ML12272A040

2011 Clinton Power Station Initial License Examination Administrative Outline and Operating Test Comments

ML12272A040
Person / Time
Site:	Clinton
Issue date:	09/14/2011
From:	Operations Branch III
To:	Exelon Generation Co, Exelon Nuclear
References
50-461/11-301
Download: ML12272A040 (5)

Text

ILT 10-1 NRC Outline and Operating Test Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station ILT Class 10-01 Exam Date 08/22/2011 Operating Test 2011-301 Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response JPMs JPM 407 Complete a SRV Actuation Report Attachments are part of the JPM itself.

RO Admin Initiating cue to examiner: Provide attached CE agreed when discussed that they would be able to information to applicant or provide information to see this when the JPMs are performed during prep applicant as applicant asks for it. week.

Fill in block 309/311 - appears that an attachment is necessary:

Fill block 309: It appears that the applicant needs to have an attachment (pg 14 of 17) to answer this question. Suggest adding cue to JPM for examiner to provide applicant attachment (pg 14 of 17) when asked.

Fill block 311: Need cue for examiner to provide applicant pictures of plant conditions.

If applicant is given all attachments with initial cue, this may be done in a group setting.

JPM 441 Perform Offsite Source Power Verification Yes. CE agreed when discussed that they would be RO Admin able to see this when the JPMs are performed during This appears too complicated to review in office, need prep week.

to review on site. There appears to be nothing wrong with this ST! Should there be errors?

JPM 442 Print Reading Changed as recommended. Clarified initiating cue to RO/SRO Admin (This can be done with all applicants simultaneously). ensure candidate recognizes action is for a Peer Check.

Added step 4 (SRO ONLY - ITS impact/compensatory 1 of 5

ILT 10-1 NRC Outline and Operating Test Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station ILT Class 10-01 Exam Date 08/22/2011 Operating Test 2011-301 Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Should have cue to provide applicants with all action).

reference material(?)

Consider having SRO applicants also review associated Technical Specifications associated with this tagout!

On Form ES 301-1, this JPM is listed as a simulator JPM. What in the simulator is needed to perform this JPM?

JPM 450 Authorize an Emergency Dose Changed as recommended.

SRO Admin Change cue to as the acting Station Emergency Director vice as the acting Shift Emergency Director.

JPM 204 Manually Startup RCIC System S1 - RCIC steam supply line leak; not used.

Simulator S2 - RCIC trips if started and will not reset.

Ensure NOT performed during scenarios. S3 - RCIC auto/manual start (logic is operable).

JPM 440 Added missing SAT/UNSAT line on page 9.

Simulator JPM 441 Removed Critical Step designation for Verify Simulator steps 8.1.2.4, 8.2.1.4, 8.3.1.1, 8.3.2.1 and 8.3.3.1. Two critical steps remain.

JPM 447 Clarified initiating cue with regard to retrieval of Simulator computer points. Added comments on pages 8,9, 11 and 12 for same reason.

JPM 448 Added REMA to documents provided to candidate.

2 of 5

ILT 10-1 NRC Outline and Operating Test Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station ILT Class 10-01 Exam Date 08/22/2011 Operating Test 2011-301 Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Simulator Clarified initiating cue by adding the REMA, field operator availability by phone and that RP has been notified of pending pump shift.

JPM 449 Reset a SCRAM NOT performed during scenarios.

Simulator Ensure NOT performed during scenarios.

Clarified comments on page 9, pointing out that the resetting ARI/RPT is not part of the critical step.

JPM 450 Changed Initiating Cue to say Acting Station Simulator Emergency Director vice Acting Shift Emergency Director at Examiners request. Changed page 8 brief Standard to include cancer risks.

JPM 453 Several changes made to step comments to clarify Simulator what the Examiner should expect. Several changes made to step cues to emphasize NOT. Standards were changed in two steps for Examiner clarification.

JPM 454 New JPM.

Simulator JPM 455 New JPM.

Simulator 3 of 5

ILT 10-1 NRC Outline and Operating Test Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station ILT Class 10-01 Exam Date 08/22/2011 Operating Test 2011-301 Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response JPM 210 Manually Open the LPCS Injection Valve Replaced.

In Plant Too simplistic. Recommend replacing.

JPM 031 Manual Makeup of CCW Expansion Tank Replaced.

In Plant Too simplistic. Recommend replacing.

JPM 026 Added As Found position to comments on pages 8 &

In Plant 9.

Scenarios Scenario 1 D-1 Sheet Review: No TS credit given for Event 4? CPS 2202.04F001 Reactor Operator Instructions For Criticality - changed Expect Xenon to burn out to Event 2: Ensure that enough control rods are Expect Xenon to remain relatively stable and when withdrawn to allow credit for reactivity manipulation criticality is expected to occur (changed between prior to reaching stuck rod. steps 19 and 25 to between steps 4 and 9). Scenario conditions were changed during development but the Event 9: If operators detect a degrading situation, change was omitted in error on this form.

they might manually scram the unit and wont see the auto scram failure. D-2 Form page 13 Simulator Operator Instructions -

changed step 22, rod 20-37 is at 12 to step 05, rod 36-25 is at 00. Scenario conditions were changed during development but the change was omitted in error on this form. Added last statement Select correct screen - SRM/IRM Overlap Display. Ensures conditions are as the candidate would expect.

4 of 5

ILT 10-1 NRC Outline and Operating Test Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station ILT Class 10-01 Exam Date 08/22/2011 Operating Test 2011-301 Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Scenario 2 D-1 Sheet Review: Is Event 5 an event for ATC or D-2 Form page 2 Event 1 - Added Test Prep switch BOP? operation. Omitted in error.

D-2 Form page 9 Event 7 - Added valve numbers for IA and FC isolation bullets. Omitted in error.

Scenario 3 Event 1: Cue should be to the entire crew that time D-2 Form page 5 Event 4 - Added ARP or to how compression is being used, not just to the BOP. the CB pump is operated. Omitted in error.

Event 5: No TS LCOs associated with tripping of CCW pump? D-2 Form page 9 Event 8 - Added valve numbers for F/D Bypass valve bullets. Omitted in error.

5 of 5