ML12341A369
| ML12341A369 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Fermi  |
| Issue date: | 11/20/2012 |
| From: | Harvey W Detroit Edison, Co, DTE Energy |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| References | |
| NRC-12-0075 TMPE-12-0294, Rev 0 | |
| Download: ML12341A369 (101) | |
Text
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet I of 3 Status: (D N U ABB-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets. P5002DOO1 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 562'-0" Room, Area' B-02, Col. G-15 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results ofjudgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
All nearby equipment adequately anchored Y
NEI ULI N/AEl
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Y4 NEI UEi N/AEl degraded conditions?
No degradation of anchors observed in the area.
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
Cable trays and conduit are too far away. Asset is protected from above by a concrete ceiling. (See Picture 6).
YONEI Uo N/Arl
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial YX NEI UE-N/AEl interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
Asset is not close enough to other equipment to have seismic spatial interactions.
'If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-8
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 2 of 3 Status: X' N U NJPR-12-0043 ABB-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets. P5002DO01 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 562'-0" Room, Area' B-02, Col. G-15
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
The sprinkler system nearby has adequate anchorage, is free of brittle attachments and has no potential interactions that would cause it to rupture.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic:
interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
No fire hazards nearby.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
There are currently workers in the area - nothing is stored improperly.
YK NEI UE] N/A[!
YKNEI UE] N/A[
Y*dNE] UEI N/A[
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yp< NEI UI-adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area.?
Note that scaffold in area has been approved by PSE on 7/25/12.
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
None.
LO/q/~
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-9
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 3 of 3 Status: @ N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El. _52-/O4 Room, Area'
-e0'2
? 6 o 1.
- T Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator#1
Date:
5/?1 /1 Date:
_9/21/12-X Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #2:
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-10
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB ABB-1 Floor El.
562'-O" Room, Area B-02, CoL G-15 (Picture #6)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-1 1
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet I of 3 Status: Y U
AB2-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: E41K805, HllP612, HllP628, HllP857, HllP870, HllP898A, HllP898B, HllP903, H11P913, H11P915, H11P923, R31KO05, R3200SO61A, R3200S061B Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 613 '-6" Room, Area' B-15, Relay Room Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results ofjudgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
Seismic bracing evident on ducts, cable trays & between cabinets.
Cabinet welded to enclosed plates/channel which is seismically robust.
YM ND UEI N/AD1
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant YFJ NO UD N/ADl degraded conditions?
No degraded condition observed
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit YEll N~g Ur] N/AD]
raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
Lights on chains & cables. Fire wrap around cables loose in places, but not a seismic concern. Foil outer casing is light weight and would not fall or cause damage in a seismic event. HVAC mounted on seismic supports. Gatronics mounted on rigid conduit over Div. II breaker panel-See CARD 12-26630. (se ?pcT-rAgiES D
t..oelZ Sc.0oC72),to--"
Wi1o0117-
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles. Lights on chains and cables have adequate rattle space. Tubes enclosed in plastic sheath. Cable tray has longitudinal bracing added.
YO ND UD N/ADt 1 If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TM PA Ž~2kk9LU4 Apni aeD Appendix D Page D-12
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheetk2f 3 Status: Y U U
NJPR-12-0043 AB2-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets. E41K805, HllP612, HllP628, H11P857, H11P870, HllP89&4, H]lP898B, HllP903, H11P913, HI1P915, H11P923, R31KO05, R3200SO61A, R3200SO61B Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 613 '-6" Room, Area' B-15, Relay Room
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
No water pipes observed.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
Area protected by Cardox System.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Portable equipment properly restrained.
YM NEI UE-N/AEl Y[3 NEl UEI N/AUI YIE NEI UL-N/AU1
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yj[NEI uFI adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
This evaluation applied to all equipment within the relay room.
E41K805, H11P612, H11P628, H11P857, H11P870, H11P898A, H11P898B, H11P903, HI1P913, HJlP91.5, H11P923, R31KO05, R3200SO61A, R3200SO61B TMPE-R 2*ý94 Appendix D Pac e D-13 I I
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 She 0 of 3 Status:10dU 3t~
ýkL A %- I k.
Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location: Bldg. 48 Floor El. 6132C4 Room, Area' RE4A Y Roc'A,1 S-IS Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified (Df;eI Evaluator #1 Date: blft*,q us2OIZ_-
9' Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #2:
Date:
ti L 6&t
,2l Z
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-14
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB2-1 Floor El.
613'-6" Room, Area B-15. Relay Room (DSCN0071)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-15
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB2-1 Floor El.
613'-6" Room, Area B-15. Relay Room (DSCNO072)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-16
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
613'-6" Room, Area AB2-1 B-15. Relay Room (DSCNO073)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-17
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB2-1 B-15. Relay Room Floor El.
613'-6" Room, Area (DSCN0201)
"Halon Piping above, Ref. Dwg. M-5327" TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-18
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB2-1 B-15. Relay Room Floor El.
