|
---|
Category:Meeting Briefing Package/Handouts
MONTHYEARML22222A1102022-07-21021 July 2022 KM Session Final ML22178A1952022-06-27027 June 2022 2021 Davis Besse Nuclear Power Station End-of-Cycle Meeting Presentation ML22028A3922022-02-0101 February 2022 Licensee Regulatory Conference Presentation ML22028A3972022-02-0101 February 2022 NRC Regulatory Conference Presentation ML21176A1992021-06-25025 June 2021 Slideshow Presentation for 2020 End -of-Cycle Public Meeting for Davis-Besse and Perry ML20210M0712020-07-27027 July 2020 Combined End-of-Cycle 2019 Public Meeting Slide Presentation ML19249D0212019-09-0606 September 2019 End-of-Cycle Summary Handout (2018) ML18310A3802018-11-0808 November 2018 Pre-Submittal Meeting Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station (DB) Post-Shutdown Emergency Plan (PSEP) License Amendment Request ML18180A1962018-06-29029 June 2018 Slides for Davis Besse 2017 EOC Open House ML17229B3382017-08-17017 August 2017 Presentation for 2016 Davis-Besse EOC Open House ML16174A3152016-06-21021 June 2016 Annual Assessment Meeting Open House June 21, 2016 ML15156A6962015-06-11011 June 2015 Annual Assessment Meeting Open House Handout ML14224A1112014-08-25025 August 2014 Safety Culture Presentation for Brazil, U.S. Workshop on Safety and Security Culture - August 25, 2014 ML14218A0542014-08-0707 August 2014 Handout Davis-Besse EOC Mtg ML14050A4002014-02-20020 February 2014 NRC Presentation for Davis-Besse Steam Generator Replacement Webinar ML13322B3112013-11-13013 November 2013 NFPA 805 Transition - Meeting Slides, 11/13/2013 ML13294A5972013-10-21021 October 2013 FENOC Presentation Slides for Public Meeting September 24, 2013 ML13157A0642013-06-0606 June 2013 June 11, 2013 NRC Presentation ML13159A0092013-06-0404 June 2013 Notable Failures in Nondustructive Testing - June 4, 2013 Public Meeting ML12269A0612012-09-26026 September 2012 FENOC Presentation for 2012-09-26 Public Meeting ML12227A4172012-08-15015 August 2012 NRC End-Of-Cycle Assessment 2011 Meeting Presentation ML12221A2642012-08-0909 August 2012 NRC Public Meeting NRC Presentation 8/9/12 ML12221A2682012-08-0909 August 2012 FENOC Shield Building Cracking Davis-Besse Public Meeting 8/9/12 ML12132A3442012-05-11011 May 2012 NRC-AERB Bilateral Meeting Slide Presentation (Nro/De), Aerb, India - May 16-17, 2012 ML1206901712012-02-29029 February 2012 Slides and View Graphs - Boric Acid Corrosion Testing Program: Industry Perspective ML12200A2402012-02-23023 February 2012 Presentation Slides on Davis-Besse Shield Building Crack ML1204402842012-02-16016 February 2012 Public Meeting Construction Experiences - Evaluate Impact of Concrete Degradation ML12004A0102012-01-0404 January 2012 Public Meeting NRC Slides ML12200A2492011-12-22022 December 2011 Presentation Slides on Shield Building /Containment Delamination ML11220A2542011-08-0101 August 2011 DBNPS-Info Meeting Slides ML1116400632011-06-15015 June 2011 EOC NRC Slides for Public Meeting ML1117209902011-06-15015 June 2011 Meeting Presentation NRC Annual Assessment Meeting: Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station. ML1021501182010-07-29029 July 2010 Licensee Slides for Davis-Besse Annual Assessment Meeting ML1021501112010-07-29029 July 2010 NRC Slides for Davis-Besse; July 29, 2010; Annual Assessment Meeting L-02-002, G20100238/EDATS: OEDO-2010-0305 - Ltr. Tom Gurdziel, 2.206 - Firstenergy - Davis-Besse2010-04-15015 April 2010 G20100238/EDATS: OEDO-2010-0305 - Ltr. Tom Gurdziel, 2.206 - Firstenergy - Davis-Besse ML0920202972009-07-15015 July 2009 NRC Slides from EOC Meeting ML0920202872009-07-15015 July 2009 Meeting Slides, NRC Annual Assessment Meeting Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station ML0725600562007-09-12012 September 2007 9/12/2007 Meeting to Discuss Davis-Besse License Amendment Request for Conversion to