev. 5 Location: Control Room NUREG 1123 Ref: 233000 A2.08 (2.9/3.1) Performance Method: Simulate Task Standard: Service Water has been aligned to FPC-HX-IA and to FPC-HX-IB.

LOOO1756 Rev.O Page 2 of9

Attachment 5 JPM CHECKLIST INITIAL Columbia was operating in Mode 1 when a complete loss of RCC occurred. A reactor scram was inserted and efforts are underway CONDITIONS: to restore RCC cooling. SW-P-1A and SW-P-1B are running. Fuel Pool temperatures are rising. Free release ofRCC heat exchanger water to the Service Water spray ponds has been approved. OSP-SW-M101 and OSP-SW-M102 have been referenced for component flow requirements. OPS2 has been briefed and is on station.

INITIATING The Control Room Supervisor has directed you to align Service Water to both Fuel Pool Cooling Heat Exchangers per SOP-FPC CUE: OPS Section 5.6. Inform the CRS when Service Water has been aligned to both Fuel Pool Cooling heat exchangers. The performance of this JPM will be simulated. Control manipulations will not be performed.

• Items are Critical Steps Time Step Element Standard Cue SatlUnsat.

NOTE: Standby Service Water to FPC-HX-IA(B) is normally used if RCC flow is lost and restoration is not anticipated prior to 125" F in the Fuel Pool, as indicated on FPC-TI-7/8 at H13-P626 (FPC I), or for evolutions that require the Fuel Pool to be cooled below the capabilities of the RCC system. Examples: Loading spent fuel into an ISFSI MPC or to raise stay time for divers.

NOTE: If Standby Service Water is aligned to the FPC heat exchanger, it is acceptable to operate below the minimum flow specified in OSP-SW-MIDl(Ml02) as long as the minimum operability value specified in PPM 8.4.81 is maintained.

NOTE: If RCC is lined up to SSW for GE 48 hours5.555556e-4 days <br />0.0133 hours <br />7.936508e-5 weeks <br />1.8264e-5 months <br />, then it is recommended RCC-RV -34A(B) (FPC-HX-IA(B) Shell Side Relief Valve) be scheduled for replacement and test as soon as possible after swapping back to RCC. This is due to the potential for loose debris in SSW causing RCC-RV-34A(B) to lift and leak.

1 Step 5.6.1 Recognizes that discharge of RCC S/U Verify free release of RCC Heat heat exchanger water into the Service Exchanger water to the Service Water Water spray ponds has been Spray Ponds. approved.

I 2 Step 5.6.2 Performs this step. S/U If desired, then lineup Standby Service Water Cooling to FPC-HX-1 A as follows:

L0001756 Rev.O Page 3 of9

Attachment 5

• Items are Critical Steps Time Step Element Standard Cue SatJUnsat 3 Step 5.6.2a Given as complete in the Initial If OSP-SW-MlOl is referenced, refer S/U Refer to OSP-SW-MlOl for Standby Conditions does not perform. candidate to Initial Conditions.

Service Water Loop A for component flow requirements.

4 Step 5.6.2b Given in Initial Conditions as If candidate approaches front panel S/U Verify SW-P-IA is running. running. refer candidate to Initial Conditions.

Note: The candidate must perform at least one of the following two steps 5 Step 5.6.2c Simulates turning the control switch As each control switch is turned:

S/U*

IfRCC cooling to FPC-HX-IB is not for the following valves to close and The switch is in the closed position.

required, then close the following: verifies Green light on and Red light (Note:

The Green light is on and the Red off for: Either this

• RCC-V-129 (Fuel Pool HX-A/B RCC light is off.

• RCC-V-129 step or the Cooling Inlet) next step is criticaL At

• RCC-V-130 (Fuel Pool HX-AIB RCC least one of Cooling Outlet)

• RCC-V-130 these steps must be

• RCC-V-131 (Fuel Pool HX-NB performed)

RCC Cooling Outlet)

• RCC-V-131 L0001756 Rev.O Page 4 of9

Attachment 5

• Items are Critical Steps Time Step Element Standard Cue SatJUnsat 6 Step 5.6.2d Verbalizes to direct OPS2 to perlorm If candidate approaches front panel to S/U*

IfRCC cooling to FPC-HX-IB is Step 5.6.2d of SOP-FPC-OPS to use the radio, direct candidate to required, or SW is to be aligned to both close RCC-V-9A and RCC-V-IOA. simulate communications. (Note: If FPC-HX-IA and FPC-HX-lB, then close Roleplay and then as OPS2 report RCC-V the following: step 5.6.2d is complete as RCC-V-9A 129, V-130 and RCC-V-lOA are closed. and V

• RCC-V-9A (FPC-HX-IA RCC Cooling 131were Inlet) (FPC HX Room) previously closed, this

• RCC-V-lOA (FPC-HX-IA RCC is not a Cooling Outlet) (FPC HX Room) critical step

-refer to above step).

N01E: SW-V-187 A and SW-V-I88A keylock switch spring returns to NORMAL from OPEN, and maintains in CLOSE.

A DISCUSSION WHERE THE KEYS ARE LOCATED IS SUFFICIENT (KEYS ARE LOCATED IN CABINETS NEXT TO TE SHIFT MANAGERS OFFICE DOOR).

WHEN CANDIDATE CORRECTLY STATES KEY LOCATION CUE THAT THE KEYS HAVE BEEN OBTAINED.