613-6" Room, Area (DSCN0203)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-19
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 1 of 3 Status: Y (1) U AB2-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: H21P100, H21P624, H21P628, R1400S050 & R3200S062 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 613'-6" Room, Area' B-11, Div. ISwitchgear Room Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings, Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially YN NEI U-- N/AU adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
Anchorage is robust and acceptable. Wall mounted cabinets and equipment are supported by unistrut strips anchored to the wall.
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant YEI NEI UU-N/AUl degraded conditions?
Where welds are outside cabinets and visible, they are free of degradation.
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
Overhead cable trays have adequate seismic clearances. HVAC duct and tray supports are all robust. Trays have longitudinal bracing.
Seismic clearance between asset R1400SOOC and IYAC duct on west side of asset is 4". Per Dwg. M-5433, Rev. B (posting TCEDP 26116, Date 06/94), a minimum clearance of 6" is required (see Photo DSCN 0319). Initiated CARD 12-27959.
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles in the area. With one exception, lights are supported by cables and chains. Lightfixture to and south of asset R1400SOO1C has one chain detached (see Photo DSCN 0323). Fixture is resting against stiffener on nearby HVAC duct. Cable is suppdrfing frxture where chain is detached. CARD 12-27093 was initiated to correct condition, YE] NEI UQ N/AU Yio NO UU N/AU]
'If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-20
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 2 of 3 Status: Y _ U A1B2-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: H21PIOO, H21P624, H21P628, R1400S050 & R3200S062 Location: Bldg. AB FloorEl. 613"'6" Room, Areal B-11, Div. [SwitchgearRoom
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic YK] NEI UEI N/AD interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
Water supply to air handling unit is robustly supported. The air unit is inside a berm with afloor drain.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
There are no flammable gas cylinders or combustible materials in the area.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Tool boxes tied off. Other portable items are properly secured or stored in enclosures.
YP NO U[] N/AU Y
NEI] UD N/AE]
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Y
NIEI UTI adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Reviewed adequacy of brackets securing portable fire extiguishers to concrete walls and columns (see Photo DSCN 0330). Determined bracket was evaluated andfound adequate in Calc. DC-3277 Vol. H, Rev. 0.
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
Block walls NE & SW corners of switchgear room are seismically restrained by structural angles at concrete walls. Refer to Calc. No. 's DC-084L Rev. D; and DC-4479, Rev. Bfor analysis of walls and restraints.
TMPE-12-0294 ADDendix D Paa e D-21 l
l
Fermi 2 Seisriic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJ-PR-12-0043
. Sheet 3 of 3 Status: Y 0-(*
1$
)r,--
Af~2-0 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
.Ag+*; :.R*,P1OO, 142.1p*a4, R4P2~1 g OQS,,
o5ooo 4 g.2dOo~o2oz Location: Bldg.
Floor El. 4132 6" Room, Area' _
t f'A'AfZ,.QcL bII/ t I
e
)
M f
1..1. * :
N. Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator 4 :
1-6D Date:' '
/
2__
X'Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #2 Date:
m-TMPE-12-0294
,Appendix D Page D-22
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB2-2 B-1l, Div. I Switchaear Room Floor El.
613"-6" Room, Area (Photo DSCN 0319)
Seismic Gap between HVAC Duct and Cabinet R1400SO01C TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-23
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB2-2 B-i1, Div. I Switchgear Room Floor El.
613'"6" Room, Area (Photo DSCN 0323)
Detached Light Chain by R1400SOO1C TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-24
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
613'-6" Room, Area AB2-2 B-11, Div. I Switchgear Room (Photo DSCN 0330)
Fire Extinguisher Mounting Bracket TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-25
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 1 of 3 Status:@ N U AB3-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets. R3200S004 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 643'-6" Room, Area' Battety Room (B-22W)
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
Cabinets R3200SO08A, R3200S011 and R3200SO08B on frame anchored to floor. 3/8 "0 anchors with 1 Y" of thread extended above washer - acceptable see drawing E-2833-1 0.
3 A
(_Sef-Phoio OSC.Nol.&qQ)
I' YO NEI UE] N/All fri t/I2~~
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant degraded conditions?
Area is clean.
(,..e Pho+o DSUJtoiq3 QnJ D.SCIV l,-1q)
I A /l NEI UE] N/AE]
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit Yg] NEI UE] N/AEl raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
HVAC duct - could not verify hangers covered with silver insulation/fire wrap - NOTE: duct is wall-mounted and at such a height & distance from the battery racks that the HVAC system does not pose a seismic risk. Lights have plastic covers and chain with cable, emergency light fixture a pears adequate (See Phofo sc coi3iDSCtJOilq'iSC#JOi 3&andtDS&NO1q) 0/1-
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial YI NE] UE] N/AE]
interactions witn otner equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles ana lighting)?
Lights have plastic covers and chain with cable, emergency lights acceptable - robust.
(See Pho~o DSC..I0o3Li, 0,c~oj3q and DSWkO1l4o)
J4A 10/1 V12..