Improved Technical Specifications (ITS) 9/12/2007 NRC Meeting Slides ML0725600462007-09-11011 September 2007 9/11/2007-Meeting to Discuss Davis-Besse License Amendment Request for Conversion to Improved Technical Specifications (ITS) - 9/11/2007 NRC Meeting Slides ML0722201892007-08-0808 August 2007 NRC EOC Public Meeting Slides ML0717905962007-06-27027 June 2007 Slides from Public Meeting Between NRC and FENOC Regarding Response to May 14, 2007, Demand for Information ML0702603952007-01-31031 January 2007 Summary of Conference Telephone Call Regarding the Spring 2006 Steam Generator Inspections - Handouts ML0706502022007-01-23023 January 2007 Slides to Summary of Pre-Application Meeting with FENOC Proposed License Amendment Request for Measurement Uncertainty Recapture Power Uprate ML0632003672006-12-11011 December 2006 Slides, Improved Technical Specification Conversion from Category 1 Pre-submittal Meeting with Fenco to Discuss Davis-Besse's' Proposed Conversion to Improved Technical Specifications ML0612404142006-05-0202 May 2006 NRC Annual Assessment Meeting ML0601801602006-01-18018 January 2006 Industry Safety Culture Presentation for January 18, 2006 Public Meeting ML0603002272006-01-10010 January 2006 Multi-Regional NRC Public Meeting Licensee (FENOC) Slide Presentation ML0802205572005-09-12012 September 2005 NRC Commissioners Briefing by Firstenergy Nuclear Operating Co ML0525604472005-08-17017 August 2005 B&W Owners Group Reactor Vessel Working Group Summary of the Plans of the B&Wog Reactor Vessel Integrity Program ML0526600162005-08-16016 August 2005 Mantg Conference, 8/16/05 - Plenary - Keynote Speech by Samuel J. Collins, Regional Administrator, Region I, the Changing Roles of the Operators and Trainers 2022-07-21
[Table view] Category:Slides and Viewgraphs
MONTHYEARML23152A2022023-06-0101 June 2023 2022 Davis-Besse End-of-Cycle Meeting Presentation ML22222A1102022-07-21021 July 2022 KM Session Final ML22178A1952022-06-27027 June 2022 2021 Davis Besse Nuclear Power Station End-of-Cycle Meeting Presentation ML22028A3922022-02-0101 February 2022 Licensee Regulatory Conference Presentation ML22028A3972022-02-0101 February 2022 NRC Regulatory Conference Presentation ML21176A1992021-06-25025 June 2021 Slideshow Presentation for 2020 End -of-Cycle Public Meeting for Davis-Besse and Perry ML20210M0712020-07-27027 July 2020 Combined End-of-Cycle 2019 Public Meeting Slide Presentation ML19249D0212019-09-0606 September 2019 End-of-Cycle Summary Handout (2018) ML18310A3802018-11-0808 November 2018 Pre-Submittal Meeting Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station (DB) Post-Shutdown Emergency Plan (PSEP) License Amendment Request ML18180A1962018-06-29029 June 2018 Slides for Davis Besse 2017 EOC Open House ML17229B3382017-08-17017 August 2017 Presentation for 2016 Davis-Besse EOC Open House ML16174A3152016-06-21021 June 2016 Annual Assessment Meeting Open House June 21, 2016 ML16117A1822016-04-22022 April 2016 Industry Slides for the Spring 2016 Conference Call Regarding the Steam Generator Tube Inservice Inspections ML15156A6962015-06-11011 June 2015 Annual Assessment Meeting Open House Handout ML14224A1112014-08-25025 August 2014 Safety Culture Presentation for Brazil, U.S. Workshop on Safety and Security Culture - August 25, 2014 ML14218A0542014-08-0707 August 2014 Handout Davis-Besse EOC Mtg ML14050A4002014-02-20020 February 2014 NRC Presentation for Davis-Besse Steam Generator Replacement Webinar ML13322B3112013-11-13013 November 2013 NFPA 805 Transition - Meeting Slides, 11/13/2013 ML13294A5972013-10-21021 October 2013 FENOC Presentation Slides for Public Meeting September 24, 2013 ML13220A0632013-08-30030 August 2013 Dsd ED2013 3267 Presentation, Primary Water Stress Corrosion Cracking Tests and Metallurgical Analyses of Davis-Besse Control Rod Drive Mechanism Nozzle #4. ML13157A0642013-06-0606 June 2013 June 11, 2013 NRC Presentation ML13159A0092013-06-0404 June 2013 Notable Failures in Nondustructive Testing - June 4, 2013 Public Meeting ML13078A2492013-03-20020 March 2013 Project Overview-Public Mtg 3-20-13 Non Proprietary ML12269A0612012-09-26026 September 2012 FENOC Presentation for 2012-09-26 Public Meeting ML12227A4172012-08-15015 August 2012 NRC End-Of-Cycle Assessment 2011 Meeting Presentation ML12221A2642012-08-0909 August 2012 NRC Public Meeting NRC Presentation 8/9/12 ML12221A2682012-08-0909 August 2012 FENOC Shield Building Cracking Davis-Besse Public Meeting 8/9/12 ML12138A0732012-05-14014 May 2012 FENOC-Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 Docket No. 50-346, License No. NPF-3 Submittal of Contractor Root Cause Assessment Report-Section 5 ML12132A3442012-05-11011 May 2012 NRC-AERB Bilateral Meeting Slide Presentation (Nro/De), Aerb, India - May 16-17, 2012 ML1206901712012-02-29029 February 2012 Slides and View Graphs - Boric Acid Corrosion Testing Program: Industry Perspective ML12200A2402012-02-23023 February 2012 Presentation Slides on Davis-Besse Shield Building Crack ML1204402842012-02-16016 February 2012 Public Meeting Construction Experiences - Evaluate Impact of Concrete Degradation ML1200501462012-01-0505 January 2012 Public Meeting FENOC Slides ML12004A0102012-01-0404 January 2012 Public Meeting NRC Slides ML12200A2492011-12-22022 December 2011 Presentation Slides on Shield Building /Containment Delamination ML11220A2542011-08-0101 August 2011 DBNPS-Info Meeting Slides ML11221A3012011-08-0101 August 2011 521- R326C B&W Tech Cross Training - Chapter 16 Davis-Besse Loss of All Feedwater ML1117303602011-06-21021 June 2011 FENOC Licensee Slides for 6-21-11 All FENOC Meeting ML1116400632011-06-15015 June 2011 EOC NRC Slides for Public Meeting ML1117209902011-06-15015 June 2011 Meeting Presentation NRC Annual Assessment Meeting: Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station. ML1032103472010-11-16016 November 2010 FENOC 11/16/10 Public Meeting Presentation Slides ML1025103462010-09-0909 September 2010 SIT Exit Meeting Presentation Slides ML1021501112010-07-29029 July 2010 NRC Slides for Davis-Besse; July 29, 2010; Annual Assessment Meeting ML1021501182010-07-29029 July 2010 Licensee Slides for Davis-Besse Annual Assessment Meeting ML1015400332010-06-0303 June 2010 Licensee Slides for June 3, 2010 Public Meeting Presentation ML1015400342010-06-0303 June 2010 NRC Slides for June 3, 2010 Public Meeting Presentation ML1009102662010-03-31031 March 2010 Slides FENOC and NRC Senior Management Briefing, 3-31-10 ML0920202872009-07-15015 July 2009 Meeting Slides, NRC Annual Assessment Meeting Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station ML0920202972009-07-15015 July 2009 NRC Slides from EOC Meeting ML0814104322008-05-13013 May 2008 Meeting Slides, Davis-Besse Annual Assessment Meeting, Reactor Oversight Program - Cy 2007 2023-06-01
[Table view] |
Text
NRC Public Meeting Davis Besse Shield Building Cracks August 9, 2012
Welcome Charles Ch l CCasto t
Regional Administrator NRC Region III 2
Meeting Information Steve Reynolds y
Director Division of Reactor Safety NRC Region III 3
Meeting Agenda
- Meeting Purpose & Background
- Public Questions and Comments 4
Meeting Purpose
- Presentation by licensee on results of root cause evaluation and corrective actions
- Presentation by NRC on NRCs inspection of licensees root cause activities and actions going forward 5
Safety Issue
- On October 10, 2011, licensee promptly notified NRC upon identifying cracking in the Davis Besse shield building.
- NRC determined there was no immediate safety concern. The plant was shut down at the time.
- NRC conducted a rigorous inspection resulting in licensee performing additional testing and more extensive, sophisticated calculations.