7 Step 5.6.2e Simulates placing key 219 in the The control switch was placed in S/U*

Open SW-V-187A (FPC-HX-IA control switch and turning the Open and spring returned to Norm.

Backup Cooling SW-A Inlet) (H13 control switch for SW-V-187A The Red light is on and the Green P626). clockwise to open. light is off.

Verifies Red light on and Green light off.

LOOO1756 Rev.O Page 50f9

Attach ment 5

• Items are Critical Steps Time Step Element Standard Cue Sat/Unsat 8 Step 5.6.2f Simulates placing key 221 in the The control switch was placed in S/U*

Open SW-V-188A (FPC-HX-IA control switch and turning the Open and spring returned to Norm.

Backup Cooling SW-A Outlet) (H13 control switch for SW-V-188A The Red light is on and the Green P626). clockwise to open. light is off.

Verifies Red light on and Green light off.

9 Step 5.6.3 Performs this step.

S/U If desired, then lineup Standby Service Water Cooling to FPC-HX IB as follows:

10 Step 5.6.3a Given as complete in the Initial If OSP-SW-M102 is referenced, refer S/U Refer to OSP-SW-M102 for Standby Conditions - does not perform. candidate to Initial Conditions.

Service Water Loop B for component flow requirements.

11 Step 5.6.3b Given in Initial Conditions as If candidate approaches front panel S/U Verify SW-P-IB is running. running. refer candidate to Initial Conditions.

12 Step 5.6.3c Recognizes that these valves were If candidate performs this step - the S/U IfRCC cooling to FPC-HX-IA is not closed in a previous step - does not Green light is on and the Red light is required, then close the following: perform. (If this step was not off for RCC-V-129, RCC-V-130 and (Refer to previously performed it may be RCC-V-13L note inJPM

• RCC-V-129 (Fuel Pool HX-A/B performed at this point).

RCC Cooling Inlet) step 5)

• RCC-V-130 (Fuel Pool HX-AIB RCC Cooling Outlet)

• RCC-V-131 (Fuel Pool HX-A/B RCC Cooling Outlet)

L0001756 Rev.O Page 6 of9

Attachment 5

• Items are Critical Steps Time Step Element Standard Cue Sat/Unsat 13 Step 5.6.3d Verbalizes to direct OPS2 to perform If candidate approaches front panel to SIU If RCC cooling to FPC-HX-IA is Step 5.6.3d of SOP-FPC-OPS to use the radio, direct candidate to required, or SW is to be aligned to close RCC-V-9B and RCC-V-lOB. simulate communications. (Note: If both FPC-HX-IA and FPC-HX-IB, Roleplay and then as OPS2 report RCC-V then close the following: step 5.6.3d is complete as RCC-V-9B 129, V-l30

• RCC-V-9B (FPC-HX-IB RCC and RCC-V-lOB are closed. and V-l31 were not Cooling Inlet) (FPC HX Room) previously

• RCC-V-lOB (FPC-HX-IB RCC closed this Cooling Outlet) (FPC HX Room) is a critical step).

NOTE: SW-V-187B and SW-V-188B keylock switch spring returns to NORMAL from OPEN, and maintains in CLOSE.

14 Step 5.6.3e Simulates placing key 220 in the The control switch was placed in S/U*

Open SW-V-187B (FPC-HX-IB control switch and turning the Open and spring returned to Norm.

Backup Cooling SW-B Inlet) (H13 control switch for SW-V-187B The Red light is on and the Green P626). clockwise to open. light is off.

Verifies Red light on and Green light off.

15 Step 5.6.3f Simulates placing key 222 in the The control switch was placed in SIU

• Open SW-V-188B (FPC-HX-IA control switch and turning the Open and spring returned to Norm.

Backup Cooling SW-B Outlet) (H13 control switch for SW-V-188B The Red light is on and the Green P626). clockwise to open. light is off.

Verifies Red light on and Green light off.

Termination Criteria: Student informs CRS that Service Water has been aligned to both Fuel Pool Cooling Heat Exchangers.

Transfer the following to the "Results of JPM" page: Any Unsat step* indicate if step was a Critical Step; JPM completion time.

LOO01756 Rev.O Page 7 of9

Attachment 5 RESULTS OF JPM ALIGN SERVICE WATER TO THE FUEL POOL COOLING HEAT EXCHANGERS Examinee (Print): _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

Evaluator (Print): _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __

Task Standard: Service Water has been aligned to FPC-HX-IA and to FPC-HX-IB.

Overall Evaluation JPM Completion Time SAT I UNSAT (Circle One) Minutes COMMENTS:

Evaluator's Signature: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Date: _ _ _ __

L0001756 Rev.O Page 80f9

Attachment 5 STUDENT INFORMATION CARD Initial Conditions:

Columbia was operating in Mode 1 when a complete loss of RCC occurred.

A reactor scram was inserted and efforts are underway to restore RCC cooling.

SW-P-IA and SW-P-IB are running.

Fuel Pool temperatures are rising.

Free release of RCC heat exchanger water to the Service Water spray ponds has been approved.

OSP-SW-MIOI and OSP-SW-MI02 have been referenced for component flow requirements.

OPS2 has been briefed and is on station.

Initiating Cue:

The Control Room Supervisor has directed you to align Service Water to both Fuel Pool Cooling Heat Exchangers per SOP-FPC-OPS Section 5.6.

Inform the CRS when Service Water has been aligned to both Fuel Pool Cooling heat exchangers.

The performance of this JPM will be simulated.

Control manipulations will not be performed.

Page 9 of 9