1 If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TML-TMPE-1 2-0294 Apni aeD2 Appendix D Page D-26
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 2 of 3 Status:&
N U NJPR-12-0043 AB3-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: R3200S004 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 643 -6" Room, Area1 Battery Room (B-22 W)
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
No pipe in this area.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
No combustible items.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
All equipment and cabinets are tied back Area is clean.
YM NEI UE] N/AL YO NEI U[] N/AL YP NEI U-1 N/ALE
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could YfA NEI UE--
adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
A green cable was observed entering an open conduit into thefloor. Cable restraints orpenetration seals could not be verified. However, the installation is in accordance with drawing E-2833-10 and was installed in accordance with EDP-26959. The installation is acceptable.
TtPA-L-2-0294 Appendix D PaaE D-27 I
I
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sh t3of3 Status: 6 N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
A05 9320Wsoo),I/
Location: Bldg.
9 FloorEl. 43____
Room, Area'
'BA7rX0,Y /Qt" awt'r azw M Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator#1: Q w O*f,,J A.,
p Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #2:
Date:
- /*/g
/2-Date: 06/0 & I I_,
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-28
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643'-6" Room, Area AB3-1 Battery Room (B-22W)
(DSCN0131)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-29
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB3-M Battery Room (B-22W)
Floor El.
643"-6" Room, Area
%I (DSCNO134)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-30
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643'-6" Room, Area AB3-1 Battery Room (B-22W)
(DSCN0138)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-31
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643'-6" Room, Area AB3-1 Battery Room (B-22W)
(DSCN0139)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-32
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643'-6" Room, Area AB3-I Battery Room (B-22W)
(DSCN0140)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-33
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB3-1 Battery Room (B-22W)
Floor El.
643'-6" Room, Area (DSCN0143)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-34
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643'-6" Room, Area AB3-1 Battery Room (B-22W)
(DSCN0144)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-35
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 1 of 3 Status/
N U AB3-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets.: R3200S016 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 643 '-6" Room, Area' B-20, DIVII Switchgear Room Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results ofjudgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Y¥V NEI UU N/A-1 adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
All items above cabinet, copper pipe, tube track and HVAC ducts appear seismically supported. Copper pipe connected to valves P50F701 &P5OF3 77, part of instrument air system.
4m LSeG Phoito
.sc-J'OaOqt041 OSCoI.O and DSCNOA3,J)
'I"J/,-
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant YPI NEI U[ N/A[]
degraded conditions?
Adjacent fire wall anchored to the floor. Adjacent Div. I cabinet anchored to the floor. Air handling unit T4100B033 approximately 15" from R3200S016 evidence of corrosion at the base. Corrosion is minor, and condensation moisture issues are being addressed by placement of absorbent socks at condensation location.
JAM
(.See Pho-to DsecNo2oq, DSc. Ncoao, DSC.MJo1-74h/ d Dbsc I'O-a'.)
WI/fl,..
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
11VAC ducts are seismically supported. Instrument air tube-track and copper header pipe is seismically supported
~e, e Pho4o 5OCN0o1)
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles in this area. Lights hung with chain and redundant wire.
(See Photo D../oJ ii) i,,u Y[4 NEI UU1 N/AU1 Y[l NE U-- N/AU1 I-.
If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-36
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 2 of 3 StatusO N U AB3-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: R3200S016 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 643 '-6" Room, Area' B-20, DIVIlSwitchgear Room
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
Cooling water flow and return pipes for T4100B033 appear seismically supported and acceptable. Fire protection is C02.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
Area is clean.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Small desk, mop & bucket are restrained.
Y9 NEI UE N/AU YJ NO UU N/AU Yt NE UD N/AU
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Y*]- NEI-UI-adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
None.
TMW-I'10O294 Appendix D Page D-37
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 3 of 3 Status:Q N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location: Bldg.
4 FloorEl. 6__-_'
Room, Area' */V_
SVTCU/E*g9 AP5/M r Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #1:
I c-Y C M Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53 Qualified Evaluator #2:
6b!,4
/_,i Date:
'/2o7 Date:
d&
Z01-TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-38
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643a-6" Room, Area AB3-2 B-20, Div. II Switchgear Room (DSCN0208)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-39
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643'-6" Room, Area AB3-2 B-20, Div. II Switchgear Room (DSCN0209)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-40
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643"-6" Room, Area AB3-2 B-20, Div. II Switchgear Room (DSCN0210)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-41
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643"-6" Room, Area AB3-2 B-20, Div. II Switchgear Room (DSCN0211)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-42
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643"-6" Room, Area AB3-2 B-20, Div. II Switchgear Room (DSCN0217)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-43
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
643'-6" Room, Area AB3-2 B-20, Div. II Switchqear Room (DSCN0224)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-44
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 1 of 3 Status 0 N U AB3-3 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets. R3200S020C Location: Bldg. AB3 Floor El. 643 '-6" Room, Area' B-20, near Col. G-11 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially YP NiO UI-N/AL adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
All equipment anchored to the floor or wall with robust seismic supports.