6
NRC Safety Conclusion Regarding Operability
- Licensee could safely restart the plant
- Public meeting held 1/5/12 on NRCs safety conclusion 7
Confirmatory Action Letter Issued to Licensee
- Letter dated December 2, 2011
- Implement a short-term monitoring program
- Complete a root cause evaluation
- Develop and implement corrective actions
- Develop and implement a long-term monitoring program 8
Additional NRC Actions to Ensure Continued Safety of the Shield Building
- Conducted a follow-up inspection of root cause evaluation and proposed corrective actions
- Continued relentless monitoring of licensee correction actions
- Scrutinous oversight of licensee actions going forward 9
Introductions - NRC
- Charles Casto, Regional Administrator, Region III
- Steve Reynolds, Director, Division of Reactor Safety
- Melvin Holmberg, Senior Reactor Inspector
Introductions - NRC
- David Hills, Chief, Engineering Branch 1
- Jamnes J C Cameron, ChiChief, f RReactor t P Projects j t B Branch h6
- Brian Harris, Project Manager, DLR, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
- Bryce Lehman, Structural Engineer, DLR, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
First Energy Nuclear Operating Company (FENOC) Introductions and Presentation 12
NRC Root Cause Inspection Melvin Mel in Holmberg Senior Reactor Inspector Division of Reactor Safety NRC Region III 13
NRC Safety Focused Inspection
- Early NRC Engagement with the Root Cause Investigation - December of 2011.
- Provided NRC with real time results
- Facilitated independent NRC observations and interaction with licensee and vendor staff
- Facilitated coordination of independent NRC inspections onsite 14
NRC Safety Focused Inspection
- NRC Actions - Assess Validity of the Causes of the Shield Building Cracking.
- Team of 4 NRC Inspectors
- Independently observed cracks in:
- 1. SB access opening
- 2. Core bores
- 3. Removed core samples
- Observed offsite vendor test facilities- core bore samples 15
NRC Safety Focused Inspection
- Reviewed licensee and vendor Root Cause Reports
- Evaluated licensee cause determination process
- Evaluated inputs/assumptions/modeling for SB calculations
- Evaluated licensee and vendor experience and education 16
NRC Conclusion - Causes of Shield Building Cracking
- Sufficient basis established for the causes of the shield building laminar cracking:
- Blizzard of 1978
- Lack of exterior moisture barrier
- Structural design elements of shield building 17
Basis for NRC Conclusion
- Systematic Root Cause Process Followed with Qualified Subject Matter Experts
- Experts in concrete degradation and root cause analysis considered and eliminated a wide range of possible causes
- Comprehensive analysis in accordance with well known and accepted root cause processes 18
Basis for NRC Conclusion
- Objective j Evidence:
Weather records, core bore sample and impulse response test results
- Analytical Analysis Five analytical model results
- Operating Experience Similar structures identified with laminar cracking which supports the identified causes 19
NRC Conclusions - Corrective Actions
- The NRC determined that the licensees proposed corrective actions, if adequately implemented, should keep the shield building safe to operate.
operate 20
Basis of NRC Conclusion -
Correction Actions
- Exterior moisture barrier to prevent additional moisture related laminar cracking.
- Procedures to examine the exterior moisture barrier and monitoring of extent of existing cracking
- NRC follow-up inspections to closely monitor licensee implementation of corrective actions 21
NRC Identified Weakness in Root Cause Report
- Certain details associated with supporting the licensees licensee s analysis and conclusions
- The licensee entered these weaknesses into the Corrective Action Program
- Two examples for which the corrective actions proposed by licensee were too narrow
- The licensee entered these observations into the Corrective Action Program.
22
License Renewal Inspections Ann Marie Stone Engineering Branch Chief Division of Reactor Safety NRC Region III 23
License Renewal Perspectives
- Incorporation p of Shield Buildingg cracking g in the License Renewal process
- Perform detailed technical reviews and audits
- Perform independent inspections 24
License Renewal Perspectives
- In-plant walk downs, and review of current credited programs, planned future programs/actions, p g , and operating p g experience.
p
- Determine if licensees programs, when implemented, will be consistent with requirements.
- Inspection Results Documented in Inspection Reports 05000346/2011010 and 05000346/2011012 25
License Renewal Perspectives
- Current and future actions
- Application: Licensees proposed aging management program titled Shield Building Monitoring Program being reviewed
- (If a renewed license is granted) Post Renewal:
Additional NRC inspections to verify the licensee completed the commitments and license conditions 26
Regulatory Overview
- NRC continues to provide close oversight going forward
- NRC will keep the public informed 27
Summary Charles Ch l CCasto t
Regional Administrator NRC Region III 28
Meeting Contacts
- Followup Questions - Contact the NRC Region III Office of Public Affairs Vikt i Mitlyng Viktoria Mitl / Prema P Chandrathil Ch d thil Tel: (630) 829-9500 OPA3@nrc.gov 29