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant YM NI" UI-N/AL degraded conditions?
Adjacent battery chargers anchored with same detail. 5e-QAs+','.,- I a'o\\eP.
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit YP NO] UL] N/AL raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
Tray and duct on rigid seismic supports, no ceiling tiles, lights on chain andcable. (sece P1,o4r,
c
,'~~
(o7.)
~
~
i~
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial YfA NEI UL N/AL]
interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles in the area, lights hung on chains with redundant cable.
5 10/1 0/1 1 If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
~jukL TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-45
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 2 of 3 Statusn N U NJPR-12-0043 AB3-3 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: R3200S020C Location: Bldg. AB3 Floor El. 643 '-6" Room, Area' B-20, near Col. G-11
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
No water lines in the area. Fire protection is Halon system.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
Area is free ofpotentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause afire.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of po:rtable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
This area contains no housekeeping issues, portable equipment or temporary installations.
Yf4 NEI U-N/AIl YEP NEO UL] N/AU YX] NEI UI-N/AU
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Y[R NEI ur-1 adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
None.
TN*K4-2-0294 Appendix D Page D-46
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 3 of 3 Status: &
N U NJPR-12-0043 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Location: Bldg.
N5'2 FloorEl.
p4'---'
Room, Area1 CotGn,'
6?-.11-'
I, Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #1: QýJ, 6r t
ý CO Date: /6/,/4.!f w 2o,2 ti4 Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #2 :
Date:
0 Z
'¢ z TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-47
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
A83 AB3-3 B-20. near CoL G-1 1 Floor El.
643"-6" Room, Area (DSC00074)
Overhead Cable Trays and HVAC Ducts TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-48
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB3 Floor El.
643"-6" Room, Area AB3-3 B-20, near CoL G-11 (DSCO0075)
Overhead Cable Trays, HVAC Ducts and Light TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-49
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 1 of 3 Status: (V N U AB3-4 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets. T4100C009, T4100B044 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 653'-0" Room, Area' B-22W, Div. 1I Battery Room Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results ofjudgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
Equipment mounted to floor, walls and ceiling are adequately supported.
JAM (See-Pho+, D6CfNO..t i) to/*,.
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant degraded conditions?
All anchors observed look new or show no signs of significant degradation.
(See Pho+o DsC.1osI ')
A*,
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
HVAC and cable trays/conduits are seismically supported.
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
Light contacts filter frame. Frame is very robust and light will not damage fan or filter (T4100B044).
(See Pholo l)SCN015oa')
1, Yd NEl UI-N/AU Y% NEI UE1 N/A-]
YP NEI UEr N/ArU Y14 NE UE-N/A-1 1 If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-50
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 2 of 3 Status:
N U AB3-4 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: T4100C009, T4100B044 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 653 '-0" Room, Area' B-22W, Div. IIBatter Room
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
All piping is robust & supported seismically.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
Combustible loading is small. Area appears free of adverse seismic interactions that could cause afire.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
No portable equipment.
YO NE U-] N/AEl YP NEI U[- N/AEl YA NEI UEiI N/AE]
V,
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could YO N[--] UED adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
None TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-51
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Status:~
6 Nf Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC) 5sesF7: -71"4oocc o5 DrI Z.
Location: Bldg.
4I e Floor El.
,3ý O' Room, Area'
?AtItM.
- .tt&'Y
-g4o" (e, -*.)
Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #l: (D a o "
.iX -
Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #2,:
O64L Date:
- 1Y12 012.
Date:
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-52
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
653"-O" Room, Area AB3-4 8-22W, Div. II Battery Room (DSCNO151)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-53
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
653"-O" Room, Area AB3-4 B-22W, Div. II Battery Room (DSCN0152)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-54
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet I of 3 Status:* N U NJPR-12-0043 AB4-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets. H21P080 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 659'-6" Room, Area1 Ventilation Equipment Area (B-24)
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially YO NEI Ut] N/At]
adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
Equipment anchored to floor or wall. Conduit and piping seismically supported. Block wall seismically supported with brown steel and through bolts.
-)41A (5ee Pho+o DSCNOI t5, OSC_*4NB7 a'iJ DSCNO'48qCIVM/,,)
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of sigrnificant YO NEI Ut] N/At]
degraded conditions?
All anchors observed look "new".
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
HVAC & Cable tray / conduit seismically supported.
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles. Lights supported by chains and redundant cable.
(See Photo DcNioqspog d DSCNoqq3)
JM 1CO'V12.
YP Nt] Ut] N/At]
Y[* Nt] Ut] N/At]
' If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-55
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 2 of 3 Status: M N U AB4-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: H21P080 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 659 -6" Room, Area' Ventilation EguipmentArea (B-24)
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic YQ9 NEI U-N/Al interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
Pipes in the area are supported seismically. Area has hose reels - not a riskfor flooding water will drain down the stairs.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
Low fire risk area - no combustibles in the area.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Tool box and ladders correctly stored and restrained YIP NEI UH N/AUI YO NE UEJ N/AU
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Y NO NIUD1 adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
None.
TMPE4A294 Appendix D Page D-56
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 3 of 3 Status
_,N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
&A~-l Location: Bldg.
A fS Floor El. 6 5 9'-f 6 " Room, Area' t/F-MTI/rta'gMw-A4*eEA 9' Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53 Qualif ed Evaluator#1: ?c--
C:*i Date:
Date:
(
O LO
/I I' Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #2:
6~AL,/YL QiL&(/&L~
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-57
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
659"-6" Room, Area AB4-1 Ventilation Equipment Area (B-24)
(DSCN0485)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-58
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area AB4-1 Ventilation Equipment Area (B-24)
(DSCN0487)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-59
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area AB4-1 Ventilation Equipment Area (B-24)
(DSCN0488)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-60
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB4-1 Ventilation EauiDment Area (B-24)
Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area (DSCN0489)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-61
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area AB4-1 Ventilation Equipment Area (B-24)
(DSCN0493)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-62
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 1 of 3 Status:
N U NJPR-12-0043 AB4-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: H21P081, H21P083, H21P085, H21P087 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 659'-6" Room, Area' A-34, Col. F-11 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results-of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
All Equipment and Duct supports are of a robust seismic nature (vee photos DSCN0245 & 0248)
Y1 NE-U-' N/AU
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant YP NEI UL1 N/AU-degraded conditions?
Bolting of equipment in area is corrosion free or painted.
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
Ductwork, conduits & Cable raceways (No cable trays) are seismically supported or wall mounted and rigid. Adequate Flex conduit connections to cabinet (see photos DSCN0247, 0244 & 0249)
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles in the area. Lights are supported with 2 chains and 1 extra cable @ each end. Lights are over 1 "O-" away, therefore not a rattle space issue. (see photo DSCN0248)
Yr' NEI UU1 N/AU YUI NE UU N/AU 1 If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-63
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 2 of 3 Status:t 0N U
AB4-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: H21P081, H21P083, H21P085, H21P087 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 659'-6" Room, Area' A-34, Col. F-11
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic Y
N ULI N/AH interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
Since a nearby open stairwell acts as afloor drain flooding is not a problem in this room.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic YJA NHI U[-] N/AEl interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
Compressed gas cylinders are seismically supported The wall east of the panels isolates the panels from the rest of the area and serves as a fire wall.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic YK NH3 U-" N/AHl interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
No temporary items in the area. Ladders around the corner and in front of the stairs leading up to the next level are seismically supported. (see photo DSCN0243)
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Y
NHI UHJ adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
CMU block walls to the north (Stairwell walls) and to the south (Room FIO walls) are seismically retrofitted (see DSCN023 7 & 0252)
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
None ZY TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-64
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 3 of 3 Status:cY. N U AB4-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: H21P081, H21P083, H21P085, H21P087 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 659 '-6" Room, Area' A-34, Col. F-1 XSeismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53 Qualified Evaluator #1 :
Date:
/o 2-*1,2..
"_2 Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53 Qualified Evaluator #2:
Date:
I " ( "
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-65
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area AB4-2 A-34 / Col. F-11 (DSCN0237)
CMU Block Walls - Seismically Reinforced TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-66
Area Walk-By Pictures A134-2 Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area A-34 / CoL. F-11 (DSCN0244)
HVAC and Raceways in the Area TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-67
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB4-2 Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area A-34/CoL F-11 (DSCN0245)
HVAC, Raceways & Equipment Adequately Anchored to Slab or the Walls TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-68
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB4-2 Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area A-34 / CoL F-11 (DSCN0247)
HVAC and Raceways Adequately Supported TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-69
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB4-2 Floor El.
659"-6" Room, Area A-34 / Col. F-1I (DSCN0248)
HVAC, Raceways & Equipment Anchored Adequately to the Walls & Slab TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-70
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
659'-6" Room, Area A-34 / Col. F-11 (DSCN0249)
HVAC and Raceways are Adequately Supported in the Area TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-71
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area AB4-2 A-34 / CoL F-11 (DSCN0252)
CMU Block Walls - Reinforced Seismically TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-72
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
659'-6" Room, Area AB4-2 A-34 / CoL F-11 (DSCN0243)
Ladders Adequately Supported. CMU Block Walls - Reinforced Seismically TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-73
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 1 of 3 Status___ N U AB4-3 Area Walk-ByChecklist (AWC)
Assets: T4100F041 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 670'-0" Room, Area' B-24, Col. H-12 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of'judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
Duct supports, IA supports and cabinets all seismically supported T4100B046 & B045 are robustly supported
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant degraded conditions?
All anchors observed look new or show no signs of significant degradation.
YJV NE ULI N/AO YW NEI U-N/AU1
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit Y1 NI UE-N/AO raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limit?
Duct on line H on Rod Hangers & Lateral supports. Ok bjEJ. 77'6 from T4100F041, and same elevation.
r Z..
1 J
(See. Pbolo D.()Soooa3 ~h J DscC~ovo S&)
34r
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles. Lights hung from chains with redundant cable.
YJ[ NE UO N/AU 1 If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE--- A-4 Apni aeD7 Appendix D Page D-74
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 2 of 3 Status: Y, N U NJPR-12-0043 AB4-3 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: T4100F041 Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 670'-0" Room, Area' B-24, Col. H-12
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic YK NEI UI-N/AEl interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
T4100B046-compressors robustly supported Any flooding would flow into equipment hatch.
141A
(.SeP6 ho-l+o 0Co1oo")
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic YJA N] UI" N/AEI interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
Clean room. Area appears free of adverse seismic interactions that could cause afire.
jA1A (See. Po-l-o 05Cooo81, V.ýC0ooo cand DSc ODORS.)
lo/,/2.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
No staged equipment.
YV1 NE] ULI NIAD
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Y[ý NEI UOl adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area.?
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
Water lines above panel 72C-3B & PIS-H21-P3 76 Div Ion rod hangers. Pipes go to valves P50-F106 V23-2058 - Station A VR & P800-F092 - FP and Hose Reel - Pipes are robustly supported, and would not cause serious flooding in the area.
(See Pho4o R5C)
Oooosq)
TMRg,.294 Appendix D Pag:e D-75 I 1 v
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 3 of 3 Status:&
N U NJPR-12-0043 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
/15'//_-'5 Location: Bldg.
/49 Floor El. 67et-O'" Room, Area' I/VA6C ROoML( (3-2Y)
(ol. -';I I Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator# #:
-aJ' C V i
Date:
_______,?a___
E" Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified AIAI. Oý4lAv Evaluator #2:
Date:
7-7,.-
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-76
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB4-3 Floor El.
670'-O" Room, Area B-24, CoL H-12 (DSCOOO81)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-77
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
670"-O" Room, Area AB4-3 B-24, CoL H-12 (DSCO0082)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-78
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
670"-Q" Room, Area AB4-3 B-24. CO/. H-12 (DSCO0083)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-79
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
670'-O" Room, Area AB4-3 B-24, Col. H-12 (DSCO0084)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-80
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
670'-O" Room, Area AB4-3 B-24, CoL H-12 (DSCO0087)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-81
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
670'-O" Room, Area AB4-3 B-24, CoL H-12 (DSC00088)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-82
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB4-3 Floor El.
670'-0" Room, Area B-24, CoL H-12 (DSC00089)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-83
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet I sf 3 Status: Y.*)U AB5-I Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: H21P296A, T4100B009, T41F1OIA Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 677"-6" Room, Area' HVACEquip. Room(B-27A)
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results ofjudgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially YRI NF-UF-1 N/Al]
adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
Crowded area. Everything has massive supports or anchorage - room is seismically acceptable. (See photo DSCN0496, DSCN0502 and DSCN0512)
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant YRI NO-Url N/AOl degraded conditions?
Anchors are all good.
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
HVAC fan robustly supports, ducts are robust and strong, seismically acceptable.
(See photo DSCN0510)
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles, lights have chains with redundant cable.
(See photo DSCN0500 and DSCN0502)
YIn NEI UF-N/AE]
Y[N N[] U[: N/AEl 1 If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
JA L TMPE-12-0294 Appendix Q Page D-84
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 2 of 3 Status: Y U NJPR-12-0043 AB5-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets. H21P296A, T4100B009, T41F101A Location: Bldg. AB Floor El. 677'-6" Room, Area' HVAC Equip.
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
Water piping to chiller is seismic. (See photo DSCN0495) Floor drain stand-pipe located by T4100B009 is shown extending1-1/2" above the floor per Detail D1 of Dwg. M-2221, Rev. Q. Field condition reflects the floor drain stand-pipe extending 8-1/2" above the floor. CARD 12-2 7556 was written to address this "As-Built" condition and dispositioned under TSR-37042, Rev. 0.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
There are no combustible materials stored in this area. All equipment is seismically designed
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
No portable equipment stored in this area.
Room(B-27A)
YEI NX ULI N/AW Yp( NEI UE] N/AE YO NEI UE N/AE]
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could YD" NE] U--
adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
No adverse condition were observed.
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
None.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-85
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
A54-fS
- s #
/2tPa2.951A
, -r14 o rbo oq3/4T~L1IF I DIA
$htat ýLof Location: Bldg. -A4B.
Floor El. 677-le Room, Area1 AIV/C E WPAIP1&NT/ROOM 6-2.-.Aj R-t5 Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified K,-L1.
c*,
Evaluator #1 Date:
/x22
.4 Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qu fed Evaluator #2:
Date:
d6//.
7-
"2 TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-86
Area Walk-By Pictures AB5-1 Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
677T-6" Room, Area HVAC Equipment Room (B-27A) CoL H-15 (DSCN0495)
TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-87
Area Walk-By Pictures AB5-1 Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
677'-6" Room, Area HVAC Equipment Room (B-27A) CoL H-15 (DSCN0496)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-88
Area Walk-By Pictures AB5-1 Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
677'-6" Room, Area HVAC Equipment Room (B-27A) CoL H-15 (DSCNOSOO)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-89
Area Walk-By Pictures AB5-1 Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
677"-6" Room, Area HVAC Equipment Room (B-27A) CoL H-15 (DSCN0502)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-90
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
AB AB5-1 Floor El.
677"-6" Room, Area HVAC Equipment Room (B-27A) CoL H-15 (DSCN0510)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-91
Area Walk-By Pictures AB5-1 Location: Bldg.
AB Floor El.
677'-6" Room, Area HVAC Equipment Room (B-27A) CoL H-15 (DSCN0512)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-92
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 1 of 3 Status: (
N U NJPR-12-0043 RBSB-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: E115OFO04C Location: Bldg. RB Floor El. 540'-0" Room, Area' A-01, Torus Area (sub-bsmt)
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results ofjudgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
All anchorage in the area was observed to be intact and securely tightened See pictures 7 & 8for typical conditions.
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant degraded conditions?
No anchorage in the area was observed to be degraded. See pictures 7
& 8for typical conditions.
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
Cable/conduit raceways are adequately supported. No cable trarys in this area.
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No ceiling tiles in the area. No rattle space issues identified.
Y1 NE UE-N/AU Ylf N[] UZ N/AU YX' NEI UL1 N/AU YN'NE UE-N/AEl 1 If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-93
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 2 of 3 Status: (T) N U NJPR-12-0043 RBSB-1 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: E115OFO04C Location: Bldg. RB Floor El. 540'-0" Room, Area' A-01.,
Torus Area (sub-bsmt)
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
There are no observed interactions with the potential for rupture of vessels or piping systems.
YX NEI UE] N/AE
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
There are no observed interactions with the potential to producefires.
Y(
NE UI-N/AEI
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
See comment section below.
Y$i NE UE N/AE
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Y
NINEI U-adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area.?
No other seismic conditions identified.
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
Housekeeping: There are several miscellaneous sign stands placed near the wall at column lines A-12
& 13 that do not have any signs attached.
Technical evaluation TE-A30-08-066 (CARD 08-24488) shows that RP stanchions will not overturn during seismic event. These stanchions are very similar to the sign stands mentioned Therefore, there is no restriction from a seismic standpoint on their use in the plant TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-94
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 3 of 3 Status: ON U P,bsAp,-
Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
W&IJ-1EA(,L / /5-Or-()o4-C VA4LV F Location: Bldg.
)Z ý FloorEl. 540-t-O Room, Area1 A-0-1,
'o0p--o A-PL-GA, C(,SU8-AS.T)
- Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator#l:
1 P.
Date:
b 1
4,eismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator 122:
Date:
_L*. z 1 1 !'2_
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-95
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
RB RBSB-1 A-01, Torus Area (Sub-Bsmt)
Floor El.
540'-0" Room, Area (Picture 7)
Torus TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-96
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
RB RBSB-1 A-01, Torus Area (Sub-Bsmt)
Floor El.
540W-0" Room, Area (Picture 8)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-97
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet 1 of 3 Status: (!) N U NJPR-12-0043 RBSB-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets.- E2101COO1C, E5150F045 Location: Bldg. RB Floor El. 540'-0" Room, Area' A-05, Col. G-15 Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results of judgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
Hose reel support is missing a nut, however it is not close enough to E5150F045 or E2101COO1C to pose any realistic hazard. (See Pictures 19 and 20.) CARD 12.-26957 has been written (8/21/12)for the missing nut on the hose reel support baseplate. The other equipment in the area has adequate anchorage.
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant degraded conditions?
No degradation observed.
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
No adverse conditions observed.
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
The overhead lights are mounted on swivel mounts with proper clearance such that they do not act as impact sources that could damage the asset or equipment.
YS4 NEI UOI N/AE5 Y19 NEI ULI N/AEl YIr NEI ULI N/Al-YO NEI UE N/AE]
If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-98
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sheet 2 of 3 Status: Q N U RBSB-2 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: E2101COOC, E5150F045 Location: Bldg. RB Floor El. 540 '-0" Room, Area' A-05, Col. G-15
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
The sprinklers in area are appropriately supported. There is a mist in the area due to a leak. RP is aware. It does not present a seismic concern.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic, interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
No fire hazards observed.
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Portable cart nearby has its wheels clamped to prevent movement and is restrained by a cable.
Y19 NE UEI N/AEU Y$
NE uEh N/AU YO NE UE1 N/AU
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Y[W' NEI U[-]
adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
See comments.
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary)
The RP basket stanchion is placed in the middle of the room and is being used to delineate the contaminated area. Technical Evaluation TE-A30-08-066 shows that the stanchions will not overturn during a seismic event, therefore, there is no restriction on their use in the plant.
frP5 Io/41/,-
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-99
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sh t3 of 3 Status: 9 N U Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC) s,45 '5 : fol CoolC E_5oFoq*5 Location: Bldg.
M)
Floor El../0 Room, Area, An"
(.
- I i X'Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator #1:
7e P.,14-0ocr I. Seismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53Qualified Evaluator#2: I C-."&
Date:
S/*I/I Date:
/VI TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-100
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
RB RBSB-2 Floor El.
540"-O" Room, Area A-05 / CoL G-15 (Picture 19)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-101
Area Walk-By Pictures RBSB-2 Location: Bldg.
RB Floor El.
540"-0" Room, Area A-05/CoL G-15 (Picture 20)
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-102
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist Sheet I of 3 Status:@ N U NJPR-12-0043 RBSB-3 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: E4101COOC, E4150FOO1, E4150FO04, H21P420 Location: Bldg. RB Floor El. 540'-0" Room, Area' HPCIRoom (B-01)
Instructions for Completing Checklist This checklist may be used to document the results of the Area Walk-By near one or more SWEL items. The space below each of the following questions may be used to record the results ofjudgments and findings.
Additional space is provided at the end of this checklist for documenting other comments.
- 1. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of potentially Yg Ni-U-I N/AE]
adverse seismic conditions (if visible without necessarily opening cabinets)?
All nearby equipment is anchored and will not respond adversely during a seismic event.
- 2. Does anchorage of equipment in the area appear to be free of significant Y* NEI U[" N/AUj degraded conditions?
No degradation observed
- 3. Based on a visual inspection from the floor, do the cable/conduit raceways and HVAC ducting appear to be free of potentially adverse seismic conditions (e.g., condition of supports is adequate and fill conditions of cable trays appear to be inside acceptable limits)?
The light suspended from the ceiling can swing; however, it has no potential impact interaction and adequate clearance with SWEL items is provided
- 4. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic spatial interactions with other equipment in the area (e.g., ceiling tiles and lighting)?
No rattle space issues observed All equipment is far enough apart* and restrained to prevent seismic spatial interaction per "Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown and Area walk-by Guideline in support of NTTF 2.3 Section 4".
Ye NE UWJ N/AU YO NW UW3 N/AU1
- > 6" apartforflexible equipment and > 2" apart for rigid equipment.
If the room in which the SWEL item is located is very large (e.g., Turbine Hall), the area selected should be described. This selected area should be based on judgment, e.g., on the order of about 35 feet from the SWEL item.
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-103
Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline Area Walk-By-Checklist NJPR-12-0043 Sht t 2of3 Status: 6 N U RBSB-3 Area Walk-By Checklist-(AWC)
Assets: E4101COOC, E4150FO01, E4150F004, H21P420 Location: Bldg. RB Floor El. 540'-0" Room, Areal HPCIRoom (B-01)
- 5. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause flooding or spray in the area?
The fire sprinkler on the ceiling near asset H21P420 is well supported with a pipe hanger as shown in picture B3. The seismic accelerations are small in this area and therefore the sprinkler does not impose any realistic hazards.
- 6. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions that could cause a fire in the area?
There are no observed flammable items in the area.
Y;9 NE UI1 N/AU Y% N[
UU N/AU YX" NEI UI N/AU
- 7. Does it appear that the area is free of potentially adverse seismic interactions associated with housekeeping practices, storage of portable equipment, and temporary installations (e.g., scaffolding, lead shielding)?
Ladders south of E415OFOO1 are not secured to the wall racks by cables per MOP23. Per Specification 3071-544 and drawing C-2585 the wall mounted ladder racks are acceptable without cable restraints. Shielding at southwest corner is not anchored to the floor however it's noted that shield stand does not require seismic ties per TSR 26056, revision A.
(See pictures B1 & B2.)
- 8. Have you looked for and found no other seismic conditions that could Yr' NEI UI--
adversely affect the safety functions of the equipment in the area?
Comments (Additional pages may be added as necessary) bon rn Q '
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-104
. Fermi 2 Seismic Walkdown Guideline
. Area Walk-By-Checklist Sh t3of3 Status:
N U NJPR-12-0043 RBSB-3 Area Walk-By Checklist (AWC)
Assets: E4101COO1C, E4150F001, E4150FO04, D21P420 Location: Bldg. RB Floor El. 540'-0" Room, Area' LIPCIRoom (a-01)
XSeismic Engineer Walkdown PSE-53 QualtWed Evaluator #1: Michael P. Sasso 2 ig, 4t Date:
I)5 2
SSeIsnlc Engineer Walkdown PSE-53 Qualtfled Scott Bauer Ic A
Evaluator #2 Date:
i/5 /12_
TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-105
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
Floor El.
540'-0" Room, Area (Picture Bi)
ALARA Shielding and Mounted Ladder Racks TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-106
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
RB Floor El.
540'-0" Room, Area RBSB-3 HPCI Room (B-01)
(Picture B2)
ALARA Shielding TMPE-12-0294 Appendix D Page D-107
Area Walk-By Pictures Location: Bldg.
Floor El.
540"-0" Room, Area (Picture B3)
Overhead Fire Sprinkler TMPE-1 2-0294 Appendix D Page D-108